II .
ExpetimentsfJr ascertaing how far Telescopes will enable us to determine very , small Alngles , and to distinguish the realfrom the spzaius Diameters of celestial and terrestrial Objects : with an Application of the Result of these Experiments to a Series of Observations on the Nature and Magnitude of Mr. Harding 's lately discovered Star. .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F. R. S. Read December 6 , 1804 .
THE discovery of Mr. HARDING having added a moving celestial body to the list of those that were known before , I was desirous of ascertaining its magnitude ; and as in the observations which it wasnecessary to make I intended chiefly to use a ten-feet reflector , it appeared to me a desideratum highly worthy of investigation to determine how small a diameter of an object might be seen by this instrument .
We know that -a very thin line may be perceived , and that objects may be seen when they subtend a very small angle but the case I wanted to determine relates to a visible disk , a round , well defined appearance , which we may without hesitation affirm to be circular , if not spherical .
In April of the year 1774 , I determined a similar question relating to the natural eye : and found that a square area could not be distinguished from , an equal circular one till the diameter of the latter came to subtend an angle of 2 ' 17 " .
I did not .
think it right to apply the same conclusions to a telescopic view of an object , and therefore had recourse to the following experiments .
ISt Experiment , with the Heads of Pins 'I selected a set of pins with round heads , and deprived them of their polish by tarnishing them in the flame of a candle .
The diameters of the heads were measured by a microscopic projection , with a magnifying power of 8o .
These measures are -so exact , that when repeated they will seldom differ more than a few ten thousandths parts of an inch from each other .
Their sizes were as follows:,1375 o083 G 0,821 , o602 04cp5 .
I placed the -pins in a regular order upon a small post erected in my garden , at 2407,85 inches from the centre of the object mirror of my ten-feet reflecting telescope ' .
The focal length of the mirroron Arcturus 'is 1 19,64 inches , but on these objects J 25 9 .
The distance was measured with deal rods .
When , I looked at these -objects in the telescope , I found immediately that only the smallest of them , at this distance could be of any use ; for with an eye-glass of 4 inches , which gives the telescope a magnifying power-of no more than 1,5 , this pin 's head appeared to be a round body , and the view left no doubt ubpon the subject .
It subtended -an angle of 3"G64 at the centre of the mirror , and the magnllified angle under which I saw it was 1 ' 54"6 .
This low power however required great attention .
With a lens 3 , power 38,1i5 , I. saw it instantly round and globular .
The magnified angle was 2 ' 18",9 .
With a magnifying power of 231,8 , * I saw it so plainly that the little notch in the pin 's head between the coils of the wire making the head , appeared like a narrow black belt surrounding the pin in the manner of the belts of Jupiter .
This notch by the microscopic projection measured,00475 inch ; and subtended an angle , at the centre of the mirror , of o",4o07 With 303,5 I saw the belt still better , and could follow it easily in its contour .
With 432,0 I could see down into the notch , and saw it well defined within .
With 5,2,3 the pin 's head was a very striking globular object , whose diameter might easily be divided by estimation into ten parts , each of which would be equal to o",364 .
With 925,6 I saw all the same phenomena still plainer .
The result of this experiment is , that an object having a diameter , o425 may be easily seen in my telescope to be a round body , when the magnified angle under which it appears is 2 ' 18,9 , and that with a high -power a part of it , subtending an angle of o"',364 may be conveniently perceived .
When I considered the purpose of this experiment , I found the result not sufficient to answer my intention ; for as the size of the object I viewed obliged me to use a low power a doubt arose whether the instrument would be equally distinct when a higher should be required .
To resolve this question , it was necessary either to remove my objects to a greater distance , or to make them smaller .
2d !
Experiment , with small Globules of Sealing-wax .
I melted some sealing-wax thinly spread on a , broad knife , and dipped the point of a fine needle , a little heated , into it , Which took up a small globule .
With some practice I soon acquired the art of making them perfectly -round and extremely small To prevent my seeing them at a distance in a different aspect from that in which they were measured under the microscope I fixed the needles with sealing-wax on small slips of cards before the measures were taken .
Eight of these globules of the following dimensions o466 , O325,0290 0o2194,0210 oig o44 , o0763 were placed upon the post in my garden , and I viewed them in the telescope .
With a power of 231,8 I saw all the first seven numbers well defined , and round , and could see their gradual decrease very precisely from No. 1 to No. 7 .
With 3035 I saw them better , and had a glimpse of No. 8 , but Could not be sure that I saw it distinctly round ; though the magnified angle was 3 ' 18l",2 .
With 43o,0 they are all very palpable objects , and , as a solid body , No. 8 may be seen without difficulty ; at the centre of the mirror it subtends an angle of o',653 .
Withl attention we may also be sure of its roundness ; but here the magnified angle is not less than 4 ' 42",1 .
With 522,3 I see them all in great , perfection as spherical bodies and the magnitude of No. 7 may be estimated in quarters of its diameters .
The angle is " ,2,53 , and one quarter of it is 0"4313 .
No. 8 may be divided into two halves with ease ; each of which is o",327 .
With 925,4 I saw No. 8 still better ; but sealing-wax is not bright enough for so high a power .
By this experiment it appears , that with a globule so small as , o076b3 of a substance not reflecting much light , the mag nified angle must be between 4 and 5 minutes before we can see it round .
But it also appears that a telescope with a sufficient power , will show the disk of a faint object when the angle it subtends at the naked eye is no more than o",653G 3d Exp eimmnt , with Globules-of Silver .
As the objects made of sealing-wax , on account of their colour , did not appear to be fairly selected for these investigations , I made a set of silver ones .
They were formed by running the end of silver wires , the 3o,5th and Moth part of an inch in diameter , into the flame of a candle .
It requires some practiceto get them globular , as they are very apt to .
assume the shape of a pear ; but they are so easily made that we have only to reject those which do not succeed .
Thirteen of them , in a pretty regular succession of magnitudewere selected and placed upon the post .
Their dimensions were,03956 o037i,0329 0317 , O272 o0260 oo87 , o178 , o164 012,01137 , oo8oo 0o556 .
For the sake of more convenience I had removed my telescope from its station in the library to a work-room .
The distance of the objects from the mirror of the telescope , measured with deal -rods , was here only g37o,5 inches ; and the focal length of the mirror , the magnifying powers of the telescope ; and the angles subtended by the objects have been calculated accordingly .
With 522,7 1 see all the globules , from No. 1 to No.:3 , perfectly -well and can estimate the latter in quarters of its diameter .
The angle it subtends at the centre of the mirror is 0",484 --and one quarter of it is o " , 121 .
With the same power I see the wires which hold the balls , so , well that even , the , smallest of them may be divided into half its thickness .
It measures,00237 ; the angle is .
o"-,2o5 ; and half of it o1h ' 3o .
With 433,0 I see all the globules of a round form , and can by estimation divide No. i3 into two halves .
The magnified angle is here g ' 29 " , o , but as its diameter could by estimation he divided into two parts , the round form of a globule somewhat less might probably have been perceived , so that the magnified angle would perhaps not have much exceeded the quantity 2 ' i 8",9 that has been assigned before. .
After some time the weather became much overcast , andas the globules were placed over a cut hedge , the leaves and interstices of which did not reflect much light , they received the greatest part of their illumination from above .
This made them gradually assume the shape of half moons placed horizontally .
The dark part of these little lunes , however , did -not appear sensibly less than the enlightened part , so that there could not be any thing spurious about them .
By this experiment we find that the telescope acts very well with a high power , and will show an object subtending only o"/ ,484i so large that we may divide it into quarters of its diameter .
4th Experiment , with Globules of Pitch , Bee's-wax , and Brimstone .
, I had before objected to sealing-wax globules on account of their dingy-red colour ; in the last experiment a doubt was raised with regard to the silver ones , because they were perhaps too glossy .
In order to compare the effect of : different substances together in the same atmosphere , I put up three globules , No. i of silver , diameter , oi137 ; No. 2 of sealingwax , o 125 ; NTO .
3 of pitch , oo653 .
With 522,7 I saw No. i round , and could estimate L of its diameter .
The angle is o",989 ; 4 of it is O",247 .
I saw No. 2 -round , but of a dusky-red colour .
It is not nearly so bright as No. i ; nor does it appear quite so large as the proportional measure of the globuleswould require .
I can estimate -3 of its diameter .
The angle is o",979 ; and I of it iS O"',326 .
No 3 reflects so little light that I can barely perceive the globule , but not its form ; and yet it subtends an angle of o",568 .
To discover whether this ought to be ascribed entirely to the want of reflection of the pitch , I took up some white melted bee's-wax , by dipping the fine point of a needle perpendicularly into it .
This happened to be only half a globule , and its diameter was , o0o .
When I examined the object with 523 I saw it with great ease , and could estimate of its diameter .
The angle is o",914 ; and 4 of it is o",228 .
1 saw also that it was but half a globule .
I took up another , that I might have a round one ; but found thatagain I had only half a globule .
It was so perfectly bisected , that art and care united could not have done it better .
Its diameter was , oi o8 .
In the telescope I saw its semiglobular form , and could estimate 4 .
of its diameter .
By some further trials it appeared , that a perfect globule of this substance could not be taken up , the reason of which it is not difficult to perceive ; for as it melts with very little heat , it will cool the moment the needle is lifted up ; and the surface , which cools first , will be flat .
The roundness of the objects being a material circumstance , I melted a small quantity of the powder of brimstone , and dipping the point of a needle into it , I found that globules , perfectly spherical and extremely small , might be taken up .
1 had one of them that did not exceed the 64oth part of an inch in diameter .
When four of the following sizes , ,oo962,009125,00475 , o002375 were placed on the post in the garden and viewed from the work-room station with 522,7 1 saw No. 1 , 2 , and round , but N 4o .
was invisible .
These globules reflect but little light , so that theyare not easily to be distinguished from the surrounding illumination of the atmosphere ; but when I placed some dark blue paper a few inches behind them , I then could also perceive No. 4 as a round body .
The angle it subtends is o " , eo7.,5th Experiment with Objects at a greater Distance .
Having carried the minuteness of the globules as far as appeared to be proper , I considered that a valuable advantage would be gained by increasing the distance of the objects .
The experiments might here be made upon a larger scale , and the body of air through which it would be necessary to view the globules would bring the action of the telescope more upon a par with an application of it to celestial objects .
On a tree , at 962,04 inches from the object mirror of the te .
lescope , I fixed the sealing-wax globules of the 2d experiment .
The distance was measured by a chain compared with deal rods , and by calculation the altitude of the objects has been properly taken into the account .
With 502,6 No. 1 is a very large object ; so that were I to see a celestial body under the same angle , I could never miss take it for a small star , TIhe angle it subtends is o ' , 999 .
I see the diameters of No. ?
and 3 very clearly , and can divide them .
by esti]mation into two parts half of No. 3 iS o"It .
I see No. 4 and 5 as round bodies , but cannot divide them by estimation .
The diameter of No..is o"m .
No 6 may also be n , but 7 and 8 are iinvisible , These objects reflecting too little light , the silvei globules of the 8d experiment were placed on the tree .
It will be right to mention that they were all so far tarnished by having been out in the open air for more than a fortnight , that no improper reflection was to be apprehended .
The air being uncommonly clear , I saw with os6 the globules No. i\ , X , 3 , 4 , by , and 6 , as well defined black balls I could easily distinguish 4 of the diameter of No. 6 ; which is o1139 .
With 4t5,7 I saw them all round as far as No. to included With 502,6 I saw No. 9 and io very sharp and black , and .
could divide No. to into two parts each of which would be With a new lens , power 759,7 , I saw No. lo better than with 502,6 , and could with ease distinguish it into halves , or even third parts of its diameter .
j of it is o " , o89 .
With 223 , i I saw them all as far as No. to included as visible objects , but the smallest of them were mere points .
No. 6 might be divided with this power into two parts ; each being o",279 .
With 992,1 I saw No. to sharp and round , The magnified angle is only a ' t8",3 .
One half of No. 6 may be perceived with great ease .
The weather being as favourable as possible , I saw with 415,7 the globule No. lo round at first sight ; the magnified angle is a ' Sll/ ,2 .
I can see No. 12 steadily round ; the angle is oil4 72 .
It is however a mere point , and divisions of it cannot be made .
With a new io-feet reflector , power 540 , the globule No. 1o is beautifully well defined , and -L of it may be estimated ; the angle is o",268 ; v of it is o",134 .
With the old reflector , and 502,6 , I see No. 12 steadily round .
No. 7 , ii , and 13 , have met with an accident , and could not be observed .
6th Experiment zwith illumiinated Globules .
The night being very dark , 8 silver globules , from , o291 to,0o596 in diameter were placed on the post , and illuminated by a lantern held up against them .
With 522,7 1 saw them all perfectly well , but the small quantity of light thrown on them was not sufficient to make angular experiments upon them .
As objects I saw them as easily as in the day time .
Probably the phases of the illuminated disks I saw might be such as the moon would show when about 9 or lo days old .
The angle of No. 8 , had it been full , would have been o " , ,519 .
A better way of illumination might be contrived .
SPURIOUS DIAMETERS OF CELESTIAL OBJECTS .
Observations and Experiments , wit/ h Remarks .
July 17 , 1779 .
With a 7-feet reflector , power 280 , I saw the body of Arcturus , very round and well defined .
I saw also .
Ursce majoris and other stars equally round , and as well defined .
REMARKS .
( .
) As these diameters are undoubtedly spurious , it follows that , with the stars , the spurious diameters are larger than the real ones , which are too small to be seen .
Sept. 9 , 1779 .
The two stars of ?
Bootis are of unequal diameters ; one of them beings about three times as large as the other .
( 2 .
) From this and many estimations of the spurious diameters of the stars* it follows , not only that thwey are of different sizes , but also that under the same circumstances , their dimensions are of a permanent nature .
August 25 , i78o The large star of -y Andromeda is of a very fine reddish colour , and the small one blue .
( 3 .
) By this and many other observations it appears , that the spurious diameters of the stars are differently coloured , and that these colours arepermanent when circumstances are the same .
Nov 23 , 1 779 .
1 viewed a Geminorum with a power of 449 , and saw the two stars in the utmost perfection .
The vacancy between them was about 1i diameter of the largest .
I found when I looked with a lower power , that the proportion between the distance and magnitude of the stars underwent an alteration .
With ?
22 , the vacancy was i{ diameter , and with i 1 ?
, it was no more than i diameter of the smallest of the two stars , or less .
( 4 .
) By many observations , a number of instances of which may be seen in my catalogues of double stars , their spurious diameters are lessened by increasing the magnifying power , and increase when the power is lowered .
( s. ) It is also proved by the same observations , that the increase and decrease of the spurious diameters , is not inversely as the increase and decrease of the magnifying power , but in a much less ratio .
Nov. 13 .
1782 .
The two stars of the double star 40 Lyncis , with a power of 46o are very unequal ; and with 227 they are extremely unequal .
( 6 .
) From this we find , that the magnifying power acts unequally on spurious diameters of different magnitudes ; less on the large diameters , and more on the small ones .
Aug. 20 , i781 .
I saw ?
Bootis with 460 , and the vacancy between the two stars was 1* diameter of the large one .
I then reduced the aperture of the telescope by a circle of pasteboard from 6,3 inches to 3 , , and the vacancy between the two stars became only 2 diameter of the small star .
The proportion of the diameters of the two stars to each other was also changed considerably ; for the small one was no-w at least -3 if not 3 of the large one .
( 7 .
) This shows that when the aperture of the telescope is lessened , it will occasion an increase of the spurious diameters and when increased will reduce them .
( 8 .
) It also shows that the increase and decrease of the unequal spurious diameters , by an alteration of the aperture of the telescope , is not proportional to the diameters of the stars : ( 9 .
) But that this alteration acts more upon small spurious diameters , and less upon large ones .
Aug. 7 , 1783 .
1 tried some excessively small stars near y Aquilae .
When v was perfectly distinct and round , the ertremely small -stars were dusky and ill defined ; the excessizoely small ones were still less defined .
As there are stars of all sizes in this neighbourhood , I saw some so very minute , that they only had the appearance of a small dusky spot , approaching to mere nebulosity .
By very long attention I perceived many small dusky nebulous spots , which had it not been for this attention might have been in the field of view without the least suspicion .
, ( o. ) From this we find that stars when they are extremely small , lose their spurious diameters , and become nebulous .
Jully 7,1780 .
I saw the spurious diameter of Arcturus gradually diminished by a haziness of the atmosphere till it vanished entirely .
A more circumstantial account of this observation has already been given ; and some other causes that afect the spurious diameter of the stars , have been pointed out in the same paper , such as tremulous air , wind , and hoar-frost .
January 3S , 178g.r The star in the back of Columba makes a spectrum , about A or 6 " long , and about 2 " broad , finely coloured by the prismatic power of the atmosphere at this altitude .
July S8 , 1783 .
Fomalhaut gives a beautiful prismatic spectrum , on account of its low situation .
July 17 , 1781 .
With a new lens , power between 5 and 6r hundred , I saw ( Aquarii , and found the vacancy between the two stars exactly 2 diameters .
With my old one , power only 460 , it was full 2 diameters .
As it should have been larger with the high power than with the low one , it shows that the best eye-lens will give the least spurious diameter .
0 See Phil. Trans. for 3803 , page 2z4 . ?
z Oct. 12 , 1782 .
I tried a new plain speculum , made by a very good workman , and found that when I viewed a Geminorum with 460 , the vacancy between the two stars was barely ij diameter , but the same telescope and power with my own small speculum , made the distance 92 diameters , so that the figure of this mirror affects the spurious diameters of the stars .
( 1 i. ) Hence we may conclude that many causes will have an influence on the apparent diameter of the spurious disks of the stars ; but they are so far within the reach of our knowledge , that with a proper regard to them .
, the conclusion we have drawn in Rem .
( 2 .
) " that under the same circumstances " their dimensions are permanent , " will still remain good .
SPURIOUS DIAMETERS OF TERRESTRIAL OBJECTS , WITH SIMILAR REMARKS .
7th Experiment with Silver Globules .
A number of silver globules were put on the post , before they had been tarnished ; and the sun shone upon them .
When I viewed them in the telescope , there was on each of them a lucid appearance resembling the spurious disk of a star .
I could distinguish this bright spot from the real , diameters of the globules perfectly well , and found it much less than they Were .
REM .
( 1 .
Hence we conclude that the terrestrial , spurious disks of glohules are less than the real disks ; whereas we have seen , in Remark ( i. ) of the celestial spurious disks , that these are larger than the real ones .
8th Experiment .
The luminous spots , or spurious disks of the globules were of unequal diameters .
The globule No. l had the largest disk , and the smaller ones the least ; and the gradation of the sizes followed the order of the numbers .
( 2 .
) This agrees with the spurious disks of celestial objects : the stars of the first , second , and third magnitude having a larger spurious disk than those that are of inferior magnitudes .
9th Experiment .
I found that there was a considerable difference in the colour of the spurious disks ; one of them was of a beautiful purple colour , another was inclined to orange , a large one was straw coloured , a small one pale-ash coloured , and most of them were bluish-white .
( .
) With respect to colours , therefore , the terrestrial also agree with the celestial spurious disks .
moth Experiment .
I made two globules of different diameters , and placed them ) very near each other , so that their spurious disks might re-semble those of a double star ; this succeeded perfectly well .
I viewed them with different powers .
With 177 , the vacancy between them is X diameter of the large star .
With 232 , it is idiameter .
With 3o3,8 , it is I8 diameter .
With 432,3 , it is i4 .
( i. ) This experiment proves that the spurious diameters of the globules are also in this respect like the spurious disks of the stars ; for they are proportionally lessened by increasing the magnifying power , and increased when the power is lowered .
( s5 .
) When the estimations are compared with the powers , it will also be seen that the increase and decrease of the spurious disks of the globules is not inversely as the powers , but in a much less ratio .
iith Experiment .
Two other globules of different sizes were examined and With 706,3 they were pretty unequal .
With 52g,7 they were considerably unequal .
With 3o3,8 they were very unequal .
( 6 .
) This proves that the effect of magnifying power is unequally exerted on spurious diameters ; and that , as with celestial objects , so with terrestrial this power acts more on the small spurious disks than on the large ones .
12th Experiment .
I viewed a different artificial double star with 52,7 , and keeping always the same power , changed the aperture of the telescope .
With the inside rays I found them considerably unequtal , and 21 diameters of the largest asunder .
The spurious disks are perfectly well defined , round , and of a planetary aspect .
With all the mirror open , they are also round and well defined .
With the outside rays , they are near4 diameters of the largest asunder , and are also round and distinct , but surrounded with Jiashing rays and bright nodules in continual motion .
( 7 .
) This shows that the spurious terrestrial disks , in this respect again resemble those of the stars ; increasing when the aperture is lessened , and decreasing when it is -enlarged .
i3th Experiment .
With the same magnifying power 432,3 , but a change of aperture , I viewed two equal globules , and two unequal ones .
With the inside rays the equal:globules were i diameter asunder .
With all the mirror open , they were 1+2 diameter asunder .
And with the outside rays they were 2 diameters asunder .
The unequal globules , with the inside rays , were a little unequal , and i diameter of the large one asunder .
With the outside rays they were considerably unequal , and 2 diameters of the large one asunder .
( 8 .
) By these experiments it is proved , that the increase and decrease of the diameters occasioned by different apertures is not proportional to the diameters of the spurious disks .
( 9 .
) But that the change of the apertures acts more on the small , and less on the large ones .
14th Experiment .
No. i of a set of globules , has the largest spurious diameter .
No. 3 is larger than No. 2 ; whereas No. 2 has ' the largest real diameter .
It is inclined to a greenish colour .
No. : 3 is Know reddish , and is larger than No. i , which is at present less than No. - .
No. i grows-bigger , and is now the largest .
The sun which had been shining , was obscured by some clouds , but the spurious diameters of the globules I was viewin &amp; remained visible , and were almost as bright as when the sun shone upon them .
I saw one of globules lose -its spurious diameter while the sun continued to shine .
After some time the spurious diameter came on again and very gradually gre brighter , but not larger .
The colour of one of the globules being of a beautiful purple , changed soon after to a brilliant white .
The sun being obscured by some clouds , a globule -lost its spurious diameter , and acquired the shape of an half moon , of the size of the real disk or diameter of the globule .
I saw the sun break out again , and the half moon was gradually transformed into a much smaller spurious disk .
( ic. ) The spurious disks of globules are lost for want of proper illumination , but do not change their magnitude on that account The brightness of the atmosphere in a fine day is sufficient to produce them ; though the illumination of the sun is generally the principal causeof them .
( ii .
) The diameters of spurious disks are liable to change from various causes ; an alteration in the direction of the illumination will make the reflection come from a different part of the globule , which can hardly be expected to be equally polished in its surface , or of equal convexity every where , being very seldom perfectly spherical ; but as upon the whole the figure of them is pretty regular , the apparent diameter of the spurious disks will generally return to its former sizes l5th Experiment , with Drops of Quicksilver .
At a time of the year when bright sun-shine is not very frequent , I found that my silver globules , would seldom give no an opportunity for experiments on spurious disks ; to , obviate this inconvenience , I used small drops of quicksilver .
They are more lucid , and will give a bright spot with very little sunshine .
Many of these drops of all sizes were exposed upon a plate of glass , and some on slips of steel .
The management of them is a little different from that of the globules .
For in order to represent a double star these must be placed one almost behind the other , as otherwise they cannot be brought near enough without running together .
The following general observation will include all the necessary particulars .
The bright spots on drops of quicksilver are very small compared to the size of the drops .
They are not proportional to the magnitude of the drops , though less on the small ones and greater on large ones .
In some of the large ones the bright spot is about -tO or of the diameter of the drop .
The magnitude of the luminous spots is liable to changes , but is rather more permanent than with the silver globules .
There is a little difference in the colour of the luminous spots ; they are generally of a brilliant white , but sometimes they incline to yellow , and the small ones to ash-colour .
With high magnifying powers they are very well defined , and , on account of their brightness , will bear these powers better than the silver globules .
If M and m , stand for the diameters of the large and small mirror of my telescope , then will an aperture " + Mt 2 give half the light of the telescope .
With this I examined two of the drops , and found the luminous spots upon them with 9254 nearly equal , and Ad diameters of the largest asunder .
706,3 nearly equal , and above 2 diameters of the largest asunder .
432,3 pretty unequal , and 2 diameters of the largest asunder .
177 , o considerably unequal , and iA diameter of the largest asunder .
I examined also two other drops , with different apertures , without changing the power , which was 706,3 .
Edith the inside rays they were very little unequal , and i diameter of the largest asunder .
With the outside rays they were considerably unequal , and i4 diameter of the largest asunder .
From what has been said , it appears that all the remarks which have been made with regard to the spurious disks of the silver globules are confirmed by the luminous spots on the drops of quicksilver .
There is a difference in the proportion which the spurious disks on quicksilver bear to the drops , and that on the silver globules to the size of the globules the latter also give a greater variety of colours and magnitudes than those on quicksilver ; these are circumstances of which it would be easy to assign the cause , but they can be of no consequence to the result we have drawn from the experiment .
16th Experi nt , with black and zvh'te Circles .
I tried to measure some of the spurious disks by projecting them on a scale with a moveable index , but found their diameters were too small for accuracy by this method ; , fo r this reason I had recourse to artificial measuring-disks , and pre pared a set of eleven white circles on a black ground , and eight black ones on a white ground .
In order to guard against I deceptions , I fixed them up against a tablet !
Ai inches from the eye , where it was intended to project the spurious disks of the globules , and examined them at that distance with the naked eye .
Comparing then the size of the black to the white , I judged Noi 'of the black to be a little larger than No. 6 of the white -circles .
By a measure taken afterwards , it appeared that the black one was,4o and the white,9 .
Without supposing that every estimation may be made at this distance with equal accuracy , t the hundredth part of an inch , it is sufi- .
ciently evident that no material deception can take place in estimating by either of the sets of circles on account of their colour .
17th Experiment , with .
dferent Ii natin A similar experiment was made in the microscope , by which the globules were measured .
Two of them were placed on the measuring stand , and with an illumination from below , they appeared black , and were projected on white paper .
The dia- .
meter of each globule and the distance between them were then measured .
After this , I caused the illumination to come from above , and the globules being now of a silvery white , were projected on a slate .
In this situation , when I repeated the former measures , no difference could be perceived .
i8th Expernment .
Measures of spun $ Disks .
The spurious disk of a globule wxas then projected on the tablet where the white circles were placed .
While I was comparing it with No. 4 , which is,3i in diameter and estimated it to be a little less than the circle , the spurious disk , grew brighter but it remained still of the same size ; so that a variation in the quantity of the illumination will make no difference .
, Every thing being now arranged for the measurement , I viewed the spurious diameter , with a magnifying power of 522,7 , and compared it to the circles which succeeded each other by small differences of magnitude .
With all the mirror , from the centre to 8,8 inches open , the diameter of the spurious disk was , ft inches .
With 6,3 inches open , it was less than 4o and larger than '355 .
With 5 inches open , it was,4cx XVith 4 inches open , it was,42 .
With 3 inches open , it was,465 nearly .
From these measures it might be supposed that by lessening the quantity of light , we bring on a certain indistinctness which gives more diameter to the spurious object ; to prove that this is not the cause of the increase , I used the following apertures .
With an annular opening from 6,5 to 8,8 inches , the spurious disk was rather less than , i8 .
WithII another from 5 to 8,8 it was exactly , i8 .
With an opening from 4 to 6,5 it was,22 .
With another from 1,6 to 4 it was 42 .
( 12 .
) Now since the outside rim from 6,5 to 8,8 , which reflected C leSs than half the light of the mirror , produced a spurious disk less than,18 in diameter , and the whole light as we have seen gave a disk of,3 1 , it is evidently not the quantity of the light , but the part of the mirror from which it is reflected , that we are to look upon as the cause of the magnitude of the spurious disks of objects .
( 13 .
) These measures therefore point out an improvement in my former method of putting any terrestrial disk we suspect to be spurious to the test .
For the inside rays of a mirror , as before , will increase the diameter of these disks , but the outside rays alone will have a greater effect in reducing : it , than when the inside rays are left to join with them .
L9th Experiment .
Trial of Estimations .
I placed two silver globules at a small distance from each , other upon the post , but without measuring either the globules or their distance .
When I viewed them with 522,7 they appeared in the shape of two half:moons in an horizontal situation .
The unenlightened parts of them were also pretty distinctly visible .
I estimated the vacancy between the cusps of the lunesto be i diameter of the largest .
On measuring the diameters and distance under the micro- .
scope , it appeared that the largest was,0312 ; a quarter of which is,0078 .
The distance of the globules from each other measured , o 111 .
The difference in the estimation , oo33 is lessthan 1 , part of an , inch .
The experiment was repeated with a change of the distance of the globules from each other .
They were then estimated to be less than the diameter of the large one asunder , but full that of the small one .
When they were measured it was found that their distance was 026 , o 8 , and the diameter of the small one was,0247 , which estimation is still .
more accurate than the former .
20oth Experiment .
Use of the Criterion .
It remained now to be ascertained whether these half moonswere spurious or real ; for although I could also imperfectlyperceive the dark part of the disks of the globules , yet a doubt would arise whether the two halves were really of equal magnitude ; to resolve this 'questionI vie'wed them first with the inside rays of the mirror , then with the outside , and found .
that in both cases the distance of the lunes remained without the least alteration .
I viewed them also with the whole mirror open , but it occasioned no change .
g i. t Experiment .
Measures o the comparative Amount of the spunous Diameters , produced by the Inside and Outside Rays .
I divided the aperture of the mirror into two parts , one from o to 44 and the other from 44 to 8,8 inches .
When I , measured the spurious--diameter of a globule , the inside rays made it4o ; with all the mirror open it was 3 , a ; and with the outside rays it was Aeo .
( 14 .
) From this we may conclude that the diameters given by the inside rays , by all the mirror open , and by the outside ras , are in an arithmetical progression ; and that the inside rays will nearly double , the diameter given by the outside .
It remains however to be ascertained whether this will hold good with spurious disks of various magnitudes .
It will not be necessary to carry the divisions of the aperture farther ; for as the application of these experiments is chiefly intended for astronomical purposes , we can hardly do with less than half the mirror open ; and on the other hand with a very narrow rim of reflection from the outside of the mirror , disk tinctness would be apt to fail , e2d Experiment .
Tral of the Criterion on celestial Objects .
I viewed a Lyre with the outside rays , and found its spurious disk to be small ; with all the mirror open it was larger , and With the , inside rays it was largest .
a AS far as the imagination will enable us to compare objects we see in succession , the magnitudes appeared to be in an arithmetical progression .
23d Experiment .
I examined a Geminorum with 410,5 , and with.the outside rays the stars were considerably unequal , and 1i diameter of the largest asunder .
With all the mirror open they were more unequal and 1 ?
diameter of the largest .
With the inside rays they were very unequal , and j-I of the largest asunder .
These experiments show that , if it had not been known that the apparent disks of the stars were spurious , the application of the improved criterion of the apertures would have discovered them to be so- ; and that consequently the same improvement is perfectly applicable to celestial obj ects .
OBSERVATIONS ON THE NATURE AND MAGNITUDE OF MR. HARDING S LATELY DISCOVERED STAR .
It will be remembered that in a former Paper , where I investigated the nature of the two asteroids discovered by Signior PJIAZZI and Dr. OLBERS , I suggested the probability that more of them would soon be found out ; it may therefore be easily supposed that I was not much surprised when I was informed of Mr. HARDINKG'S valuable discovery .
On the day I received an account of it , which was the 24th of September , I directed my telescope to the calculated place of the new object , and noted all the small stars within a limited compass about it .
They were then examined with a distinct high magnifying power ; and since no difference in their appearance was perceivable , it became necessary to attend to the changes that might happen in the situation of any one of them .
They were delineated as in Fig. i , ( Plate I. ) which is a mere eye-draught , to serve as an elucidation to a description given with it in the journal ; and the star marked k , as will be seen hereafter , was the new object .
Sept. 25 .
The moon was too bright to see minute objects well , and my description the night before , for the same reason , bad not been sufficiently particular ; nor did I expect , from the account received , that the star had retrograded so far in its orbit .
Sept. 26 .
The weather being very hazy , no regular observations could be made ; but as I noticed very particularly a star not seen before , it was marked I in Fig. 2 , and proved afterwards to have been the lately discovered one , though still unknown this evening , for want of fixed instruments .
Sept. 27 .
1 was favoured with Dr. MASKELYNE'S account of the place of the star taken at the Royal Observatory , by which communication I soon found out the object I was looking for .
Sept. 29 .
Being the first clear night , I began a regular series of observations ; and as the power of determining small angles , and distinctness in showing minute disks , whether spurious or real , of the instrument I used on this occasion , has been sufficiently investigated by the foregoing experiments , there could be no difficulty in the observation , with resources that were then so well understood , and have now been so Ifully ascertained .
" Mr. HARDENG'S new celestial body precedes the very " small star in Fig. I , between 29 and 33 Piscium , and is a " little larger than that star ; it is marked A. fg h are taken " d from Fig. i. I suppose g to be of about the 9th magnitude , " so that the new star may be called a small one of the t 8th .
" With the iao-feet reflector , power 496,3 , I viewed it attentively , and comparing it with g and h , Fig. 3 , could find no difference in the appearance but what might be owing to its being a larger star .
By way of putting this to a trial , I changed the power to 879,4 , but could not find that it magnified the new one more than it did the stars g and h. " I cannot perceive any disk ; its apparent magnitude with " this power is greater than that of the star g , and also -a very little greater than that of h ; butin the finder , and the night"glass g isconsiderably smaller than the new star , and h is also a very little smaller .
" I compared it now with a star which in the finder appeared to be a very little larger ; and in the telescope with 8,79,4 the apparent magnitude of this star was also larger than that of the new one .
" As far as I can judge without seeing the asteroids of Mr. ' " PIAZZI and Dr. OLBERS at the same time with Mr. HARDING 's , " the last must be at , least as small as the smallest of the former , which is that of Dr. OLBERS .
" " The star k , Fig. a , observed Sept. 24 , is wanting , and was " therefore the object I was in search of , which by computation " must have been that day in the place where I saw it .
" " The new star being now in the meridian with all those to " which I am comparing it , and the air at this altitude being cs very clear , I still find appearances as before described : the " new object cannot be distinguished from the stars by mag. .
" nifying power , so that this celestial body is a true ASTEROID .
" Mr. BODE 's stars 19 , 25 and 27 Ceti are marked 7m , and by comparing the asteroid , which I find is to be called Juno , with these stars , it has the appearance of a small one of the 8th magnitude .
With regard to the diameter of Juno , which name it will at present be convenient to use , leaving it still to astronomers to adopt any other they may fix upon , it is evident that , had it been half a second , I must have instantly perceived a visible disk .
Such a diameter , when I saw it magnified 879,4 times , would have appeared to me under an angle of 7 ' 19",7 , one half ofwhich , it will be allowed , from the experiments that have been detailed , could not have escaped my notice .
Oct. i. Between flying clouds , I saw the asteroid , which in its true starry form has left theplace where I saw it Sept. 29. .
It has taken the path in which by calculation I expected it would move .
This ascertains that no mistake in the star was made when I observed it last .
Oct. 29 7h .
Mr. HARDING'S asteroid is again removed , but is too lov for high powers .
8h " S ' .
I viewed it now with 2o0,3 288,4 4,5 496,3 and 879,4 .
No other disk was visible than that spurious one which such small stars have , and which is not proportionally magnified by power .
With 288,4 , the asteroids had a larger spurious disk than a star which was a little less bright , and a smaller spurious disk than another star that was a little more bright .
Oct. A , with 410,5 .
The situation of the asteroid is now as in Fig. 4 .
I compared its disk , which is probably the spurious appearance of stars of that magnitude , with a larger , an equal , and a smaller star .
It is less t han the spurious disk of the larger , equal to that of the equal , and larger than that of the smaller star .
The gradual difference between the three stars is exceedingly small .
" With 496,3 , and the air uncommonly pure and calm , I see " so well that I am certain the disk if it be not a spurious one , is less than one of the smallest globules I saw this morning in the tree .
" ' The diameter of this globule was,02 .
It subtended an angle of Pil 429 , and was of sealing-wax ; had it been a silver one , it would have been still more visible .
With , 8794 .
All cwparative magnitudes of the asteroid and stars , remain as with 496,3 .
I see the minute double star q Ophiuchi * in high perfection , which proves that the air is clear , and the telescope in good order .
The asteroid being now In the meridian , and the air very pure , I think the comparative diameter is a little larger than that of an equal star , and its light also differs from star-light .
Its apparent magnitude , however , can hardly be equal to that of the smallest globule I saw this morning .
This globule measured , o1358 , and at the distance of 9620,4 inches subtended an angle of o",214 .
When I viewed the asteroid with 879,4 I found more hazin-ess than an equal star would have given : but this I ascribe to want of light .
What I call an equal star , is one that in an achromatic finder appears of equal light .
Oct. 7 .
Mr. HARDING'S asteroid has continued its retrograde motion .
The weather is not clear enough to allow the use of ligh powers .
Oct. 8 .
If the appearance resembling the spurious disks of small stars , which I see with 410,5 in Mr. HARDING'S asteroid , should be a real diameter , its quantity then by estimation may amount to about od,3 .
This judgment is founded on the facility with which I can see two globules often viewed for this purpose .
The angle of the first is o " , L29 , and of the other o0,214 ; and the asteroid might be larger than the latter , but certainly was not equal to the former .
With 496,3 , there is an -ill defined hazy appearance , but nothing that may be called a disk visible .
When there is a glimpse of more condensed light to be seen in the centre , it is so small that it must be less than two-tenths of a second .
To decide whether this apparent condensed light was a real or spurious disk , I applied different limitations to the aperture of the telescope , but found that the light of the new star was too feeble to permit the use of them .
From this I concluded that an linerease of light might now be of great use , and viewed the asteroid with a fine io-feet mirror of -2 inches diameter , but found that nothing was gained by the change .
The tem , perature indeed of these large mirrors is very seldom the same as that of the air in which they are to act , and till a perfect uniformity takes place , no high powers can be used .
The asteroid in the meridian , and the night beautiful .
After many repeated comparisons of equal stars with the asteroid , I think it shows more of a disk than they do , but it is so small that it cannot amount to so muchi as -tenths of a second , or at least to no more .
It is accompanied with rather more nebulosity than stars of tne same size .
Gx The night is so clear , that I cannot suppose vision at this altitude to be less perfect on the stars , than it is on day objects at the distance of 8cc feet in a direction almost horizontal .
Oct. i i. By comparing the asteroid alternately and often with equal stars , its disk , if it be a real one , cannot exceed 2 , or at most 3-tenths of a second .
This estimation is founded on the comparative readiness with which every fine day I have seen globules subtending such angles in the same telescope , and with the same magnifying power .
" The asteroid is in the meridian , and in high perfection .
I " perceive a well defined disk that may amount to 2 or 3-tenths " of a second ; but an equal star shows exactly , the same ap ?
" pearance , and has a disk as well defined and as large as that of the asteroid.".* RESULT AND APPLICA1 ION OF THE EXPERIMENTS AND OBSERVATIONS .
We may now proceed to draw a few very useful conclusions , from the experiments that have been given , and apply them .
to the observations of the star discovered by , Mr. HARDING ; and also to the similar stars of Mr. , PIAZZI and Dr. OLBERS .
These kind of corollaries may be expressed as follows .
, ( I. )A io-feet reflector will show the spurious or real disks .
of celestial and .
terrestrial objects , when their diameter is .
of a second of a degree ; and when every circumstance is fai vourable , such a diameter may be perceived so distinctly , that it can be divided by estimation into two or three parts .
( 2 .
) A disk , of X of a second in diameter , whether spurious or real , in order to be seen as a round , well defined body,. .
requires a distinct magnifying power of J or 6 hundred and must be sufficiently bright to bear that power .
( s. ) A real disk of half a second in diameter will become 0o much larger by the application of a magnifying power of 5 or 6 hlundrted , that it will be easily distii guished from an equal spurious one , the latter not being affected by power in the same proportion as the forimer .
( 4 .
) The different effects of the inside and outside rays of a mirror , with regard to the appearance of a disk , are a criterion that will show whether it is real or spurious , provided its diameter is more than i of as cond .
( s. ) When disks , either spurious or real , are less than i of a second in diameter , they cannot be distinguislhed from each other ; because the magnifying power will not be sufficient to make them appear round and well defined .
( 6 .
) The same kind of experiments are applicable to tele .
scopes of different sorts and sizes but will give a different result for the quantity which has been stated at v of a second of a degree .
This will be more when the instrument is less perfect , and less when it is more so .
It will also di-ffr even with the same instrument , according to the clearness of the , air , the condition , and adjus .
tment of the mirrors and the practical habits of the obseVVer .
With regard to Mr. HARDING'S new starry celestial body , we have shown by observation , that it resembles , in every respect , the two Nother lately discovered ones of Mr. PIAZZI and -Dr .
OLBERs ; so that Ceres , Pallas , and Juno , are.erta-inly three individuals of the saespecies .
That they are beyohd comparison smaller than any of the seven planets cannot be questioned , when a telescope that will show a diameter of 4 of a second of a degree , leaves it undecided whether the disk we perceive is a real or a spurious one .
A distinct magnifying power , of more than , 5 or 6 hundred , has been applied to Ceres , Pallas , and Juno , but has either left tus in the dark , or at least has not fully removed every doubt upon this subject .
The criterion of the apertures of the mirror , on account of the smallness of these objects , has been as little successful ; and every method we have tried has ended in proving theirresemblance to small stars .
It will appear , that when I used the name asteroid to denote the condition of Ceres and Pallas , the definitionr I then gave of this term X will equally express the nature of Juno , which , by its similar situation ; between Mars and Jupiter , as well as by the smallness of its disk , added to the considerable inclination and excentricity of its orbit , departs from the general condition of planets .
, The proprietytherefore of 'using the same appellation forth latelydiscovered celestial body cannot be doubted .
Had Juno presented us with a link of a chain , uniting it to those great bodies , whose rank in the solar system I have alsodefinedt by some approximation of a motion in the zodiac , or by a magnitude not very different from a planetary one , it might have been an inducement for us to suspend our judge * See Phil. Trans. for x8o , p. 229 , line IO .
t Ibid. page 224 , line 3 of the same Papery meant with respect to aclassification ; 'but the specifc difference between planets and asteroids appears now by the addition of a third , individual of the latter species to be more fully established , and that crcumstance , in my opinion , has added more to the ornament of our system than the discovery of another planet : could haveddne .
Slough , near Windsor , Dec. i , 18i4 .

