to show that their Sight was obscured in very different Degrees ; with Experiments to determine the proportional Knowledge of Objects acquired by them immediately after the Cataracts were removed .
By Everard Home , Esq. F. R. S. Read January 15 , 1807 .
MVR .
CHESELDEN'S observations on this subject , recorded in the Phil. Trans. for the year 1728 , pointed out two material facts ; that vision alone gives no idea of the figure of objects , or their distance from the eye , since a very intelligent boy , 13 years of age , upon recovering his sight was unable to distinguish the outline of any thing placed before him , and thought that every object touched his eye .
Mr. WARE'S cases , which have also a place in the Phil. Trans. for 1801 , and are compared with that of Mr. CHESELDEN , appear to lead to a different conclusion .
The following observations are laid before the Society with a view to explain this circumstance .
CASE I. WILLIAM STIFF , twelve years of age , was admitted into St. George 's Hospital under my care , on the i7th of July , 1806 , with cataracts in his eyes , which , according to the account of his mother , existed at the time of birth .
From earliest .
M 2 infancy he never stretched out his hand to catch at any thing , nor were his eyes directed to-objects placed before him , but rolled about in a very unusual manner , although in other respects he was a lively child .
The eyes were not examined till he was six months old , and at that time the cataracts were as distinct as when he was received into the hospital .
Previous to an operation being performed , the following circumstances were ascertained respecting his vision .
He could distinguish light from darkness , and the light of the sun from that of a fire or candle : he said it was redder , and more pleasant to look at , but lightning made a still stronger impression on his eyes .
All these different lights he called red .
The sun appeared to him the size of his hat .
The candle flame was larger than his finger , and smaller than his arm .
When he looked at the sun he said it appeared to touch his eye .
When a lighted candle was placed before him both his eyes were directed towards it , and moved together .
When it was at any nearer distance than 12 inches , he said it touched his eyes .
When moved further off he said it did not touch them ; and at 22 inches it became invisible .
On the 21st of July the operation of extractiag the crystallie lens was performed on the left eye .
The capsule of the lens was so very strong as to require some force to penetrate it .
When wounded , the contents , which were fluid , rushed out with great violence .
Light became very distressing to his eye , and gave him pain .
After allowing the eye-lids to remain closed for a few minutes , and then opening them , the pupil appeared clear , but he could not bear exposure to light .
On my asking him what he had seen , he said , " your head , which 84 seemed to touch my eye : " but he could not tell its shape .
He went to bed , and took an opiate draught : the pain in his eye lasted about an hour , after which he fell asleep .
The whole of that day the light was distressing to his eye , so that he could not bear the least exposure to it .
On the 22d the eye-lids were opened to examine the eye .
The light was less offensive .
He said he saw my head , which touched his eye .
There was so much inflammation on the eye-ball , that a leech was applied to the temple , and the common means forremoving inflammation were used .
On the s3d the eye was less inflamed , and he could bear a weak light .
The pupil was of an irregular figure , and the wounded cornea had not united with a smooth surface .
He said he could see several gentlemen round him , but could not describe their figure .
My face , while I was looking at his eye , he said was round and red .
On the 25th the inflammation had subsided , but on the 27th returned , and continued notwithstanding different means were employed for its removal , till the ist of August , when : it was almost entirely gone .
On the 4th the eye was apparently so well that an attempt was made in the presence of Mr. CAVENDISiI and Dr. WOLLASTON to ascertain its powers of vision ; but it was so weak that it became necessary to shade the glare of light by hanging a white cloth before the window .
The least exertion fatigued the eye , and the cicatrix .
on the cornea , to which the iris had become attached , drew it down so as considerably to diminish , the pupil .
Fromthese circumstances nothing could be satisfactorily made out respecting the boy 's vision .
On the ilth a second attempt was made in the presence of Mr. CAVENDISHu , but the pupil conti- nued so contracted and irregular , and the eye so imperfect in its powers , that it became necessary a second time to postpone any experiments .
On the i6th of September the right eye was couched .
This operation was preferred after what had happened to the other eye , in the hope that there would not be the same degree of inflammation , and as the former cataract was fluid , there was every reason to believe that couching would in this instance be most efficacious .
The operation gave pain , and the light was so distressing to his eye that the lids were closed as soon as it was over , and he was put to bed .
The consequent inflammation was not severe , but as soon as the fluid cataract , which had been diffused through the aqueous humour was absorbed , the capsule of the lens was found to be opaque , and the sight consequently imperfect .
The eyes were not examined with respect to their vision till the l3th of October , during which period the boy remained quiet in the hospital .
On that day the upper part of the pupil of the left eye had in some measure recovered its natural state , and had become transparent , but the cicatrix in the cornea was more extensively opaque than before .
The light now was not distressing to either eye , and when strong , he could readily discern a white , red , or yellow colour , particularly when bright and shining .
The sun and other objects did not now seem to touch his eyes as before , they appeared to be at a short distance from him .
The eye , which had been couched , had the most distinct vision of the two , but in both it was imperfect .
The distance at which he saw best was five inches .
When the object was of a bright colour , and illuminated 86 by a strong light , he could make out that it was flat and broad ; and when one corner of a square substance was pointed out to him , he saw it , and could find out the other , which was at the end of the same side , but could not do this unider less favourable circumstances .
When the four corners of a white card were pointed out , and he had examined them , he seemed to know them : but when the opposite surface of the same card , which was yellow , was placed before him , he could not tell whether it had corners or not , so that he had not acquired any correct knowledge of them , since he could not apply it to the next coloured surface , whose form was exactly the same , with that , the outline of which the eye had just been taught to trace .
CASE II .
JoHN SALTER , seven years of age , was admitted into St. George 's Hospital on the ist of October , 18o6 , under my care , with cataracts in both eyes , which according to the accounts of his relations had existed from his birth .
After he was received into the hospital , the following circumstances were ascertained respecting his vision .
The pupils contracted cotsiderably when a lighted candle was placed before him , and dilated as soon as it was withdrawn .
He was capable of distinguishing colours with tolerable accuracy , particularly the more bright and vivid ones .
On the 6th of October the left eye was couchied .
This operation was preferred to extraction , from a belief that the cataracts were not solid , and as the injury done to the capsule by the operation would be less , there was not the same chance of inflammation , the disposition for which , had been so 87 strong in the former case .
As the eye was not irritable , and was likely to be but little disturbed by this operation , every thing was previously got ready for ascertaining his knowledge of objects , as soon as the operation was over , should the circumstances prove favourable .
The operation was attended with success , and gave very little pain .
The eye was allowed ten minutes to recover itself : a round piece of card of a yellow colour , one inch in diameter , was then placed about six inches from it .
He said immediately that it was yellow , and on being asked its shape , said , " Let me touch I it , and I will tell you .
" Being told that he must not toucl it , after looking for some time , he said it was round .
A square blue card , nearly the same size , being put before him , he said it was blue and round .
A triangular piece he also called round .
The different colours of the objects placed before him he instantly decided on with great correctness , but had no idea of their form .
He moved his eye to different distances , and seemed to see best at 6 or 7 inches .
His focal distance has been since ascertained to be 7 inches .
He was asked whether the object seemed to touch his eye , he said " No ; " but when desired to say at what distance it was , he could not tell .
These experiments were made in the theatre of the hospital , in which the operation was performed , before the surgeons and all the students .
He was highly delighted with the pleasure of seeing , and said it was " so pretty , " even when no object was before him , only the light upon his eye .
The eye was covered , and he was put to bed , and told to keep himself quiet , but upon the house-surgeon going to him half an hour afterwards , his eye was found uncovered , and he was looking at his bed curtains , which were close drawn , 88 The bandage was replaced , but so delighted was the boy with seeing , that he again immediately removed it .
This circumstance distressed the house-surgeon , who had been directed to prevent him from looking at any thing till the next day , when the experiment was to be repeated .
Finding that he could not enforce his instructions , he thought it most adviseable to repeat the experiment about two hours after the operation .
At first the boy called the different cards round ; but upon being shown a square , and asked if he could find any corners to it , he was very desirous of touching it .
This being refused , he examined it for some time , and said at last that he had found a corner , and then readily counted the four corners of the square ; and afterwards when a triangle was shown him , he counted the comers in the same way ; but in doing so his eye went along the edge from corner to corner , naming them as he went along .
Next day , when ][ saw him , he told me he had seen " the " soldiers with their fifes and pretty things .
" The guards in the morning had marched past the hospital with their band ; on hearing the music he had got out of bed , and gone to the window to look at them .
Seeing the bright barrels of the musquets , he must in his mind have connected them with the sounds which he heard , and mistaken them for musical instruments .
On examining the eye 24 hours after the operation , the pupil was found to be clear .
A pair of scissors was shown him , and he said it was a knife .
On being told he was wrong , he could not make them out ; but the moment he touched them he said they were scissors , and seemed delighted with the discovery .
On being shown a guinea at the distance of 15 inches from his eye , he said it was a seven shilling piece , but placing it about 5 inches from his eye , he knew it to be a guinea ; and made the same mistake , as often as the experiment was repeated .
From this time he was constantly improving himself by looking at , and examining with his hands , every thing within his reach , but he frequently forgot what he had learnt .
On : the 10th I saw him again , and I told him his eye was so well that he:night go about as he pleased without leaving the room .
He immediately went to the window , and called out , " What is that moving ?
" I asked him what he thought it was ?
He said , " A dog drawing a wheelbarrow .
There is one , two , three dogs drawing another .
How very pretty !
" These proved to be carts and horses on the road , which he saw from a two pair of stairs window .
On the igth , the different coloured pieces of card were separately placed before his eye , and so little had he gained in thirteen days , that he could not without counting their corners one by one tell their shape .
This he did with great facility , running his eye quickly along the outline , so that it was evident he was still learning , just as a child learns to read .
He had got so far as to know the angles , when they were placed before him , and to count the number belonging to any one object .
The reason of his making so slow a progress was , that these figures had never been subjected to examination by touch , and were unlike any thing he was accustomed to see .
He had got so much the habit of assisting his eyes with his hands , that nothing but holding them could keep them from the object .
On the 26th the experiments were again repeated on the couchedeye , to ascertain thdege of improvement which had been made .
It was now found that the boy , on looking at any one of the cards in a good light , could tell the form nearly as readily as the colour , From these two cases the following conclusions may be drawn : That , where the eye , before the cataract is removed , has only been capable of discerning light , without being able to distinguish colours , objects after its removal will seem to touch the eye , and there will be no knowledge of their outline ; which confirms the observations made by Mr. CHESELDEN : Thatwhere the eye has previously distinguished colours , there must also be an imperfect knowledge of distances , but not of outline , which however will afterwards be very soon acquired , as happened in Mr. WARE'S cases .
This is proved by the history of the first boy in the present Paper , who before the operation had no knowledge of colours or distances , but after it , when his eye had only arrived at the same state , that the second boy 's was in before the operation , he had learnt that the objects were at a distance , and of different colours : that when a child has acquired a new sense , nothing but great pain or absolute coercion , will prevent him from making use of it .
In a practical view , these cases confirm every thing , that has been stated by Mr. POT and Mr. WARE , in proof of cataracts in children being generally soft , and in favour of couching , as being the operation best adapted for removing them .
They also lead us to a conclusion of no small importance , which has not before been adverted to ; that when the cataract has assumed a fluid form , the capsule , which is N 9~ naturally a thin transparent membrane , has to resist the pressure of this fluid , which like every other diseased accumulation is liable to increase , and distend it , and therefore the capsule is rendered thicker and more opaque in its substance , like the coats of encysted tumours in general .
As such a change is liable to take place , the earlier the operation is performed in all children , who have cataracts completely formed , the greater is their chance of having distinct vision after the operation .
It is unnecessary to point out the advantages to be derived from its being done at a more early age , independent of those respecting the operation itslf ,

