V. An Account of some new Experiments on thefluoric Compounds ; with some Observations on other Objects of Chemical Inquiry .
By Sir H. Davy , LL. D. F.R. S. P. P. R. L Read February 13 , 1814 .
IN this Paper I shall offer to the Society a continuation of those researches , the details of which have been already honoured with a place in their Transactions ; and I trust , that the experiments and observations which I have to communicate , will be found to elucidate some important but obscure parts of chemical philosophy .
In the last Paper , which I had the honour of presenting to this Body , I have given an account of a number of experiments made with a view of decomposing the fluoric acid : the most probable inference , from my results , was that the pure liquid fluoric acid consists of hydrogen united to a substance , which , from its strong powers of combination , has not as yet been procured in a separate form , but which is detached from hydrogen by metals , and which , in union with the basis of the boracic acid and silica , forms the fluo-boric and silicated fluoric gases .
All the new experiments , that I have made on the fluoric compounds , tend to confirm this idea ; and the various attempts that I have made , since the last session , to decompose the principle in the fluoric acid separated at the negative surface in Vollaic combinations , have been unsuccessful .
I have found that fluate of lead , the substance formed by the action of a soluble salt of lead on fluate of potassa or fluate of ammonia , is immediately decomposed , wrien moist , by am .
moniacal gas , and a white powder separates from it , which must contain oxygen , as it gives carbonic acid by being ignited with charcoal ; but dry fluate of lead may be iused in ammonia without undergoing the slightest alteration , and the presence of water , which nay furnish oxygen to the lead and hydrogen to the fluoric principle , seems absolutely necessary for the production of oxidated bodies from the fluoric combinations .
I obtained analogous results by acting on silicated fluate of ammonia and fluo-borate of ammonia by chlorine ; when the salts were moist , or when the gas was not free from vapour , silica and boracic acid were formed in small quantities , but when water was carefully excluded , these bodies did not appear ; and the results were muriate of ammonia and silicated fluoric gas , or fluo-boric gas and azote .
I ignited two points of charcoal intensely in fluo-boric and silicated fluoric acid gases , pure , and mixed with oxygen ; but no change , indicating a decomposition , took place ; the only new product was a little inflammable gas , which was probably disengaged from the charcoal .
I passed pure liquid fluoric acid over charcoal ignited to whiteness , in a platinum tube ; no carbonic acid was formed , and a very minute quantity of gas only was produced , which proved to be hydrogen .
I mentioned in my last communication to the Society , that I had made several experiments on the composition of the fluates ; since that time I have repeated some of the processes , and I shall detail such of the results as appear to be most correct .
In experiments on the fluates , it is very difficult to exclude sources of inaccuracy ; glass vessels cannot be used , and even silver and platinum vessels are slightly acted upon by the pure fluoric combinations soluble in water .
Fluor spar decomposed by sulphuric acid increases more than three-fourths of its original weight ; but to produce this result several successive distillations of it with fresh portions of acid are necessary , and the spar must be in very fine powder , and the result must be powdered after every operation .
In an experiment made in a crucible of platinum , in which very pure white Derbyshire spar was used , and sulphuric acid distilled in glass vessels , and in which the product was heated to whiteness in every operation , ioo grains became in the first operation 159.4 grains , which gained in the second 6.9 in the third 4 .
in the fourth 1.9 in the fifth.6 in the sixth.9 in the seventh 0.3 in the eighth -.o Total increase 75.2 If this result be calculated upon , supposing the number representing calcium to be 40 , as I have given it in my Elements of Chemical Philosophy , the number representing fluorine will be 34.2 , and fluor spar must be supposed to be composed of 40 calcium , and 34.2 fluorine .
e2 grains of fused subcarbonate of potassa decomposed by diluted liquid fluoric acid , in an experiment made with great care , was found to afford 18.15 grains of dry fluate of potassa ; and by a very careful analysis , it was found that this subcarbonate contained 31 per cent. of carbonic acid ; now , if the remainder of the salt be supposed to be pure potassa , and the calculations be made on this idea , it will appear that fluate of potassa must consist of 125.9 of potassium and 54.74 of fluorine , and the number representing fluorine must be regarded as 32.6 .
The 18.15 grains of fluate of potassa decomposed by sulphuric acid afforded 38.5 of acid sulphate of potash .
Supposing acid sulphate of potassa to consist of two proportions of sulphuric acid 15o , and &amp; one of potassa go , they ought to have given 40 grains , and this loss is no more than might be expected in the process of decomposition and evaporation .
In some experiments that I made on the decomposition of the hydrates of potassa and soda , when decomposed by fluoric acid , the results indicated a number for fluorine a little lower .
Thus o. grains of hydrate of potassa were converted into 19.8 grains of fluate of potassa , and o2 grains of hydrate of soda into 19.6 of fluate of soda ; but I do not place so much confidence in these results , as there always was great heat produced during the action of the acid upon the hydrates ; and probably a minute quantity of the hydrates might have been dissipated at the beginning of the process .
It appears reasonable to conclude , as I have stated in my last paper , published in the Philosophical Transactions , that the number representing fluorine is less than half of that representing chlorine , about 33 .
I endeavoured to ascertain the composition of fluate of ammonia , by adding together hydro-fluoric acid and solution of ammonia of known composition , and I found in this way , that 1oo parts of solution of ammonia of specific gravity 9162 required for its saturation 52 grains of diluted fluoric acid of such a strength , that an equal portion produced exactly 32 grains of fluate of potassa .
According to this experiment fluate of ammonia must consist of 9.7 of fluorine to 22 of ammonia ; * and , if it be conceived that liquid fluoric acid consists of two proportions of hydrogen to one of fluorine , the true composition of fluate of ammonia will be one proportion of fluoric acid 35 , and two proportions of ammonia 64.t The volatility of fluate of ammonia rendered it impossible to ascertain by evaporation the real quantity of solid salt formed , though the heat was never raised so high as that of boiling water , yet only 12.7 grains of solid fluate of ammonia could be procured .
Two hundred cubical inches of ammonia , which weigh 36 grains , condense one hundred cubical inches of silicated fluoric gas , weighing , under the same circumstances , 1 o.7 , and if it be supposed that silicated fluate of ammonia contains one proportion of silicated fluoric acid and one of ammonia , then the number representing silicated fluoric gas will be 98.4 , and it may be conceived to consist of two proportions of fluorine 66 , and one of the siliceous basis 32.4 .
According to the experiments of JOHN DAVY , 100 parts of silicated fluoric acid afford 61.4 of silica when decomposed by aqueous solution of ammonia , hence silica may be conceived to consist of 32.4 of basis and s9 of oxygen , and this is very near two proportions of oxygen .
I decomposed 2o grains of silicated fluate of ammonia by solution of ammonia , and I obtained 9g2 grains of silica .
This result offers proportions very little different from those gained in the preceding calculations .
I have made some direct experiments with the hopes of determining the proportions of oxygen in silica , but they have been unsuccessful ' I have ascertained , however , that it requires more than three parts of potassium to decompose one part of silica , which shows that this substance cannot contain much less than half its weight of oxygen .
I have endeavoured to separate the siliceous basis in a pure form , with the view of making synthetical experiments on its nature by combustion in oxygen , and my results , though not perfectly satisfactory , yet seem worthy of notice , and may lead to more successful attempts .
I decomposed silica by passing potassium in excess through it , in a heated tube of platinum : the result consisted chiefly of alkali containing a dark coloured powder , the basis of silica diffused through it .
I fused the whole mass with sulphur , which , in combining with the dry alkali , produced ignition .
I attempted to detach the sulphuret of potassa by water : in this case the dark particles separated , but during their separation and after , they acted upon the water of the solution producing gas , and , in attempting to collect them by the filter , I failed to procure sufficient for examination , for they were principally converted into silica .
I heated the substance procured in another experiment of this kind with hydrate of potassa ; in this case there was a copious effervescence , and silica appeared to be reproduced and dissolved by the alkali .
K2 67 I heated a , portion of a similar result hl strong lixivium of potassa ; the solution gained a tint of olive , but there was scarcely any effervescence ; from this it seems probable , that the inflammable basis of silica , like boron , is soluble in alkaline solutions without decomposing them .
Indeed this body , in its general characters , appears very analogous to boron .
It appears to be neither volatile nor fusible ; its oxide exerts , like boracic acid , a neutralizing power on the alkalies , though of a feebler kind , and forms , like boracic acid , vitreous , bodies with the alkaline earths , and , like boron , the siliceous basis in combination with fluorine constitutes a powerful acid .
In my first views of the nature of the boracic and siliceous bases , I thought it probable that they would both appear as metals , if they could be entirely freed from oxygen ; but it now seems more probable , that they form a class by themselves , offering a kind of link in the chain of natural bodies , when .
arranged according to their analogies , between charcoal , and sulphur and phosphorus .
It seems worthy of an experimental inquiry , whether the siliceous basis may not be obtained pure by heating the result procured from silica by potassium with pure sulphuric acid , which might possibly detach the potassa to form acid sulphate of potassa , without being decomposed by the inflammable basis .
I have made many new experiments with the hope of decomposing chlorine , but they have been all unavailing ; nor have I been able to gain the slightest evidence of the existence of that oxygen which many persons still assert to be one of its elements .
I kept sulphuret of lead for some time in fusion in chlorine , the results were sulphurane ( Dr. THOMSON'S liquor ) and plumbane ( muriate of lead ) ; not an atom of sulphate of lead was formed in the experiment , though if any oxygen had been present , this substance might have been expected to have been produced .
I heated plumbane ( muriate of lead ) in sulphurous acid gas , and likewise in carbonic acid gas , but no change was produced ; now , if oxygen had existed either in chlorine , or in its combination with lead , there is every reason to believe , that the attractions of the substances concerned in these experiments would have been such as to have produced the insoluble and fixed salts of lead , the sulphate in the first case , and the carbonate in the second .
I shall not enter into any discussion upon the experiments in which water is said to be produced by the action of muriatic gas on ammonia : there is , I believe , no enlightened and candid person , who has witnessed the results of processes in which large quantities of muriate of ammonia , made by the combination of the gases in close vessels , have been distilled , without being satisfied , that there is no more moisture present , than the minute quantity which is known to exist in the compound vapours diffused through ammoniacal and muriatic acid gases , which cannot be considered either as essential to .
the existence of the gases , or as chemically combined , with them.* One of the first experiments that I made , with the hope of detecting oxygen in chlorine , was by acting upon it by ammonia , when I found that no water was formed , and that the results were merely muriate of ammonia and azote ; and the driest muriate of ammonia , I find , when heated with potassium , converts it into muriate of potassa , which result would be impossible on the hypothesis of oxymuriatic gas being a compound of oxygen , for , if there was a separation of water during the formation of the muriate , the same oxygen could not be supposed to be detached in water , and yet likewise to remain so as to form part of a neutral salt .
If water had been really formed during the action of chlorine on ammonia , the result would have been a most important one : it would have proved either that chlorine or azote was a compound , and contained oxygen , or that both contained this substance ; but it would not have proved the existence of oxygen in chlorine , till it had been shown that the azote of the ammonia was unchanged in the operation .
Some authors continue to write and speak with scepticism on the subject , and demand stronger evidence of chlorine being undecompounded .
These evidences it is impossible to give .
It has resisted all attempts at decomposition .
In this respect , it agrees with gold , and silver , and hydrogen , and oxygen .
Persons may doubt , whether these are elementary bodies ; but it is not philosophical to doubt , whether they have not been resolved into other forms of matter .
By the same mode of reasoning , as that in which oxygen is conceived to exist in chlorine , any other species of matter might be supposed to form one of its constituent parts ; and I'hilosophical Transactions for 181o .
by multiplying words all the phenomena might be satisfactorily explained .
Thus in the simple view of the formation of muriatic acid , it is said one volume of chlorine combines with one of hydrogen , and they form two volumes of muriatic acid gas .
In the hypothesis of chlorine containing oxygen , it is said , the oxygen of the chlorine combines with the hydrogen to form water , and this water unites to an unknown something , or dry muriatic acid , to produce a gaseous body .
If it were asserted that chlorine contained azote , oxygen , and this unknown body , then it might be said , that , in the action of hydrogen on chlorine , the azote , the oxygen and the chlo ' .
rine , having all attractions for hydrogen , enter into union with it , and form a quadruple compound .
Professor BERZELIUS has lately adduced some arguments , which he conceives are in favour of chlorine being a compound of oxygen from the .
laws of definite proportions ; but I cannot regard these arguments of my learned and ingenious friend as possessing any weight .
By transferring the definite proportions of oxygen to the metals , which he has given to chlorine , the explanation becomes a simple expression of facts ; and there is no general canon with respect to the multiples of the proportions in which different bodies combine .
Thus azote follows peculiar laws in combining with every different body ; it combines with three volumes of hydrogen , with half a volume of oxygen , with 1.2 and i of the same body , and with four volumes of chlorine .
The chemists in the middle of the last century had an idea , that all inflammable bodies contained phlogiston or hydrogen .
It was the glory of LAVOISIER to lay the foundations'for a sound logic in chemistry , by showing that the existence of 71 this principle , or of other principles , should not be assumed where they could not be detected .
In all cases , in which bodies support combustion or form acids , oxygen has been supposed by the greater number of modern chemists to be present ; but as there are many distinct species of inflammable bodies , so there may be many distinct species of matter which combine with them with so much energy , as to produce heat and light ; and various bodies appear capable of forming acids ; thus hydrogen enters into the composition of nearly as many acids as oxygen , and three bodies , namely , sulphuretted hydrogen , muriatic acid , and fluoric acid which contain hydrogen , are not known to contain oxygen .
The existence of oxygen in the atmosphere , and its action in the economy of nature , and in the processes of the arts , have necessarily caused it to occupy a great portion of the attention of chemists , and , being of such importance , and in constant operation , it is not extraordinary , that a greater number of phenomena should be attributed to it , than it really produces .
In the views that I have ventured to develope , neither oxygen , chlorine , or fluorine , are asserted to be elements ; it is only asserted , that , as yet , they have not been decomposed .
As the investigation of nature proceeds , it is not improbable , that other more subtle bodies belonging to this class will be discovered , and perhaps some of the characteristic differences of those substances , which apparently give the same products .
by analysis , may depend upon this circumstance .
The conjecture appears worth hazarding , whether the carbonaceous matter in the diamond may not be united to an extremely light and subtle principle of this kind , which has hitherto escaped detection , but which may be expelled , or newly combined , during its combustion in oxygen .
That some chemical difference must exist between the hardest and most beautiful of the gems and charcoal , between a non-conductor and a conductor of electricity , it is scarcely possible , notwithstanding the elaborate experiments that have been made on the subject , to doubt : and it seems reasonable to expect , that a very refined or perfect chemistry will confirm the analogies of nature , and show that bodies cannot be exactly the same in composition or chemical nature , and yet totally different in all their physical properties .

