the thermometer or hygrometer , yet the law of these variations is not altogether so simple as I had hoped it might be found .
I shall , on the present occasion , first relate the facts on which this opinion is founded , and which are in themselves sufficiently remarkable , on account of the unexpected quantity of refraction observable over a short extent of water ; I shall , in the next place , show that the exact determination of the concurrent changes of the atmosphere are of less value , and their irregularities of less consequence , than I had conceived , as there is a very easy method whereby the quantity ' of dip at sea may be at any time correctly measured ; and therefore the end which I sought by indirect means , may be at once directly attained .
The first instance that occurred to me , of observable refraction over the surface of the Thames , was wholly accidental .
I was sitting in a boat near Chelsea , in such a position that my eye was elevated about half a yard from the surface of the water , and had a view over its surface , that probably somewhat exceeded a mile in length , when I remarked that the oars of several barges at a distance , that were then coming up with the tide , appeared bent in various degrees , according to their distance from me .
The most distant appeared nearly in the form here represented ; dd bei/ g my vble ho-zon by apparent here represented ; dd being my visible horizon by apparent curvature of the water ; ab the oar itself in its inclined position ; and bc an inverted image of the portion be .
By a little attention to other boats , and to buildings on shore , I could discern that the B 3 appearance of all distant objects sepn near the surface of the water was affected in a similar manner , but that scarcely any of them afforded images so perfectly distinct as the oblique line of an oar dipped in the water .
A person present at the time ( as well as some others to whom I have since related the circumstance ) was inclined to attribute the appearance to reflection from the surface of the water ; but , by a moderate share of attention , a very evident difference may be discovered between the inversion occasioned by reflection , and that which is caused by atmospherical refraction .
In cases of reflection , the angles between the object and image are sharp , the line of contact between them straight and well defined , but the lower part of the image indefinite and confused , by means of any slight undulation of the water .
But , when the images are caused by refraction , the confines of the object and its inverted image are rounded and indistinct , and the lower edge of the image is terminated by a straight line at the surface of the water .
In addition to these marks of difference , there is another circumstance which , if attended to , must at once remove all doubt ; for , by bringing the line of sight near to the surface of the water , boats and other small objects are found to be completely hidden by an apparent horizon , which , in so short a distance , cannot be owing to any real curvature of the water , and can arise solely from the bending of the rays by refraction .
When I reflected upon the causes which were probably instrumental in the production of these phenomena , they appeared referrible to difference of temperature alone .
After a succession of weather so hot that the thermometer , during one month preceding , had been rl times above 80 ?
, and on an average of the month at 68 ?
, the evening of that day ( August 22 , 18oo ) was unusually cold , the thermometer being 55 ? .
The water might be supposed to retain the temperature it had acquired during a few weeks preceding , and , by warming the stratum of air immediately contiguous to it , might cause a diminution of its refractive density , sufficient to effect this inverted curvature of the rays of light , in the manner formerly explained .
As I was at that time unprovided with instruments of any kind , I had it not in my power to estimate the quantity of refraction , or temperatures ; and can only say that , to my hand , the water felt in an uncommon degree warmer than the air .
Being thus furnished with an unexpected field for observation , I from that time took such opportunities as similar changes of the weather afforded me , of examining and measuring the quantities of refraction that might be discovered by the same means over another part of the river , that I found most suited to my convenience .
The situation from which the greater part of my observations were made , was at the SE corner of Somerset house .
The view from this spot extends under Blackfriars bridge , towards London bridge , upwards of a mile in length , and in the opposite direction through Westminster bridge , which is three quarters of a mile distant .
Such distances are however by no means necessary ; and indeed the air over the river , in cold weather , is generally , or at least very frequently , not sufficiently clear for seeing distinctly to so great distances .
For , since the winds which are most likely to effect a sufficient change of temperature , on account of their coldness , are usually from the E , or NO , the principal smoke of the town is then brought in that direction , and hovers , like a dense fog over the course of the river .
This circumstance deprived me of many opportunities which the changes of the thermometer indicated to belfavourable for my purpose , and obliged me often to make use of shorter distances than I should otherwise have chosen , by bringing the line of sight as near as I could to the surface of the water .
For this purpose , I had a plane reflector fitted to the objectend of a small pocket telescope , at an angle of 45 ' , so that , when the telescope was held vertically , it gave a horizontal view at any level that was found most eligible .
When the water has been calm , I have observed that the greatest refraction was visible within an inch or two of its surface , and I have then seen a refraction of six or seven minutes in the space of 3oo00 or 400 yards : at other times , I have found it greatest at the height of a foot or two ; but , in this case , a far more extensive view becomes necessary .
The first measures that I took were on the 2sd of September , 18oo .
The water was 9j ?
warmer than the air , and I found a refraction of about 4 ' .
Oct. 17 .
The difference of temperature was ?
, and the refraction ' .
Oct. 22 .
The water was ii- ?
warmer than the air , yet the quantity of refraction did not exceed 3 ' .
The smallness of the quantity of refraction upon this occasion , I attributed to the dryness of the atmosphere , conjecturing that a rapid evaporation might in great measre counteract that warmth which the water would otherwise have communicated to the air .
From that time , therefore , I have noted not only the heights of the thermometer in the water and in the air , but have added also the degrees of cold produced by keeping the bulb of it moistened for a sufficient time to render it stationary .
In confirmation of my conjecture respcting the dryness of Oct. -2 , I have also , in the following Table , which comprises the whole of my observations , inserted a column from the Register kept at the apartments of the Royal Society , containing the heights of the hygrometer , on those mornings when my observations were made .
TABLE .
At 8 , A. M t. i. Cold by Hygro8 A. * Air .
Water Difference .
, Refraction .
evaporation .
meter , 1800 .
Sept. i 57 69o 3 .
I 4 ' 72 Oct. 17 46349-3 3 72 22 38 49i2 : 13 67 Nov. i 41 445 ? ?
4i 8x8 76 4 4 : 4341 46i .
3 3-72 5 37 45 88 + : i 69 12 2 44-3 48 ? ?
2 4 ; i+32 73 13 4i ? ?
4413 41 '5 i 76 t8o1 .
June3 $o69+5 65 22i 55 6i 666+6 65 23 , 55 62 764 65 24F i 55 6i653 67 Sept. 86 64 472 78 9r 64 64t 53 74 6o 4 64i4 74 10o 58 64:6 72 70 12 o clock , 10 6 64 i , t 4 ' 10 From a review of the preceding Table it will be found , upon the whole , that when the water is warmer than the air , some increase of depression of the horizon may be expected ; but 7 that its quantity will be greatly influenced , and in general diminished , by dryness of the atmosphere .
It appears , however , that no observable regularity is deducible from the measures above given ; but that the quantity , on some occasions , is far different from what the states of the thermometer and hygrometer would indicate .
On the gth of September , for instance , the difference of temperature is only,3 , and the evaporation , to counteract this slight excess of warmth , produced as much as 3 ' of cold ; nevertheless , the refraction visible was full ' .
In this observation I think that I could not be mistaken , as the water was at the time perfectly calm , the air uncommonly clear , and I had leisure to pay particular attention to so unforeseen an occurrence .
This one instance appears conformable to the opinion entertained by Mr. HUDDART , and by M. MONGE , that , under some circumstances , the solution of water in the atmosphere causes a decrease in its refractive power ; but , on no other occasion have I been induced to draw a similar inference .
The object that I have at all times chosen , as showing best the quantity of refraction , has been either an oar dipped in the water at the greatest discernible distance , or some other line equally inclined ; and the angle measured has been , from the point where the inverted image is terminated by the water , to that part of the oar itself which appears to be directly above it .
( The apparent magnitude of ec , Fig. p , 3 .
) The eight first angles were taken with a mother-of-pearl micrometer in the principal focus of my telescope , and are not so much to be depended upon for accuracy as the succeeding eight .
These last were measured with a divided eye-glass micrometer , and consequently are not liable to any error from unsteadiness of the instrument or object .
From the foregoing observations we learn , that the quantity of refraction over the surface of water may be very considerable , where the land is near enough to influence the temperature of the air .
At sea , however , so great differences of temperature cannot be expected ; and the increase of dip caused by this variation of horizontal refraction , it is to be presumed , is not so great as in the confined course of a river ; but , if we consider that it may also be subject to an equal diminution from an opposite cause , and that the horizon may even become apparently elevated , there can be no question that the error in nautical observations , arising from a supposition that it is invariably according to the height of the observer , stands in need of correction .
The remedy employed by Mr. HUDDART , * of taking two angles of the sun from opposite points of the horizon at the same time , and considering the excess of their sum above 180o as double the dip , must without doubt be effectual ; but , from causes which he assigns , it is practicable only within certain limits of zenith distance ; for , where the zenith distance is small , and the changes of azimuth rapid , there is required considerable dexterity and steadiness of a single observer who attempts to turn in due time , from one observation to another ; and , when it exceeds o ?
, the greater angle cannot be measured with a sextant , and consequently his method is , with that instrument , of use only in low latitudes .
On account of the difficulty attending some of the adjustments for the back observation , he rejects that method for taking angles in general , with much reason ; but he has theeby overlooked a means of determining the dip , which I am inclined to think might be employed with advantage in all latitudes , without any occasion to hurry the most inexperienced or cautious observer .
By the back observation , the whole vertical angle between any two opposite points of the horizon may be measured at once , either before or after taking an altitude .
Half the excess of this angle above 180o , should of course be the dip required .
But , if it be doubtful whether the instrument is duly adjusted , a second observation becomes necessary .
The instrument must be reversed , and , if the apparent deficiency of the opposite angle from 18oo be not equal to the excess before obtained , the index error may then be corrected accordingly ; and , since the want of adjustment , either of the glasses at right angles to the plane of the instrument , or of the line of sight parallel to it , will affect both the larger and smaller angle very nearly in an equal degree , the 4 part of their difference will be extremely near the truth , and the errors arising from want of those adjustments may with safety be neglected .
This method of correcting the index error for the back observation at sea , was many years since recommended by Mr. LUDLAM ; * yet I do not find that it has been noticed by subsequent writers on that subject , or suggested by any one for determining the dip ; but I can discover no reason for which it could be rejected as fallacious , and I should hope that in practice it would be found convenient , since in theory it appears to be effectual .
The most obvious objection to this , as well as to Mr. HUDDART'S 11 method , is the possibility that the refraction may be in some measure different in opposite points of the horizon at the same time .
When land is at no great distance , such an inequality may be found to occur ; but , upon the surface of the ocean in general , any partial variations of temperature can rarely be supposed to exist ; and it is probable , that under any circumstances , the difference will not bear any considerable proportion to the whole refraction ; nor can it be thought a sufficient reason for rejecting one correction proposed , that there may yet remain other smaller errors , to which all methods are equally liable , but which it is not the object of the present dissertation to rectify .
PHILOSOPHICAL TRANS ACT ION S. I. The Bakerian Lecture .
Observations on tide Quantity of horizontal Refraction ; Xwith a QMethod of measuring the Dip at Sea By William Hyde Wollaston , M. D. F. R. S. Read November i , 1802 .
IN a Paper which I some time since presented to this Society , ( printed in the Phil. Trans. for 180o , ) I endeavoured to ascertain the causes , and to explain the various cases , of horizontal refraction , which I had either observed myself , or had seen described by others .
At the time of writing that essay , I had not met with the Memoires sir l'Egypte , published but a short time before ; and I was not aware that an account had been given by M. MONGE , of the phenomenon known to the French by the name of mirage , which their army had daily opportunities of seeing , in their march through the deserts of Egypt .
In the perusal of this memoir , I could not fail to derive instruction from the information it contained ; but , as the facts related by him accord entirely with the theory that I had advanced , I was by no means induced to adopt the explanation that he has proposed , in preference to my own .
The definite reflecting surface which he supposes to take place between two strata of air of different density , is by'no means consistent with that continued ascent of rarefied air which he himself admits ; and the explanation founded on this hypothesis iwill not apply to other cases , which may all be satisfactorily accounted for , upon the supposition of a gradual change of density , and successive curvature of the rays of light by refraction .
I have since learned that the same subject had also been ably treated by Mr. WOLTMAN , in GILBERT'S Annalen der Physik ; but I have to regret that his dissertation , as well as that of GRUBER , in the same Annals , were written in a language that was unknown to me , and that I could not avail myself of the assistance that I might otherwise have received from their researches .
When I formerly engaged in this inquiry , being impressed with the advantage to be derived from it to nautical astronomy , on account of the variations in the dip of the apparent horizon , from which all observations of altitude at sea must necessarily be taken , I suggested the expediency of a series of observations , to be made by a person attentive to those changes of temperature or moisture of the atmosphere , on which he might find the depression of his horizon principally to depend .
I had at that time no expectation that I could myself pursue this subject farther to any useful purpose , having little prospect of residing for a sufficient length of time in view of the sea , and seeing no other method by which the same end might be accomplished .
I have , however , since that time , found means to satisfy myself , by observations over the surface of the Thames , that although the quantity of refraction varies in general with any change of

