III .
An Account of a curious Phenomenon observed on the Glaciers of Chamouny ; together with some occasional Observations concerning the Propagation of Heat in Fluids .
By Benjamin Count of Rumford , V. P. R. S. Foreign Associate of the National Institute of France , &amp;c. &amp;c. Read December 15 , * 1803 .
IN an excursion which I made the last summer , in the month of August , to the Glaciers of Chamouny , in company with Professor PICTET of Geneva , I had an opportunity of observing , on what is called the Sea of Ice , ( Mer de Glace , ) a phenomenon very common , as I was told , in those high and cold regions , but which was perfectly new to me , andengaged all my attention .
At the surface of a solid mass of ice , of vast thickness and extent , we discovered a pit , perfectly cylindrical , about seven inches in diameter , and more than four feet deep ; quite full of water .
On examining it on the inside , with a pole , I found that its sides were polished ; and that its bottom was hemispherical , and well defined .
This pit was not quite perpendicular to the plane of the horizon , but inclined a little towards the south , as it descended ; and , in consequence of this inclination , its mouth or opening , at the surface of the ice , was not circular , but elliptical .
From our guides I learnt , that these cylindrical holes are frequently found on the level parts of the Ice ; that they are formed during the summer , increasing gradually in depth , as long as the hot weather continues ; btit that they are frozen up , and disappear , on the return of winter .
I would ask those who maintain that water is a conductor of heat , how these pits are formed ?
On a supposition that there is no direct communication of heat between neighbouring particles of that fluid , which happen to be at different degrees of temrperature , the phenomenon may easily be explained ; but it appears to me to be inexplicable on any other supposition .
The quiescent mass of water , by which the pit remains constantly filled , must necessarily be at the temperature of freezing ; for it is surrounded on every side by ice : but the pit goes on to increase in depth , during the whole summer .
From whence comes the heat that melts the ice continually at the bottom of the pit ?
and how does it happen , that this heat acts on the bottom of the pit only , and not on its sides ?
These curious phenomena may , I think , be explained in the following manner .
The warm winds which , in summer , blow over the surface of this column of ice-cold water , must undoubtedly communicate some small degree of heat to those particles of the fluid with which this warm air comes into immediate contact ; and the particles of the water at the surface so heated , being rendered specifically heavier than they were before , by this small increase of temperature , sink slowly to the bottom of the pit ; where they come into contact with the ice , and communicate to it the heat by which the depth of the pit is continually increased .
This operation is exactly similar to that which took place in one of my experiments , ( See my Essay on the Propagation of heat in Fluids , Experiment I7 , ) the results of which , no person , to my knowledge , has yet explained .
There is another very curious natural phenomenon , which I could wish to see explained in a satisfactory manner , by those who still refuse their assent to the opinions I have been led to adopt , respecting the ma'nner in which heat is propagated in fluids .
The water at the bottons of all deep lakes is constantly at the same temperature , ( that of 410 FAHRENHEIT , ) summer and winter , without any sensible variation .
This fact alone appears to me to be quite sufficient to prove , that if there be any immediate communication of heat between neighbouring particles or molecules of water , de proche en proche , or from one of them to the other , that communication must be so extremely slow , that we may with safety consider it as having no existence ; and it is with this limitation that I beg to be understood , when I speak of fluids as being non-conzductors of heat .
In treating of the propagation of heat in fluids , Il have hitherto confined myself to the investigation of the simple matter of fact , without venturing to offer any conjectures relative to the causes of the phenomena observed .
But the results of recent experiments on the calorific and frigorific radiations of hot and of cold bodies , ( an account of which I shall .
have the honour of laying before the Royal Society in a short time , ) have given me some .
new light respecting the nature of heat , and the mode of its communication ; and I have hopes of being able to show why all changes of temperature , in transparent liquids , must necessarily take place at their surfaces .
I have seen with real pleasure , that several ingenious gentlemen , in London , and in Edinburgh , have undertaken the investigation of the phenomena of the propagation of heat in fluids ; and that they have made a number of new and inges nious experiments , with a view to the farther elucidation of that most interesting subject .
If I have hitherto abstained from taking public notice of their observations on the opinion I have advanced on that subject , in my different publications , it was not from any want of respect for those gentlemen that I remained silent , but because I still found it to be quite impossible to explain the results of my own experiments , on any other principles than those which , on the most mature and cdispassionate deliberation , I lead been induced to adopt ; and because my own experiments appeared to me to be quite as conclusive ( to say no more of them ) as those which were opposed to them ; and , lastly , because I considered the principal point in dispute , relative to the passage of heat in fluids , as being so clearly established by the circumstances attending several great operations of nature , that this evidence did not appear to me to be in danger of being invalidated by conclusions drawn from partial and imperfect experiments , and particularly from such as are allowed on all hands to be extremely delicate .
In all our attempts to cause heat to descend in liquids , the heat unavoidably communicated to the sides of the containing vessel , must occasion great uncertainty with respect to the results of the experiment ; and , when that vessel is constructed of ice , the flowing down of the water resulting from the thawing of that ice , will cause motions in the liquid , and consequently inaccuracies of still greater moment , as I have found from my own experience ; and , when thermometers immersed in a liquid , at a small distance below its surface , acquire heat , in consequence of a hot body being applied to the surface of the liquid , that evewt is no decisive proof that the heat acquired by the thermometer is communicated by the fluid , from above , downwards , from molecule to molecule , de proche en proche ; so far fcom being so , it is not even a proof that it is from the fluid that the thermometer receives the heat which it acquires ; for it is possible , for aught we know to the contrary , that it may be occasioned by the radiation of the hot body placed at the surface of the fluid .
In the experiments of which I have given an account , in my Essay on the Propagation of Heat in Fluids , great masses , many pounds in weight , of boiling hot water , were made to repose for a long time !
( three hours ) on a cake of ice , without melting but a very small portion of it ; and , on repeating the experiment with an equal quantity of very cold water , ( namely , at the temperature Of 41 ?
FAHRENHEIT , ) nearly twice as much ice was melted in the same time .
In these experiments , the causes of uncertainty above mentioned did not exist : and the results of them were certainly most striking .
The conclusions which naturally flow from those results , have always appeared to me to be so perfectly evident and ins disputable , as to stand in no need , either of elucidation , or of farther proof .
If water be a conductor of heat , how did it happen that the heat in the boiling water did not , in three hours , find its way downwards to the cake of ice , on which it reposed , and from which it was separated only by a stratum of cold water , half an inch in thickness ?
I wish that gentlemen who refuse their assent to the opinions I have advanced respecting the causes of this curious phenomenon .
, would give a better explanation of it than that which I have ventured to offer .
I could likewise wish that they would inform us how it happens , that the water at the bottoms of all deep lakes remains constantly at the same temperature : and , above all , how the cylindrical pits , above described , are formed in the immense masses of solid and compact ice which compose the Glaciers of Chamouny ?
A remark , which surprised 'me not a little , has been made by a gentleman of Edinburgh , ( Dr. THOMSON , ) on the experiments I contrived , to render visible the currents into which liquids are thrown on a sudden application of heat , or of cold .
Lie conceives , that the mot'ons observed in my experiments , among the small pieces of amber which were suspended in a weak solution of potash in water , were no proof of currents existing in that liquid ; as they might , in his opinion , have been occasioned by a change of specific gravity in the amber , or by air attached to it .
I am sorry that so mean an opinion of my accuracy as an observer should have been entertained , as to imagine that I could have been so easily deceived .
For nothing surely is easier , than to distinguish the motion of a solid suspended in a liquid of the same specific gravity , which is carried along by a current in the liquid , from that ( of a body which descends , or ascends , in the liquid , in consequence of its relative Weight , or levity .
In the one case , the motion is uniform ; in the other , it is accelerated .
In a. current , the body may be carried forward in all directions , and even in curved lines , butl when it fills in a quiescent fluid , by the action of gravity , or rises , in conse.quen ce of its being specifically lighter than the fluid , it must necessarily move in a vertical direction .
The fact is , that I very often observed , in the course of my numerous experiments , the io ions of small particles of matter , of different kinds , in water , which Dr.'THoMsON describes ; but .
so far from inferringfrom them the existence of currents in that fluid , their cause was so perfectly evident , that I did not even think it'necessary to make any mention of -them .
I cannot conclude this Paper , without requesting that the Royal Society would excuse the liberty I hAve taken in troubling them with these remarks .
Very desirous of avoiding every species of altercation , I have hitherto cautiously abstained from engaging in literary disputes and I shall most certainly endeavour to avoid them in future .
I am responsible to the public for the accuracy of the accounts which I have published of my experiments ; but it cannot reasonably be expected , that I should answer all the objections that may be made to the conclusions which I have drawn from them .
It will however , at all times , afford me real satisfaction to see my opinions examined , and my mistakes corrected ; for my first and most earnest wish is , to contribute to the advancement of useful knowledge .

