XIII .
On the oblique Refraction of Iceland Crystal .
By William Hyde Wollaston , M. D. F. RI S. Read June 94 , ioS0 .
IN the preceding communication , I have inserted two different measures of refractive powers , distinctly observable in the Iceland crystal , as well as an estimate of its dispersive power ; but have reserved for a separate treatise , some remarks which the same mode of investigation has enabled me to make on its oblique refraction .
The optical properties of this body have been so amply described by HUYGENS , in his Traite de la Lumiere , that it could answer little purpose to attempt to make any addition to those which he has enumerated .
Bu.t , as the law to which he has reduced the oblique refractions occasioned by it , could not be verified by former methods of measurembnt , without considerable difficulty , it may be worth while to offer a new and easy proof of the justness of his conclusions .
For , since the theory by which he was guided in his inquiries , affords ( as has lately been shown by Dr. YOUNG* ) a simple explanation of several phenomena not yet accounted for by any other hypothesis , it must be admitted that it is entitled to a higher degree of consideration than it has in general received .
According to that hypothesis , light proceeding from any luminous centre , is propagated by vibrations of a medium highly a BAK EBRIAN Lecture .
Phil. Trans. for X8oi .
elastic , that pervades all space .
In ordinary cases , the incipient undulations are of a spherical form ; but , in the Iceland crystal , light appeared to HUYGENS to proceed as if the undulations were portions of an oblate spheroid , of which the axis is parallel to the short diagonal of an equilateral piece of the crystal , and its centre the point of incidence of the ray .
From this spheroidical form of the undulations , he deduces the obliquity of refraction ; and lays down a law , observable in all refractions , at any surface of the spar , whether natural or artificial , which bears the closest analogy to that which obtains universally at other refracting surfaces ; for as , in other cases , the ratio is given between the sine of incidence and sine of refraction , ( or ordinate of the spherical undulation propagated , ) so , in the Iceland crystal , the ratio between the sine of incidence and ordinate of refraction ( in any one section of the spheroidical undulation ) is a given ratio .
If ABD ( Fig. i , Plate XV .
) be any surface of the spar , let FHOK be a section of the spheroid through its centre C , and RC any ray of light falling on that surface ; draw FO a diameter of the spheroid , in the plane of incidence RVO , and CT , its semiconjugate diameter , in the plane of refraction FTO .
Then , if CI be the refracted ray , VR , the sine of incidence , shall be to El , the ordinate of refraction parallel to FC , in the constant ratio of a given line N to the semidiameter FC .
In any other plane of incidence , the ratio of sine to ordinate is also constant ; but it is a different ratio , according to the magnitude of that diameter in which the plane of incidence intersects the ellipse FHLOK .
When the incidence of a ray passing from any medium of greater density upon a surface of this spar , is such that the 3s4 emergent ray becomes parallel to the surface , the ordinate of refraction is then a semidiameter of the spheroid ; and , accordingly , the refractive power of this spar , when examined by means of a prism in different directions , should be found to vary as that semidiameter which coincides with the plane of incidence and refracting surface .
The observations that I have made on this substance , accord throughout with this hypothesis of HUYGENS ; the measures that I have taken , correspond more nearly than could well happen to a false theory , and are the more to be depended on , as all my experiments , excepting the last , were made prior to my acquaintance with the theory , and their agreement was deduced by subsequent computation .
Exp. i. The oblique refraction of this spar is rendered visible , by cementing a surface of it to a prism of flint-glass , with a little balsam of Tolu .
When the line of sight bisects an acute angle of a natural surface of the spar , the refractive power is seen to be less than in any other direction , and may be expressed by the sine 1,488 , or its reciprocal 0,67204 .
Exp. 2 .
When the plane of incidence is parallel to one of the sides , the power is 1,518 , of which the reciprocal is o,6587 .
Exp. 3 .
In a direction at right angles with either side , it is found still higher , being 1,537 , or its reciprocal 0,6506 .
Exp. 4 .
And , in the plane bisecting an obtuse angle , the refractive power of the natural surface appears greatest , and is expressed by the sine 1,571 , or its reciprocal 0,6365 .
Exp. 5 .
When either of the two greatest solid angles of the spar contained under three obtuse angles , is cut off by a polished surface making equal angles with each of its sides , the same refractive power 1,488 is found in all directions .
By the 3D g theory also , the section of the spheroid is in this case a circle , and every semidiameter ( FC ) the same , since the plane is at right angles to the minor axis .
Exp. 6 .
If a plane surface be formed bisecting an obtuse angle of the spar , and applied to a prism , the same minimum of refraction 1,488 , is found in a direction that coincides with the preceding plane , and therefore with the major axis of the generating ellipse ; but , as the direction is varied , it increases so rapidly as soon toexceed the power of glass , and to be no longer ascertainable by the angle of incipient reflection .
Exp. 7 .
The regular refraction of this spar is also too great for examination by means of any prism , for want of a medium of union of sufficient density ; but , by trial in the usual method , it measured , on an average of several experiments , 1,6 7 , or its reciprocal o,6o35 .
By assuming , as HUYGENS has done , the equality of this power with the maximum of the oblique refraction , we have sufficient data for construction of the spheroid by which the refractions are regulated ; for we have o,670o4 ( Exp. i. ) as major axis of the generating ellipse , and 0,6035 ( Exp. 7 .
) will be the minor axis , parallel in position to the short axis of the spar .
The angle of inclination of this axis.to the surfaces of the spar , if supposed to be equilateral , may be computed by spherical trigonometry , from any other angle that has been ascertained by measurement .
The measures that I have taken are not exactly those of HUYGENS ; but I nevertheless hold them in equal estimation , from the conformity which I find they bear to each other , by assistance of his theory , Exp. 8 .
I measured with care , an angle at which two surfaces of the spar are inclined to each other , and found it to be 105 ? ?
5 ' .
Hence , the greater angle of the surfaces themselves may be computed to be lo1 ? ?
55 ' ; and the angle which the short axis makes with each plane surface is 45 ?
S 2'5 " .
If GSMP ( Fig. ~ .
) be a plane bisecting an obtuse angle of the spar , the section of the spheroid in that plane passes through the axis CS , and therefore is the generating ellipse .
By calculating from the known dimensions of its major axis CP o,67204 , its minor axis CS 0,6035 , and : the angle GCS -=.45 23 ' 25 " , CG will be-found* to be 0,6365 , of which the reciprocal is 1,5736 ; differing but little from 1,571 , as it appeared by measurement .
( Ep. 4 .
) Again , if ABDE ( Fig. 4 .
) be one of the natural surfaces , and PGp the ellipse formed by that section of the spheroid , PC being as beforeo,67204 , and CG 0,6365 , the reciprocal of 1,571 found by measurement , ( Exp. 4 .
) then the semidiameter CT , parallel to the side AE , which makes an angle TCP 39 ? ?
2-t ' will be found to be 0,6573 , instead of 0,6587 , and its reciprocal 1,5215 , instead of 1,518 .
( Exp. 2 .
) The semidiameter also , in the direction of CL , perpendicular to the ijde , at an angle LCP ? ?
57-1't , is found by calculation 0,65o , and its reciprocal 1,539 , instead of o,6o56 and 1,537 .
( Exp. 3 .
) From the foregoing data , the course of a ray perpendicular to the surface of the spar may likewise be computed ; for , since the sine of incidence is then nothing , the ordinate of refraction must be also nothing , and the ray will be refracted along the semiconjugate diameter CM1 .
( Fig. 2 .
) By calculation , * the angle which this conjugate makes with the perpendicular is 6 ? ?
73 ' .
But , by the following measurement , it appears to be 6 ?
i6 ' .
Exp. 9 .
A piece of spar that measured 1,145 inch in thickness , was laid upon a line , and showed two images that were removed from each other -4o6 of an inch .
Then , as 1,145 : 0,126 : : radius : tang .
of 6 ? ?
16 ' .
The different results deduced from theory and from observation , will be seen at one view in the following statement .
In Exp. 2d , observed 1,518 ; calculated 1,5215 .
gd , --1,537 -----:,539 .
4th , ---1,571 _ 1,5736 .
gth , angle observed 6 ? ?
16 ' 60 7- ' The angle observed differs from that obtained by computation , in a greater degree than any of the former measures ; but , when the difficulty of measuring this angle with accuracy is considered , and also the greater effect of any incorrectness in the data from which a semiconjugate is computed , I think the result of this , as well of the preceding comparisons , must be admitted to be highly favourable to the HUYGENIAN theory ; and , although the existence of two refractions at the same time , in the same substance , be not well accounted for , and still less their interchange with each other , when a ray of light is made to pass through a second piece of spar situated transversely to the first , yet the oblique refraction , when considered alone , seems nearly as well explained as any other optical phenomenon .
( Fig. S* ) CS CP::tang .
PCG : tang .
pCO or co-tang .
PCQj then CP CS : : tang .
PCQ : tang .
PCM ; and LCP PCM = MCL .
[ .
Ilit*iiqI LI Ii Ii/ I jj ?
1 I ; ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I Ii i(i , ijr ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i it~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i i~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~j I_r~~__JIIII4/ ij 'vt i "

