XVI .
On a mal-conformation of the uterine system in women ; and on some physiological conclusions to be derivedfrom it .
In a letter to Sir Everard Home , Bart. V. P. R. S. from A. B. Granville , M. D. F. R. S. F. L. S. Physician in ordinary to H. R. H. the Duke of Clarence ; Member of the Royal College of Physicians , and Physician-Accoucheur to the Westminster General Dispensary .
Read April 16 , 1818 .
DEAR SIR , AtVHEN I proceeded , two years ago , to Paris for the purpose of studying still farther , and in a more advantageous manner , the particular branch of the medical profession I have embraced , you did me the honour to request that I would communicate to you any fact , which might occur to me during my stay in that capital , calculated to elucidate the process of generation .
The good fortune I enjoyed in being admitted into the Maternit , or Great Lying-in Hospital , than which no other similar public institution in Europe , except perhaps that at Vienna , is better calculated to advance the study of the obstetric art ; and the frequent anatomical investigations at which I assisted , through the kindness of Mons. CHAUSSIER , one of the most distinguished professors of the Faculty of Medicine , have , I am willing to believe , placed it within my power to satisfy you on the subject of your request .
Of the many facts , however , which the numerous opportunities I possessed have brought before me , connected with the physiology of generation , none , in my opinion , deserves more to be mentioned than the one which it is the purport of the present letter to describe ; and when I reflect on the many important researches you have made on this interesting subject , I feel confident , that you will find the contents of the following pages worthy of your attention ; since the case they record appears to me to stand single in the annals of descriptive anatomy .
It is for this reason , therefore , that I shall confine myself to its description alone , leaving any other information I may possess on the subject , as matter for future correspondence .
Early in June 1817 , I was summoned to attend the opening of the body of a woman aged 40 , who died at La Maternit ?
, six or seven days after delivery , of what had long been suspected to be a disease of the heart , or of some of the larger vessels .
This conjecture was not ill founded ; for on examining the contents of the thorax , an aneurism of the aorta was discovered , together with a considerable enlargement of the heart .
As a subject for secondary consideration , it may not be improper to mention , also , that the bronchiae were found lined by a beautifully formed membrane , entirely detached from their inner surfaces , and admitting of being extracted without deranging its tubiform structure ; yet , the patient had never complained of any disorder of the respiratory organs .
Our attention , however , during dissection , was soon engaged by a still more curious anatomical arrangement , which presented itself to our view on the examination of the abdominal viscera .
The womb , half concealed by the intestines , and immersed in a considerable quantity of serous fluid , being four times at least the size of what it is in the unimpregnated state , was lying in its natural position .
On clearing it from all the surrounding parts , it was found that this viscus had acquired its full developement on the right side only , where it presented the usual pear-like convexity and undulation ; while the left , exhibited a direct straight line , scarcely half an inch distant from the centre , although more than two inches could be measured from that same point to the outline of the right side .
But this is not all : the spermatic and uterine vessels , the Fallopian tube , and the ovarium , with its surrounding peritonaeal folds ( which on the right side were placed as usual , and in their natural state , with the regular opening into the fundus uteri ) were not to be found in the left .
The rudiments , for they could be called by no other name , of those appendages of the uterine system on that side , were discovered lying in the inferior part of the cavity of the pelvis , loosely connected with the cervix of the uterus ; the ligamentum rotundum being inserted into the superior and interior ridge of the os pubis of the same side .
In dissecting this confused mass , we perceived what may be said to have been an ovarium , shrivelled , horny , and dry , and lost within the intricacies of the substance to which it was attached .
None of the other parts of generation presented any particular appearance worthy of remark .
I have endeavoured to portray the peculiar arrangement of the parts above described in the accompanying sketch , taken at the time .
( P1 .
XVII .
) This woman had been the mother of eleven children of both sexes , and had , as I have before observed , been delivered a few days previously of twins , a male and a female .
From this latter circumstance , in particular , we are enabled , for the first time , to form a definite opinion regarding the theory which has been advanced , at different times , respecting,10o the cause that has been supposed to influence the procreation of the two sexes : and to answer effectually , if an answer to such a proposition can be thought necessary , the arguments adduced by some systematic writers on the subject , but more particularly by Mons. MILLOT , in a recent work , " on the art of procreating the two sexes at pleasure ; " in which he lays down distinct precepts for ensuring to parents either a male , or a female succession .
Most of these systems , and that of the latter physiologist more especially , are founded on the ovarium and the other uterine appendages being always double ; and it is curious to reflect , that however gratuitous such an idea might seem , no proof to the contrary has ever been brought forward before , to my knowledge .
The case I have now recorded , however , expunges of course for ever from our books of physiology such an hypothesis , and leaves us to discover a more plausible reason for this peculiar and very interesting feature in the process of generation .
It moreover puts to rest our doubts respecting a phenomenon of even greater importance , the existence of which , every physiologist , who has treated on the subject , with the exception of yourself , seems to have been disposed to deny .
I allude to the fact of the ova of twins , and those of different sexes too , coming from the same ovarium ; when , as in the present case , the fimbriated part of the Fallopian tube must necessarily remain attached for a considerable length of time to the ovarium , so as to allow both ova to pass into the uterus , without any union taking place between their membranes at any period of their progress through the tube , and afterwards coming in contact with a different part of the womb , to which they adhere .
These circumstances necessarily suppose a distance between the ova , which distance cannot exist without two distinct momenta in the propulsion of the two ova from the ovarium into the oviduct .
What obtains in cases of twins , must also take place where three , four , or even six children have been brought forth at one birth ; three ova being formed in each ovarium , so near to each other , that the three points at which they were expelled , must have all come within the long continued grasp of the fimbriated bodies .
Indeed it is possible , that the separation of more than one ovum at a time , from one ovarium , or from both , takes place oftener than we are led to believe , from the mere calculation of the number of complex labours .
For if the ova pass into the uterus even without copulation ; it is no bad logic to suppose , that some will occasionally go through that viscus , which are never impregnated at all .
This is indeed proved by a greater number of corpora lutea being found in the ovaria of some females , than corresponds to the number of young they have produced ; a doctrine , which I first read in your valuable communication in the Philosophical Transactions , " On the Passage of the Ovum in Women , &amp;c. " when you last year gave me the paper to carry to Monsieur CUVIER , and which I was happy to find afterwards immediately adopted by that eminent naturalist , in his course of lectures on generation .
These remarks lead to another , and the last consideration on the present subject ; namely , the existence of separate placentae in cases of twins , or even triplets ; which unless viewed in its true light , will make us run the risk of rendering that obscure , which in the process of generation seems perhaps the most intelligible .
Instances of such occurrences are very numerous ; they have been often mentioned by 3 , ia authors of veracity , and are recorded in the registers of the Great Lying-in Hospitals at Paris and Vienna .
Within the last eighteen months , four cases have occurred within my own practice ; and I have at this moment in my possession , the preparation of two placentae , one of which was expelled several days before the membranes of the second were ruptured .
In the case I have related , both the placentae and membranes came away separately , and at different periods ; proving still farther the soundness of the foregoing reasoning , giving a greater weight to the present observations , and explaining a number of cases in the ordinary process of generation , which have been brought forward as cases of superfetation .
In one of the volumes of the Transactions of the Royal College of Physicians , is a paper entitled " A case of superfetation , " which merely goes to prove the occasional coexistence of separate ova in utero , and proves nothing farther .
The Lady , whose prolific disposition is much descanted upon in that paper , and with whom twin cases were a common occurrence , was delivered of a male child sometime in November , 1807 , c " under circumstances very distressing to the parents , and on a bundle of straw ; " and again in February , 1808 , ( that is , scarcely three months afterwards ) of another male infant , " completely formed !
" -mark the expression , for it was not made use of in describing the first .
The former died " without any apparent cause , " when nine days old ; the other lived longer .
Now , can we consider this otherwise than as a common case of twins , in 313 which one of the foetuses came into the world at the sixth , and the other at the ninth month of pregnancy , owing to the ova being quite distinct and separate ?
Had this not been the case , the distressing circumstances , which brought on the premature contraction of the womb , so as to expel part of its contents in November , as in the simplest cases of premature labour , would have caused the expulsion of the whole , or in other words , of both ova , in that same month ; and we should not have heard of the second accouchement in the following February ; which led the author of the paper in question to bring the case forward as one of superfetation , in opposition to what he has called " the scepticism of modern physiologists .
" Had it been proved that the child , of which the Lady in question was delivered , had reached its full term of uterogestation in November , and that she had brought forth another child one , two , or three months afterwards , of equally full growth ; then a case something like superfetation would have really occurred , and scepticism would have been staggered .
I have now under my eyes a recent preparation from Mr. CHAPMAN , at Windsor , destined for Mr. CLARKE'S collection ; but which through the kindness of Dr. BAILLIE I have been allowed to examine for my private information ; where the complete ovum is seen , such as it was expelled at the seventh month of pregnancy ; the Lady being safely delivered of another child alive , two months afterwards .
Although the first foetus was expelled at the seventh month , it was evidently of a growth of a shorter period , and had remained in the uterus dead for three months .
When the case was read before the Medico Chirurgical Society , I ventured to give an explanation of it , similar in point to the one I have offered with regard to the Lady from Palermo , mentioned in the Transactions of the College ' ; and I was happy to find that evety one present coincided in my opinion ; throwing quite out of the question every idea of superfetation .
I have the honour to be , Dear Sir , yours truly , A. B. GRANVILLE .
Saville Row .

