XV .
On the nature and combinations of a newly discovered vegetable acid ; with observations on the malic acid , and suggestions on the state in which acids may have previously existed in vegetables .
By M. Donovan , Esq. Communicated by F. H. Wollaston , M. D. Sec. R. S. Read June i , 18i5 .
HAVE ING often observed the sour disagreeable taste of the berries of the Sorbus ( or Pyrus ) Aucuparia , it occurred to me that the juice might contain an acid of a peculiar nature , and I resolved to submit it to a strict examination .
I was not at that time acquainted with the fact , that these berries had already occupied the attention of SCHEE : LE , and that this philosopher had pronounced their acid to be the Malic .
Some preliminary experiments showed me that the juice occasioned a precipitation in acetate of lead and nitrate of silver ; :t it produced no change in lime water , barytes water , sulphtate of copper , nor , although it might be expected from its very astringent taste , did it affect sulphate of iron .
A quantity of the juice was poured into a solution of sugar of lead ; a curdy and somewhat heavy precipitate appeared , which was separated by filtration : this , from its solubility in acetic and dilute nitric acid , I judged to be malate of lead .
The filtered iiquor was red , and perfectly transparent , but after a few hours , I observed a powder deposited at the bottom , and as I saw no sufficient reason for its appearance , it attracted my attention .
To the naked eye it looked like a coarse powder ; but , when examined by the microscope , proved to be composed of amorphous crystalline grains .
With this small quantity of powder I made some trials , which ended in exciting farther curiosity .
It was probable , that the precipitate which remained on the filter might be made to furnish more grains , and accordingly , after edulcorating the mass , I caused boiling water to pass through it .
After two hours I examined the different washings ; those made with cold water remained as at first , but those with boiling water had become white and turbid , from the suspension of a subtle powder .
In several hours after , the cloud had disappeared , and displayed an abundant and beautiful formation of slender prismatic crystals , which glistened with silvery splendor at the bottom of the vessel .
The mass which remained on the filter had become hard , was much diminished , and was very dense .
I accounted for the production of crystals by supposing that the precipitate , whatever might be its composition , was insoluble in cold water , but soluble in very large portions of boiling water , and hence the crystalline deposition-on cooling .
Experiment , however , showed , that the residual hard mass , even when levigated , boiled with water , and filtered , would no longer afford crystals on cooling : and this was a sufficient objection to my supposition ; for , if one portion of the compound be soluble , why not the whole ?
I observed , that even when the precipitate newly obtained , was washed with portions of cold water until it no longer altered vegetable colours ; yet the first , second , and sometimes the third washing with boiling water would , after the deposition of the crystals , immediately redden litmus .
An 232 opinion now suggested itself , which the following trials greatly strengthened .
In order to obtain the acid of the saturnine precipitate , the latter was boiled with dilute sulphuric acid : the liquor became red and transparent , while the sulphate of lead subsided to the bottom .
Imagining that I had now obtained the acid in a state of sufficient purity , although coloured with adhering vegetable matter , I thought to separate the sediment by filtration , but was disappointed : for the liquorcame through very turbid , notwithstanding that the supernatant liquor had been transparent .
It was apparent , therefore , that the sulphuric acid being in too small a quantity , had displaced but a part of the vegetable acid , that the latter dissolved the remaining part of its own combination with lead , and deposited it when the solution touched any thing cold , thus producing the turbidness .
After some hours , the turbidness in the filtered liquor subsided , forming a stratum on the bottom of the vessel , over which lay a number of crystals .
The theory of the crystalline formation in the washings of the precipitate now became obvious .
It appeared that when the saturnine compound was washed with cold water , no other effect than edulcoration was produced : but that hot water partially decomposed the mass into a super and a sub-salt , the former of which being soluble in boiling water , filtered through , but on cooling , deposited crystals of the neutral salt , while free acid was left dissolved in the liquor .
The first washing contained most free acid , and therefore suffered least of the neutral salt to crystallize .
The red acid liquor , as has been stated , contained much lead , and this it was necessary to separate .
The most unex ceptionable method appeared to be the transmission of sulphuretted hydrogen through the clear liquor .
This was accordingly done , after having heated the acid liquor so as to redissolve the crystals and sediment .
The resulting sulphuret of lead was filtered off , and the clear fluid was boiled for a length of time , to expel the superfluous gas .
Supposing now that I had obtained the pure acid , I began to form various conjectures as to its nature ; in the midst of which I discovered , that the berries of the Sorbus Aucuparia had already occupied the attention of SCHEELE , and that he had pronounced their acid to be the malic .
There was indeed a great coincidence of properties between the two acids : malic acid is red , when evaporated to dryness it deliquesces , its combinations with potash , soda , and ammonia are deliquescent ; such were also the properties of the acid under consideration .
Yet I had never understood that malate of lead could be made to afford crystals : an experiment on this head , therefore , became necessary .
The juice of nearly ripe apples was saturated with potash , and the solution when filtered , was mixed with solution of acetate of lead : the precipitate was collected on a filter .
This after being edulcorated was washed with boiling water , as before .
In sixteen hours , crystals , precisely the same as the berries had afforded , were deposited , although less in quantity .
The production of crystals in both these cases , seemed to show that the acid of both fruits was the same : yet there was one difference .
The precipitate remaining on the filter , after the action of boiling water , was , in that produced from apples , soft and pasty ; but that obtained from the Sorbus berries was hard and dense .
It became therefore necessary , 2g3 to discover what would be the habitudes of malate of lead obtained by other means .
SCHEELE showed that the primary action of nitrous acid on sugar is to form malic acid .
I therefore heated together equal weights of these substances , until the effervescence ceased .
The brown residue was diluted with lime water , and when the oxalic acid that might have been formed , was in this manner separated , the remaining acid substance was saturated with potash .
Acetate of lead was added , and the malate of lead thus formed was collected and edulcorated .
Itl now remained to ascertain whether this malate possessed the property of crystallizing , like that prepared from apple juice .
I accordingly poured on it different portions of boiling water which were received in different vessels : the washings were all of a brownish yellow colour , from a small quantity of malate of lead held dissolved .
At the end of 48 hours this salt was all deposited in the state of a brown subtle powder , but there was no formation whatever of crystals .
On the surface of each washing was an iridescent pellicle of some lustre , which I found to be characteristic of the malic acid .
This experiment , as SCHEELE directs , was made with weak nitric acid ; I repeated it with an acid of considerable strength , but after sixty hours there was not one crystal .
It deserves attention , that the matter which remained on the filter in these two experiments , after washing with boiling water , were as soft and pasty as when first collected ; whereas the salt of lead obtained from the berries of the Sorbus , had grown dense , hard , and was much diminished .
The saturnine compound that had been formerly obtained '35 from the berries , when partially decomposed by sulphuric acid , afforded crystals on cooling : in order to ascertain if the malate of lead obtained from sugar would do the same , I repeated the process on it , but obtained no crystals .
These experiments were made under almost every possible circumstance with the same results .
I next precipitated all the lead from the remaining malate ; the malic acid thus obtained , was again mixed with acetate of lead , and the precipitate treated with boiling water as before : but the results were the same .
From this malate of lead the acid was again separated , and the same process as before was four times repeated : but notwithstanding nearly all the foreign matter was thus separated , no crystals formed .
ScHEELE found that the gooseberry contains nearly equal parts of citric and malic acids .
I thought it necessary to examine if this fruit would afford crystals .
SCHEELE'S process for separating the acids is as follows .
The juice is to be evaporated to the consistence of honey , the pure acid to be separated by alcohol , and the alcohol to be finally evaporated .
The residuum is to be dissolved in water , saturated with carbonate of lime ; the solution is to be filtered , and boiled so as to separate the citrate of lime .
The remaining brown solution is malate of lime : the salt is to be precipitated by alcohol , redissolved after edulcoration , and the solution is to be precipitated with acetate of lead.* All this I followed ; but after treating the malate of lead with boiling water , I obtained no crystals .
The raspberry was found by SCHEELE to contain the same acids .
I examined this fruit in a similar manner , but no crystals were produced .
VAUQTELIN detected malic acid in a variety of plants , but in none so abundantly as the Sempervivum Tectorum .
In the juice of this plant , it is united to lime in the state of a supersalt.* Malate of lead was formed by pouring solution of acetate of lead into the filtered juice of this plant .
The precipitate , when washed with boiling water , deposited on cooling , the the same subtle powder as usual , but no crystals .
Nor were any obtained when the malate was partially decomposed by sulphuric acid , in the manner already described .
SCHEELE found that the berries of the Sambucus Nigra , contain the malic acid unmixed with any other .
I therefore examined their very mucilaginous juice , but could not produce crystals .
As in my experiments on apples I had obtained crystals , I wished to try what effect the vinous fermentation might have on their juice .
The process was repeated with cider , but I was surprised to find , that although a malate of lead was obtained , the property of forming crystals had been destroyed .
From various conjectures it appeared possible , that the berries of the Sorbus while very young , might perhaps contain a malic acid that would furnish few or no crystals .
In the beginning of August ( 812 ) the berries being still green , I made an infusion of them , which after filtration afforded a precipitate with acetate of lead .
Boiling water produced no crystals , nor did the mass become hard as on former occasions .
Seven varieties of malic acid had now been examined , which when united to lead would not afford crystals .
In the two latter cases it was surprising that those acids which in other trials afforded abundance , would now afford none .
That the juice of the green berries was real malic acid , was proved by the following properties .
i. The acid , when separated from the juice , was of a crimson colour .
a. When evaporated to dryness , it soon deliquesced .
3 .
When rendered solid , and acted on by nitrous acid , some crystals of oxalic acid appeared .
4 .
The acid formed deliquescent salts with potash , soda , and ammonia .
5 .
Its combinations with lime and lead possessed their proper characteristics .
The acid of very young sour apples was combined with lead , and the compound treated with boiling water : the washings deposited much more crystals than mature apples , would have done .
The truth was now manifest .
Beside the malic , there is another acid formation , which in different fruits is formed at different periods , and which has hitherto escaped observation : and I consider the preceding details by no means redundant , inasmuch as they establish one decided difference between the two acids .
Many others will shortly be stated .
The first step towards confirming the difference , was to obtain the new acid in a state of purity : and after numerous attempts , I found that the only way to obtain it pure , was to separate it from the crystals .
The process is indeed complex and difficult .
The berries of the Sorbus Aucuparia are to be collected when first they have arrived at maturity .
After sufficient bruising in a Wedgewood mortar , they are to be subjected to strong pressure in a linen bag .
If collected at the most favourable time , they will afford nearly one half their weight of juice , s. G. 1077 .
This after due subsidence is to be strained , and mixed with filtered solution of acetate of lead .
The precipitate is to be collected on a filter , and in order to separate any uncombined colouring matter , it should be washed with cold water .
A very large quantity of boiling water is to be poured on the filter , and allowed to pass through the precipitate into different glass jars .
After some hours , the washings become opaque , and at length deposit crystals of singular lustre and beauty .
Those which have been formed in the colourless washings are to be alone retained ; they are to be separated by the filter , dried in the air , and preserved for a farther process .
The original mass remaining on the filter , from which the crystals have been obtained , being now hard and brittle , is incapable of affording any more , without undergoing a new operation .
It is to be boiled for half an hour with a little more dilute sulphuric acid than is sufficient to decompose the salt ; when cold it is to be filtered .
The filtered liquor is to be mixed a second time with acetate of lead : the precipitate washed , as before , with boiling water , and the crystals selected from the colourless washings only .
The remaining mass again grown hard , is to undergo the process of decomposition with sulphuric acid , combination with lead , and the formation of crystals : and after all , it will be found that the crystals of all the processes will be inconsiderable when collected .
The whole of the crystalline product being dried , is to be 239 boiled for half an hour with 2.3 times its weight of sulphuric acid , s. 1090 , supplying water as fast as it evaporates , and taking care to keep the mixture constantly stirred with a glass rod .
The clear liquor is to be filtered off , and poured into a tall glass jar of small diameter .
While still hot , a stream of sulphuretted hydrogen is to be transimitted through it , and when all the lead has been precipitated , the fluid is to be filtered off , and boiled in an open basin , until the discharged vapour no longer blacken paper impregnated with acetate of lead .
The theory of the process is obvious .
When acetate of lead is added to the juice , malate of lead and the combination of the new acid with lead precipitate ; the latter is decomposed by boiling water into a super and a sub-salt ; the supersalt is held in solution , but as the liquor cools , the neutral compound deposits itself in crystals , and the first washings contain most free acid .
When boiling water is no longer able to overcome the attraction of the latter portions of acid to oxide of lead , no more crystals can be formed .
We then apply the stronger power of sulphuric acid , we obtain the free vegetable acid , and proceed as at first .
When all the crystals are collected , such a quantity of sulphuric acid is added as will be nearly sufficient to decompose them : this is so done in order completely to exclude the sulphuric acid , which without this precaution would be exceedingly difficult to efiect .
The undecomposed portion of the crystals dissolves in the vegetable acid newly extricated : but , if in the boiling , the fluid were not continually stirred , a mass would be formed in the bottom so hard as to resist decomposition .
If the liquor after filtering were allowed to cool , the neutral salt 24 ?
would crystallize ; it must therefore be used hot .
The stream of sulphuretted hydrogen passing through so high a column of fluid soon separates the lead , while the pure vegetable acid is liberated , contaminated indeed with a little sulphu .
retted hydrogen .
This gas does not disappear completely by boiling , for the acid retains the odour , be it ever so long boiled ; exposure for a few days in an open vessel dissipates it completely .
In preparing this acid , it is not necessary , as it is in the process for malic acid , to saturate the juice of the berries with potash , at the commencement of the process : for of the two compounds formed after the mixture with acetate of lead , the malate dissolves in the evolved acetic acid in preference to the other .
The colouring matter , which adheres obstinately to the malate of lead , is very apt , when extricated during the washing with boiling water , to tinge the otherwise perfectly colourless crystals , which form as the liquor cools .
This is a great inconvenience , for the colouring matter cannot be washed away , even by cold water , without decomposing a quantity of the salt : hence the only remedy is , to reject all the crystals formed in the coloured washings , and to reserve those only that are of a pure whiteness .
The crystals are of so delicate a fabric that they must be separated by the filter .
When dried on paper , by exposure to air , they form a white brilliant flake of a silver lustre , resembling wellprepared acetate of mercury , but still more beautiful .
As to the amorphous crystalline grains which first attracted my attention , the following experiment elucidates the theory of their formation .
A quantity of the pure acid obtained by the above process , was boiled for some time on an excess of Mp676CCc 11eX 2I4 carbonate of magnesia .
The liquor after filtration was found to restore the original colour of reddened litmus , and to render green the tincture of cabbage .
An acetate of lead was formed by boiling solution of super-acetate on carbonate of lead .
This solution was mixed with the former , and the precipitate was collected by the filter .
Notwithstanding the evident excess of magnesia existing in one solution , and the necessary neutrality of the other , yet the filtered liquor was found strongly to redden litmus paper .
We are not to suppose that the two salts evolved a free acid during their mutual decomposition .
As much oxide of lead was liberated from the acetate , as was necessary to the neutrality of the acid eliminated from the compound with magnesia ; the solution would therefore have retained all its ingredients in a state of neutrality , except that which originally contained an excess of magnesia .
But the new salt of lead at the moment of its formation , was decomposed by the water present into a super and a sub-salt : the excess of acid being not only sufficient to saturate the redundant magnesia , but also to leave a portion free in the solution .
This liquor , after an hour , deposited a quantity of crystalline grains , and after that , the acidity increased .
Hence appears the reason of a crystallization in the original liquor : a super-salt is formed , which after a while deposits the neutral salt in a crystalline form .
This acid appearing from what has been already stated , as well as from what will be hereafter detailed , to be of a peculiar nature , it became necessary to give it a name .
After some consideration I bestowed on it one , which , although not unexceptionable , is sufficiently accordant with the general analogy of chemical nomenclature , and which has received the approbation of some competent judges .
Until a better name be devised , I have called it the Sorbic Acid .
To establish its peculiar nature , I have examined its combinations with certain bases , but have confined myself to those of which the analogous combinations amongst the malates had been already examined by SCHEELE .
The sorbic and malic acids not having been distinguished by that philosopher , it seemed that here the distinction ought particularly to be established : and the standard of comparison must necessarily be whatever had been ascertained of the malates by their discoverer .
Sorbic acid , when perfectly pure , is a transparent , colourless , and inodorous fluid , soluble in alcohol , and in any proportion of water .
When evaporated , it forms an uncrystallizable solid mass which deliquesces : when subjected to distillation , the liquor which passes over , shows no traces of acidity .
Its acidity is such that it causes even a painful sensation on the organs of taste .
It is not much altered by being kept in an uncombined state .
I have had it for more than a year in a corked phial , and at the end of that time , no other change was produced than the separation of a tenuous coagulum , small in quantity , as the acid was very pure , but it is more abundant when the acid is impure .
When mixed with malic acid , as in fruits , this acid is the first to disappear , while the other retains its properties long after the commencement of decay in the plant .
A quantity of malate of lead obtained from Sempervivum Tectorum was boiled with sorbic acid and a little water ; the whole , from being colourless , became somewhat brown .
The Ii S43 liquor was then filtered , and the turbid liquor which came through , was heated until it became clear ; it was then suffered to rest .
As it cooled , it let fall a powder , but when this was filtered off , the liquor remained clear , and in an hour a great profusion of crystals was let fall .
The mass which remained on the filter contained some gritty particles .
Thus it is evident , that malate of lead was decomposed by sorbic acid , which could not happen unless the latter were a distinct substance .
The malate was only partly decomposed , the oxide of lead united to the excess of sorbic acid forming super-sorbate of lead , while the disengaged malic acid dissolved as much as it could of the remaining undecomposed malate , forming super-malate of lead .
The brown colour was produced by disengaged malic acid .
The super-malate , as it cooled , deposited its malate in the state of powder , and the super-sorbate soon after deposited sorbate of lead in the state of crystals ; and the original mass was found to contain gritty particles of sub-sorbate .
In the same manner , when a precipitate , obtained by acetate of lead from the juice of the Sorbus berries , is washed with boiling water , scarcely any malate of lead is deposited ; and if the fluid contain much free sorbic acid , the iridescent pellicle , which is a characteristic of malate of lead , does not appear .
I shall now proceed to the combinations of this acid , so as to distinguish it from malic acid : and first the salts which it forms with lead should be briefly recapitulated .
The sub-sorbate is insoluble in water ; if in a mass , it is dense and hard ; if in powder , it is gritty .
The neutral sorbate , if obtained by precipitation , is a white powder , but if obtained from solution in its own acid , it is in beautiful silvery crystals .
Neither of these salts is soluble in 5ooo times its weight of water .
The sorbate when heatedl to redness , undergoes a somewhat brilliant combustion .
The super-sorbate never assumes the solid form ; its taste is sweet .
Thus the sorbic acid forms three combinations with lead : malic forms but two , the neutral malate , which is an uncrystallizable soft powder , and the super-malate .
Not less distinguishable are the two acids by their combinations with the alkalies .
Sorbate of potash , when there is an excess of acid , forms permanent crystals soluble in water , but insoluble in alcohol .
Sorbate of soda , when there is an excess of acid , forms permanent crystals , which agree in characters with the former .
Sorbate of ammonia , when there is an excess of acid , also forms permanent crystals of similar characters with the preceding .
These three salts will not crystallize unless there be a tolerable excess of acid ; they are to be considered as super-salts .
That of soda even requires the aid of cold to render it solid .
The malates of potash , soda , and ammonia are known to be uncrystallizable and deliquescent .
In the combinations of these acids with earths , ,there are also striking differences .
SCHEELE found , that when he added carbonate of lime to malic acid , a great quantity was dissolved , but the solution gave with litmus , indications , of an abundant acid which it was impossible to neutralise with farther additions of chalk.* I obtained the same result with malic acid from the Sempervivum ; I even found that the solution might be boiled to dryness , on a fresh portion of carbonate of lime , yet when lixiviated , the filtered solution would still redden litmus , and the salt finally afforded was readily soluble .
These results often obtained , prove that it is not possible to form neutral malate from carbonate of lime .
But with sorbic acid the case was quite different .
When it was diluted , and agitated for a little while with carbonate of lime , the solution , before it could be filtered , deposited the principal part of the sorbate in the form of a discrete , gritty powder .
The liquor when filtered produced no redness in tincture of litmus , and every thing proved that the fluid by mere agitation over the carbonate , had been completely neutralised .
The same results which SCHEELE obtained from lime were afforded by carbonate of barytes : but with sorbic acid I produced a liquor which showed no signs of acidity .
The best test for ascertaining this fact , seemed to be infusion of brazil wood altered by distilled vilnegar ; and with this it even appeared , that the solution contained an excess of base .
Thus it appears , that malic acid never forms with carbonate of lime , any other than acidulous salts ; and , as SCHEELE observes , these solutions in some days deposit the neutral salt in crystals .
But with these carbonates , the sorbic acid forms neutral salts , which , as soon asformed , precipitate .
SCHEELE ascertained , that malate of magnesia is a deliquescent salt , * and in my trials I could not obtain it in a crystalline form .
When evaporated , it became thick , and dried into a semitransparent substance , which softened with the smallest quantity of water , and formed matter of a syrupy consistence .
The same earth , heated in sorbic acid , afforded a ?
CRULI , 's Chem. Annal .
1785 .
2 2g97 .
246 liquor which , after filtration , deposited permanent crystals in abundance : they required for solution no less than 28 parts of water at 6o.0 The malate of alumina was found by SCHEELE to be a salt very difficult of solution .
I wished to discover the properties of the sorbate .
I therefore boiled some very pure alumina that had been just prepared , and was therefore still soft , with sorbic acid : the boiling was continued for almost an hour , and after filtration , I discovered with no small surprise , that the alumina had not been acted upon .
The acid was tried by every means , and nothing but the most minute vestiges of the earth could be obtained .
Thus there is no sorbate of alumina .
I consider that from this property the sorbic acid may become a valuable instrument of analysis .
The process for separating alumina from other earths , has been complicated and uncertain : may it not be rendered simple by the use of this acid , employed in excess ?
Thus , I think there can be no doubt , that the sorbic acid is an acid suigeneris , and probably intermediate between malic and oxalic .
With regard to the other acids , with which the sorbic coexists in fruits , it is to be observed , that it is never found in mature fruits that contain any other than the malic ; that the latter is never found alone in any mature fruit , but always accompanied by the sorbic , and that these two acids , when together , exclude all others .
To this , however , there is an apparent exception , namely , the berry of the Sambucus Nigra , which ( probably from the immense quantity of mucilage and * It deserves remark , that in SCH EELE'S experiments , there could have been no sorbic acid present , as might have been expected , had he prepared his acid from apples : he obtained it from gooseberries , and thereby avoided this source of fallacy .
247 colouring matter present ) afforded me no sorbic acid .
The fruits that contain the sorbic and malic acids together are apples , plums , berries of the sorbus , barberries , and sloes .
Of these , the berries of the sorbus contain the greatest quantity of sorbic acid , unripe apples less , ripe apples and sloes still less , barberries very little , and plums least of all .
The green berries of the sorbus , ( perhaps , ) those of the sambucus , and the plant sempervivum tectorum , contain no other than the malic ; and agreeing with the foregoing statements , raspberries and gooseberries , as they contain citric and malic acids , contain no sorbic whatever .
Observations on the malic acid .
In 1785 , during an examination of different fruits and berries , SCHEELE discovered that gooseberries , beside lemon acid , contained one of a peculiar nature : this he afterwards found to exist in apples , without , as he thought , a sensible admixture of any other .
On this account he gave it the name of apple acid , or malic acid .
He also ascertained , that by the action of nitrous acid on sugar , a substance is produced , which shows no traces of nitric acid , yet unites and forms a soluble salt with lime , " it therefore is not the oxalic acid .
" By some other experiments he found that an acid is produced " c which does not differ in the least from the properties of the apple acid , and is accordingly the same .
' This acid he detected in a great variety of vegetable juices , Since that period , VAUQUELIN has extended the catalogue , but of all other plants , it is most abundantly contained in the Sempervivum Tectorum .
SCHEELE'S process for obtaining malic acid is as follows , f8 02175 'I Saturate the juice of apples , whether ripe or unripe , with carbonate of potash ; add solution of acetate of lead until it cease to produce a precipitation .
To the edulcorated precipitate , add as much dilute vitriolic acid , as is necessary to give the mixture a perfectly acid taste , without any sweetness .
" ' There are several objections to this process , all of which seem to have considerable weight .
In the preceding pages I have shown , that the juice of apples , whether ripe or unripe , always contains two acids of very different properties .
By the above process these acids are not separated ; they are in fact found in what is supposed to be the resulting pure malic acid , and it is impossible , without the most complicated processes , to obtain this substance in the insulated form .
The precipitation of the lead by means of sulphuric acid , appears to be objectionable .
I have often attempted to adjust the proportion of the latter substance , so as to throw down all the lead , without leaving any free sulphuric acid , but I uniformly failed : and it is evident , that , if not impossible , it is exceedingly difficult and troublesome .
SCHEELE also attempted to obtain malic acid from malate of lime , by means of sulphuric acid , but found " the mode rather difficult , as the acid would not let the calx fall completely .
" VAUQUELIN observed the same thing .
The last process proposed by SCHEELE , is to distil equal parts of weak nitric acid and sugar , until the mixture become brown , which is a sign that all the nitrous acid has been abstracted : the oxalic acid formed , is to be separated by lime water , and the remaining acid to be saturated with carbonate of lime , * CRELL'S Chemische Annal .
1785 .
Vol. II .
295 .
The solution is to be filtered , the filtered liquor to be mixed with alcohol , and the coagulum thus obtained , is to be edulcorated with new portions of alcohol .
The coagulum is then to be dissolved in water , and mixed with a solution of acetate of lead : a precipitate falls , which is to be treated with sulphuric acid , in the manner already directed .
No one who has not gone through this process , can fully conceive the difficulty and expense of it : and I have found that the acid obtained is variable in its nature .
In one case I obtained an acid , which , when mixed with solution of acetate of lead , did not at first produce any effect , but at length slowly deposited a precipitate .
The heating of another portion of the acid with carbonate of lime , produced a separation of a black powder , which possessed the properties of charcoal .
There were also many other peculiarities ; and the combined effect of all was to convince me , that great differences exist between the acid obtained in this manner , and that obtained by other processes .
The experiments of VAUQUELIN satisfied hilm that the acid which is combined with lime in the Sempervivum Tectorum , is the true malic : and all my trials convince me , that it does not contain even the least quantity of the sorbic .
Since then , by the means generally employed , we do not obtain malic acid , the only alternative is to adopt the hitherto neglected process of VAUQUELIN ; and it will be found that his process affords the acid with greater ease , and in much greater purity , than any other .
The method of detaching the acid from the malate of lead by sulphuric acid is , as we have seen , difficult ; and the criterion of the taste is liable to this fallacy , that as the sourness increases , the sweetness decreases .
There will ol this account , be a period when the latter will disguise the former , and yet the lead will be still present .
I would therefore suggest the substitution of sulphuretted hydrogen in place of sulphuric acid .
If it were required to obtain malic acid exceedingly pure , and still more divested of vegetable matter , the following process may be adopted .
The juice of Sempervivum Tectorum is to be evaporated to two-thirds , and , after standing some hours , it is to be filtered , and mixed with an equal quantity of alcohol .
The coagulum is to be separated by the filter , edulcorated with fresh portions of alcohol , and dried in the air , lest any adhering alcohol should impede its subsequent solution .
The mass is then to be dissolved in water , mixed with solution of acetate of lead , and the precipitate collected on a filter .
After being well edulcorated from any superfluous acetate of lead , the precipitate is to be boiled for 15 minutes with a little less of dilute sulphuric acid than is sufficient to saturate the oxide of lead : and for this part of the process , the criterion of sweetness will very well answer the purpose .
The whole is to be set aside for some days , and , during this period , a small quantity of sulphate of lead which the malic acid held dissolved , will be deposited .
The liquor is now to be filtered , and in order to separate the last portions of lead , a stream of sulphuretted hydrogen is to be transmitted through it : the black precipitate is to be filtered off ; and the liquor should be boiled in a vessel freely exposed , until paper moistened with acetate of lead is no longer blackened by the discharged vapour .
This acid is the purest that can be obtained ; it retains Kk a slight odour of the gas , but even this is destroyed by exposure to the air for a few days .
VAUQUELIN observes , that malic acid thus obtained is nearly colourless : his was therefore diluted .
I have found that it becomes perfectly brown by concentration : and I have decomposed and recomposed malate of lead several times , using each time the same specimen of malic acid , yet so obstinately did the colouring matter adhere , that it was always found in the resulting acid .
Thus , as far as we know , this acid cannot be procured free from colour ; and the nearest approximation is that obtained by VAUQUELIN 's process .
Suggestions concerning the state in ' , which acids may previously have existed in vegetables .
I have sometimes indulged in the supposition , that the vegetable acids are not primarily formed by the immediate union of their elements , but that they may have previously existed in a definite combination , called the bitter principle .
It is possible that this principle may be a conmpound basis , which by uniting to oxygen , or by undergoing more complicated processes , might change its nature so far as to become an acid .
The whole is a mere conjecture , and perhaps deserving of little consideration ; the facts , however , which suggested it may be noticed .
The sweetness of any vegetable juice , has been generally attributed to a sweet principle called sugar .
In the same manner it has been lately supposed , that bitterness depends on a bitter principle , which , although variously disguised , is always identical .
Dr. THOMSON has shown , that when water is digested over Quassia , and afterwards evaporated to dryness , a transparentsubstance is obtained , which differs in its properties from all other vegetable principles : this he considers as the bitter principle , and , I believe , with very great justice .
I found that the liquor obtained by digestion , although slightly coloured , was transparent even to the end of the evaporation .
The resulting mass was nearly transparent , and minute in quantity , considering the proportion of Quassia employed ; and such was its bitterness , that a particle placed on the tongue , which could not have exceeded -th of a grain , diffiused an intense bitterness over the whole mouth and fauces .
This matter was heated with nitric acid ; it dissolved with effervescence , and the bitterness was no longer sensible .
The remaining substance formed a precipitate in acetate of lead , which possessed all the properties of malate of lead : and it appeared that no other than the malic acid was produced .
With this experiment the following agrees in a remarkable Ilanner .
Five ounces of white sugar , and an equal weight of very strong nitric acid were mixed in a retort .
Without the application of external heat the action commenced , and soon became violent .
When cold , the residual matter was found to be thick and tenacious ; its taste was sour , and extremely bitter .
The malic acid being abstracted from a portion of this by means of lime , it was found that the bitterness , now no longer disguised by acidity , had become intense .
The other portion , which had not been saturated with lime , by being treated with more nitric acid , lost all its bitterness , and oxalic acid was formed .
In this experiment it appears , that by some action of nitrous acid on sugar , a bitter substance and malic acid were produced together ; that by the farther action of nitrous acid , the bitter substance disappeared , and acid appeared in its stead .
The foregoing conjectures correspond also with the fact , that by the action of certain substances on each other , the bitter principle is evolved at the same time with those acids which I suppose to have been produced from that compound basis : and the appearance of both at the same time may be accounted for by admitting that the conversion was not.complete .
Thus , if alcohol be distilled with nitrous acid , a liquor is produced which has a sweet taste .
If this liquor be re-distilled with another portion of acid , a bitter liquor comes over .
And if this bitter liquor be distilled a third time with a fresh portion of nitrous acid , crystals of oxalic acid make their appearance in the residuum .
This series of changes bears a striking resemblance to that produced by the action of nitrous acid on sugar .
HAUSSMAN observed , that when nitric acid is digested with indigo , a very bitter substance results , to which WELTHER gave the name of Amer : in this process , oxalic acid is also formed .
The vegetable acids are even formed by the action of nitrous acid on animal substances ; in the instance of muscle we obtain the abovementioned Amer with oxalic acid .
In bile the bitter principle is already formed ; when acted on by nitrous acid , oxalic acid is produced .
On examination we shall not be at a loss to find operations analogous to some of the preceding , taking place naturally in the vegetable kingdom .
The Pyrus Malus or common crab apple , while young , is very bitter , and has little sourness : as the fruit advances towards maturity , the taste becomes proportionately sour , and the bitterness diminishes .
The young berries of the Sorbus Aucuparia also are bitter , contain but one acid , and even that in small quantity : when the berry is ripe , it contains two acids , the combined quantity of both is considerable , but the bitterness has in a great degree given place to a coarse astringency .
It is not improbable , that the bitterness produced in all the foregoing cases , should be owing to the formation of the same bitter principle : and its constant conjunction with a vegetable acid , seems to show that there is some very intimate connexion between them , at present unknown .
The preceding observations are offered as mere conjecture ; and I am fully sensible of what little consideration should be attached to them : they are not hlowever entirely devoid of probability .
An hypothesis is below the dignity of a system which is founded on the indestructible basis of experiment : and even though it be supported by the coincidence of admitted facts , by direct analogies , and by the correspondence of recei ?
ved opinions , it should nevertheless be the beginning , and not the end of knowledge .

