XI .
Observations on Basalt , and on the Transition from the vitreous to the stony Texture , whdich occurs in the gradual Refrigeration of melted Basalt ; with some geological Remarks .
In a Letterfrom Gregory Watt , Esq. to the Right Hon. Charies Greville , V. P. R. S. Read , May io , 1804 .
SIR , Soho , April ic , 1804 .
IH E important geological consequences that seem deducible from the changes of texture developed by Sir JAMES HALL'S very judicious Experiments on the regulated cooling of melted Basalt , induced me to attempt a repetition of them , some time after the publication of his interesting and ingenious Paper.* I believe that formerly I had the honour ' of showing you some of the results of my imperfect and diminutive experiments , which only served to afford additional proofs of the transition from the vitreous to the stony texture , which takes place in the gradual refrigeration of glass .
Circumstances have prevented my resuming these investigations , till it lately occurred to me that somethingr might be learned , by exposing to the action of ' heat , a much larger mass of basaltic matter than , as far as I am informed , had ever at one time been subjected to experiment .
One of the common , reverberatory furnaces used in iron founderies for the fusion of pig iron , was strongly heated by a fire maintained for several hours .
About seven hundred weight of amorphous basalt , here called Rowley Rag , was broken into small pieces , and deposited gradually on the elevated part of the interior of the furnace , between the fire and the chimney , from whence , as it melted , it flowed into the deeper part , in whhich , in ordinary operations , the melted iron is collected .
It was observed by the persons attending , that it did not require half the quantity of fuel , to fuse the basalt , that would have been necessary to melt an equal weight of pig iron .
When the whole was melted , it formed a liquid glass , rather tenacious , from which a large ladle-full was taken , -which , on rbeing allowed to cool , retained the characters of perfect glass .
The fire was maintained , though with gradual diminution , for more than six hours ; after which time , the draught of the chimney was intercepted , the surface of the glass was covered with heated sand , and the furnace was filled with coals , which were consumed-very slowly .
It was eight days before the mass in the furnace was sufficiently cool to be extracted , and even then it retained considerable internal heat .
The form of the mass , being given by the bottom of the furnace , was considerably irregular , approaching to the shape of a wedge whose lower angles were rounded .
It was nearly three feet and a half long , two feet and a half wide , about four inches thick at one end , and above eighteen inches at the other .
From this diversity of thickness , and from the unequal action of the heat of the furnace , too great an irregularity had prevailed in the refrigeration of the glass , to permit its attainment of a homogeneous texture .
These circumstances might probably have been counteracted by better devised precautions ; but the inequality of the product is not to be regretted , since it has fortuitously disclosed some very singular peculiarities , in the arrangement of bodies passing from a vitreous to a stony state , .
which might have remained unobserved , if the desired homogeneity of the result had been obtained .
I shall now endeavour to describe the various products of this operation ; and I shall also submit to your consideration , some remarks which appear to me to arise naturally from the phenomena I have observed ; premising that , except where my opinions are supported by the unequivocal demonstration of facts , I offer them with the utmost deference to the decision of more experienced and judicious mineralogists and geologists .
It may be proper to give a concise description of rowley rag itself , before I consider the products which it yields by igneous fusion .
This species of basalt is fine-grained , of a confused crystallized texture ; its fracture uneven in small pieces , conchoidal in large pieces .
Its hardness superior to common glass , but inferior to feldspar .
Its tenacity considerable .
Its action on the magnetic needle strong , but without signs of polarity .
Its specific gravity , according to my trials , 2.868 .
Its general colour iron gray , approaching to black .
It is opaque ; and it reflects light from a number of brilliant points , some of which seem to be feldspar , and others hornblende.* ist .
This substance is easily fused into glass , whose texture is completely vitreous , with few air-bubbles .
Its fracture undulated conchoidal .
Its hardness superior to feldspar , but inferior to quartz .
It possesses scarcely any action on the magnetic needle .
Its colour is black : it is nearly opaque , being translucent only in very thin fragments .
Its specific gravity appears to be 29743 .
2d .
The tendency towards arrangement , in the particles of the fluid glass , is first developed by the formation of minute globules , which are generally nearly spherical , but sometimes elongated , and which are thickly disseminated through the mass .
The colour of these globules is considerably lighter than that of the glass ; they .
are commonly -grayish-brown , sometimes in-~ clining to chocolate brown , ; and , when they have been formed near the interior surface of the cavities in the glass , they project , and resemble a. .
cluster of small seeds .
Their diameter rarely exceeds a line , and seldom attains that size , as , in general , they are so near to one another , that their surfaces touch before they can acquire considerable magnitude .
In the process of cooling , they adapt their form to their confined situation , fill up every interstice , and finallypresent a:homogeneous body , wholly unlike glass , and equally unlike the parent basalt .
When the union of the little globules has been imperfectlyeffected , the fracture of the mass indicates its structure , by numerous minute " Cannay , one of the Hebrides , described by Geoan'E DE-MPSTER , Esq. in the Trahsactions of the Society of Antiquaries in Scotland , Vol. .
" See Mineralogy of theSouth-west part of Staffordshirehy JAM ; ES KEIRj Esq. , F. R S. published-Jii 6HAW 'S H itstory of Staffordshire , Vol. J. Mr. Ki RW AN 'states the specific gra'vity of rowley rag , which he calls ferrilite , at 2.748 ; and assigns its melting point at 980 of WEDGWOOD 's pyrometer .
conchoidal fractures , which display the form of each globule .
But , if the arrangement has extended a little farther , all these subdivisions are entirely lost ; the mass becomes perfectly compact , has an even or a flat conchoidal fracture , is nearly of the same hardness as the glass , -is commonly of a chocolate colour , graduating into a brownish-black , and the intensity of the colour increases in proportion to the degree to which the arrangement has extended .
Its aspect is rather greasy ; and it much resembles some varieties of jasper , in the compactness of its texture , and in its opacity .
Its magnetic action is extremely feeble .
Its specific gravity appears to be.9,38 .
-3d .
If the mass were now rapidly cooled , it is obvious that the result would be the substance I have just described ; but , if the temperature adapted to the farther arrangement of its particles be continued , another change is immediately commenced , by the progress of which it acquires a more stony texture , much greater tenacity , and its colour deepens as these changes advance , till it becomes absolutely black .
Sometimes this alteration is effected by a gradual transition , the limits of which cannot be assigned , but more generally by the formation of secondary spheroids , in the heart of the compact jaspideous substance .
These spheroids differ essentially from those first described ; the centres of their formation are mow remote from each other , and their magnitude is proport onably greater , sometiunes extending to a diameter of two inches , and seerming only to be limited by contact with the peripheries of other sphero Xs .
They are radiated , with distinct filbles ; sometimes the ores resemble those of brown haen ; *atit s , and sometimes the , e fasciculated irregularly , soas to be Very similar in appearance to the argil laceous iron ores rendered prismattic by tonlaection .
They are generally well defined , and easily separable from the mass they are engaged in ; and often the fibres divide at equal distances from the centre , so as to detach portions of the spheroid in concentric coats , The transverse fracture of the fibres is compact and fine grained ; the colour black ; and the hardness somewhat inferior to that of the basaltic glass .
When two of the spheroids come into contact by mutual enlargement , no intermixture of their fibres seems to take place ; they appear equally impenetrable , and , as neither can penetrate , both are compressed , and their limits are defined by a plane , at which a separation readily takes place , and each of the sides is invested with a rusty colour .
When several spheroids come in contact on the same level , they are formed by mutual pressure into pretty regular prisms , whose division is perfectly defined ; and , when a spheroid is surrounded on all sides by others , it is compressed into an irregular polyhedron .
4th .
The transition from this fibrous state to a different arrangement , seems to be very rapid ; for the centre of most of the spheroids becomes compact , before they attain the diameter of half an inch .
As the fibrous structure propagates itself by radiating into the unarranged mass , the compact nucleus which supplies its place gradually extends , till it finally attains the limits of the spheroids ; and the same arrangement pervades the matter comprehended between them. .
The mass has now assumed a compact stony texture , and possesses great tenacity .
Its hardness is somewhat inferior to that of the glass from which it was formed .
Its action on the magnetic needle is very considerable .
Its specific gravity is 2.938 .
Its colour is black , inclining to steel gray : it is absolutely opaque , and only reflects light from a few minute points .
Though the divisions between the spheroids are rendered imperceptible to the eye , they are not obliterated , and their rusty surfaces are often disclosed by an attempt to-fracture the mass .
5th .
A continuation of the temperature favourable to arranges meant , speedily induces another change .
The texture of the mass becomes more granular , its colour rather more gray , and the brilliant points larger and more numerous : nor is it long before these brilliant molecules arrange themselves into regular forms ' ; and , finally , the whole mass becomes pervaded by thin crystalline laminave which intersect it in every direction , and form proje ting crystals in the cavities .
-The hardness of the basis seems to continue nearly the same ; but the aggregate action of the basis , and of the imbedded crystals , on the -magnetic needle , is prodigiously increased .
It appears to possess some polarity ; and minute fragments are suspended by a magnet .
Its specific gravity is somewhat increased , as it is now 2.949 .
The crystals contained in it , when examined by a microscope , appear to be fasciculi of slender prisms , nearly rectangular , terminated by planes perpendicular to the axis ; they are extremely brilliant ; their colour is greenish-black ; they are harder than glass , and fusible at the blowpipe ; they are suspended by the action of a magnet .
They are arranged nearly side by side , but not accumulated in thickness , so that they present the appearance of broad thin laminae ; they cross one another at all angles , but always on nearly the same plane ; and the lamina thus formed is often three or four lines long , and from a line to a line and-a half broad , but extremely thin.* It seems obvious , that an equalised temperature would have rendered the whole similar to the substance last described ; and it may be fairly inferred , that by a continuance of heat , the minute crystals would have been augmented in their dimensions , by the accession of molecules still engaged in the basis , or by the union of several crystals , till they acquired sufficient mag nitude for their nature to be absolutely determined by the usual modes of investigation It is probable , however , if such prep cautions had been taken as might have secured this degree of perfection in the ulterior result , that the mass -would only have exhibited an uniform aspect , and that the interesting initial phenomena would not have been discovered.* There are some considerations which appear to offer a partial -explanation of the formation of the globules , and of the radiated spheroids .
It is well ascertained that heat is emitted by all bodies , in their change from a gaseous to a fluid state , and also These minute points are soon obliterated by the large curves of the fibrous spheroids , which give a mamellated form to the interiors of the cavities ; and , when the crystals are generated in the mass , they shoot into some of the cavities and line them with their brilliant laminx .
in their change from a fluid to a solid state .
It is reasonable to suppose , that heat may also be emitted in those changes of arrangement which affect the internal texture of a body , after it has attained an apparently solid state .
That a succession of such changes does actually take place , appears to , me demonstrated by the appearances I have described and by the increase of specific gravity , which seems to keep pace with the 'internal changes of the substance .
It would appear , that these changes are caused by a gradual diminution of temperature , which permits certain laws to induce peculiar arrangements among the particles of the glass .
When several of these particles enter into this new bond of association , they must form a minute point , from which heat must issue in every direction .
That heat will gradually propagate itself , till the temperature of the glass is equalised ; and then the recurrence of the circumstances which -induced the first particles to arrange , will cause other particles to arrange also , which the attraction of aggregation will dispose round the point first formed .
A second emission of heat in every direction will take place ; the temperature will again be equalised ; and again another concentric coat of arranged particles will apply itself to the little globule .
But , at the time when the central point of this globule was formed , the equality of temperature , in the mass of glass , would probably cause a number of similar points to be generated .
The formation of each must proceed in a similar manner to what I have described , till their surfaces touch , and all the glass .
be converted into the same substance .
These globules are therefore formed of concentric coats , but they are also radiated .
Every one must haveremarked the connexion that almost uniformly exists , between the radiated structure and the formation by concentric coats .
There are few radiated substances which are not divisible into concet rag- .
ments ; and as few concentric arrangemen'ts which are not radiated .
Of the first , it may be sufficient to mention hnmatites ; of the second , calcareous stalactites .
The tendency to this union of structure , may perhaps be produced by the radiation of the emitted heat , or moisture , if the solution be aqueous ; and the divisions of the coats will naturally take place at those pauses in the accumulatio n of particles , whichI the mQmentary cmission of heat necessarily induced .
If this be allowed to explain the formation of the first series of globules -which consolidate into the jaspideous substance , it will also explain the formation of the larger and more distinctly radiated spheroids which have been already stated'-to , be very easily divisible into concentric fragments .
They probably were also formed round a central point , by the accumulation of thin coats ; and the tendency to radiation , which seems almost insex parable from this structure , was perhaps aided by the arranges .
meant induced by the emission of heat from every part of the surface of the spheroids , This mode of formation has the adzvantageof explaining their impenetrability .
Had they been generated by radii diverging from a centre , their compactness must have diminished as their d'iameter increased ; but , in the structure which I have supposed , each coat is composed of particlessolidly arranged in immediate contact with each other , leaving no , spaces for penetration .
The same progress is rigidly observed in the extension of the compact nucleus , which always occupies the centre of the ; radiated spheroids , and finally extends to their peripheries .
It observes the concentric divisions of the radiated part with the greatest precision ; and the line of their separation is always perfectly defined. .
But the state of aggreg a tion into which the substance has now entered , is so perfect as to overcome the operation of the causes which formerly induced the fibrous structure , and the mass remains compact .
The only change that the substance afterwards undergoes consists in the gradual accumulation of the crystalline molecules , and their arrangement , by their individual polarity , into regular solids .
This depends on very different laws from those which consolidated the fluid glass , and aggregated its particles into a compact uniform sstone.d The appearances that I have endeavoured to describe , seem deserving of consideration in several points of view .
Few things can be more at variance with commonly received opinion , than the diversified succession of changes of structure which this glass exhibits in its passage to a crystallized state.d The generation of the globules which unite to form the jaspideous substance , is what we might be prepared to expect , by observing the cooling * The case is considerably different , where crystals possessing regular forms are generated in glass .
The molecules of which they are formed , have doubtless , been only suspended in the vitreous medium ; and their union is determined by crystalline polarity , which appears to me perfectly distinct from the simple aggregation which changes a fluid into a solid , whether it be homogeneous or compound , which affects the internal arrangement of those bodies , but which never can separate their comply nents into distinct masses , or form them into regular solids .
Every molecule , at the moment of its formation , must necessarily be endowed with all the properties it afterwards possesses .
The suspension of such molecules in a fluid medium , though it may conceal , cannot alter those properties ; and the union of such molecules " to form a regular solid , in no respect alters their individualvr aggregate qualities .
Whether heat be evolved at the moment of this union , is a question not easily solved ; as the cry 's tallizations with which we are familiar are from chemical solutions , in which some of the molecules are generated by the separation of a combined substance , at th-11moment when others are united by crystalline polarity .
Pp .
2 of a common iron furnace flag .
But it appears not very-obvious to common apprehension , that the species of arrangement requisite to form this intermediary substance , could be compatible with any fluidity permitting farther motion of the molecules of the mass ; yet , immediately after the completion of this arrangement , they receive a new disposition , and the radiated fibrous structure commences .
Sometimes this pervades even the unaltered glass ; l but I presume this only to happen where the minute globules first formed were scattered so far asunder that their centres became fibrous , before their peripheries came into contact , This view of the subject is justified by the analogous operation of the formation of crystals , similar to those described , in the heart of the radiated spheroids , while their exteriors still retained the fibrous texture .
If it be considered as extraordinary , that a change should be effected , converting an apparently solid and homogeneous mass into an accumulation of radiated spheroids , and that these radii should lose their fibrous structure , and assume the texture , aspect , and tenacity , of a compact , hard , and homogeneous stone , it is certainly much more extraordinary , that this stone should permit farther arrangement to proceed , and should enable the crystalline -molecules which it contains in a state of confused aggregation , to-arrange themselves , and to form crystals , which , although minute , are equal in the perfection of their forms , and in the brilliancy of their natural -polish , to the most precious products of -crystallization .
It is also well deserving of observation , by how regular a march the magnetic influence of the substance keeps pace with the perfection of its arrangement , till it becomes so powerful , treat fragments of the regenerated stone are suspended by the attraction of a magnet .
it has been most justly remarked by Mr. SMITHSON , that solution , far from being necessary to crystallization , effectually prevents its commencement ; for , while solution subsists , crystallization cannot take place .
It may remain a question , whether previous solution be essential , as a preparatory means of ob , taining , by subsequent evaporation , or cooling , the small parts of bodies disengaged , so that they may unite to form regular crystals .
If by solution be only meant , that simple action of he at , Or water , which merely counteracts the force of aggrega-tion , and relieves the molecules from their bond of union with each other , it certainly is a requisite ; but if by solution be meant , that action of affinities by which not " only the force of aggregation is overcome , but the combinations which constitute the molecules are destroyed , it obviously is not only unnecessary , but prejudicial tocrystallization ; as a new set of molecules , must be formed , by a new combination of the elementary particles , before the formation of regular bodies can commence .
The suspension 'of the molecules ready to crystallize , may be correctly said to be merely mechanical .
Though the mechanical action-of trituration can never be expected to resolve even the most easily divisible body into its molecules , because the fractures will be at least as frequently across the natural joints as in their direction , yet , even by this rude , method , some perfect molecules may be disengaged ; for we ' find , that water passing over large surfaces of siliceous sand , finds some molecules of silex in the state proper for aggregation , and even for crystallization .
Mechanical suspension in a fluid medium , of such density that the crystalline polarity may be enabled to counteract the power of gravity , is with justice considered by Mr. SMITHSQN the only requisite for the formation of crystals.* The circum stances i have detailed ) appear to me an additional confirmation of this remark , and , perhaps go still further , by showing that even the fluidity ( in the common sense of the word ) of the suspending medim is not an indispensable condition .
For it appears impossible to annex the idea of fluidity to the union of the minute globules which form the jaspideous substance , still less to that substance when formed , and still less to those spheroids whose obstinate impenetrability is so strongly defined .
And if , by any power of imagination , these can be supposed to be fluid at the time they retain this conformation , how can it be supposed that the compact hard tenacious stone into which they are changed could retain these characters in a fluid state ?
Yet the subsequent formation of crystals proves , that either all these contradictions must be , or that the particles of bodies apparently solid must be capable of some internal motion , enabling them to arrange themselves according to polarity , while they are solid and fixed , as far as they have reference to the ordinary characters of fluidity .
Instances even more remarkable have very long been known And authenticated though perhaps they have not been generally regarded with the attention they deserve .
Glass vessels are well known to be convertible into REAUMUR'S porcelain , by the internal arrangement of their particles , Without losing their external form ' , and consequently at a temperature very much below that'requisite for their fusion .
The change of glass into REAUMUR'S porcelain , does not arise from an evaporation of the alkali , as has been alleged , but from a regular arrangement of the molecules of the glass .
It commences by the formation of fibres perpendicular to the surface of the glass , and penetrating into it .
At nearly the same time , small radiated globules are formed in the interior of the glass , and the union of these with the fibres , by their mutual increase , forms the whole into a new substance ; and , if the requisite temperature be longer maintained , the fibres disappear , and the whole becomes finee-grained , and almost compact .
This substance , from the improved state of its aggregation , is much stronger and more tenacious than before , and is not fusible at a heat sufficient to fuse the glass it was formed from ; but , if--that aggregation be once destroyed , the glass resulting from its fusion is equally fusible ' with the original glassand a repetition of the process will again form REAUMUR'S porcelain , which may be again fused , and so on repeatedly , for the quantity of alkali evaporated during the operation is extremely small .
The hardness and and brittleness of metals rapidly cooled , contrasted with the softness and tenacity resulting from their gradual refrigeration , are all analogous instances ; and all the processes in which annealing is employed , and more remarkably the tempering of steel , are proofs of theinternal motions and arrangements of the particles of matter , &gt; at temperatures very much below the heat requisite for their fluidity Whatever doubts may arise respecting the formation of the crystals , there seems no reason to suppose that their gradual , increase would cease , till all the molecules belonging to that species were exhausted , if the temperature favourable to their generation was continued , If the mass was entirely composed of one species of molecules , it would be resolved into an aggregation of crystals of the same substance ; and probably , by a , Still farther continuation of the process of arrangement , into one crystal , which , though it might not possess a regular external form , would be perfect in its internal structure .
But , if the mass contains two distinct species of molecules , different results must take place , which will bemodified by the proportional quantities of the components .
As it has been demonstrated by BERTHOLLET , that the attraction of masses of matter are relatively as their quantities , it follows , that unless a very potent counteracting cause be exerted , the most abundant ingredient in the mixture will be the first to crystallize .
But this crystallization will not comprehend the -whole of its molecules ; for , after a certain quantity of them arearranged , the proportions of the remaining fluid are altered ; that ingredient which was before the least , may now be equal , or even greatest , and it will exercise its attraction .
As the first -crystallization , by subtracting a large portion of the fluid particles , must have obliged the molecules of the less abundant substance to approach each other very closely , they may be able to collect themselves entirely in their -first attempt to crystallize , or they may form alternate crystallizations with the remaining unarranged mole , Cules of the more abundant substance .
However various the species of molecules may be , they will be regulated by analogous laws , and only serve to diversify the generated substances .
It by no means follows , that the crystals afterwards found to be most infusible would be first generated .
Their formation does not altogether depend on their greater or less fusibility , but on the relative strength of the attraction which unites them to the , matter they are immersed in , and of the polarity which invites them to crystallize .
In all crystallization from compound fluids , the order in which the several bodies crystallize must be determined by their relative quantities and attractions .
It is perfectly obvious , that no molecules can form a crystal in a heat sufficient for its fusion ; but it by no means ensues , that it will be formed as soon as the molecules are cooled to the point where the crystalline polarity overcomes the disintegrating power of heat ; for they may remain suspended in a fluid formed by more fusible bodies , provided this fluid be sufficiently abundant to keep them from contact with each other , for the crystalline polarity appears to exert itself only at extremely small distances .
In a mass composed of substances in a state of fluidity , with refractory molecules suspended among them , it is pretty clear , from the preceding paragraph , that the most abundant ingredient will be the first to crystallize .
But the removal of a portion of the suspending fluid must bring the refractory molecules nearer together , and perhaps so near that the crystalline polarity may overcome the attraction of the fluid for them ; they will therefore crystallize next , and will be followed by the remaining ingredients , in the order their attractions dictate .
As the crystals last formed niust necessarily be impressed , at the parts in contact , by the peculiar forms of those which have been first generated , it also follows , if the preceding reasoning be just , that the infusible crystals may be found impressed by the more fusible substance , which crystallized first ; and the remaining ingredients of the mixture , which were subsequently arranged , may be moulded on the refractory crystals ; and thus , in the same specimen may exist , a refractory substance genes rated by fire , impressed by more fusible bodies , and impressing them in its turn .
From the same consideration it is obvious , that no crystal -can be formed at a temperature above the degree of its 'fusibility ; and that , as a necessary consequence , no crystal which is more fusible than the basis in which it is imbedded , can be formed by igneous operation .
The same laws must regulate the arrangement of aqueous solutions , and of molecules suspended in aqueous solutions .
All these are dependant on heat ; for we are unacquainted with any fluidity , and consequently with any solution , which heat does not produce .
Ice and soda have no more action on each other than soda and quartz : raise the temperature of the ice , and it unites with the soda ; raise the temperature of the soda , and it nites with the : quartz .
Both solutions are efflcted by heat , of the degrees of which we know neither the beginning nor the end , and are therefore utterly unable to estimate what aliquot part ; of its scale is adequate to the preduction of these effects .
Probably a very minute one .
A curious diversity may prevail in the products of a com-3 ; pound body subjected to fusion , when absolute solution is produced .
When merely simple fusion takes place , the aggregation of the parts only is destroyed : the fluidity arises from the facility with which they move on each other ; and a regulated diminution of temperature , by facilitating their reunion , can hardly fail to recompose the same species that formeriy appeared to exist in the compound .
But , if the molecules have been disc solved and decomposed , and their component particles diffused throughthe fluid , there seems to be very little probability that .
any reunion shouldcompose the sam'e molecules .
It ismore likely that new compounds will be formyed , from which new molecules , and of course new crystals , will be generated ; and that , consequently , the same rock may become the parent of very diversified offspring .
These will however retain some 'traces of their origin ; for , as there can be no fusion of a comew pound body imagined , in which the mutual action of the conponents will not decompose some portion , there can be no solution supposed so perfect that every molecule shall be destroyed .
In the first case , there will exist the germs of a new composition ; avid , in the second , there will remain the relics of the old .
If these observations are correct , considerable utility seems derivable from them , in the explanation of some geological problems .
It will appear , that they strikingly illustrate the analogy which exists between the aqueous and igneous formations , and show that precisely the same order and kind of arrangement is followed , in the generation of stony masses from water as from fire ; for , the change of structure , which I have observed to be the most inexplicable part of the process by which glass passes into stone , is almost exactly imitated in the formation of calcarcous stalactites .
Successive depositions of calcareous carbonate , form a stalactite which at first is fibrous .
A continuance of the process causes the fibrous structure to disappear , and the stalactite becomes irregularly spathose .
The irregularities then vanish , and it becomes perfect calcareous spar , divisible into large rhomboids , with the form peculiar to that mineral ; and all the gradations may be found in the same specimen .
Nor is this change confined to a few solitary specimens ; for , a considerable extent of coast nearSunderland , is formed of alimestone composed of radiated spheroids , from half an inch to three inches diameter , imperfectly united .
When one of these spheroids attains sooner thing more than the usual magnitude , it becomes compact in the heart ; and it is snot unusual to discover portions of the rock , in which the radii have entirely disappeared , and the whole mass has become compact .
It is probable that the entire formation of colithi and pisolithi is owing to the same cause ; and that they are prevented from ever arriving at great size , by the union of their surfaces , and their subsequent consolidation into compact limestone , into which they are continually found to graduate .
Hitherto , I have selected instances from substances which have an undisputed claim to an aqueous origin .
I shall now , on the authority of DOLOMIEU , instance a similar arrangement , in a substance respecting the origin of which theorists are not agreed .
A species of petrosilex is found in the Val de Nido , in Corsica , which contains radiated petrosiliceous glands , from half a line to an inch in diameter .
These glands only differ from the basis by their radiated structure , and their colour ; and appear to indicate very clearly , that the rock was subjected to a species of arrangement which , if it had been completed , would have changed its nature , and probably would have rendered it porphyritic ; for DOLOMIEU observes , that the centre of the glands was often occupied by a small crystal of feldspar.* The extraordinary rock called the globular Granite of Corsica , is an analogous instance .
It is composed of crystals of hornblende , feldspar , quartz , and mica , in confused aggregation ; and in this basis are 'immersed spheroids , about an inch and a half or two inches in diameter , composed of concentric alternate coats of quartz and hornblende .
The centre is principally occupied by hornblende ; this is surrounded by a zone of quartz .
These spheroids are radiated to the centre .
There can be little doubt that this rock is merely the result of interrupted crystallization ; and that , if the process of arrangement had continued , this structure ] DOLOMIEU , 7ournal de Physique , 1794 , page z6o .
would have disappeared , and the whole rock would have resembled the present basis .
Hitherto , this very singular rock has only been found in detached fragments.* The admission that solution is not a requisite of crystallization , appears to me an important concession in favour of the aqueous system , which has laboured under very great embarrassment , from the difficulty of dissolving quartz .
If a very perfect mechanical suspension be all that is requisite , we may cease to wonder at the almost daily formation of petrified wood , ( in which , though crystallization does not actually take place , a very perfect arrangement is indicated , by the intimate union of the siliceous particles , ) or of hydrophanous semiiopals in the decomposed serpentine of Mussinet , near Turin , or of chalcedony containing drops of water , in the decomposed basalt of Vicenza .
I have endeavoured to show , that in the crystallizations rev suiting from igneous fusion , it is not only possible but probable , that the most infusible substances might not be the , first to.crystallize ; and this appears to involve important consequences , for it partly removes one of the greatest difficulties that embarrasses the igneous theory , by explaining the possibility of refractory substances generated by fire being impressed by the forms of more fusible ones .
It seems , however , that the same order of arrangement would prevail in substances that were suspended in a fluid medium , as the degrees of attraction would be the same .
In either case , the first step by which the arrangeSment of an apparently homogeneous mass commenced , would probably be the accumulation of particular molecules into little globules .
Such seems to have happened in variolites , and other rocks which contain spherical concretions of a different nature from their basis .
Still farther advanced is the arrangement of porphyries : the molecules of one species have assumed a regular crystalline form ; and sometimes two or even more varieties of crystals are formed , which re-main unmixed in the unarranged basis .
If the remaining molecules of that basis are susceptible of crystallization , it may be fairly concluded , that an extension of the process of arrangement would convert the porphyry into granite , or at least into one of the compound aggregates of crystals which constitute the numerous tribes of granites , grimsteins , and sienites ; and it seems equally probable that this might be accomplished , whether the molecules were indebted to a suitable temperature , or to an aqueous medium , for the requisite facility of movement .
The formation of granite and other rocks , must however be referred to the ultinate perfection of crystallization , by which all the molecules have been permitted to arrange .
Those granites called porphy itic , in which large crystals of feldspar are imp bedded in a asis compounded of the ordinary ingredients of granite i imall grains , are apparently generated from a men.struum in which the molecules of one spel:ies , being greatly.predozninant in number to the rest , are the first to exercise their polarity , and constitute large crystals , which are afterwards sure rou ded by smaller ones , resulting Mrom the successive separations of the remaining elementary molecules .
The changes of the substance that led toi the forego-ing rev marks , serve to show that they are not altogether hypothetical ; and any proof that may appear deficient , seem.s to be provided by the phenomena exhibited by lavas , in which may be observed every step of the passage from the vitreous to the stony , from that to the porphyritic , and finally to the granitic stater .
The lava of Lipari , which passes from glass to lava , by the generatioio of minute globules , may be cited , on the authority of SPALLANZANI , as an instance of the commencement of the process of arrangement ; * and , were not their origin still disputed , I might also cite the pitchstone lavas of the Euganean hills .
It would appear , that the transition from the stony to the porphyrytic state is rapid , for perfectly homogeneous lavas are among the rarest of volcanic products .
The porphyritic lavas are most numerous ; and it is needless to detail the varieties they present .
But , though the process of arrangement has often only advanced thus far , it has in many instances proceeded much farther , and it is by no means unusual to find the entire basis regularly arranged into crystalline bodies ; thus , to cite a well known instance , in many of the ancient lavas of Sommna , large augites are imbedded in a crystalline mass , formed of minute crystals of leucite , together with another crystalline substance , whose nag ture is not perfectly determined .
The casual occurrence of volcanic glass is nowise at variance with this account , as it is sufficiently probable , that some glasses may have a much greater tendency to crystalline arrangement than others possess ; and it cannot appear extraordinary , that regular crystals should sometimes be generated , even in the glass , as it is a matter of daily occurrence in artificial glasses , and in furnace slags .
If the distinction attempted to be shown between igneous fusion and solution be established , -it may offer a means of accounting for the abundance of peculiar bodies in lava , which do not exist in other situations , or at least are of extremely rare occurrence .
For , if the igneous action decomposes the molecules of the substances on which it operates , there seems every ifirgments , as glass properly ( does .
Besides , it has I know not what of unctuosity to the touch , and to the eye , which is not perceptible in the more perfect volcanic K glasses .
It yields sparks with steel , like the lava ; but the lava is wholly opaque , and tes w glass , at the angles arid thin edges , has considerable transparency .
It is only opaque where the globules are , which appear to be particles of lava .
" probability that new compounds may result , dissimilar to any substances we are acquainted with .
It vould appears that the necessity of imagining an undiscovered stratum abounding in leucites ; chrysolites , and augites , may be dispensed with ; and , as I have endeavoured to show the probability that the most infusible substances will not be the first to crystallize , the penetration of refractory leucites by fusible augites , will cease to be an argument against both being generated in the lava .
I may also observe , that the same causes which vary the crystallized bodies resulting from igneous solution , must operate upon the unarranged basis ; and that the same rock may be fused into lavas extremely dissimilar , as their varieties must depend on the degree of solution which the fusion has accomplished.* If the analogy attempted to be shown between the aqueous and igneous formation appear founded , the transition from glass to stone can no way affect the great question which has so long divided geologists , about the origin of basalt ; for , though it is synthetically demonstrated that basalt may be formed by fire , the converse of that proposition stands supported by strong analogical arguments , and its formation by water must be allowed to be at least equally possible .
How far the probabilities derived from the examination of basaltic formations may influence the ultimate decision , is an enquiry in which I shall not now engage ; though I cannot avoid recalling to my mind , the numerous The evidence of the generation of leucites in the lava which contains them , collected by LEOPOLD de BucH , and BREiSLAC , and finally acquiesced in by DOLOv , appears so satisfactory , that it can hardly be deemed presumptuous to assume the point as determined .
Neither de Bucn nor DoLoMiEu have been able to con .
un ce themselves that the augites were also formed in the lava ; b.ut I confess myself entirely unable to appreciate the cogency of their arguments , wiich seem annihilated 1y the admission they have made in favour of leucites .
MIDCCclV .
Rr instances of petrifactions found in basalt , and , as a counterpoise to that observation , the-equally numerous instances in which the heat emanating from it appears to have indurated strata , and coaked beds of coal .
One remark may be stated here with propriety , as it arises immediately from the experiment which has occasioned these observations .
In the ultimate result of that experiment , the arrangement of the molecules was much more-perfect than in the original rock .
It might be supposed , that a longer continuance of the suitable temperature was afforded it .
This , however , could not be , for the mass Was only a few feet long , and a few inches thick .
; the fire was only maintained a day ; and the whole was cooled in a week .
But the hill of solid basalt , from which the substance operated upon was taken , is several miles long , and several hundred feet high ; and , supposing it to have been irrupted in a state of igneous fusion , it must have required months , nay years , for its refri-geration .
How then comes it , that the process of crystallization is so little advanced ?
How comes the confusion of its texture to indicate the very reverse of the tranquillity and perfection of arrangement , which may be fairly assumed as necessarily attending the extremely gradual changes of so immense a mass , ?
This objection admits of being obviated , upon the supposition that , in the process of melting , the molecules of the basalt were decomposed ; and that the new ones generated were more disposed to crystallize than those whose place they supplied .
This explanation is in some degree justified , by the total disappearance of the minute feldspars and hornblende of the basalt ; instead of which , the regenerated stone contains thin laminam of crystals , which are probably augites .
I cannot leave this subject without noticing some particulars , in which the process of arrangement described in the early part of this Letter , appears to yield a probable explanation of some of the peculiarities of basalt .
The general disposition of basalt to divide into globular masses , in decomposing , is too remarkable a fact to have escaped the -attention of naturalists ; though , as far as I am informed , no satisfactory explication of it has been given .
The common effects of decomposition are obviously inadequate ; for it is common to see a large block of amorphous basalt separate into numerous balls , after a few months or years exposure to the weather ; and , rapid as the process of decomr .
position has been in the intervening portions , these balls resist its farther progress with , uncommon obstinacy .
May not this be attributed to the formation of the radiated spheroids , whose occurrence in my experiment I have already mentioned . ?
and may not their greater resistance of weather simply arise from their aggregation being more perfect than that of the incoherent molecules which have filled the intervals between them . ?
Though the radiated structure has disappeared to the eye , these portions of the stone retain the superiority of more perfect internal arrangement ; and , if my , pigmy experiments could yield spheroids of two inches diameter , there can be no difficulty in supposing that the grand operations of nature may produce them of several feet .
The separation of the decomposed fragments in concentric coats , seems easily explained ; for I have already pointed out the facility with which the radii of the spheroids separated at nearly the same distances from their centres , and the form of the fragments which resulted , resembling fragments of bombs.* If this idea be not considered as entirely divested of plausibiy lity , I may venture to extend the same principle , to account for the wonderful regularity of the prismatic configuration of basaltic columns , and also for their articulations .
If we suppose that a mass of fluid basalt has filled a valley to an indefinite depth and extent , the process of arrangement in its particles must be induced by the removal of its heat or moisture , according as its solution is igneous or aqueous .
This can only he dlone by the action of the atmosphere on its upper surface , and by the ground on which it reposes absorbing the heat or moisture from its under surface .
From the variations of the atmosphere , its action must be irregular ; and , from the perpetual change of the parts in contact with the heated or moist surface , its operations will always be nearly as active as at first , allowance being made for its variations .
But the absorption of the ground will be regular , and regularly diminishing in activity ; , in proportion as the parts near the mass approach nearer to the same temperature , or same moisture , with the mass above ; and its absorptions can only be carried on by its transmission of heat or moisture to the solid rocks below .
From these con-sidlerations it--seems evident ) that the arrangement of the part of the basalt near the ground , will be begun with more energy than it can be continued , and that the results will be more slow and regular than the arrangement induced by the perpetual though variable action of the at mosphere .
After the first stage in the process of arrangement has been performed , and a stra- .
turn , it I may so termi it , of the jaspideous substance extended over Lhe surface of the ground , there seems no reason to doubt so many substancesS that WERNER has called the formation it seems to indicates " ( f ?
bgesonderle sliicke , " which has be n rwndered in English distinct concretiois , that a number of radiated spheroids would be generated in it , which would probably have all their centres about the same distance from the ground ; and , as the arranging power undergoes a gradual dimiinution of energy , it is not probable that two rows in height of them should be formed at once , as that would indicate a hasty process , which had prepared a greater mass of matter for their almost simultaneous formation .
From , these considerations , there seems no , improbability in .
supposing , .
; that in the arrangement of a mass of fluid basalt , a. single layer , of radiated spheroids would be formed , reposing on the ground .
which supported the mass .
I have already stated , that when the radii of two spheroids came into contact , no penetration ensued , but the two bodies became mutually compressed , and separated by a plane , welldefined .
, and invested with a rusty colour .
I also stated , that when several spheroids encountered , they formed one another into prisms with well defined angles .
In a stratum composed of an indefinite number in superficial extent , but only one in height , of impenetrable spheroids , with nearly equidistant centres , .
if their peripheries should come in contact on the same plane , it , seems obvious that their mutual action would form them into hexagons .
; and , , if these were resisted below , and there was no opposing cause above them , it seems equally clear , that they would extend their dimensions upwards , and thus form hexas gonal prisms , whose length might be indefinitely greater thanw their diameters .
The farther the extremities of the radii swear .
removed from .
the centre , the nearer would be their approachto parallelism ; and the structure would be finally propagated by .
nearly parallel fibres , still keeping within the limits , of the hexa-y gonal prism with which their incipient , formation-.commenced ; ; and the prisms might thus shoot to an indefinite length into the undisturbed central -mass of the fluid , till their structure was deranged by the superior influence of a counteracting cause , which would be provided by the action of the atmosphere on the upper surface of the basalt .
If this arrangement existed , the same cause that determined the concentric fractures of the fibres of the spheroids , would produce convex articulations in the lower joints of the prisms ; and , in proportion as the centre from which they were generated became more remote , the articulations would approximate to planes .
If the generating centres were not equidistant , the forms of the pillars would be irregular ; and the irregularity would be in proportion to the diversity of distance between the centres .
If the difference was great , the number of sides would be altered , and they might be found pentagonal , tetrahedral , and trihedral .
As the compression of the fibres would be greatest in the level of the generating centres , the lower part of the prisms would be most compact .
All these conditions seem to be fulfilled , in the actual conformation of basaltic columns ; for , in ' every instance I am acquainted with , they appear to have been formed in the tranquil bosom of the mass , as they have been originally masked by amorphous trap , and their prismatic structure is only displayed by the removal of this covering .
This has been variously effected , sometimes by the apparent disrupture of rocks , sometimes by the exterior portions of the mass being thrown down by the failure of the ground on which it stood , sometimes by the violence of the waves , and not unfrequently by the working of quarries .
In most instances , these operations have only removed the covering from one side of the colonnade ; and it remains crowned , and generally surrounded , by an immense amorphous mass .
Where there are two ranges of columns , with an ' intervening amorphous stratum , it is probable that the upper is the result of a second inundation of fluid basalt .
It is well known that basaltic columns are most solid at the bottom ; and their convex articulations have been repeatedly observed .
Since these considerations occurred to me , I have had no opportunity of examining , whether the divisions approach nearer to the plane surfaces as they recede from the centre from which the prism was generated , nor whether below that centre the convex surface of the articulations is inverted ; but I think it by no means improbable , that subsequent observations may establish this to be the case , and thus confer on this hypothesis nearly all the demonstration of which it is susceptible .
I may however add , that the phenomena of prismatic division in basaltic veins , perfectly coincide with what might be inferred from the data upon which my reasoning has proceeded .
In veins , it is obvious that the refrigerating or absorbing cause must operate with nearly equal force on each side of the vein ; and it follows , that two sets of prisms would be generated which would be horizontal instead of perpendicular , and that , unless a mass of amorphous basalt was interposed between them , they must form a division in the middle of the vein , as , from the mutual imp .
" netrability of their fibres , they could not incorporate .
The coincidence of the existing phenomena with these conclusions , is sufficiently remarkable ; for , in numerous observations I have made on the basaltic veins which affect the prismatic configuration , I found the prisms were always horizontal , and often , that there were two ranges of them .
One of their ends applied to the wall of the veins , the other frequently united to an amorphous mass which separated them and , when no such _intermedium occurred , there was invariably a division in the middle of the vein .
Not unfrequently , the veins contain three sets of prisms ; a range of small ones on each side , and of much larger ones in the middle .
In this case , the little prisms are always separated from the large ones , and the divisions of the large ones are very irregular .
After the statement of my opinion , that perfect similarity of structure may exist in the products of aqueous and igneous formation , it will hardly be necessary to conclude these observations with remarking , that I should not consider the establishment of these peculiar modes of arrangement as the slightest , demonstration of the igneous origin of basalt .
It appears to me , that the truth of my deductions is entirely independent of either theory , and that , if ever the period should arrive when the origin of basalt shall be determined by irrefragable demonstration , the inferences I have drawn may be accommodated with , equal facility to either mode of agency .
t* The observations alluded to were -made during the course of last summer , ( 1803 , ).on the very numerous basalt veins , or , as they are there called , Whin Dykes , which traverse the red sandstone and red sandstone breccia , which forms the greatest part of the coast of the Firth of Clyde , between Greenock and the Largs .
t Mr. KEIR , in his Paper on the Crystallizations formed in Glass , suggests the probability of basaltic pillars being formed by the crystallization of vitreous lavvas .
See Philosophical Transactions for 1776 , Vol. LXV1 .
page 53o .
DOLOIMI EU was of opinion , that the prismatic form was peculiar to kavas which had " lowed into the sea ; and he attributed it to the shrinking of the mass : his descrption.of the appearances exhibited by what he calls the prismatic lavas at the foot of Etna , merits quotation .
In the lavas of Etna , the form and dimensions of the columns vary as much as the manner in which they are grouped ; hexaedral and pentaedral prisms are most abundant ; then the tetraedral , the triedral , heptaedral , and octaedral .
The least I have seen ark only four inches diameter ; others are more than three set ; they are The immerse magnitude of some basaltic columns , the extreme regularity of their prismatic configuration , and the peculiar structure of their articulations , have directed the attention of not uralists to them , much more than to any of the other rocks which affect the columnar form .
Yet many of these are sufficiently remarkable to deserve more particular notice than has generally been paid to them ; and they afford most illustrative proof , that this configuration is not confined to either the aqueous or igneous formation ; for some lavas , universally allowed to commonly of a single shoot , which is sometimes 6o feet high ; others are divided by " articulations , which are from one to six feet asunder .
'I I have more than once observed a large column divide into several smaller in its " upper part .
The columns are generally larger near the top than the bottom of the de stream of lava , because they subdivide ; and they are always least in that part of the .
" stream of lava which first enteredthe water , the refrigeration being more prompts " and its effects more marked .
Sometimes the columns are placed perpendicularly " side by side , and form vertical walls , which are : sometimes more than ioo feet high , " S and a league long ; sometimes they are heaped obliquely , horizontally , and in all " c positions .
Some , without being divided in their length , are larger at one end than " s the other ; and then they are arranged like wood piled up , with all the small ends at Cc one side ; sometimes they are formed into pyramidal bundles , by parting from a " i common centre ; and , finally , there are some which , by their reunion , form large " balls .
These radii of lava , which are rather pyramidal than prismatic , resemble " r those Qf the obular pyrites , striated from the centre to the circumference , which " are found in the chalk of Champagne .
" c On the shore of la Trezza , near the Mole , there is a very curious group of little " ' articulated prisms , which issue from a common centre , and form fasciculi singularly ts twisted .
The articulations are marked , but the species-of vertebra do not separate .
" C In the heart of the mountain on which stands the Castello di Jaci , there are large " balls , from two to four feet in diameter , resembling in form the large pyrites in the " chalk of Champagne .
These balls of lava are formed of pyramidal columns , united " by their points in axcommon centre .
" 'Catalogue des Laves de l'Etna , page 453 .
The division of the upper part of basaltic columns into several smaller ones , has also been observed in the basaltic columns of Fairhead , by Dr. RICHARDSON .
See NICHOLSON'S Journal , 4to .
Vol. V. page 321 be such , are prismatic.* Columns of porphyry are not rare ; and , among other places , are found near Dresden , several feet in length , and not more than two -inches in diameter .
Columns of petrosilex compose a large portion of a mountain near Conistone lake .
Very perfect quadrangular prisms of argillaceous schistus are found near Llanwrst .
Rubble slate assumes the columnar form at Barmouth .
The limestone near Cyfartha , in Glamorganshire , is divided into very regular acute rhomboidal prisms : even the sandstone of the same district is not unfrequently columnar ; and one of the beds of gypsum at Montmartre is distinctly divided into pretty regular columns .
Sandstone , clay , argillaceous iron ore , and many other substances , become prismatic by torrefaction ; and the prisms of starch formed in drying have often been considered as illustrative of basaltic formations .
I am very far from conceiving , that all these configurations are influenced by such systematic arrangements as have determined the form of some basaltic columns .
I consider most of them as solely attributable to contraction ; which is only a farther extension of the aggregative force , and must be regulated by the texture , the form , and the position of the mass .
Where the texture of the mass is homogeneous , and its contractions unit form , its dimensions may be diminished , without its continuity being destroyed , provided its aggregation be so strong .
as to overcome the vis inertia ?
of the mass , and its adhesion to other substances .
But , when the resistance is sufficient to overcome the aggregation , the mass will be rent by fissures perpendicular to the direction in which the greatest resistance to its contraction takes place , or , in other words , by fissures perpendicular to its greatest surface ; for it is from the extremities of the greatest surface , that the largest quantity of matter must traverse the greatest space , in order that the contraction may be performed without breach of continuity ; therefore , if it be an extensive tabular mass , it will be divided into prisms , by fissures perpendicular to its surfaces The power of aggregation would determine these prisms to be hexagonal , as that form contains the greatest quantity of matter in the least surface , of any , prisms that can be united without interposing prisms of other forms .
But this would require the texture , the contraction , the thickness of the mass , and its adhesion to surrounding substances , to be every where precisely the same ; and , as these conditions can never be fulfilled in an extensive formation , all the irregularities that are found must necessarily ensue .
The same rule that determines the fissures of a tabular mass to be perpendicular to its surfaces must determine the rents in a spheroid to 'be directed from its periphery to its centre .
Though these considerations may be sufficient to explain the tendency to division into prisms , which is so generally extended , and which has produced many of those abortions that have been on Pasalt , &amp;c. dignified with the name of columns , because they have occurred in lavas and in rocks of trap formation , they are utterly inadequate to illustrating the formation of the more perfect basaltic prisms : they offer no means of accountingfor the extreme regularity of the sides and the precision of the angles , for the articulations , for the close contact in which the perfect columns are placed to one another , nor for their mutual adhesion , which is so strong , that it often requires considerable violence to separate them .
These facts are in absolute contradiction to all idea of retreat or contraction , and seem to me to coincide perfectly with the explanation of their origin which I have already presumed to lay before you .
I have the honour to be , &amp;c. GREGORY WATT .

