X. Concerning the Differences in the magnetic Needle , on Board the Investigator , arising from an Alteration in the Direction of the Shi p 's Head .
By Matthew Flinders , Esq. Commander of his Majesty 's Ship Investigator .
In a Letter to the Right Hon. Sir Joseph Banks , K. B. P. R. S. Read March 28 , 1805 .
XVHILST surveying along the south coast of New Holland , in i8oi and 1802 , I observed a considerable difference in the direction of the magnetic needle , when there was no other apparent cause for it than that of the ship 's head being in a different direction .
This occasioned much perplexity in laying down the bearings , and in allowing a proper variation upon them , and put me under the necessity of endeavouring to find out some method of correcting or allowing for these differences ; for unless this could be done , many errors must unavoidably get admission into the chart .
I first removed two guns into the hold , which had stood near the compasses , and afterwards fixed the surveying compass exactly amidships upon the binnacle , for at first it was occasionally shifted to the weather side as the ship went about ; but neither of these two arrangements produced any material effect in remedying the disagreements .
* The following Table contains the observations for the 'variation of the compass in which the differences are most remarkable , and from which I shall beg to point out such inferences as I think may be drawn from them .
I\ Number of Number of sets of Place of Supposed Observed Ship 's Time .
Latitude .
Longitude , compasses observations taken .
the true variation head .
Observer .
used .
compass .
variation , I80I .
o , o , , o , Dec. AM 35 5S II6 28 E two ths binnacle W 5 ' W NWb .
N Commander Princess Royal Harbour three 6 on shore 6 IS 6 23 theodolite I_68 180Z .
Jan. 9 , PM 34 I 12I 20 one 2 binnacle 5o9 22 ES i6 , AM GooseIsland Bay one 24o 054 W I803 .
May 2o , AM 268E I802 .
Jan. I8 , PM 33 37 124I0 2_ 430 544 NNE 20 , PM 32 38 I25 35 27 I5 Eb .
N 2I , PM 32 30 125 48 _24 45 S 22 , PM 32 30 i26 724 15 6 13 NO b. E 23 , PM 32 ZI i26 33 I amplitude 4o4 18 S b. E 24 , AM 32 S 128 I5 2 azimuths 3o64 Eb .
N 26 , PM 32 I5 I28 15 three 637S b. E Lt. Flinders 30 , AM 32 I8 I32 29 One 2 30 41 SSE Commander Feb. 4 , AMI No. 4 , bay in island e20 15 2 23 Easterly 5 , AM 32 39 I33 55 'amplitude 1 56 E b. S 6 , AM 32 36 I33 58 three 6 azimuths IoE NW Lt. Flinders i6 , PM 34 3 I35 20 one 2 _I 5EI 33 W SE b. E Commander , PMI 34 5 I35 24 I amplitde 53 56 E SW IS , A,3450 t35 32 three 6 azimuths I IZ 1 I2 S Lt. Flinders Mar. I , PM i iL No. Io , bay theodolite I on shore I 39 I 39 Commander 5 , PM _ one 2 binnacle 1 39 0 53 S b. E 17 , PM 34 12 I37 20 Iamplitude 2 I5 4 38 SW b. S Commander I8 , PM 34 23 I37 36 one 2 azimuths binnacle 2 IS 0 35 SE 2i , AM 35 33 I37 I5 three 62 40 EI IO SE b. S 23 , AM Kanguroo Island two 42 58 6 31 SSW 26 , AM 35 10 I37 41 one Iamplitude 2 45 I 49 NO b. N 27 , AM 35 21 137 52 one 12 50 1 49 SSE April 6 , AM Kanguroo Islansd 2 azimutlss on shore z 58 2 I0 , AM 3 47 I amplitude binnacle 305 'I W b. S IIPM 35 53 139 26 2 azinuths 300 50 SE I3 , PM 36 45 I40 523 30 I 25 SE b. S i6 , AM 37 55 139 55 { Iamplitude 4 15 2 20 17 , PM 37 57 139 56 2 aZ muth _4 15 22 NE 22 ; AM 39 38 144 50 z7 45 W 52 sw 26 , PM ' 38 35 I44 25 2_7 30 3 4I NEb .
E - , AM 38 38 | 144 3S I Iamplitude 730 6 48 NE b.N Note .
All the compasses made use of on board the lnvestigator were of WALK RR'S construction , one excepted .
which was made by APAMS , and uis d only oi July 2zd , I8oI .
It is apparent that some of the observed variations .
in .
the above , Table are e-j less and others ; e greater than the truth ; and it may beremarked , that when this error is westward , the !
ship 's head was east , or nearly so , and when it was eastward the head was in .
the opposite direction .
When the observations agree nearest with what was taken on shore , or with what may be deemed the true variation , the ship 's head was nearly north or south ; and a minute inspection of the Table will , favour the opinion , that the excess or diminution of the variation was generally inproportion as the ship 's head inclined on either side from the magnetic .
meridian .
After I hadwell ascertained the certainty of a difference in the compasses , arising from an alteration in the point steered , I judged it necessary , when I wanted a set of bearings from a point where we tacked the ship , to take one set just before and another immediately after that operation : some specimens of these here follow .
Head ES .
Head SWb .
W. 80oz .
April i3th r Le Geographe Rocks , N 550 to 710 E 11 32L , AM X point N. W after tacking N 9gW n fpoint S 3z E SS40 E. Head SE b. E. Head W. April 14th In point rocky , inner part N 390 E after tacking .
, N 300 E 9b 29 ' , AM J projecting part N 67 EN 59 E Furthestvisible extreme from deck S5tE S55 E. Head EN .
Head SW b. S. April Xi5th 1Rn , the western part N 15 W after tacking , N Zi0I W Ih s50 , AM JA peaked hummock N ig EN X5 E Furthest extreme from deck S5ES 61 E Centre of a naked sandy patch E5 N. Variation per amplitude April I 5 , AMP 0 8'E ship 's head being S. taken with the surveying compass 3 Head. .
Head SW b. S. April 1 5th , The peaked hummock _N 'z0a W after tacking , N ISO W bh PM 5 Former extreme , a projection S 59 EiS 64 E ; Naked sandy patch , distant 3 .
' N 33 EiN 3 .
From some little change of place after tacking the ship , and from the part whose bearing was set ; not being perhaps the individual spot in both instances , the difference between the separate bearings in any set will not be always the , same : to these causes for error also may be added inaccuracies in taking the angles arising from the motion of the ship and compass , from the view of the object being obstructed by the rigging , masts , or ship 's upper works , and from too much haste to get the bearings before the ship 's place was materially altered .
Even in the Table of azimuths and amplitudes greater accuracy than one degree must not be looked for ; and in ship-bearings 2 or even 3 degrees is not , I believe , too great an allowance for error , unless in very favourable circumstances .
Without attending to small differences , it is evident that the bearings correspond with the observations in requiring a less east variation to be applied when the ship 's head was easterly , and a greater when it was to the westward , in order to get at the true direction of the object.* When examining the north As a specimen of the plan I followed in protracting such bearings as the above , take the set of April 15 , AM , when the true variation appears .
to have been 4 ?
E. On the first bearings the ship 's head was sic points on one side of the meridian , and on the second it was three points on the other side , the mean is one point and an half on the east side ; now for this one point and an , half I allow il of error , which , as it is on the east side of the meridian , and the variation is easterly , must be subtracted : the variation then to be allowed upon the .
mean between the bearings before and after tacking will be 30 E , from which the true bearings will stand as follows April i5th , AM n western part Ni s0E 1I1h ls ' A peaked hummock N so E Furthqst extreme from deck S 54 E Centre Qf a naked sandy patch E ol S. In the .
same manner upon single sets of bearings I was obliged to allow a variatio n different from what I supposed the true to be , unless the ship 's head was nearly north or south : but , that I might proceed as little upon conjecture as possible , I always and east coasts of New Holland , I always endeavoured to take the angles on shore with a TROUGHTON'S portable theodolite , and to observe for the variation in the same places , that all the errors might be done away or corrected ; and as I was frequently fortunate enough to carry on mysurveys in this manner for weeks together , instances that might corroborate or contradict the preceding remarks are neither very numerous or pointed ; the following are the most remarkable .
Number of Number of Place of Supposed Observed Ship 's Time , Latitude .
Longitude .
compasses sets of observathe true variation .
, head .
Observer .
used .
tions taken .
compass .
variation .
1802*5 , PM 23 5I S I5I14z E one I amplitude binnacle o IZ7 E WSW Commander AMd 23 SI I5I 40 _ _I ; O rS WvNW,2 , PM is 3 ?
I5 I1 three 6 azimuths 6 50 SSE Lt. Flinders is , PM 2Z3 23I5II6 one 2 --7 45 752 Xy Commander 31 C2 : 23 I 50 38 two 47 30 4 4-9 E Sept. 6 , AM Upon Pier Head theodolitei on shore 8o8Z Oct. I4 , PM 20 44 150 42 one I amplitude binnacle 706 40 SSE Lt. Flinders 20 , PM 19 22 I48 40 I6o5 39 S Commander 21 , AM i8 I5 I$8 38 three 6 azimuths _5 42 N b. E Lt. Flinders Nov. 2 , PM 10 30 142 32 one 2_403 3z E Commander 7 , AM Iz I 1420 _ -1 _S Lt. Flinders 9 , PM I2 37 142 Z2 I amplitude __ 24 W Comimand-r 1803 .
Jan. 3 , PM 1+ 20 136 16 I2 30 o 58 F 7 , PM I14 20 136 37 19 SE 13 { }M 13 38 137 20 2_303 47 Westerly Lt. Flinders 14 , AM I3 3 36 58 wsW Commader iG , PM InNW Bay ( Gr .
Eyl .
) theodolite i azimuth on shore 36 Feb. 3 , AM Arnhem S Bay three 6 binnacle 2 20 2 z6 NW b. W 9 , AM theodolite I on shore z 20 Mar. io , AM ii1 134 15 one Z binnacle Io1 55 WNW endeavoured to get observations for the variation when the ship 's head was in the same direction as when I had taken or wished to take a particular set of bearings , and Ii then allowed that variation exactly , whatever it was .
The perplexity arising from , disagreements in bearings was by these means much alleviated , and happy agreements were frequently produced , when , without such corrections , there was nothing but , discord .
In the latter of these observations , the differences arising from a change in the direction of the ship 's head is less considerable than in the higher latitudes ; indeed , on approaching the line of no variation upon the south coast , the differences in the variation were smaller than before and afterwards ; but that these differences shall be greater in a large variation and smaller in a less , both places being equally distant from the magnetic pole , I will not venture to assert .
The inferences that I think may be safely drawn from the above observations are as foblows 1 ist .
That there was a difference in the direction of the magnetic needle on board the Investigator when the ship 's head pointed to the east and when it was directed westward .
2d .
That this difference was easterly when the ship 's head was west , and westerly when it was east .
3d .
That when the ship 's headwas north or south the needle took the same direction or nearly so that it would on shore ; and showed a variation from thetrue meridian , which was nearly themedium between what it showed when east and when west .
4th .
That the error in variation was nearly proportionate to the number of points which the ship 's head was from the north , or south .
Constant employment upon practice has not allowed me to become much acquainted with theories , but the little information I have upon the subject of magnetism has led me to form some notion cowncerning the cause of these differences and although most probably vague and unscientific , I trust for the candour of the learned in submitting it , as well as theinferences above drawn , to their judgment .
Ist .
I suppose the attractive power of the different bodies in a ship , which are capable of affecting the compass , to be collected iinto something like a focal pointor center of gravity , and that this -point is nearly in the center of the ship where the shot are deposited , for here the greatest quantity of iron is collected together .
2d .
I suppose this point to be endued with the same kind of attraction as the pole of the hemisphere where the ship is ; consequently , in New Holland the south -end of the needle -would be attracted by it and the north end repelled .
3d .
That the attractive power of this point is sufficiently strong in a ship of war to interfere with the action of the magnetic -poles upon a compass placed upon or in the binnacle .
If these suppositions are consistent with the laws of magnetism , established by experiments , I judge that they will account for all the differences above noticed ; for the interference will necessarily be most perceptible upon a compass when the attractive point is at right angles to the magnetic meridian , that is , when the ship 's head is east or west , and will altogether vanish or become imperceptible when the attractive point and meridian coincide , or when the ship 's head is north or , south .
That the power of this point should become less as the ship increases her distance from the magnetic pole has not indeed entered into myssuppositions ; but it may probably be true , and is indeed almost -a necessary consequence of the second supposition .
If the above hypothesis , so to call it , be true , it must follow , that the differences in the variation of the magnetic needle , arising from a change in the ship 's head , ought to be directly contrary to those before recited , when the ship is on the north side of the magnetic equator , for the north point of the needle should then be attracted , and the south end repelled .
I have no observations which are very decisive upon this head , but those that were taken on board the Investigator seem to bespeak that it is So ; they are as follows .
Numbell Numberof Suppos Time .
Latitude .
Longitude .
of coma of obserPlace of the cd true Observed Ship 's Observer .
passes vatioen takers , coipass .
variavariation , head .
used .
-tion .
July 2I1 , PM Start Pointin sight two azmltmu binn)cle 29 3 4W W We .
Thistle to the NO one Iamnplitude .
29 30 22 , PM 490 1o ' N s5025 ' W two 4 2zbnuths upon the 211i2 WNW IJ ~~~~~~~~~~~~boonis in1 - , AM 48 iS 6 45 one I arplitud the middle 1 24 49 WSW:8 , PM 38 xI ' z0 five oazi uths l ohe ship J 20 57 Sa1__ -^ XX_ binnacle X 25 34 Commander 31 , PM Porto Santo in sight two 422 45 _ Are .
Thistle to the NW _ .
booms I95 Aug. 24 , AM 0o 2o 22 15 one z binnacle 12 45 SE b cS Jommander 29 , AM 5 40 i6 twoo 4tw 12 I8 Lt. Fliitders Sept. 5 , AM z2 15 14 .
00 3 -|14 54 |WSW ` 4r .
Thistle These observationss , particularly those of July 28 , seem to be decisive in showing that the variation is more westerly when taken upon the binnacle of a ship whose head is westward in north latitude , than when observed in the center of the ship , which is a strong confirmation of the suppositions before given ; but the observations on the change of the ship 's head are too few to be satisfactory .
Almost every sea officer can tell whether he has observed the variation of the compass to be greater when going down the English Channel than when coming up it : and indeed it would be very easy for a ship lying in harbour to ascertain the point beyond controversy .
Should this point be well established , I think it would follow , that from , a high south latitude where the differences are great on one side , they are most likely to decrease gradually to the equator , and to increase in the same way to a high north lati. .
tude , where they are great on the other side ; thus the smaller IDCCCV .
C c differences on the north coast of New Holland will be accounted for .
I shall leave it to the learned on the subject of magnetism to compare the observations here given with those made by others in different parts of the earth , and to form from them an hypothesis that may embrace the whole of the phenomena : the opinion I have ventured to offer is merely thevague conjecture of one who does not profess to understand the subject .
Some account of the magnetism of Pier Head , upon the east coast of New Holland , may not perhaps be thought an unappropriate conclusion to this Paper .
I was insduced to attend to this from the following passage in HAWKESWORTH , Vol. III .
p. 12 6 .
" 'At sun-rise I went ashore , says Captain COOK , " and " climbing a considerable hill , " Pier Head , " I took a view of " the coast and the islands that lie off it , with their bearings " having an azimuth compass with me for that purpose ; but I " observed that the needle differed very considerably in its " c position , even to thirty degrees , in some places more , in " others less ; and once I found it differ from itself no less c " than two points in the distance of fourteen feet.* I took up " some of the loose stones that lay upon the ground , and " applied them to the needle , but they produced no effhct ; In a set of angles taken near the head of Arnhem north bay , on the west side of the guiph of Carpentaria , I found the needle of the theodolite had been drawn S-o from Its proper direction .
The shore consisted of grains of iron ore caked into a stony Lass ; and a piece of it , when applied to the needle , drew it 6 or 8 degrees from its direction , but it then swung back to its error of 500 where it was stationary .
In Arnhem south bay a small piece of similar store drew the needle of the theodolite entirely round , yet the bearings taken in this place did not show any disagreement from the varnation and bearings taken in th2 no ghbouring places , where the stone did not produce any sucth of etc. IL most pl ces Ont shore , where I had occasion to take angles , it w13 my practcf to try 4hIe eff et of a piece of the stone upon the theodolite , ; n order to dtetct the presence of iron ore , as well as on account of my survey .
It " and I therefore concluded that there was iron ore in the hills , " of which I had remarked other indications , both here and " in the neighbouring parts .
" On landing at Pier Head I found the stones lying on the surface to be porphyry , of a dark bluish colour ; but although I understand thisspecies is usually found to possess some magnetic power , a piece did not produceany sensible effect upon the needle of the theodolite when applied to it. .
In the following observations the theodolite always stood about four feet from the ground , that being nearly the lengt of is legs .
I first took an extensive set of bearings from the top of the hill , amongst which were two stations whence Pier Head had been before set .
The first , called Extensive Mount , distant 81 miles , differed from its back bearing 40 35 ' to the right , and the second island a , distant 29i miles , differedf 4 ' the same way .
I now moved the theodolite three yards to the westward , and the same two objects bore 2 ? ?
10t to the right of their back bearing ; on moving it three yards to the south-eastward from the first place , they differed 2 ?
to the left ; and on moving the theodolite four yards to the northward , the same two objects bore i ?
to ' to the right of their back bearings .
On the folb lowing morning I determined to try the magnetism more particularly .
Taking the theodolite and dipping-needle , I landed upon the shore of the Head , whence the top of the hill bore N 500 W , about one-third of a mile .
The variation of the theodolite in this place I observed to be 8 ?
' A E , and the commonly happened that no effect was apparent , but yet I could not trust implicitly to the angles , ( particularly on the main land , ) unless observations for the variation were taken before the instrument was moved , or I had a back bearing of some station where such observations had been made .
Cc 2inclination of the south end of the dipping needle 5e 50 ' , the needle stood vertical when the face of the instrument was S ?
E. I then took the follo ving bearings : Extensive Mount 1o80 3o ' , the same exactly as by back bearing .
Double Peak 143 0o ' ; from hence I rowed round the Head , and landed on a rock , whence the top of the hill bore SSW one-sixth of a mile ; Extensive Mount bore 1100 14 ' , the inclination of the dbping-needle o 29 ' , and the needle stood vertical when the instrument faced SS E. Thus the difference was 1- ?
ifnthe horizontal , and -LO in the vertical direction of the needle .
Ascending the hill , I made the following observations on the top : Extensive Mount Iiit so ' , a island i33 ' 52 ' , Double Peak 1480 B ' ; the inclination of the -needle was 5 ' 20 ' , and it stood vertical at S 3 ?
E. The differences here are ?
lo ' in the horizontal , and a ?
R3o ' in the vertical direction , from what the needle stood at in the first morning 's place .
On moving ten yards SSE , the bearings were , Extensive Mount 1080 44P , Double Peak 143i 25 ' ; the inclination was 52 ' 18 ' , and the needle was vertical when the instrument faced S,5 W. In this 4th set of observations , the horizontal direction of the needle is only a few minutes different from the first place , but the vertical direction is 1o 28 ' .
From the top of the hill I now moved twenty yards to the north-eastward , when Extensive Mount bore 1 o0 , Double Peak i4 ?
~42 ' ; the inclination of the dipping needle was now 5co 35 ' , and it stood vertical at S so W. Thus it appears that tOle polarity of the magnetic needle is most interrupted at the top of the hill , both according to the thodolite and dipping-needle .
Whether this may arise from sonre particular mamgnetic substance lodged in the heart of the hill , or from the attractive powers of all the substances which compose Pier Head being centered in a similar point to what I have supposed to take place with all the ferruginous bodies lodged within a ship , I shall not attempt to decide .
The greater differences in the horizontal direction of the needle observed by Captain CooK , might have arisen from his using a common azimuth compass , which was probably not further elevated from the ground than to be placed on a stone .
MATTHEW FLINDERS .
Isle of France , Marchi gth , 18o4 .

