PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
VIII .
Observations on the two lately discovered celestial Bodies .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F. R. S. Read May 6 , i8o2 .
IN my early account of the moving star discovered by Mr. PIAZZI , I have already shown that it is of a remarkably small size , deviating much from that of all the primary planets.* It was not my intention to rest satisfied with an estimation of the diameter of this curious object , obtained by comparing it with the GEORGIAN planet , and , having now been very successful in the application of the lucid disk micrometer , I shall relate the result of my investigations .
But the very interesting discovery of Dr. OLBERs having introduced another moving star to our knowledge , I have extended my researches to the magnitude , and physical construction , of that also .
Its very particular nature , which , from the observations I shall relate , appears to be rather cometary than planetary , will possibly throw also considerable light upon the circumstances belonging to the other celestial body ; and , by that means , enable us to form some judgment of the nature of both the two last-discovered phenomena .
As the measures I have taken will oblige me to give a result which must appear extraordinary , it will be highly necessary to be particular in the circumstances of these measures , and to mention the condition and powers of the telescopes that were used to obtain them .
Magnitude of the new Stars .
April i , 1802 .
Having placed a lucid disk at a considerable distance from the eye , but so that I might view it with perfect distinctness , I threw the image of Mr. PIAZZI'S star , seen in a 7-feet reflector , very near it , in order to have the projected picture of the star and the lucid disk side by side , that I might ascertain their comparative magnitudes .
I soon perceived that the length of my garden would not allow me to remove the disk-micrometer , which must be placed at right angles to the telescope , far enough to make it appear nolarger than the star ; and , not having disks of a less diameter prepared , I placed the smallest I had , as far from me as the situation of the star would allow .
Then , bringing its image again by the side of the disk , and viewing , at the same time , with one eye the magnified star , while the other eye saw the lucid disk , I perceived that Ceres , which is the name the discoverer has given to the star , was hardly more than one third of the diameter of the disk , and certainly less than one half of it .
This being repeated , and always appearing the same , we 2g1 shall not under-rate the size of the star , by admitting its diameter to have been 5 hundredths of the lucid disk .
The power of the telescope , very precisely ascertained , by terrestrial geometrical measures properly reduced to the focus of the mirror on the stars , was 370,42 .
The distance of the lucid disk from the eye , was 2131 inches ; and its diameter 3 , inches .
Hence we compute , that the disk was seen under an angle of ' 29 " , o0 ; and Ceres , when magnified 370 times , appearing , as we have shown , 45 hundredths of that magnitude , its real diameter could not exceed o",4o .
Had this diameter amounted to as much as was formerly estimated , the power of 37o would have made it appear of 6 ' io " , which is more than the whole lucid disk .
This extraordinary result , raised in me a suspicion , that the power 370 of a 7-feet telescope , and its aperture of 6,3 inches , might not be sufficient to show the planet 's feeble light properly .
I therefore adapted my lo-feet instrument to observations with lucid disks ; which require a different arrangement of the head of the telescope and finder : I also made some small transparencies , to represent the object I intended to measure .
April 21 .
The night being pretty clear , though perhaps not quite so proper for delicate vision as I could have wished , I directed my lo-feet reflector , with a magnifying power of 516,54 , also ascertained by geometrical terrestrial measures reduced to the focus of the instrument on celestial objects , to Mr. PIAZZI'S star , and compared it with a lucid disk , placed at 1486 inches from the eye , and of 1,4 inch in diameter .
I varied the distance of the lucid disk many times ; and fixed at last on the above-mentioned one , as the best I could find .
There was , however , a haziness about the star , which resembled a faint coma ; and this , it may be supposed , must render the measure less satisfactory than it would otherwise have been .
From these data we compute , that the disk appeared to the natural eye under an angle of ' 14",33 ; while Ceres , when magnified 516-times , was seen by the other eye of an equal magnitude ; and that consequently its real diameter , by measurement , was only o0"38 .
April 22 .
il1 38 ' , sidereal time .
I used now a more perfect small mirror ; the former one having been injured by long continued solar observations .
This gave me the apparent diameters of the stars uncommonly well defined ; to which , perhaps , the very favourable and undisturbed clearness of the atmosphere might contribute considerably .
With a magnifying power of 881,51 , properly ascertained , like those which have been mentioned before , I viewed Dr. OLBERS'S star , and compared it with a lucid disk of 1,4 inch in diameter , placed at 1514 inches from the eye , measured , like the rest of the distances , with long deal rods .
The star appeared to me so ill defined , that , ascribing it to the eye-glass , I thought it not adviseable to compare the object , as it then appeared , with a well defined lucid disk .
Exchanging the glass for that which gives the telescope a magnifying power of 516 ?
, I found Pallas , as the discoverer wishes to have it called , better defined ; and saw , when brought together , that it was considerably less in diameter than the lucid disk .
In order to produce an equality , I removed the disk to 1942 inches ; and still found Pallas considerably less than the disk .
Before I changed the distance again , I wished to ascertain whether Ceres or Pallas would appear under the largest angle , especially as the air was now more pure than last night .
On 216 comparing the diameter of Ceres with that of the lucid disk , I found it certainly less than the disk .
By proper attention , and continued examination , for at least an hour , I judged it to be nearly ?
of the lucid disk .
Then , if we calculate as before , it appears by this observation , in which there is great reason to place confidence , that the angle under which this star appeared , was only o".a2 .
For , a lucid disk of 1,4 inch diameter , at the distance of 1942 inches , would be seen under an angle of 2 ' 28",7 ; three quarters of which are 1 ' 51",52 .
This quantity , divided by the power 516,54 , gives / " ,2 159 , or , as we have given it abridged , 0",22 .
13h 7 ' .
I removed the micrometer to the greatest convenient distance , namely , 2136 inches , and compared Dr. OLBERS'S star , which , on account of its great altitude , I saw now in high perfection , with the lucid disk .
It was , even at this distance , less than the diameter of the disk , in the proportion of 2 to 3 .
When , by long continued attention , the appearance of Pallas was reduced to its smallest size , I judged it to bear no greater proportion to the diameter of the lucid disk of the micrometer , than as i to 2 .
In consequence of these measures , it appears that the diameter of Pallas , according to the first of them , is o",17 ; and , according to the last , where the greatest possible distinctness was obtained , only o",13 .
If it should appear almost incredible that these curious objects could give so small an image , had they been so much magnified as has been reported , I can say , that curiosity led me to throw the picture of Jupiter , given by the same telescope and magnifying power , on a wall at the distance of 1318 inches , of which it covered a space that measured 12 feet 11 inches .
I do not 217 mention this as a measure of Jupiter , for the wall was not perfectly at right angles to the telescope , on which account the projected image would be a little larger than it should have been , nor was I very attentive to other necessary minute circumstances , which would be required for an accurate measure ; but we see at once , from the size of this picture , that the power of the telescope exerted itself to the full of what has been stated .
As we generally can judge best of comparative magnitudes , when the measures are , as it were , brought home to us ; it will not be amiss to reduce them to miles .
This , however , cannot be done with great precision , till we are more perfectly acquainted with the elements of the orbits of these stars .
But , for our presenlt purpose , it will be sufficiently accurate , if we admit their mean distances from the sun , as the most recent information at present states them ; for Ceres 2,6024 ; and for Pallas 2,8 .
The geocentric longitudes and north latitudes , at the time of observation , were , for Ceres , about ao 20 4 , , 15 ? ?
2o ' ; and for Pallas , Im 23 ? ?
40 ' , 17 ? ?
30 ' .
With these data , I have calculated the distances of the stars from the earth at the time of observation , partly by the usual method , and , where the elements were wanting , by a graphical process , which is sufficiently accurate for our purpose .
My computed distances were 1,634 for Ceres , and 1,8333 for Pallas ; and , by them we find , that the diameter of Ceres , at the mean distance of the earth from the sun , would subtend an angle of o",35127 ; and that , consequently , its real diameter is 16,6 miles .
It also follows , that Pallas would be seen , at the same distance from the sun , under an angle of o",3199 ; and that its real diameter , if the largest measure be taken , is 147 miles ; but , if we take the most distinct observation , which gives the a18 smallest measure , the angle under which it would be seen from the sun , will be only 0",2399 ; and its diameter , no more than Io I0 miles .
Of Satellites .
After what has just now been shown , with regard to the size of these new stars , there can be no great reason to expect that they should have any satellites .
The little quantity of matter they contain , would hardly be adequate to the retention of a secondary body ; but , as I have made many observations with a view to ascertain this point , it will not be amiss to relate them .
Feb. 25 .
2-feet reflector .
There is no small star near Ceres , that could be supposed to be a satellite .
Feb. 28 .
There is no small star within 3 or 4 minutes of Ceres , that might be taken for a satellite .
March 4 .
h1 45 ' , sidereal time .
A very small star , southpreceding Ceres , may be a satellite .
See Plate V. Fig. i. where C is Ceres , S the supposed satellite , abed of , are delineation stars , c and d are very small .
S makes nearly a right angle with them ; e is larger than either c or d. There is an extremely faint starf , between e and d. 14h 16 , ' Ceres has left the supposed satellite behind .
March 5 .
There are two very small stars , which may be satellites ; see Fig. 2 .
where they are marked , ist S , 2d S. The rest , as before , are delineation stars .
March 6 .
The two supposed satellites of last night remain in their situation , Ceres having left them far behind .
10h I6 ' .
There is a very small star , like a satellite , about 75d south-following Ceres .
See Fig. 3 .
It is in a line from C to b of last night .
219 P1 so ' .
Ceres has advanced in its orbit ; but has left the supposed satellite behind .
March 3o .
c9 35 ' .
A supposed ist satellite is directly following Ceres : it is extremely faint .
A 2d supposed satellite is north-following .
See Fig. 4 .
The supposed satellites are so small , that , with a 2o-feet telescope , they rquire a power of Soo to be seen ; and the planet should be hiddenr behind a thick wire , placed a little out of the middle of the field of view , which must be left open to look for the supposed satellites .
12h 17 ' .
Ceres has changed its place , and left both the supposed satellites behind .
March 31 .
9h 20 ' .
There is a very small star , on the northpreceding side of Ceres , which may be a satellite .
1h,50 ' .
Ceres has moved forwards in its path ; but the supposed satellite remains in its former situation .
The nearest star is 2o " of time from Ceres ; so that , within a circle of 40 " of time , there certainly is no satellite that can be seen with the space-penetrating power of this instrument .
It is evident , that when the motion of a celestial body is so considerable , we need never be long in doubt whether a small star be a satellite belonging to it , since a few hours must decide it .
May i. 12^ 51 ' .
I viewed Pallas with the 2o-feet reflector , power 300 ; there was no star within 3 ' , that could be taken for a satellite .
Of the Colour of the new zStars .
Feb. 13T .
The colour of Ceres is ruddy , but not very deep .
April 21 .
Ceres is much more ruddy than Pallas .
April 22 .
Pallas is of a dusky whitish colour .
~2 ?
0 Of the Appearances of the new Stars , with regard to a Disk .
Feb. 7 .
Ceres , with a magnifying power of 516g , shows an ill defined planetary disk , hardly to be distinguished from the surrounding haziness .
Feb. 13 .
Ceres has a visible disk .
April 22 .
In viewing Pallas , I cannot , with the utmost attention , and under the most favourable present circumstances , perceive any sharp termination which might denote a disk ; it is rather what I would call a nucleus .
April 28 .
In the finder , Pallas is less than Ceres .
It is also rather less than when I first saw it .
Of the Appearances of the new Stars , with regard to an Atmosphere , or Coma .
April 21 .
I viewed Ceres for nearly an hour together .
There was a haziness about it , resembling a faint coma , which was , however , easily to be distinguished from the body .
April 22 .
I see the disk of Ceres better defined , and smaller , than I did last night .
There does not seem to be any coma ; and I am ' inclined to ascribe the appearance of last night to a deception , as I now and then , with long attention , saw it without ; at which times , it was always best defined , and smallest .
April 28 .
Ceres is surrounded with a strong haziness .
Power 550 With 516 ?
, which is a better glass , the breadth of the coma beyond the disk may amount to the extent of a diameter of the disk , which is not very sharply defined .
Were the whole coma and star taken together , they would be at least three times as MDcccII .
Gg 2241 large as my measure of the star .
The coma is very dense near the nucleus ; but loses itself pretty abruptly on the outside , though a gradual diminution is still very perceptible .
April 3o .
Ceres has a visible , but very small coma about it .
This cannot be seen with low powers ; as the whole of it together is not large enough , unless much magnified , to make up a visible quantity .
May i. The diameter of the coma of Ceres , is about 5 times as large as the disk , or extends nearly 2 diameters beyond it .
1Sh 19 ' .
2o-feet reflector ; power 477 .
The disk of Ceres is much better defined than that of Pallas .
The coma about it is considerable , but not quite so extended as that of Pallas .
May .
13h 20 ' .
Ceres is better defined than I have generally seen it .
Its disk is strongly marked ; and , when I see it best , the haziness about it hardly exceeds that of the stars of an equal size .
Memorandum .
This may be owing to a particular disposition of the atmosphere , which shows all the stars without twinkling , but not quite so bright as they appear at other times .
Jupiter likewise has an extremely faint scattered light about it , which extends to nearly 4 or 5 degrees in diameter .
April 22 .
Pallas , with a power of 88i1 , appears to be very ill defined .
The glass is not in fault ; for , in the day time , I can read with it the smallest letters on a message card , fixed up at a great distance .
13h 171 .
The appearance of Pallas is cometary ; the disk , if it has any , being ill defined .
When I see it to the best advantage , it appears like a much compressed , extremely small , but ill defined , planetary nebula .
April 28 .
Pallas is very ill defined : no determined disk can be seen .
The coma about it , or rather the coma itself , for no star appears within it , would certainly measure , at first sight , 4 or 5 times as much as it will do after it has been properly kept in view , in order to distinguish between the haziness which surrounds it , and that part which may be called the body .
May 1 .
Pallas has a very ill defined appearance ; but the whole coma is compressed into a very small compass .
13 h.5t Qo-feet reflector ; power 477 .
I see Pallas well , and perceive a very small disk , with a coma of some extent about it , the whole diameter of which may amount to 6 or 7 times that of the disk alone .
May 2 .
1h O ' .
l o-feet reflector .
A star of exactly the same size , in the finder , with Pallas , viewed with 516- , has a different appearance .
In the centre of it is a round lucid point , which is not visible in Pallas .
The evening is uncommonly calm and beautiful .
I see Pallas better defined than I have seen it before .
The coma is contracted into a very narrow compass ; so that perhaps it is little more than the common aberration of light of every small star .
See the memorandum to the observation of Ceres , May 2 .
On the Nature of the new Stars .
From the account which we have now before us , a very important question will arise , which is , What are these new stars , are they planets , or are they comets ?
And , before we can enter into a proper examination of the subject , it will be necessary to lay down some definition of the meaning we have hitherto affixed to the term planet .
This cannot be difficult , since we have seven Gg o3 patterns to adjust our definition by .
I should , for instance , say of planets , i. They are celestial bodies , of a certain very considerable size .
e. They move in not very excentric ellipses round the sun .
3 .
The planes of their orbits do not deviate many degrees from the plane of the earth 's orbit .
4 .
Their motion is direct .
5 .
They may have satellites , or rings .
6 .
They have an atmosphere of considerable extent , which however bears hardly any sensible proportion to their diameters .
7 .
Their orbits are at certain considerable distances from each other .
Now , if we may judge of these new stars by our first criterion , which is their size , we certainly cannot class them in the list of planets : for , to conclude from the measures I have taken , Mercury , which is the smallest , if divided , would make up more than 135 thousand such bodies as that of Pallas , in bulk .
In the second article , their motion , they agree perhaps sufficiently well .
The third , which relates to the situation of their orbits , seems again to point out a considerable difference .
The geocentric latitude of Pallas , atpresent , is not less than between 17 and 8 degrees ; and that of Ceres between 15 and 16 ; whereas , that of the planets does not amount to one half of that quantity .
If bodies of this kind were to be admitted into the order of planets , we should be obliged to give up the zodiac ; for , by extending it to them , should a few more of these stars be discovered , still farther and farther deviating from the path of the earth , which 2$4 is not unlikely , we might soon be obliged to convert the whole firmament into zodiac ; that is to say , we should have none left .
In the fourth article , which points out the direction of the motion , these stars agree with the planets .
With regard to the fifth , concerning satellites , it may not be easy to prove a negative ; though even that , as far as it can be done , has been shown .
But the retention of a satellite in its orbit , it is well known , requires a proper mass of matter in the central body , which it is evident these stars do not contain .
The sixth article seems to exclude these stars from the condition of planets .
The small comas which they show , give them so far the resemblance of comets , that in this respect we should be rather inclined to rank them in that order , did other circumstances permit us to assent to this idea .
In the seventh article , they are again unlike planets ; for it appears , that their orbits are too near each other to agree with the general harmony that takes place among the rest ; perhaps one of them'might be brought in , to fill up a seeming vacancy between Mars and Jupiter .
There is a certain regularity in the arrangement of planetary orbits , which has been pointed out by a very intelligent astronomer , so long ago as the year 1772 ; but this , by the admission of the two new stars into the order of planets , would be completely overturned ; whereas , if they are of a different species , it may still remain established .
As we have now sufficiently shown that our new stars cannot be called planets , we proceed to compare them also with the other proposed species of celestial bodies , namely , comets .
The criteria by which wehave hitherto distinguished these from planets , may be enumerated as follows , 325 1 .
They are celestial bodies , generally of a very small size , though how far this may be limited , is yet unknown .
2 .
They move in very excentric ellipses , or apparently parabolic arches , round the sun .
3 .
The planes of their motion admit of the greatest variety in their situation .
4 .
The direction of their motion also is totally undetermined .
5 .
They have atmospheres of very great extent , which show themselves in various forms of tails , coma , haziness , &amp;c. On casting our eye over these distinguishing marks , it appears , that in the first point , relating to size , our new stars agree sufficiently well ; for the magnitude of comets is not only small , but very unlimited .
Mr. PIGOTT'S comet , for instance , of the year 1781 , seemed to have some kind of nucleus ; though its magnitude was so ill defined , that I probably over-rated it much , when , November 22 , I guessed it might amount to 3 or 4 " in diameter .
But , even this , considering its nearness to the earth , proves it to have been very small .
That of the year 1783 , also discovered by Mr. PIGOTT , I saw to more advantage , in the meridian , with a 2o-feet reflector .
It had a small nucleus , which , November 29 , was coarsely estimated to be of perhaps 3 " diameter .
In all my other pretty numerous observations of comets , it is expressly remarked , that they had none that could be seen .
Besides , what I have called a nucleus , would still be far from what I now should have measured as a disk ; to constitute which , a more determined outline is required .
In the second article , their motions differ much from that of comets ; for , so far as we have at present an account of the 226 orbits of these new stars , they move in ellipses which are not very excentric .
Nor are the situations of the planes of their orbits so much unlike those of the planets , that we should think it necessary to bring them under the third article of comets , which leaves them quite unlimited .
In the fourth article , relating to the direction of their motion , these stars agree with planets , rather than with comets .
The fifth article , which refers to the atmosphere of comets , seems to point out these stars as belonging to that class ; it will , however , on a more particular examination , appear that the difference is far too considerable to allow us to call them comets .
The following account of the size of the comas of the smallest comets I have observed , will show that they are beyond comparison larger than those of our new stars .
Nov. 22 , 1781 .
Mr. PIGOTT'S comet had a coma of 5 or 6 ' in diameter .
Nov , .
9 , 1783 .
Another of Mr. PIGOTT'S comets had a coma of 8 ' in diameter .
Dec. s2 , 1788 .
My sister 's comet had a coma of 5 or 6 ' in diameter .
Jan. 9 , 1790 .
Another of her comets was surrounded by haziness of 5 or 6 ' in diameter .
Jan. i8 , 1790 .
Mr. MECHAIN 's comet had a coma of 5 or 6 ' in diameter .
Nov. 7 , 1795 .
My sister 's comet had a coma of 5 or 6 ' in diameter .
Sept. 8 , 1799 .
Mr. STEPHEN LEE 's comet had a coma of not less than lo ' in diameter , and also a small tail of i , ' in length .
2.7 From these observations , which give us the dimensions of the comas of the smallest comets that have been observed with good instruments , we conclude , that the comas of these new stars , which at most amount only to a few times the diameter of the bodies to which they belong , bear no resemblance to the comas of comets , which , even when smallest , exceed theirs above a hundred times .
Not to mention the extensive atmospheres , and astonishing length of the tails , of some comets that have been observed , to which these new stars have nothing in the least similar .
Since , therefore , neither the appellation of planets , nor that of comets , can with any propriety of language be given to these two stars , we ought to distinguish them by a new name , denoting a species of celestial bodies hitherto unknown to us , but which the interesting discoveries of Mr. PIAZZI and Dr. OLBERS have brought to light .
With this intention , therefore , I have endeavoured to find out a leading feature in the character of these new stars ; and , as planets are distinguished from the fixed stars by their visible change of situation in the zodiac , and comets by their remarkable comas , so the quality in which these objects differ considerably from the two former species , is that they resemble small stars so much as hardly to be distinguished from them , even by very good telescopes .
It is owing to this very circumstance , that they have been so long concealed from our view .
From this , their asteroidical appearance , if I may use that expression , therefore , I shall take my name , and call them Asteroids ; reserving to myself , however , the liberty of changing that name , if another , more expressive of their nature , should occur .
These bodies will hold a middle rank , between the two species that 228 were known before ; so that planets , asteroids , and comets , will in future comprehend all the primary celestial bodies that either remain with , or only occasionally visit , our solar system .
I shall now give a definition of our new astronomical term , which ought to be considerably extensive , that it may not only take in the asteroid Ceres , as well as the asteroid Pallas , but that any other asteroid which may hereafter be discovered , let its motion or situation be whatever it may , shall also be fully delineated by it .
This will stand as follows .
Asteroids are celestial bodies , which move in orbits either of little or of considerable excentricity round the sun , the plane of which may be inclined to the ecliptic in any angle whatsoever .
Their motion may be direct , or retrograde ; and they may or may not have considerable atmospheres , very small comas , disks , or nuclei .
As I have given a definition which is sufficiently extensive to take in future discoveries , it may be proper to state the reasons we have for expecting that additional asteroids may probably be soon found out .
From the appearance of Ceres and Pallas it is evident , that the discovery of asteroids requires a particular method of examining the heavens , which hitherto astronomers have not been in the habit of using .
I have already made five reviews of the zodiac , without detecting any of these concealed objects .
Had they been less resembling the small stars of the heavens , I must have discovered them .
But the method which will now be put in practice , will completely obviate all difficulty arising from the asteroidical appearance of these objects ; as their motion , and not their appearance , will in future be the mark to which the attention of observers Will be directed .
A laudable zeal has induced a set of gentlemen on the Continent , to form an association for the examination of the zodiac .
I hope they will extend their attention , by degrees , to every part of the heavens ; and that the honourable distinction which is justly due to the successful investigators of nature , will induce many to join in the meritorious pursuit .
As the new method of observing the zodiac has already produced such interesting discoveries , we have reason to believe that a number of asteroids may remain concealed ; for , how improbable it would be , that if there were but two , they should have been so near together as almost to force themselves to our notice .
But a more extended consideration adds to the probability that many of them may soon be discovered .
It is well known that the comas and tails of comets gradually increase in their approach to the sun , and contract again when they retire into the distant regions of space .
Hence we have reason to expect , that when comets have been a considerable time in retirement , their comas may subside , if not entirely , at least sufficiently to make them assume the resemblance of stars ; that is , to become asteroids , in which state we have a good chance to detect them .
It is true that comets soon grow so faint , in retiring from their perihelia , that we lose sight of them ; but , if their comas , which are generally of great extent , should be compressed into a space so small as the diameters of our two asteroids , we can hardly entertain a doubt but that they would again become visible with good telescopes .
Now , should we see a comet in its aphelion , under the conditions here pointed out , and that there are many which may be in such situations , we have the greatest inducements to believe , it would be a favourable circumstance to lead us to a more perfect knowledge of the nature of comets and their orbits ; for instance , the comet of the year 1770 , which 33o Mr. LEXELL has shown to have moved in an elliptical orbit , such as would make the time of its periodical return only about 5x years : if this should still remain in our system which is however doubtful , we ought to look for it under the form of an asteroid .
If these considerations should be admitted , it might be objected , that asteroids were only comets in disguise ; but , if we were to allow that comets , asteroids , and even planets , might possibly be the same sort of celestial bodies under different circumstances , the necessary distinction arising from such difference , would fully authorise us to call them by different names .
It is to be hoped that time will soon throw a greater light upon this subject ; for which reason , it would be premature to add any other remarks , though many extensive views relating to the solar system might certainly be hinted at .
Additional Observations relating to the Appearances of the Asteroids Ceres and Pallas .
May 4 , 12 " 40 ' .
io-feet reflector ; power 516- .
I compared Ceres with two fixed stars , which , in the finder , appeared to be of very nearly the same magnitude with the asteroid , and found that its coma exceeds their aberration but in a very small degree .
2h 50 ' .
0o-feet reflector ; power 477 .
I viewed Ceres , in order to compare its appearance with regard to haziness , aberration , atmosphere , or coma , whatever we may call it , to the same phenomena of the fixed stars ; and found that the coma of the asteroid did not much exceed that of the stars .
Hh 2 23 .
I also found , that even the fixed stars differ considerably in this respect among themselves .
The smaller they are , the larger in proportion will the attendant haziness show itself .
A star that is scarcely perceptible , becomes a small nebulosity .
lo-feet reflector .
13h 1 ' .
I compared the appearance of Pallas with two equal fixed stars ; and found that the coma of this asteroid but very little exceeds the aberration of the stars .
14h 5 ' , 20-feet reflector .
I viewed Pallas ; and , with a magnifying power of 477 , its disk was visible .
The coma of this asteroid is a little stronger than that which fixed stars of the same size generally have . ?
/7/ wa ... w. MI )((( 1.I./ Y V , r / . .
, 4 .
* ) , ) .
$cC / -/ 0 6 ' ( / / ?
&lt; .^ ; f , w41 *a a ; X ?
t-/ &lt; I:t * d , e6 *b FF I I.I 7 .

