XX .
On the different methods f constructing a catalogue offixed stars .
By J. POND , Esq. F. R. S. Astronomer Royal .
Read May i , 18i8 .
IN the present state of practical astronomy , the principal object in a national observatory , such as that at Greenwich , is to define the position in the heavens , of the fixed stars and other celestial bodies , at the moment of their passage over the meridian ; and we judge of the perfection of the instruments , and of the skill with which they are employed , by the degree of precision with which this operation is performed .
The very great changes and improvements that have taken place within these few years in the instruments of this establishment , are well known to all persons who have interested themselves in its concerns .
The liberality of his Majesty 's Government has been literally unbounded ; and instruments of unusual magnitude and of most difficult construction , have been executed with a success that has exceeded the most sanguine expectation .
Such powerful means entrusted to my care , could not but produce , on my part , a continued anxiety that they should be employed in the most advantageous manner .
Being constantly under the necessity of reflecting a great deal on the various possible modes , both of making observations and of deducing results from them , I have insensibly been led to adopt methods which differ very materially from those generally pursued , and some of these appear to .
me to possess advantages so decided , that I venture to submit them to the consideration of this Society ; at the same time , conscious that the subject cannot excite a very general interest , I shall endeavour to abstain as much as possible from every unnecessary detail , and confine myself to the explanation of the general principles of the method which I propose to recommend .
According to the method hitherto invariably followed in this Observatory in constructing a catalogue of stars , either in declination or right ascension , some one star has been taken as a point of departure , and the positions of all the rest determined by direct comparison with this alone .
The declinations were determined by direct measurement with qy Draconis ; * and a Aquilae was chosen as the common term of comparison in right ascension .
This mode of proceeding with the mural quadrant , though evidently capable of improvement , was not so very objectionable , as when applied to the observations made with the transit instrument ; as the observer must be supposed desirous of obtaining the greatest possible accuracy from a given number of observations .
Indeed , in the latter case , the principle is so very objectionable , that I cannot now help expressing some surprise that it should have been employed for so great a length of time .
In the first place , every result deduced from the observation of each star is affected with a double error ; that committed in the observation of a Aquila , and that in the observation of the star itself ; this objection however is but trifling , compared with a more important one , which is this : if the observation of a Aquilae be omitted , either from bad weather , or from its passing the meridian at an inconvenient hour , or from neglect , then the observations of all the other stars are , for the purposes of this investigation , rendered entirely useless .
Hence arose the necessity of combining the observations of so many years , to construct a catalogue with the accuracy required .
That extreme accuracy was ultimately obtained , I am most happy to have it in my power to affirm , since the difference is almost insensible between the catalogue lately deduced from the new transit instrument and that of my predecessor ; though an interval of ten years has intervened between the periods of their construction .
The advantage therefore of my method I conceive to consist in this ; that a catalogue may be constructed from the observations of a single year , equal in accuracy to one which formerly was obtained in three .
The method I propose is equally applicable to the mural circle and the transit instrument .
With neither do I assume any particular star as a point of departure , in preference to the rest ; but , on the contrary , every star in its turn is assumed as a point of reference to the others ; thus endeavouring , in the first instance , to establish their relative distances from each other on the equator , or meridian , leaving the choice and determination of some common point of departure as a subject for future consideration .
To render this more easily intelligible , perhaps it would be better to consider each instrument separately .
40o7 Whoever attentively examines the construction of the mural circle at Greenwich , will perceive that its operation is entirely limited to the measurement of the meridional distance between different stars .
It is , in fact , a theodolite placed vertically .
By an extension of its principle , it can measure the distance between a star and its reflected image from a mercurial horizon , and thus determine the altitude of a star ; and , in common with every other circle , it can measure the distance of a circumpolar star from the pole by an observation of its inferior and superior passage over the meridian .
As the instrument cannot be reversed , a plumb line could not be applied , with any advantage .
In circles that turn freely in azimuth , a double observation of a star gives the angle which the star makes with the axis of the instrument round which it turns , and a plumb line is properly applied in this case to ensure the verticality of this axis ; but on the Greenwich circle , a plumb line could only serve as a point of departure ; and this having no reference to the real zenith , would , in my opinion , be very injudiciously chosen .
Let us suppose , by way of example , that twelve starshad been observed with the mural circle , and one of these the pole star ; moreover , that this star had been observed below the pole .
Then , as it would be easy to determine the polar point , the position of all the remaining stars , with reference to this point , might likewise be ascertained .
It is however evident in this case , that each result would be affected by a double error , viz. the error committed in the determination of the polar point , and also that due to the observation of each star .
40o8 Let us next suppose that , from some accidental cause , the inferior passage of the pole star had been omitted ; then , if the declination of this star be supposed to be known from previous observation , the polar point may be deduced from this supposition ; but the pole star , in this case , would have no superiority over any other star , whose polar distance should previously have been determined .
If we employ two stars equally well known , it is evident that greater accuracy will be obtained ; and it is easy to conceive that by taking a greater number of stars , for instance the whole twelve , we may obtain greater accuracy than even by a double observation of the pole star , because the error of observation , and that arising from false assumption of polar distance , will necessarily be much diminished by the natural tendency which the positive and negative errors will have to counteract each other .
These considerations , aided by daily trial and experience , induced me very soon after the mural circle was erected , to abandon every method which assumed one particular point of departure , and I directed all my efforts to the determination of the difference of declination which existed between every star and all the rest ; constructing by this means a catalogue , which , with respect to the pole or the zenith , might be subject to a common error ; reserving to myself the power of investigating this common error by a process which will afterwards be explained .
In the practical execution of this method , the observation of each star is employed for a double purpose ; it first serves , in combination with all the others , to find the common index error ; this common error again applied to the individual observation , gives a 409 new result of the position of the star : and of the totality of these results is the catalogue ultimately formed .
In a paper which ; I had the honour of communicating to the Society , in the year 18i6 , I have given several examples of the manner in which the index error of the mural circle is calculated , though I did not at that time explain the principle or advantages of this method .
In the printed Greenwich observations will be also found the computations of this index error for every month .
I should observe , that when the greatest possible accuracy is required , the whole of the observations should be re-computed from the catalogue now supposed to be in its most perfect state , except the extremely small improvement it may receive from this process .
And thus , by continued observation and approximation , may the relative places of the stars be assigned to a very unexpected degree of accuracy .
Now , though a continuation of this process has an evident tendency to improve the catalogue , as far as concerns the relative distances of the several stars to each other , yet it can have no effect in correcting any common error that may exist from a false assumption either of the zenith or the pole .
I will endeavour , therefore , to explain the next part of the process , which is to determine the common error in polar distance .
It is to be presumed that the pole star forms one of the stars of which the intended catalogue is composed , and it should be observed most assiduously , both above and below the pole .
These observations are to be treated as if appertaining to different stars , and the place of each determined in the catalogue , by applying the same index error as that em41o ployed for the other stars .
When the whole catalogue is completed , these two results are to be examined ; and , if they appear equally distant from the pole , the catalogue is affected by no common error ; but if , on the contrary , the polar point is not found to be precisely between these results , then half the difference will be the common error .
The details of these computations will be found in the Greenwich observations ; and it will there be seen that the polar distances of this star , determined by 158 observations , in the same manner as anyother star of the catalogue , namely , by the application of the common index error , was found to be 41.1.21.50 Below the pole , by 132 observations , computed in the same manner S58.x8.38.$3 Their sum 35959.59.89 360 Difference from 360 oo 0".18 Difference or common error 0.09 This difference , 0".09 , is the common error to be added to each star of the catalogue , and the polar distance of the star thus corrected will be 1.i4.21.59 .
I find by about 350 observations , deduced in the usual manner , without any reference to the other stars , i.4.B1.65 , reduced to the beginning of 1813 .
The same principle , which I have thus attempted to explain , may be applied with equal facility , and even greater advantage , to the formation of a catalogue in right ascension .
The error of the clock in this case , answers to the index error of the circle , and is investigated in precisely the same manner .
An approximate catalogue is first assumed ; and here , as with the circle , the observation of each star serves a double purpose : in the first place , in common with all the rest , it is employed to determine the error of the clock ; and the error thus found is applied to the observation of the star .
In this case , the right ascension of the star is supposed to be known ; in the second part of the process , the star is considered as a planet , or unknown object , and its right ascension found by the usual rules , and recorded as a single result ; and from the totality of these results is the right ascension ultimately obtained .
Should the deduced right ascensions differ materially from those originally assumed , the improved catalogue must be substituted for the approximate one , and the whole process recomputed .
In this substitution , however , some judgment and discretionary power must be exercised ; for should the assumed or approximate catalogue be very exact , and the subsequent observations few or inaccurate , it is evident that the new catalogue might be less correct than the assumed one ; this , however , does not arise from any defect in the method , but is the inevitable consequence of any attempt to improve good observations by bad ones .
As a practical illustration of this remark , I might add , that having myself assumed an approximate catalogue , so exact as that of Dr. MASKELYNE , it happens that at this moment , in the case of some stars which have not been very frequently observed , I have great doubts whether the new determination is more exact than the old one ; but by continuing this process , a proper ascendancy will necessarily be acquired by the latest observations .
In comparing my catalogue of right ascensions with that of Dr. MASKELYNE , I meet with a singular coincidence , which seems tome to illustrate and confirm , in a very striking manner , the advantage of the principle in question .
In each catalogue , the right ascension of a Aquilae , though deduced apparently by a different process , comes out the same , even to the hundredth part of a second .
Accident may possibly have some little share in this very exact coincidence , but it appears to me chiefly to arise from the very nature of our respective processes .
In Dr. MASKELYNE'S method , the right ascension of every star is derived from direct comparison with a , Aquilae , or in other words , the right ascension of a Aquilal is derived by comparing it with every star .
So it is in my method ; and hence the same result ought to be obtained .
But the advantage which in one case is peculiar to a Aquilae , is in the other method extended to every star : no possible reason can be given , why the place of one star should be more accurately assigned than that of another , provided an equal number of observations be obtained of each , since the place of every star is deduced exactly in the same manner from a comparison of all the rest.* Though not immediately connected with the present subject , I wish to take this opportunity of stating , that , in comparing the observations of the old transit instrument with those of the new one , I find a much less difference than I expected .
It appears to me that the former instrument must have described nearly a correct hour circle , though this circle was evidently not exactly the meridian .
With all the decided superiority of the new instrument , I cannot venture to assign to the catalogueof my predecessor an error much greater than one tenth of a second of time , even in the stars near the horizon , where the error appears probably to have been the greatest .
I trust it will be considered by astronomers , as creditable to the history of this Observatory , that two observers , with different instruments ( and by as different a method of computation as the case admits of ) should deduce two catalogues so exactly alike , that they may be considered almost as identical .
It is an interesting question to every astronomer possessed of a valuable instrument , to know to what degree of accuracy its results can be depended on .
I have examined a great number of observations made with the new transit instrument with this view , and it appears to me , that near the equator , 60 observations will generally give the second decimal place of a second of time very correctly ; io observations will give this with greater certainty , but not in the proportion of two to one.* This I think is rather a greater exactness than can be obtained by the mural circle , t and the reason I apprehend to be this .
With the mural circle , or any similar instrument , the place of a star appears to be defined at the moment of observation with much greater precision than by a transit instrument ; but the error of the latter , I conceive , to be much more purely accidental ; so that the result of a great number of observations will be more exact .
Local refraction places an insurmountable limit to observations in declination , particularly at any sensible distance from the zenith : observations in right ascension are free from this material source of error , and are therefore susceptible of attaining greater accuracy by continued perseverance .
I have no doubt but to many persons , and even to those extremely conversant with the theory of astronomy , it may appear , that a very undue degree of importance is attached by practical astronomers to the investigation of such minute quantities as form the subject of this paper ; and it is a question often asked , of what importance can it be to science , that the place of a fixed star should be so accurately ascertained ?
A person in my situation might reply , that being employed to do this , it is incumbent on him to do it in the best manner possible , leaving the question of utility to others ; but there is really a very reasonable and satisfactory answer to be given to this question .
In the first place , since the position of the sun , moon , and planets , are deduced from direct comparison with the principal stars , it is requisite , for this purpose , that their places should be accurately known , and their various changes ascertained .
Moreover , very good one ; but of all the instruments in the Observatory , it is certainly that in which improvement would be most beneficial .
though in common language we speak of determining the places of the fixed stars relatively to the equator and ecliptic , the real fact is , that the stars being stationary , it is the situation of these circles themselves , and the point of their intersection , that is the ultimate object of research ; and in this point of view we at once perceive how these precise determinations may facilitate the most abstruse investigations of physical astronomy .

