XX .
On the separation of Iron from other metals .
By J. F. W. HERSCHEL , Esq. F. R. S. Read April 5 , 18ai .
AN easy and exact method of separating iron from the other metals with which it may happen to be mixed , has always been a desideratum in chemistry .
Every one conversant with the analysis of minerals is aware of the difficulty of the problem , which indeed is such that , in experiments conducted on any thing like a large scale , it might hitherto be regarded as insuperable .
In consequence of this , and of the importance of the enquiry , there is hardly a chemist of eminence who has not proposed some process for the purpose , but ( with the exception of that which depends on the insolubility of the persuccinate of the obnoxious metal , which I have not tried , and which is too expensive to be resorted to for any but the nicer purposes of analytical research ) they are all of them either inadequate to the end proposed , intolerably tedious , or limited in their application .
That which I have now to propose , on the other hand , is liable to none of these objections , being mathematically rigorous , of general application , and possessing in the highest degree the advantages of facility , celerity , and cheapness .
It is briefly this : The solution containing iron , is to be brought to the maximum of oxidation , which can be communicated to it by boiling with nitric acid .
It is then to be just neutralized while in a state of ebullition , by carbonate of ammonia .
The whole of the iron to the last atom , is precipitated , and the whole of the other metals present ( which I suppose to be manganese , cerium , nickel , and cobalt ) , remains in solution .
The precautions necessary to ensure success in this process are few and simple .
In the first place , the solution must contain no oxide of manganese or cerium above the first degree of oxidation , otherwise it will be separated with the iron .
It is scarcely probable in ordinary cases that any such should be present , the protoxides only of these metals forming salts of any stability ; but should they be suspected , a short ebullition with a little sugar will reduce them to the minimum .
If nitric acid be now added , the iron alone is peroxidized , the other oxides remaining at the minimum.* Moreover , in performing the precipitation the metallic solution should not be too concentrated , and must be agitated the whole time , especially towards the end of the process ; and when the acid reaction is so far diminished that log-wood paper is but feebly affected by it , the alkaline solution must be added cautiously , in small quantities at a time , and in a diluted state .
If too much alkali be added , a drop or two of any acid will set all right again ; but it should be well observed , as upon this the whole rigour of the process depends , that no inconvenience can arise from slightly surpassing the point of precise neutralization , as the newly precipitated car* Dr. FORSCHAMMER , in a paper recently published in THOMSONrS Annals of Philosophy , contends that the proto-salts of manganese are absolutely void of colour .
To this I can only say , that I have not succeeded in depriving the muriate of its pale rose colour by any length of ebullition with sugar or alcohol , after which , however , not a trace of deutoxide could be detected in it .
I cannot help regarding the process here proposed for freeing manganese from iron as preferable to that of Dr. F. 094 bonates of the above enumerated metals are readily soluble , to a certain extent , in the solutions in which they are formed ( though perfectly neutral ) .
In the cases of cobalt and cerium , this re-dissolution of the recent precipitate formed by carbonate of ammonia is very considerable , and a solution of either of these metals , thus impregnated with the metallic carbonate , becomes a test of the presence of peroxide of iron , of a delicacy surpassing most of the re-agents used in chemistry , the minutest trace of it being instantly thrown down by them from a boiling solution , provided no marked excess of acid be present .
To be certain however that we have not gone too far , it is advisable , after separating the ferruginous precipitate , to test the clear liquid , while hot , with a drop of the alkaline carbonate .
If the cloud which this produces be clearly re-dissolved on agitation , we may be sure that only iron has been separated .
If otherwise , a little acid must be added , the liquor poured again through the filter , so as to wash the precipitate , and the neutralization performed anew .
The precipitation of iron above described seems at first sight to result from a double decomposition .
Were it so , the principle of the method would be merely a difference of solubility in the carbonates of iron and the other metals , and as such would have no claim to be regarded as rigorous .
Such however is not the case .
The iron is not separated in the state of a carbonate , but of a sub-salt , or a simple peroxide , the whole of the carbonic acid escaping with effervescence at 'each addition of the alkali .
The phenomenon turns on a peculiarity in the peroxide of this metal , in virtue of which it is incapable of existing in a neutral solution at the boiling temperature .
If we add an alkaline , earthy , or metallic carbonate by little and little to a cold solution of peroxide of iron , the precipitate formed is re-dissolved with effervescence , readily at first , but gradually more and more slowly , till at length many hours , or even days , elapse before the liquid becomes quite clear .
Meanwhile it deepens in colour till ( unless much diluted ) it becomes dark brown or red .
If the addition of the carbonate be carried as far as possible without producing a permanent precipitate , the solution is perfectly neutral , and continues clear at a low temperature for any length of time .
In this state it may be evaporated to dryness in vacuo , and the residue ( which does not effervesce with acids ) is stillsoluble in water without letting any iron fall , and so on as often as we please .
The compound thus formed is however far from permanent .
It is in fact in a state of tottering equilibrium , which a very slight cause is sufficient to overset .
Supposing the point of saturation to have been exactly attained , the addition of an extremely small quantity more of the alkaline solution is sufficient to determine the separation of the whole , or nearly the whole , metallic contents ; and if the solution operated on be pretty concentrated , it fixes after a longer or shorter time into a stiff and almost solid coagulum .
Again , if to the coagulum so formed , a quantity equally inappreciable of the original ferruginous solution be added , it gradually liquefies , and after some time is completely re-dissolved ( forming no inapt representation of the celebrated imposture of St. Januarius 's blood)* A similar change is produced by an increase of temperature .
If we heat a solution exactly neutralized as above described , it speedily grows turbid , deposits its ferruginous contents in abundance , and at the same time acquires a very decided acid reaction .
The acid so developed holds in solution a portion of oxide , but if the neutralization be performed afresh while hot , this separates entirely , and the liquid after filtration has no more action on gallic acid , ferrocyanate , or sulphocyanate of potash , than so much distilled water.* It is not my object in this paper to enter into any minute detail of the nature of the persalts of iron , a subject not nearly exhausted , and which want of leisure alone has prevented my entering upon , but merely to point out the practical application of this one of their properties , to an important precipitate , the solvent and the matter dissolved .
I can call to mind but one instance of so small a quantity of matter operating a chemical change on so large a mass , wiz : the decomposition of oxygenated water by fibrin and other animal substances .
The action seems to be propagated from particle to particle .
Whether the superabundant oxide of iron be retained in solution in a state at all analogous to that of the oxygen in THENARD'S experiments , might possibly deserve consideration .
object in analysis .
The principle here developed furnishes a ready method of detecting the minutest quantities of other metals in union with iron , and therefore cannot but prove of important service in various cases where this metal constitutes the chief ingredient in the substance examined , as in meteoric iron , the various natural oxides of this metal , &amp;c. &amp;c. I will exemplify this in one or two instances .
36oo grains of meteoric iron ( furnished me by the kindness of Dr. WOLLASTON ) were dissolved in dilute nitrosulphuric acid , leaving behind a minute quantity of a brilliant black powder , which however dissolved by digestion in nitromuriatic acid , and appeared only to contain an excess of nickel .
The solutions were mixed , and being neutralized at a boiling temperature by carbonate of ammonia , and the iron separated , a green solution remained .
Into this when boiling , a drop of persulphate of iron being let fall , was immediately precipitated in the state of subsulphate , which being separated , the solution was boiled with excess of caustic potash till all smell of ammonia disappeared .
Oxide of nickel separated , which collected and strongly ignited , weighed 4-65 grains , or 12'92 on the hundred , which ( taking the atom of nickel to weigh So , and that of oxygen 8 , hydrogen being unity ) gives X o'2o per cent for the contents of the specimen analyzed in metallic nickel .
loo grains of titanious iron from North America , being dissolved in muriatic acid ( after the requisite ignition with potash ) were treated ( after separating the titanium ) with excess of carbonate of lime and filtered .
The excess of carbonic acid being expelled , ammonia was added , and a small quantity of a white precipitate fell , which speedily blackened 298 in the air , and proved to be mere oxide of manganese , uncontaminated by iron , and amounting to half a grain .
Manganese has been suspected in various species of cast iron ; and though Mr. MUSHET 's experiments go to prove that it does not usually enter in abundance , they can hardly be regarded as establishing the fact of its absence .
It might not be uninteresting to resume the investigation with the aid of a mode of analysis so well adapted to experiments on a large scale , as I have no doubt that , with proper care , one part in a thousand , or even less , of manganese might be insulated from iron .
The separation of iron from uranium cannot be accomplished by the process above described , that metal possessing a property analogous to that which forms the subject of this paper .
By inverting the process , however , we shall succeed even here .
A mixed solution of iron and uranium being de-oxidized by a current of sulphuretted hydrogen , and then treated with an earthy carbonate , the iron passes in solution while the uranium separates .
This difference in the habitudes of the two oxides of iron presents us in fact with a kind of chemical dilemma , of one or the other of whose horns we may avail ourselves in any proposed case .
In studying the habitudes of uranium , however , I have met with some anomalies which require farther investigation .
Zirconia too might probably be freed from iron with equal facility by a similar inversion of the process ; but this I have not yet had an opportunity of trying satisfactorily .
J. F. W. HERSCHEL .
London , April 4 , 182 .

