III .
Additional facts respecting the fossil remains of an animal on the subject of which two papers have been printed in the Philosophical Transactions , showing that the bones of the sternum resemble those of the ornithorhynchus paradoxus .
By Sir EVERARD HOME , Bart. V. P. R. S Read January 22 , 81i8 .
AMY first account of the fossil bones of this most extraordinary animal attracted the notice of geologists , and collectors of extraneous fossils , and led Mr. JOHNSTON of Bristol , and the Revd .
Mr. BUCKLAND of Oxford , to assist me with the materials in their possession , to make a farther progress in the description of its skeleton .
An account of these specimens formed the substance of my second paper .
Since that time I have frequently communicated with these gentlemen , also with the Rev. PETER HAWKER of Woodchester rectory , Minchinhampton , and Dr. CARPENTER of Lyme ; and have received from them many specimens I had not seen before , some of which it was difficult to determine to what part of the skeleton they belonged : but that being ascertained , and a similarity discovered to bones of the ornithorhynchus paradoxus , that circumstance alone made them , in my opinion , of sufficient importance to become the subject of a third communication to this Society .
There is also another reason for bringing forward these facts , and for doing so without any unnecessary delay ; for , as my former papers were the means by which I acquired them , their being made known to the public , may lead those gentlemen who have opportunities of examining the cliffs in which the bones are found , to renew their labours , and assist in making out all the essential parts of the skeleton .
In the description I am to give of the bones received , I shall begin with one , a part of which is shown lying on the scapula in Mr. BULLOCK'S specimen , engraved in the first Paper ; it was then taken for the portion of a rib accidentally brought there , but it is now found to have been nearly in its natural situation .
It bears a resemblance to the clavicular bone in birds .
In the annexed engraving ( PI .
II .
Fig. i. ) it is shown in its relative situation to the other bones .
The bones of which the sternum is composed , are the next to be taken notice of : this part of the skeleton was first pointed out by my friend Mr. BUCKLAND , who had visited every collection in which bones of this animal were known to be preserved ; he met with several specimens in which two flat bones were united together , and their union covered by a bone not unlike the upper bone of the sternum in quadrupeds , which made him believe that all the three formed part of the sternum .
These different specimens , at his request , were sent to London for my inspection , and Mr. BUCKLAND'S suggestion proves to be right .
This discovery of the sternum destroys the analogy between this animal and the cartilaginous fishes , which , while the materials were more scanty , I had been led to suspect , in consequence of the bones of the pectoral fin of the squalus having a greater degree of correspondence to the pectoral fin or paddle of the fossil animal , than any other bones I have examined .
whose As this form of the sternum appeared at the time quite new , I was very anxious not to fall into an error , and was re-examining , with Mr. CLIFT , the different specimens , when it struck him that there was something similar to this mechanism in the sternum of the ornithorhynchus paradoxus : this remark led to a comparison of the bones , and they were found to have a general agreement that could not have been expected .
In the ornithorhynchus , the first bone of the sternum , at its upper end , has two lateral processes , which are connected with a similar process from each of the scapulae ; underneath the first bone are two flat bones united together , which union is covered by the first bone .
On the outer edge of these flat bones , there is a broad process continued down from the scapula ; in this process is the hollow to which the first bone or os humeri of the pectoral fin is articulated .
It will be seen that the difference between these bones of the sternum in the fossil skeleton and that of the ornithorhynchus , consists in the fossil skeleton having a clavicular bone , which is wanting in the other ; and the ornithorhynchus having a long process from the scapula , in which is the cavity of the shoulder joint , wanting in the fossil skeleton , These slight differences are not readily perceived in looking at the parts , as will be seen on inspecting the annexed engravings , P1 .
II .
Fig. , and 2 .
The mechanism which has been described , gives a very unusual surface for the muscles attached to the sternum , which move the first bone of the pectoral fin ; and upon examining them in the ornithorhynchus , I find there is not only the great pectoral muscle , going from the first bone of the sternum to the first bone of the pectoral fin , and a small one under it which may be called the small pectoral muscle ; but two large muscles , which have their origin from the flat bones and go to the first bone of the pectoral fin , or os humeri , and are inserted just below its head , that part being unusually broad , to allow of sufficient surface for their attachment .
These muscles must be considered as peculiar to those animals that have this particular form of sternum .
As these muscles probably belonged to the animal whose fossil bones are under consideration , as well as to the ornithorhynchus , I have given them a particular description .
Till the sternum was discovered , it could not be ascertained in what manner the animal breathed ; and the ribs being attached to the middle part of the vertebra , as in fishes , made me lean to the opinion that it breathed water ; but I now find , on more attentive consideration , that there is a difference between the mode of attachment of the ribs in this animal and in fishes , which admits of their having the motion of elevation and depression required in breathing air .
In fishes , the attachment is single ; but here , as is shown in the engravings in a former paper , it is double ; and the two are considerably apart , as in the bird .
Till it was determined whether the animal breathed air or water , little attention was paid to the nostrils , further than to find their place on the skull ; more particularly as in the only head I had seen , the bony scales of the opposite eye had been pushed through an aperture situated where I considered the opening of the nostril must have been : but I whose believed that the natural appearance of the orifice had been entirely destroyed .
I have , since that time , through the favour of Mr. DELABECHE , of Lime , received a very accurate drawing of a fossil skull of this animal , in his possession , in which the apertures of the nostrils are very distinct ; and he informs me that in all the skulls he has seen , the orifices are of the same size , and similar to that engraved in my first paper ; so that there now can be no doubt respecting the real shape and size of the aperture which corresponds to that in birds ; and as in birds there is no bony septum narium , the bony plates of the opposite eye being so distinctly seen behind the aperture , is readily understood .
To find any analogy between the bones of animals now alive , and those of animals so long extinct , that they must be considered to belong to another order of beings , is matter of no small curiosity ; but to have discovered an analogy between the peculiarities met with in the bones of the animals of New Holland , by which they are so remarkably distinguished from all others that now inhabit our globe , and those of bones in a fossil state , not only creates a considerable degree of surprise , but at the same time , by connecting the present animals with those that are extinct , adds one to the intermediate links of the chain of gradation which must prove the most interesting to the comparative anatomist and the geologist .
The animal whose fossil skeleton we have been considering , is ascertained by the form of the vertebrx , to swim like a fish ; and from the shape of its chest must breathe air ; its constant residence must also be in the water .
The ornithorhynchus paradoxus , from the form of its vertebrae , swims like the whale tribe , and breathes air , but does not , like them , reside constantly in the water , as no animals covered with hair do .
As neither fishes , nor animals of the whale tribe , have any thing in the form of the sternum , or of the muscles that are attached to it , that is similar to what is met with in the fossil animal and ornithorhynchus , these last animals , in that respect , make an approach to the bird , in which the sternum has still greater breadth , and the muscles greater strength .
In finding that this structure of sternum is wanting in the whale tribe , it leads to an enquiry into the peculiarities of the habits of life of the ornithorhynchus , and the animal to which the fossil bones belonged , that make such a structure necessary .
The ornithorhynchus has its fauces and stomach commonly filled with sand and gravel , which renders it probable that it feeds at the bottom of the lakes and rivers in which it is met with ; and as it must come to the surface to breathe at short intervals , this apparatus will enable it to rise with an unusual degree of velocity ; and would answer the same purpose in the animal whose sternum has a similar construction .
Nothing of this kind is required in the whale tribe ; they are rendered sufficiently buoyant by the oil they contain .
There is a fossil bone found in the same place , having so nearly the same colour and general structure as those of this animal , that it seems to belong to it .
In its form it bears a resemblance to the first bone of the pectoral fin , only much larger in all respects , it therefore may be conjectured to be whose the first bone of the posterior fin , should the animal have had one ; but till bones like those of the pelvis are found , this cannot be determined .
It is engraved in Plate III .
that it may be generally known , and by that means its place in the skeleton will be sooner ascertained .
The bones of the pectoral fin of the fossil skeleton , bear no resemblance to those of the onithorhynchus , but have some faint likeness to those of the pectoral fin of the shark .
The bones of the pectoral fin of the ornithorhynchus correspond with those of the same fin in the whale tribe , turtles , the bones of the wings in birds , and of the fore leg of the quadruped .
It would appear from the variety that occurs among the different specimens which have come under my observation , that the fossil bones met with at Lyme , not only belonged to animals of different sizes , but of different species .
I am led to this opinion from Mr. DELABECHE having sent me two sets of the bones of the pectoral fin which evidently belonged to the same animal , in which the small bones of the paddle are set on to the long bone in a manner somewhat different to what it is in the others .
EXPLANA-TION OF THE PLATlS .
, PLATE II .
Contains two figures ; the first represents the different parts that compose the sternum , in the fossil animal , and their connection with the neighbouring bones ; the second the corresponding bones in the ornithorhynchus paradoxus , to show their resemblance .
Fig. 1 .
The sternum , and bones connected with it , in the animal whose bones are found in a fossil state .
aa Two flat bones peculiar to the sternum of this animal and the ornithorhynchus .
bA flat bone behind which is concealed the union of the edges of the two flat bones just mentioned .
cc Two processes from this bone , by means of which it is united to the scapulae .
dd The two scapulae , which , united to the flat bones , form the glenoidal cavities of the shoulder joints .
eee A slender curved bone crossing the upper end of the sternum , and uniting the two scapula together .
ff The two first bones of the pectoral fin or paddle .
Fig. 9 .
The sternum and scapulae in the ornithorhynchus paradoxus .
aa Two flat bones nearly similar to those in Fig. i. united to the scapulae , but making no part of the glenoidal cavity of the joint of the shoulder .
b The bone corresponding to that marked b , Fig. i. cc Two processes similar to those in Fig. 1 .
dd The two scapulae which differ from those in Fig. 1 .
by extending below the two flat bones , and forming the whole of the glenoidal cavity of the shoulder .
gh ij Four bones belonging to the sterntm .
All the parts are of the natural size .
PLATE IIl .
The representation of a fossil bone of the natural size , which appears to belong to the same animal .
Its place in the skeleton cannot at present be ascertained , since it is not yet known whether in this animal there is a regular pelvis .
It bears a greater resemblance to the first bone of the paddle than to any other ; so that if the animal has a posterior paddle , this must belong to it .

