II .
A memoir on the geography of the north-eastern part of Asia , and on the question whether Asia and America are contiguous , or are separated by the sea .
By Captain James Burney , F. R. S. Read December 11 , 1817 .
A BELIEF has prevailed for nearly a century , that the separation of America and Asia has been demonstrated by an actual navigation performed ; and it is distinctly so admitted in the charts .
It is proposed to show in this memoir , in the first place , that there does not exist satisfactory proof of such a separation ; and secondly , that from peculiarities which have been observed , there is cause to suppose the fact to be otherwise ; that is to say , that Asia and America are conti. .
guous , and parts of one and the same continent .
This is not an opinion newly formed , but one which many years ago was impressed on other persons as well as on myself , by circumstances witnessed when in the sea to the north of Bering 's Strait with Captain CooK , in his last voyage .
America , from its first discovery by the people of Europe , was regarded by them as a land wholly distinct from their own native continent , till the failure of many attempts to discover a northern passage to India at length suggested the possibility that the Old and New World ( as they were then called ) formed but one continent .
The solution of this problem , so far as regards a north-eastern navigation to India , has been more naturally the business of the Russians than of any other people , as well on account of the greater facilities possessed by them for prosecuting the discovery , as for the superior benefit they would derive from a practicable navigation round their coasts to the Tartarian and Indian sea , should such be found .
The memorable voyage of SEMOEN DESCHNEW and his companions in 1648 , by which the Russians first discovered the sea east of Kamschatka , ( for before that time the river Anadir was supposed to run into the Icy sea ) , is the principal circumstance which has been admitted as proof of a complete separation of Asia and America .
It is important to remark , that this admission is not so old as the expedition on which it is founded , by nearly a century ; for no certainty of an absolute navigation having been performed round a northeastern promontory and extremity of Asia was pretended till after the year 1736 , when it was inferred by Professor MULLER , from some original writings found at that time in Siberia , concerning DESCHNEW'S voyage .
Baron de STRAHLENBERG , who had lived many years in Siberia , and whose description of that country is of earlier date than MULLER'S publication , says of the expedition of 1648 , that some Russians departed from the river Lena in boats towards the east , and by that route discovered Kamtschatka .
But it was not understood to have been by a clear navigation round the N. E. of Asia ; for in a description subsequently written , he says , " a class of people , to whom has been given the denomination of Tartars , inhabit the north-eastern extremity of Asia , concerning which a Kossak officer , named Atlassow , re"c ported , that between the Kolyma and the Anadir were two great promontories , which he affirmed could not both be " doubled by any vessel , because the west coast of the first " is barred in the summer by floating ice , and in winter the sea there is frozen ; but at the second , the sea is clear , " without ice .
" SCHEUCHZER , the translator of KEMPFER ' History of Japan , in an introduction to his translation , cites some remarks which had been published concerning the Tartars , wherein it was said , " the inhabitants of Siberia who live near " the river Lena , and along the coast of the Icy ocean , in " ' their commerce with Kamtschatka , commonly go with " their ships round a Suetoi Noss Cor sacred capej , to avoid " the Tschelatzki and Tschuktzki , two fierce and barbarous " nations possessed of the north-east point of Siberia , " On this vague authority SCHEUCHZER concludes , that Asia is not contiguous to America .
When Mr. MULLER first went into Siberia , no credited tradition appears to have been there current of the north-east extremity of Asia having been sailed round .
Charts which were made in Siberia by people inhabiting the coasts of the Icy sea , showed uncertainty , and what is to be considered only as an expression of a belief of a great north-eastern promontory ; for at that part , the coast was not defined by any outline , but left without limitation : whereas a more southern promontory , supposed the second from the Koiyma , was clearly delineated in the charts without any indication of doubt ; and this last-mentioned promontory , it is evident , was the cape which was afterwards seen by BERING , and to which Captain CooK gave the name of Cape East , on account of its being the most eastern land known of Asia .
In the instructions which were given by the Czar PETER the Great I1 for Captain BERING'S voyage , the question whether Asia and America were contiguous or separate , was regarded as undetermined , and some Tschuktzki people , with whom BERING had communication , informed him that , " c their countrymen " who traded with the Russians on the river Kolyma , always " went thither by land with their merchandise on sledges , " drawn by rein-deer , and that they had never made the " voyage by sea .
" Mr. MULLER has acknowledged that from the perusal of the papers found concerning the voyage of DESCHNEW , he -adopted a belief which did not before prevail , and he regarded it as a second discovery .
Yet Mr. MULLER'S own account fell very short of warranting a certainty of the manner in which DESCHNEW arrived at the Eastern Sea ; and there is an irregularity in it which is perplexing .
He says , 'DESCHNEW in relating his adventures speaks only inciden'tally of what happened to him by sea .
We find no event mentioned till he had reached the great cape of the ( Tschuktzki .
His relation , ' says Mr. MULLER , ' begins at this cape .
It lies between the north and north-east , and turns ( circular towards the river Anadir .
Opposite to the cape are two islands , on which were seen men through whose ' lips were run pieces of the teeth of the sea horse .
With a favourable wind one might sail from here to the Anadir in three days and three nights .
' The cape or promontory which is here described is evidently the Cape East in Bering 's Strait ; and in a subsequent part of the account , DESCHNEW is represented to have said that this Noss ' on which the vessel of ANKUDINOW , ( one of his companions ) was wrecked , was not the first promontory 1 2 that had occurred , to which they had given the name of Swiatoi Noss .
' The word Swioetoi signifies sacred , and is a name suitable to a promontory which could not be doubled .
And this corresponds with the Siberian charts before noticed , * It is necessary here to explain by what means the navigators in the Icy sea were enabled to arrive with their vessels at a second promontory , without having sailed round the first .
On account of the frequency of being enclosed in the Icy sea , by the drift ice , it was customary to construct vessels in a manner that admitted of their being with ease taken to pieces ; by which they could be carried across the ice to the outer edge , and there be put together again .
The planks were fastened and kept to the timbers only by leatllern straps , in lieu of nails or pegs .
The construction of the vessels in which DESCHNEW and his companions went is not specified .
Mr. MULLER calls them Kotsches .
Baron STRAHLENBERG says they departed eastward from the river Lena in their boats .
In the beginning of the 18th century , the Czar PETER the Great sent directions to the Governor of Iakutzk to collect information concerning the discoveries which had been made .
In consequence of this order , several examinations and depositions were taken ; and the few authentic particulars which are known of the voyage of DESCHNEW were thereby preserved .
The most remarkable of the depositions which are cited by Mr. MULLER , next to what relates to the expedition of It may be objected to this inference , that another cape in the Icy sea , although it has been sailed round , bears nevertheless the name of Swiatoi Noss ; but it may naturally be imagined that the name was given before the difficulty had been surmounted .
13 DESCHNEW , is one which was made by a person named NIKIPHOR MALGIN , who stated that " a merchant named " TARAS STADUCHIN , did many years before relate to him , the " deponent , that he had sailed with ninety men in a Kotsche " from the river Kolyma towards the great cape of the " Tschuktzki : that not being able to double it , they had crossed " over on foot to the other side , where they built other vessels .
" The small breadth of the isthmus at the part where they " ( crossed , is noticed as the most remarkable circumstance in " this deposition .
" They afterwards proceeded along the coast round the Kamtschatka Peninsula , till they came to the Penschinska gulf ; and , in the short account which is given of this navigation , is found , expressed in an obscure manner , the first notice obtained by the Russians of the Kurilski islands .
This is a clearly described passage .
Besides the expedition of DESCHNEW , and this of TARAS STADUCHIN , only one other instance is mentioned of any vessel having gone by sea from the Kolyma round the Tschuktzki coast ; and this last mentioned case rests on the authority of an unauthenticated tradition , purporting that some man had gone in a vessel not larger than a skiff , from the Kolyma to Kamtschatka ; and no other particular is spoken of in the report .
This was the state of the information obtained concerning the north-eastern extremity of Asia , at the time of Captain BERING'S voyage .
The Asiatic side only of Bering 's Strait was discovered in that voyage , and the coast of Asia being there found to take a western direction , it had the effect of giving an impression , equal to demonstration , of a total separation of Asia and America .
And after that time , and not 14 before , DESCHNEW was believed to have performed the whole of his voyage from the Kolyma to the Anadir by sea .
Many reports had circulated in Siberia of the existence of northern lands in the Icy sea ; but persons sent purposely to examine , had not found land , which much discredited the reports .
A chart in which a northern land was mar ked was however published at Petersburgh , about the year 1626 , by a Colonel SCHESTAKOW , of the Jakutzk Kossaks , a man of great ability as well as enterprise .
Neither SCHESTAKOW nor his chart , however , are favourably noticed by Mr. MULLER , who was in general a candid historian .
On SCHESTAKOW'S chart , the north land was marked with the name of the Large Country .
M. de LISLE gave credit to SCHESTAKOW'S map for the Large Country , which he makes appear on his own chart as a part of America , extending westward beyond the Kolyma .
Between the years 1734 and 1739 , three expeditions were undertaken to ascertain the limits of Asia to the north and north-east , from which no advantage was reaped , and they were attended with circumstances of extraordinary distress and misery .
These undertakings show that the boundary of Asia was not then regarded as ascertained .
In 1764 , a chart was sent from Siberia to Petersburgh , which again showed a continuation of the American continent stretching far to the west , and opposite to the Siberian coast of the Icy sea .
Between the years 176o and 1765 , no less than four attempts were made by one and the same individual , a Russian merchant , named SHALAUROF , to sail from the Icy sea round the north-east of Asia .
In the last of these attempts this enterprising and persevering man perished , for neither himself nor any of his people ever returned .
The information which was obtained in the first three attempts of SHALAUROF , is simply , that he arrived at an island which he named Sabedei , and beyond it sailed into a bay of the continent , wiich he named Tschaoon bay , which was estimated to be distant about 70 leagues to the east from the entrance of the river Kolyma .
Here were found habitations and people .
Tschaoon bay ran deep into the land southward and eastward , and probably it was from this place that TARAS STADUCHIN crossed over to the eastern sea .
Northward from Tschaoon bay , the coast took something of a westerly direction .
The most advanced part of the land seen , was a high mountain far off to the north-east , SHALAUROF being then to the north of the island Sabedei .
Among the attempts to determine the north-eastern limits of Asia , is to be reckoned the march of a small Kossak army under the command of a Captain PAULUTZKI , which after traversing the Tschuktzki country , from the gulf of Anadir to the Icy sea , marched along the shore eastward , with intention to trace round the north-east coast ; but the land being found to run far north , and their provision being expended , PAULUTZKI was obliged to relinquish the attempt .
Such was the state of the information which had been obtained , when Captain COOK arrived in the sea of Kamtschatka .
Of three passages said to have been accomplished from the Icy sea to the Eastern sea , the manner of performing the voyage is distinctly expressed only in one ; and that is specified to have been by crossing an isthmus , and not by sailing round a promontory .
I come now to speak of what was observed in the voyage of Captain COOK .
The first extraordinary circumstance noticed on arriving in Bering 's Strait , was a sudden disappearance of the tides .
To the south of Bering 's Strait , both on the Asiatic and on the American side , we had experienced strong tides .
Near one of the Aleutian islands , where the ships had anchored , a tide was found running at the rate of seven miles per hour ( as measured by the log ) smooth and unruffled ; at the same time , in the middle of the channel between this island and the next , the rapidity of the stream kept the waters in a foam during four hours of the tide .
Bering 's Strait is formed at the narrowest part by two points , one named Cape Prince of Wales , which is the westernmost land known of America ; and the other .
named Cape East , being the most eastern known land of Asia .
Whilst we were to the south , and within sight of the Cape Prince of Wales , the wind and current , being in contrary directions , raised a sea that frequently broke over the ships .
On arriving within Cape Prince of Wales , the ships anchored , the east cape of Asia then bearing due west ; and it is remarked by Captain COOK , that whilst the ships lay there at anchor , which was from six to nine in the evening , there was found little or no current ; nor could it be perceived that the water either rose or fell .
Afterwards , whilst to the northward of Bering 's Strait , we always had soundings of moderate depth , which enabled us to measure the stream with great exactness ; and we seldom found one running at the rate of more than half a mile per hour : at no time at the rate of a mile .
It is doubtless possible , that large bodies of ice taking the ground may choke up a channel between two seas , so as wholly to obstruct the tides ; but it is not probable , that such should have been the case between this sea and the Icy sea , through the whole month of August and the beginning of September , to which time Captain COOK remained in the sea north of Bering 's Strait .
And the same stillness of the waters was observed there in the ensuing summer .
The bottom also , not being swept by streams , was of soft ooze , so tenacious that the sounding line in common use was not strong enough to disengage the lead , and it became necessary to sound with a smaller lead and stronger line .
From Bering 's Strait , Captain CooK coasted the land of America , to the north and north-eastward , as near as weather and other circumstances would admit , till , in latitude 70 ? ?
40 ' N. his farther advance was stopped by a close body of ice to the N. and N. E. The ice , though compact , was not fixed , and was found to be approaching the American coast .
Captain COOK remarks , ' as the ice was driving down upon us , it was evident , that if we remained longer between it and the land , 'it would drive us ashore , unless it should happen to take s the ground before us .
' Captain COOK on this , as on many other occasions , accommodated his views to the circumstances present , that there might be no unprofitable expenditure of time ; andit may be said that in all h-is changes of plan , his measures were so directly adapted to his purpose , that without other communication his intentions were immeidiately comprehended .
The month of August was at this time far advanced ; and to make the most of the short remainder of the season , Captain COOK stood on westward for the coast of Asia , keeping in as high a latitude as the ice would permit .
On the north side of his track were extensive bodies of ice , such as we call field ice .
These generally are accumulations of loose floating pieces , which have been brought together by the wind blowing a length of time in one direction towards a coast .
When the ice is so driven to land , it is evident that the inner pieces only take the ground ; the rest are confined by the wind , and when a change in the wind afterwards sets the ice from the land , it will preserve a position parallel to that which the coast gave it , until the strength and variety of winds have time to disperse it .
The deepest soundings we had in all this sea did not exceed thirty fathoms ; and this depth was found in latitude 68 ? ?
45 ' , midway between the coast of Asia and the coast of America .
Northward , beyond that latitude , the soundings were observed to decrease : and in our run from the coast of America westward , we did not find the depth to increase , as is usual in running from land .
Which peculiarities made us conclude , that there was land at no great distance from us to the north , and that we were sailing on a line parallel with its coast .
Northward of our track also , as we ran towards the Asiatic coast , was a continuity of ice which seemed as if formed into a close barrier by a long extent of coast .
The nature of the soundings , with the absence of tide , gave to this sea so much the character of a mediterranean sea , that some on board , in particular Mr. BAILEY the astronomer , and myself , who being in the same ship communed 19 on the subject , were strongly of opinion that we were enclosed by land to the north , and that Asia and America were there joined ; but we dared not venture to call in question the authority of MULLER .
If it is asked , whence then can come the great quantity of ice which is found in this sea ?
an answer readily presents itself .
It is known that the Icy sea is frozen over every winter ; and the northern part of this sea also has been known to be frozen over early in the winter .
When the return of summer breaks up the ice , it will of course fill the sea with broken pieces4 lSince the voyage of Captain COOK , little has been done towards ascertaining the termination of Asia .
Commodore BILLINGS , an Englishman in the service of Russia , was employed to command an expedition for this express purpose , furnished with every assistance that could be devised towards ensuring success .
Iis instructions directed him to make his departure from the river Kolyma , and to endeavour to follow the coast thence eastward by sea ; with this additional instruction , ' that if coasting by sea should be found impracticable , ?
and the information obtained on the spot should give hopes ' of effecting the purpose by land , he was then to endeavour to trace the coast by going in the winter in sledges over ' the ice .
' Kossaks who had before been in the Tschuktzki country were selected to accompany Commodore BILLINGS , and among them was one who was the son of a Tschuktzki woman .
' Make agreement with them , ' said the Instructions , 'or without agreement pay them the double of what is ' allowed to people who serve at sea .
And whereas on a chart transmitted to us in the year 1764 , a coast is marked 90 opposite to the Kolyma , which stretches as a continuation ' of the continent of America , it will be of use if you can ' survey and describe the circumstances of that land .
' The history of Commodore BILLINGS'S expedition may be told in few words .
He sailed with two light vessels out of the Kolyma , on the 24th of June , 1787 .
He met with much ice , and on the goth of July , without having reached so far eastward as the island Sabedei , he relinquished the farther prosecution of the attempt by sea ; at the very season , in fact , which was the most proper that could have been chosen for his outset from the Kolyma.* In this short attempt , Commodore BILLINGS did not even get sight of the north land ; but an approach to it was to be inferred from the soundings .
The snow and ice were at this time rapidly dissolving , so as to cause currents to set for several days continuance in one direction ; and during that time , the water on the surface of the sea was so fresh as to be used for cooking , and sometimes for drinking .
Afterwards , Commodore BIILINGS , with the consent of the Tschuktzki people , made a progress by land along a part of the Tschuktzki coast .
Most unaccourtably , he chose for his point of outset for this jouriey , the bay of Saint Lawrence , which is on the south side of Bering 's Strait .
He landed in the month of August with a party consisting of twelve persons , and ' travelled northward , keeping near the coast as far as to a bay called Klutchenie , which is at the extreme part of the Asiatic coast seen in Captain CooK 's voyage .
By this time , winler had set in , and the sea was frozen over .
The season proved a severe one ; the cold was extreme , and the whole party had already been so much fatigued and harassed with their journey from the bay of St. Lawrence , that they were unable to pursue the coast farther northward .
They afterwards , in their route westward towards the Kolyma , crossed a river , which , according to information from the Tschuktzki people , discharged itself into the sea seventy versts more north than the bay of Klutchenie .
In all this uncertainty respecting the north-east termination of Asia , the particular most worthy notice is , that the Tschuktzki people themselves do not appear , from any of the accounts which have been published , to know the extent of their country to the north , or to be able to give any satisfactory information concerning it , though it is known that some of their nation have travelled from the continent to islands in the Icy sea .
The charts of the present century , which have assumed to give a limitation to Asia , differ a degree in the latitude of their northernmost cape .
It does not in the smallest degree detract from the merit or fame of the first discoverers , to question their having navigated round the north-east of Asia .
Whether they sailed round a promontory , or crossed an isthmus , they are equally entitled to the honour of having first discovered for their countrymen the sea east of Kamtschatka .
The most probable chance of completing the discovery , or of arriving at any certainty concerning a north-eastern boundary of Asia , is doubtless that which was recommended by the Russian admiralty to Commodore BILLINGS ; i. e. to trace the coast in sledges when the sea is frozen .
The principal argument , and it is not a weak one , against Q8 the probability of Asia and America being joined , is , that northern land in the Icy sea has repeatedly been supposed , and reported , to be an extension of the American continent ; and it does not appear in any of the accounts to have been reported , or supposed , to join the Tschuktzki country .
In Captain KRUSENSTERN'S memoir on the lands in the Icy sea , it is related , that very lately was explored an extent of 250 versts of coast of a northern land , which has been named the New Siberia .
At the easternmost part which was seen of this land , the coast was observed to take a direction to the northwest .
This direction of the coast might keep at a distance the supposition that it joined the Tschuktzki land : nevertheless , the coast may , and is supposed by the Russian discoverer , M. HEDERSTROOM , to turn afterwards to the east ; for he gives it as his opinion that the New Siberia is a prolongation of America .
The Tschuktzki people would not explore farther north than afforded a prospect of reward for their pains .
This , it is seen , has led them to some of the islands in the Icy sea ; but no marks are noticed of their having been to the New Siberia .
The times for making expeditions of discovery in the Icy sea has generally been predetermined ; but it would be more conducive to success to watch for favourable seasons .
The state of the surface of the sea , when frozen , has also been found subject to much variation , depending upon the strength of the wind when the sea begins to be frozen .
If in a calm , the surface will be smooth ; if in boisterous weather , it will be rugged and bad for travelling .
23

