XI .
On the parallax of the fixed stars .
By John PondJ Esqi Astronomer Royal , F. R. S. Read February go , 1817 .
IT is now very generally known to astronomers , that , for several years past , Dr. BRINKLEY , with the eight feet circle of the Observatory at Dublin , has constantly observed a periodical deviation of several fixed stars from their mean places ; which strongly indicates the existence of an annual parallax in those stars , The magnitude and perfection of the instrument , the regular continuation of the same result without exception , during a period of several years , and above all , the judicious reflections of Dr. BRINKLEY , and his unprejudiced statement of every objection that might be supposed to occur , seem to leave but little doubt upon the subject .
Thus much at least is certain , that the observed discordance arises from some very permanent cause , and is totally distinct from what has usually been termed error of observation .
The deviation from the mean place resulting from the supposed parallax being a very small quantity ( never exceeding a single second ) , Dr. BRINKLEY was naturally desirous that the result of his observations should be confirmed by other astronomers .
Few , however , are fortunate enough to possess instruments sufficiently accurate either to confirm or confute the hypothesis above stated .
The mural circle at the Royal Observatory , erected in the was supposed to be well adapted to this species of investigation , and , I confess , I expected to find the effects of parallax in Dr. BRINKLEY'S stars , and perhaps in some others , almost as decidedly as the effects of aberration and nutation .
I soon however found ( what indeed if I had sufficiently reflected on the subject , I ought to have foreseen ) , , that this instrument ( at least in the manner in which I employ it ) is not so exactly adapted to the purpose as might at first be supposed .
My principal object was to obtain the mean places of a certain number of stars , with the greatest precision that the nature of the instrument admitted .
I therefore availed myself of the principles of its construction , to give every possible variety to my observations , by bringing a new system of divisions to bear upon those stars , The effect of parallax was necessarily involved in these changes ; and , though I certainly did expect that under all these disadvantages a parallax so considerable as that assumed by Dr. BRINKLEY , , Would have become very apparent , yet , upon not finding it , I did not think it by any means fair to infer its noniexistence , more particularly as the discordances I really did meet with , were very universally in favour of parallax .
Finding , therefore , that I could not elucidate this question in a perfectly satisfactory manner without dedicating the circle entirely to this investigation , I rather directed my attend tion tocontrive some other instruments which might be employed exclusively to this object .
At the last visitation , I proposed that two or more telescopes should be fixed to stone piers , and directed to the particular stars whose parallax was suspected ; that each telescope should be furnished with a micrometer , by which the star could be compared with others passing through the same field .
This suggestion was approved of by the visitors , and , till a proper building can be contrived and erected , I have fixed two ten feet telescopes , one on the circle pier directed to a Aquilke , and one on the quadrant pier directed to a Cygni , and with these temporary instruments I am about to comrn mence a series of observations .
The advantages I presume those instruments to possess are , length of radius ; great steadiness , and simplicity of construction ; and being used only for a few select observations these few are more likely to be made with extreme care .
Although , for the reasons above stated , I was unable to devote the mural circle entirely to the investigation of parallax , yet during the summer of i81 , and the following winter , I was induced to continue the telescope in the same position , with the view of examining any changes that might occur indicative of parallax , or any other irregularity .
During thisperiod , the three principal stars observed by Dr. BRINKLEY ( a Lyrx , a Aquile , a Cygni ) arrive at their maximum and minimum of parallax ; as far , therefore , as the observations of one single year can be supposed to have any weight , these seem , I think , to be as good as : ever may reasonably be expected to be made with the same instrument .
The object of the present communication is to submit the result of these observations to the Society ; and whatever remarks I may be induced to make on the discordances between Dr. BRINKLEY'S observations and my own , I hope , will be considered rather in the light of suggestions , arising from circumstances obviously presenting themselves to.our notice .
than as arguments to decide a question , which I anxiously wish to keep open for future experiment and investigation .
The question of parallax in a theoretical point of view , is scarcely of any importance , it is in fact one of mere curiosity .
The motion of the earth has long since ceased to be a subject of controversy , and could a difference of opinion still be supposed to exist , the advocates for the Copernican system would derive but slender support from the discussion of such small variations , as form the subject of this Paper .
But with reference to the state of practical astronomy the case is very different ; in the future history of this branch of the science , that period of time will always acquire a certain degree of celebrity , in which astronomical instruments shall have been brought to such a degree of perfection , as to exhibit distinctly the effects of parallax in the fixed stars , and to distinguish these from the variety of complicated oscillations to which , from other causes , they are perpetually subject : and , as far as relates to the natural history of the sidereal system ( if I may so express myself ) , it is surely a subject of rational curiosity to ascertain whether the distance of the nearest fixed star can be numerically expressed from satisfactory data , or if it be really so immeasureably great , as to exceed all human powers either to conceive or determine .
As I have already observed , the object of this communication is not to decide this question , but to state the result of the Greenwich observations .
The first star I shall consider , is ac Lyra this star having been diligently observed from the first erecting of the instrument with a view to this particular investigation .
In the annexed Tables will be seen the observations selected DICCcxVIIe Y at those times when the parallax is at a maximum .
To the observations themselves is subj oined the process of computing the correction to be applied for deducing the true polar distance .
This correction , which is of the nature of an Index error , is usually found by comparing the observed places of all the stars , during the\ same period , with their computed places deduced from a standard catalogue derived from the instrument itself .
If all the stars were used indiscriminately for this purpose , the method would be liable to an objection stated by Dr. BRINKLEY , for if of the stars -from which this correction is deduced , several were themselves subject to considerable parallax , the effect of this parallax would be involved in the correction , and , if they were selected near to the star whose parallax was sought , the effect of this would be to conceal the parallax , by showing only the difference of parallax instead of the whole .
To obviate entirely this objection , I reject those stars supposed by Dr. BRINKLEY to have parallax , and likewise ry Draconis , whose parallax arrives at its maximum nearly at the same period with that of o Lyre , a Aquilae and a Cygni .
I employ chiefly those stars whose parallax must be neutral , and those opposite in right ascension , which method has rather a tendency to exaggerate the effect of parallax by exhibiting to a certain degree the sum of the parallaxes of different stars .
The difference of these two methods , however , as may be seen in the annexed Tables , does not amount to one tenth part of a second .
The abovementioned objection , therefore , though theoretically just , cannot be made to explain the discordance which exists between Dr. 3RINKLEY'S observations and mine .
The mean of 40 observations of a Lyrae from JLlne 22 , to August 21 , gives for the north polar distance of that star t 2t3 o02 78 The mean of 2o taken nearer to the period of opposition will be 51 23 o,26L The mean of 30 winter observations is 5i .
23 0,867 The discordance between the winter and summer observations , therefore , does not exceed o,6 " equal to one third of the discordance found by Dr. BKINKLEY , and with the refraction employed by him , it would be about one quarter of a second less .
a Cygni .
Thirty observations of this star in summer , 0/ I about the period of opposition , give 45 22 56,938 The mean of So in winter 45 a 57,448 But as lo of these observations were made too far distant from the time of conjunction , it will be better to take the mean of 20 , awhich is 45 22 57489 The difference o,5,56 " is the total discordance in favour of parallax .
This quantity is likewise nearly equal to one. .
third of the discordance found by Dr , BRINKLEYx a Aquilae .
Thirty observations of this star in the summer / of i8 13 , are as follows : io=8i 36 5,555 o=Si 6 58,536 1o=81 36 S8,3oo Mean of 3o summer 8i j6 58 , X6 , Mean of 20 winter 81 36 59,3o0 Difference o,836 With Dr. BRINKLEY'S refractions , this difference would be reduced to less than half a second , a quantity equal to one quarter of the discordance found by Dr. BRINKLEY .
On the Observations of the year 1i8t 2 .
The observations of the year i812 , are liable to all the objections which I have already stated , yet so very sm'alI is the effect of change in the position of the telescope , that I should be inclined myself to prefer a mean takesn from the two years observations , than to that deduced fro(m the observations of 1813 above .
The early observations in the summer of 1812 , are probably not very good , the instrument being then in a very unfinished state .
a Lyre was diligently observed during the whole of the summer ; there are but few observations of a Aquilie , and none of a Cygni ; but the winter observations of these stars are very good .
The mean result of two years observations will stand as follows : a. Lyre .
Summer Winter No. of No. of Observations .
Observations .
1812 0,16 1812 20 0711 '813 40,278 , 3,87 64 0,236 SO o,8o8 Difference o.572 " with BRADLEY'S refractions .
The French refractions would reduce this difference to about ost or o0,4 .
M Aquilx .
Summer Winter No. of No. of Observations .
Observations .
1812 10 58,052 1812 20 59,606 1813 30 58,464 1813 20 159,300 40 581 ) 40 59,453 Difference.o092 " This quantity by the French refraction employed by Dr. BRINKLEY , would be reduced to about 0,5 " .
C Cygni .
Winter Summer Observations .
Observations .
9 1812 57,120 20 1813 57489 1813 30 56,933 29 57,366 Difference 0,433 Fro ' the above observations then , it appears that in the three stars supposed by Dr. BRINKLEY to have the greatest parallax , viz. a Lyrae , a Cygni , and x Aquilke , we find discordances between the summer and winter observations of nearly half a second , ; now , though these quantities are so much smaller than those found by Dr. BRINKLEY , they appear to me to be equally independent of any accidental error of observation , and it is not improbable but they may originate from some similar cause .
But , I confess , I doubt much if this cause be parallax , and for the following reasons .
I do not find these discordances sensibly increased by direct comparison with an opposite star as Capelia ; now the maxim mum of parallax is nearly as great in Capella , as in a Aquilk , at least in the proportion of 4 to 5 ; it is very unlikely then , the parallax of the one star should be above , A " , and the other an insensible quantity .
It may be remarked , that both Dr. BRINKLEY and myself , find nearly the same discordance in all these stars , though the deduced parallax necessarily comes out very different .
This is very unlikely to happen from parallax .
Moreover , these stars all pass the meridian about the time of the winter solstice at their maximum of parallax , and , in proportion as stars do not possess this property , both Dr. BRINKLEY and myself find either a much smaller discordance , or none at all .
It is rather , therefore , to this peculiar circumstance that we should look for some explanation of the difficulties .
In addition to this I should add , that I find y Draconis involved in this discordance , oa Lyre and ry Draconis have been observed together for five successive years .
Above three hundred observations of each star have been made in opposition , and as many in conjunction , and I find the difference of parallax from the mean of all these observations to be about o,25 " , which quantity by the French refraction would be reduced one-half , or to an insensible quantity .
Now it is quite improbable , that two stars of such different brightness should have so exactly the same parallax .
These arguments however .
, though they seem to me to , arise naturally from the data before us , are nevertheless by no means absolutely conclusive , and 1 am well aware , how much easier it is to suggest doubts , than to propose satisfactory explanations .
I shall , therefore , conclude this Paper , by expressing my hopes that , before a very long period shall elapse , the instruments lately erected may afford , something more satisfactory and decisive .
et~hod of computinu the Equation or Index Error to be applied to the observed North Polar distances .
1813 .
July and August .
Position Ol , O. " f~~~~~~~ndex Error 4North Polar North Polar In .
ed +X 1 ... * ~Deduced lnmulltipled+ &gt; distances by di tances by dzA circle .
Catalogue .
servations .
O ... ... ... ... scrvations .
________ C_ _#___e 0pp Polaris , SP 9 358 18 38,98 38.35 + 0.63 + 5.67 O Urs .
Min .
27 154 49,3 I 48.93 0.38 1o0z6 1 Cephei -14 20 15 3I,50 30.54 o.96 13.4+ a Urs .
Maj. I27 14 31,83 31.50 0.33 3.96 a Cephei 13 28 1 7z 12,86 12.55 0-31 3 .
93 y Urs .
Maj. s 35 15 55,69 55.25 0.44 3.52 y Draconis _ 39 38 29 3,96 3.55 0.41 15.99 4 Urs .
Maj. 19 39 44 58,3 5781 0 .
50 9.50 % Persel 6 40 49 53,10 52 37 0.73 4.38 Capella 27 44 1z so ,64 20.46 O.I8 4.86 a Cygni 23 45 22 57,30 56.98 O032 7.36 a Lyra _ 39 51 23 0,70 0.48 0.22 8.58 Castor 6 57 4z 47,12 46.74 0 38 2.28 Pollux 6I 6i 3I 56,63 56.42 0.21 2.21 [ Tauri 76I 33 44,46 43.67 0.79 13.43 Cor. Bor .
Z2 62 38 56 , o 55.45 0.59 14.73 a Arietis , 67 25 36,64 36.51 0.13 o.65 Arcturus 22 69 50 19,23 19.00 0.23 5 o6 Aldebararn 12 73 52 35,6i 35.26 0.35 4.20 a Herculis _ 20 75 23 14,45 13.92 0.53 1o.60 Regulus 3 77 7 22,65 22.6z 0.03 0.09 cM Ophiuchi _ 33 77 17 39,07 38.88 0.9 6.27 o Aquile 29 81 36 58,79 58.79 0.00 0.00 a Orionis 14 82 38 15,64 15.65 0.00 0.00 a Serpentis z6 8z 58 39,81 39.23 o.58 I 5.08 No. of Observations 459 036 166.07 Rejecting y Draconis 1oq Lyrae 329 0.41 134.14 a ygui J Method of computing the Equation or Index Error to be applied to the observed North Polar distances .
181 3 .
NSovember .
0 1 ) II / / A Polaris 1 13 I 41 23.38 2I.65 + 1.73 + 22 .
49 SP .
_12 35 8 18 40.90 38 35 2.55 30.6o U Urs .
Min .
10 i5 4 .
51.04 48.93 2.1I 21.I0 C Cephei 10 20 15 3 2.09 30.54 1.55 15.50 Cephei IO 28 12 I4.I6 12.SS 1.91 19.I0 c Cassiop .
I I0 34 29 24.30 22.68 I.6z 1 6 .
so y Urs .
Maj. 425x 5648i 5.25 i.S6 6.24 y Draconis 7 38 29 6.2I 3.55 2.66 I 8.62 n Urs .
Maj. .
10 39 45 0.00 57.8I 2.19 21.90 o Cygni 8 45 22 59.3 I 56.98 2.33 I8.64 c6 Lyre I0 51 23 2.52 0.48 2.04 2040 X Andromed .
I4 61 56 32.02 30.16 I.86 26.04 g Arietis ii 67 25 38.89 36.5 I 2.38 26 .
I8 Arcturus i1 69 50 21.01 I 9.00 2.0 I 22 .
IIM Ophiuchi 3 77 17 40.74 38.88 i.86 5.58 z Aquile 10 8i 37 I30 58.80 2.50 25.00 153 z.o6 315.70 Rejecting y Draconis a Lyrx I8 1.97 233.04 a Cygni J_ 1813 .
Decenmber .
o1 If / 1 ii Polaris 71 41 24+.40 21.65 + 2.75 19.25 ?
Urs .
Min .
3 I5 4 52.41 48.93 3 48 10.44 S Cephei 2 20 I5 31I88 30.54 1.34 2.68 9C Cephei 3 28 12 j5.88 I2.I5 3.73 11.19 rCassiop .
-8 34 29 25.56 22.68 2.88 2304 lie Draconis 5 38 29 7.I6 3.55 3.6 I I8.o0 iz Persei 5 40 48 54.85 52.37 2.48 I2.40 Capella 2 44 12 23.I7 20.46 , 2.7I 5.42 ci Cygni 4 45 23 O.42 56.98 3.44 13.76 ac Lyrx 6 S1 23 4.21 0.48 3.73 22.38 as Andromed , 2 6I 56 31.90 30.16 1.74 3.48 C6 Arietis 7 67 25 39.63 36.5 I 3 .
II 21.77 Arcturus 2 69 5o 2z .
Io I 9.00 3.10 6.20 Aldebaran 6 73 52 37.92 35.26 2.66 IS.96 a Aquilke 48I 37 2.09 58.80 3.29 13.16 66 3.02 199.18 Rejecting y Draconis 3 cLyrax 47.81 318 c Aquilke J 47 _ _| 2_ |31_83 | ce _C ygni__ _______ __ _____ _ Method of computing the Equation or Index Error to be applied to the observed North Polar distances .
1814 .
January .
Polaris .
51 41 5.30 2.00 + 3.30 i6.So a Cassiop .
5 34 .
29 6.70 2.85 3.85 19.25 a PerSei1 6 40 48 42.02 38.87 3.15 18.90 Capella 6 44 I2 79.40 5.89 .
3.51 21.06 8 Tauri 4 61 33 43.10 39.8+ 3.26 13.04 a Andromeda 4 6i 56 I4 99 10Ao7 4.82 19.28 a Arietis 5 67 25 22 34 19 11 3.23 i6.iS Aldebaran 4 .
73 52 30.83 27.31 3.52 14.08 39 3Y5 5 138.26 1814 .
FebruaryPolaris _1I 41 540 2.CO + 3.40 37.40 a Cassiop .
9 3.4 29 6.52 2.85 3.67 33.03 a Persei 12 40 48 42.30 38.87 3.43 4i.16 Capella 20 44 12 19.50 15.89 3.6i 72.20O Castor 14 57 42 57.80 53.80 4.00 56oo Poillux __1 61 32 8.So 4.42 4.08 48.96 T Pauri 16 6i 33 43.86 39 84 4.02 64.32 a Arietis 8 67 25 2z2.80 19 .
11 3 69 29.5 2 Aldebaran 10 73 52 31.13 27.31 3.82 38 20 Orionis 6 82 38 *8.i8 14.28 3 .
6240 130 3.97492.95 a Lyr , 1813 .
ABCD 1813 .
ABC D._ = .
b~~~~~ _ I_ __t ... ... ... ... .
I ... ... .
0~ 10 iI June7z 51 2z..59.64-.o.4o 59.24 .
Nov. 4 51 23 .
2.00-.z0o 0.00 23 23 .
1.49 1.09 6 1.311 59.31 24 0.87 0.47 8 2.09 0.09 25 0.78 0.38 11 2.50 o--O 2 1.13 07 0 ?
473 9 18 3.85 i.85 $o.68 27 1.34 0.94 049 20 2.33 0.33 28 0.54 0 .
I4 27 2,90 0.90 July 5 0.73 0.33 30 3.49 149 6 1.67 1.27 Dec.l5 4.65..8o i.85 9 1.30 0.90 J 21 3.36 o.56 10 i.i6 0.76 23 3.24 0.44 11 o.26 59.86 26 4.57 1.77 I2 I. II 0:)7I 3 ?
0 4.31 1-51 13 0.17 59.77 31 5.12 2-32 0.93 0.53 814 .
I7 l.86 1.44 0 0374 Jan. I1 4.10-3'55 0.55 1 .
1 !
I8 1.80 1.40 12 5.03 1.48 19 I.25 0.85 29 4.90 1.35 23 22.59.28 58.88 30 4.58 1.03 24 59.94 59,54 ) 31 3.87 0.32 25 59.67 59.27 ^ Feb. 2 4-14 .
380 o03+ 3 27 23 .
0.72 0.32 3 3.81 0.0O 2 0.07 59-67 6 3.93 0.13 29 22.59.80 59.40 14 3.73 59.93 30 59-40 59.00 17 5.27 1147 Aug. 1 59,53 59.13 59.877 19 50 ? ?
1.94 23 .
0.18 59.78 19 5.1I.3 59-78 1-31~20 5.1 1.240.84 022 4.38 o.58 7 1.50 1I10 / 24 4.5 0.78 9 o.66 o.z6 J 25 4.90 1,10 10 0.75 0.35 1 26 4.60 O0 , 1 I1 o,62 0.22 __ , ___ 12 0.33 59.93 13 0.84+ 044 is o0.69 0.29 0.313 16 0.51 0.11 1 0.72 0*37 19 1.43 I1 03 20 1.04 oQ64 .
21 0 .
20 59.80J A. Observations given by the instrument corrected for precession , Abb .
Nut .
and Refract'on , Inde Error .
C Observations corrected .
D. Means of each series of xo observations .
C Cygni .
_P 1813 .
ABC 13D 18X3 ABCD July27 c z.6 .
&lt; o.+o 0 6.:28 Oct.2z45 , 2 ; s 57.33-o088 645 128 57.84 57.44 5 25 8F01 7.13 29 57-75 57:35 1 29 58.17 57.29 30 5793 57 53 31 Z5788 5700 Aug. 57.56 57.16 15 6.791 Nov 6 58 .
96 _x.oo 56 46 571095 41 57.70 57.30 9 5~9.1I1 57.11 7I 95 56.6 26.z8 II 58.88 56.88 7 57.71 S7.31 13 59139 57 39 9 56.0g 55.69 14 5936 5736 10 S 5597 55 15 59.89 57 3 11 57.43 57.03 .
18 5 ) 52 57.5S2 12 7,7 57.3 I 29 59.91 57 91 13 5.28 57.88 Dec. is.32 -2 80 57.52 15 57,70 57:30 26.46 57.66 17 5S.98 55*8 698 30 59.66 56.86 19 56.84 6 44 56987 31 61 6 58.46 57.650 20 57 53 57.1 1814 .
21 56.82 56.+2 Jan. 6o.8o -3355 57.30 2 57.5 57,14 12 60.93 57.38 23 58 .
3 57.63 1x 6i.18 5763 25 5:7.34 56.94 1 17 6i.8i 58 .
626 26 57 77 57.37 3 6o .
I 555 31 572'8 57.18 3 6o.xo 5 Sep. 57.61 57.61 Feb. 2 6.43 57.63 3 58.29 58.29 3 6I.o9 3-80 57.29 4 56.64 56764 7.025 146 I.3 357 753 99 50 56.87 56.87 15 62.19 583 759 6 S6i6.12 56.1i 17 6ogo 57 10 7 56.69 56.69 f 19 61.76 57.96 9 56.5 56.54 2 6z 5,8.6o _________ 2I 62 .
I9 58.39 js__ _~L cc Aquihe .
1813 .
ABCD 1813 .
ABCD0 _V __ __ JUly 11 81 36.57.91-.0.4 57.51 ; Oct. 131 36.5 8.68-.0O88 57.801 I2 59.57 59.17 I 14 6o.iof 59 22 1 58.0 58.50 i6 58.45 57 57 17 5 8.83 58-43 18 6o .
51 59-63 19 58.18 57.78 58555s 19 59 94 590o6 586843 21 58.96 5g &gt; 5,55 1 6o~oo 59 12 584 22 59.01 58 .
i 25 58.67 57-79 25 59.88 59.48 31 6o 79 59-91 26 58.48 58.o8 Nov. 1 6o.84.2.00oo 5884 27 59 83 59.43 J4 6i49 59 49 29 58.22 57.82 ]66 i.o6 59.o6 30 5958 59.18 II 6o.8z 58.82 Aug. 2 59.98 59.58 13 6i.o6 59.o6 3 59.20 58.80 I4 6i.5o 5950 7 59.27 58.87 I8 61,93 5993 10 57.88 57.48 58,536 22 6I.17 59.17 &gt; 59.224 II 59.54 59.14 f27 6,.49 59.491 12 58.54 58.14 30 6I 61 $961 13 58.51 58.1I Dec. x5 61.24 -2-.80 58.44 15 58.64 58.24 j 20 61.96 59.16 I6 57.68 57.28 66 62.71 59.91 17 59.30 58.90 31 63.46 6o..,6 xg 5.51 58.11 181 4 .
* 21 57.67 57.27 tan.30 355 5927 22 58.52 58Iz2 5831 62.32 58.77 24 59.29 58.89 5830 Feb. 3 62.I2 _ 3.80 58.32 &gt; .59375 25 58.6z 58.22 i5 63.34 59.54 26 59.01 5 8.6 1 17 63.96 6o.6 I31 59-191 58.79 19 6z.98 59.18 SeP .
2 S.81.- .
5S.8i 20 6z.86 59.06 J 24 62.68 58.88 Appendix to Mr. PoND 's Paper on Parallax .
Read March 1s , 18X7 .
F ao Ivi the month of April 1814 , to the present time , the observations have been made with two microscopes only , and not having this subject in view , they generally are not calculated to throw much additional light on this question .
But last autumn , being induced to suspect , that the discordance I had met with in favour of parallax , might arise from the difference of temperature in summer and winter being in an opposite state relatively to the interior and exterior thermometer , I endeavoured this winter to keep the interior temperature of the observatory the same as that without , which the extreme mildness of the season rendered very easy to accomplish .
It likewise so happens that from the 1st of July last to the present time , the index error of the instrutment has suffered no variation .
It may , perhaps , have oscillated a small fraction of a second on each side the mean , but not more ; so that during this interval , the circle may be considered as having been a fixed instrument and therefore not liable to any of the objections above stated by Dr. BRINKLEY .
Under these circumstances , the observations , though not made with six microscopes , are very worthy of attention .
Those of a Lyra , fie Draconis , z Cygni , and M Aquilie , are very numerous , and there does not appear the least indication of any periodical variation whatever ; the extremely small discordance , which is no doubt accidentals1 happens , in some of the cases , to be in a direction contrary to parallax .
It now only remains to determine , whether the fixed ink1 struments , lately erected for this particular investigation , will confirm the above result .
',0 1-4 _~ _y ILyrae .
JI uY 1818l5.41 Auyept lg .
C44 71 'orrect mean of Oo observations 49 " .
198 .
Summer .
Sept. 129 49 98J Oct. 8 , 48.76 Nov. 12 49.661 Dec. 10 48.771 Jan. 4892 c4 orrect mean of o observations 49.205 .
Winter .
Feb. 3 49X69i 'y Draconis .
July i6 , 354 Aug. 7 , 8 475 correct mean of 31 observations 3".776 .
Summer .
Sc pt .
8 , 3.40 Oct. 7 .
3.16 1 Nov. 9 , 4+ correct mean of.3 observations 3".8t7 .
Winter .
Dec. 8 , 3.25j Jan. 9 , 3.95 Sept. 14 i767 c Cygni .
Oct. 12 .
17.01 c. orrect mean of 37 observations 17".36 .
Autumn .
Nov 1 1,17.38 J Dec. 9 ' 16.73 J~aenb .
817.1 correct mean of 7 observations 17".28 .
Winter .
Feb. 11 17.94 J.7osevt Mar 9 J/ a Aquilae .
Aug. 12,.9.65 Sep. 14,30.74 correct mean of 33 observations 30".29 .
Summer .
Oct. 7,30.31J Nov. 1i630.5S 1i Jec .
14 , ,30.74 &gt; correct mean of 45 observations 30"45 .
Winter .
Janr + ) 46074I Feb. 5,3o.61 J Mar._ With the French refractions , there would appear an extremely small dis ordance of o i " in a contrary direction to the effect of parallax .

