XIV .
Continuation of an Account of the Changes that have bappened in the relative Situation of double Stars .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F. R. S. Read June 7 , 1804 .
IN my former Paper , * I have given the changes which have happened in the situation of six double stars .
When the causes of these observed changes in the double star Castor were investigated , I had recourse to the most authentic observations I could find , of the motions in .
right-ascension and " polar distance of this star .
But the Tables which have been lately published , in the last volume of the observations made by the Astronomer Royal at Greenwichgive us now the proper motions of 36 principal stars , of which a Geminorum is one ; and , as the motion of this star , especially in north polar distance , is very different from what it has been supposed in my former examination , it will be necessary to review the arguments which have been used , in order to ascertain what will be the result of this new motion .
We shall here again follow the order of the paragraphs of the former Paper , and denote those which treat of the same motions , with the same letters , that they may be readily compared .
Single Motions .
( a ) The small star x cannot be alone in motion , as we have now , in the new Tables I have mentioned , an evident proof that the large star is not at rest .
( b ) As the observations of the Astronomer Royal have ascertained the motion of Castor , so it is no less evident , from the series of observations which has been given in my Paper , that its smaller companion has also changed , if not its real situation , at least its relative one with respect to the large star .
Let us therefore examine , whether the motion of a can be the cause of the apparent change that has taken place in the relative situation of these two stars .
The annual proper motion of Geminorum , in right ascension ; , by the new Tables , isol , I ; which , in 2j31 years , will amount to 3",525 .
The annual proper motion in polar distance , by the F~~~~Aa same Tables , is offo ; which , l in the same time , will amount to o",94 , the former-motion being retrogrades and the latter to-wards the south .
Let FP , in Figure 1 , ( Plate IX .
) be the parallel of Castor , and make opal'equal to 2$`78,5 ; which wilt be the quantity of its motion in , right ascension in the par lel , when it is 3525 in the equator .
At right angles to a P , Mike ' all equal to 94o ; and this will represent the motion of the star in polar distance towards the south .
Draw the line ax so as to make an angle of 32 47 ' with the parallel Fz P on the north preceding side , andplace x at the distance of 3765 from a. Then will a and x be the situation in which these two stars were observed in the-year 1779 ; their apparent distance , estimated in diameters of the large star , being 1'1 ; and the angle of position , as has been stated 32§ 47 ' north-preceding .
If the star x had been at rest while as moved towards a. " , the .
relative situation of the two stars in the year 1803 would have been represented by cWM x ; that is to say , the apparent disks of these two stars would have been hardly It diameter of the largest asunder , and the angle of position x c " PI must have tbeen 860 2 , ' north-precedi-tg .
But this is quite inconsistent with the observations that have been given according to which , the .
small star , in the year 1803 , was situated at x ' .
It is therefore proved , that the motion of alone cannot account for the change which has taken place .
( c ) If the motion of Castor should be only an apparent one , ansing from the motion of the solar system , then the proper motion of the sun must be just the reverse of that which the new Tables assign to a Geminorum .
This being admitted let us examine what will be the result with regard to the relative situation of the small star , which , since only the sun is supposed to be in motion , must now remain at rest , as well as a. The effect of the parallax , which we are now considering , is invrsely as the distances of the stars which are affcted by it .
Hence arise the three cases which have been examined in my first Paper , When a line from the sun to Castor , Oa , * is perpendicular to the line car , joining the two stars , no change in their relative , situation can take place , arising from parallax , which will act equally on both .
For , -let a , a- " and a , in Fig. 9 , be placed as they were in Fig. ii and the real motion of the sun from 0 to 0 ' , will produce the parallactic motion of Castor from a to a"l .
It will also occasion an apparent motion of x , equal to that of a , and in a parallel direction with ' it .
This star will therefore appear to have moved from x to xi , in the same time that the large star has moved from a to a " , so that their relative situation will remain unchanged .
( d ) If x be placed beyond as the effect of parallax , exerted ire the direction xx " , parallelto &amp; a " will be less upon this star than on Castor ; and its apparent motion must fall short of the See Figure i. of the former Paper , situation x ' .
The consequence of this will be an increase of the angle of position ; but , as we know , from the observations which heave been given , that this angle has been decreasing , it follows , that the small star cannot be admitted to have been at rest , if we place-it farther from us than a. ( e ) 'When the smallest of the two stars of our double star is supposed to be much nearer than the largest , the effect of parallax will carry it beyond w. ' Let its distance from us to that of a be , for instance , as 3123 to 6076 .
In this case , while s appears to move as far as .
a " , X will be seen to move to x " ; where its angle of position XI a " P ' , will be just 100 's northpreceding , as by observation it was found to be in the year 1So3 .
But , according to this hypothesis , the distance a " x " of the two stars , ought now to be nearly double what it was in 1779 ; and , since this is contrary to observation , we must also give up this last supposition Double Motions .
( f ) Let us now suppose a and x to be in motion , while the solar system remains at rest .
Then , since there will be noparallax that can affect the appearance of these motions , they must be real , and proper to each of the stars .
But the circum stances that must take place , in order to produce the phenomena which have been observed , are so particular , that we shall soon find the great improbability of such an accidental arrangement of them .
as would answer the end .
It has already been shown , in the paragraph ( c ) of the former Paper , that we cannot place the two stars at an equal distance from us ; and it would be the height of improbability to suppose them to move in parallel planes .
But , whatever may be the directions and velocities of the motions of the stars , or at whatsoever different distances we may place them , the effect which is to arise from these combined circumstances is positively determined ; for the star a must appear to move at the rate of 3s"1 23 of an arch of a great circle in 232years , and in the direction of 170 31 ' sout3preceing its parallel ; while the star x , in the same time , must seem to move over an arch of 4",179 , in a direction of 302 52 ' south-preceing the same parallel .
When these quantities , resulting from the proper motions of our new Tables , are substituted for those which have been used in the paragraph ( f ) of my former Paper , the arguments which it contains will remain in full force , and need not be here repeated .
( g ) The same argument which has been used in the first Paper , when the sun and the small star only were supposed to be in motion , will perfectly apply to the proper motion of Castor , as given in the new Tables .
For , as this motion is now to be accounted for by the motion of the sun , we have only to substitute the velocity of 3",123 , in a direction which makes an angle of 170 30 ' A6 " north-following with the parallel of a Geminorumn , for the quantity of the solar motion before used ; and to assign a proper motion to the small star , having a direction of 680 io ' south-preceding the parallel of Geminorum , with a velocity which if the star was at the distance of a from us , would carry it in 23 ?
years through 1",4303 .
' ( h ) When the sun and Castor only are supposed to be in motion , the former statement of the case will in every respect remain conclusive .
Motion of the three Bodies .
( i ) It remains now only to be shown , that the arguments which are contained in my first Paper , against the probability of a supposition which ascribes all the observed phenomena to three real motions , will not be affected by the given alteration in the proper motion of Castor .
Without repeating any part of the discussion of the former paragraph ( i ) , it will be sufficient if I point out three motions , such as will answer the required purpose .
Let the solar motion , as before , be towards x Herculis , with such a~ velocity as will in 23 ?
years produce a parallactic motion , at the distance and situation of a Geminorum , amounting to 21,2805 , in a direction of 6o§ 36 ' 5711 south-preceding the parallel of that star .
Let Castor have a real motion , which in 23 ?
years would carry it over an arch of 2",1 41 , in a direction of 29 ' 23 ' 3 " north-preceding its parallel ; and let the real motion of the small star be such that in 23 ?
years , at its distance from us , supposed to be to that of Castor as 3 to 2 , it would describe an arch of 2",92 12 , in a direction of 180 50 ' 13 " south preceding .
Then would the parallactic motion of % , 211,28 05 , compounded with the real motion we have mentioned , give us an apparent annual motion equal to that which , in Dr. MASKELYNE 's Table , is called the proper motion in right ascension and polar distance of this star .
And the parallactic motion of xa= 1"J,52o03 , com-M pounded with the real motion we have assigned , would also produce an apparent annual motion which would correspond with my series of observed situations of this small star .
But , for the high improbability of such an hypothesis , I refer to the paras graph ( i ) of my former Paper .
What has been said of Castor , will apply to every other double star of which the proper motion may hereafter be assigned ; f~~~~~~~~~~~ for , unless the parallactic motion arising from the motion of the solar system should completely explain the observed changes , the same arguments will still remain in full force .
I shall nfow proceed to a continuation of my account of the changes that have happened in the relative situation of double stars , either in their position or their mutual distance ; and , in the following list of them , it will be seen that , of So changeable double stars which are given , 28 have undergone only moderate alterations , such as do not amount to an angle of lo degrees .
None of them however have been admitted , except where the change was at least so considerable , that the micrometer which was used on this occasion could ascertain the change with a proper degree of accuracy .
Two of the stars , indeed , have hardly suffered any alteration in the angle of position ; but , with them it will be found , that a change in their distance has been so ascertained as not to admit of any doubt .
Thirteen of the stars have altered their situation above to degrees , but less than 20 .
Three stars have undergone a change in the angle of position , of more than 20 , and as far as 3o degrees .
The six remaining stars afford instances of a still greater change , which , in the angle of position of some of them , amounts to more than 30 degrees ; in others , to near 40 , 50 , 6o , and upwards , to i3o degrees .
orHerculis .
11 , 2 .
The two stars of this double star have undergone a consi ' .
derable change in their angle of position .
By a measure taken May 20 , 1781 , it was 21 ' 28 ' south-following.-t April 3 , 1783 , two measures gave 23 29 ' .
A mean of two measures , taken i The numbers after the name of the star , refer to my Catalogue4 of double Stars , published in the Philosophical Transactions .
For instance , II , 2 , denotes that c " Herculis is the 2.d sta-t in the zd class .
+ By mistake , the first angle of position in my Catalogue is given 300 35 ' , instead of 71i 2Sf , and should be corrected .
See Phil Trans. Vol. LXXIL Part i. Pi Izz* IdDCCCIV .
3 A Feb. 21 and March 4 , 1802 , was 31i 38 ' .
By five measures , taken in 1803 and the beginning of 1804 , it was 3 14j ; and , June 3 , 1804 , by a very accurate measure , with an improved illumination of the wires , it was 820.0o .
This gives a change of I110 22 ' , in 23 years and 14 days .
It does not appear that the distance has undergone any perceptible alteration .
As we have now the proper motion of this star in Dr. MASKELYNE'S new Tables , we are enabled to enter upon an examination of the cause of the observed change ; but first it xviIi be necessary to mention , that in this and all the following stars , I have no longer supposed the solar motion to be directed towards x Herculis .
A point at no very great distance from this star has been chosen , for reasons which it would lead us too far from our present subject to assign , and which are of no absolute consequence to it .
The motion of the solar system , towards this assumed point , will produce an opposite parallactic motion , in every star that is not too far from us to be sensibly affected by it .
That change of place which astronomers have established by observation , and which is called the proper motion of a star , either may agree with this parallactic motion , ( in which case it will be only an apparent one , the star being really at rest , ) or it may be directed to another part of the heavens , so as to differ from our parallactic motion .
Whenever this happens , the star will have the following three motions a real , .
a parallactic , and an apparent one ; the latter being a composition-of the former two .
That a Herculis is one of ' those stars which has these three motions , will appear thus : the parallactic motion which this star , from its magnitude and consequent proximity , must be allowed to have , will carry it , in an angle of about 581 degrees , towards the south-preceding part of the heavens ; but the motion assigned to it in the new-Tables , has a direction towards the north .
Hence it follows , thata HLerculis has also a real motion , which , by its composition with the parallactic one , produces the tabular apparent one .
We are now to examine the effect of these three motions , on the position of the two stars of our double star , in order to see how far they will account for the observed change .
The two -stars are sufficiently different in magnitude , for us to expect a difference of parallax , on a supposition that their distances from us are inversely as their apparent magnitudes .
The change of the angle of position , arising from a superior parallactic motion of the large star , would have occasioned a retrograde motion of the small one ; but this , by my observations , has moved according to the order of signs ; its change of situation , therefore , will admit of no explanation from the effect of parallax .
The real motion of M Herculis , being such as , with the union of the parallactic one , will produce an apparent motion towards the north , is determined by the velocities and directions of the other two motions .
It must however be towards the northfollowing part of the heavens , and of a velocity considerably greater than the proper motion given in the new Tables ; but , since it is known to be compounded with the parallactic one , we are now only to consult the direction and velocity of that composition , which is such that the large star , in 2 years and,4 days , must have been carried 5",2~99 towards the north .
If the stars are not connected , the most favourable case we can put , will be to suppose the small one at rest , and at such a distance from us as to be entirely free from sensible parallaxs This being admitted , the large star , by its motion , should now have left the small one so far behind , that the distance of the centres of the two stars , ( which Sept. 2d , 1781 , by a measure with my lamp micrometer , was 4 " 3L " ' , ) should now be 7"'92 ; while , at the same time , the angle of position ought to have increased to 522 degrees .
My last observations , however ; give so different a result , that this hypothesis cannot be admitted .
If the small star , which is not so much less than .
the large one that we can justly place it at the above mentioned distance , should partake of some parallactic motion , it will then increase the objec- .
tions we have stated ; for , if the eflect of it should be only one quarter-ofwhat it is upon the large star , it will add to themagnitude of the angle of position , and increase the distance of the two stars .
Hence it follows , that , unless we should admit the supposition of three independent motions , the high improbability of which ; has been sufficiently shown , we have good reason to believe that the large star has , during the 23 last years , carried the small one along with itself , in the path it describes in space ; both being equally affected by parallax and real motion .
If this be admitted , a mutual revolution of the two stars will be the immediate consequence , when the laws of gravitation are taken into consideration ; and the change of position they have undergone , will be a necessary consequence of it , ~~~~y , &amp; ietis ' .
III , 91v This star being only of the 4th magnitude , and of the third class as a double star , we have no reason to expect a great change in the angle of position ; and yet , with the assistance of a very distant observation , which we have in MAYER'S Zodiacal Catalogue , a considerable change may be proved to have taken places The position , Nov. 2 , 1779 , was 840 o ' southfollowing.* Oct. lo , 1780 , it was 86§ 5 ; and , Feb. 7 , 1802 , it Was 890 10 ' .
The change , in 22 years and 97 days , is s lo ' .
From the given right ascension and declination of the two stars , in MAYER'S Catalogue , we compute , that their position in 1756 was 78§ 46 ' southfollowing ; which gives a change of.5 i4 ' in 23 years and 306 days , up to the time of my first observation .
The two periods , which are nearly equal , give a change of 100 24 ' , for 46 years and 38 days .
A motion of y Arietis , arising from systematical parallax , by which we may admit the smallest of the two stars ( on account of its supposed greater distance ) not to be so much affected as the large one , will perfectly account for the change ; unless , hereafter , the prUper motion of this star , when known- , should lead to a different conclusion .
, Urso .
I , 2 .
This double star has undergone a very extraordinary change in the angle of position .
Dec. 19 , 1781 , the smallest of the two stars was 530 47 ' south-following .
Feb. 4 , 18o2 , it was 0 31 !
' ; and , January 29 , 1804 , the position was only 20 38 ' .
This gives a motion of 510 9 ' , for 22 years 41 days , and amounts to 20 19 ' per year .
If an annual alteration to this amount should continue to take place for the future , a very few years would be sufficient to ascertain the cause of this change , as no motion but a revolving one could possibly explain the phenomenon .
If , on the contrary , the parallactic motion of the largest star should have occasioned the change of situation , which is not impossible , it wllI soon be verified by an increased distance of the two stars , .
accompanied with very little angular change in their position .
The little difference in the magnitude of the two stars , however , does not well agree with a supposition which gives a parallactic Motion to one of them only .
-y Andromedw .
III , A. It has already been noticed , on a former occasion , that this double star is one of the most beautiful objects in the heavens .
The striking difference in the colour of the two stars , suggests the idea of a sun and its planet , to which the contrast of their unequal size contributes not a little .
The position of the small .
star , when we consider that this double star is one of the third class , has undergone a sufficient change to deserve notice .
In the year 1781 , Oct. 15 , it was 190 37 , north-following .
Feb. SJ 1802 , 260 34 ' .
Feb. I J , 1803 , 2605'X ; and , Feb. 5 , 1804 , 270 39 ' .
The difference , in22 -years and 13 days , is 80 2 ' .
The distance of the two stars is too great to be accurately estimated by their apparent diameters ; and measures taken with a micrometer , unless fractions of a second of space could be strictly ascertained , would be useless .
If we suppose the small star sufficiently removed not to partake of the systematical parallax of the large one , the change of the angle of position may be accounted for , upon the principle of the solar motion .
The stars , however , are hardly so different in magnitude as would be required for that purpose .
We ought also to know , whether a proper motion has been observed in this star .
p Draconis .
II , 13 .
The change in the relative situation of the two stars of this double star is pretty considerable .
rihe position , Sept. 24 , 1 8oi , was 370 38 ' .
This may stand either for south-preceding or north-following , because the stars were then regarded as being equal .
March 4 , 1802 , a measure of the position gave 5Q0 ' Feb. A , 1804 , position 490 o/ south-preceding ; and , Feb. 6 , 1804 , 5o 0 ' .
A memorandum annexed to the observation says , that the preceding star is the smallest but that the diffkrence is so little as to require much attention to be perceived .
The alteration , in 22 years and 135 days , is i2 26 ' .
The two stars being nearly of an equal magnitude , we can have no inducement to suppose them to be at very different distances from us .
This makes it not probable that the difference of their parallactic motion should be the cause of the angle of position ; otherwise , the direction of that motion would be sufficiently favourable .
b Gemninorum .
II , 27 .
The measures of the position of the two stars of this double star are attended with great difficulty , on account of the faintness of the smallest ; a considerable disagreement will therefore be excuseable .
The position , Nov. i8 , 178i , Was 85 ?
i ' southpreceding .
Jan. 28,1802 , it was 76021 ' .
Feb. 4 , 1802 , 7305 ; and , Feb. 6 , 1804 , 690 52 ' .
The difference , in 22 years and 8o days , is 15 A59 ' .
We can have no assistance from observations made on the distance of the two stars , which is too great for estimation .
A parallactic motion , which , on account of the great difference in the magnitude of the stars , might be admitted , would lessen their distance , and make the angle of position retrograde , which , by my observation , has moved in a contrary direction .
A connection between the two stars is also rendered improbable , on account of the great number of small ones that are scattered in this neighbourhood , of which our small star may be one ; so that we have good reason to ascribe the change which has happened in the situation of our two stars , to a proper motion of R. ?
Draconis .
I , -8 .
In this star , we have to notice a great change of the angle of position , but none in the distance .
In the year 1782 , Sept. 4 , with 46o , I found the stars to be 1diameter of L. asunder .
May 22 , 1804 , they were still at the same distance of 12 dial meter of L. Oct. 20 , 1781 , the position was 63 " 14 ' northpreceding ; and , May 22 , 1804 , it was 840 29 ' which proves a change of 2i1 15 ' , in 22 years and 214 days .
This cannot be .
owing to a parallactic motion of the large star ; for the effect arising from such a motion , would have been directly contrary to the change which has taken place : the angle of position would have undergone a direct , instead of a retrograde alteration .
We are consequently assured that ?
Draconis cannot be at rest .
If future observations on the proper motion of the stars should furnish us with that of e , and if this motion should also fail to explain my observed change of the angle of position , without a change of distance , we shall then have good reason to admit this star into the list of those that have a small one revolving about it .
For , to ascribe an additional and independent motion to the small star , would be to have recourse to three separate motions , of given velocities , in given directions , and at given distances ; the improbability of which has been sufficiently pointed out .
4Aquarii .
II , 7 .
The position , Nov. 26 , 1779 , was 71 ' As north-following .
&gt; Sept. -24 , 1781 , it was 710 39g .
June 19 , 1782 , 720 7 ' .
Jan. 3 , 1802 .
780 3j .
The change is 60 58 ' , in 22 years and 38 days .
As the equality of the two stars gives little room for admitting a difference in their parallactic motions , we cannot reasonably ascribe the change of situation to that cause ; though , otherwise , the direction of such a motion in the largest of the two , would be siufficiently favourable .
The situation of the stars being much insulated , a connection between them may be admitted , with a high degree of probability.* ?
Jootis .
II , Is .
The change in the situation of the two stars of this double star is very remarkable .
The small star , April 1i5 , 178 % , was 650 Sgr north-following the large one .
In one of my sweeps , April 20 , 1792 , 1 perceived the small star in the 2o-feet rev flector ; and estimated its position , as it passed the field of view , .
to be about 85t north-preceding .
When the sweep was finished , I found that this star could not be in the situation I had just seen it , unless it had undergone a considerable change since the year 1 782 ; and , that no mistake had been made in the estima.tion of this evening , appeared very clearly , by a measure taken of its position , which actually gave 850 43',5 north-preceding .
This pointed out a retrograde motion of the small star .
March 22 , 1795 , the position was 84 , 56 ' .
April 1it 1802 , 82 67 ' ; and , April 2 , 1804 , I found it 830 4'A mean of the two last measures will give the present situation 8 a6 ' north-preceding ; and the total change of the angle of position , in zi years and 352 days , will be S 41 ' If it should be remarked , that the measure taken in 1795 appears to be inconsistent , it ought to be recollected , that the cause of this apparent motion remains to be investigated .
If the largest of the two stars should pass closely by the smallest , which , on account of its supposed great distance from us , may appear fixed , a very great and quick alteration in the angle of position will take place ; but , in a short time the change will become very moderate , and not long after insensible .
The same appearances may also happen , although the small star should not be fixed , but revolve about the large one ; for , if its orbit were in a plane with the line of sight , it would be seen to move with great velocity , about the opposition , and soon after appear to be almost stationary .
That either one or the other of the stars has really had a motion approaching to a straight line , is ascertained from an alteration of the distance ; for , in the year i78i , the vacancy between the two stars , with46o , was 3 diameters of the large one .
But , April 2 , 1804 , with 527 , their 'distance was greater than estimations by diameters can determine ; and , comparing g with X Bootis , I found that the stars of g were farther asunder than those of ir ; notwithstdnding , in the year 1782 , the former was placed in the 2d class , and the latter in the sd .
The change of the angle of position , if it were owing to a parallactic motion , would have been direct , instead of retrograde .
4 Leonis .
1 , 26 .
In a note added to this star , which is the 26th in my second Catalogue , a suspicion is expressed , that the two stars which compose this very minute double star , were receding from each other:* This has since been completely verified ; for , having seen the two stars close upon one another , and afterwards by degrees disengaged , as related in my second Catalogue , the separation between them kept on increasing , and , on the 21st of April , 1795 , they were 2 diameter of the small star asunder .
Feb. 5 , 1804 , with a power of 527 , the vacancy between them , was nearly i diameter of the small one .
The position has likewise undergone a sensible alteration .
Nov. i3 , 1782 , it was 200 5 south-following .
Feb. 4 , 1802 , 41 ' 28 ' .
Feb. 5 , 1804 , 4ot 17 ' .
^A mean of the two last measures , is 4ot , ' The change , therefore , amounts to i9',5D " , in 21 years and 84 days , and is probably owing to a real motion of X Leonis ; for the effect of a parallactic motion would have shown itself in a contrary alteration of the angle of -position .
X Mietis .
1X 64 .
This star is marked as being treble ; and the third star , as it happens , is now of use , in verifying the measures which have ascertained the relative change in the situation of the other two .
The position of rand its adjacent star , Oct. 29 , 1782 , was 19 9 , south-following ; and the third star was in the same line of that angle continued .
Oct. 17 , 1802 , the position was 340 1 ia and , Feb. 6 , 1804 , by a mean of two measures , 3i1 -5 ' ; which gives a change of 10 6 ' , in 21 years and ioo days .
That this change has taken place gradually , is confirmed by two observations of the third star .
Jan. 15 , 1795 , the distant star was observed to have remained a little behind , while the near one had advanced ; and , Oct. 17 , 1802 , it was again remarked , that the three stars were no longer in a line , and that the nearest small-star had advanced according to the order of the signs , which had increase I its an le of position .
The multitude of small stars in this neighbourhood , and the 3 Rst minuteness of the two that have been observed with x , as well as the distance of the farthest , render a connection between the three stars very improbable ; nor can the change of situation be owing to parallax , as this would have occasioned a retrograde motion of the small star , which , on the contrary , has been direct .
From these considerations we may conclude , that r Arietis has a proper motion , to which we must look for the cause of the observed change .
Corborng 1 , i6 .
This very minute double star has undergone a great alteration in the relative situation of the two stars .
Sept. 9 1781 , their position was 59 1 ' north-following ; and , Sept. 6 , 1802 , by a mean of two very accurate measures , it was 890 40 ' north-preceding ; which amounts to a change of 3i§ 1 ' , in 20 years and 362 days .
The distance of the two stars has not been subject to any sensible alteration .
Sept. 9 , 1781 , a very small division might be seen , with 46o .
August 30 , 1794 , they were so close that , with a io-feet reflector , and power of 6oo , a very minute division could but just be perceived .
April i , , 1803 , with a 1o-feet reflector , a very small division was also visible , with 400 , though better with Coo .
And , May 15 , 18o3 , I saw the sepia ration between the two stars , with the same 7-feet reflector , and magnifying power of 460 , with which I had seen it 22 years before .
The stars differ very little in magnitude ; so that : we have no reason to expect any effect from a difference of parallax .
Besides if the small one were out of the reach of it , a parallactic motion of the largest alone , would have occasioned the small one to move apparently according to the order of the signs ; but the motion has been retrograde .
1 Fl9 21 Ursa .
II 71 .
NoV .
17 , 1782 , the two stars were in the position of 360 451 north-preceding ; and , May 20 , 1802 , I found them 470 37 ' ; which gives a change of io 52 ' , in 19 years and 184 days .
A parallactic motion will account for it ; unless , hereafter , a proper motion of the large star should be found to have a difierent tendency .
EL .
4 Aqquai , 4 .
The position of the two stars , July 23 , 1783 , was 81§ 30 ' north preceding ; and , by a mean of two observations , August 28 and 29 , 18o2 , it was 610 L north-following .
Both the last : measures are positive , with regard to the position being following and not preceding , as it certainly was in the year 1783 .
This proves a change of 370 25 ' , in 19 years and.37 days .
The distance is perhaps a little increased .
Sept. 5 , 1782 , it was 7 diameter of S. August 29 , 1-802 , less than ?
diameter of S. A parallactic motion of the large star , would have brought on a retrograde motion of the small one , which , on the co ntrary , we find has been direct .
This proves a real motion , the nature of which cannot remain many years unknown ; its velocity , hitherto , having been at the rate of nearly 2 degrees per year , of angular change .
South-preceding , r Serpentis .
I , 8 i.* The position , March 7 , 1783 , was 490 48 ' south-preceding .
August 3o , 1802 , it was Ad j. The change is 90 17 ' , in 19 years and 176 days .
If the stars were a little more different in We now have the place of this double star in BOD E ' Catalogue , whore it is called Iia Serpentis .
magnitude , a parallactic motion of the largest would account for the change of position .
Near e BootIs .
- , 17 .
There is a considerable change in the relative situation of the two stars of this double star ; and , by the assistance of p Botis , it is remarkably well ascertained .
This star is so near , that it may be brought into the same field of view with our double star .
Sept. 3 , 178 % , the position was 87 ' 14 ' northy preceding and , about a year before , the situation of Jo Bootis had been deter .
mined , so that it appeared , from the two measures , that the three stars were almost in a line , the small star being , however , 6 49 ' on the Jot/ owing side .
August 30 , 1802 , the position of the small star was 760 14 ' north-preceding ; which , in 19 years and 361 days gives a change of 1 10 o ' ; and it was at the same time observed , that when all the three stars were seen together , the small one was on the preceding side of the line which joins this double star and z Bootis .
A parallactic motion of the large star , would have occasioned the small one to go in a direct order ; but it has had a retrograde motion .
Nortb-preceding Fr. 18 Persei .
I , 38.* The two stars , August 20 , 1782 , were situated in a direction 8O 4 north-preceding ; and , by a mean of two measures , taken March 7 , 1 80o the position was 20§ 34 ' .
This gives a change amounting to 120 0l ' , in 21 years and i9j days .
There is probably a little increase in the distance of the stars .
The first observations , with 460 , give jL diameter of either of them supposing the stars to be equal ; and the last , with 527 &gt; , make it a diameter of the smallest ; the stars being then considered as pretty unequal .
-If the difference of the parallactic motion of the two stars should be sufficiently considerable , that motion would account , not only for the change of the angle of position , but also fora small increase of the distance of the two stars .
a CoronwX .
I , .
This star has undergone a great change The position of the two stars , Oct. A5 , i78i , was 770 32 ' north-preceding ; but , Sept. 6 , 18o2 , it was 780 36 ' north-ifllowing ; which gives an alteration of 23 502 ' , in 2o years and 326 days .
The great number of small stars in this neighbourhood , is not favourable to a supposed connection between any of them and C Corona , As the two stars are considerably unequal , we may suppose the large-one to be affected by a parallactic motion , which will sufficiently account for the angular change .
E Lyra .
II , 5 and 6 .
This remarkable double-double star has undergone a change of situation in each double star separately , which is not very considerable , but deserves our notice , on account of a certain similarity in the directions of the alteration .
The position of II , , Nov. 2 , 1779 , was 5605 north-following ; and , by a mean of three observations , taken Sept. 20 , 1802 , May S6 , and 9g9 1804 , it was,59 1 ' ; which gives a change of 30 9 ' ; the motion of the angle being retrograde .
The position of II , 6 , on the same days , was 83 ' 28 ' , and 750 35 ' , south-following .
This gives a difference of 70 53 ' ; the motion being also retrograde .
Now , from the position of the apex of the translation of the solar system , it follows , that the parallax arising from this principle , cannot account for the motion of both the sets of double stars it may explain the change of : the preceding , but not of the following one .
The situation of both , however , is in a part of the heavens which is so rich in scattered small stars , that a variety of casual , and merely apparent combinations may be expected .
p Serpentar'i Fl .
0.{o II , 4 .
The alteration of the angle of position , that has taken place in the situation of this double star , is very remarkable .
Oct. 7 , 1779 , the stars were exactly in the parallel , the preceding star being the largest ; the position therefore was 00 o ' following.* Sept. 24 , 1781 , it was 90 14 ' north-following ; and , May 29 , 804 , it was 48 i ' north-preceding ; which gives a change of 1310,59 ' , in 24 years and etg4 days .
This cannot be owing to the effect of systematical parallax , which could never bring the small star to the preceding side of the large one .
x Opbiuchi .
I , 83 .
The position , March 9 , 1783 , was 14o 30 ' north-following .
May 20 , 1802 , it was 20 41 ' .
The differmnce , in id years and 72 days , is 6 ?
i ' .
March 9 , 1783 , the distance , with 4601 , was L or A diameter of the small star .
May 1 and 2 , 1802 , 1 could not perceive the small star , though the last 'of the two evenings was very fine .
May 20 , 1802 , with 527 , I saw it very well , but with great difficulty .
The object is uncommonly beautiful ; but it requires a most excellent telescope to see it well , and thefocus ought to be adjusted upon e of the same constellation , so as to make that perfectly round .
The appearance of the two stars is much like that of a planet with a large satellite or small companion , and strongly suggests the idcea of a connection between the two bodies , especially as they are much insulated .
The change of the angle of position , might be explained by a parallactic motion of the large star ; but the observations on the distance of the two stars , can hardly agree with an increase of t which would have been the consequence of that motion .
North-preceding Fl .
29 Capricorni .
I , 47 .
The position , July 943 , 1783 , was 84P 48 ' north-preceding .
Sept. i , 1802 , it was 660 ot ' .
This gives a change of l7o 58 ' , in 19 years and 40 days .
The effect of a parallactic motion would fall chiefly on the distance ; it will , however , account for the change of the angle .
Near Fl .
3 Pegasi .
1 !
, 62 .
The position , May 3 , 1783 , was 88§ 24 ' north-preceding .
August 31 , 1802 , it was 790 38 ' south-following .
The change is 8§ 46 ' , in 19 years and 120 days .
The stars are so nearly equal , that in 1783 I supposed the preceding one to be the smallest , and in 1802 the following one ; which occasions the different denomination of the angles of position .
If the distance of the preceding star should be much greater than that of the following one , a parallactic motion would explain the change of the angle , but not otherwise .
MD CCCIV .
3C Fl .
4 Serpentis .
1 , 8* .
In the year 1783 , March 7 , the position of the two stars of this double star , was 210 331 north-preceding .
May.20 , 1802 , 320 2"t and , April'2 , 1804 , 35k ' 1t0 ; which gives a change of 130 37 ' , in 21 years and:26 days .
The stars are now a little farther asunder than they were formerly .
A parallactic motion would account for the change of the angle , but not for the increased distance .
Preceding Fl .
Ai SerpeT tarli .
H , 23J The position of the stars , May 18 , 178 , was 460 24 ] north .
preceding .
May 20 , 1802 , it was 66 56 ' ; which gives a change of eo 32 ' , in 2Q years and 2 days .
A parallactic motion , if the small star should be sufficiently distant from us , will account fEor it .
Fl .
38 Piscium .
II , So .
The position , JaJune 30 , i783 , was 25 3 ' southpreceding , and , August 31 , 18o2 , it was 340 43 ! .
TI change is 9040k , in 19 years and 62 days .
The small star has been retrograde .
If the change had been ow'ing to the sstennatical parallax , the motion would havebeen direct .
Near Fl .
64 dquanrli .
Ill , 69.* The position , August 21 , 178 , was 2 3 ' north-ollowing .
Oct. 16 , 1802 , it-was 310 34'J .
Tle chancre , in 19 years and 56 days , is o 31s'/ ; { and may be accounted for by a parallacfic motion of the large star , especially as the stars are extremnely unequal in apparent magnitude .
e , Fl .
46 lerculis .
I , 79 .
There is a small change in the distance of the two stars of this double star .
Feb.is , 1783 , the interval between them , with e7 , * was nearly i diameter of L , and with 46o , A diameter of L. Sept. 29 , 1802 , it was 2j or 8 diameters of L. The position , Feb. , 1783 was 66§ 36 ' soth-following .
Sept. 29 , 18o0 , it was 760 18 ' .
The alteration is 90 42 ' , in 19 years and 236 days but cannot be owing to parallactic motion .
Cy gni 1'a1 94 .
This double star , I believe , has : furnished us with a second instance of a conjunction , resembling that of C Herculis The position , Sept. 2 , 1783 , s was i 80 2 1 ' north-following.:Jan .
- &amp; io , and li , 18o2 , I could no longer perceive the small star ; which must have been at least so near the large one as to be lost in its brightness .
Jan. 29 , 18o4 , I examined this star with powers from 527 to M0oo , and saw it as a lengthened star , but not with sufficient clearnesss to take a measure of its position .
May 22 , 1804 , in a very clear evening , I tried 527 and iBoo , with the lo-feet reflector , which acted re narkably well on other double stars , but I could not perceive the small star of S Cygni In hopes that the superior light of a 20-f et reflector would show it , I examined the star , May 29 , 1804 , with the powers 157 and 360 , but could not perceive the small one .
A parallactic motion of z will perfectly account for this occultation ; for the situation of the two stars , in 1783 , was such , that this motion In my Catalogue , the power is called 460 , instead of 27 , as it should have beenr ; and the rest of the observation , with 46o , was by mistake omitted .
3Cs must have carried the large star , by this time , nearly upon the small one .
b Draconis .
1 , 7 .
The position , Oct. lo , i78o , was 770 19 ' north-following ; and , Oct. 30 , C 180e , it was 83§ 41 ' .
The change is 6§ 2X ' in 22 years and 20 days .
The effect of a parallactic motion of the largest star , would have shown itself in a direction contrary to the observed one ; a proper motion of one of the stars , at least , must be admitted .
South-preceding Fl .
30 Orionis .
I , 75 .
The position , Jan. 9 , 178,3 , was 8-9 36 ' north-preceding ; and , Jan. 22 , 1802 , it was 79 12 north-following ; which gives a change of 10 12 ' , in 19 years and 13 days .
A parallacticmotion of either of the stars , for they are nearly equal , would chiefly affect their distance ; besides , the stars are so numerous in this part of the heavens , that We can only look upon this as a casual double star ; a proper motion therefore must be recurred to .
w Cassiopea .
III , 3 .
The situation of the two stars of this beautiful double star , June 14 , 1782 , was 270 56 ' north-following ; aid , Feb. i1 , 180o , it was 190 l4 ' , which gives a change Of 80 4~j_ ' , in go years and 242 days .
This arises probably from a real mnotion of a in space ; for parallax would have had a contrary e &amp; ect .
d Serpentis .
1 , i12 .
This star has not altered its angle of position sufficiently to be certain of the change , which only amounts to 20 8'- ; thise quantity being too small for the precision of the micrometer , when only two measures are taken ; but the alteration in the distance of the two stars is well ascertained .
Oct. 22 , 1 781 , with 278 , it was 1-idiameter of L. April 28 , 1783 , with 460 , it was 22diameters ; and , May 4 , 180g , it was not less than 4 or 5 diameters of L. If this change had arisen from a parallactic motion , there must have been a considerable alteration in the angle of position , which cannot be admitted ; it may , therefore , more properly be ascribed to a real motion of d Serpentis .
North of 1o5 Herculis .
I , 86 .
The alteration in the angle of position of this star is uncommonly great .
April 27 , 1783 it was 792 24 ' north-preceding , and , Sept. 29 , 1802 , it measured only 22§ 27 ' ; which denotes a change of R560 57 ' , in 19 years and 155 days .
The distance has undergone very little alteration , but is rather less now than ' it was formerly .
A real motion of the largest star , in a northfollowing direction , may explain this change , which cannot be ascribed to a parallactic motion of the stars .
Rigel .
II , Em .
This bright star has undergone a change of situation with regard to its distance from the small one , which is near it ; but , in the angle of position , very little difference can be perceived .
By eleven measurmes , taken between Jan. i , 1802 , and Feb. 18 , 1803 , the itmean posidon is 69 ' As south-preceding ; which is but little more than 68 ' 12 ' , the measure of Oct. 1 , 1781 , given in my Catalogue .
The distance was estimated , Oct. i , 1781 , with 46o , to be more than 3 diameters of Rigel ; and , as I supposed it to beone of those double stars of which I might ascertain the vacancy between the two stars , by estimating thenuMber of diameters of the large one that would fill it up , I placed the star in the second class .
However , by a measure taken with a micrometer , Oct. 22 , 1781 , the stars were found to be far enough asunder to come into the third class .
By a mean of six measures , which were taken the first i8 months of my observing the star , their distance was 9 32 " ' ; and , by a repetition of estimations , it appeared , Dec. 22 , 1781 , that the vacancy between the two stars was not less than 4 diameters , and , when the air was tremulous , 4 or A. A fter an interval of more than 21 years having omitted estimations by the diameter , as not very proper to be used with these stars , I wished to compare their distance with the former estimiations ; and , with the same instrument and same magniifying power that had been used before , the vacancy , Feb. 22 , 1803 , amounted to A or 6 diameters of the large star ; so that , certainly , an increase of distance must be admitted .
The number of scattered stars in this neighbourhood , and the smallness of the star to which the relative situation of Ribel has been referred , render it probable that there is only a casual proximity , and no real connection , between these two stars .
Nor can the change of their relative situation be accounted for by a parallactic motion of Rigel , although we should admit the small star to be without the reach of solar parallax ; for the effect arising from parallactic motion , would notonly lessen the distance of the two stars , but would occasion a considerable diminution in the angle of position , neither of which have taken place .
As we have now the proper motion of Rigel , in Dr. MASKELYNE 's neaw Tables , we can no longer be at a loss for the cause of the change ; , for , by a composition of the tabular motions in the relative Situation of double Stars .
381 right ascension and polar distance , this star , in 21 years and 1+1 days , must have moved about 3",48 1 , in ari angle of 790 29 ' 33 " , towards the north-following part of the heavens .
This would consequently remove it from the small star , which is placed almost in an opposite direction , and would occasion hardly any change in its angle of position ; and these are the very phenomena which have been established by my observations .
( Cancri .
III , 19 .
The position of the stars , Nov. 21 , 1781 , was 880 t6 ' south .
preceding ; and , Feb. 7 , 1802 , it was 810 47 ' south-following .
The change is 90 5 ' , in 20 years and 78 days ; and may be ascribed to a parallactic motion of the large star , which is in favour of the observed alteration .
e Capricorni .
II ) 51 .
The position , July4 , 1783 , was 84,0 o ' south-following ; and , August 29 , 1802 , it was 860 55 ' south-preceding .
This gives a change of 9O 5 ' , in 19 years and 56 days ; and a motion arising from parallax will sufficiently account for it .
North-preceding FH 6 A6ndromede .
1 , 89.* The position , July 28 , i78j , was 75§ 30 ' south-following ; and , Sept. 19 , 1802 , it was 67 ' 4 ' .
The change is 8 26 ' , in 19 years and 53 days .
A parallactic motion of the large star would have occasioned the change of the angle to be direct instead of retrograde .
Near 37 Aquile .
I , af* The position , Oct. 6 , i'8 2 , by a mean of two measures , was 370 1i ' north-preceding ; and , Oct. 2 " , i8oo , it was 440 45g .
The change is 70 so ' , in 19 years and 361i days ; and may be owing to a parallactic motion U rrsX minoris .
IV , 1 .
There has been a ssmall alteration in the relative situation of the pole star ; but , when we consider that this double star is of the fourth class , we cannot expect that any great change in the angle of position should have taken place , in the course of 2o years .
The position , Dec. 19 , 1781 , was 66 ' 42 ' south-preceding ; and , June 17 , i782 , it was 67 ?
!3 ' .
A mean of both measures , is 670 S. ?
Aarch 4 , 18o2 , the position was 610 43 ' ; which gives a difference of 50 20o ' in 19 years and 35o days .
A paraldlactic motion of the large star , which , considering the great difference of size between the two , may well be admitted , will account for the angular change ; especially as the distance of the two stars exceeds the limits which probability points out for connected stars , when the large one is of the third magnitude .
North-preceding Fl .
62 Aquik .
I , 93 .
The position , Sept. 12 , 1783 , was 190 9 ' north-preceding ; and , Oct. 2 , 180o it was 13l0 21 ' .
The change is d 48 ' , in 19 years and 2o days .
A parallactic motion of the largest of the two stars , would have occasioned a contrary apparent motion of the small one .
Preceding r Orionis .
I , S4 The position , January 22 , 1 78 , was 35 ' 42 ' north-preced'ng and , Jan. 2,5 , 1802 , it was 41 27 ' .
The change is , § 451 , in -ig years and q days ; and may be owing to the eftect of parallax .
C Ursa majoris .
III , 2 .
The position , Nov. 18 , 1781 , was 560 46 ' southlfollowing ; and , Oct. 3 , 1802 , it was 510 14 ' .
The change is 50 32 ' , in 20 years and1 319 days ; but this cannot be accounted for by a parallactic motion .
of A , which would have occasioned a contrary change of the an.le .
North-following p Herculis .
I , 37 .
The position , Oct. 6 , 1782 , was 590 48 ' south-following ; and , Sept. 20 , 1802 , it was 65 ?
o ' ; which gives a change of 50 12 ' , in 19 years and 349 days .
It cannot be ascribed to a paradlactic motion of the largest star .
North-'ollowing 'v Aquarii .
1 , 46 .
The position , July 31 , 1783 , was 62§ 27 ' north-preceding ; and , August 29 , 1802 , it was 670 27 ' .
The change is , ' o ' , in i9 years and 29 days .
The distance of these stars is now greater than it was formerlyJuly 31 , 1783 , with 460 , they were rather more than 1 diameter asunder .
August 29 , 18o02 , I found them too far ' distant to be put into the first class .
If any effect of parallax can reach such small stars , it is so far in favour , that it will account for an increase of the distance , but not for the change of the angle of position .
a Piscium .
II7 12 .
The pos0tion of the stars , Oct. 19 , 1781 , was 67§ 23 ' northpreceding ; and , by a mean of three measures , taken Jan. 28 and Feb. 4 , 1802 it 6w ' sG o ' .
This gives a change of § 23 ' , in 20 years and 105 days .
The parallactic motion of a will account for the alteration , unless a proper mnotion should hereafter lead to a different conclusion , which , from the insulated situation of this double star , is rt improbable .
FL ii .
]Monocerois .
In , 17 .
The position , Oct. 20 , 1781 , was 310 38 ' south-following ; and , by a mean of tw'o measures , taken Feb. 4 , and March 4 , i8o2 , it was 270 12 ' The change , which is 40 26 ' , i 20 years and 12t days , may be accounted for by a parallactic motion .
North-preceding y Aqu il .
1 91 .
The position , August 7,1783 , was8§ 18 north-preceding ; and , Sept , 2o , 1 802 , it was 1 !
20 23 ' .
This gives a change of 405t , in 19 years and 44 days ; and may be accounted for upon the principles of parallax .
e Gerninorum .
III , 47 .
The position , Oct. 2 , 1782 , was 890 4 ' soth-following ; and , April 6 , 1 So2 , t was 86§ 6 south-preceding ; which gives a change of 40 a ' , in ig years and 186 days .
This cannot be ascribed to parallactic motion .
Fl .
32 Eridani .
11 , 36 .
The position , Oct. 22 1781 , was 730 23 ' north-precedi g ; and , Feb. 6 , 1804 , it was 770 1i9 .
The change is 3 ' 56 ' , i 22 years and i o7 days .
It cannot be owing to a parallactic motion , which would have produceed a different dect . . .
, 0 ~~~~~~~~~~~~]~oy~~th. .
m5tv3IM ) CC CIVI Rlatg1X~p .
584..~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~WMP .
_4 A/ / 6F IF A/ ir , , ; .
A ... IF~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ II ?

