PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
X. On some phenomena of colours , exhibited by thin plates .
By John Knox , Esq. Communicated by the Right Hon. Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. G. C. B. P. R. S. Read April 6 , 1815 .
IT is not without reason that the phenomena of light have been subjects of speculative enquiry from the earliest ages of philosophy ; since perhaps no study can be more interesting to the inquisitive mind , than the contemplation of that medium through which it receives its most exalted enjoyments .
There are probably no appearances in physical optics that have excited more attention , and that have been less satisfactorily accounted for , than those prismatic concentric rings which appear between lenses , or between a flat glass and a lens , when laid together .
And , notwithstanding some of the most eminent philosophers and opticians have given explanations thereof , particularly Sir IsAAC NEWTON and Dr. HERSCHEL , it will appear from what follows , that the subject is far from being exhausted .
The insufficiency of NEWTON'S theory for the solution of this problem , by the supposed fits of easy transmission and reflection of the rays of light , is now generally admitted ; nor does it appear that any other more satisfactory , has yet been adopted in its stead .
This will not be thought surprising , if it shall appear by the following experiments , that neither NEWTON , nor any other writer that has followed him in the same line , has been in possession of all the phenomena connected with this curious and intricate subject .
I was induced to make the following experiments in consequence of having lately read Dr. HERSCHEL'S excellent paper on the same subject , published in the 9gth vol. of the Philosophical Transactions , in which he has related a great number of experiments , explaining a variety of phenomena relative to prismatic rings ; and must acknowledge my obligations to this celebrated author , for his simple but ingenious contrivance of viewing prismatic phenomena by means of the shadow of a black card ; without which , it is probable the following discoveries , such as they are , would not have been made .
Exp. i. On repeating some of the experiments mentioned by Dr. HERSCHEL in vol. 95 of the Philosophical Transactions , and having by means of the shadow of a blackened card perceived no less than eight sets of rings in some cases , and being very attentive in endeavouring to distinguish transmitted from reflected sets , I faintly saw parallel lines or streaks , which at first were mistaken for the threads of a piece of black silk which was placed under the lower glass , in order to see the rings more distinctly .
It was not until after repeated examinations by the light of a lamp , in which the direct light is shaded from the eyes , that it was ascertained , that those parallel lines were drawn through the intersections made by the several rings of the primary set and its reflected image , and that they consisted of light , although their dimensions were too small for their colours to be distinctly perceived .
The apparatus used in this experiment was a piece of good looking-glass plate laid on the plane side of a plano-concave lens belonging to a compound microscope , and was used for holding mites or other animalcules on the concave side .
The plane side of this glass had acquired in the polishing ( accidentally perhaps ) a very small degree of convexity , probably equal to that of a lens of several feet focal length .
This lens , when the plane glass was laid thereon , produced a larger set of primary rings than could be otherwise procured .
Its concave side had been ground on a sphere of about two inches radius ; therefore the set of transmitted rings , reflected from its lower internal surface , was too small to cause any confusion either in the primary set or its reflected image ; and it was in a great measure owing to this accidental circumstance , that these parallel lines happened to be discovered at all ; nor could they have been discovered , even with this apparatus , without the use of the shadow .
Exp. 2 .
Having ascertained the reality of these parallel fringes , I painted the concave side of the plano-concave lens black , in order to prevent all reflection from its concave surface ; by which means the fringes were seen in much greater perfection .
They were found to consist of all the prismatic colours ; were equidistant and parallel ; equal in number to the rings of both sets taken together , exclusive of the central one ; and each fringe was drawn through the several interY i63 sections of the primary set of rings with those of its reflected image ; and their lengths extended to the edge of the lens on both sides , they were formed at right angles to the direction of the light , and to a line joining the centres of the primary and its reflected image ; which indeed is a necessary consequence of their being projected through the intersections of two sets of concentric rings perfectly equal in dimensions .
See fig. i , pl. VII .
compared with fig. 3 , pl. VIII .
I was convinced that those parallel fringes consisted of prismatic colours ; yet with the apparatus now used , they were too small and too close to each other to enable me to perceive distinctly the order in which those colours were arranged , with respect to each other .
As their distances from each other , or , which is the same thing , their breadths depended on the distances of the intersections through which they were projected ; it was obvious that by separating , or widening the distances of the latter , the parallel fringes would also be separated , and consequently their breadths enlarged .
Exsp. .
For effecting this purpose , two modes presented themselves , either by increasing the dimensions of the primary set of rings , and consequently that of its reflected image ; or by lessening the distance between them .
The former mode was at that time out of my power , having no lens of a longer focus than the one in use .
The latter was effected by procuring a thinner piece of plate glass than that used in the ist experiment ; and although by this apparatus the field of view was narrowed , the breadths of the fringes were enlarged , and by this means it was easily perceived , that each fringe was composed of the same prismatic colours as the Newtonian rings , and were placed in the same order with respect to each other ; that is , beginning with red , next orange , then yellow , green , blue , indigo , and lastly , violet : but that the fringes themselves were divided into two classes , ( with respect to the position of the colours of each particular fringe ) by a centtral band or fringe passing through a point bisecting the distances between the centres of the primary set and its image , each fringe , on both sides of this imaginary point , respecting it as a centre , and having the red colour of each fringe turned outwards , or from that centre ; the central band alone being equal on both of its sides with respect to colour ; being as it were composed of two of the inside halves of the two adjoining fringes , imagined to be laid together ; having no red in its composition , and being rather less intense in colour than any of the others .
An imitation is given in fig. i. pl. VII .
and as it would be impracticable to express all the colours of each fringe by shadowing , the darkest shade denotes the violet , the unshaded side the red of each fringe , and the black lines the divisions between them .
Exp. 4 .
Another mode of producing those fringes was by applying a convex and a concave lens together , the curvature of the one differing but little from that of the other .
This apparatus produced a larger set of primary rings , and consequently broader fringes , than by either of the foregoing experiments ; but in this case none of them were straight , except the central fringe , all the rest being bent more or less into elliptical shapes , conformable to the surfaces between which they were formed .
Exp. 5 .
But a better mode still was found , by applying a slip of looking-glass plate to one of the sides of a triangular 165 prism , about $5 inches long , and a full inch broad ; for although the sides had been intended to be made perfectly flat , they had acquired , in polishing , such a small degree of convexity , as on application of the flat glass plate , produced a larger set of primary rings than could be had by any of the former experiments .
This apparatus was still farther improved , by painting two of the sides of the prism black , so as to exclude all extraneous light ; by which means I could easily perceive that those fringes ( which were produced by rings of about three quarters of an inch diameter , ) extended from one end of the prism to the other , that is , to an extent of at least seven or eight times the diameters of the rings , and it is uncertain how much farther they might have extended with a longer prism .
They were also seen parallel to the edges of the prism , by carrying the eye in that direction , either to the right or left .
Nor do these rings or fringes cross each other undisturbed , for the prismatic colours of the rings , where they intersect each other , are deranged from their natural order ; and the division lines of the fringes , where they intersect the other intersections , are drawn into a zig-zag form , but beyond those intersections they proceed in straight lines .
These several intersections produce a most beautiful appearance of chequer , orrather net work , the meshes of which assume the hexagonal form , resembling the cups of a honeycomb ; of which it is impossible to convey an adequate idea without seeing the experiment .
Exp. 6 .
Having discovered unexpectedly these phenomena from one set of primaries and its reflected image , I was induced to try what effect could be produced by two sets of i66 primaries brought into a similar situation with respect to each other .
For this purpose , a double convex lens , of about thirtysix inches focus , was laid on a flat piece of looking-glass plate , having its under side painted black ; on the lens was placed another piece of plane glass plate ; by these means two sets of primary rings were produced , whose positions with respect to each other could be varied at pleasure .
On using the shadow of the black card I was agreeably surprised to find , that instead of parallelfringes a new species of prismatic rings appeared , whose number and sizes varied with the positions and distances of the two sets of primaries ; their dimensions were from two to three times the diameters of the primaries from which they appeared to originate , sometimes only one set appeared , sometimes two , and at other times a third very faintly .
On first observing these new rings , it was found , that on moving the eye in a horizontal direction to the right or left , they sometimes moved with , and sometimes contrary to the motion of the eye ; others were stationary , although the eye moved ; also , that sometimes the prismatic colours were seen in the usual order , and at other times inverted ; all of which facts seemed not a little perplexing at that time ; but their causes will be better understood from what follows .
Exp. 7 .
By a subsequent experiment , it was discovered , that those rings towards the circumference of the new sets had their colours always in the usual order ; but that those nearest the centres had their colours always inverted ; that the number of rings of each class were equal : that they all passed through the several intersections of the two primary sets of rings with each other , from which intersections they A67 seemed to originate ; that the dividing ring between the classes , passed through a point , whose distance from the centre of each primary set was in proportion to its largest diameter .
This will be better understood by referring to fig. s. pl. VII .
where A and B are the primary sets of rings : C will represent one of the newly discovered sets , which were denominated intersectionaries * from their apparent origin .
The fourth ring from the centre will be the division between the two classes .
Those rings within the division having the red on their insides , and those without having the red on their outsides , as represented by the figure ; where the same rule has been observed in shadowing these rings , as was observed with respect to the parallel fringes in fig. 1 , namely , that the shaded side represents the violet , and the unshaded side the red of each ring , and the dark lines the divisions between them .
Admitting that parallel fringes are necessarily rectilinear , in consequence of being drawn through intersections of circles that are perfectly equal in dimensions , it follows , that where two sets of circles differ in dimensions , the corresponding intersections cannot lie in straight lines , but must necessarily be circular , as will appear evident on inspection of the figure ; where the dividing ring DE could not pass through the several intersections in the points 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 1o , 1 , i2 , unless it were circular : the same thing will hold true of all the other rings of the intersectionary set .
It also appears by the foregoing experiments , that rectilinear fringes and intersectionary rings are coloured exactly alike , and are alike divided into two classes with respect to the order of the colours .
There is also an exact similarity in O The best apology for using a new word is , that it expresses a new idea , i68 the reticulated crossings before mentioned , whether the sets of primaries by which they are caused , are equal or unequal in dimensions .
Fringes and intersectionary rings , therefore , differ in no other respect than as right lines and circles ; it is , therefore , a fair conclusion , that the phenomena of rectilinear fringes , formed between two sets of rings of equal magnitudes , are bent into rings when the two corresponding sets are unequal in magnitude .
There is also an infinite variety in the dimensions of those intersectionary rings , according as the diameters of the primaries differ more or less , being least where that difference is greatest , and increasing in size as the two sets of primaries approach to equality , until at last they end in straight lines .
The dimensions of these intersectionaries will also ( cateris paribus ) diminish as the two sets of primaries approach each other , and enlarge as these are separated ; and , like Newtonian rings , enlarge or diminish with the less or greater elevation of the eye .
It will be easy to conceive from inspection of fig. 4 , ( pl. VIII .
) that where an intersectionary set of rings is formed between two sets of primaries of unequal magnitudes , it must necessarily appear on the side towards the smaller of the two primaries ; which agrees with actual experiment .
The above hypothesis accounts for one set of intersectionaries ; but experiment shows that if one set appears , it is almost always accompanied by a second , sometimes equal , but oftener unequal in dimensions , as in fig. 3 , ( pl. VIII .
) at other times part of a third set appears as segments of circles only .
It would , therefore , seem that they are formed not only between primary sets , but also between primaries combined with either transmitted or reflected sets , provided the two , between which they are formed , are unequal in dimensions .
Exp. 8 .
The four sets of rings represented in fig. 3 , ( pl. VIII ) were produced by an arrangement consisting of two convex lenses laid on each other , and a piece of plane looking-glass plate laid on the uppermost lens .
The large imperfect set , whose centre is at D , was evidently produced by the intersections of the two primary sets , A and B , ( the former was observed to have a dark and the other a light centre ) , but the set whose centre is at C cannot be accounted for on the same principle ; but may be owing to another cause , which will be better understood by a future experiment .
Notwithstanding these intersectionaries seem to owe their origin to a few rings only , adjoining that which divides the two classes ; yet they are always filled up to the centre with prismatic colours ; unless when very large , as that whose centre is at D , ( fig. 8 .
pl. VIII .
) or when they appear in part only , as segments of circles ; in which case the central spaces appear blank .
Exp. 9 .
It is perfectly certain that these intersectionary rings are always formed between the two contiguous surfaces of the two lower pieces of glass when three pieces are employed ; this is easily proved by the test of the shadow .
But if four or more pieces are laid on each other , the number of spectra may be increased indefinitely , and these again may be multiplied by internal reflections ; so that to pursue these phenomena through all the varieties of which they are capable would be an endless task .
Let it be observed here , that the several drawings of prismatic rings in figures i , , 3 , ( plates VII .
VIII .
) are such as would appear to the eye , could it see them at right angles to the plane in which they are formed ; but as the eye cannot well see them in this position , nor until it is lowered to an obliquity of about thirty degrees , the proper allowance must be made ; for such rings will always appear of elliptical forms , less or more elongated according to the greater or less elevation of the eye .
See fig. 4 .
( Pl .
VIII .
) Exp. o0 .
Finding from the foregoing experiments , that two sets of rings of equal magnitudes produced straight fringes , and that those of unequal sizes produced rings ; it was obvious that both fringes and rings might be considered as diagonals to the angles in which they were formed .
It was , therefore , concluded from analogy , that if primary fringes could be produced between two flat pieces of looking-glass plate , and that if two of those sets were made to cross each other , a set of straight or rectilinear fringes should be formed diagonally between them ; and , on making the experiment , I had the pleasure to find the result precisely answered expectation .
So far theory and experiment agreed ( see fig. 6 , pl. VIII .
) ; but in the course of making this and some of the succeeding experiments , several unexpected phenomena were discovered .
Exp. 1i .
The slips of plate glass used in this and several of the following experiments were from four to six inches long , and about one and a half inch broad , their edges having been ground straight .
On wiping two of those glass slips perfectly clean with soft shammy or a soft dry linen rag , ( which is absolutely necessary , as the smallest particle of dust , scarcely perceptible even with a microscope , interposed between the slips , Za 171 would prevent the success of the experiment ) , and by applying two of their ends together , and by using some friction and a considerable degree of pressure , a beautiful set of rectilinear prismatic coloured fringes appeared across the glass slips , having all the prismatic colours in the same order as Newtonian rings , and equally vivid , ( see fig. 5 , pl. VIII .
) and although the breadths of those fringes could be increased or diminished by the greater or less degree of pressure ( which had the effect of diminishing or increasing the angle formed by the planes ) , yet their breadths continued to be uniform , or as nearly so as might be expected , considering the unavoidable imperfections of the best plate glass .
It was proved by Sir ISAAC NEWTON , that primary prismatic rings were repeated at equal increments of interval between two spherical surfaces , because the semi-diameters ( or , which is the same thing , the diameters ) of those rings were found on actual measurement to be to each other as the square roots of the series , o , 2 , 4 , 6 , 8 , &amp;c. beginning at the centre of the rings or point of contact , as must be well known to mathematicians ; it might , therefore , have been known by reasoning a priori , that if similar prismatic phenomena could be produced between two flat planes , the corresponding repetitions must take place at regular and equal intervals from the point of contact , or vertex of the angle , corresponding to the natural numbers of which the measurements of the rings express the square roots ; that is , as the series o , 2 , 4 , 6 , 8 , &amp;c. The principle is , therefore , fully confirmed by this experiment .
Exp. s2 .
Those primary fringes have also transmitted sets between them , alternate in colours to their primaries , exactly similar to Newtonian rings ; for , by placing them longitudi17X nally in the direction of the light , and by using the shadow of a black card thrown across them , both primaries and transmitted fringes may be seen at once by the naked eye .
Let the light come in the direction AB in fig. 5 , pl. VIII .
and let CD represent the edge of the shadow next the light , those fringes above the line CD are primaries , and those below it are transmitted sets , alternate in colours to the others .
Although these primary fringes are uniform in their breadths , they are not quite so with respect to colour ; for the yellow , blue , indigo , and violet , are predominant in the first , second , and third fringes next to the place of contact , although these four colours are but little perceived after the third fringe , where ten are seen , the red , orange , and green being predominant in all the rest .
Exp. 3 .
After having produced one set of primary fringes , I succeeded in having another set formed at right angles thereto , by applying a third slip of glass longitudinally to the upper one of the first two , on which the expected diagonal fringes immediately appeared in the angle between the two primary sets , as shown in fig. 6 , pl. VIII .
where B and C are the primary fringes , and D the intersectionary set divided into two classes , as shown by the dotted line .
Exp. 14 .
It was found by trials , that the relative position of two sets of fringes , when formed by three slips only of glass plates , connected together as in Experiment 12 , could not be changed at pleasure ; but , by using four slips , and having a set of fringes formed between each pair , which were unconnected , these could be placed the one over the other in any position , and at any required angle ; by this arrangement , it was discovered , that whatever was the magnitude of the angle 173 formed by the two sets of primaries , that angle was always bisected by the central band of the intersectionaries .
And although these latter evidently proceed from the crossings of the two sets of primaries , yet they are never continued through those crossings to the opposite angle at A , fig. 6 , ( pl. VIII .
) nor could they be made to appear in any angle formed by primary fringes , unless the said fringes were so disposed as to have their red sides turned inwards , or towards each other .
This remarkable fact was proved by several repetitions of the same experiment .
Exp. 15 .
In the course of making these experiments , I had accidentally left a single slip of glass on one of the pairs between which a set of primaries were formed , without any other pressure than its own weight ; on examining the apparatus a few minutes afterwards , I was agreeably surprised to find no less than four sets of the same kind of fringes which appeared in the angle between the two sets of primaries , as before related in Experiment is , almost parallel to each other , and nearly so to the primaries , and at about an inch distant in front thereof .
( see fig. 5 .
p1 .
VIII .
) The set marked 2 , had broader fringes , more vivid in colour , and consisted of a greater number , ( from fifteen to nineteen ) , than those sets on each side thereof ; for these latter appeared to have that inferiority of colour to the principal set , that it bore to the primary set .
All the four sets were by attentive observation visible to the naked eye , and were all divided into two classes by a central band , as was before observed of the others ; and on application of the shadow , were found to consist of primary and transmitted fringes , precisely in the same manner as first primaries , or Newtonian rings .
A representation is shown in fig. 5 , ( pl. VIII , ) before referred to , where the sets denoted by i , 2 , 3 , and 4 , may be called primaries in respect of 5 , 6 , 7 , and 8 , which , in like manner , may be denominated transmitted sets ; all the space below the line CD being supposed covered with a shadow of a black card .
Not having hitherto observed these secondary fringes , except where they proceeded from intersections of primaries , it was concluded , that this was the only cause of their appearance ; but , by this last experiment , I was convinced of the error of this opinion , and that they are entitled to the same rank of originality as primary fringes or Newtonian rings ; and , since they are always found divided into two classes , I shall henceforward venture to denominate them binaries , which perhaps may not be an improper characteristic for the whole genus , in contradistinction to primaries , as it will appear in the sequel , that there are several species of the former , and at least two of the latter .
Exp. i6 .
This experiment was made to ascertain whether two slips of glass only , when the uppermost was pressed by its own weight alone , would produce binary fringes between them ; and I succeeded in perceiving one set whose breadths were about one-tenth of an inch each , see fig. , ( pl. IX .
) ; these are best seen by clear day light ; but it is also necessary to have a piece of black velvet under the lower slip , otherwise to have its under side painted black , Exp. 17 .
In endeavouring to see these fringes mentioned in the last article by candle light , I was disappointed , but accidentally perceived others of a different species , less in breadth , but much more numerous , and by which the whole length and breadth of the glass slips were covered .
These were visible by the light of a small candle only , nor could they be perceived except in the image of the blaze of the candle reflected from the upper surface of the upper slip of glass , and by moving either the eye , or the candle , or the slips across the direction in which the fringes appeared : and even with every precaution , I sometimes failed in seeing them , which I attributed to the presence of very minute dust between the glass plates , which in some cases can be known only by its effects .
Moreover , when the eye changes from a greater to a less quantity of light , it requires some time to adapt itself to such delicate and minute objects , before it can perceive them satisfactorily .
See fig. 8 .
( pl. IX .
) Exp. i8 .
By subsequent trials it was found , by the use of an oil lamp , having five or six small wicks in a row , composed of hempen packthread , which produced a pale brownish light , that those singular fringes could be seen with nearly as much ease and certainty as any of the other phenomena , though not all at once ; but , by moving the light over them , otherwise moving the slips with respect to the light , and by using a magnifying glass , it was ascertained that the specimen represented by fig. 8 , ( pi .
IX .
) contained thirty of these fringes to an inch .
Being uncertain whether they might not be the same as the primary fringes mentioned in Experiment 11 , or a continuation of them , I caused a few of these latter to be formed at one end of the slips at A , fig. 8 , ( pl. IX .
) when it was found that they crossed each other at a certain angle as shown in the figure ; therefore , they could not be the same .
Moreover , as they have no perceptible colour like first primaries , nor are divided into classes as binaries , they must be different from either .
Exp. ig9 .
It next occurred to try what effect could be produced by three slips of glass when laid together , and pressed by their own weight alone .
Leaving them in this situation about fifteen minutes , I found an irregular set of binaries spread over the surface of those slips ; a representation of which is shown in fig. 9 .
pi .
IX .
On drawing or sliding the upper piece of glass along the surface of the middle one , these fringes changed their shape , and disappeared as far as the middle slip was uncovered by the upper one ; or if the upper two were kept together , and both moved over the surface of the under slip , the same phenomena took place .
But if the upper glass was in the smallest degree separated from the other two , or if the two upper pieces were in the same degree separated from the lower one ; in either case , the spectra first changed their shapes and then vanished ; but , on leaving the slips to the pressure of their own weight , were again as instantly restored .
On changing the position of these three slips by placing the two upper ones across the lower one , a new spectrum was formed as seen in fig. to , pl. IX .
In these as well as in the following figures of binaries , the central band , dividing the two classes , is always denoted by a dotted line .
These spectra may be varied almost to infinity by the smallest change of distance or relative position of any one of the three slips to the other two ; and it affords a pleasing amusement to observe those fleeting forms start into new and fantastic shapes in such a manner as strongly to resemble , in miniature , the coruscations of the aurora borealis .
In order to determine whether these spectra were formed between the two upper , or between the two lower surfaces of the glass slips , the test of the shadow was applied , which determined them to be always formed between the two lower contiguous surfaces .
Exp. so .
But it appearing very unaccountable that the mere presence of the upper glass slip should produce spectra between the two lower , slips ; I wished to have the fact corroborated by another experiment .
For this purpose two similar slips of glass were so closely applied together , as to produce primary fringes between them ; and in this position they were cemented together with bees ' wax , to prevent .
shifting : this double slip being substituted , instead of the two upper unconnected slips in Experiment 12 , produced binaries as usual .
On application of the shadow , the primaries appeared in the second , and the binaries in the third shadow , as expected ; but it being perfectly certain that the primaries were formed between the two upper contiguous surfaces , and as the shadow proved that the thickness of one slip of glass was interposed between the two spectra , there could not remain a doubt of the binaries being formed between the two lower contiguous surfaces .
Exp. 1 , .
These results being so unexpected with three slips , it naturally occurred to me , to try what effect four would produce .
Having placed two , laid together horizontally on a table , I took up the double slip mentioned in Experiment 18 , in order to clear it of dust , and was in the act of holding it up between the light and the eye , in order to examine whether it was perfectly clean ; and it happening accidentally to be in , the direction of the two lying on the table , I was agreeably surprised to find a spectrum already appear , as if formed in the air , although the two pairs of slips were several inches asunder ; which spectrum , on moving the 178 double slip in the hand , out of the direction of those on the table , vanished as far as those on the table were uncovered by those in the hand .
And notwithstanding this spectrum appeared to be formed in the air , the test of the shadow proved it to be formed between:the ' two slips on the table ; and although it was visible when the two pairs of slips were not less than ten inches asunder , it could not be perceived except through the medium of the double slip held in the hand .
A representation of this experiment is shown in fig. 1i , pi .
IX .
where AB is a section of the two slips held in the hand ; and CD of those on the table .
Fig. 12 p. IX .
represents one of those fleeting and fantastic forms as seen by the eye at F in this experiment .
Exp. ?
2 .
If the result of the last experiment appears extraordinary and unaccountable , the present one will appear still more so ; for , on lowering the double slip in the hand from its former elevation of about 45 degrees , to about 15 degrees , so that its image was seen reflected from the upper surface of the upper glass on the table , as represented by GH in fig. i3 .
pl. IX .
, a new spectrum , fig. 14 , pl. IX .
was seen in this reflected image , superadded to that shown in fig. 12 , which was not to be perceived in the object AB itself !
Both spectra together , as seen by the eye at F , are represented in fig. 15 .
Exp. 23 .
It was fully ascertained by the test of the shadow , that while the double slips were in the position described in Experiment 2o , both spectra were formed between the two slips on the table ; but , on lowering the two upper slips until they , were laid flat on.those incumbent on the table , both Aa2 179 were gradually metamorphosed into two others ; one of which was formed between the two lower , and the other between the two middle slips brought into contact by this new arrangement ; this was also proved by the test of the shadow , It may be worthy of remark , that in every variety of shape assumed by these spectra , the binary characteristic is clearly visible in them all .
Exp 24 .
On viewing a set of Newtonian rings , as described in Experiment 4 , through one of the double slips , while in the position fig. 11 .
pl. IX , the apparatus forming the rings being on the table ; a set of narrow binary rings appeared , concentric to the primaries , and near to the edge of the lenses : and on lowering the double slip to the second position , fig. 13 .
pl. IX .
, another set of binary rings appeared in the reflected image of the double slip , also concentric to the primaries , but consisting of broader rings , though less in diameter than those of the first set ; and all these three sets were seen distinctly , at one and the same time .
The two sets of binary rings , seen in this experiment , correspond to the two irregular spectra in experiment 20 ; and since the rings must have been formed between the lenses on the table ( because no rings are ever formed unless between surfaces , one of which at least is spherical ) , this affords a corroborating proof , that the irregular spectra seen in Experiment.o , although apparently formed in the air , were really formed between the two slips of glass lying on the table .
The above results differ so widely from any that lave hitherto been published , that it is allowable to doubt , whether they can be accounted for on the common and received 18o If i , ; : : . ? ? ? ? ?
'c- ? . ?
- ?
ILW'I i. ?
;:j 'i ? ? ?
?-rr ?
; ?
: : ?
; ? ? ? ?
; :--i- ?
- .
; ?
: ?
IL ; ' : : : " ' : " ?
I a:t:lwl ?
r , F __ I_ __ I_III_____X ?
--.l--I -------. .
II ____ ] , byfI~:i ; ?s.raz !
r , rjK\Dc CCXVflatcVU',.i~ , yo\\~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I i~~~~~~~~~~~~I 77 !
ij 7~ ___________iI iziiz~~ I I ; ?:ij.iL .
: -------Lj .
i ?
J B:i:rr i : : : Xtj ; ile " : ?
-I .
S1.::x Sil : " ?
iiF.rire ; Lii : : : : 'I i sl : -i.i : : : . ?
:i s h : ' !
SPi iil : F':-:r:-- ?
C/ .
: CI:ijjl ' ; I:iiii : I ?
i ?
I/ ijA ii I : ?
I , IiI i ?
it:i_ ?
i. ?
' " Is ; ;"'I:1:11.-li:irel ?
;--i------- ?
TTI1 r4 ?
i !
i jjj ; 1 !
I ; 1 C ____ ?
_I___ -X 6- .
' ~f ?
c -BU -~ : . ?
:I , : R ?
i ; IYt ?
: R:S. .
: ii : : ?
i:::1 ; : : : : ?
t : : ?
: : : ? .
: ? ? ? ? . ? . ? .
: ?
: ? . ? ?
1 ?
: : : : ?
:j : : ?
- .
; .:t ? ? ? ? ?
: : : ?
: : ?
: ?
: .
: " ?
: ; : ?
iit : I : : : ?
: : : : : ii It , : : ?
: . ?
i ?
` : ?
'::i : : ?
;:I : tl : : ?
j ?
: ?
r : ?
:T : ?
;- ?
B ? ? ?
?- ?
?9 I W ; ;/ ; l I3 3 'I I s " " ^-~~`i-I-~~ ~ I~-----~1-2I / zilos .
TranJ .
IlMDCC CXV.'l IX.p.I 10 .
if , - , I III 7/ 6/ 4 D.7 / .
e/ ,.F , I. , I ?
II II i/ ~~~~~ ~ , w~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1 Ii I:t i i , iIIII II I principles of physical optics , unless perhaps the newly discovered prinlciple , which has been denominated the polarity of the rays of light , may serve to explain their causes .
However , " as every desideratum may be considered as an imperfect discovery , " which when completed may lead to others of still greater importance ; and as the subject is so far from being exhausted , that perhaps we are only entering on a new career of discoveries , not only in optics , but in every other branch of natural knowledge ; in this point of view , the prospect before us is rendered as extensive as it is animating and delightful .
JOHN KNOX .
Belfast , Oct. 6 , 1812 .
181

