X. On the fallacy of the experiments in which water is said to have been formed by the decomposition of Chlorine .
By Sir H. Davy , L ... Fb R S. Read February it , 1818 .
SOME experiments have been lately communicated to the Royal Society of Edinburgh , from which it has been inferred , that water is formed during the action of muriatic acid gas on certain metals , and consequently , that chlorine is decomposed in this operation .
In repeating those experiments , I have ascertained , that the water is derived from sources not suspected by the authors , and that their conclusions are unfounded .
To take up the time of the Society by long experimental details and theoretical speculations on such an occasion , will be unnecessary ; I shall therefore only transiently mention the sources of error , and demonstrate their operation by two or three examples .
When muriatic acid gas is passed through flint glass tubes heated to redness , a small quantity of water is formed by the action of the gas on the oxide of lead in the glass , and a smaller quantity by its action on the alkali of the glass , the process being one of double affinity , the hydrogen of the mu riatic acid unites to the oxygen of the oxide , and the chlorine combines with the metals .
A copious dew was formed by passing muriatic acid gas through flint glass tubes red hot , and a less copious dew , by passing it through green glass tubes .
In the first instance , the glass became opaque , and gained a pearly lustre , and a combination of chlorine and lead sublimed from the hotter into the colder part of the tube .
In the second , the surface of the tube became slightly opaque , but no sublimate was formed .
When fine clean iron wire was introduced into such tubes , and made red hot , and muriatic acid gas passed over it , no particular precautions being taken to free the tubes from common air , much more water appeared ; but this excess of water principally owed its existence to the combination of hydrogen disengaged from the muriatic acid gas by the iron with the oxygen of the common air .
I say , principally , because an inappreciable quantity must have been deposited from the vapour of hydrated muriatic acid in the muriatic acid gas .
This was proved by filling the whole apparatus with hydrogen in another experiment , and generating the muriatic acid gas in a retort filled with hydrogen , when the water produced was no more than might have been expected from the action of the muriatic acid gas on the oxide of lead and alkali in the glass .
I give the details .
Above 21 grains of the first combination of chlorine and iron were formed ; the quantity of moisture collected by bibulous paper , and which was a strong acid solution of the proto-muriate of iron , amounted to less than half a grain , and of this not more than two-thirds could have been water .
Now , if chlorine had been decomposed in this operation , the quantity of water ought to have been at least ten times as great .
I have shown by numerous experiments , that in the action of muriatic acid gas upon metals , hydrogen , equal in bulk to half the volume of the gas , is produced ; it is therefore evident , that if water had been generated by the action of muriatic acid gas on metals , it must have been the chlorine , or the metal , or both , that were decomposed .
As chlorine can be freed from much of its aqueous vapour by dry muriate of lime , which is not the case with muriatic acid gas , it offers a much more unexceptionable substance for experiments of this kind .
I passed 23 cubical inches of chlorine slowly through dry muriate of lime into a flint glass tube red hot , containing a green glass tube full of iron wire ; the chlorine combined with this iron wire with intense heat ; the bright sublimate formed was passed through more iron wire heated to redness , so as to form a considerable quantity of the first compound of chlorine with iron , which , when examined , was found exactly the same as that produced by the action of muriatic acid gas on iron .
All the products were heated strongly , and the end of the glass tube kept very cool ; but not the slightest appearance of moisture was perceptible .
In all these experiments I was assisted by Mr. FARADAY of the Royal Institution .
Muriate of ammonia is not altered by being passed through porcelain or glass tubes heated to redness , but if metals be present , it offers similar results to muriatic acid gas .
In one experiment , in which muriate of ammonia recently sublimed was used , instead of muriatic acid gas , the appearance of moisture was less than in the experiment on muriatic acid gas , which has been just detailed , and yet there was a considerable action on the oxide of lead in the glass , not only by the muriatic acid , but likewise by the free hydrogen of the decomposed ammonia .

