V. On uer-acid and Sub-acid Salts .
By William Hyde Wollaston , M. D. Sec. R. S. Read January 28 , i8o8 .
N : the paper which has just been read to the Society , Dr. THOMSON has remarked , that oxalic acid unites to strontian as well as to potash in two different proportions , and that the quantity of acid combined with each of these bases in their super-oxalates , is just double of that which is saturated by the same quantity of base in their neutral compounds , As I had observed the same law to prevail in various other instances of super-acid and sub-acid salts , I thought it not unlikely that this law might obtain generally in such compounds , and it was my design to have pursued the subject with the hope of discovering the cause to which so regular a relation might be ascribed .
-But since the publication of Mr. DALTON'S theory of chemical combination , as explained and illustrated by Dr. THOMSON , '* the inquiry which I had designed appears to be superfluous , as all the facts that I had observed are but particular instances of the more general observation of Mr. DALTON , that in all cases the simple elements of bodies are disposed to unite atom to atom singly , or , if either is in excess , it exceeds by a ratio to be expressed by some simple multiple of the number of its atoms .
However , since those who are desirous of ascertaining the justness of this observation by experiment , may be deterred by the difficulties that we meet with in attempting to determine with precision the constitution of gaseous bodies , for the explanation of which Mr. DALTON'S theory was first conceived , and since some persons may imagine that the results of former experiments on such bodies do not accord sufficiently to authorize the adoption of a new hypothesis , it may be worth while to describe a few experiments , each of which may be performed with the utmost facility , and each of which affords the most direct proof of the proportional redundance " or deficiency of acid in the several salts employed .
Sub-carbonate of Potash .
Exp. 1 .
Sub-carbonate of potash recently prepared , is one instance of an alkali having one-half the quantity of acid necessary for its saturation , as may thus be satisfactorily proved .
Let two grains of fully saturated and well crystallized carbonate of potash be wrapped in a piece of thin paper , and passed up into an inverted tube filled with mercury , and let the gas be extricated from it by a sufficient quantity of muriatic acid , so that the space it occupies may be marked upon the tube .
Next , let four grains of the same carbonate be exposed for a short time to a red heat ; and it will be found to have parted with exactly half its gas ; for the gas extricated from it in the same apparatus will be found to occupy exactly the same space , as the quantity before obtained from two grains of fully saturated carbonate .
MDGCCVIti .
0 Sub-carbonate of Soda..xp .
2 .
A similar experiment maybe made with a saturated carbonate of soda , and with the same result ; for this also becomes a true semi-carbonate by being exposed for a short time to a red heat .
Super-sulphate of Potash .
By an experiment equally simple , super-sulphate of potash may be shown to contain exactly twice as much acid as is necessary for the mere saturation of the alkali present .
Exp. S. Let twenty grains of carbonate of potash ( which would be more than neutralized by ten grains of sulphuric acid ) be mixed with about twenty-five grains of that acid in a covered crucible of platina , or in a glass tube three quarters of an inch diameter , and five or six inches long .
By heating this mixture till it ceases to boil , and begins to appear slightly red hot , a part of the redundant acid will be expelled , and there will remain a determinate quantity forming super-sulphate of potash , which when dissolved in water will be very nearly neutralized by an addition of twenty grains more of the same carbonate of potash ; but it is generally found very slightly acid , in consequence of the small quantity of sulphuric acid which remains in the vessel in a gaseous state at a red heat .
In the preceding experiments , the acids are made to assume a determinate proportion to their base , by heat which cannot destroy them .
In those which follow , the proportion which a destructible acid shall assume cannot be regulated by the same means ; but the constitution of its compounds previously formed , may nevertheless be proved with equal facility .
98 Super-oxalate of Potash .
Exp. 4 .
The common super-oxalate of potash is a salt that contains alkali sufficient to saturate exactly half of the acid present .
Hence , if two equal quantities of salt of sorrel be taken , and if one of them be exposed to a red heat , the alkali which remains will be found exactly to saturate the redundant acid of the other portion .
In addition to the preceding compounds , selected as distinct examples of binacid salts , I have observed one remarkable instance of a more extended and general prevalence of the law under consideration ; for when the circumstances are such as to admit the union of a further quantity of oxalic acid with potash , I found a proportion , though different , yet analogous to the former , regularly to occur . ? .
Quadroxalate of Potash .
In attempting to decompose the preceding super-oxalate by means of acids , it appeared that nitric or muriatic acids , are capable of taking only half the alkali , and that the salt which crystallizes after solution in either of these acids , has accordingly exactly four times as much acid as would saturate the alkali that remails .
Exp. 5 .
For the purpose of proving that the constitution of this compound has been rightly ascertained , the salt thus formed should be purified by a second crystallization in distilled water ; after which the alkali of thirty grains must be obtained by exposure to a red heat , in order to neutralize the redundant acid contained in ten grains of the same salt .
The quantity of unburned salt contains alkali for one part out of 0 2 four of the acid present , and it requires the alkali of three equal quantities of the same salt to saturate the three remaining parts of acid .
The limit to the decomposition of super-oxalate of potash by the above acids , is analogous to that which occurs when sulphate of potash is decomposed by nitric acid ; for in this case also , no quantity of that acid can take more than half the potash , and the remaining salt is converted into a definite super-sulphate , similar to that obtained by heat in the third experiment .
It is not improbable that many other changes in chemistry , supposed to be influenced by a general redundance of some one ingredient , may in fact be limited by a new order of affinities taking place at some definite proportion to be expressed by a simple multiple .
And though the strong power of crystallizing in oxalic acid , renders the modifications of which its combinations are susceptible more distinct than those of other acids , it seems probable that a similar play of affinities will arise in solution , when other acids exceed their base in the same proportion .
In order to determine whether oxalic acid is capable of uniting to potash in a proportion intermediate between the double and quadruple quantity of acid , I neutralized fortyeight grains of carbonate of potash with thirty grains of oxalic acid , and added sixty grains more of acid , so that I had two parts of potash of twenty-four grains each , and six equivalent quantities of oxalic acid of fifteen grains each , in solution , ready to crystallize together , if disposed to unite , in the proportion of three to one ; but the first portion of salt that crystallized , was the common binoxalate , or salt of sorrel , and a 100 portion selected from the after crystals ( which diffterd very discernibly in their form ) was found to contain the quadruple proportion of acid .
Hence it is to be presumed , : that if:these salts could have been perfectly separated,.it would ; hae been found , that the two quantities of potash were equally divided , and combined in one instance with two , and in the other with the remaining four out of the six equivalent quantities of acid taken .
To account for this want of disposition to unite in the proportion of three to one by Mr. DALTON'S theory , I apprehend he might consider the neutral salt as consisting of 2 particles potash with i acid , The binoxalate as i and i , or 2 with 2 , The quadroxalate as 1 and 2 , or 2 with 4 , in which cases the ratios which I have observed of the acids to each other in these salts would respectively obtain .
But an explanation , which admits the supposition of a double share of potash in the neutral salt , is not altogether satisfactoryv ; and I am further inclined to think , that when our views are sufficiently extended , to enable us to reason with precision concerning the proportions of elementary atoms , we shall find the arithmetical relation alone will not be sufficient to explain their mutual action , and that we shall be obliged to acquire a geometrical conception of their relative arrangement in all the three dimensions of solid extension .
For instance , if we suppose the limit to the approach of particles to be the same in all directions , and hence their virtual extent to be spherical ( which is the most simple hypothesis ) ; in this case , when different sorts combine singly there is but one mode of union .
If they unite in the proportion of 0Q1 two to one , the two particles will naturally arrange themselves at opposite poles of that to which they unite .
If there be three , they might be arranged with regularity , at the angles of an equilateral triangle in a great circle surrounding the single spherule ; but in this arrangement , for want of similar matter at the poles of this circle , the equilibrium would be unstable , and would be liable to be deranged by the slightest force of adjacent combinations ; but when the number of one set of particles exceeds in the proportion of four to one , then , on the contrary , a stable equilibrium may again take place , if the four particles are situated at the angles of the four equilateral triangles composing a regular tetrahedron .
But as this geometrical arrangement of the primary elements of matter is altogether conjectural , and must rely for its confirmation or rejection upon future inquiry , I am desirous that it should not be confounded with the results of the facts and observations related above , which are sufficiently distinct and satisfactory with respect to the existence of the law of simple multiples .
It is perhaps too much to hope , that the geometrical arrangement of primary particles will ever be perfectly known ; since even admitting that a very small number of these atoms combining together would have a tendency to arrange themselves in the manner I have imagined ; yet , until it is ascertained how small a proportion the primary particles themselves bear to the interval between them , it may be supposed that surrounding combinations , although themselves analogous , might disturb that arrangement , and in that case , the effect of such interference must also be taken into the account , before any theory of chemical combination can be rendered complete .

