XIII .
Observations tending to investigate the Nature of the Sun , in order togefind the Causes or Symptoms of its variable Emission of Light and Heat ; , with Remarks on the Use that may pose sibly be drawn from Solar Observations .
By William Herschel , L L.D. F.R.S. Read April i6 , i8ol .
ON a former occasion I have shxewn , that we have great reason to look upon the sun as a most magnificent habitable globe ; and , from the observations which will be related in this Paper , it will now be seen , that all the arguments we have used before are not only confirmed , but that we are encouraged to go a considerable step farther , in the investigAtion of the physical and planetary construction of the sun .
The influence of this eninent body , on the globe we inhabit , is so great , and so widely diffused , that it becomes almost a duty for us to study the open rations which are carried on upon the solar surface .
Since light and heat are so essential to our well-being , it must certainly be right for us to look into the source from whence they are derived , in order to see whether some material advantage may not be drawn from a thorough acquaintance with the causes from which they originate .
A similar motive engaged the Egyptians formerly to study and watch the motions of the Nile ; and to construct instrunents for measuring its rise with accuracy .
They knew very well , that it was not in their power to add a single inch to the flowing waters of that wonderful river ; and so , in the case of the sun 's influence , we are likewise fully aware , that we shall never be able to occasion the least alteration in the operations which are carried on in the solar atmosphere .
But , if the Egyptians could avail themselves of the indications of a good Nilometer , what should hinder us from drawing as profitable consequences from solar observations ?
We are not only in possession of photometers and thermometers , by which we can measure from time to time the light and heat actually received from the sun , but have more especially telescopes , that may lead us to a discovery of the causes which dispose the sun to emit more or less copiously the rays which occasion either of them .
And , if we should even fail in this respect , we may at least succeed in becoming acquainted with certain symptoms or indications , from which some judgment might be formed of the temperature of the seasons we are likely to have .
Perhaps our confidence in solar observations made with this view , might not exceed that which we now place on the indications of a good barometer , with regard to rain or fair weather ; but , even then , a probability of a hot summer , or its contrary , would always be of greater consequence than the expectation of a few fair or rainy days .
It will be easily perceived , that in order to obtain such an intimate knowledge of the sun as that which is required for the purpose here pointed out , a true information must be first procured of all the phenomena that usually appear on its surface .
I have therefore attended to many circumstances , that have either not been noticed at all before , or have not been examined with any particular view of information .
The improvement also in the solar apparatus of my ten-feet telescope , by which I can take away as much light and heat as required , has given me additional facility of making a great number of particular observations ; and , as they have been all directed to an irnvestigation of certain points , I shall give them here , in the order which the arrangement of my subject will require .
It will be necessary , before I can enter into a detail of the observations , to give notice that , from an improved knowledge of the physical construction of the sun , I have found it convenient to lay aside the old names of spots , nuclei , penumbrw , facula , and luculi , which can only be looked upon as figurative expressions that may lead to error .
Nor were these few terms sufficient to describe the more minute appearances on the sun , which I have to point out .
The expressions I have used are openings , shallows , ridges , nodules , corrugations , indentations , and pores .
It will not be amiss to give a short explanation of these terms .
Openings are those places where , by the accidental removal of the luminous clouds of the sun , its own solid body may be seen ; and this not being lucid , the openings through which we see it may , by a common telescope , be mistaken for mere black spots , or their nuclei .
Shallows are extensive and level depressions of the luminous solar clouds , generally surrounding the openings to a considerable distance .
As they are less luminous than the rest of the sun , they seem to have some distant , though very imperfect , resemblance to penumbrae which might occasion their having been called so formerly .
Ridges are bright elevations of luminous matter , extended in rows of an irregular arrangement .
Nodules are also bright elevations of luminous matter , but confined to a small space .
These nodules , and ridges , on account of their being brighter than the general surface of the sun , and also differing a little from it in colour , have been called faculw , and luculi .
Corrugations , I call that very particular and remarkable unevenness , ruggedness , or asperity , which is peculiar to the luminous solar clouds , and extends all over the surface of the globe of the sun .
As the depressed parts of the corrugations are less luminous than the elevated ones , the disk of the sun has an appearance which may be called mottled .
Indentations are the depressed or low parts of the corrugations ; they also extend over thewhole surface of the luminous solar clouds .
Pores are very small holes or openings , about the middle of the indentations .
Any other terms I may hereafter use , will be sufficiently explained by the observations in which they occur .
I shall now enter into an examination of all the phenomena that may be observed in viewing the sun through a good telescope , beginning with those " that are most common ; a critical investigation of which will lead us gradually to such as are more intricate .
It will be seen that I have brought my observations under a number of short heads , or propositions , such as my subject requires .
The advantage of this method is , that the tendency of 'every observation will be immediately understood , while it is read ; whereas , had I arranged these observations in the order in which they were made , the mixture of the various points to be ascertained by them must have brought on a considerable obscurity ; and , in drawing conclusions from them afterwards , a repetition of the observations which were to support them would have been unavoidable .
I must take notice of what will perhaps be censured in many of the observations ; they may be said to be accompanied with surmises , suppositions , or hypotheses which should have been kept separate .
In defence of this seeming impropriety , I must say , that the observations are of such a nature , that I found it impossible , at the very time of seeinb the new objects that presented themselves to my view , to refrain from ideas that would obtrude themselves ' .
It may even be said , that since observations are made with no other view than to draw such conclusions from them as may instruct us in the nature of the things we see , there cannot be a more proper time for entertaining surmises than when the object itself is in view. .
Now , since the suggestions that have been inserted were always such as arose at the moment of the observations , they are so bended with them , that they would lose much of their value as arguments , if they were given separately .
In order not to lengthen this Paper unnecessarily , I have given but a few observations under each head ; especially with those propositions which may be looked upon as already sufficiently established by the observations of other astronomers .
The whole tenor of the observations I have given , though divided under such numerous heads , is indeed such as must produce a mutual support ; so that , frequently , one or two particular observations were thought sufficient to establish my point , when ; I might have added many more , from my journals , in support of it .
OF OPENINGS .
Openhigs are Places where the luminous Cloutds of the San are removed .
That those appearances which have been called spots in the sun , are real openings in the luminous clouds of the solar atmosphere , may be concluded from the following observations , where the sides or thicknesses of the borders which limit the openings are distinctly described .
Jan. 4 , i8oi .
There isa large opening much past the centre of the sun , with a shallow about it .
* On the preceding side , I see the thickness of the shallow , from its surface downwards .
On the following side , I also see the edge of the shallow near the opening ; but it is sharp , and its thickness cannot be seen .
I see also the side of the elevation surrounding the shallow , going curvedly down to the surface of the shallow , on its prep ceding side .
A large collection of openings , of very different sizes , are near the following limb .
They all manifest the same kind of optical appearance , but on the side which is contrary to that in the opening before mentioned ; for here the thicknesses or depths of the shallows , and of the slopes going down from the upper surface to the shallows , are only visible on the following side , but not on the preceding one.t See Plate XVII1 .
Fig. i and 2 .
t For a geometrical proof of the depression of the nucleus of a spot , as an opening was formerly called , see a most valuable paper of Observations on the Solar Spots , by the late ALEX AN DE R WI LSON , M. D. Professor of Practical Astronomy in the University of Glasgow .
Phil. Trans. Vol. LXIV .
Part I. Large Openings have generally Shallows about them .
Jan. 24 , i8oi .
The two largest openings of January 19 , are completely surrounded by shallows .
Many Openings are without Shallows .
Jan. 22 , 18oo .
There are two openings which have not the least shallow about them .
The corrugations go equally between and around them .
Feb. 7 , 1800 .
There are two considerable openings not far from each other : they have no shallows about them .
Small Openings are generally without Shallows .
Dec. 2 , 18oo .
There are a great number of large and small openings : the large ones have shallows about them ; the small ones are mostly without .
Openings have generally Ridges and .
Nodules about them .
Dec. 20O , 1794 .
There are two openings near the preceding margin of the sun ; they have elevated extensive luminous ridges about them .
Dec. 23 , 1 799 .
A pretty considerable opening , on the following side of the disk , is surrounded by many ridges .
Feb. 7 , X8oo .
Following two considerable openings , which are not far from each other , are several irregularly dispersed ridges , more bright than the rest of the sun .
Jan , 0 , i 8o 1 .
Many clustering openings are lately come into the disk ; a crowd of ridges and nodules surround , and are interspersed among them .
Openings have a Tendency to run into each other .
Dec. 9,5 , 1799 .
The large opening of December 23 , and the small one near it , are now nearly run into each other .
Jan. 4 Soi .
The two largest openings of Jan. 2 , are nearly .
4 , .
joined Into one .
Jan. 6 , i Sol .
The largest of the preceding openings , of a set observed Jan. 4 , has drawn together all the small ones , and is increased in dimensions .
Jan. 29 , 180o .
2h Wo ' .
A longish opening , observed at 12h , is increased by the addition of two projections .
With more attention , however , I perceive that these projections are united to each other , but separated from the longish opening , by a narrow luminous bridge , or compressed row of luminous clouds .
Jan. 30 , 180i .
The two united projections of yesterday are now joined to the longish opening .
New Openings break out near other Openings .
Dec. 23 , 1799 .
There is a small opening near the large one observed yesterday , which then was not visible .
Jan. 2-1 , i Soo .
The preceding of two openings observed before , has now two other small ones near it .
Probable Cause of Openings .
Jan. i8 , 18oi .
Between two clusters of openings , near each other , there are some , as I suspect , incipient openings : they resemble coarse pores of indentations .
Jan , 19 , 18ot .
The incipient openings , between the clusters of yesterday 's observation , are completely turned into considerable openings .
It seems as if an elastic , but not luminous gas , had come up through the pores or incipient openings , and spread itself on the luminous clouds , forcing them out of the way , and widening its passage .
Feb. i8 , i8oi , 7'.4 .
The south preceding one of three large connected openings , * has a narrow branch coming from its shallow .
Si 55 .
The opening is broken out at three places ; t and the shallow has three projections just opposite .
It is plain that the breakings~-out and the projections must have the same cause ; which probably acts first at the opening , and widens it , then goes forward , and occasions the corresponding projections in the shallows .
The shallow is very large on that side where the breakingsout are situated ; and , on the contrary , very narrow on the opposite , or , as it may be called , the quiescent side , 10i 12 ' .
The broadest of the little sprouting shallows is oppoO site the broadest of the breakings-out , or encroachments of the opening on the general shallow , Direction and Operation of the disturbing Cause .
Jan. 24 , i8oi .
A small oblong opening , near a preceding large one , has on its north side a very long shallow , This made me surmise , that the elastic fluid coming out of it might have a strong direction from below , towards that side .
Examining therefore this opening all round , I found that the shallow ex. .
tended only to one side , leaving the other parts full of luminous matter close to the margin of the opening .
And , on examining the large opening , I found that the shallow about it was also arger , in the same direction as the shallow about the small one Eight other small openings , forming together a cluster with the former two , have every one also their incipient shallows on the same side ; that is , towards the north-following ; and none at all on the other parts of their margins .
3h 1IJ .
The shallow about the small opening has changed its direction .
Itwas like Fig. A , and is nowas inFig.6 .
( PlateXVIII .
) In the farthest end of it , I expect an opening to be coming on .
4h 30 ' .
There is already the appearance of an incipient opening.* Jan. 6 , 80oi .
The shallows about the large opening and the small one near it , are much altered in situation and dimensions .
All the smaller openings near them have undergone great changes ; some being gone , and new ones come in different places , while others have altered their appearance .
The bias in the direction of the shallows is also considerably changed .
Jan. So , 18oi .
9h 2o0 .
There is a cluster of small openings , which I expect to see united into one , by the breaking downy driving away , or dissolution , of the intermediate communications of luminous clouds .
From having seen it yesterday , I know the largest of the openings to be a generating one .
It has an increasing shallow ; and the next largest opening of the cluster has an incipient one .
IOh 40 ' .
The incipient shallow is now pretty large , l1h 2 ' .
There is now also an incipient shallow about the most south of the small openings .
l Ah 6 ' .
The shallow of the largest opening is increased .
Maxima of Openings .
Janm 29 , igo i , ll of .
The shallow of the largest of many openings that are visible , is most extended towards the northfollowing side.* It affects a circular form more than the open- .
ing , but is not concentric with it .
It has a small lip on the north , which I suppose denotes the direction of the gas coming out of the opening .
A similar lip is visible in the opening itself , as if the gas , in coming out , pressed against the luminous clouds which limit the opening , and belong to the flat .
2h lo ' The lip or projection of the shallow about the opens ing is filled up at the sides ; they being now as broad as the lip 's projection .
The filling up is marked with points in the figure .
Jan. 30 , Soi .
71lhe large opening observed yesterday is no longer increased ; but seems to be nearly at its maximum .
Feb. 4 , 18oi , P io ' The shallow of the large opening is 'much more round than the opening , though not concentric with it , Hence , its figure being no longer disturbed , I guess that the opening is near its maximum .
There i 's some D~jerence in the Colour of Openings .
March i , 80oo .
There are two large openings , which seem to be partially covered , or rather to have a thin , semitransparent , luminous veil of clouds still hovering over them ; this gives them a fainter black colour than openings generally have .
Openings divide when they are decaying .
Dec. 26 , 1799 .
An opening observed the 2 , Sth is reduced ; and is divided in the middle by a lucid line.t Dec. 27 , 1799 .
The luminous bridge or passage across the opening is pretty broad , and has a branch about the middles This branch of light has the appearance of a luminous cloud , See Plate XVI11 .
Fig. 8 .
t See Fig. 9g irregularly breaking out from the passage , towards the southernhalf of the opening .
Dec. 28 , 1799 .
The opening is so completely vanished , that I cannot find the least mark of its former existence .
From the appearance of the branch yesterday , in the luminous division resembling a bridge thrown over a cave , I surmise that this branch , as well as the sides of what I call the bridge , have extended themselves , and as it were drawn a lucid curtain over the opaque surface of the sun .
Decaying Openings sometimes increase again .
Feb. 8 , 18o0 .
The great opening , which has been gradually diminishing since Feb. 4 is now enlarged again .
W~hen Openings are divided , they grow less , and vanish .
Dec. 29 , 799 .
The south preceding of two openings observed yesterday is divided into three small ones .
Dec. At , 1799 , The divided opening of the 29th exists no longer .
Feb. 9 , 8ioo .
Of two considerable openings observed Feb. 7 , the preceding one is divided into several smaller parts .
Feb. to , 800o .
The divided opening observed yesterday is in a vanishing state .
Feb. i i , i8oo .
The openings are all covered in , and no trace of them can be found .
Decayed Openings sometimes become large Indentations .
Feb. a. 18co .
The preceding of two openings observed the 7th of February is now about half filled up ; and that half contains two indentations , with black pores , or rather remaining small openings .
They are nearly of the size of the general corrugations of the solar surface at present .
Decaying Openings turn sometimes into Pores .
Feb. io , i8oo .
1h ol .
Between the half of the opening and that part which was nearly covered in yesterday , is a set of indentations , with pores rather larger than they are in general .
When Openings are vanished , they leave Disturbance behind .
Dec. 28 , 1799 .
12h 1o ' .
There is a place among the corrugations , where they are coarser now than they were an hour ago .
Ih " .
Two considerable openings are broken out , in the place where the corrugations were coarse .
They are both so completely dark , and free from thin luminous clouds , that it appears very plainly they were only hidden behind the slight covering of luminous obstructions ; one of them is about the place where the opening of yesterday was situated .
Jan. 24 -i8oo .
There is a pretty large place , which contained the openings observed the 22d , the luminous clouds of which are in a state of disturbance : it includes five or six places , where the pores of indentations assume the shapes of incipient openings , and after some time lose them again , more or less .
Feb. ii , 18oo .
There is a place which I suppose to be that where the now vanished openings were yesterday : it seems to be rather disturbed in the arrangement of its corrugations .
One of the indentations is probably an evanescent opening , as it still shows a considerable pore .
Apparent View into the Openigs , under luminous Bridges ana Shallows .
Dec. 27 , 1799 .
A luminous passage across a large opening has all the appearance of a bridge going over a hollow space ; and I have no doubt but that it is at a considerable distance from the opaque surface of the sun .
Jan. 4 , 18oi .
A ridge which separates two openings much past the centre , shows its thickness on the following side : it has a shallow , the preceding side of which I see going down to the opening ; and it appears to me , that there is a considerable distance between the lowest part of that shallow and the dark surface of the sun under it .
Nor can I help believing that I see aslant under it , towards the preceding side ; though I find it difficult to account for such vision , on the principles of solar perspective .
Jan. 6 , 18oi .
The same opening is now further advanced towards the limb of the sun .
It appears again to me , that on the preceding side I see far under the shallow .
I suspect the part towards P to be of a deeper dark colour than that towards F ; * but the difference , if there be any , is not marked enough to be decisive .
Depth of the Openings , indicated by their Darkness .
Jan. 15 , doi .
11"h ic ' .
One of the openings , which is near the preceding limb of the suit , is remarkably black .
The tint of openings may perhaps assist us to infer their depth ; which must be greater in a direction towards us , when the opening is near the circumference , than when it is near the centre , if the w.See Plate XVIII .
Fig. x and z. distance from the shallows to the opaque surface should be considerable .
I have compared the darkness of two openings near the centre , with the appearance of that near the preceding limb .
It is decidedly in favour of the blackness of ' the latter : this is however larger than the former two ; which may occasion deceptions .
The opening near the limb is certainly darker than the two which are near the centre .
Feb A , i oi An opening very near the preceding margin is of a deep black colour ; certainly more so than another which is not far off , but is more towards the centre of the sun .
Feb. 8 , i8oi .
The large opening near the margin , is darker than two other openings which are about the centre of the solar disk : the difference , however , is hardly sufficient to be decisive .
The two openings are also much smaller ; which may occasion a deception .
Distance between the Shallows and solar Surface , indicated by the free Motion of low Clouds .
Jan. 9S , i80o .
9h 2z ' .
A large opening , which I have been observing since the i9th , is now much advanced towards the limb.* I can see into it ; and , on the preceding side , as it appears to me , a good way under the lowest regions of the clouds of which the shallow consists .
The upper margin of the shale low is very sharply determined ; but the clouds of the lower part of it ; on the contrary , are more dispersed ; some of them hanging a good way down , towards the surface of the sun 's body.+ , oh go/ The preceding side of the shallow of the large ^ See Plate XIX .
Fig. io..t See Fig. i x. opening , is now more abruptly terminated at the bottom of its thickness ; the hanging or projecting clouds being removed towards the following side.d OF SHALLOWS .
Shallows are depressed below the general Surface of the Sun ; and are Places where the luminous solar Clouds of the upper Regions are removed .
That those appearances which have been called penumbra are real depressions , or shallows , may already be concluded , from what has been related with regard to the slopes from the upper surface of the sun , down to the top of these shallows ; and will follow still more evidently , from an observation of one of them on the very limb of the sun .
Dec. 3 , i8oo .
There is a considerable opening just come into the disk , which is followed by another that is actually in the limb of the sun .
The uniformity of the circular termination of the limb suffers a small deviation ; it being somewhat depressed , owing to the shallow Baout the opening .
I do not yet perceive the opening itself with certainty ; but suppose it will appear to be one , when it advances more into the disk .
The Thickness of the Shallows is visible .
Jan. 6 , i8oi .
There is a large opening much advanced be. .
yond the centre , with a shallow round it .
On the preceding side of the shallow , its descent down towards the opening is visible ; but , on the following side , I see abruptly into the opening .
n See Plate XIX .
Fig. Xz .
Sometiines there are Sballows without Openings in them Feb. 7 , 18oi .
There is a pretty large shallow enclosed by the ridges which follow some preceding openings .
Feb. 12 , i8oo .
A place where yesterday I saw five or more nodules , at present contains low ridges enclosing some shallows .
Incipient Shallows come from the Openings , or branch out from Sballows already formed , and go forwards .
Jan. 18 , 18oi .
In a cluster of openings , there is an incipient shallow , coming from one of them .
Jan. 19 , 18oi .
The incipient shallow is increased , and has now spread all round the opening .
Jan. 24 , 1801 .
A large opening sends from its shallow already formed , a narrow projection , towards the end of a neighbouring shallow belonging to a smaller opening , as if they were going to meet .
Probable Cause of Shallows .
-Jan .
25 180o , gh 20 ' .
Two branrches A f , * of a shallow coming from an opening C , are going towards the south .
It seems as if they were destined to meet the incipient shallow of a south-following opening D. 9h 50 ' .
The shallow B is now very nearly united to the narrow part of the shallow surrounding the opening D. The shallow A seems to advance , in a direction towards the farthest south .
following opening E. 1oh 20 ' .
The shallow B is now completely run into the shalh low about D ; ?
and the shallow A is grown broader towards F. iAh 3o ' .
The shallow B is so completely joined to the shallow about D , that it appears as if it had not come from the opening C. The shallow A now ends in a sharp point.* 12h sot .
The shape of the shallow A is again much changed ; it is no longer pointed , but very broad at the endd t and there is a new branch breaking out at G. These changes seem all to denote , that the shallows are occasioned by something coming out of the openings , which , by its propelling motion , drives away the luminous clouds from the place where it meets with the least resistance ; or which , by its nature , dissolves them as it comes up to them .
If it be an elastic gas , its levity must be such as to make it ascend through the inferior region of the solar clouds , and diffuse itself among the superior lumrninous matter .
P 10 ' .
The new branch G increases ; and the openings C , D , El are enlarged .
A new branch is also breaking out from the shalh low about E. It is marked H in Fig. t4 , and denoted with points .
These changes seem to prove , that the same gas which diffuses itself over the shallows has forced open the passages at first , and is now widening them. .
Hence , the 'increase of the openings is an additional circumstance which points out the cause of the shallows .
oh got .
From the shallow of a very large preceding opening , which is in an increasing state , are lately projected three small branches a , b , c.t 2h 3 ' .
The vacancies between the three small projecting shallows are now filled up by the same cause that occasioned them , so as to have given them the shape of an uniform but broader shallow , on the side where the branches come out , as denoted by points .
Shallows have no Corrugations , but are tufted .
Feb. 4 , iBot .
The great shallow about a large opening has no corrugations .
Feb. t8 , i8oi , The lower clouds of the shallow of a large opening , though not corrugated , are not smooth , but tufted .
They are so closely connected in their tufts , that it makes them appear as if , in every vacancy , -there were clouds under clouds , that prevent : our looking far into them .
Decay of Shallows .
Jan. 3o , i8oi .
The borders of the shallow belonging to the large opening observed Jan 29 , seem to be remarkably high ; so that , if the opening were near the limb , they would probably appear like ridges .
The shallow has again a lip , nearly in the place where there was one yesterday .
But it seems as if the lip , which is visible now , had a cause contrary to what produced it yesterday .
For the luminous clouds all round the shallow seem no longer to be kept off by an issuing elastic fluid , but are probably now breaking in upon the shallow , except in the place of the lip , where some energy , like that exerted yesterday , may still remain in action ; in that case , the shallow , as well as the opening , is past its maximum .
OF RIDGES .
Ridges are Elevations above the general Surface of the luminous Clouds of the Sun .
Dec. 27 , 1799 .
On the south-following side of the sun 's disk , close to the margin , are some bright ridges .
They are all in a 00 !
2 direction parallel , or nearly parallel , to the margin ; and have the appearance of elevations .
Jan. 29 , 1 8ol .
Two sets of openings , near the north-following limb , have wide-spreading ridges about them : four other sets , being farther advanced into the disk , do not show any .
This denotes them to be thin elevations , which can only be seen near the circumference , by a side view .
Feb. 8 , 18ol .
Many ridges and nodules are now to be seen about the large opening , which yesterday had none .
I suppose they are become visible by its advancement towards the margin , to which it draws near .
Length of a Ridge .
Dec. 27 , 1799 .
I measured one of the longest ridges in view , It extended over an angular space of 2 ' , +451,9 , which is nearly 75ooo mlfes .
Ridges generally accompany Openings .
Feb. 5 , i8oi .
Three sets of openings near the preceding limb , and two near the following one , are surrounded by luminous ridges .
Ridges are also often in Places where there are no Openings .
Dec. 22 , 1799 .
On the following side of the sun are luminous ridges ; but not within SO Or 6o degrees of an opening .
Jan. 4 , i8oi .
Towards the north , near the limb , is a collection of ridges without openings .
Feb 5 .
Two of the sets of openings of yesterday are gone but have left extensive ridges behind .
Ridges disperse very soon .
Dec. 28 , 1799 .
The appearance of the ridges I saw yester .
day is much changed : they are less luminous and extensive than ' they were .
The range is much broken ; and they appear more in detached irregular elevations .
Dec. 29 , 1799 .
The ridges are so much reduced to the resemblance of the ri.t of the quin .
thnt hod I nnt knowIli where to look for them , I should hardly have been able to trace any vestige of them .
Feb. 9 , iSoo .
The ridges Which followed some openings Feb. 7 , exist no longer .
Dffferent Causes of Ridges hinted at .
Jan. 4 , i Soi .
A crowd of ridges and nodules ' surround , and are interspersed among , a cluster of openings .
A ridge which crosses one of the openings like a bar or bridge , is sharp on the following side , but shows thickness on the preceding .
It seems probable , that the openings permit a transparent elastic fluid to come out , which disturbs the luminous matter on the top , so as to occasion ridges and nodules .
There are not less than 17 openings in the cluster .
Jan. 6 , 186i .
Following a set of openings lately come into the disk , are many luminous and broad , that is to say , high ridges , without any openings among them ; so that the cause which produces them acts probably below the shining matter .
Their own levity also may occasion them to go into the higher regions .
Jan. 3o , i8ci .
Near the following margin is an extended plane , full of bright ridges and nodules , with a great number of openings lately broken out , and still breaking out among them .
This leads us to suppose that some elastic gas , acting below the luminous clouds , lifts them up , or increases them ; and at last forces itself a passage through them , by throwing them aside .
OF NODULES .
Nodules are small , but highly elevated luminous Places .
Jan. 24 , 1 8oo .
On the south , near the limb of the sun , is a nodule ; and on the south-following side is another , with two smaller ones near it .
They are round , or roundish , bright elevae tions , of the same nature as the ridges .
Feb. 19 , 18oo .
There are two small bright nodules , on the preceding limb of the sun .
Why they should only be seen near the sun 's margin , can only be explained by admitting their elevation .
Nodules may be Ridges foreshortened .
Dec. 27 , 1799 .
Mixed with many ridges , nearly parallel to the margin of the sun , are here and there small thicknesses or knotty places .
I take them to be ridges in a more central direction , which gives them the shape of nodules .
The most north of three nodules , in one of the ridges , seems to be highest in elevation .
If it should last till tomorrow , it will then appear whether that nodule is really more elevated than the rest , or whether it is the foreshortening of a ridge extended in the direction of a radius .
OF CORRUGATIONS .
Corrugations consist of Elevations and Depressions .
Dec. 23 , 1799 .
The corrugations have a mottled appearance .
I see the figure of the dark and bright places .
Many of the dark places are not round , but a little extended in different directions , and appear to be lower than the bright places .
This , if admaitted , will explain why the corrugations towards the margin of the sun , cannot so readily be seen as about the middle of the disk .
Jan. 4 , i 8oo .
The -day being very favourable , I saw the sun uncommonly well .
The corrugated surface presented its elevations and depressions , with as much distinctness as the rough surface of the moon .
Corrugations extend all over the Surface of the Sun .
Dec. 23 , 1799 .
The corrugations extend all over the sun .
They are less distinct all around towards the limb , than at the centre .
Jan. 22 , 180c .
I followed the corrugations from the centre to the circumference ; and could trace them every where to within , I suppose , txvo minutes of the margin .
Jan. 24 , i Soo .
The corrugations are equally spread over the whole surface of the sun .
I viewed them distinctly in every part of it ; and traced them with much attention to within , I suppose , half a minute of the margin .
Jan. 4 , 1 Sol .
The corrugations are extended all over the disk of the sun , and go to the polar regions , as well as to the equatorial parts .
Dispersed Ridges or Nodules make Corrugations .
NoV .
17 , 18co .
The surface of the sun appears richly filled with very small broken or dispersed ridges , which produce the corrugated appearance .
Feb. i8 , 1801 .
The high parts of the corrugations contain numberless separations , like small nodules , which leave room for the indentations to be seen between them .
Corrugations change their Shape and Situation ; they increase , dimzinish , divide , and vanish quickly .
Dec. 27 , 1800 .
h o ' .
There is a pretty large corrugation near a small opening , which serves me as a direction to find the place .
Its indentation is about four diameters of the opening from it ; and io or i6 degrees north-precedlng .
ih J,1 I have seen the corrugation again ; and find its indentation larger than it was , and farther from the opening .
1h 10 ' .
It is vanished and several other such very minute changes have taken place .
Ih 121 .
Within a diameter of the opening , and a little northfollowing it , is an oval indentation , nearly as 'large as the small opening .
1h i5 ' .
Its shape is altered ; and it is divided into a corrugation , with two indentations .
1h S5 ' .
Both are entirely gone .
Jan. 18 , 1 8o .
Between two clusters of openings , that are near each other , there are some incipient openings , which resemble coarse corrugations , and establish a step between small openings and pores of indentations .
I showed them to my friend Dr. WILSON , whho happened to be upon a visit to me , at Slough .
He saw the same phenomena ; and judged of their being a link in the chain of appearances , as I did .
We drew a small sketch of the place of the phenomena , merely to serve us to communicate our observations to each other.* P 19 ' .
A , is a small opening without a shallow , which we had fixed upon , by way of enabling us to find again the minute objects which were to be examined .
B , is the indentation , or dark places of a corrugation I pointed out to DrWnton .
C , is a dark place of a corrugation he pointed out to me .
Ph 24 ' .
Weboth found the dark part of the corrugation B gone ; and C had either changed its place or was vanished .
1h 4 ' , C , was certainly gone .
Dr. WILSON pointed out another round pore , which Ore had not perceived before , at some distance ; also a largish indentsa , tion near the opening , which guided our research .
Shortly after , we found the indentation gone ; and the pore was further removed from the opening .
OF INDENTATIONS .
The dark Places of Corrugations are Indentations .
' Dec. 27 , 1799 .
That the low places of the corrugations are not much depressed , is evident from their visibility pretty near the margin of the sun .
Jan. 27 , i8oo .
The corrugations in many -places are so coarse , that their indentations resemble small shallows .
The *See Plate XIX .
Fig. i8 , indentations go down at the sides , like circular arches , present .
ing their concavities to us ; but the bottom of them is nearly flat.* Indentations are without Openings .
Jan. 15 , i 8oi The low places of corrugations do not contain punctures ; but seem to be irregularly shaped places , of less luminous matter than the borders which enclose them .
In some Places the Indentations contain small Openings .
Dec. 2 ' 1799 .
On examining some of the largest corrugations with a high magnifying power , I see plainly , that the less bright parts , or indentations , are small openings ; and that those dark -places , which were the coarsest , ^ show the opaque surface of thesun best : some of them ' are as black as the large openings .
The Elevations and Indentations of Corrugations are of different Figures .
Feb. i8 , i8oo .
Among all the corrugations , I could hardly perceive any that were round : they were of all shapes ; chiefly lengthened .
Indentations change to Openings .
Feb. io , 18oo .
Three corrugations , observed anhour ago , are now so enlarged , that their indentations are passed over from their former state , to small openings .
Indentations are of the same Nature as Shallows .
Jan. so , i8oi .
The depressed parts , or indentations , of corrugations , are of the colour of shallows ; and are probably of the same depth below their elevations , as shallows are below the general surface of the sun .
Indentations are low Places , which often contain very small Openings .
Jan. i8ol .
That indentations are small hollow places , and that the pores in them are little openings , may be concluded from a set of real openings of different sizes , of which I see no less than 13.Four of them are visible openings ; five of them are less than the smallest openings , and larger than the in .
dentations of corrugations ; the remaining four may already be called large pores .
We cannot expect to see into these pores , as we do into holes , their diameter being too small .
Indentations are of djferent Sizes .
Jari .
A3l 18 , io .
; The indentations are very uniform , but not round .
It seems they admit-of every possible shape .
Indentations are extended all over the Sun .
Dec. 20 , 1794 .
I can follow the indentations , from the centre up to the margin of the sun ; but it requires great attention , as , on account of the sphericity of the disk , they become gradually less conspicuous , the nearer we go to the circumference .
I saw them equally well at the north -pole of the sun .
-Dec .
22 i 799 The whole -disk of the sun is strongly indented .
Pp S Witb low magnifying Powers , Indentations wtill appear like Points .
Feb. 4 , 1800 .
I tried a magnifying power of only 45 times,.and the sun then appeared punctulated , instead of indented .
The points , or rather darker coloured places in the punctulations , were of different figures ; few of them being round .
OF PORES .
The low Places of Indentations are Pores , Dec. 20 , 1794 .
The lowest parts of the indented appearances , are almost dark and depressed enough to be called very minute openings , Pores increase sometimes , and become Openings .
Feb. io , 18oo .
Two indentations , observed an hour ago , are increased , and contain large pores , as if they were going to be converted into visible openings , like the indentations of three neighbouring corrugations mentioned under a former article .
Jan. 229 , 18oo .
Betweensome large and small openings were two pores , that grew darker while I looked at them , and may now be taken for very small openings .
This seems to trace the openings to their origin , and perfectly connects the pores with them .
Pores vanish quickly .
Dec. 27 , 18oo .
A small pore , that was north-following a very small opening , which served me as a direction for finding it again , Pl So ' ago , is no longer to be seen .
1Ai 30 ' .
There were two pores north-preceding the same opening .
When I returned to the telescope , in order to descrbe their situation exactly , they were vanished .
OF THE REGIONS OF SOLAR CLOUDS- .
It must be sufficiently evident , from what we have shown of the nature of openings , shallows , ridges , nodules , corrugations , indentations , and pores , that these phenomena could not appear , if the shining matter of the sun were a liquid ; since , by the laws of hydrostatics , the openings , shallows , indentations , and pores , would instantly be filled up ; nor could ridges and nodules preserve their elevation for a single moment .
Whereas , many openings have been known to last for a whole revolution of the sun ; and extensive elevations have remained supported for several days .
Much less can it be an elastic fluid of an atmospheric nature : this would be still more ready to fill up the low places , and to expand itself to a level at the top .
It remains , therefore , only for us to admit this shining matter to exist in the manner of empyreal , luminous , or phosphoric clouds , residing in the higher regions of the solar atmosphere .
The following observations , will explain and support this idea more at large .
Changes in the Solar Cloud &amp; happen continually .
Feb. 19 , 10oo .
In order to find whether the solarclouds were subject to very quick changes , I fixed my attention on several places ; but , on looking off , even for a moment , the spots I had marked for the purpose could not be found again.* There are two different Regions of Solar Clouds .
Feb. 19 , iSoo .
It is not possible to see the sun more distinctly than I do at present .
The corrugations are evidently caused by a double stratum of clouds ; the lower whereof , or that which is next to the sun , consists of clouds less bright than those which compose the upper stratum .
The lower clouds are also more closely -connected ; while the upper ones are chiefly de .
tached from each-other , and permit us to see every where through them .
Feb. A , 18ot .
An opening near the preceding limb has no shallow about it .
I can see the thickness of the preceding partition , from the top of the luminous clouds down to the vacancy ; and perceive that the lower part of the descent is of a less bright nature than the upper one : it is of the colour of an incipient shallow .
The inferior Clouds are opaque , and probably not unlike those of our Planet .
Feb. 5,1 So 1i .
The shallows about three considerable openings , on the following side of the sun , are of the same colour with that of a large opening on the preceding side .
Feb. i8 , i8oi .
The tufts of the shallows , or lower clouds , are all of the same colour .
The shallows about the three largest openings are all of the same colour , which is that of all the shallows I have ever seen .
Feb. 4 , 8oi .
The colour of a very small shallow about a little opening , is as faint as that of a large shallow of a very large opening now in view ; and , as far as I can remember , all the shallows I have seen have been nearly of the same colour , Hence we have reason to conclude , thate there are two different regions of clouds , the lowest whereof is never affected in colour by the cause which acts upon the upper one , when shallows are generated .
If so , these clouds are probably of a very different nature ; for , were they not different , they would not be differently affected by the same cause .
Perhaps this lower region is a set of dense opaque planetary clouds , like those upon our globe .
In that case , their light is only the uniform reflection of the surrounding superior self-luminous region .
If this be admitted , it will at once account for the sameness of the colour of the shallows , and of their tufts ; and for many other phenomena .
Quantity of Light reflectedfrom the inferior Planetary Clouds .
Feb. 7 , 1801 .
I made an artificial contrivance , for the use of my photometer , to represent a portion of the bright surface of the sun , and of an opening with a shallow surrounding it .
The opening was represented by a small patch of black velvet , resembling nearly , in shape , the large opening in the sun which is now visible .
This was fastened on the farthest vane of my photometer , covered with white paper , and arranged so as to be in the line of the centre .
In the nearest vane , covered with the same paper , and equally prepared so as to move in the centre of the photometer , I cut a hole large enough to show the black velvet on the farthest vane , with a small margin of its paper about it , which was intended to represent the shallow about the opening .
The illumination of the nearest vane was to represent the brightness of the sun .
The two vanes were arranged so as to be one behind the other , in a straight line ; and a single hole was made in the middle of the moveable piece No. 4 , of the photometer described in my last paper..* I now viewed the opening and shallow in the sun , and immediately after went to the photometer , to examine the artificial phenomenon .
By withdrawing the farthest vane , I diminished its illumination , till I found the small visible rim about the velvet less luminous -than the paper of the first vane , in the same proportion as I judged the shallow to be less bright than the rest of the sun .
Then .
, going alternately many times to the telescope and to the photometer , and making such little alterations in the apparatus as I thought necessary , I obtained at last a result , which showed that the rim of paper representing the shallow reflected 469 parts of the incident light .
Hence , if the superior self-luminous clouds of the sun throw the same quantity of light on the inferior region of opaque solar clouds as they send to us , it follows , that those inferior clouds of which the shallows are composed , reflect about 469 rays out of every thousand they receive .
With regard to the solar surface which we see in the openings , I also found that black worsted , which , by my lately published tables , reflects 16 rays out of a thousand , was not dark enough , compared to the blackness of the opening , but that black velvet seemed to be nearly of the same intensity ; so that , probably , when the luminous surface of the sun sends us looo , and the flats 469 rays , the solid surface seen in the openings reflects no more than about seven .
" See Phil. Trans. for idoom p. SaS Indentations are planetary Clouds , reflecting Light through the open Parts of the Corrugations .
Jan. 15 , i8ol .
The corrugations do not contain pores , but irregularly shaped depressed places , of a darker or rather less luminous matter than the borders of the corrugations ; probably owing to the same cause that makes the shallows appear less bright than the general surface .
Feb. 7 , 18o .
The corrugations go up to the borders of the shallow of an opening observed since Feb. 4 .
Indeed the high parts of the corrugations themselves consist of the upper selfluminous clouds ; while their indentations are the reflection of light from the lower regions of the opaque ones .
The opaque inferior Clouds probably suffer but little of the Light ofJ the selflluminous superior Clouds to come to the Body of ; the Sun .
Feb. 5 , i So 1 .
The shallow of a large opening , though already contracted &gt; is still sufficiently broad not to permit a single direct ray of the superior self-luminous clouds to enter this opening ; and the blackness of the opening shows , that but little light can penetrate through the inferior region of planetary clouds of which the shallow consists .
Motion of the inferior Clouds .
Feb. 6 , 18oi .
The great opening of Feb. 4 , is much diminished : it is now divided by a branch of the inferior clouds of the shallow , with a few superior ones upon the following half of the division or bridge .
The shallow on the other side of the bridge is plainly still free from self-lumninous clouds .
1 1h 53 ' .
On the preceding side , more of the planetary clouds are advancing to draw themselves over the opening ; they are very faint .
Feb. 7 , 18oi .
Another passage is now thrown over the great opening , consisting evidently of the lower clouds .
Perhaps a few clouds of the upper regions may be drawn upon it ; but , at both sides , the shallow continues to be visible from the bridge to its margin , or confinement by the surrounding selfluminous clouds .
10h 40 ' .
A third passage is beginning to come ; on from the following side , also consisting of lower clouds .
It seems that the curtain will be closely drawn over the opening , before many of the self-luminous clouds can advance .
Motion of the superior Clouds .
Feb. A , i8oi .
The large opening of Feb. 4 , is in a diminishing state .
Its shallow is contracted ; and , though it has no corrugations , it seems as if a few self-luminous clouds of the upper regions were here and there scattered over it .
I see their superior brightness , and their elevation above the shallow in the places where they are .
Ph 42 ' .
More of the clouds of the upper regions have scattered themselves over the shallow ; and one of them faintly passes over part of the opening , almost across it .
This will probably form a division .
Ihi5o ' .
There is an opposite cloud advancing to meet the former one ; probably that part of the opening where they are , opposes less resistance than the rest .
P 53 ' .
The shallow contracts very fast ; the sides of the upper regions of clouds press on ; the borders become irregulars and jagged , according to the advancement of the clouds ; but a coarsely circularform of the shallow in general is still preserved .
Eminent Use of theplanetary Clouds .
It has been shown that the openings , compared to the lumps nous surface of the sun , reflect less than i6 rays out of a thousand , and probably not more than seven .
To account for this extraordinary darkness , it must be remembered that according to the observations which have been given , hardly any but transmitted rays can ever come to the body of the sun , Theshallows about large openings are generally of such a size , as hardly to permit any direct illumination from the superior cloudsto pass over them into the openings ; and the great height and closeness of the sides of small ones , though not often guarded by shallows , must also have nearly the same effet .
By this it appears , that the planetary clouds are indeed a most effectual curtain , to keep the brightness of the superior regions from the body of the sun .
Another advantage arising from the planetary clouds of the sun , IS of no less importance to the whole solar system , We have shown that corrugations are every where dispersed over the sun ; e and that their indentations may be called shallows in miniature .
From thiswe may conclude , that the immense curtain of the planetary solar clouds is every where closely drawn ; and , as our photometrical experiments have proved that these clouds reflect no less than 49 rays out of a thousand , it is evident that they must add a most capital support to the splendour of the sun , by throwing back so great a share of the brightness coming .
to them from the illumination of the whole superior regions Q q &lt; 2 OF THE SOLAR ATMOSPHERE .
The Sun has a planetary Atmosphere .
Our observations on the double regions of clouds in the sun , are certainly a sufficient proof of the existence of a solar atmo .
sphere .
The clouds of the lower regions of the sun bear such a resemblance to our own , that they can only , like ours , be upheld by a thin elastic medium , in which , like ours in air , they may freely move about in all directions .
The Sun 's planetary Atmosphere extends to a great Height .
If we have concluded , from the appearance of the clouds of the lower regions , that they were supported by an atmosphere , the same will hold good with regard to the self-luminous clouds of the upper regions .
For , though probably they do not swim or float in the planetary atmosphere of the sun , like the lower ones , it is evident , from observation , that they arrange themselves regularly at certain given altitudes ; which can only be ascribed to the specific gravity of the gases to which they owe their existence .
Besides , as the solar atmosphere is elastic , it can be no otherwise confined than by its gravitation to the sun , in the same manner as the air , by its own weight is kept down to the earth ; and the solar atmosphere must therefore expand itself consider .
ably above the highest ridges and nodules .
The planetary Atmosphere of the Sun is of a great Density .
This may be deduced directly from the known quantity of , matter in the sun .
Sir ISAAc NEWTON has proved , that the gravitation of bodies on the surface of the sun , is 27 times stronger sot than it is with us .
Hence , the compression of the elastic gases of which the solar atmosphere consists , if similar to our own , must be greater than that of ours , in proportion to the superior force by which they are compressed , namely , their own powerful gravitation towards the sun .
The Solar Atmosphere , ike ours , is subject to Agitations , such as with us are occasioned by J ?
inds .
A proof of this may be drawn from the observations which have been given .
In several instances , we have seen the planetary clouds move over the openings ; which could not have happened , unless the atmosphere in which they floated had been considerably agitated .
In many other instances , we have shown that a strong bias existed in the direction of the cause which generates the shallows .
This indeed is so evident , that I have hardly ever seen a single shallow which had not some excentricity ; the smallest segments of these shallows being always turned towards what I have called the quiescent side of the openings .
To this may be added , that the continual luminous decompositions in the superior regions , and the consequent necessary regeneration of the atmospheric gases that serve to carry them on , and which probably are produced below the inferior cloudy regions , near the surface of the sun 's body , must unavoidably be attended with great agitations , such as with us might even be called hurricanes .
There is some clear Atmospheric Space , between the solid Body of the Sun and the lowest Region of the Clouds .
From what has just now been said of the agitations which appear to take place in the solar atmosphere , it follows , that those biases which have been shown to affect the direction of a number of shallows at the same time , must have arisen from a notion of the atmospheric gases under the clouds ; and , that there is a considerable vacant space between these clouds and the solid body of the sun , is also to be inferred , from the free motion of clouds considerably lower than usual , which were seen to pass over an opening , and which cannot be supposed to have rolled over the ground in contact with it .
Without , however , entering into any particular examination of the amount of the distance from the sun to the first cloudy regions , which , were I to guess by some pretty obvious circumstances , would not be less than some hundreds of miles , we may tale it for granted , that the altitude of the clouds will every where be determined by their own density , and by that of the atmosphere in which they aresuspended .
The Sun 's planetary , Atmosphere is transparent .
It Will be easily shown , that the gases of the solar atmosphere are transparent ; for we have already given observations that prove our being able to see the reflected light of the corrugations from their indentations ; and of the self-luminous regions in , general , from the shallows which they surround and illuminate .
To this may be added , that we also see clearly down through thespace which leads through the openings as fully appears from our being able to see the thicknesses of the borders which enclose them .
We have likewise given an instance of seeing the limb of the sun broken by a vacancy proceeding from a large shallow ; though undoubtedly that shallow must have been covered with the solar atmospheric gases , THEORETICAL EXPLANATION OF THE SOLAR PHENOMENA .
We have admitted , in order to explain the generation of shallows , that a transparent elastic gas comes up through the openings , by forcing itself a passage through the planetary clouds .
Our observations seemed naturally to lead to this supposition , or rather to prove it ; for , in tracing the shallows to their origin , it has been shown , that they always begin from the opens ings , and go forwards .
We have also seen , that in one case , a particular bias given to incipient shallows , lengthened a number of them out in one certain direction , which evidently denoted a propelling force acting the same way in them all .
I am , however , well prepared to distinguish between facts observed , and the consequences that in reasoning upon them we may draw from them ; and it will be easy to separate them , if that should hereafter be required .
If however , it be now allowed , that the cause we have assigned may be the true one , it will then appear , that the operations which are carried on in the atmosphere of the sun are very simple and uniform .
Generation of Pores .
By the nature and construction of the sun , an elastic gas , which may be called empyreal , is constantly formed .
This ascends every where , by a specific gravity less than that of the general solar atmospheric gas contained in the lower regions .
When it goes up in moderate quantities , it makes itself small passages among the lower regions of clouds : these we have frequently observed , and have called them pores .
We have shown that they are liable to continual and quick changes , which must be a natural consequence of their fleeting generation .
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~a Formation of corrugations .
When this empyreal gas has reached the higher regions of the sun 's atmosphere , it mixes with other gases , which , from their specific gravity , have their residence there , and occasions decompositions which produce the appearance of corrugations .
It has been shown , that the elevated parts of the corrugations are small self-luminous nodules , or broken ridges ; and I have used the name of self-luminous clouds , as a general expression for all phenomena of the sun , in what shape soever they may appear , that shine by their own light .
These terms do not exactly convey the idea affixed to them ; but those of meteors , coruscations , inflammations , luminous wisps , or others , which I might have selected , would have been liable to still greater objections .
It is true , that when speaking of clouds , we generally conceive something too gross , and even too permanent , to permit us to apply that expression properly to luminous decompositions , which cannot float or swim in air , as we are used to see our planetary clouds do .
But it should be remembered , that , on account of the great compression arising from the force of gravity , all the elastic solar gases must be much condensed ; and that , consequently , phenomena in the sun 's atmosphere , which in ours would be mere transitory coruscations , such as those of the aurora borealis , will be so compressed as to become much more efficacious and permanent .
Cause of Indentations .
The great light occasioned by the brilliant superior regions , must scatter itself on the tops of the inferior planetary clouds , and , on account of their great density , bring on a very vivid reflection .
Between the interstices of the elevated parts of the corrugations , or self-luminous clouds , which , according to the observations that have been given , are not closely connected , the light reflected from the lower clouds will be plainly visible , and , being , considerably less intense than the direct illumination from the upper regions , will occasion that faint appearance which we have called indentations .
Cause of the mottled Appearance of the Sun .
This mixture of the light reflected from the indentations and that which is emitted directly from the higher parts of the corrugations , unless very attentively examined by a superior telescope , will only have the resemblance of a mottled surface .
Formation of small Openings , Ridges , and Nodules .
When a quantity of empyreal gas , more than what produces only pores in ascending , is formed , it will make itself small openings ; or , meetingiperhaps with some resistancein passing upwards , it may exert its action in the production of ridges and nodules .
Production of large Openings and Shallows .
Lastly , if still further an uncommon quantity of this gas should be formed , it will burst through the planetary regions of clouds , and thus will produce great openings ; then , spreading itself above them , it will occasion large shallows , and , mixing afterwards gradually with other superior gases , it will promote the increase , and assist in the maintenance , of the general luminous phenomena .
If this account of the solar appearances should be well founded , we shall have no difficulty in ascertaining the actual state of the sun , with regard to its energy in giving light and heat to our globe ; and nothing will now remain , but to decide the question which will naturally occur , whether there be actually any considerable difference in the quantity of light and heat emitted from the sun at different times .
But , since experience has already convinced us , that our seasons are sometimes very severe , and at other times very mild , it remains only to be con-i sidered , whether we .
should ascribe this difference immediately to a more or less copious emission of the solar beams .
Now ; as we have lately had seasons of deficiency , that seem to Indi- .
cate a want of the vivifying principles of light and heat , and as , from the appearance of last summer , and the present mild -winter , there seems to be a change that may be in our favour , it will be proper to have recourse to solar observations , in order to compare the phenomena which indicate the state of the sun , with the seasons of these remarkable times .
The following two sets , which are selected from my journals , I believe will assist us materially in this inquiry .
SIGNS OF SCARCITY OF LUMINOUS MATTER IN THE SUN .
Visible Deficiency of empyreal Clouds .
July 5 , 1795 .
1h 6 ' .
The appearance of the sun is very different from what I have ever seen it before .
There is not a single opening in the whole disk ; there are no ridges or nodules ; there are no corrugations .
A perfect Calm in the upper Regions of solar Clouds .
Dec 9 , 1798 .
32h A The sun has no openings of any kind ; nor can I perceive any places that look disturbed like those where openings have lately been .
Want of Openings , Ridges , and Nodules .
Sept. i8 , 1795 .
There is no opening in the sun .
I viewed it with powers from 9o to 4600 April i , 1798 .
th 49 ' .
-I examined the sun with a power of oo ; but could find no openings .
Nov. 27 , 1799 .
The sun is without openings .
I cannot however perceive any indication that , by the mere look , would denote a deficiency of light .
Dec. 31 , 1799 .
There are no openings in the disk of the sun .
Jan. 3 .
i8oo .
There is no opening visible any where .
Jan. 27 , i8oo .
There is no opening .
There are no ridges ; nor is there a single nodule any where .
Jan. 3o , i80o .
There are neither openings , ridges , nor nodules , in the sun .
Jan g1 , 1Soo .
There are neither openings , nor ridges , in the sun .
Feb. 4 , i Soo .
There are neither openings , ridges , nor nodules , any where .
Feb. 1i , 1 Soo .
There is not an opening , ridge , , or nodule , any where in the sun .
Feb. 18 , 18oo .
There are no openings , no ridges , or nodules .
Dec. 22 , 1799 .
In one part of the sun are some vivid ridges ; but I cannot find any of them in other parts .
Dec. 27 , i799 .
Near the following margin are some bright ridges ; but there is not a single one to be seen in any other part of the sun 's disk , Many Indentations without , and others with , changeable Pores .
Jan. i , i8oo .
The indentations contain fewer black points than last week .
Jan.4 , i8oo .
The corrugations are punctured with blackish indentations .
The sun is more affected in this manner than it was yesterday .
Rr X Jan. 27 , iSoo .
The sun is every where coarsely indented , but not punctured ; there being no black points in the indentations .
SIGNS OF ABUNDANCE OF LUMINOUS MATTER IN THE SUTN .
Visible Increase of empyreal Clouds .
Feb. 12 , 1 8o .
The indentations , in many parts , are changed to small shallows of corrugations .
There seems to have been a gradual increase of the luminous clouds for some time past .
The reason why I am not positively assured of this increase is , that my present method of viewing the sun is so much better than formerly , that , by seeing things to greater advantage , there may be some deception in the seeming change of appearances .
March a , i8oo .
I can .
now entertain no doubt that the lumlinous clouds are more copious than they were some time ago .
The corrugations seem all to be better filled .
Hardly any of the indentations have pores .
Many Openings , Ridges , and Nodules .
March $ , 1 Soo .
A range of openings has a very fine appearance ; there are 55 of them .
The most south and largest has a considerable shallow about it .
Two , just north of it , have shallows on the northern side , but not towards the south , where the borders of the openings seem to be full as elevated as the highest luminous clouds .
Near the south-following margin are extensive ridges , studded here and there with nodules .
Nov. 17 , 18oo .
The sun is beautifully ornamented with openings , shallows , ridges , and nodules .
Dec. 2 , i8oo .
The sun is every where richly covered by luminous clouds .
Ridges and nodules are also to be seen in many places .
Bog Dec. 27 .
A large opening is lately come into the disk ; se .
veral other small ones are visible .
; and there are , near the prece.ding and following limbs , many extensive ridges .
The luminous clouds are very plentifully and richly scattered all over .
Jan. Ad , iSoo .
There are three collections of openings in different parts of the disk of the sun , and many ridges and nodules .
The small indentations , as I have formerly called them , are so coarse , and of such irregular shapes , that they can be called so no longer .
Corrugations , therefore , are that variety and unevenness of the whole surface of the sun , when it appears richly furnished with luminous clouds .
I am now much inclined to believe , that openings with great shallows , ridges , nodules , and corrugations , instead of small indentations , may lead us to expect a copious emission of heat , and therefore mild seasons .
And that , on the contrary , pores , small indentations , and a poor appearance of the luminous clouds , the absence of ridges and nodules , and of large openings 'and shallows , will denote a spare emission of heat , and may induce us to expect severe seasons .
A constant observation of the sun with this view , and a proper information respecting the general mildness or severity of the seasons , in all parts of the world , may bring this theory to perfection , or refute it , if it be not well founded .
Jan. 24 , 8o8i .
The surface of the sun is every where richly decked out with luminous clouds .
An additional opening is lately come into view , attended by many spreading ridges .
Jan. 29 , 1801 .
If openings be a sign of richness in the illuminating and heating disposition of the sun , there are enough of them : considerable ones are scattered in sixt different regions , taking up a broad zone .
Feb. 4 , 18oi .
Between flying clouds , I counted 31 openings in the sun .
March 2 , 18oi .
There are six different sets of openings in the sun .
One of them consists of ten ; another of two ; the rest are single .
Coarse and luminous Corrugations .
Jan. 4 , i Soil .
The corrugations are very coarse ; and the luminous clouds seem to be very rich .
Jan. , 18oi .
The elevations of the corrugations are all very luminous , like so many nodules .
Feb. iS , 180X .
The corrugations are every where very luminous .
March 2 .
The general surface of the sun is so rich , that the indentations are a good deal covered by self-luminous clouds .
From these two last sets of observations , one of which establishes the scarcity of the luminous clouds , while the other shows their great abundance , I think we may reasonably conclude , that there must be a manifest difference in the emission of light and heat from the sun .
It appears to me , if I may be permitted the metaphor , that our sun has for some time past been labouring -under an indisposition , from which it is now in a fair way of recovering .
An application of the foregoing method , however , even if we were perfectly assured of its being well founded Will still remain attended with considerable difficulties .
We see how , in that simple instrument the barometer , our expectations of rain or fair weather , are only to be had by a consideration of many circumstances , besides its actual elevation at the moment of inspection .
The tides also present us with the most complicated varieties in their greatest elevation , as well as in the time when they happen on the coasts of different parts of this globe .
The simplicity of their cause , the solar and lunar attractions , we might have expected , would have precluded every extraordinary and seemingly discordant result .
In a much higher degree , may the influence of more or less light and heat from the sun , be liable to produce a great variety in the severity or mildness of the seasons of different climates , and under different local circumstances ; yet , when many things which are already known to affect the temperature of different countries , and others which future attention may still discover , come to be properly combined with the results we propose to draw from solar observations , we may possibly find this subject less intricate than we might apprehend on a first view of it .
If , for instance , we should have a warm summer in this count try , when phenomena observed in the sun indicate the expecta- , tion of it , I should by no means consider it as an unsurmountable objection , if it were shown that in another country the weather had not been so favourable .
And , if it were generally found that our prognostication from solar observations held good in any one given place , I should be ready to say that , with prosper modifications , they would equally succeed in every other situation .
Before we can generalize the influence-of a certain cause , we ought to confine our experiment to one permanent situation , where local circumstances may be supposed to act nearly alike at all times , which will remove a number of difficulties .
To recur to our instance of the tides , if we were to examine the phenomena which they offer to our inspection in any one given place , such as the mouth of the Thames , we should soon be convinced of their agreement with the motion of the sun and moon .
A little reflection would easily reconcile us to every deviation from regularity , by taking into account the direction and violence of winds , the situation of the coast , and other circumstances .
Nor should we doubt the truth of the theory of the tides , though high water at Bristol , Liverpool , or Hull , should have been very deficient , at a time when , in the place of our experiments , it had happened to be uncommonly abundant .
, Now , with regard to the effects of the influence of the sun , we know already , that in the same latitudes the seasons differ widely in temperature ; that it is not hottest at noon , or coldest at midnight ; that the shortest day is neither attended with the severest frosts , nor the longest day with the most oppressing heats that large forests , lakes , morasses , and swamps , affect the temperature one way : and rocky , sandy , gravelly , and barren situations , in a contrary manner ; that the seasons of islands are considerably different from those of large continents , and so forth .
But it will now be necessary to examine the accounts we already have of the appearance and disappearance of the solar spots , and to compare them with the temperature of the respec .
tive times , as far as history will furnish us with records .
The first thing which appears from astronomical observations is , that the periods of the disappearance of spots on the sun are of much shorter duration than those of their appearance ; so that if the symptoms which have been pointed out , as denoting the state of the sun with regard to light and heat should be well founded , we ought rather to look upon the absence of spots as a sign of deficiency , than on their presence as one of abundance ; and this would justify my expression , of the recovery of the sun from an indisposition , as being a return to its usual splendour .
In going back to early observations , we cannot expect to meet with a record of such minute phenomena as we have attended to .
The method of viewing spots on the sun , by throwing their picture , in a dark room , on a sheet of white paper , is not capable of delicacy ; nor were the direct views of former astronomers so distinct as , in the present improved state of the telescope , we can have them ; a very imperfect account of solar spots may therefore be expected , considering our present inquiry , which would require complete observations of every spot , great or small , that has been on the sun during such -periods as will be examined .
With regard to the contemporary severity and mildness of the seasons , it Will hardly be necessary to remark , that nothing decisive can be obtained .
But , if we are deficient here , an indirect source of information is opened to us , by applying to the influence of the sun-beams on the vegetation of wheat in this country .
I do not mean to say , that this is a real criterion of the quantity of light and heat emanated from the sun , ; much less will the price of this article completely represent the scarcity or abundance of the absolute produce of the country .
For the price of commodities will certainly be regulated by the demand for them ; and this we know is liable to be affected by -many fortuitous circumstances .
However , although an argument drawn from a well ascertained price of wheat , may not apply directly to our present purpose , yet , admitting the sun to be the ultimate fountain of fertility , this subject may deserve a short investigation , especially as , for want of proper thermometrical observations , no other method is left for our choice .
Our historical account of the disappearance of the spots in the sun , contains five very irregular and very unequal periods.* The first takes in a series of 21 years , fromi6o to 1670 , both in- , eluded .
But it is so imperfectly recorded , that , it is hardly safe to draw any conclusions from it ; for we have only a few observations of one or two spots that were seen in all that time , and those were only observed for a short continuance .
However , on examining the table of the prices of the quarter of nine bushels of the best or highest priced wheat at Windsor , marked in Dr. ADAM SMITH'S valuable Inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations , f we find that wheat , during the time of the 21 years above mentioned , bore a very high price ; the average of the quarter being ?
2 , ios .
5 -d .
This period is much too long to suppose that we might safely compare it with a. preceding or following one of equal duration .
Besides , no particulars having been given of the time preceding , except that spots in the sun , a good while before , began to grow very scarce , there might even be fewer of them than from the year 165o to i 67o .
Of the 21 years immediately following , we know that they certainly comprehend two short periods , in which there were no spots on the sun ; of these , more will be said hereafter ; but , including even them , we have the average price of wheat , from 1671 to 1691 , only ? ?
2 .
4s .
the quarter .
The difference , which is a little more than as 9 to 8 , is therefore still a proof of a temporary scarcity .
Our next period is much better ascertained .
It begins in December i676 , which year therefore we should not take in , and goes to April 1684 ; in all which time , Flamsteed , who was then observing saw no spot in the sun .
The average price of wheat , during these 8 years , was 2 2 .
7s .
7d .
the quarter .
We See Astronomy par M. PDe la Land &amp; , ? ?
3235 .
alSee eBook 1 .
Chap. XL , cannot justly compare this price with that of the preceding 8 years , as some of the former years of scarcity would come into that period ; but the 8 years immediately following , that is , from 1685 to 1691 , both included , give an average price of no more than f i. 17s .
1 3d .
The difference , which is as full 0 to 4 , 1s well deserving our notice .
A third but very short period , is from the year i686 to 1688 , in which time Cassini could find no spot in the sun .
If both years be included , we hbave the average price of wheat , for those three years , ? ?
1 .
-is .
o -d .
the quarter .
We ought not to compare this price with that of the three preceding years , as two of them belong to the preceding period of scarcity ; but the three following years give the average price for the quarter of wheat 1 .
12S .
lo -id .
or , as nearly io to lo .
The fourth period on record , is from the year 1695 tO 1 700 , in which time no spot could be found in the sun .
This makes a period of A years ; for , in 1700 the spots were seen again .
The average priceof wheat , intheseyears , was 3 3 .
Sd3 J. the quarter .
The A preceding years , from 1690 to 1694 , give f2 .
9S .
445d .
and the A following years , from 170 to 1704 , givedi .
17S .
11 d These differences are both very considerable ; the last is not less than 5 to 3 .
The fifth period extends from 1710 to 1713z ; but here there wras one spot seen in 170o , none in 1711 and 1712 , and again one spot only in 1713 .
The account of the average price of wheat , for these four years , is 217s .
44 .
the quarter .
The pre &amp; ceding four years , from 1706 to 1 709 , give the price ?
2 .
3s .
7j-d .
and the following years , from 1714 to 1717 , it was ?
2 6s .
9d .
When the astronomical account of the sun for this period , which has been stated above , is considered , these two differences will be found very considerable ; the first of them being nearly as 4 to 3 .
The result of this review of the foregoing five periods is , that , from the price of wheat , it seems probable that some temporary scarcity or defect of vegetation has generally taken place , when the sun has been without those appearances which we surmise to be symptoms of i copious emission of light and heat .
In order , however , to make this an argument in favour of our hypothesis , even if the reality of a defective vegetation of grain were sufficiently established by its enhanced price , it would still be necessary to show that a deficiency of the solar beams had been the occasion of it .
Now , those who are acquainted with agriculture may remark , that wheat is well known to grow in climates much colder than ours ; and that a proper distribution of rain and dry weather , with many other circumstances which it will not be necessary to mention , are probably of much greater consequence than the absolute quantity of light and heat derived from the sun .
To this I shall only suggest , by way of answer , that those very circumstances of proper alternations of rain , dry weather , winds , or whatever else may contribute to favour vegetation in this climate , may possibly depend on a certain quantity of sun-beams , transmitted to us at proper times ; but , this being a point which can only be ascertained by future observations , I forbear entering farther into a discussion of it .
-It will be thought remarkable , that no later periods of the disappearance of the solar spots can be found .
The reason however is obvious .
The perfection of instruments , and the increased number of observers , have produced an account of solar spots , which , from their smallness , or their short appearance , would probably have been overlooked in former times .
If we should in future only reckon the years of the total absence of solar spots , even that remarkable period of scarcity which has fallen under my own observation , in which nevertheless I have now and then seen a few spots of short duration , and of no great magnitude , could not be admitted .
For this reason , we ought now to distinguish our solar observations , by reducing them to short periods of symptoms , for or against a copious emission of the solar beams , in which , all the phenomena we have pointed out should be noticed .
The most striking of them are certainly the number , magnitude , and duration of the openings .
The increase and decrease of the luminous appearance of the corrugations is perhaps full as essential ; but , as it is probable that : their brilliancy .
may be a consequence of the abundance of the former phenomena , an attention to the latter , which is subject to great difficulties , and requires the very best of telescopes , may not be so necessary .
What remains to be added is but short .
In the first of my two series of observations , I have pointed put a deficiency in what appears to be the symptomatic disposition of the sun for emitting light and heat : it has lasted from the year 179 ' to 1800.* That we have had a considerable deficiency in the-vegetation of grain , will hardly require any proof .
The second series , or .
rather the commencement of it , for I hope it will last long , has pointed out a favourable return of the rich appearance of the sun .
This , if I may venture to judge , will probably occasion a return of such seasons as , in the end , will be attended by all their usual fertility .
The subject , however , being so new , it will be proper to conclude , by adding , that this prediction ought not to be relied on by any one , with more confidence than the arguments which have been brought forwards in this Paper may appear to deserve .
EXPLANATION OF THE 1St , 2d , tiith and 12th FIGURES .
SEE PLATES XVIII .
and XIX .
Plate XVIII .
Fig. i , represents an opening in the luminous solar clouds , with its surrounding shallow , in a situation much pastthe centre , towards the preceding limb of the sun .
The lines marked with the letters a , b , c , d , of , answer to those which are marked with the same letters in Fig. 2 .
Figure 2 , is a section of the same opening .
The lines a , b , c , H , elf , are supposed to be drawn from the eye of the observer .
a and b point out the elevation of the corrugations g , h , on the preceding side P , above the surface of the shallow i , k. c and d show the thickness of the shallow and the line d goes through the opening , down into the clear atmospheric space P IF , till it meets with the opaque surface of the sun A B. On the following side F , the thickness of the shallow and elevation of the corrugations cannot be seen ; since the line e goes abruptly into the opening ; and f goes as abruptly , from the top of the corrugations , down to the shallow .
Plate XIX .
Fig. X i , shows a : section of the corrugations , shallow , and opening , of Fig. 1o , in the same manner as Fig. X represents those of Fig. i. There is a hanging cloud a , in Fig. 1a , over the preceding part of the opening ; and the same cloud is represented at b , in Fig. 12 , to which place it was seen to move from its former situation , in 58 minutes of time .
The rest of the figures are sufficiently explained in the places of the text which refer to them .
~~~~~~~ E A. x J1y j.3 .
C !
I / 4 K~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ !
CIC JA~~~~~ig ~~~~~%4~~~~--~~~~~ - .
9+%/ v. ~~~~~~ gn* qg ~~9 br j4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 9~~~~~~~~ , M

