XIII .
On an Improvement in the Manner of dividing astronomical Instruments .
By Henry Cavendish , Esq. F. R. S. Read May i8 , 1809o T HE great inconvenience and difficulty in the common method of dividing , arises from the danger of bruising the divisions by putting the point of the compass into them , and from the difficulty of placing that point mid-way , between two scratches very near together , without its slipping towards one of them , and it is this imperfection in the common process , which appears to have deterred Mr. TROUGHTON from using it , and thereby gave rise to the ingenious method of dividing described in the preceding part of this volume .
This induced me to consider , whether the abovementioned inconvenience might not be removed , by using a beam compass with only one point , and a microscope instead of the other ; and I find , that in the following manner of proceeding , we have no need of ever setting the point of the compass into a division , and consequently that the great objection to the old method of dividing is entirely removed .
In this method , it is necessary to have a convenient support for the beam compass : and the following seems to me to be as convenient as any .
Let CC C ( Fig. i. ) be the circle to be divided , BBBa frame resting steadily on its face , and made to slide round on it with an adjusting motion to bring it to any required point : dS is the beam compass , having a point near S , and a microscope m made to slide from one end to the other , This beam compass is supported at d , in such manner as to turn round on tXis ponmt as a centre , without shake or tottering ; and at the end a it rests on another support , which can readily be lowered , so as either to let the point rest on the circle , or to prevent its touching it .
It must be observed , however , that as the distance of d from the center of the circle must be varied , according to the magnitude of the arch to be divided , the piece on which d is supported had best be made to slide nearer to , or further from , the center ; but the frame must be made to bear constantly against the edge of the circle to be divided , so that the distance of d from the center of this circle , shall not alter by sliding the frame .
This being premised , we will first consider the manner of dividing by continued bisection .
Let F andJ be two points on this limb which are to be bisected in cp .
Take the distance of the microscope from the point nearly equal to the chord offp , and place d so that the point and the axis of the microscope shall both be in the circle in which the divisions are to be cut , Then slide the frame BBB till the wire of the microscope bisects the point F ; and having lowered the support at S , make a faint scratch with the point .
Having done this , turn the beam compass round on the center d till the point comes to D , where it must rest on a support similar to that at 3 ; and having slid the frame till the wire of the microscope bisects the pointf , make another faint scratch with the point , which if the distance of the microscope from the point has been well taken , will be very near the former scratch ; and the point mid-way between them will be the accurate bisection of the arch Ff ; but it is unnecessary , 222 and better not to attempt to place a point between these two scratches .
Having by these means determined the bisection at qp , we must bisect the arches Fq andfcp in just the same manner as before , except that the wire of the microscope must be made to bisect the interval between the two faint scratches , instead of bisecting a point .
It must be observed , that when the arch to be bisected is small , it will be necessary to use a bent point , as otherwise it could not be brought near enough to the axis of the microscope ; and then part of the rays , which form the image of the object seen by the microscope , will be intercepted by the point ; but I believe , that by proper management this may be done without either making the point too weak , or making the image indistinct ; but if this cannot be done , we may have recourse to Mr. TRoUGHTON'S expedient of bisecting an odd number of contiguous divisions .
It must be observed too , that in the bisections of all the arches of the same magnitude , the position of the point d on the frame remains unaltered ; but its position must be altered every time the magnitude of the arch is altered .
It is scarcely necessary to say , that the bisections thus made are not intended as the real divisions , but only as marks from which they are to be cut .
In order to make the real divisions , the microscope must be placed near the point , and the support d must be placed so that d shall be a tangent to the circle at .
The wire of the microscope must then be made to bisect one of these marks , and a point or division cut with the point , and the process continued till the divisions are all made .
It is plain that in this way , without some further precaution , Gg 223 we must depend on the microscope not altering its position in respect of the point during the operation ; for which reason I should prefer placing the axis of the microscope at exactly the same distance from the center of motion d , as the point ; but removed from it sideways , by nearly the semi-diameter of the object glass ; so that having made the division , we may move the beam compass till the division comes within the field of the microscope , and then see whether it is bisected by the wire , and consequently see whether the microscope has altered its place , In the operation of bisection , as above described , it may be observed , that if the two scratches are placed so near together , that in making the second the point of the compass runs into the burr raised by the first , there seems to be some danger that the point may be a little deflected from its true course ; though in BIRD'S account of his method , I do not find that he apprehends any inconvenience from it .
One way of obviating this inconvenience , if it does exist , would be to set the beam compass not so exactly to the true length , as that one scratch should run into the burr of the other ; but as this would make it more difficult to judge of the true point of bisection , perhaps it might be better to make one scratch extend from the circle towards the center , and the other from it .
It is clear , that the entire arc of a circle cannot be divided to degrees , without trisection and quinquesection ; and I do not know whether our artists have recourse to this operation , or whether they avoid it by some contrivance similar to BIRD'S , namely , that of laying down an arch capable of continued bisection ; but if the method of quinquesection is preferred , it may be performed by either of the three following methods : 224 First Method .
Let aa ( Fig. 2 ) be the arch to be quinquesected .
Open the beam compass to the chord of one fifth of this arch ; bring the microscope to a , and with the point make the scratchf ; then bring the microscope tof , and draw the scratch e ; and in the same manner make the scratches d and b. Then turn the beam compass half round , and having brought the microscope to v &amp; , make the scratch 3 ; and proceeding as before , make the scratches S , s and p. Then the true position of the first quinquesection will be between b and A , distant from 3 by one fifth of b A ; and the second will be distant from S by two fifths of d , and so on .
Then , in subdividing these arches , and striking the true divisions , the wire of the microscope , instead of bisecting the interval between the two scratches , must be brought four times nearer to A than to b. But in order ' to avoid the confusion which would otherwise proceed from this , it will be necessary to place marks on the limb opposite to all those divisions , in which the inlterval of the scratches is not to be bisected , showing in what proportion they are to be divided ; and these marks should be placed so as to be visible through the microscope , at the same time as the scratches .
Perhaps , the best way of forming these marks , would be to make dots ; with the point of the beam compass contiguous to that scratch which the wire is to be nearest to , which may be done at the time the scratch is drawn .
Perhaps an experienced eye might be able to place the wire in the proper manner , between the two scratches , without further assistance ; but the most accurate way would be to 2S5 have a moveable wire with a micrometer , in the focus of the microscope , as well as a fixed one ; and then having brought the fixed wire to b , bring the moveable one to 3 , and observe the distance of the two wires by the micrometer ; then reduce ' the distance of the two wires to one fifth part of this , and move the frame till the moveable wire comes to , , and then the fixed wire will be in the proper position , that is four times nearer to 3 than to b. It will be a great convenience , that the moveable wire should be made in such manner , as to be readily distinguished from the fixed , without the trouble of moving it .
In this manner of proceeding , I think a careful operator can hardly make any mistake : for if he makes any considerable error in the distance of the moveable wire from the fixed , it will be detected by the fixed wire not appearing in the right position , in respect of the two scratches ; and as the mark is seen through the microscope , at the same time as the scratches , there is no danger of his mistaking which scratch it is to be nearest to , or at what distance it is to be placed from it .
To judge of the comparative accuracy of this method with that of bisection , it must be considered that the arches a 3 , 3 , &amp;c. though made with the same opening of the compass , will not be exactly alike , owing partly to irregularities in the brass , and partly to other causes .
Let us suppose , therefore , that in dividing the arch aa into five parts , the beam compass is opened to the exact length , but that from the abovementioned irregularities the arches G , , 3 , o , and ea are all too long by the small quantity s , and that the arches af , fe , ed , and db are all too short by the same quantity , which is the supposition the most unfavourable of any to the exactness of the operation ; then the error in the position of P3 - , and the point b errs 4e in the same direction , and therefore the point assumed as the true point of quinquesection , will be at the distance of 3 .
from 3 , and the error in the position of this 5 point == 1 x. By the same way of reasoning , the error in the position of the point taken between d and '=Ex 2x .
In trisecting the error of each point =X -1- ; and in bisecting , the error = E ; and In quadrisecting , the error of the middle point == 2 e. It appears therefore that in trisecting , the greatest error we are liable to does not exceed that of bisection in a greater proportion than that of 4 to ; but in quinquesecting the error of the two middle points is 2times greater than in bisecting .
It must be considered , however , that in the method of continued bisection , the two opposite points must be found by quadrisection ; and the error of quinquesection exceeds that of quadrisection in no greater proportion than that of six to five ; so that we may fairly say , that if we begin with quinquesection , this method of dividing is not greatly inferior , in point of accuracy , to that by continued bisection .
Second Method .
This differs from the foregoing , in placing dots or scratches in the true points of quinquesection and trisection , before we begin to subdivide .
For this purpose , we must have a microscope placed as in page 224 , first par .
at the same distance from the center of motion as the point is ; and this microscope must be furnished with a moveable wire and micrometer , as in page 9s7 and then having fir3t made the fixed wire of this microscope correspond exactly with the point , we must draw the scratches b and 3 , d and ' , &amp;c. as before , and bring the fixed wire to the true point of quinquesection between b and G , n the manner directed in page s2G6 , and with the point strike the scratch or dot ; and if we please , we may , for further security , as soon as this is done , examine , by means of the moveable wire , whether this intermediate scratch or dot is well placed .
The advantage of this method is , that when this is done , we may subdivide and cut the true divisions , by making the wire of the microscope bisect the intermediate scratches , instead of being obliged to use the more troublesome operation of placing it in the proper proportion of distance between the two extremes .
This method certainly requires less attention than the former , and on the whole seems to be attended with considerably less trouble ; but it is not quite so exact , as we are liable to the double error of placing the intermediate point and of subdividing from it .
As in this method the intermediate points are placed by means of the micrometer , there is no inconvenience in placing the extreme scratches b and 0 , &amp;c. at such a distance from each other , that the intermediate one shall be in no danger of running into the bur raised by the extremes .
Third Method .
Let a ( Fig. 3 ) be the arch to be quinquesected ; lay down the arches a b , bd , and de , as in the first method ; then turn the beam compass half round , and lay down the arches a/ 228 and 3 ' ; then , without altering the frame , move the moveable wire of the microscope till it is four times nearer to A than to e , and , having first rubbed out the former scratches , lay them down again with the compass thus altered ; but as this method possesses not much , if any , advantage over the second , in point of ease , and is certainly inferior to it in exactness , it is not worth while saying any thing tfurther about it .
It was before said , * that the center of motion of the beam compass is to be placed , so that the point and axis of the microscope shall both be in the circle in which the divisions are made ; but it is necessary to consider this more accurately .
Let AS ( Fig. 4 ) be the circle in which the scratches are to be made , a the point of the beam compass , which we will suppose to be exactly in this circle , d the center on which it turns , and Mm the wire in the focus of the microscope , and let m be that point in which it is cut by the circle ; and let us suppose that this point is not exactly in the line do , then , when the beam compass is turned round , the circle will cut the wire in a different point p , placed as much on one side of d ' , as m is on the other , so that if the wire is not perpendicular to d , the arch set off by the beam compass , after being turned round , will not be the same as before ; but if it is perpendicular , there will be no difference ; for which reason , care should be taken to make the wire exactly perpendicular to d- , which is easily examined by observing whether a point appears to run along it , while the beam compass is turned a little on its center .
It is also necessary to take care that the point A is in the arc of the circle , while the bisection is observed by the microscope , which may most conveniently be obtained , by placing a stop on the support on which that end of the beam compass rests. .
If proper care , however , is taken in placing the wire perpendicular , no great nicety is required either in this or in the position of d. Another thing to be attended to , in making the wire bisect two scratches , is to take care that it bisects them in the part where they cut the circle ; for as the wire is not perpendicular to the circle , except in very small arches , it is plain , that if it bisects the scratches at the circle , it will not bisect them at a distance from it .
There are many particulars in which my description of the apparatus to be employed will appear incomplete ; but as there is nothing in it which seems attended with difficulty , I thought it best not to enter further into particulars , than was necessary to explain the principle , and to leave the rest to any artist who m1ray choose to try it .
It is difficult to form a proper judgment of the conveniences or inconveniences of this method , without experience ; but , as far as I can judge , it must have much advantage , both in point of accuracy and ease , over that of dividing by the common beam compasses ; but it very likely may be thought that Mr. TROUGHTON'S method , is better than either .
Whether it is or is not , must be left for determination to experience and the judgment of artists .
Thus much , however , may be observed , that this , as well as his , is free from the difficulty and inaccuracy of setting the point of a compass exactly in the center of a division .
It also requires much less apparatus than his , and is free from any danger of error , fro mt he , slipping or irregularity in the motion of a roller ; in which respect his method , notwithstanding the precautions used by C ?
- , ; a ? .
7 .
BB1 B b , , .
d\R ' &lt; ',6 } e !
&gt; i ?
yx"- , / b ( C IiiI A.I~ II~L ?
---_ ~~~~~~~~~ ?
_ _ ?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ __ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ -1 1IIiiiI I , I zl'(~ , ,i:.lzz , - , : MDCCCI(X , y.at_ X. p , .
Z31 .
e / , ( a , It , " , J/ / , / , c : ' .
him , is perhaps not entirely free from objection ; and what with some artists may be thought a considerable advantage , it is free from the danger of mistakes in computing a table of errors , and in adjusting a sector according to the numbers of that table .
H Ii OS3

