XIII .
On some Properties of Light .
By David Brewster , LL. D. F. R. S. Edin .
In a Letter to Sir H. Davy , LL. D. F. R. S. Read January 28 , 1813 .
DEAR SIR , HAVING been for some time engaged in a series of experiments on the phenomena of light arising from its transmission through diaphanous bodies , I have taken the liberty of communicating to you , for the information of the Royal Society , a short and general account of the results of my enquiries .
In the narrow compass of a letter , it would be impracticable to include the various details of these experiments ; the particular methods of observation that were employed ; or the numerical results which I have obtained for the refractive and dispersive powers of nearly two hundred substances .
As these will form part of a separate work , in which I am now engaged , I shall confine myself at present to some of those results which appear to be most interesting , either from their novelty or importance .
i. On a new Property of refracted Light .
As you are already well acquainted with the optical properties of doubly refracting media , and the analogous property of reflected light discovered by MALUS , it will be unnecessary to take any notice of these phenomena .
After repeating the experiments of MALUs , and measuring several of the angles of incidence at which this property was communicated to light by reflection from different substances , I made a variety of experiments , with the view of discovering if a similar character could be impressed upon light by its transmission through bodies , either wholly or imperfectly transparent .
All these experiments afforded no new result , and every hope of discovering such a property was extinguished , when my attention was directed to a singular appearance of colour in a thin plate of agate .
This plate , bounded by parallel faces , is about the fifteenth of an inch thick , and is cut in a plane perpendicular to the laminae of which it is composed .
The agate is very transparent , and gives a distinct image of any luminous object ; but on each side of this image is one highly coloured , forming with it an angle of several degrees , and so deeply affected with colour that no prism of agate , with the largest refracting angle , could produce an equivalent dispersion .
Upon examining this coloured image with a prism of Iceland spar , I was astonished to find that it had acquired the same property as if it had been transmitted through a doubly refracting crystal , and upon turning the Iceland spar about its axis , the images alternately vanished at every quarter of a revolution .
My attention was now directed to the common colourless image formed by pencils transmitted perpendicularly through the agate ; and by viewing it through a prism of Iceland spar , it exhibited all the characters of one of the pencils produced by double refraction , the images alternately vanishing in every quadrant of their circular motion .
When the image of a taper reflected from water at an angle of 52§ 45 ' , so as to acquire the property discovered by MALUS , is viewed through the plate of agate , so as to have its laminae 102 parallel to the lane of reflection , it appears perfectly distinct ; but when the agate is turned round , so that its lamine are perpendicular to the plane of reflection , the light which forms the image of the taper suffers total reflection , and not one ray of it penetrates the agate .
If a ray of light incident upon one plate of agate is received after transmission upon another plate of the same substance , having its lamina parallel to those of the former , the light will find an easy passage through the second plate ; but if the second plate has its lamina perpendicular to those of the first , the light will be wholly reflected , and the luminous object will cease to be visible .
Owing probably to a cause which will afterwards be noticed , there is a faint nebulous light unconnected with the image , though always accompanying it , and lying in a direction parallel to the larnine .
This light never vanishes along with the images , though it is evidently affected by the different changes which they undergo ; and in one of the specimens of agate , it is distinctly incurvated , having the same radius of curvature with the adjacent lamine .
This character of the nebulous light I consider as an important fact , which may be the means of conducting us to a satisfactory theory , and I am at present engaged in examining it with particular care .
This remarkable property of the agate I have found also in the kindred substances of cornelian and chalcedony , and it is exhibited in its full effect even when these bodies are formed into prisms , and when the incident rays fall with any angle of obliquity .
In one specimen of agate , which has no veins to indicate the direction in which it was cut , the images did not vanish as before ; and in another specimen of the same io$ character the images suffered only an alternate diminution of brightness , in the same manner as a pencil of light receives only a partial modification when reflected from water at a greater or a less angle than 529 45 ' .
The different experiments which have now been mentioned were repeated , with the most satisfactory results , by Mr. PLAYFAIR , Dr. HOPE , and Mr. JOHN DAVY .
Although the preceding results are by no means ripe for generalization , I cannot omit the present opportunity of hazarding a few conjectures respecting the cause of this singular property of the agate .
May not the structure of this mineral be in a state of approach to that particular kind of crystallization which affords double images ?
and may not the nebulous light be an imperfect image arising from that imperfection of structure ?
When one of the images vanishes , the nebulous light which encircled it is then a maximum , and it gradually diminishes during the re-appearance of the image .
When the image which had disappeared recovers its full lustre , the surrounding nebulosity is very small , and this remaining light is , in all probability , no portion of the unformed image , but merely a few scattered rays arising from the imperfect transparency of the mineral .
By forming the agate into a prism , the nebulous light should be separated from the image which it encloses , in proportion to the angle contained by the refracting planes ; but owing , perhaps , to the smallness of its double refraction , if it has such a property , I have not observed any separation of this kind .
The incurvated form of the nebulous light corresponding with the curvature of the lamine , seems to connect it^with the 1o4A laminated structure of the agate , and to indicate that the phenomena of double refraction are produced by an alternation of lamiina of two separate refractive and dispersive powers .
In Iceland spar , one set of the laminm may be formed by a combination of oxygen and calcium , while the other set is fortmed by a combination of oxygen and carbon .
In chromate of lead , the chromium and oxygen may give one image , while the oxygen and lead give another .
In like manner the carbonate of lead , the carbonate of strontites , jargon , and other crystals may give double images , in virtue of similar binary combinations .
Of the simple inflammable bodies , sulphur is the only one which has the property of double refraction , but it will probably be found that it holds a metal or some other ingredient in its composition , which chemists have not been able to discover .
If the explanation which has now been given of the polarising power of the agate should be confirmed by future experiments , this property will be considered as a case , though a very curious one , of double refraction ; but if these conjectures should be overturned , the phenomena which we have described must be ranked among the most singular appearances in the wide range of optical science .
2 .
On the double Refraction of Chromate of Lead .
In the course of my experiments on refractive powers , I discovered a double refraction in this metallic salt of such enormous magnitude , that the deviation of the extraordinary ray is more than thrice as great as that produced by Icelalnd spar .
The ratio of the sines , for both refractions , and the other properties of this extraordinary mineral will be noticed in the next article .
3 .
On Substances with a higher refractive Power than the Diamond .
Since the time of Sir ISAAc NEWTON , who first measured the action of the diamond upon light , its refractive power has been regarded as superior to that of every other substance ; but , in the course of my researches , I have found that realgar and chromate of lead exceed the diamond in refractive power , and that this high refraction , in both these substances , is accompanied with dispersive powers greater than those of any other body .
The following are the measures which I have obtained for these , and a few other substances .
Refractive Powers .
Index of Refr. Index of Refr. Chromate of lead Phosphorus 2.224 ( gr. refr.).926 Sulphur , native 2.115 Ditto , least refraction 2.479 Cryolite.344 Realgar 2.510 Ice.307 Diamond ( according to NEWTON ) 2.439 Dispersive powers or values of R-i ' Chromate of lead Phosphorus -o.128 ( gr. refr.).400 Flint glass ( highest ) 0.052 Ditto , least refraction o.262 Diamond 0.038 Realgar 0.255 Water 0.035 Oil of cassia o.39 Fluor spar o.o22 Sulphur o.130 Cryolite 0.o It appears from the first of these tables , that phosphorus icis next to diamond in refractive power , and that the three simple inflammable substances have their refractive powers in the order of their inflammability .
Dr. WOLLASTON has placed phosphoruis below horn and flint glass , but I am confident that this distinguished philosopher , to whom the physical sciences are so deeply indebted , will find , upon making the experiment with prisms or lenses , that I have assigned the right place to that remarkable substance .
The difference between the extreme dispersive powers in the second table is very remarkable , and the result for oil of cassia indicates in that body the existence of some ingredient , which chemical analysis has not been able to detect .
4 .
On the Existence of two dispersive Powers in all doubly refracting Crystals .
It has been long known , and it is indeed obvious , from a simple inspection of the images formed by a prism of Iceland crystal , that the one image is more coloured than the other , or that the actual dispersion of the one refraction is greater than the dispersion of the other , in the same manner as the dispersion of a prism of flint glass with a refracting angle of 12 degrees , is greater than the dispersion of a prism of the same glass with an angie of only lo degrees .
Dr. WOLLASTON , who was the first person that examined the subject of dispersive powers with philosophical accuracy , makes the dispersive power of Iceland spar considerably above water , and even above diamond .
Upon repeating this experiment , with the least refracted image , I found the dispersive * Dr. WOLLASTON is satisfied that his original estimate was erroneous , and that Dr. BREWSTER 's determination is very near the truth .
H. D. P2 lopower , or the value of -R , to be o.2o6 very considerably below water , which stands at 0.055 of the scale , and I therefore concluded that Dr. WOLLASTON had examined the greatest refraction , while I had examined the least , and that the vast discrepancy between our measures arose from the existence of a double dispersive power .
This conclusion was confirmed by determining the dispersive power of the greatest refraction , which coincided exactly with the order assigned to it by Dr. WOLLASTON .
The dispersive powers , which I have obtained for other doubly refracting crystals , such as carbonate of strontites , carbonate of lead , and chromate of lead , have confirmed this result , and establish the general law , that each refraction of crystals which give double images is accompanied with a separate dispersive power .
The double dispersive powers of these bodies are given in the following table .
Chromate of lead ( gr. refr .
) estimated at o.400 Ditto Ditto must exceed 0.296 Ditto ( least refr .
) 0.262 Carbonate of lead ( gr. refr .
) + 0.091 Ditto ( least refr .
) 0.066 Carbonate of strontites ( gr. refr .
) 0.046 Ditto ( least refr .
) o.o27 Calcareous spar ( gr. refr .
) 10.040 Ditto ( least refr.).026 In a table of refractive powers , published by the late Mr. CAVALLO , he has given , from other authors , the dispersions , or the dissipations as he calls them , of a few substances , and he has annexed a different dispersion to the two refractions of ioIceland crystal ; but it is obvious , from a simple inspection of the table , that these are measures of the dispersion or quantity of colour , and not of the dispersive power of the substances .
The measures in the table alluded to , with the exception of one or two , are so completely incompatible with those taken by Dr. WOLLASTON and myself , that I can scarcely believe that the experiments were ever made .
The singular property of a double dispersive power , while it seems to exclude some of the theories by which the double refraction has been explained , adds another to those numerous difficulties with which philosophy has yet to struggle , before sly can reduce to a satisfactory generalization those anomalous and capricious phenomena which light exhibits in its passage through transparent bodies .
I have the honour to be , dear Sir , your most obedient humble servant , DAVID BREWSTER .
Edinburgh , 23 , Duke-street , December 19 , 1812 .
To Sir H. Davy , LL. D. F. R. S. log

