XIX .
Case of a young Gentleman , who recovered his Sight when seven Years of Age , after having been deprived of it by Cataracts , before he was a Year old ; with Remarks .
By Mr. James Ware , Surgeon .
Communicated by Maxwell Garthshore , M.D. F.R.S. Read June 1a , i8o0 .
iMASTER W. the son of a respectable clergyman , at Castlecary , in Somersetshire , was born in the year 1793 ; and , for many months , appeared to be a healthy perfect child : his eyes , in particular , were large and rather prominent .
When about six months old , he began to cut his teeth ; which was attended with great pain , and frequently with violent convulsive fits .
About the end of his first year , a number of persons passing in procession near his father 's house , accompanied with music and flags , the child was taken to see them ; but , instead of looking at the procession , it was observed that , though he was evidently much pleased with the music , his eyes were never directed to the place from whence the sound came .
His mother , alarmed by this discovery , was naturally led to try whether he could see silver spoons , and other glaring objects , which she held before him at different distances ; and she was soon convinced , that he was unable to perceive any of them .
A surgeon in the country was consulted , who , on examining the child 's eyes , discovered an opacity in the pupils , which was so considerable , that he did not hesitate to pronounce there was a complete cataract in each .
A description of the child 's situation was then sent to me , with a request that I would point out those steps which its parents should pursue .
The case was so evident , that I could not hesitate in saying , that the removal of the opaque crystalline humour , from the place it occupied behind the pupil , was the only method by which the child could obtain his sight ; and , attached as I was , at that time , in all cases , to the operation of extracting the cataract , in preference to that of depressing it , I added , that I did not think he would be fit for the operation , until he was -at least thirteen or fourteen years old .
This advice being approved , all thoughts of assisting his sight were , for the present , relinquished .
He soon discovered a great fondness for music ; his memory was very retentive of the little stories that were read or recited to him ; and , in every way , it became evident that he had a mind capable of receiving information .
As soon as he could speak , it was also observed , that when an object was held close to his eyes , he was able to distinguish its colour , if strongly marked ; but , on no occasion , did he ever notice its outline or figure .
In November , i 8oo , his parents took him to Bristol whither they went for the purpose of seeing the works carried on in the school -for the indigent blind in that city ; and in order that they might ascertain whether their son , who was then arrived to his seventh year , could be taught any thing that would be useful or amusing .
Here he very quickly learnt the art of making laces .
But his parents , having brought him so far from home , thought it adviseable to extend their plan , and make a visit to the metropolis , for the sake of giving me an opportunity of inspecting his eyes , and of hearing whether my opinion continued the same as that which I had written to them six years before .
About a month previous to the time of their arrival , a Portuguese boy , fourteen years old , had been put under my care , who was in a similar situation ; and , in this case , notwithstanding all the efforts I could use , I found it impossible to fix the eye , in order to extract the cataract , without employing a degree of force which might have been highly injurious .
I therefore relinquished my intention of performing the operation in that way , and determined to makeuse of the couching needle ; being prepared , either to depress the cataract with this instrument , if it was sufficiently solid for the purpose , or , if it was soft or fluid , ( which I rather expected , ) to puncture its capsule largely , so as to bring the opaque crystalline into free contact with the aqueous and vitreous humours .
In order to fix the eye for this operation , I was not afraid to make use of a speculum oculi ; since a pressure , which would have been highly dangerous in extracting the cataract , might be applied on the present occasion with perfect safety .
Conformably to my expectation , the cataract was of a soft consistence ; in consequence of which , I was not able to depress it , and contented myself with making a large aperture through the capsule , by means of which the crystalline was brought into contact with the other humours , a considerable part of it coming forward~s , and showing itself directly under the cornea .
This being the immediate result of the operation , it could not be expected that any improvement should Je made in the sight of the patient at that time .
In a few days , however , the opaque matter was wholly absorbed , the pupils became clear .
; and the lad recovered the sight of both his eyes.* Encouraged by the I It should be remarried , that the sight obtained by children who are born with Car taracts , is seldom so perfect as that which those reccvmr , after the operation , whoQ re success which followed this operation , I was induced to retract the opinion which I had formerly sent to Master W. 's father , ( which opinion I had given under the impression that the catan ract should be extracted , ) and I now proposed , that an attempt should .
be made to afford relief to one eye , at least , without further loss of time ; this attempt , in the way above mentioned , being practicable with as much safety at his present age as at any future period ; and , if it proved successful , it would give the young gentleman the benefit of vision five or six years sooner than his friends had been encouraged to expect , by my former letter on this subject .
They were naturally much pleased with this alteration in my advice ; and the child himself appearing to possess a great degreeof fortitude , I performed the operation on the left eye , on the 29th of December last , in the presence of Mr. CHAMBERLAIN , F. A. S. Doctor BRADLEY , of Baliol College , Oxford , and Mr. PLATT , surgeon , ill London .
It is not necessary in this place , to enter into a description of the operation .
It will be sufficient to say , that the child , during its performance , neither uttered an exclamation , nor made the smallest motion , either with -his head or hands .
The eye was immediately bound up , and no inquiries made on that day with regard to his sight .
On the 3oth , I found that he had experienced a slight sickne-ss on the preceding evening , but had made no complaint of pain , either in his head or eye .
On the 31st , as soon as I entered his chamber , the mother , with much joy , informed -afflicted with the disorder later in life .
In consequence either of some remaining opacity in the crystalline capsule , which hinders the free admission of the rays of light , or of a greater tenuity in the remaining humours of the eye , children require , in general , a much -deeper convex glass to enable them to see minute objects ; and , at the same time , they are obliged to hold them much nearer their eyes than older persons .
me that her child could see .
About an hour before my visit , he was standing near the fire , with a handkerchief tied loosely over his eyes , when he told her that under the handkerchief , which had slipped upward , he could distinguish the table by the side of which she was sitting : it was about a yard and a half from him ; and he observed that it was covered with a green cloth , ( which was reallythe case .
) and that it was a little farther off than he was , able to reach .
No further questions were asked him at that time ; as his mother was much alarmed , lest the use thus made of his eye might have been premature and injurious .
Upon examination , I found that it was not more inflamed than the other eye ; and the opacity in the pupil did not appear to be much di. .
minished .
Desirous , however , to ascertain whether he was able to distinguish objects , I held a letter before him , at the distance of about twelve inches , when he told me , .
after a short hesitation , that it was a piece of paper ; that it .
was , square , which , he knew by its corners ; and that it was longer in one , direction than it was in the other .
On being desired to point to the corners he did it with great precision , and readily carried his finger in the line of its longest diameter .
I then showed himi a small oblong band-box covered with red leather , which he said was 'red and square , and pointed at once to its four corners .
After this , I placed before hirm an oval silver box , which he said had a shit ning appearance ; and , presently afterwards , that it was round , because it had not corners .
The observation , however which appeared to me most remarkable , was that which related to a white stone mug ; which he first called a white , bason , but , soon after , -recollecting himself , said it was a mug , because it had a handle .
These experiments did not give him any pain ; and they were made in the presence of his .
mother , and of Mr. WOODFORD , a clerk in his Majesty 's Treasury .
I held the obW o. , o , ... jects at different distances from his$ eye and inquired very particularly if hewas sensible of any difference in their situation ; which he always said le was , informing me , on every change , whether they were brought nearer to , or carried further from him .
I again inquired , both of his mother and himself , whether he had ever , before this time , distinguished by sight any sort of object ; and I was assured by both that he never had , on any occasion ; and that , when he wTished to discover colours , which he could only do when they were very strong- , he had always been obliged to hold the coloured object close to his eye , and a little on one side , to avoid the prjection of the nose .
No further experiments were made on that day .
On the ist of January , 1 found that his eye continued quite free both from pain and inflammation , and that he felt nouneasiness on the approach of light .
I showed him a table knife ; which at first he called a spoon , but soon rectifiedte mistake , giving it the right name , 1and distinguishing the blade from the handle , by pointing to each as-he was desired .
He afterwards called a yellow pocketbook by its name , taking notice of the silver lock in the cover .
I held my hand before hin ; ;Which he knew , bUt could not at first tell the number of my fingers , nor distinguish one of them from another .
I then held up his own hand , and desired him to remark the dierence between his thumb and fingers ; after which , he readily pointed out the distinctions in mine also .
Dark-coloured and smooth objects , were more agreeable to him than those WhiCh were bright and rough .
On the 3d of January he saw , from the drawing-room window , a dancing bear in the street , and distinguished a number of bOYs that were standing round him , noticing particularly bundle of clothes w}hich im , ~~~ n , icn ate one of them had on his head .
On the same evening , I placed him before a looking glass , and held up his hand : after a little time he smiled , and said he saw the shadow of his hand , as well as that of his head .
He could not then distinguish his features ; but , on the following day , his mother having again placed him before the glass , he pointed to his eyes , nose , and mouth , and seemed muchgratified with the sight .
Having thus stated the principal observations that were made by Master W. I shall now make a brief comparison between this statement , and that which is given in the XXXVth Volume of the Philosophkial Transactions , of Mr. CHESELDEN'S patient , who was supposed to be born blind , and obtained his sight when he was between thirteen and fourteen years old .
It should be observed , that though Master WA .
was six years younger than Mr CHESELDEN'S patient , he was remarkably intelligent , and gave the most direct and satisfactory answers to every question that was put to him .
Both of them , also , if not born blind , lost their sight so very early , that , as Mr. CHEr SELDEN expresses it , " they had not any recollection of having " ever seen .
My first remark is , that , contrary to the experience of Mr. CHESELDEN'S patient , who is stated " , to have been so far from " making any judgment of distance , that he thought all objects " touched his eyes , as what he felt did his skin , " Master W. distinguished , as soon as he was able to see , a table , a yard and a half from him ; and proved that he had some accuracy in his idea of distance , by saying , that it was a little further off than his hand could reach .
This observation , so contrary to theac count we have received of Mr. CHESELDEN'S patient , would have surprised me much more than it did , if I had not previously , in some similar instances , had reason to suspect that children , from whom cataracts had been extracted , had a notion of distance the first moment they were enabled to see .
In the instance particularly of a young gentleman from Ireland , fourteen years old , from each of whose eyes I extracted a -cataract , in the year 1794 , in the presence of Dr. HAMILTON , Physician to the London Hospital , and who , before the operation , assured me , as did his friends , that he never had seen the figure of any object , Dr. IAMILTON and myself were much astonished by the fcity.with ' which , on the first experiment , he took hold of my band-at dif. .
ferent distances , mentioning whether it was brought nearer to , or carried further from him , and conveying his hand to mine Min , a circular direction , that we might be the better satisfied o t-heaccuracy with which he did it .
In this case , however , and in others of a like nature , although the patients had certainly been blind from early infancy , I could not satisfy myself that they had not , before this period , enjoyed a sufficient degree of sight to impress the image of visible objects on their minds , andtogive them ideas which could not afterwards be entirelyoblitea rated .
In the instance of Master W. however , no suspicion of this kind could occur ; since , in addition to the declaration of himself and his mother , it was proved by the testimony of the surgeon who examined his eyes in the country , that the cataracts were fully formed before he was a year old .
And I ; beg leave to add further , that on making inquiries of two children , betweenseven and eight years of age , now under my care , both of whom have been blind from birth , and on whom no operation has yet been performed , I find that the knowledge they have of colours , limited as it is , is sufficient to enable them to tell whether .
coloured objects be brought nearer to , or carried further from them , for instance , whether they are at the distance of two inches or four inches from their eyes ; nor have either of them the slightest suspicion , as is related of Mr. CHESELDEN'S pan tient , that coloured objects , when .
held before them , touch their eyes .
But the judgment which Master W. formed of the different distances of objects , was not the only instance in which he dif-fered from Mr. CHESELDEN'S patient ; who , we are informed , -c did not know the figure of any thing , nor any one thing from sc another , however different in shape and magnitude ; " for Master W. knew and described a letter , not only as white , but also as square , because it had corners ; and an oval silver box , not only as shining , but also as round , because it had not corners : he likewise knew , and called by its name , a white stone mug , on the first day he obtained his sight , distinguishing it from a basGn , because it had a handle .
These experiments were made in the presence of two respectable persons , as well as myself ; and they were several times repeated , to convince us that we could not be mistaken in them .
I mention the circumstance , however , with much diffidence , being-aware that the observations not only differ from those that are related of Mr. CHESELDEN'S pan -tient , but appear , on the first statement , to oppose a principle in optics , which I believe is commonly and justly admitted , that the senses of sight and feeling have no other connection than that which is formed by experience ; and , therefore , that the ideas derived from feeling can have no power to direct the judgment , with respect either to the distance or form of visible objects .
It should be recollected , however , that persons , who have cataracts in their eyes , are not , in strictness of speech , blind , though they are deprived of all useful sight .
The instances I heave adduced prove , that the knowledge they have of colours is sufficient to give them some idea of distance , even in their darkest state .
When , therefore , their sight is cleared by the removal of the opaque crystalline , which intercepted the light , and the colour of objects is thereby made to appear stronger , will it be difficult or unphilosophical , to conceive that theirideas of distance will be strengthened and so far extended as to give , them a knowledge , even of the outline , and figure of those obo ects .
with the colour of which they were previously acquainted ? .
The case which I have here related appears to deserve notice , not only on account of the observations that were made byr the patient on recovering his sight , but also on account of the hi'nt which it affords to surgeons , relative , both to the mode in which the cataract may best be removed , when childrenare born with this disorder , and , the time when , it is most proper to perform , .
the operation .
, The Baron DE WENZEL , in his ingenious Treatise on the CAtaract , with great force of reasoning , deduced from the long and ' successful experience of his father andhimself , recommends , in all cases of this disorder , without making any exceptions the operation of extraction , in preference to that of depression ; .
and I believe it is now generally acknowledged by medical men , that , in the more common cases , his decision , as to the mode of operating is perfectly well founded .
TheBaron admits that the operation is not so certain a cure in children as it is in persons of a more advanced age ; both on accou-nt of their untract- , abieness , and because , in them , the opacity of the crystalline is not unfrequently accompanied with an opacity in the capsulethat contains it .
On these accounts , when children are borni vwitll this disorder , he advises to postpone the operation , until they are old enough to be made sensible of the loss they sustain by the want of sight , and have firmness ' of mind to submit patiently to the means that are requisite in order to obtain it .
Influenced by this opinion of the Baron , and believing the operation of extract tion to be so much superior to that of depression , that the latter ought not , on any occasion , to have the preference , I have given advice , in the cases of a considerable number of children who were born with this disorder , to postpone every attemptto relieve them , until they were thirteen or fourteen years old .
Prior to this time , it did not appear to me that children could be depended upon to submit , with due steadiness , to the repeated introduction of instruments , which is sometimes necessary inlextracting the ca .
taract ; and , even at this age , the eyes of some are so small , and in such a constant rolling motion , that it is almost impossible properly to accomplish the operation .
The Portuguese lad , whose case has been related , afforded an instance of this kind ; and I consider it as a fortunate circumstance that it came under my notice , since , in some degree , it may be said to have obliged me to examine , more attentively than I had before done , the advantages and disadvantages of the operation of depression ; which operation , being more easy to perform than that of extraction , has certainly this advantage in the cases of children , ( to which alone I here advert , ) that it may be performed with equal safety when they are only seven years of age , as it may at any subsequent period of their lives .
It is well known that the late Mr. POT , who published his remarks on the cataract in the year 1775 , was a strenuous advocate for this operation ; and , though he appears to me to have much under-rated the advantages of extraction , it must be alllowed that he makes many just and highly pertinent observations on the use of the couching needle , in those cases where the cataract is soft ) or fluid .
Mr. POT considered this as a very common state of the disorder ; and does not make any distinction between the cataract when it attacks grown persons , and when children are born with it .
In the former case , experience inclines me to:believe , that the cataract is very rarely fluid , or even soft ; whereas , in the latter , I have always found it , agreeable to the observation of the Baron DE WENZEL , in one or other of these states .
Although , therefore , in the case of grown persons , the operation of extraction appears to me to have very great advantages over that of depression , yet , in the case of children , I canreadily accede to almost the whole that Mr. POTS advances in fvour , of depression .
If the couching needle be passed in the way in which it is usually introduced to depress the cataract , and thereby a large aperture be made in the capsule of the crystalline , ( which operation -may be performed with perfect safety , and with very little pain to the patient , whilst the eye is fixed with a speci 1um .
ocu.lh ) the opaquecrystalline , being thus brought into contact with the aqueous and vitreous humours , will , in ashorter or longer space of time , according to its degree of softness , be absorbed- ; and , if there be -not an opacity in ' the capsule , as well asin the crystalline , the pupil will become clear , and the patient will acquire a very useful sight .
If , in addition to the opacity of the crystalline , the capsule be also opaque , and in consequence6f this , the operation do not prove successful , the eye will nevertheless be per .
fectly uninjured , and it will be as fit , at a subsequent period to have the capsule extracted , as it would have been if no attempt of theabove kind had been previously made .
From the foregoing observations , I flatter , myself I shall be justified in deducing the following inferences .
First , When children are born blind , in consequence of having cataracts in their eyes , they are -never so totally deprived of sight as not to be able to distinguish colours- ; and , though they cannot see the figure of an object , nor even its colour , unless it be placed within a very short distance , they nevertheless can te1l whether , when within this distance , it be brought nearer to , or carried farther from them.e Secondly , In consequence of this power , whilst in a state of Comparative blindness , children who have their cataracts removed , are enabled , immediately on the acquisition of sight , to form some judgment of the distance , and even of the outline , of those strongly defined objects with the colour of which they were previously acquainted .
Thirdly , When children have been born with -cataracts , the crystalline humour has generally if not always , been found either in a soft , or fluuid s7 " t-eIif therefore , it be not accompanied with .
an opacity , either in the anterior or posterior portion of the capsule , and this capsule be largely punctured with the couching needle , introduced in the way in which this instrument is usually employed to depress the cataract , there is reason to expect that the opaque matter will , sooner or later , be absorbed , the pupil become clear , and the sight be restored .
Fourthly , If , in addition to the opacity of the crystalline humour its capsule be also opaque , either in its anterior or posterior portion , or in both , ( which circumstance cannot be ascertained before the operation , ) and , in consequence of this , the operation above mentioned should not prove successful , it will not preclude the performance of extraction afterwards , if this be thought adviseable .
Fifthly , The operation above mentioned being much more easy to perform than that of extraction , and itbeing possible to fix the eye with perfect safety during its performance , by means of a speculum oculi , it may be undertaken at a much earlier age than the latter operation ; and a chance may of course be given to the patient , of -receiving instruction , without that loss of time which has usually been thought unavoidable , when children are born with this disorder .
* unable to distinguish their figure .
At the end of a month , finding no further improved .
meant in her vision , it appeared to me most probable that the remaining opacity was situated in the capsules .
I therefore determined to extract either a part or the whole of each of them .
The incisions of the cornea were made in the usual manner ; after which , I punctured the anterior parts of both the capsules with the sharp end of a gold curette .
The punctures became immediately transparent , without affording an issue to the liquor Meibomii , or any other humour .
From hence it seems evident , that nothing was cone tained within the capsules , or , in other words , that the crystalline humours were absorbed a and it appears to me highly probable , that their absorption had been occasioned by the previous operation of puncturing their capsules with the couching needle .
I dilated the new punctures with the end of the curette ; and afterwards , being still afraid that the apertures in the capsules might not be large enough to admit a sufficient number of the rays of light , I removed a portion of each of them with a small forceps .
This was accomplished in the left eye , without occasioning the discharge of any part of the vitreous humour ; and , in the right , the quantity of this humour that came away was very small .
In the course of a week , the inflammation that followed the operation was nearly removed ; a large portion of both pupils was quite clear ; and the young lady distinguished objects with quickness and precision .

