XVIII .
Observations and Experiments upon Dr. James 's Powder ; with a Method of preparing , in the humid Way , a similar SWub stance .
By Richard Chenevix , Esq. F. R. M. fR .
IAl Read June 4 , 1801o AFTER the observations and experiments inade by Dr. PEARSON , to investigate the nature of Dr. JAMES'S Powder , and presented by him to this Society , very little remained to be effected or desired towards a further knowledge of the sulject .
But those very experiments served to suggest , that the mode of preparation was far from being the best that the present improved state of chemical knowledge might afford ; and that , in all probability , a less defective composition might result from a process more conformable to some improvements , which of late have been advantageously applied to pharmaceutic chemistry .
It may be laid down as a general principle , that , in delicate experiments , whether analytical or synthetical , fire ( that potent and once believed to be universal agent ) is too precarious in its means , and too uncertain in its application , to be employed with full and constant success .
And , if it is still recurred to , the advantage of promptness , and a remnant of ancient custom , are the principal reasons .
But , where other methods can be devised to effect the same combinations , ( and the humid way offers many , ) every person conversant in chemical knowledge will allow the benefit of adopting them .
The recent improvement in I the mode of preparing calomel , is a striking example of such salutary corrections being successfully introduced .
A few observations upon the formula according to which Dr. JAMES'S Powder , or the Pulvis Antimonialis , is prepared , and upon some properties of antimony , will place this assertion in a more prominent point of view .
In order to prepare this powder , we are told to take equal weights of bone or hartshorn shavings and crude antimony , and calcine them together , at a high temperature : in other words , to take phosphate of lime , which already contains a great excess of lime , and add to it an oxide of antimony .
In this process , it has been supposed , that the phosphoric acid of the bone or hartshorn will saturate , not only the lime with which it was originally combined , but , in addition to it , a new portion of metallic oxide , and a new portion of lime .
For , what little sulb phuric acid might , during the process , have been formed by the combustion of the sulphur of the crude antimony , is dissipated , at a much lower temperature than that to which the powder is exposed .
Every oxide of antimony with which we are acquainted , is volatile at a high degree of heat : it would therefore be hazardous to assert , that it is possible to preserve always the same proportion of antimony , whatever care may be employed in directing the operation ; and , a dissimilarity in the chemical result , must necessarily be attended with uncertainty in the medical application .
To this property may be added another , no less conducive to error .
That portion of oxide of antimony which is not volatilized , becomes , in a great measure , insoluble in all the acids .
What the effect of the gastric juice may be , upon a substance which resists the action even of nitro-muriatic acid , it is not my purpose to determine .
It is sufficient for me to say , that , as the quantity of insoluble matter , in a given quantity of Dr. JAMES'S Powder , prepared at different times , may vary , the effect of any dose also may differ , according to the proportions of soluble and insoluble matter .
I look upon it as a fortunate circumstance , that those experiments and observations which I mentioned in the beginning of this Paper , existed as a standard to which I might refer my own attempts , and by which I might estimate their validity .
Dr. PEARSON has proved , ( as by.my own experiments I have found , ) that in Dr. JAMES'S Powder about 28 per cent. resisted the action of every acid .
In examining some of the Pulvis Antimonialis of the London Pharmacopeia , I found the average quantity of insoluble matter to be about 44 per cent This proportion , however , was liable to considerable variation.* The powder here treated of is denominated , by Dr. PEARSON , a triple salt , or a real ternary combination of a double basis , ( lime and antimony , ) with phosphoric acid .
What I have men-tioned , with regard to the quantity of acid contained in bone or hartshorn , as being too small to saturate a new portion of these bases , may throw some doubts upon the possibility of any such combination in the present case .
But I have made some more direct experiments , which tend to prove , that no such combination does exist .
oI find , from the information of several medical gentlemen , that the Pulvis Antimoxialis is generally considered as stronger than Dr. JAME S'S Powder .
This seems rather extraordinary , when we consider that the quantity of insoluble matter is greater in the former than in the latter ; and would almost lead us to suspect it to be the active part of the medicine .
I took some white oxide of antimony , ( formerly called Algae roth Powder , ) precipitated by water from muriate of antimony , and heated it for a long time with phosphoric acid .
I decanted the liqUor , and washed the powder that remained .
No antimony could be found in the liquor ; nor could any traces of phosphoric acid be detected in the residuary oxide of antimony .
I then took a solution of muriate of antimony , and divided it into two equal parts : into one , I poured distilled water ; and , into the other , a solution of phosphate of soda .
In each liquor , a copious precipitate was formed ; ' which precipitates , after being well washed , were dried .
The weight of both was the same ; whereas , it is evident that , had any phosphoric acid been combined with the oxide , there would have been an augmentation of weight , in that which was precipitated by the solution of phosphate of soda .
This precipitate likewise , upon examination , gave no traces of phosphoric acid .
From these experiments it appears , that there exists no combination , which can be denominated a phosphate of antimony .
To attempt an explanation of the real nature of the powder here spoken of , I had recourse to some experiments of Mons. BERTHOLLET .
By detonating sulphuret of antimony and nitrate of potash , in a crucible , he obtained a mass , which he reduced to powder , and washed .
The liquor gave , upon evaporation , a crystallized salt , which M. BERTHOLLET terms an antimoniate of potash .
I never could succeed in any attempt to form a similar combination between the above white oxide of antimony and potash , -owing , I believe , to the small quantity of oxygen contained therein , compared with that which is combined with the .
oxide obtained by detonation .
I cannot therefore say , that the powder in question is , in any degree , what M. BERTLIOLLET would call an antimoniate " of lime .
7 But , be the state , whether of mixture or of combination , what it may , my purpose is to endeavour to produce a substance , which , from its more certain mode of preparation , may be more equal and constant in its effects .
Dissolve , together or separately , in the least possible portion of muriatic acid , equal parts of the forementioned white oxide of antimony and of phosphate of lime .
X Pour this solution gradually into distilled water , previously alkalizated by a sufficient quantity of ammonia .
A white and abundant precipitate will take place , which , well washed and dried , is the substitute I propose for Dr. JAMESS Powder .
The theory of this precipitation is -so clear and simple , that it does not require any comment , It may be useful , however , to those who wish to make this preparation , to remark , that it is absolutely necessary that the solution of phosphate of lime and of oxide of antimony , in muriatic acid , should , after being well mixed , be poured into the alkaline liquor , in order to obtain a precipitate homogeneous throughout the operation .
Forshould the alkaline liquor be poured into the acid * In order to procure the phosphate of lime , I dissolved in muriatic acid , a quantity of calcined bone , and precipitated by ammonia , in its state of greatest causticity .
By this means , the excess of muriatic acid , which held in solution the phosphate of lime , is saturated , and the phosphate is precipitated ; but no muriate of lime is decomposed , if the ammonia is quite free from carbonic acid .
This is the most direct method of obtaining phosphate of lime pure .
This salt is not decomposed , as some have asserted , by muriatic acid , but merely dissolved by it .
I have been induced to state fully these particulars , because , from the beneficial effects of this salt in the treatment of rachitis , as proposed by M. BoNHOMME , ( Annals de Chimie , Vol. XVIII .
p. I I3 , ) it may be ' .
come of general use .
The oxide of antimony , I obtained by precipitating , by water , the common butter of antimony of the shoys .
3C 2 , solution , the water of the , former would act upon the entire mass of oxide of antimony , while the alkali would precipitate the phosphate of lime only as it saturated the acid which held that salt in solution : thus , the precipitate would contain more antismony in the beginning ; and , towards the end , the phosphate of lime would be predominant , For the same reason too , a pure alkali is preferable to its carbonate ; for the carbonic acid disengaged , would retain in solution a portion of phosphate of lime .
Whether this composition be a chemical combination or a mixture , I will not take upon me to determine ; but , for the reasons above mentioned , in speaking of Dr. JAMES'S Pawder , I believe it to be merely a very intimate mixture .
At all events , it must be more homogeneous thank any that can be prepared in the dry way .
It is entirely soluble in every acid -that can dissolve either phosphate of lime or oxide of antimony separately ; and , to have it constantly and uniformly the same , no further address in preparing it is required , than to avoid the errors .
I have mentionedc As , after some medical trials of the powder , it was suggested to , me , that it might be advantageous to render it somewhat stronger , I prepared another portion , by taking two parts of oxide of antimony and but one of phosphate of lime , and precipitating as above described .
The medicinal power was then considerably increased. .
Dr. JAMES'S Powder is a medicine which has been so long in use , and is so deservedly ranked among the most valuable wepossess , that every attempt to render the process for preparing it more simple and more certain , must be allowed to be of some importance .
But , whatever reason there was to think , by argUing , upon its chyniucal properties , that I had really succeeded in improving its medicinal virtues , it still remained to be proved ' by actual experiment , that the hoped-for success was not merely conjectural .
To ascertain this , I gave some of my powder to Dr. CRICHTON , Dr. BABINGTON , and Mr. ABERNETHY ; gentlemen whose extensive practice and acknowledged skill sufficiently enabled them to judge of its medical properties .
They all concur in opinion , that , in its general effects , it agrees with Dr. JAMES'S Powder and the Pulvis Antimonialis ; but that it is more mild , and consequently may be given in largerquantities , seldom producing nausea or vomiting in doses of less than eight or ten grains .

