I An A c-count of some fossil rematns of the Rhinoceros , discovered by Mr. Whitby , in a cavern enclosed in the lime-stone rock , from which he is forming the Break*water at Plymouth .
By Sir Everard Home , Bart. V. P. R. S. Read February s7 , 1t87 .
1VHEN Mr. WHxTBY engaged to superintend this most arduous undertaking , Sir JosX PE BAN s requested him to examine narrowly any caverns he miight meet with in the rock , and have the bones , or any other fossil remains that were met with , carefully preserved .
Mr. WHITBY in complian-e with this request , in November 1816 , Sent UP to Sir JOSEPH BANKS a box of fbssil bones , which are the subject of the present Paper .
Mr. WHIThY states the bones to have been found in a cavern , in the solidlimestone rock , 15 feet wide , 45 feet long , taking the direction into the clifT , and 12 feet deep .
This cavern was filled with solid clay , in which the bones were imbedded , and lay about 3 feet above the bottom of the cavern .
The lime-stone quarries of Oreston , in which this cavern was met with , are situated on the south side of Catwater , and about one mile from Plymouth .
When Mr. WHITB3Y began to work this quarry , the rock was 74 feet perpendicular above high water ; the bones were found 70 feet below the surface of the rock , and about 4 feet above high water mark .
He quarried 60 feet horizontally into the cliff , before he came to the cavern .
Before Mr. WIJITBY began to quarry here , ioo feet had been quarried into the cliff , so that X Co feet was the distance between the cavern and the original edge of the cliff ; in all other directions the quarries c'onsist of compact lime-stone to a great extent .
The workmene came to this cavern by blasting through the solid rock , and at the depth in the rock at which it was met with , the surrounding lime-stone being every where equally strong , and requiring the same labour to quarry it ; Mr. WHITBY saw no possibility of the cavern having had any external communication , through the rock in which it was enclosed .
The cavern was quarried within about a foot of its bottom , the lower clay was not all cleared out , but the bottom was .
sounded by an iron crow , and rock was every where met with .
Many such caverns , Mr. WHITBY says , have been met with in these quarries , and , in some instances , the rock on the inside was crusted with stalactite ; but nothing of that kind was met with in the cavern in which the bones were found ; so that there is no proof that any opening in the rock from above had been closed by infiltration .
The quarry in which this cavern was met with , is directly opposite the place where Mr. WHITBY lands , every time he visits the quarries , and therefore his attention was more naturally drawn to it than to any of the others ; and as , in the contract of quarrying , there are two prices , one for rock , another for clay-earth and rubbish , and two officers attend , one , for the crown , and the other on the part of the contractors , who measure the contents of all caverns that contain clay , or other soft materials , it is only necessary to mention that these officers state , that the rock surrounding the cavern , was equally hard with the other parts , requiring the same force to blast it , and that the quarrying was paid for accordingly .
The following is a list of the bones sent up by Mr. WHITBY to Sir JOSEPH BANKS ; they all belonged to the Rhinoceros ; but it will appear in the enumneration that they were parts of the skeletons of three different animals .
The third grinding tooth from behind , on the right side of the upper jaw .
The third grinder from the left side of the same jaw .
The second grinder from behind , on the right side of the lower jaw .
The second grinder from before , on the left side of the tupper jaw .
The third or middle grinder on the left side of the lower jaw .
One of the smallest of the anterior grinders .
The upper portion of the radius of the right fore leg .
A portion of the fifth dorsal vertebra .
A portion of the cotyloid cavity of the scapula of the left shoulder .
The upper part of the atlas .
with a portion of the articulating surface .
The olecranon of the right fore leg .
The first phalanx of one of the toes of the fore foot .
The lower extremity of the left os humeri .
Upper part of the right os humeri .
The head of the left os femoris .
The lower extremity of ditto , One of the bones of the carpus of the left foot .
The lower extremity of the right ulna .
The lower extremity of the inside toe of the right foot .
The head of the os humeri .
The upper part of the right femor with the epiphysis separated .
The metacarpal bone of the middle toe of the right fore foot .
All these bones are in the most perfect state of preservation ; almost every part of the surface entire , to a degree that I have never seen in specimens of fossil bones .
The metacarpal bone is complete except a small injury on one side of it , which it received probably at the time it was dug out of the clay .
The teeth of the Rhinoceros differing in their form as well as structure , from those of every known animal , it was readily ascertained that these fossil teeth belonged to that animal ; and it is a circumstance extremely satisfactory , that every one of the portions of bones dug up , possessed some distinguishing character , so as not only to enable me to ascertain the particular bone to which each broken portion belonged , but that character was also sufficiently well marked , to make it clear that the bones belonged to the Rhinoceros .
It was very much in our favour , that the elephant is the only animal whose equality of size could lead us into any mistake on this subject .
The metatarsal bone , the only one which was sent up entire , was immediately recognized to belong to the Rhinoceros since these bones in that animal are nearly double the length of the same bones in the elephant .
Mr. BRooKs , Surgeon , and Teacher of Anatomy in Blent heim Street , has in his collection the skeleton of a Rhinoceros , which is considered to have been the largest ever seen in this country .
I took advantage of Mr. BROOKS'S kindness , not only to compare all the fragments of these bones , with the entire ones in the skeleton , but also to measure with some accuracy the length and breadth of the metacarpal bone in the fossil state and that in the skeleton , so that we might form some comparative idea of the size of the two animals , to which they belonged .
The skeleton stands 5 feet 8 inches high , the metacarpal bone is 7X inches long , 2inches broad .
The metacarpal bone , in a fossil state , is 8h inches long , and 21 inches broad .
All the bones appear to have belonged to Rhinoceroses of nearly the same size , except the cotyloid cavity of the left scapula , which evidently was part of the skeleton of a smaller animal , and the olecranon of the right fore leg of one still smaller .
It is deserving of remark , that all the bones found in this cavern belonged to the same species of animal .
Great pains were taken to ascertain whether there were any other bones than those sent up to London , but no others were discovered .
Professor BRAND , Secretary to the Society , analysed a portion of one of the bones and a portion of one of the teeth .
He remarked , that he had never mnet with fossil bones so purely earthy , and free of extraneous matters .
When the bone was heated , it exhaled scarcely any smell of animal matter , nor had it lost any of its natural whiteness .
It consisted of 6o Phosphate of lime .
28 Carbonate of lime .
2 Animal matter , io Water .
The tooth consisted of 78 Phosphate of lime .
8 Carbonate of lime .
8 Extraneous earthy matter .
6 Animal-matter , water and loss .
At my request he made at the same time an analysis of a Rhinoceros 's tooth found at Brentford , and of the tibia of an Hippopotamus found at the same place , as well as of the rib of the fossil remains of an animal of the fish tribe found at Lyme ; an account of the Brentford bones , as well as of the bones at Lyme , has a place in the Philosophical Transactions .
The Rhinoceros 's tooth from Brentford contained 70 Phosphate of lime .
6 Carbonate of lime .
2o Extraneous earthy matter .
4 Animal matter and water .
The tibia of the Hippopotamus contained 5o Phosphate of lime .
5 Carbonate of lime .
24 Siliceous earth .
io Aluminous earth .
4 Oxide of iron .
2 Water .
Animal matter , The fish 's rib contained 5o Phosphate of lime .
1 Carbonate of lime .
i,5 Aluminous earth .
5 Siliceous earth .
8 Water .
3 Animal matters From the Press of W BULPMER 0e Co. CleveZand-row , St. 7ames 's , Londmon

