XXV .
On the fluents of irrational functions .
By Edward Ffrench Bromhead , Esq. M. A. Communicated by J. F. W. Herschel , Esq. F. R. S. Read June 4 , 18i6 .
HE efforts of analysts in determining the fluents of rational functions , have been completely successful , and their labours form one of the most perfect and beautiful branches of the fluxionary calculus .
In the irrational functions , however , we find but little effected .
With the exception of WARING , modern analysts have not added any thing important , to the forms given by NEWTON , CRAIG , COTES , and BERNOULLI .
No attempt lias been made to generalize the known forms , and the last eminent writer on the subject , LA CRoix , seems to consider them as independent results , not deducible from any common principles , and refers us to the Petersburgh Acts , and other miscellaneous Collections .
In the following pages , it is attempted to generalize and systematize our knowledge on this subject ; and to show that all the known forms result from other forms of the greatest extent , not depending on particular functions , but upon the properties of all rational functions whatever .
R , R , R , R , denote rational functions of any kind ' ; R"- ' , R- ' , XZn ]i R-~ , Rt their inverse functions .
Thus if x -R ( v ) any rational function of ( v ) , then v= R- ' ( x ) the inverse function .
It is thought unnecessary to prove , that the fluxions of all rational functions , and all rational functions of them , are themselves rational .
PROP .
1 dx .
Rx , xR'(x ) } can be rationalized .
Let R ' ( x ) = -v ; x R(v ) ; dx = dr DR ( v ) which substituted produce the rational form dv .
DR ( v ) .
R tR ( v ) Cor. 1 .
This form includes dx .
Rrx R ' .
R x , R- ' x. x.R x R-I(x ) Cor. 2 .
We may find , a priori , what fluents will come under this form .
For let x=R( ) any rational function whatever + .
4v *7+ a. *+a2a+a v+ aV + .
012 which is the general form taken by rational functions , when the integer powers are expanded , and the fractions reduced to a common denominator , the coefficients being positive , negative , or nothing .
Hence we have R- ' ( x ) = v , determined from this equation .
( ao.+ ( a. c v+ ) .
+ .
- ... -= o Cor. 3 .
Let the equation be ( a. ) + ( bx - .
)v=o Then R ' ( x ) =v= { + } .
we knowif d.R{ , ( ) } Cor. 4 .
Let the equation be ( ax-a ) + ( bx - ) .
n+ ( cx y ) .
=n o from which we can determine 2CX 272 Z eCXx -4 and therefore any fluent of the form Jdx .
RIx , / x + xiq+ : It is obvious that these deductions may be carried to any extent , producing forms hitherto supposed impracticable .
ax +P Cor5. .
ax + is both of the form 11'(x ) and R+ ' ( x ) .
PROP .
-II We can rationalize dx , R x , RP -(x ) ) , - ' ' ),. .
R ' IR-..R R(x ) X a , ? ?
ax i. A Let R- ' .
R-~'(x)=- .
Then nI x=R R ... R ( v ) Rl.'x R R. .
R ( v ) &amp;c. &amp;c. which , substituted in the original expression , make it rational .
Cor , i. If R=R= R , the fluxion becomes dT .
R\x , Rt ( x ) R"(x ) , .
xR-"( ) Cor. 2 .
By this theorem , any of the expressions deducible from Prop. I. may enter contemporaneously , and we may find fluents of very great intricacy .
Cor 3 .
The fluents ^.R{id^( , +^ * ( I ; )..1 fl\d 337 Jdx .
R tx , + Vabb. .
/ R.(x,. .
and some of the most complex expressions in WARING'S Med. Anal. are very particular cases of this form .
PROP .
III .
We can rationalize I xI dX , R{x , R--'(a/ ( P- " ( X))m , ( R--X(x ) ) " " ( R ) ) *** } Let R- ' ( x ) - } v"m n r. Then xR ( um n * ' ) § 1{ ^R'( ; ) } m f Jdx .
R { x , S2 xi + kX + qy , ( x + 4/ 1 x ' + { x +y)m,.y. .
} with an indefinite number of forms too complex for convenient expression .
Cor. 3 .
This form may be extended to Prop. II .
and other general expressions .
Thus we know iI dx .
R x , R-'( ) , R-1R-7(Z),. .
( R-'. .
( ))R-x-I ' ... R '(x ) n ... ^it iAnIa The forms given above are wholly inapplicable , when the fluxion involves expressions , such as R-'R R"~ ... ( x ) where the functions are alternately inverse and direct .
The cases are very few , in which the ditficulty can be overcome , and perhaps the following Propositions will be found to include all the instances , in which analysts have effected the reduction .
PROP .
IV .
We can rationalize dx .
DR(x).{R(x ) , RR(x ) } Let R ( x ) = v , and it becomes dv .
RIv , R'(v)}as in Prop. i. Cor. i. We can generally reducefdx .
Dp ( x ) .
( x ) to dv .
p ( v ) .
Thus we deduce from fdx .
xrn .
p ( x ) the Jdv .
v'lq ( v ) , and fromJ x. p ( xl ) the/ j. ( v ) , reductions of frequent occurrence , by which analysts have given their forms an appearance of generalization without the reality .
Cor. a : This form may be extended to all the former Propositions .
Cor. 3 .
As it is very tedious and often impracticable to find x in terms of v , in order to know whether the reduction be applicable ; the following process may sometimes be useful , Let the expression be d. DR(x ) .
R ' R ( x ) .
RR(x ) Then if it be divided by dx .
DR ( x ) .
R-'R ( x ) the quotient will be a rational function of R ( x ) or of the form + .
R( ) + ( R ( ) ) ' + .
o ( xa ) R()-+( ( R))R .
+ the coefficients being indeterminate .
a+a.Rx)+a .
( R ( z)+ If the reduction be applicable , these may be found , and the substitution made at once .
Cor. 4 .
We may thus reduce xn " + ( n-I ) c.x.dx.n--_ .
Rt xl +c x1+ ... JC..R { ++ to - .
R ( v ) , which may be found .
Cor. 5 .
In dx .
xr-I .
( n , + n ) .
Rn~ " +I divide by dx .
nlxn- ' .
( Cxn -+ )2 and the quotient is ? .
( 'r .
iR ( oxr " + p ) .
The latter factor is already of the required form , and by assuming x(r- ' ) = a. ( cx + A)r , + a. ( ZX + )Y-2+ , 0 ?
the indetermi nates may be found .
In particular cases there are readier processes , but this method is universally applicable .
PROP .
V. We can rationalize dx .
R { , R'R ( x ) if we can determine , R'R ( x ) ln It nR ( x ) .
R-(x ) , for the fluxion then becomes dx .
R{ , R ( x ) .
R'I(x ) as in Prop. I. Cor. i. Cor. 1 .
We also know dx .
R{ x , R- ` ( ) , RR(x)l n Cor. .
We may thus transform dx *R{( ) ( ax +3 ( ax + b)n t } into T dx .
R{x , ( +b ) + , ( a + b)( we can determine F ; c. Rx , R-1 Sx ) R- ` R ( x ) } f R71 R ( x)l " l Cor. 4 .
If R-'R(x ) ) R ( ) m/ R- ' ) ; R- ' R ( x)= R ( x ) .
zfI 0 , ?
n st VR-xx ) ; &amp; c , we know fdx .
R x , R(x ) , R ( ) , RR ( x ) , R-RR ( x),. .
am ft %3r as in dx .
R+ G ( a+ b)m- , x/ 7 ; X + ; 3)( x ( ax+b)n .
T Cor. 5 .
Generally if R ( x ) and R ( x ) are so related , that RR ( x ) can =RR ( x ) , R and R being any rational x n ?
mnnn functions whatever taken at pleasure , then dx .
R tz , RR(x ) } can be rationalized by taking == R ( v ) .
It then becomes dv DR ( v ) R { R ( v ) , R ( v ) } .
mmn PROP .
VI .
By combining Prop. IV .
and V , we can rationalize dx .
DR(x ) .
RR ( x ) , R1 RR ( x ) } mmInm if R-I R ( v ) -R ( v ) .
R(v ) ; for let R ( x ) = v , and it becomes dv .
R v , R ( v ) .
R ' ( ) } as before .
Cor. i. If we have p dx .
n- , ( 4S +R { a{ + } Remove the multiplier xn % as in Prop. V. , and it becomes , dxm ( Qs + P3Z-n ) ? .
R+ x-n ) np which will fall under Prop V. IV If x can be expressed by a rational function of a+ Px--n .
This will happen if +qP n r , or if= +r any integer .
Hence we know J_r dx r dx Cor. 9a We can determine ax~"swam 13dx J XZn-+ v __ Jn+ yX " Va +x +c^n + which becomes by Prop. 5 .
na , -n-x di oa tx..f_ t V+ t+C Now this falls under Prop. IV .
For let Vc,4 Xn + xF-.+ c. =v aXn + X-n ?
+ qy V= un +_C s. .
( pxx- , tn-i ) .
d-x = vn--I .
dv Whence the fluxion becomes -d , of which a particular v +.--c case is deduced in LEGENDRE'S Elliptic Transcendents .
PROP .
VII .
If we can rationalize dx .
R{x , ( x ) , p ( x),. .
} we also can dx .
R x , R ' ( x ) , R ` ( x ) , R(z),. .
for by taking R- ' ( x ) v , it is reduced to the former form .
Cor. 1 .
If we can rationalize x. Rt , R ' R ( ) } , we also can dx .
R{ x , R- ' ( ) , RR R-x ( x ) m3nm Therefore we can find adx .
Rx , R-I ( x ) , 1/ a + b.R1 ( x ) + c. ( x)R2 dx .
R , V+x -+ bx } &amp;c. Cor. 2 .
Generally we can reduce dx .
Rx , R R-1 ... R R-1 ( x ) } to dx .
R x , R..R ( x ) Cor. 3 Infdx p ( x ) , let v= p ?
( x ) , and if it be an algebraic filnction , R { x , v , } = o. Now take x=R ( z ) o+az+ Cz + &amp;c. $ + &amp;c. :+-+ &amp; c : and = ( ) - &amp; with ina +az+ a. with ; determinate coefficients .
Hence we have R { R ( z ) , R ( z ) } = o ; remove fractions and make the coefficients of the powers of z vanish .
This will give the indeterminates , if x and v admit common rationalities .
Thence xe have d. DR ( ) .
R ( z ) rational .
Should all the artifices in the foregoing propositions fail , we must attempt to resolve the fluxion into a series of terms , such that each term may be separately rationalized .
This is 344l4 often possible , when the original function does not admit a rational expression , and can be effected sometimes directly , and sometimes by introducing a new variable .
But it will first be necessary to reduce all irrational functions whatever to a definite form .
LEMMA .
To reduce all irrational functions to a definite form .
1 .
By successively multiplying numerators and denominators into the same expressions , every irrational function may at last be reduced to a series of terms , whose numerators and denominators do not contain any fraction or negative index .
Thus + ' .
and if , y , a , b , c , are ( a+ +jT .
( acn + b)m functions involving fractions or negative indices , themselves , the reduction is continued in the same manner .
2 .
Now multiply both the numerators and denominators of the expressions so reduced , by such multipliers , as will render the denominators rational .
This factor is the product of all the different values of the denominator , with the exception of the denominator itself .
The new numerators will still consist of a series of terms not involving any fraction or negative index. .
If R , R , R , &amp;c. denote functions of the form cix + c. mm-l ... , the irrational takes the form , R ( x ) R(x ) acR ( x ) are )+ rr ) *~ ( X ) .
T ( X d ... + R d. + ( X).*. .
+ .
I3 $5 4 .
By reducing the fractional indices of the factors to the '45 common denominator ( n ) , the whole will consist of a series of R ( x ) terms 2 .
~( ) .
xvx)q* .
3 5 .
By expanding all the integer powers under the index 7 ; and again reducing the indices of the sums and products , which are under it , to a common denominator n ' ; we shall by continuing the same operations , ultimately reduce the whole expression , to a series of terms of the form R ( x ) AV mS denoting the sum of any number of terms such as follow it , wherein R ( x ) may be different in each term , but always of the form cxm + cxm-+ e the series of terms above exhibited , may readily be found ; by introducing all the rational parts entirely under the radicals ; by reducing the indices of all the terms to a common denominator p ; by expanding all integer powers ; and by again reducing all the products and sums contained under - , to indices with a common denominator yt .
These operations continued , will ultimately lead to the expression\y/ F/ P* ( b ) R ( x ) SS v ' ... S V/ , where amay be of any diffeR ( x ) R ( -x ) rent values in the different sums , but always of the form ax + ax + .
I bx + bx+ .
IR ( x ) 9 .
R(X is said to be of aMdimensions ; and if a be dimensions of that rational part , whose dimensions are greatest ; then the dimensions of the whole irrational are'-e Io , The fluxion , and its dimensions in any irrational , may be found by applying this formula , d { ... ( x ) } -=D q q. .
p ( x ) .
D ( ) D. ( x ) dx , the D BI n1X3nn only referring to the functional characteristic immediately succeeding it .
PROP .
VIII .
To divide a fluxion into expressions admitting distinct raC tionalities .
MDccCXVIL Zz 347 Let ( x ) be any irrational , and q ( x ) , p ( x ) &amp;c. surds deduced as in the Lemma .
Then gr dx .
R x ) dx .
R(x ) / fd * ( r ) 73 -R ( ) + ?
+ &amp; cx where the fluent of the 1st term may always be found , and the other terms may often be rationalized by distinct substitutions , when we are unsuccessful withfdx. .
p ( x ) .
Again since in each of the terms , x. R ( x ) R ( x ) I3 - , -a ( ) ) Rn may be reduced to a series of terms of the form Aax and ( j ; therefore the fluent depends ( X + " a on a series of terms fdx .
x ' .
( x ) , and dx .
( x+a)(x ) .
InI the latter case , the form of p ( x ) is not changed by substituting x for x+ a , and ' the fluents of all irrationals are determinable byJdx .
x + .
p ( x ) .
Cor. i. If we multiply the denominator of dz , .
R ( x ) R ( x ) .
" Va'x+ d+d R ( ) .
v ' iX2 +X +v by its rationalizing factor , the fluxion will be reduced to two terms , which admit distinct rationalities .
Cor. 2 .
Sometimes by the substitution of a new variable , for some function of x , the fluxion will be divided into a series of terms , each of which may be separately made rational .
-But unfortunately no general principle has been discovered , to which these reductions can be referred .
Cor. 3 .
As the fluent of each term can sometimes be found apart , when the fluent of the whole cannot be found at once ; so conversely , the fluent of a series of terms may be found , when each separate term surpasses the powers of analysis .
Thus we , know d q ?
( x ) +d &lt; ( x ) +4o p(x ) + ( x ) + o But we do not know d9 ( x ) r dp ( x ) x+ ( ) p ( ) + ?
( + ) Again , let p ( x ) be such a function of x , that 2 '(x ) = 7 ; let p ( x ) x ; , , Thenfdx .
c ( x ) = x. cp ( x ) -fd ( x ) .
x= x. q ( x ) -fd q ( x ) .
cp ( x ) .
=x .
-ed xf P , ( .
dx .
( x ) +e fdx .
( x ) = .
Which theorem admits farther extension , and may be applied to elliptic arches .
Should the above processes for rendering the fluxion rational fail us , we must attempt the fluxion at once in its irrational state , for which purpose I shall add a few miscellaneous observations .
i. If &lt; p ( x ) , V ( x ) be any algebraic functions , d ( x ) then dT{ ( x ) + log .
m ( x ) } = dp ( x ) + i- .
is an algebraic expression .
Whenever , therefore , we meet with an 349 algebraic fluxion , we may legitimately try q ( x ) + log .
p ( x ) , as a form to which the fluent may possibly belong.* 9 .
It presents three cases : ist .
where the fluent is wholly algebraic , for which we assume some expression so general , that its fluxion will include the given fluxion , if it admit an algebraic fluent ; or we find the fluent implicitly by an equation : ddly .
where the fluent is mixed , when we attempt to separate the algebraic part : 3dly .
where the fluent is purely logarithmic , when we assume , as in the firat case , some expression with indeterminate constants , sufficiently general to include the given fluxion .
g. In assuming for an algebraic fluxion , it must be observed , that the fluent will always be a surd of the same order as the fluxion .
On this principle WARING gives some assumptions for surds of the second order , but nothing has been attempted generally for surds of all orders , for want of some definite form which should include them all .
In irrationals of the first order , the fluxion may always be reduced to series of terms , such as dx .
Ix + a".x + aY ix + a\ where the factors are all different , and where the indices are positive , negative , fractions , integers , or unity .
Then let R.(x ) be any expression cx"+ cxn-Z +. .
with indeterminate coefficients .
Assume for the fluent ( )( x ?
) n+ ) R ( x ) n-I Its fluxion will be DR ( x ) .
x( + a ) .
a( xa _.-- ... .
IR ( X ) _-R ( a ) .
( a ).(x+ ) -(+ a +( +(3 + i).(x+ a ( { +a+ ( ni SI S I^ multiplied by dx .
( xv + a). .
( x a ) the original fluxion .
In Now that the two expressions may be equal , the coefficient found above must be = i , or we must have DR ( x).Q-R ( ).Q ' R ( x ) } n-I n-I n-i where Q and Q ' are the expressions in the coefficient involving a , a , a. By equating the terms in this equation , the indei n terminates c , c , c , &amp;c. may be found ; but the reduction will I2 often be impossible , as there are more equations to be satisfied than there are indeterminates .
4 .
If any index a , 3 , y =--- , the expression fails , and there is no algebraic fluent ; also WARING says , that if the dimensions of a fluxional coefficient be--i , the fluent cannot be algebraic .
5 .
If ( x ) be an irrational function , let z =fdx .
q ( x ) =fdJx .
v ; then since R x , v}o there are cases , where we can determine , R x , z } = o.* 6 .
If ( x ) , ,r ( x ) be irrational functions of .
, we have Jdf .
( x ) =fd .
{ ( x ) +s ( x ) } ~-fJ .
( , ) Now let I ( x ) be so assumed , that See Phil , Trans , 1764- , -EMBRsoNR ' Fluxions 351 fdx .
*{ ( x ) +{ ( )x ) } I ?
( ) , and we have $dx * .
q ( x)3 p ( x)--fod .
r ( x ) .
If therefore ?
r ( x ) be a simpler expression than ( &lt; x ) , the fluxion will be reduced to a simpler form .
In order to find w ( x ) ; ( x ) is assumed with indeterminate coefficients , so that its fluxion may be of the same form as dx .
&lt; q ( x ) .
Now equate the similar terms in the two expressions , and the indeterminates may be found .
But as there may be more equations than indeterminates , we add vr ( x ) a function of the same form , and containing indeterminates of sufficient number , to satisfy all the deficient equations .
We shall thus have Dp ( ) =P ( X ) +x ( + ) and .
( x ) =d .
{ ( x ) + ( x ) } by which the difficulty may be reduced to findingfdx .
r ( x ) .
Reductions of particular kinds were discovered by SIMPSON and others , but this is universally applicable .
7 .
It may be of advantage to reduce the index of the variable under the radical , which may sometimes be effected .
In dx .
e mr ++1 } , assume xm+n +1= un ; Then we have dx .
xm + }= mr .
dv .
^ .
( v ) )m n And in the same manner surds of one order may be transformed into another .
8 .
If the fluent be wholly logarithmic , we may assume for irrationals of the first order iog , )R ( ).(x + a)6 .
( x + b ) ... +R ( ).( + c)( .
+ } O ?
i(~~~~~~~~~~~~ I shall conclude by observing that the fluxion may always be made rational , if the fluent be wholly algebrate , or wholly logarithmic .
Thus , if q ( x ) be any algebraic function , take xa= p,1 R ( v ) , Then dq ( x ) =d ( qR ( v ) ) dR ( v ) and d ( log .
( px =d ( log .
q)p-l R ( v ) i are both rational .
If the fluent be of the mixed form ?
\ ( x ) + log .
( x ) , its fluxion may be made rational , if R , 1R , can be so assumed that ?
-I R ( x ) = p--1 R ( x ) ; and it may ii always be effected by introducing two new variables .
First let x= -x -R ( v ) , and the fluxion becomes d(99'R ( v ) dR ( v ) + -R--'- ; now let v R- ' pCR ( Z ) , an Rq ) 'R(v ) S-^(l i^ we get dRdR ( z ) a ( v ) +R ) which is wholly rational .
I E'DWARD FFRENCH BROMHEAD .
Note.-As modern analysts have in general confounded the fluxions , either with the increments or the derived functions , it may not be superfluous to state precisely , what is meant by the symbols d and D. If it be possible , ( which must be shown in each particular case ) to expand p ( x + v ) in the form p ( x ) +9 ( x ) .
+q ( x). .
; then 9 ( x ) is called the derived ~'* function of i ( x ) , and its relation to Q ( x ) is thus expressed , p ( x ) D ( x ) .
Hence , if x be considered a function of itself , we have ( x + v ) = ( x ) +D ( x ) .
v , and , .
D ( x ) Now to avoid a constant reference to the variable x , of which other variables are considered as functions , we introduce fluxions .
Ify , , w , ... are functions of the 355 same variable , then die , dz , dw , * are expressions proportional to the derived func tions of y , zs , w. whatever may be the variable of which they are common functions .
Iene e Wy =-Dz ; and if y be a function of x , or = ( ) , then d= Dop ( x ) De = Dp ( x ) and.- , die dx .
Dp ( x ) .
Moreover , since the derived functions are in the limiting ratio of the increments , so also are the fluxions .
From this consideration we can in the applications of analysis , practically determine the ratio of the fluxions , when the derived functions are unknown .
ERRATA .
Page 7,2 , line so , for parts , read part .
_-- " 73 , line 3 , for between , read below .
98 , line 4 from bottom , del the comma after A. o- , line 6 from bottom , del BH .
Io2 , line 4 , for axes , read axis .
-64 , line x , del the comma between m and n. -174 , line 7 , for consisted of , read consisted in .
----- , -line last , for m , n , read m , m. o line -z - ] 9-1 , line I3 , for q x , read p zx .
2-13 , line 14 , for t +4 , ( x , y ) , read ~ -4 ( x , y ) .
14 , line 1o , del s in an infinite number of ways " .
-24 , line zz , forf(a ) , readf(x ) .
-226 , line 24 , for = x , read = z. -232 , line 16 , in the denominator , for x- , read 1 ------ , line 8 , ditto , ditto , for -- , read xi ? .
d+ x , I ) d % ( X- ) -z , line 9 , for d read Ydx dx --.-- , line x x , for d in both numerator , read dz .
---r -a ?
line 13 , for 1 ) read x({ ) .
JY BIj

