cisely as a muscle of voluntary motion will by rest recover its excitability , although all its nerves are divided , if its circulation continues .
M. BICHAT ( Recherches Phys. sir la vieet la mort .
) has shown that in a frog the circulation continues in the capillaries after the heart no longer propels the blood .
Exp. 21 .
The foregoing experiment cannot be performed in the same way on warm-blooded animals , but it may be performed in a way equally satisfactory .
In two rabbits the brain was crushed by a blow .
In both the heart immediately beat with an extremely feeble and fluttering motion .
The anterior part of the brain only was crushed in another rabbit , with the same result .
A strong ligature was thrown round the neck of a fourth rabbit , and at the moment it was tightened , the head was cut off .
The bleeding was restrained by the ligature , except from the vessels defended by the bone .
General spasms made the body hard for the space of between one and two minutes , so that the beating of the heart could not be felt .
At the end of this time , the heart was felt through the side , both by Mr. Hastings and myself , beating regularly , and not more quickly than in health .
All the rabbits used in this experiment were of the same age .
Exp. ?
2 .
The following experiment is still more conclusive .
The anterior part of the brain of a rabbit was crushed by a blow .
The side was rendered hard by spasm for about half a minute .
Neither during this , nor after it , could I perceive any motion of the heart by applying the hand to the side .
The head was then cut off , about three quarters of a minute after the brain had been crushed .
No blood spouted out , and very little ran from the vessels .
A strong ligature was passed round the neck of another rabbit of the same age .
It was suddenly tightened , and the head cut off .
In this instance little spasm took place , and the heart was found beating regularly under the finger for about three quarters of a minute .
At the end of this time , the ligature was slackened , and the blood spouted out to the distance of three feet , and continued to spout out with great force , till nearly the whole blood was evacuated .
Exp. 23 .
From the strength of the spine of a rabbit , and the situation of the neighbouring parts , it is impossible to crush it , without directly influencing the state of the heart by the blow .
We opened it between the cervical and dorsal vertebrae , and suddenly forced a steel rod through the cervical part .
As in the experiments of M. LE GALLOIS , the action of the heart was immediately debilitated .
In the preceding experiments , the reader has seen , we repeatedly , slowly destroyed , or removed entirely , both the cervical and other portions of the spinal marrow , without at all influencing the action of the heart .
These experiments point out an easy solution of the difficulties mentioned by M. LE GALLOIS in the 1 igth and following pages of his Treatise .
When the whole spinal marrow was destroyed by small portions at a time , comparatively little effect was produced on the heart ; but when a considerable part of it was crushed at once , the power of the heart was so impaired , that circulation ceased .
So in other cases , where the injury was inflicted slowly , and where it was inflicted suddenly , the result was found to be different .
Thus he observes , that if the spinal marrow be divided near the occiput , and a certain part of it immediately destroyed , circulation ceases .
If some time intervene between the division and the destruction of precisely the same part , the circulation is not interrupted .
M. LE GALLOIs ' explanation of these facts cannot surely be admitted , and indeed is inconsistent with his own positions .
He found , that confining the circulation to a less extent , by throwing ligatures round the large vessels at some distance from the heart , enables this organ to support the circulation under circumstances where it would otherwise have failed .
Writers on midwifery have , on the same principle , recommended compressing the arteries of the limbs when the powers of the heart are much weakened by hemorrhagy .
From this experiment , compared with others , M. LE GALLOIS infers , that when the spinal marrow is destroyed by small portions , the circulation , in the parts corresponding to these portions , being impeded , the effect is similar to that produced by the ligatures .
Now , although it were ascertained that the circulation is impeded in any part by destroying the portion of the spinal marrow from which it is supplied with nerves , which I think may easily be shown not to be the case , this explanation would still be in opposition to M. LE GALLOIS ' fundamental position : Que la quantity , que le contingent de forces , que chaque " portion de moelle fournit a cet organ , egale pour le moins 6 celles dont il auroit strictement besoin pour entretenir la ( circulation dans les seules parties correspondantes a cette " portion .
" When the ligatures were thrown around the vessels , the heart was deprived of none of its supposed nervous influence .
When , on the contrary , portions of the spinal marrow were successively destroyed , as far as this is supposed to confine the circulation , it must also , according to M , LE 87 GALLOIS , occasion a loss of power in the heart .
He remarks that till the above explanation occurred to him , he had resolved to abandon this part of the inquiry .
" Apres bien des efforts inutiles pour porter la lumi &amp; re dans cette t6ndbreuse question , je pris le parti de l'abandonner , non sans " regret d'y avoir sacrifi6 un grand nombre d'animaux , et perdu beaucoup de temps .
" Just before , he observes , c " En un mot , j'eus presque autant de r6sultats diff6rens que d'ex ?
" pdriences .
' This may be easily accounted for , as he was not aware that the rapidity with which any portion of the spinal marrow is destroyed , influences the result .
We also see why the sudden destruction of one half of the spinal marrow , after it had been divided , not only brought death to that part of the animal to which it belonged , but to the other also ; a fact which seems in direct opposition to M. LE GALLOIS ' explanation of that we have just been considering .
In M. LE GALLOIS ' experiments , the spinal marrow was always crushed by a stilet , of precisely the same dimensions with the cavity of the spine .
In the foregoing experiments , the spinal marrow was either removed or destroyed by a comparatively small wire moved about in it till all its functions ceased .
The reader will easily understand , from what has been said , why this apparently slight circumstance occasions so essential a difference in the result of the experiments .
We have just seen the difference of the result when any portion of the spinal marrow is successively destroyed by parts , or crushed at once , and when the brain is crushed at once or wholly removed .
We have every reason to believe , from the experiments which have been related , that the peristaltic motion of the bowels obeys the same laws as the action of the heart .
It appears from those experiments , that this motion is wholly independent of the nervous system .
It continues till the parts become cold after the brain and spinal marrow are removed .
I have already mentioned the circumstances which prevented our positively ascertaining , whether it is influenced by stimuli applied to the brain and spinal marrow , ( Exp. 17 .
) but we know that the action of the bowels is frequently influenced by affections of the mind .
From the whole of the foregoing experiments and observations , it appears , i. That the muscles of involuntary motion obey the same laws with those of voluntary motion .
Exp. 1 , 2 3,4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 10 , 11 , 1 , 13 14,15 , 16 , and 17 , compared with Exp. 18 , and 19 ; see also observations under Exp. 19 .
e. That the apparent difference in the nature of these muscles , arises from their being under the influence of different stimuli ; see observations under Exp. 19 .
3That they are both capable of being stimulated through the nervous system .
Exp. 12 , 13 , 15 , i6 .
4 .
That the power of both is independnt of the nervous system .
Exp. 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 10 , 11 , 17 , 18 , and 19 .
5 .
That what is called the nervous system consists of two parts , whose existence is not immediately dependent on each other ; the one performing the sensorial functions , the other conveying impressions to and from the sensorium , and , without bestowing any power on the muscular system , acting as a stimulus to it .
See the observations under Exp. 9g .
See also Exp. 1 , , 34 , 5 , 6 , 7 8 , lo , 11 , 18 , 19 .
6 .
That there is therefore in the most perfect animals a combination of three distinct vital powers , not immediately depending on each other ; one of the muscular system , one of the nervous system properly so called , and one of the sensorial system .
See observations under Exp. 19 .
7 .
That the muscular system , though independent of the nervous system , is so influenced by it , that the power of the former may even be destroyed through the nervous system .
Exp. , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , lo , 1 , compared with Exp. 18 , so , and 23 .
8 .
That both the muscular and nervous systems , though independent of the sensorial system , are so influenced by it , that they may even be destroyed through it .
Exp. 8 , lo , ii , 17 , and two last paragraphs under Exp. 19 , compared with Exp. 20 , 2i , 22 .
g. That although in the less perfect animals we find the muscular life existing alone , and the muscular and nervous existing without the sensorial life ; in the more perfect animals they are so connected , that none can exist long without the others .
See the last paragraph under Exp. 19 .
lo .
That nutrition , circulation , and respiration , are the means by which they are so connected .
Worcester , August x6tb , 1814a VI .
Eeriens ae ith a vie to ascea the po VI .
Experiments made with a view to ascertain the principle on which the action of the heart depends , and the relation which subsists between that organ and the nervous system .
By A. P. Wilson Philip , Physician in Worcester .
Communicated by Andrew Knight , Esq. F. R. S. Read February 9 , 1815 .
TH E following experiments were begun with a view to ascertain the manner in which certain poisons act in destroying life .
I soon found that , in order to make any considerable progress in such an inquiry , it is necessary to ascertain how far the powers of the nervous and sanguiferous systems directly depend on each other .
There seems never to have been any difference of opinion respecting the direct dependence of the nervous on the sanguiferous system .
When the powers of circulation are increased or diminished , the nervous system always suffers a corresponding change , nor can the latter , under any circumstances , continue to perform its functions after the fornier are destroyed .
I speak of the warm blooded animals .
In cold blooded animals the process of dying is so slow , that the functions of the nervous system abate very gradually , after the circulation has wholly ceased .
The converse of the above proposition is by no means so generally admitted .
It is evident that certain changes of the nervous , produce corresponding changes in the sanguiferous , ,system ; yet , while some assert , that the action of the heart depends as immediately on the brain , as that of the latter does on the heart , others maintain , that the nervous power may be wholly destroyed without impairing the vigour of this organ .
This point it is necessary to determine , before we can trace with precision the modus operandi of poisons .
The following inquiry therefore may be divided into two parts .
In the first , I shall endeavour to ascertain how far the power of the heart is influenced by the state of the nervous system ; in the other , by what steps certain poisons destroy the powers of both .
This I shall reserve for another paper , and here confine myself to the first part of the subject .
Till the time of HALLER , it seems to have been the general opinion , that the muscles derive their power from the nervous system .
He taught , that the power of the muscies depends on their mechanism , that the nervous influence is merely a stimulus which calls it into action , and consequently that those muscles , the heart for example , which act only by the application of one peculiar stimulus , unconnected with the nervous system , are wholly independent of it .
This opinion seemed confirmed by its being generally admitted , that the action of the heart continues after it is removed from the body , and that it cannot be influenced by stimulating the brain , or spinal marrow , or the nerves which terminate in it .
HALLER and his followers maintain , that there are two distinct vital powers , one of the nervous and another of the sanguiferous system .
The supporters of HALLER'S doctrine however , found many difficulties to contend with .
The evident objections to it are , that the heart is influenced by affections of the mind , and that it is supplied with nerves .
Various hypotheses have been framed to get rid of these objections , some of which imply a considerable modification of the original opinion .
Several writers have maintained , that although the heart is independent of the brain and spinal marrow , it may be subject to some peculiar action of its own nerves ; others , that the ganglia through which its nerves pass have a power independent of the sensorium commune .
FONTANA and others have maintained , that the nerves of the heart are absolutely useless ; others , that these nerves are distributed on its vessels , and do not enter the substance of the heart .
SCARPA , however , has proved , that nerves are distributed to the heart in the same way as to other similar parts .
Nothing can show more strikingly the imperfection of our knowledge of this important branch of physiology , than that opinions so different , and so destitute of proof , should be maintained by the best writers upon it .
An author has lately appeared , who , among other ingenious and important experiments , has made many relating to this subject , and arrived at conclusions which have surprised physiologists , yet apparently so well supported as to have obtained their general assent .
M. LE GALLOIS* maintains , that by the destruction of the whole or cervical part of the spinal marrow , the action of the heart is immediately so debilitated , that it is no longer capable of supporting the circulation ; while by the destruction of the brain , on the contrary , its action is unimpaired : from which he infers , that it is from the spinal marrow that the heart derives the principle of its life and of its motions .
Those motions of the heart , says M. LE GALLOIS , which remain after the destruction of the spinal marrow , or the interruption of the nervous influence upon the heart in any other way , and which misled HALLER and his followers , are motions without force , incapable of supporting the circulation , and analogous to the motions of other irritable parts on the application of a stimulus , which in this case is the arterial blood contained in it .
The experiments , on which these opinions are founded , he repeated in the presence of a Committee of the National Institute at Paris , which has expressed its conviction of their accuracy .
Notwithstanding this high authority , I was led , from some experiments which I made many years ago , in which both the brain and spinal marrow were destroyed by the action of opium and tobacco , to doubt M. LE GALLOIS ' conclusions .
The reader will judge how far the following experiments tend to invalidate these conclusions , and influence our opinions of the subject to which they relate .
I cannot here omit to express my thanks to Mr. HASTINGS , House-surgeon to the Worcester Infirmary , who assisted me in the following experiments .
His expertness in dissection was often of great use , where it was necessary to be expeditious , and to lose as little blood as possible .
Exp. i. A rabbit was deprived of sensation and voluntary power by a stroke on the occiput .
When the rabbit is killed in this way , the respiration immediately ceases ; but the action of the heart and the circulation continue , and may be supported for a considerable length of time by artificial respiration , as practised first , I believe , by FONTANA , and since by CHIRAC , Mr. BRODIE , M. LE GALLOIS , and others .
This mode of destroying the sensibility does not influence the result of the experiment , and has the double advantage of preventing the animal 's sufferings , and his motions .
Its greatest inconvenience is , that if the blow is very severe , considerable vessels are sometimes ruptured , and there is always some rupture of vessels , which of course tends to impair the vigour of the circulation .
In the present experiment , the circulation was supported by artificial respiration .
The spinal marrow was laid bare from the occiput to the beginning of the dorsal vertebrae , The chest was then opened , and the heart found beating regularly , and with considerable force .
The spinal marrow , as far as it had been laid bare , was now wholly removed , but without in the least affecting the action of the heart .
After this , the artificial respiration being frequently discontinued , we repeatedly saw the action of the heart become languid , and increase on renewing it .
The skull was then opened , and the whole of the brain removed , so that no part of the nervous system remained above the dorsal vertebre , but without any abatement of the action of the heart , which still continued to be more or less powerful , according as we discontinued or renewed artificial respiration .
This being for a considerable time discontinued , the ventricles ceased to beat about half an hour after the removal of the brain .
On renewing the respiration , however , the action of the ventricles was restored .
The respiration was again discontinued and renewed , with the same effects .
Exp. 9 .
A rabbit was made insensible by removing part of the skull , and applying opium to the brain .
The spine was then opened between the cervical and dorsal vertebrae .
We then laid open the thorax , and supported the action of the heart by artificial respiration .
The force with which it beat was carefully observed , and the spinal marrow destroyed by running a hot wire up and down the spine , through the opening made in it , by which the action of the heart was not at all affected .
Exp. $ .
In the foregoing experiments , it may be said , there was no direct proof of the continuance of the circulation after the spinal marrow was destroyed or removed .
On this account several of the following experiments were made .
A rabbit , previously exhausted by dividing the eighth pair of nerves , was deprived of sensation by a blow on the occiput , and the circulation supported by artificial breathing .
The carotids were seen beating near to the place where the nerves had been divided .
The cervical part of the spinal marrow was then destroyed by a hot wire , after which the carotids were still found beating .
Exp. 4 .
In a rabbit rendered insensible by a blow on the occiput , the whole spinal marrow was destroyed by a hot wire , and the breathing artificially supported .
One of the carotid arteries was then laid bare .
Its beating was evident , and on dividing it , florid blood flowed from it freely .
Exp. ; .
The only difference between this and the last experiment was , that artificial breathing was not performed .
In both , the spinal marrow was destroyed , by introducing a wire hot enough to make a hissing noise through an opening between the cervical and dorsal vertebre , first through the upper portion into the brain , then through the under portion to the end of the spine .
On laying open one side of the neck , the carotid artery was found beating .
On dividing it , blood of a much darker colour than in the former experiment was thrown out copiously per saltumn .
Exp. 6 .
A rabbit was rendered insensible by a blow on the occiput , and artificial respiration maintained .
The spinal marrow from the base of the skull to the beginning of the dorsal vertebrae was removed , and a hot wire forced through the remaining part of the spine .
The carotid artery was then found beating , and on dividing it florid blood rushed out with great force per saltum .
Exp. 7 .
This experiment resembled the last , except that the spinal marrow , instead of being partly removed , was wholly destroyed by a hot wire , and artificial breathing was not performed previous to opening the carotid , from which dark coloured blood flowed per saltum .
We then inflated the lungs , and arterial blood soon began to flow copiously from the vessel , and appeared like a florid stream mixing with the dark coloured blood which had previously come from it .
This experiment was repeated in the same manner , and with the same result .
Exp. 8 .
In this experiment the rabbit was rendered insensible , but not motionless , by the blow on the occiput , so that the breathing still continued .
The spine was opened , and the spinal marrow destroyed , as in the preceding experiment .
The wire was used very hot .
On introducing it through the spine into the brain , the breathing immediately ceased .
The femoral artery was laid bare about two or three minutes after respiration had ceased .
The beating of the artery was evident .
On opening it , a dark coloured blood flowed from it freely .
We now had recourse to artificial respiration .
When 71 it had been continued for about half a minute , the blood , which continued to flow copiously from the artery , became of a highly florid colour .
The other fernoral artery was then opened , from which florid blood also flowed freely .
When about an ounce of blood had flowed from the two vessels , the inflation of the lungs was discontinued , and the blood again flowed of a dark colour .
On renewing the inflation of the lungs , the blood , in less than half a minute , again became of a florid colour .
It continued to flow from the femoral arteries altogether for seven minutes .
Three minutes after the blood had ceased to flow from them , the artificial respiration being continued , one of the carotid arteries was opened , from which a florid blood flowed in a free stream , to the amount of a dram and a half .
The flow from the carotid artery ceased in eleven minutes after the femoral artery had been opened .
Most of the blood was now of course evacuated .
A good deal had been lost in opening the spine , which always happens .
The left auricle and ventricle were found nearly empty .
The blood which remained in them was florid .
The right auricle and ventricle were full of dark blood .
Exp. 9 .
From various trials , we found that in such experiments the circulation ceases quite as soon without , as with the destruction of the spinal marrow .
Loss of blood seems to be the chief cause which destroys it .
When the animal was operated upon , without being rendered insensible , pain also contributed to this effect .
We frequently , after laying open the skull and spine , found the circulation lost before either the brain or spinal marrow had been disturbed .
In the younger rabbit , it was lost sooner than in the older .
The formuer seemed to die sooner from any injury , except the interruption of respiration .
The circulation is particularly apt to fail , if artificial respiration is not carefully performed after the animal ceases to breathe .
In making such experiments , after opening the bone , it is always necessary to ascertain whether the circulation continues , before we destroy or remove the brain or spinal marrow .
As little blood is lost in this part of the operation , when the carotid arteries were beating before , we always found them beating after it .
The result of this experiment is still more striking in the cold blooded animals , in which death takes place so slowly , that the circulation continues long after the total destruction of the nervous system .
Exp. lo .
The brain of a frog and the spinal marrow as low as the dorsal vertebra were laid bare .
The thorax was then opened , and the heart found acting vigorously ; and from the transparency of its sides , the passage of the blood through it distinctly seen .
The part of the spinal marrow , which had been laid bare , was then removed , but without at all affecting either the motion of the heart , or the passage of the blood through it .
The brain was then removed , with the same result .
Exp. 11 .
The brain and spinal marrow of a frog were wholly removed .
On opening the thorax , the heart was found performing the circulation freely .
I have already had occasion to observe , that it is generally admitted that the action of the heart cannot be influenced by stimuli applied to the nervous system : and it seems almiot a contradiction to suppose that it should , when we see that it cannot be influenced by the total destruction .
of this system .
There were many reasons , however , which induced me to try MPrcccxv .
L 73 the effect on the heart of stimuli so applied to the brain and spinal marrow , as not to excite any of the muscles of voluntary motion , whose action , either by throwing more blood towards the heart , or in some other way influencing its action , prevents our judging of the effect of the stimulus .
Exp. 1 .
A rabbit was deprived of sensation and voluntary motion by a blow on the occiput , the action of the heart supported by artificial respiration , and the brain and cervical part of the spinal marrow laid bare .
The thorax was now opened , and the action of the heart , which beat with strength and regularity , observed .
Spirit of wine was then applied to the spinal marrow , and a greatly increased action of the heart was the consequence .
It was afterwards applied to the brain with the same effect .
The increase of motion was immediate and decided in both cases .
We could not perceive that it was more in the one case than the other .
Exp. 13 .
The foregoing experiment was repeated , with the difference , that the whole of the espinal marrow was laid bare .
The motion of the heart was nearly , if not quite , as much influenced by the application of the stimulus to the dorsal , as to the cervical portion of the spinal marrow ; but it was very little influenced by its application to the lumbar portion .
Exp. 1 .
In this experiment , only that part of the brain which occupies the anterior part of the head was laid bare .
The rabbit in other respects was prepared in the same way as in the preceding experiments .
The spirit of wine applied to this part of the brain , produced as decided an effect on the motion of the heart as in those experiments .
The spirit of wine was washed off , and a watery solution , first of opium , then of tobacco , applied , with the effect of an increase , but a much less increase of the heart 's action than arose from the spirit of wine .
The increased action was greater from the opium , than from the tobacco .
The first effect of both was soon succeeded by a more languid action of the heart than that which preceded their application to the brain .
This effect was greatest , and came on soonest when the tobacco was used , and we always , for we frequently repeated the experiment , saw an evident increase in the action of the heart , when we washed off the tobacco .
We could also perceive this , though in a less degree , when the opium was washed off .
Little or none of this debilitating effect was observed when the spirit of wine was used .
After its stimulating effect had subsided , the action of the heart only returned to about the same degree as before the application of the stimulus .
Exp. 15 .
The foregoing experiment was repeated on an animal of cold blood .
Mr. HASTINGS had found , that immersing the hind legs of a frog in tincture of opium , in less than a minute , deprives it of sensibility .
This does not arise from any action of the opium ; a watery solution of opium , we found , however strong , does not produce the effect .
It is immediately produced by simple spirit of wine , and arises from the action of the spirit on the nerves of the part to which it is applied , for it takes place quite as readily as in the healthy frog , after a ligature has been thrown round all the vessels attached to the heart .
It is remarkable , that if simple spirit of wine is used , the animal expresses severe pain , if tincture of opium , very little .
I have already mentioned the reason why it is necessary , in order to judge of the result of this experiment , that the animal should be rendered insensible .
( Exp. i. ) Having thus deprived a frog of sensibility , we laid bare the L e brain and spinal marrow , and opened the chest .
The heart was found contracting with vigour .
Spirit of wine was then applied to the spinal marrow , with an immediate and evident increase of the action of the heart .
It was then applied to the brain with the same effect .
Watery solutions of opium and tobacco were also applied to both , with precisely the same effect as in the rabbit .
The increase of action from the opium and tobacco was much less than from the spirit of wine , and was soon followed by a great diminution of action .
The increase of action was least , and the diminution greatest from tobacco .
On washing off the opium and tobacco with a wet sponge , the heart immediately beat more strongly .
The different parts of this experiment were frequently repeated with the same result .
It is remarkable that we could affect the motion of the heart by stimuli applied to the brain and spinal marrow , after they had ceased to produce any effect on the muscles of voluntary motion through the medium of the nervous system .
Exp. 16 .
This experiment only differed from the last in the cervical part of the spinal marrow and lower part of the brain being removed , and the stimuli applied only to that part of the brain which lies between the eyes of the frog .
Spirit of wine , opium , and tobacco , thus applied , affected the motion of the heart quite as much , and precisely in the same way , as when they were applied to the entire brain and spinal marrow .
When opium and tobacco were applied to the lower part of the spinal marrow , the motion of the heart appeared to be hardly at all affected by them .
It was evidently increased when spirit of wine was applied to the same part .
We found in the foregoing experiments , that considerable pressure , either on ihe brain or spinal marrow , produced little or no effect on the action of the heart .
Its action could be influenced by stimuli applied to the brain and spinal marrow long after the circulation had ceased .
The peristaltic motion of the intestines , as far as we could judge from the following experiments , obeys the same laws as the action of the heart .
Exp. 17 .
A rabbit was deprived of sensibility by a blow on the occiput .
The whole of the spinal marrow was then destroyed by a hot wire .
On opening the abdomen , we found the peristaltic motion of the stomach and small and great intestines quite as strong as when the nervous system is entire , as we ascertained by exposing the abdominal viscera of other rabbits .
In another experiment , the spinal marrow was wholly removed , without at all affecting this motion .
The removal of the brain , we found , produces as little effect upon it , as that of the spinal marrow .
When both were removed at the same time , it remained unaffected .
It continues till the intestines become cold , so that when the portions exposed to the air have lost their power , the motion of the parts beneath still remains .
We endeavoured to ascertain how far this motion is influenced by stimuli applied to the brain and spinal marrow , but from its nature it is in every way so irregular , that no certain result can be obtained .
It often appeared to us , that spirit of wine applied to the brain and spinal marrow increased it .
The admission of air into the cavity of the abdomen throws the bowels into strong spasmodic action , which aione would obscure any effect that can be supposed to arise from stimulating the brain .
To remove this cause offailure , the abdomen 77 was opened under tepid water ; but this was found to excite even stronger spasms than the air had done .
What are the simple results of the foregoing experiments ?
The first set prove , that the power of the heart is independent of the brain and spinal marrow , for we find that it continues to perform its function after they are destroyed or removed , and that their removal is not attended with any immediate effect on its motions .
The second set prove , that the action of the heart may be influenced by agents applied to any considerable portion either of the brain or spinal marrow .
Itis as readily influenced by agents applied to the anterior part of the brain , as by those applied to the cervical part of the spinal marrow .
This is what we should expect when we trace the various origins of its nerves .
If it be said that the results of these experiments imply a contradiction , that we cannot suppose the power of the heart to be wholly independent of the brain and spinal marrow , and yet influenced by stimuli applied to them , the reply is , that such are the facts , of the truth of which any one may easily satisfy himself .
Daily occurrences correspond with these facts .
We rarely see the action of the heart destroyed by injuries of the brain and spinal marrow , unless they are such as interrupt respiration ; yet its action is constantly influenced by affections of the mind .
On a closer examination of the phenomena of the nervous system , we shall find other similar difficulties .
The experiments of M. LE GALLOIS prove , in the most satisfactory manner , that a principal function of the spinal marrow is to excite the muscles of voluntary motion , and that it can perform this office independently of the brain .
It performs it after the brain is wholly removed , and its powers seem not at all immediately impaired by the removal of the brain ; yet we , constantly see injuries of the brain impairing the functions of the spinal marrow .
We may wholly remove the brain , and the animal performs the various motions of its limbs as well as before its removal .
Yet an injury of the brain often produces complete haemiplegia , nay often instantly destroys every function of the system .
Of this apparent inconsistency , M. LE GALLOIS justly remarks , that two facts well ascertained , however inconsistent they may seem , do not overturn each other , but only prove the imperfection of our knowledge .
Whichever of the disputed opinions respecting the functions of the nervous system we adopt , the foregoing phenomena seem to imply a contradiction ; for an explanation of them , therefore , we must recur to principles different from those hitherto assumed .
The following experiments point out still another instance of this apparent contradiction , and seem to suggest the principle on which the whole depends .
Exp. 18 .
By applying strong stimuli to the spinal marrow of a frog , strong and repeated contractions were excited in the muscles of the hind limbs , as long as the stimuli would produce the effect .
On examining the state of the muscles of these limbs , I found them wholly deprived of their excitability .
Now it is well known , that although all the nerves supplying the limbs of a frog be divided , and cut out close to the place where they enter the muscles , the latter still retain their excitability , which appears to be not at all less than while the nerves are entire .
Lest it may be supposed that the nervous intluence , which was exhausted in this experiment by stimulating the spinal marrow , still remains in 79 the muscles after the nerves are divided , and thus preserves their excitability , the following experiment was made .
Exp. 19 .
All the nerves supplying one of the hind limbs of a frog were divided , so that it became completely paralytic .
The skin was removed from the muscles of the leg , and salt sprinkled upon them , which , being renewed from time to time , excited contractions in them for twelve minutes ; at the end of this time they were found no farther capable of being excited .
The corresponding muscles of the other limb , in which the nerves were entire , and of which consequently the animal had a perfect command , were then laid bare , and the salt applied to them in the same way .
In ten minutes they ceased to produce any contractions , and the animal had lost the command of them .
The nerves of this limb were now divided , as those of the other had been , but the excitability of the muscles to which the salt had been applied was gone .
Its application excited no contraction in them .
It sometimes happens , while the nerves of the limb are entire , that the voluntary efforts of the animal prevent the contractions usually excited by the application of salt .
This experiment was repeated in the same manner , and with a similar result .
After the experiment , the muscles of the thighs in both limbs were found to contract forcibly on the application of salt .
It excited equally strong contractions on both sides .
It is remarkable , that in this experiment , the excitability of the muscles whose nerves were entire , was soonest exhausted .
In the repetition of the experiment , this was the case to a still greater degree , the muscles , whose nerves were entire , losing their excitability in about one half of the time required for exhausting the other .
8o From this experiment it is evident , that the nervous influence , so far from having a power of preserving the excitability of the muscles , exhausts it like other stimuli .
The excitability therefore is a property of the muscle itself .
Yet we have just seen , that it may be wholly destroyed by changes induced on the nervous system .
On the same principle we explain the seeming contradiction respecting the action of the heart .
We have seen that its power exists as independently of the brain and spinal marrow , as the action of the first muscles to which the salt was applied , whose nerves had been divided ; but , while the brain and spinal marrow retain their functions , and the connection of nerves is entire , the heart , as well as the muscles of voluntary motion , may be influenced by agents acting through the nervous system .
It is not difficult to account for the latter being more copiously supplied with nerves than the heart , because all the stimuli which affect them , act through their nerves , while the heart is only now and then influenced through its nerves , its usual stimulus being as immediately applied to it , as the salt was to the muscles of the limb in the above experiment , and acting as independently of the nervous system .
We do not surely in all this see any difference in the nature of the muscular power of the heart , and that of the muscles of voluntary motion , except their being fitted to obey different stimuli , a difference which we find in the two sides of the heart itself .
It may here be objected , that in apoplexy the power of the muscles of voluntary motion is lost , while that of the heart is little or not at all impaired .
Were such the fact , this objection would be unanswerable ; but I have repeatedly examined the state of the muscles of voluntary motion in apoplexy , MDcccxv .
M both in the warm and cold blooded any ; nals , and found their excitability unimpaired .
It is not their power , but the stimulus which excites them , that is lost in apoplexy .
In this disease , the heart continues to contract , because its stimulus is still supplied ; the muscles of voluntary motion cease to contract , because their stimulus is withdrawn .
By the foregoing experiments we arrive at the conclusion of HALLER , that the heart and other muscles possess an excitability independent of the nervous system ; but we are carried a step farther , and taught that they are all equally capable of being stimulated through this system , by which the great objections to HALLER'S doctrine are removed .
We may , I think , trace the subject still farther .
It has been shown by direct experiment by M. LE GALLOIS , that the spinal marrow is capable of performing its functions independently of the brain , yet , as has just been observed , the spinal marrow may be influenced through the brain .
Thus the excitability of the spinal marrow bears the same relation to the brain , which that of the muscles bears to the spinal marrow and its nerves , and I would add all nerves distributed to muscles , some of which arise from the brain , but seem to bear precisely the same relation to the sensorium with those which arise from the spinal marrow .
Even M. LE GALLOIS , although his experiments lead to an opposite conclusion , observes , that the brain seems to act on the spinal marrow as the latter does on the parts it animates .
We know the peculiar office of the brain , by observing what functions are lost by its removal , the sensorial functions .
The nervous , then , obeys the sensorial system , in the same way in which the muscular obeys the nervous system , but as the muscular system has an existence independent of the nervous , so has the nervous , independent of the sensorial system .
What is here said is finely illustrated by reviewing the various classes of animals .
In the lowest class we find only the muscular system , which exists without either nervous system or sensorium .
In the next class we find the muscular and nervous systems , which exist without sensorium .
In the most perfect animals , we find the three vital powers combined , each having an existence not immediately depending on the others , but all so connected , that none can exist long without the others .
The nature of this connectio'n is obvious , when we consider that all are supported by the circulation , which depends for its immediate support on the muscular system , and cannot long exist without respiration , and that this depends not on the sensorium , but , as M. IE GALLOIS has satisfactorily proved , on the nervous system , which system is under the immediate influence of the sensorium , directing , but not producing , its various movements ; and such is the power of the sensorium over the nervous system , that its affections may , through this system , at once destroy every function of life .
Thus joy and other strong passions have killed more speedily than suffocation can , and therefore otherwise than through the destruction of respiration .
Exp. o2 .
All that has been said of the vital power of the heart is strikingly confirmed by the following experiments .
If the head and spine of a frog be removed , the heart continues to perform its function perfectly for many hours , nor does it seem at all immediately affected by their removal .
But we find the effect very different when the most sudden and powerful agent is applied to them .
If they are destroyed by being cut M X to pieces , or even by a hot wire , the heart after their destruction beats just as before it .
But if either the brain or spinal marrow be instantly crushed , the heart immediately feels the shock .
The thorax of a large frog was laid open , and the motion of the heart observed , which performed the circulation perfectly , and with great force .
The brain was then crushed by the blow of a hammer .
The heart immediately performed a few quick and weak contractions .
It then lay quite still for about half a minute .
After this , its beating returned , but it supported the circulation very imperfectly .
In ten minutes its vigour was.so far restored that it again performed the circulation with freedom , but with less force than before the destruction of the brain .
An instrument was then introduced under the heart , and after ascertaining that this had produced no change on its action , the spinal marrow was crushed by one blow , as the brain had been .
The heart again beat quickly and feebly for a few seconds , and then seemed wholly to have lost its power .
In about half a minute it again began to beat , and in a few minutes acquired considerable power , and again supported the circulation .
It beat more feebly , however , than before the spinal marrow was destroyed .
It ceased to beat in about an hour and a half after the brain had been destroyed .
In another frog , after the brain and spinal marrow had been wholly removed , the heart beat nine hours , gradually becoming more languid .
In this experiment we see that the heart not only retains its power long after the brain and spinal marrow are removed , but that if they are destroyed in such a way as to impair and almost destroy the action of the heart , it can recover the power of performing .
its function , after they no longer exist ; pre- ,

