PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS .
XII .
On double Images caused by atmospherical Rejraction .
By William Hyde Wollaston , M. D. F. R. S. Read March E , 18oo .
IN some of the last volumes of the Philosophical Transactions , there have been related many instances of strong atmospherical refraction , by which , objects seen near the horizon have appeared inverted , and the horizon itself either elevated or depressed .
Mr. HUDDART first took notice of a distinct image , inverted , beneath the object itself ; and , in the Philosophical Transactions for 1797 , has described several such appearances , accompanied with an optical explanation , wherein he shows , that the-lowest strata of the air were at the time endued with a weaker refractive power , than others at a small elevation .
In the volume for 1799 , Mr. VINCE has given an instance ( Tab. I. Fig. 1 .
) where erect , as well as inverted images were visible above , instead of beneath , the objects themselves ; and , by tracing the progress of the rays of light , in a manner similar to Mr. HUDDART'S , concludes that these phenomena arose from s " unusual variations " of increasing density in the lower strata of the atmosphere .
In the volume for 1795 , Mr. DALBY mentions having seen " the top of a hill appear detached , for the sky was seen under ( r it .
" In this case , as well as in the preceding , it is probable that inversion took place , and that the lower half of the portion detached was an inverted image of the upper , as the sky could not be seen beneath it , but by an inverted course of the rays .
Since the causes of these peculiarities of terrestrial refraction have not received so full an explanation as might be wished , I have endeavoured , ist .
To investigate theoretically the successive variations of increasing or decreasing density to which fluids in general are liable , and the laws of the refractions occasioned by them .
2dly .
To illustrate and confirm the truth of this theory , by experiments with fluids of known density .
And lastly , to ascertain , by trial upon the air itself , the .
causes and extent of those variations of its refractive density , on which the inversions of objects , and other phenomenon observed , appear to depend .
The general laws may be comprised in three propositions .
Prop. i. If the density of any medium varies by parallel indefinitely thin strata , any rays of light moving through it in the direction of the strata , will be made to deviate during their passage , and their deviations , will be in proportion to the increments of density where they pass .
For each ray will-be bent towards the denser strata , by a refracting forc2 proportioned to the difference of the densities abojve and below the line of its passage ; and , as their velocities are the same , and therefore the times of action of the forces equal , the deviations will be as the refracting forces , i. e. as the increments of density .
Prop. ir .
When two fluids .
of unequal density are brought into contact , and unite by mutual penetration ; if the densities at different heights be expressed by ordinates , the curve which terminates these ordinates will have a point of contrary flexure .
For the straight lines da , rn , ( Plate IX .
) Fig. i. which terminate the ordinates rx , die , of uniform density , will be parallel , and , if not united by contrary curvature , some straight line of union , as ao , must be supposed .
But , from whatever cause the first line ao is inferred , by the same cause other intermediate lines mp , tq , &amp;c. will be produced , and curves defm , mtsr , will be ultimately formed , having a point of contrary flexure atm .
The form of the curve does not appear to admit of accurate investigation , nor is it of importance to the subsequent reason .
ing , if wholly unknown .
We may , however , form some judgment of its nature ; for , whether the densities depend on different specific gravities of different fluids , or on unequal temperatures of different portions of the same fluid , the curves will be nearly alike .
In each of these cases , to whatever small distance pc , Fig. 2 , the mutual attraction is sufficient to occasion intimate union of the fluids , the density mn of the mixture will be an arithmetic mean ; and , for the same reason , at any intermediate smaller distances , there will be a series of arithmetic means of , gh , &amp;c. interposed , and the line a o , uniting the ordinates , will be straight .
By progressive effect of this attraction , and successive interpolations , inFig .
i , curves defi , rs tim , will be formed , of whe-h the straight lines mp , tq , &amp;c. are tangents .
Ii 7 The attracting distances np , o q , &amp;c. are subtangents ; and , if it be admitted that these are every where -equal , the curves so produced are logarithmic , and the increment of the ordinate greatest at rn , where they meet .
Prop. iIi .
If parallel rays pass through a medium varying according to the preceding proposition , those above the point of contrary flexure will be made to diverge , and those below the same point will converge , after their passage through it .
For , since the deviation of each ray depends on the increment of density where it passes , and since the increment of density is greatest at the point of contrary flexure , any rays , as ab , Fig. 3 , passing near to that point , will be refracted more towards the denser medium than those at cd , which move in a higher stratum , and will diverge from them , but will be refracted towards and meet those at of , which pass nearer to the denser medium , where the increments of density are also less .
Cor. Hence , adjacent portions of the converging rays will form a focus , beyond which they will diverge again ; and the varied medium will produce effects similar to those caused by a medium of uniform density* having a surface similar to the curve of densities , since convergence or divergence will be produced , according as the curve of densities is convex or concave ; consequently , by tracing backwards , to the extremities of an object , the progress of the visual rays , ( or axes of the pencils received by the3 eye , ) it will be manifest that , Any object seen through the inclined concave part rm , Fig. 5 .
would appear elevated , erect , and somewhat diminished .
An object seen through md , where it is convex and inclined , .
would be elevated ; and , if situated beyond the focus of visual rays from the eye , it would appear inverted .
The magnitude would depend on the relative distances of the eye and object .
Below the point d , where the curve terminates , vision would be direct , so that an object might be situated so as to be seen in all three ways at the same time , direct at 0 , inverted at 1 , and erect again at A. I consider the foregoing propositions as applicable to all cases of varying density , whether occasioned by mutual solution of different fluids , or partial rarefaction of the same fluid .
; and , by trial of various fluids , however different in density , or even in viscidity , I find that the refractions observe a law agreeable to the theory , as will appear .
by the following experiments .
Experiment i. Into a square phial containing a small quantity of clear syrup , I put about an equal quantity of water , in such a way that it floated on the surface of the syrup , without mixing .
For a short time , the stratum of union was so thin that nothing could be distinctly seen through it .
But soon , by mutUal penetration of the water and the syrup , theeffects represented at A , Fig. 6 , were produced .
Through the syrup , a word written on a card placed behind was seen erect , and .
in its place ; through the adjacent variable medium , an inverted image was visible above the true place ; and also , above that , a second image of the same object appeared erect .
When these appearances are first discernible , the variations of density are so great , that the object to be looked at may be in contact with the phial ; but , when the variations of density become more gradual , and thereby the focus more distant , any object so near is only elongated , and requires to be removed an inch or two , to be seen inverted .
Exper .
2 .
Over the surface of the water , in the same phial , I next put about the same measure of rectified spirit of wine .
At the stratum where the water and spirit united , the appearances were the same ; but , since the refractive power of spirit exceeds that of water , the true place of the object was seen uppermost ; the inverted and erect images are below .
Fig. 6 , B. When an oblique line der is viewed through any variable medium so made , it appears bent into different forms , according to its situation with respect to focal distance .
If it be at the distance of the principal focus , one point of it is dilated into a vertical line , as Im. Fig. 7 , A. If beyond that focus , the portion Im is inclined backwards , being an inverted image of dl ; and mn is another image of the same portion seen erect .
Fig. 7 , B. On this account , it becomes a convenient object for ascertaining the state of any medium under examination .
In these experiments , the appearances continue many hours , even with spirit of wine ; with syrup , two or three days ; with acid of vitriol , four or five ; with a solution of gum arabic , much longer ; but , although their disposition to unite is so different , the appearances produced are nevertheless the same in all .
The refraction is greatest nearly in the plain of original contact of the fluids , diminishing from thence both upwards and downwards .
The exact rate of diminution above or below this point , I had no means of measuring , with the accuracy that would be requisite for determining the nature of the curves of density formed according to the first proposition .
But the truth of the second proposition appeared capable of confirmation by experiment ; for the deviation of a ray is there said to depend on the increment of density , and time of the ray 's passage , jointly ; accordingly , the deviation caused by a given increment should be in proportion to the extent of the medium .
In order to try what effect a greater extent of medium would produce , Exper .
3 .
I made a rectangular glass vessel , of which the sides were in the ratio of lo to 30,6 ; and , having put into it some clear syrup , with water on its surface , I measured the greatest refractions through it in both directions , and found them in the ratio of lo to about 29 .
In another vessel , of which the sides were as 1o to 40,4 , .
the refractions were , on an average , as 1 to 4 .
Being now fully satisfied of the effict of different fluids , I made the following experiment , whereby it appears , that the variations of density occasioned by difference of temperature between adjacent strata of the sa'me fluid , follow a similar law .
Exper .
4 .
Having put some cold water into a square vessel , I covered its surface with a piece of writing paper perforated with a few small holes , and then filled the vessel cautiously with boiling water .
The paper nearly prevented any mixture of the hot and cold water ; but , by floating gradually -up , left them to communicate their heat by contact alone .
While they were in this state , I examined the appearance of remote objects through the varied medium , and found , that when my eye was removed four or five feet from the vessel , the effects were the same as in the preceding experiments with different fluids ; above any object viewed through the coldwater , I could distinguish two images of it , the one inverted , the other erect , as usual ; but these appearances did not continue more than five or six minutes .
Having thus established , by experiments sufficiently varied , that the contiguity of two fluids of unequal , density is capable of occasioning all the appearances that have been observed , I shall proceed to show by what means the air may be made to exhibit similar phenomena .
Exper .
r. I heated a common poker red-hot , and held it so as to look along the side of it , at a paper lo or 92 feet distant .
The rarefaction occasioned by it caused a -perceptible refraction , to the distance of about -8 of an inch from the side of the poker .
A letter seen more distant from it appeared as usual ; within that distance there was a faint image of it reversed ; and still nearer to the poker was a second image direct , and as distinct as the object itself , but somewhat smaller , as in Fig. 8 , in which a section of the atmosphere surrounding the poker is represented .
At the bottom and sides it -is nearly circular ; but upwards the circular form is lost in undulations , occasioned by the rapid ascent of the rarefied air .
The greatest deviation produced in this case measured about _a degree .
Exper .
6 .
By a red-hot bar of iron , So inches long , the refractions were much greater , the extreme deviations amounting to full '4 degree .
The refractions observed in these experiments may , at first view , be thought greater than could be caused by difference of temperature alone , being in one instance more than double thegreatest horizontal refraction of the heavenly bodies ; in which case , as the rays enter from a -vacuum , the greatest possible effect of the atmosphere might be expected .
But it must be remembered , that when a star appears in the horizon , its rays intersect the superior strata of the atmosphere at an inclination of several degrees , and that they pass but once through the variations from rarity to density ; but , on the contrary , that in the experiments with red-hot iron , the rays may pass actually in the direction of the strata , and that they are refracted , not only by their entrance from the denser into the rarer medium , but the effect is doubled , since the refraction caused by their emergence is equal to that produced by their incidence .
Although a stratum of air , heated by these means to so great a degree , affords an erect , as well as an inverted , image of objects seen through it , the more moderate warmth communicated to it from bodies heated by the action of the sun upon them seems insufficient to produce both images ; but the in .
verted image may generally be seen , when the sun shines upon a brick wall , or other darker-coloured surface .
While the eye of the observer is placed nearly in a line with the wall , if another person , at 3o or 40 yards distance , extends any object towards the wall , an image similar to it will appear to come out to meet it .
It would be difficult to ascertain with accuracy the degree of rarefaction capable of showing this appearance , but it may be of some use to future observers , to mention the different degrees of heat which I observed .
In one instance , a thermometer in contact with the wall , stood at 960 ; but , at 3 of an inch distance , 82 % ' .
One morning , when the sun shone bright , I examined the temperaturesand refraction -produced at the surface of a deal bar painted green , about 8 feet long .
A small thermometer in contact with the bar , rose to 960 ; at 4 of an inch distance , it stood at 73* .
The refraction at the same time exceeded 2o minutes .
To explain why red-hot iron occasions two images , while solar heat produces but one , I imagine that the intense heat in the former case rarefies the air for some small distance uniformly , and thereby affords the same series of variations as between other fluids of uniform density- ; but that , in the latter , the heat is conveyed off as fast as it is generated ; so that , as there is no extent of medium uniformly rare , the densities corresponding to the concave portion rm , Fig. 5 .
of the curve before described do not take place , but the phenomenon occasioned by the convex part md are alone produced .
It must be remarked , that the vertical position of the surface contributes greatly to increase the effect ; for , since the heated -air rises in the direction of the surface , its ascent has in this case no tendency to blend it with the adjacent denser strata , and hence very different degrees of density take place in the thickness of 4 of an inch ; so that , as the increments of density are great , the refractions will be proportionally so ; but , -where the heated surface is horizontal , the ascent of the rarefied air into the superincumbent denser strata renders the variations far more gradual ; consequently , a heated surface of far greater extent must be requisite , to produce equal refraction .
However , over extensive plains , when the sun shines , some degree of inversion is very frequently to be seen but the inverted images are rarely well defined , unless over a very even surface .
One of the best situations for this purpose , is over a level open road , with a gentle breeze blowing across it .
A current offair brings a cool stratum more closely in contact with the heated surface ; and , since refraction depends on the increment or difference of density in a given small space , a very moderate breeze will thereby render inversion more perceptibl-e ; but a strong wind will reduce the temperature of the surface , and may make the heated stratum too thin for any object to be seen through it from a distance .
In one instance , when I saw a refraction of about 9 minutes , at the distance of 3 of a mile , a thermometer in the sand was io01 ; at 4 inches above , 820 , and , at i foot above , 76g .
Over water , the evenness of the surface is favourable to the production of such appearances ; but , since the action of the sun is weak on a body so transparent , a far greater extent of surface is requisite to produce any perceptible inversion .
Being at Bognor one bright morning , when the sea was calm , I had an opportunity of observing the appearance of Selsea Bill , about 6 miles distant .
The whole extent of coast , when viewed with a pocket telescope magnifying about i6 times , appeared inverted from one end to the other ; and the lower part of a brick house upon the shore , was seen as distinct as the house itself .
I judged the quantity of refraction , in this case , to be about 2 minutes of a degree .
This state of atmosphere appears to be not very uncommon ; for , at Shanklin Chine , in the Isle of Wight , a few days preceding , similar appearances were visible in several directions , but I neglected to make any estimate of the quantity of rev fraction .
In the instance of the inverted vessel seen by Mr. HUDPART , ( Phil. Trans. for in'p7 , Tab. 1 .
Fig. A. ) at the distance of 8 miles , the refraction seems to have been about a ' .
All the appearances described by him , I am inclined to think , arose from difference of temperature alone .
He offers a con. .
jecture , that evaporation might occasion the lower strata of the atmosphere to have a -weaker refractive power ; but , from the following experiments , it seems to have a contrary effect .
Exper .
7 .
1 took a plate of glass , and , while I looked along the surface , I poured upon it a small quantity of ether .
A line upon the opposite wall , appeared instantaneously elevated many minutes , and at times above 2a degree .
This fluid being the most volatile , and most soluble in the atmosphere , of any known liquid , produces the greatest effect ; since the cold , during evaporation , conspires with the ether dis-0 solved in the air , to increase the refractive power .
Rectified spirit of wine also produces , from the same cause , a very considerable effect .
Exper .
8 .
By moistening a board , A feet in length , with alcohol , and observing the elevation of an object viewed over its surface , I found the refraction to be about 15 ' .
Exper .
9 .
I next made a similar experiment with water itself .
Of this , the effect was barely visible , when tried in the same way ; but , by means of a surface of io feet , and by viewing a luminous point at a greater distance , the refraction became evident , and the object elevated above 3 minutes .
In the course of these experiments , I tried whether confining the saturated atmosphere , by boards.on each side , would vary the effect , and found the refraction in all cases much lessened ; and , when water was used , it became imperceptible ; but , as soon as the boards were removed , and a free current allowed to pass across , the full effect was again produced .
The reason of this difference appears to -be , that the quicker evaporation increases the degree of cold , and the current brings greater differences of density contiguous .
This state of rapid evaporation will fully account forth phaxnomenon witnessed by Mr. LATHAM , who has described ( in the Phil. Trans. for 1796 , p. 357 ) an extraordinary eleva .
tion of the opposite coast of France , so as to be seen from the beach at Hastings , and other parts of Sussex .
There is a fact of the same kind stated by DE LA LAND , ( Astron. Tom. II .
) who says that the mountains of Corsica ( though at the distance of more than loo miles ) are occasionally visible from Genoa .
It is probably owing to the same cause , that other objects fhave been sometimes seen , at such distances that we should expect them to be intercepted by the curvature of the earth ; for it is evident , that whenever the evaporation over each mile of surface occasions a refraction of about i minute , the rays receive a curvature equal to that of the ocean , so that its surface will appear flat , and the spherical form of the earth will not obstruct horizontal vision of objects at any distance , .
It still remained to explain the phenomena seen by Mr. VINCE , as I had not hitherto made an atmosphere capable of exhibiting images inverted , as well as elevated , by increased density .
For , in the refractions produced in the 7th , 8th , and 9th experiments , by evaporation at an exposed surface , I ; observed the effect was always greatest in contact with the evaporating surface ; any lower point a , Fig. , appeared brought nearer to a higher point c , by the pencil of rays from-a being more refracted at b , than the pencil from c was refracted at d. Therefore , any rays passing from the eye at e , as a point , through b and d , would be made to diverge to a and c ; consequently , visual rays could not , under these circumstances , intersect each other , and no objects could appear inverted .
But , whenever the lowest strata of the air become saturated with moisture , the variations between the saturated stratum and the incumbent atmosphere of the common density , will follow a law similar to what is found at the confines of other fluids of unequal density ; hence , inversion will become visible as there will be a point below which the increment of density will decrease , and where the refractions will consequently be less , although through a denser medium .
Exper .
10 .
To produce these appearances , I procured a trough of thin deal , , feet long , 1 inch wide , with sides 2 inches high , and closed the extremities of it with glass .
A section of it is given in Fig. 0o .
When the bottom was wetted with ether , the greatest refraction was , at intervals , more than.4 of an inch from the bottom of the trough ; and , beneath this height , I saw a second image inverted , when my eye was removed to 14 or At feet distance , and the object at about 70 feet .
The focus seemed at the same time to be about 9 feet distant .
There was not depth enough of uniformly saturated atmosphere for the object itself to be seen through it , but its true place , compared with that of the images , is represented at a. Exper .
a i. When I made use of rectified spirit in the same apparatus , I had also sufficient proof that the laws of evapora- .
tion would admit of such appearances being produced ; for the same object now appeared curved downwards , as in Fig. ii , so that rays nearer to the bottom were manifestly less refracted than such as passed at some distance above .
A degree of convergency must therefore have been produced , although the distance at which the rays would meet , was beyond that of my eye , and circumstances would not admit of my removing beyond 5 feet .
The evaporation of water coult not be expected to produce any sensible effect of this kind , in so short a space .
-.but , in a view of some miles extent , there can be no doubt , from the foregoing experiments , that evaporation from the surface of the sea , ind such a state of the atmosphere as would allow the lower strata to be saturated , is capable of occasioning all the phenomena which have been described , and probably was the cause of those which Mr. VINCE observed .
Since heat alone tends to depress objects , and evaporation produces apparent elevation , it is probable , that in the instance of refraction related by Mr. DALBY , ( Phil. Trans. for i79 , p. $87 ) , the heat of the sun was the principal agent , and that the moisture rather tended to counteract than assist its action .
Simple inversion may generally be seen , when the sun shines upon a dry even road of A or j mile extent ; but , when the ground has been wet , I have very rarely seen it , and have even failed of discerning it , when the heat has been sufficient to raise a steam from the ground .
The following experiment shows that it is not to be expected but by very great extent of surface .
Exper .
12 .
I placed a dark-coloured board in the sunshine and , having examined the refraction along its surface , I made a wet line along it , with a sponge dipped in boiling water .
Notwithstanding this additional heat , the refraction , in the direction of the wet line , was far less than over the rest of the board , although I took care to observe the effect , before the surface could be cooled again by evaporation .
I should therefore expect the depression of the horizon at sea , where the refraction occasioned ' by heat must always be cou-nteracted by evaporation , never to excedx a few minutes ; and that any one in a situation commanding a view of the sea , by attention to the various degrees of the dip of the horizon under different circumstances , might soon form some estimate of the proper allowance to be made , for brightness of the sun at the time of an-astronomical observation , or for difference of temperature between the sea and air .
Having now examined the several peculiarities of refraction which I proposed for consideration , I shall , in few words , recapitulate the purport of the foregoing pages , According tot the theory here given , there appear to he two opposite states of the atmosphere , either of which may occasion objects to be seen doubled or tripled , since both increase and decrease of its density , when partial , produce similar effects .
It has been explained , 1st .
Why air heated by the moderate warmth of the sun 's rays , occasions objects to appear doubled and inverted .
2dly .
Why rarefaction , by a higher degree of heat , gives an additional image , which is -not inverted .
3dly .
In what state of evaporation the increase of the air 's density brings distant objects into view by unusual elevation .
4thly .
Under what circumstances evaporation may also produce an inverted image less elevated .
And it is probable , that the same reasoning will afford a ready explanation to other varieties of terrestrial refraction , that may have been , or may hereafter be observed .
4 4 ' co 62 =2 = d } rn / a-----__~~~~------iT at I 4.II~~ &lt; X 57 -2 - ; -h Xh ii ~ 124}\_j l '8 )t '- !
$\i\\dl s. i\\ g !
xed .
, \\\1('A~ pok , , , -r l~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~C C. -lz &amp; IX IC -- ' ' .
, A le ' IX X~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-------I/ 2 =X 6Adas __ _i___ d = , e -I / / 't 1I _ , ---X'''t , ,_ _ _at_ S ... ----2 Ct~I __ , l- ! !
=_ g ___ __ ____ ... ..I.Il ... .
L. 1 pj~~~~gU~~~t,0 Stem/ t~~~~~~~t ' -|FI -44 A Ii ' ________ 24 __ 2 ci ___ -C &lt; K cc cc

