VII .
Account of the Dissection of a Human Faetus , in which the Circulation of the Blood was carried on without a Heart .
By MrB .
BC .
Brodie .
Communicated by Everard Home , Esq. F.R.S. Read February x6 , 80o9 .
AN opportunity lately occurred to me of examining a human foetus , in which the heart was wanting , and the circulation of the blood was carried on by the action of the vessels only .
There have been some other instances of this remarkable deviation from the natural structure ; but in that to which I allude the growth of the child had been natural , and it differed much less from the natural formation than in any of those , which are on record , and I have therefore been induced to draw up the following account of it .
A woman was delivered of twins in the beginning of the seventh month of pregnancy .
There was a placenta with two umbilical chords , which had their origin about three inches distant from each other .
The placenta was not preserved , but Mr. ADAMS , who attended the mother in her lying-in , observed nothing unusual in its appearance .
Both foetuses were born dead .
They were nearly of the same size .
One of them in no respect differed from the ordinary formation ; the other had an unusual appearance , andMr .
ADAMS thought it deserving of examination .
Through Dr. HOOPER it was put into my hands for this purpose .
The foetus measured thirteen inches from the summit of the cranium to the feet .
The thorax and abdomen were surrounded by a large shapeless mass , which concealed the form of the whole upper part of the body .
This mass proved to be the integuments covering the posterior part of the neck and thorax , distended with a watery fluid about three pints in quantity , contained in two cysts , lined by a smooth membrane .
When the fluid was evacuated , and the cysts allowed to collapse , the foetus had nearly the natural form .
Its extremities had nearly the usual appearance , except that on the right hand there was no thumb ; on the left hand there was no thumb also , and only a single finger .
There were three toes on the right foot , and four toes on the left foot .
The external nostrils consisted only of two folds of skin , under each of which was the orifice of an internal nostril , but pervious only for about half an inch .
There was a hare lip , and a cleft in the ; bony palate extending one third of an inch backwards .
On dissection , the cranium was found somewhat compressed by the fluid contained in the cyst behind it .
The brain itself was too putrid for accurate examination , but it was of nearly the natural size , and nothing unusual was observed in it .
The membranes had the natural appearance , and the nerves appeared to go off from the brain and spinal marrow nearly as usual .
In the thorax there was no heart , thymus gland , or pleura .
The trachea was situated immediately behind the sternum .
It had its natural appearance , and divided as usual into the two bronchia .
The latter terminated in the lungs , which consisted of two rounded bodies , not more than one third of an inch in diameter , having a smooth external surface , and l62 composed internally of a dense cellular substance .
The oesophagus had the usual situation , but it terminated in a cul-desac at.the lower part of the thorax .
The rest of the thorax was filled with a dense cellular substance ; and in place of the diaphragm , there was a membranous septum between it and the cavity of the abdomen .
In the abdomen , the stomach had no cardiac orifice .
The intestine was attached to the mesentery in the usual way ; but it was proportionably shorter than natural .
There was an imperfect coecum , but the colon was not distinguished by any difference of structure or appearance from the rest of the intestine .
The rectum had its usual situation in the pelvis .
The spleen and renal capsules were small ; the kidnies , bladder , penis , and testicles had the usual appearance .
The abdomen was lined by peritonaeum , but there was no omentum .
The liver and gall-bladder were wanting .
As there was no heart , it became an object of importance to ascertain the exact nature of the circulation : for this purpose , the blood-vessels were traced with attention .
The umbilical chord consisted of two vessels only : one of these was larger than the other , and its coats resembled those of a vein , while those of the smaller vessel were thick and elastic , like those of an artery .
Both of these vessels entered the navel of the child .
The artery passed to the left groin by the side of the urachus , occupying the usual situation of the left umbilical artery .
Here it gave off the external and internal iliac arteries of the left side , and was then continued upwards on the fore-part of the spine forming the aorta .
From the aorta arose the common trunk of the right iliac artery , and the branches to the viscera and parietes of the thorax and Yi i6.3 abdomen .
At the upper part of the thorax , it sent off the two subclavian , and afterwards divided into the two carotid arteries , without forming an arch .
The veins corresponding to these arteries terminated in the vena cava , which was situated on the anterior part of the spine before the aorta , and passed downwards before the right kidney to the right groin .
Here it became reflected upwards by the side of the urachus to the navel , and was continued into the larger vessel or vein of the chord .
It appears therefore , that , in this foetus , not only the heart was wanting , but there was no communication of any kind between the trunks of the venous and arterial systems , as in the natural foetus , where there is a heart .
The only communication between the two sets of vessels , was by means of the capillary branches anastomosing as usual in the foetus and in the placenta .
The blood must have been propelled from the placenta to the child through the artery of the chord , and must have been returned to the placenta by means of the vein , so that the placenta must have been at once the source and the termination of the circulation , and the blood must have been propelled by the action of the vessels only .
It is to be understood , that the circulation in the foetus receives no propelling power from the action of the heart and arteries of the mother .
This , although perfectly known to anatomists , it is proper to mention , as it may not be equally known to all the members of this Society .
It appears extraordinary , that under these circumstances , notwithstanding the circulation through the placenta must have been more languid than is natural , that organ should nevertheless have beeni capable of exercising its proper functions , so as to produce those changes on the blood , which are necessary for the maintenance of foetal life .
This may be explained by considering that in the natural foetus the umbilical arteries are branches of the general arterial system , and only a portion of the blood of the child is sent to the placenta , whereas in the foetus which I have described , the trunk of the vena cava was continued into the vein of the chord , and the whole of the venous blood circulated through the placenta , and was exposed to the influence of the arterial blood of the mother .
But the most interesting circumstance , which we learn from this examtination is , that the circulation not only can be carried on wsithiout a heart , but that a child so circumstanced can be maintained in its growth , so as to attain the same size as a foetus which is possessed of that organ .
This fact is contrary to what prior experience has led us to expect , as will appear from the following abstract of the authenticated cases of this species of malformation , which we find on record .
A monster , in which there was no heart , is described by M. MERRY .* There were twins , one of which was well formed , and of the usual size of a six month 's child : the size of the other was not mentioned , so that no comparison could be made between them .
In the latter , the lead , neck , and upper extremities were wanting .
There were no vestiges of a brain , nor was there any liver .
The dissection of the blood-vessels does not appear to have been very accurately made , but from the general account I should suppose , that the circulation did not materially differ from that of the foetus which I have described .
' Hi.s !
oire de PlAcademnie Royal des ckiences , 172zo i65 , Another instance of this kind is described by M. WINsLow.* This was also a twin , only seven inches in length .
The age and size of the other child are not mentioned .
In this instance there was no head , nor any vestige of brain .
There were no lungs , liver , stomach , nor spleen , and only a small portion of intestine .
The arterial system is described as being complete , communicating with the placenta by the umbilical vein opening into the aorta , and the umbilical arteries arising nearly as usual .
In this instance there was a circle of vessels formed by the arteries only , for M. WINSLOW expressly states , that there were no veins ; and however extraordinary this may appear , we cannot be otherwise than cautious in denying an observation made by an anatomist , so remarkable for his extreme accuracy and minuteness .
Dr. LE CAT of Rouen , states another case of twins t born at the end of the ninth month of pregnancy .
One of them was a well formed child of the usual size ; but the other was only twelve inches and a half in length .
The head of the latter was very imperfect , and there was only a very minute portion of brain .
The heart , lungs , liver , stomach , and spleen were entirely wanting , and there was only a small portion of intestine .
The arterial system was perfect ; the umbilical vein terminated in the aorta , and the umbilical arteries had their origin from the internal iliac , as usual .
There is , however , an obscurity in the account of the circulation , as it is stated that there were veins , but they were not traced , nor was any communication made out between them and the arteries , or the vessels of the chord .
Dr. CLARKE* has given an account of a case , in which a woman , after a natural labour , was delivered of a healthy child , and also of a substance covered by common integuments , of an oval form , four inches in length , and having a separate navel string and placenta .
In this substance there was one os innominatum , with a femur , tibia , and fibula .
There were neither brain nor nerves ; nor were there any viscera , except a small portion of intestine .
The umbilical chord consisted of two vessels , an artery and a vein , both of which ramified in this substance and in the placenta .
In Dr. IIUNTER 's anatomical collection , there are two specimens of monsters born without hearts .
In both of them the whole upper part of the body was wanting ; and in neither was the exact nature of the circulation ascertained .
In each of the instances which I have quoted , not only the heart was wanting , but the foetus in other respects was so imperfect , that it could not be considered as any thing more than a mola , or an irregularly formed living mass connected with the placenta .
In particular , in all of them the brain , which may with justice be considered as affording the best distinction between a mola and a foetus , was wanting ; whereas in that which forms the subject of the present paper , the brain was nearly as large as usual , and in other respects the foetus varied much less from the natural structure , than in any former instance .
In the cases already on record , we have seen , that whereever the size of the monster was mentioned , it was much smaller than a natural foetus .
This would have led to the supposition , that a circulation , which was carried on by the action of the vessels only , was incapable of maintaining the natural growth of a child , had it not been found that the foetus , which I have described , though the heart was wanting , was fully equal in size to a foetus of the same age , which was possessed of that organ .
It may be observed , that in all these cases , in which the heart was wanting , the liver was wanting also .
It is probable , that the action of the vessels only , without the assistance of the heart , would have been insufficient to propel the blood through the circulation of the liver , which is so extensive in the natural foetus .

