VII .
Outlines of Experiments and fnquiries respecting Soun4 and Light .
By Thomas Young , M. D. F. R. S. In a Letter to Edward Whitaker Gray , M. D. Sec. R. S. Read January 36 , 18oo .
DEAR SIR , IT has long been my intention to lay before the Royal Society a few observations on the subject of sound ; and I have endeavoured to collect as much information , and to make as many experiments , connected with this inquiry , as circumstances enabled me to do ; but , the further I have proceeded , the more widely the prospect of what Iay before me has been extended ; and , as I find that the investigation , in all its magnitude , will occupy the leisure hours of some years , or perhaps of a life , I am determined , in the mean time , lest any unforeseen circumstances should prevent my continuing the pursuit , to submit to the Society some conclusions which I have already formed from the results of various experiments .
Their subjects are , I. The measurement of the quantity of air discharged through an aperture .
II .
The determination of the direction and velocity of a stream of air proceeding from an orifice .
III .
Ocular evidence of the nature of sound .
IV .
The velocity of sound .
V. Sonorous cavities .
VI .
The degree of divergence of sound .
VII .
The decay of sound .
VIII .
The harmonic sounds of pipes .
IX .
The vibrations of different elastic fluids .
X. The analogy between light and sound .
XI .
The coalescence of musical sounds .
XII .
The frequency of vibrations constituting a given note .
XIII .
The vibrations of chords .
XIV .
The vibrations of rods and plates .
XV .
The human voice .
XVI._ The temperament of musical intervals .
I. Of the Quantity of Air discharged through an Aperture .
A piece of bladder was tied over the end of the tube of a large glass funnel , and punctured with a hot needle .
The funnel was inverted in a vessel of water ; and a gage , with a graduated glass tube , was so placed as to measure the pressure occasioned by the different levels of the surfaces of the water .
As the air escaped through the puncture , it was supplied by a phial of known dimensions , at equal intervals of time ; and , according to the frequency of this supply , the average height of the gage was such as is expressed in the first Table .
It appears , that the quantity of air discharged by a given aperture , was nearly in the subduplicate ratio of the pressure , ; and that the ratio of the expenditures by different apertures , with the same pressure , lay between the ratio of their diameters and that of their areas .
The second , third , and fourth Tables show the result of similar experiments , made with some variations in the apparatus .
It may be inferred , from comparing the experiments on a tube with those on a simple perforation , that the expenditure is increased as in water , by the application of a short pipe .
P1 Table .
is th are IcA is the area , in square in ches , of an ABC aperture nearly circular .
B , the pressure in inches .
C , the number of cubic inches.oooi8.25 3.9.00018 '.58 11.7 discharged in one minute..00 o.0lo4s 56 7.8 All numbers throughout this paper,.001 j.2 15.6 where the contrary is not expressed , are.001.7 31.2 to be understood of inches , linear , square,.004.35 6.8 004 4 or cubic .
Table it .
A is the area of the section of a tube IL_ _____ : about two inches long .
B , the pressure..07 1 .
2000 .
C , the quantity of air discharged in a mi.07 -2 .
j2900 .
nute , by estimation .
Table ii .
ABCDA ' is the area of the section of a.oo64 1.15.2 46.8 tube .
B , its length .
C , the pressure..0064 10..4 46.8 D , the discharge in a minute..o0064 13.5.35 31.2.oo64 13.5.7 46.8 Table Iv .
A is the area of an oval apetture , formed ABC by flattening a glass tube at the end : its dia.846 meters were 4025'and.152 .
B , the pressure .
01 ~~C , the discharge .
II .
Of the Direction and Velocity of a Strewn of Air .
An apparatus was contrived for measuring , by means of a water-gage communicating with a reservoir of air , the pressure by which a current was forced from the reservoir through a cylindrical tube ; and the gage was so sensible , that , a regular blast being supplied from the lungs , it showed the slight varia-f tlon produced by every pulsation of the heart .
The current of air issuing from the tube was directed downwards , upon a white plate , on which a scale of equal parts was engraved , and which was thinly covered with a coloured liquid ; the breadth of the surface of the plate laid bare was observed at different distances from the tube , and with different degrees of pressure , care being taken that the liquid should be so shallow as to yield to the slightest impression of air .
The results are collected in Tables v. and vi .
and are exhibited to the eye in Plate Ill. Figs. iAcei 2 .
In order to measure with greater certainty and precision , the velocity of every part of the current , a second cavity , furriished with a gage , was provided , and pieces perforated with apertures of different sizes were adapted to its orifice : the axis of the current was directed as accurately as possible to the centres of these apertures , and the result of the experiments , with various pressures and distances , are inserted in Tables vii .
viii .
and ix .
The velocity of a stream being , both according to the commonly received opinion and to the experiments already related , nearly in the subduplicate ratio of the pressure occasioning it , it was inferred , that an equal pressure would be required to stop its progress , and that the velocity of the current , where it struck against the aperture , must be in the subduplicate ratio of the pressure marked by the gage .
The ordinates of the curves in Fig. 13-23 , were therefore taken reciprocally in the subduplicate ratio of the pressure marked by the second gage to that indicated by the first , at the various distances represented by the abscisses .
Each figure represents a different degree of pressure in the first cavity .
The curve nearest the axis , is deduced from observations in which .
the aperture opposed to the tube was not greater than that of the tube itself ; and shows wlat would he the diameter of the current , if the velocities of every one of its particles in the same circular section , including those of the contiguous air , which must have acquired as much motion as the current has lost , were equal among themselves .
As the central particles must be supposed to be less impeded in their motion than the superficial ones , of course , the smaller the aperture opposed to the centre of the current , the greater the velocity ought to come out , and the ordinate of the curve the smaller ; but , where the aperture was not greater than that of the tube , the difference of the .
-velocities at the same distance was scarcely perceptible .
When the aperture was larger than that of the tube , if the distance was very small , of course , the average velocity came out much smaller than that which was inferred from a smaller aperture ; but , where the ordinate of the internal curve became nearly equal to thisaperture , there was but little difference between the velocities indicated , with different apertures .
Indeed , in some cases , a larger aperture seemed to indicate a greater velocity : this might have arisen in some degree from the smaller aperture not having been exactly in the centre of the current ; but there isgreater reason to suppose , that it was occa .
sioned by some resistance derived from the air returning between the sides of the aperture and the current entering it .
Where l. this took place , the external curves , which are so constructed as that their ordinates -are reciprocally in the subduplicate ratio of the pressure observed in the second cavity , with apertures equal in semidiameter to their initial ordinate , approach , ,for a short distance , nearer to the axis than the internal curve : after this , the ) continue their course very near to this curve .
H Hence it appears , thatno observable part of the motion diverged beyond the limits of the solid which would be formed by the revolution of the internal curve , which is seldom inclined to the axis in an angle so great as ten degrees .
A similar conclusion may be made , from observing the flame of a candle subjected to the action of a blowpipe : there is -no divergency beyond the narrow limits.of the current ; the flame , on the contrary , is every -where forced by the ambient air towards the current , to supply the place of that which it has carried away by its friction .
The lateral communication of motion , very ingeniously and accurately observed in water by Professor VENTU1RI , is exactly similar to the motion here shown to take place In air and these experiments fully justify him in rejecting the tenacity of water as its cause : no doubt it arises from the relative situation of the particles of the fluid , in the line of the current , to that of the particles in the contiguous strata , which is such as naturally to lead to as communication of motion nearly in --a parallel direction ; and this may properly be termed friction .
The lateral pressure which urges the flame of a candle towards the stream of air from a blowpipe , is probably -exactly similar to that pressure which causes the inflection of a current of air near an obstacle .
Mark the dimple which a slender stream of air makes on the surface of water ; bring a convex body into contact with the side of the stream , and the place of the dimple will immediately show that the current is inflected towards the body ; and , if the body be at liberty to move in every direction , it will be urged towards the current , in the same manner as , in VENTURI'S experiments , a fluid was forced up a tube inserted into the side of a pipe through which water was flowing .
A similar interposition of an obstacle in the course of the wind , is probably often the cause of smoky chimneys .
One circumstance was observed in these experiments , which it is extremely difficult to explain , and which yet leads to very important consequences : it may be made distinctly perceptible to the eye , by forcing a current of smoke very gently through a fine tube .
When the velocity is as small as possible , the stream proceeds for many inches without any observable dilatation ; it then immediately diverges at a considerable angle into a cone , Plate IV .
Fig. s4 ; and , at the point of divergency , there is an audible and even visible vibration .
The blowpipe also affords a method of observing this phenomenon : as far as can be judged from the motion of the flame , , the current seems to make something like arevolution in the surface of the cone , but this motion is too rapid to be distinctly discerned .
When the pressure is increased , the apex of the cone approaches nearer to the orifice of the tube , Figs. s5 , s6 ; but no degree of pressure seems materially to alter its divergency .
The distance of the apex from the orifice , is not proportional to the diameter of the current ; it rather appears to be the greater the smaller the current , and is much better defined in a small current than in a large one .
Its distance in one experiment is expressed in Table x , from observations on the surface of a liquid ; in other experiments its respective distances were sometimes considerably less with the same degrees of pressure .
It maybe inferred , from the nunbers of Tablesvii and vii rI .
that in several instances a greater height of the first gage produced a less height of the second : this arose from the nearer approach of the apex of the cone to the orifice of the tube , the stream losing a greater portion of its velocity by this divergence than it gained by the increase of pressure .
At first sight , the form of the current bears some resemblance to the vena contracta of a jet of water : but VENTURI has observed , that in water an increase of pressure increases , instead of diminishing , the distance of the contracted section from the orifice .
Is it not possible , that the facility with which some spiders are said to project their fine threads to a great distance , may depend upon the small degree of velocity with which they are thrown out , so that , like a minute current , meeting with little interruptior from the neighbouring air , they easily continue their course for a considerable time ?
Table v. A 1 .
2 .
31 3.8 BCC 1..1.1 The diameter of the tube.o7 .
2..12.12.2 A is the distance of the liquid from 3l.17.25.3 the orifice .
B , the pressure .
C , 5 .
-25 S. the diameter of the surface of the 6..30.52 liquid displaced .
7..35.54 58 37..56 9..39.58 10X 40.6.6 i8..5o r1C0 .
___ Table vi:. .
Table vii .
AI z. A.5 BCC B.o0 65 1 .
*1.~ X Diameter of CDD 2..13 the tube , .
x. 3.2.2 A , B , and .
I.033 Diameter of the tube.o6 .
4 .
325.3.C2.i6 A is the distance of the op. .
6..3 4 C , as in.3.25 I. posite aperture , from the orifice 7..35 *5 Tab1t..4 *35 .
10..35.6 *5 45 of the tube .
B , the diameter of 15 -.35.7.6.53.2 the aperture .
C , the pressure , 20..35.7.7.6 indicated by the first gage .
D,.8 Sv the height of the second gage .
1.2 4.4 1.5.6 2..67.S5 4 .
1.3 I. 8 .
2 .
14..5 Table vii .
A,5 I. 2 .
4 .
B o6 IS.3.5.o6.*i5 3 5.o6.15.3 S. o6.I5.3.S CDDDDDDDDDDDDDD D.1.05.05.03.017.2 I.1.12 08.02.034.5.2.22.1.00 00 1I.32.36..*7 1.1.05.04 2..S z.6.2 8.22.2 1.08.07 3. .
8.9.3.4.36.3 12.12.1.I 4 , 1.1 I.Z.4.58.52.42 i6 8 I.I S.14 v5e I.15 5.8.68.5 2.2.23.2.I8.04.04.05 6 .
1.7.6 I. 83.63.2S.3.25.22.05.o5 o6 71.9.7 I.2 1..75 -3.35.3.z6.o6.o6.07 8 .
2.1.8 1.5 1.2.88.34.4.34.3.07.07.07 9 .
2.3.9 1.7 1.4 1..37.45.37.34.o8.o8.o8 l0 .
2 .
x. i.9 z.6 I._.4.5.4 *37.09.09.09 Diameter of the tube .
, i A , B , C , and D , as in Table vI i. Table ix .
Table x. A334 Diameter ABA is the pres .
-_ ' lo~ till _ of the tube sure .
B , the disB .
I.3.5 I. o6 1 *I5 i..o6.3 4 .
6 .
tance of the aC DDDDDDDD A,2 18 5 pexofthecone " _b _"-1 l.and D , as in X.8 I. from the orifice.5f.1.I.1 Table vI 2 .
* .
5 of a tube.x in I..2.2.2 4 .
2 .
'4.35 *34 I13 '1 1.125 3.6 5 -5 aS -15 i. 8 .
III .
Ocular Evidence of the Nature of Sound .
A tube about the tenth of an inch in diameter , with a lateral orifice half an inch from its end , filed rather deeper than the axis of the tube , Fig. 27 , was inserted at the apex of a conical -cavity containing about twenty cubic inches of air , and luted perfectly tight : by blowing through the tube , a sound nearly in unison with the tenor C was produced .
By gradually increasing the capacity of the cavity as far as several gallons , with the same mouth-piece , the sound , although faint , became more and more grave , till it was no longer a musical note .
Even before this period a kind of trembling was distinguishable ; and this , as the cavity was still further increased , was changed into a succession of distinct puffs , like the sound produced by an explosion of air from the lips ; as slow , in some instances , as 4 or 3 in a second .
These were undoubtedly the single vibrations , , which , when repeated with sufficient frequency , impress on the auditory nerve the sensation of a continued sound .
On forcing a current of smoke through the tube , the vibratory motion of the stream , as it passed out at the lateral orifice , was evident to the eye ; although , from various circumstances , the quantity and direction of its motion could not be subjected to 02 exact mensuration .
This species of sonorous cavity seems susceptible of but few harmonic sounds .
It was observed , that a faint blast produced a much greater frequency of vibrations than that which was appropriate to the cavity : a circumstance similar to this obtains also in large organ pipes ; but , several minute observations of this kind , although they might assist in forming a theory of the origin of vibrations or in confirming such a theory drawn from other sources , yet , as they are not alone sufficient to afford any general conclusions , are omitted at present , for the sake of brevity .
IV .
Of the Velocity of Sound .
It has been demonstrated , by M. DE LA GRANGE and others , that any impression whatever communicated to one particle of an elastic fluid , will be transmitted through that fluid with an uniform velocity , depending on the constitution of the fluid , without reference to any supposed laws of the continuation of that impression .
Their theorem for ascertaining this velocity is the same as NEWTON has deduced from the hypothesis of a particular law of continuation : but it must be confessed , that the result differs somewhat too widely from experiment , to give us full confidence in the perfection of the theory .
Corrected by the experiments of various observers , the velocity of any imripression transmitted by the common air , may , at an average , be reckoned 13o feet in a second .
V. Of sonorous Cavities .
M. DE LA GRANGE has also demonstrated , that all impressions are reflected by an obstacle terminating an elastic fluid , 'ith the same velocity with which they arrived at that obstacle , When the walls of a passage , or of an unfurnished room , are smooth and perfectly parallel , any explosion , or a stamping with the foot , communicates an impression to the air , which is reflected from one wall to the other , and from the second again towards the ear , nearly in the same direction with the primitive impulse : this takes place as frequently in a second , as double the breadth of the passage is contained in 1 130 feet ; and the ear receives a perception of a musical sound , thus determined in its pitch by the breadth of the passage .
On making the experiment , the result will be found accurately to agree with this explanation .
If the sound is predetermined , and the frequency of vibrations such as that each pulse , when doubly reflected , may coincide with the subsequent pulse proceeding directly from the sounding body , the intensity of the sound will be much increased by the reflection ; and also , in a less degree , if the reflected pulse coincides with the next but one , the next but two , or more , of the direct pulses .
The appropriate notes of a room may readily be discovered by singing the scale in it ; and they will be fQund to depend on the proportion of its length or breadth to 1 130 feet .
The sound of the stopped diapason pipes of an , organ is produced in a manner somewhat similar to the note from an explosion in a passage ; and that of its reed pipes to the resonance of the voice in a roomn : the length of the pipe in one case determining the sound , in the other , increasing its strength .
The frequency of the vibrations does not at all immediately depend on the diameter of the pipe .
It must be confessed , that much remains to be done in explaining the precise manner in which the vibration of the air in an organ pipe is generated .
Ma DANIEL BERNOULLI has solved several difficult problems relating to the subject ; yet some of his assumptions are not only gratuitous , but contrary to matter of fact .
VI .
Of the Divergence of Sound .
It has been generally asserted , chiefly on the authority of NEWTON , that if any sound be admitted through an aperture into a chamber , it will diverge from that aperture equally in all directions .
The chief arguments in favour of this opinion are deduced from considering the phenomenon of the pressure of fluids , and the motion of waves excited in a pool of water .
But the inference seems to be too hastily drawn : there is a very material difference between impulse and pressure ; and , in the case of waves of water , the moving force at each point is the power of gravity , which , acting primarily in a perpendicular direction , is only secondarily converted into a horizontal force , in the direction of the progress of the waves , being at each step disposed to spread equally in every direction : but the impulse transmitted by an elastic fluid , acts primarily in the direction of its progress .
It is well known , that if a person cjlls to another with a speaking trumpet , he points it towards the place where his hearer stands : and I am assured by a very respect-able Member of the Royal Society , that the report of a cannon appears many times louder to a person towards whom it is fired , than to one placed in a contrary direction .
It must have occurred to every one 's observation , that a sound such as that of a mill , or a fall of water , has appeared much louder after turning a corner , when the house or other obstacle no longer intervened ; and it has been already remarked by EULER , on this h1ead , that we are not acquainted with any substance perfectly impervious to sound .
Indeed , as M. LAMBERT has very truly asserted , the whole theory of the speaking trumpet , supported as it is by practical experience , would fall to the ground , if it were demonstrable that sound spreads equally in every direcc tion .
In windy weather it may often be observed , that the sound of a distant bell varies almost instantaneously in its strength , so as to appear at least twice as remote at one time as at another ; an observation which has also occurred to another gentleman who is uncommonly accurate in examining the phenomena of nature .
Now , if sound diverged equally in all directions , the variation produced by the wind could never exceed one-tenth of the apparent distance : but , on the supposition of a motion nearly rectilinear , it may easily happen that a slight change in the direction of the wind , miaay convey the sound , either directly or after reflection , in very different degrees of strength , to the same spot .
From the experiments on the motion of a current of air , already related , it would be expected that a sound , admitted at a considerable distance from its origin through an aperture , would proceed , with an almost imperceptible increase of divergence , in the same direction ; for , the actual velocity of the particles of air , in the strongest sound , is incomparably less than that of the slowest of the currents in the experiments related , where the beginning of the conical divergence took place at the greatest distance .
Dr. MATTHEW YOUNG has objected , not without reason , to M. HUBE , that the existence of a condensation will cause a divergence in sound : but a much greater degree of condensation must have existed in the currents described than in any sound .
There is indeed one difference between a stream of air and a sound ; that , in sound , the motions of different particles of air are not synchro ' nous : but it is not demonstrable that this circumstance would affect the divergency of the motion , except at the instant of its commencement , and perhaps not even then in a material degree ; for , in general , the motion is communicated with a very gradual increase of intensity .
The subject , however , deserves a more particular investigation ; and , in order to obtain a more solid foundation for the argument , it is proposed , as soon as circumstances permit , to institute a course of experi inents for ascertaining , as accurately as possible , the different strength of a sound once projected in a given direction , at dif , ferent distances from the axis of its motion .
VII .
Of the Decay of Sound .
Various opinions have been entertained respecting the decay of sound .
M. DE LA GRANGE has published a calculation , by which its force is shown to decay nearly in the simple ratio of the distances ; and M. DANIEL BERNOULLI'S equations for the sounds of conical pipes lead to a similar conclusion .
The same inference would follow from a completion of the reasoning of Dr. HELSHAM , Dr. MATTHEW YOUNG , and Professor VENTURI .
It has been very elegantly demonstrated by MACLAURIN , and may also be proved in a much more simple manner , that when motion is communicated through a series of elastic bodies increasing in magnitude , if the number of bodies be supposed infinitely great , and their difference infinitely small , the motion of the last will be to that of the first in the subduplicate ratio of their respective magnitudes , and since , in the case of concentric spherical laminate of air , the bulk increases in the duplicate ratio of the distance , the motion will in this case be directly , and the velocityinversely , as the distance .
But , however true this may be of the first impulse , it will appear , by pursuing the calculation a little further , that every one of the elastic bodies , except the last , receives an impulse in a retrograde direction , which ultimately impedes the effect of the succeeding impulse , as much as a similar cause promoted that of the preceding one : and thus as sound must be conceived to consist of an infinite number of impulses , the motion of the last lamina will be precisely equal to that of the first ; and , as far as this mode of reasoning goes , sound must decay in the duplicate ratio of the distance .
Hence it appears , that the proposal for adopting the logarithmic curve for the form of the speaking trumpet , was founded on fallacious reasoning .
The calculation of M. DE LA GRANGE is left for future examination ; and it is intended , in the mean time , to attempt to ascertain the decay of sound as nearly as possible by experiment : should the result favour the conclusions from that calculation , itwould establish a mrark-ed difference between the propagation of sound and of light .
VIII .
Of the harmonic Sounds of Ptpes .
In order to ascertain the velocity with which organ pipes of different lengths require to be supplied with air , according to the various appropriate sounds which they produce , a set of experiments was made , with the same mouth-piece , on pipes of the same bore , and of different lengths , both stopped and open .
The general result was , that a similar blast produced as niearly the same sound as the length of the pipes would permit ; or at least that the exceptions , though very numerous , lay equally on each side of this conclusion .
The particular results are expressed in Table xi .
and in Plate IV .
Fig. 28 .
They explain how a note may be made much louder on a wind instrument:1 MDccc. .
1 by a swell , than it can possibly be by a sudden impression of the blast .
It is proposed , at a future time , to ascertain by experiment , the actual compression of the air within the pipe under different circumstances : from some very slight trials , it seemed to be nearly in the ratio of the frequency of vibrations of each harmonic .
Table xi .
OPEN .
J STOPPED .
ABCDEFABCDEF --I----.-------4 5 0.7 8.8 d4 05.3 i.8 d1 4.1 8.8 2 1.2 1.7 10.0 3 5.0 9.0 5 9.4 0 .
3.1 0._9 fg o.8 8.o 2 9.4 0.2 04 f1 2.0 18.o 3 ?
i45.6 3 5.o 8.o 0o.o 4 1.1 1.6 8.5$ i6.5,8.o 5 7.0 8.o 7 19.0 20.0 6 16.1 o.4 o.6 d* 6.1 o0.4 10.0 g2 o.6 o.6s 1.1 5 o.8 1.0 21.2 3 0.9 1.1 2.4 7 1.2 2.2 4.7 4 1.6 2.4 4.9 9 2.2 4.7 11.5 5 2.5 4.8 9.0 ? ?
3.4 13.5 6 6.o 7.0 _3 4.0 15.0 7 6.5 10o.0 8 ... ... . .
20.5o.8 1.1 C* _ 1.0 1.1 3.8 9 20.5 o.6 ' o.8 b3 1.8 3.8 ii o.8 1.9 4 3.2 3.8 12 .
17 1.1 1.9 5.7 5 12 .
0 00 4.5 5.7 8 A , is the length of the pipe from the lateral orifice to the end .
C , the pressure at which the sound began .
B , its termination , by lessening the pressure ; D , by 'increasing it .
E , the note answering to the first sound of each pipe , according to the German method of notation .
F , the number showing the place of each note in the regular series of harmonics .
The diameter of the pipe was.35 ; the air duct of the mouth .
piece measured , where smallest,.z : by.035 ; the lateral orifice.z5 by.iz5 .
The apparatus was not calculated to apply a pressure of above 2z inches .
Where no numbex &gt; tandq under C , a sudden blast was required to produce the note , R IX .
Of the Vibrations of different elastic Fluids .
All the methods of finding the velocity of sound , agree in , determining it to be , in fluids of a given elasticity , reciprocally in the subduplicate ratio of the density : hence , in pure hydrougen gas it should be V/ g = 3.6 times as great as in common air ; and the pitch of a pipe should be a minor fourteenth higher in this fluid than in the common air .
It is therefore probable that the hydrogen gas used in Professor CHLADNI'S late experiments was not quite pure .
It must be observed , -that in an accurate experiment of this nature , the pressure causing the blast ought to be carefully ascertained .
There can be no doubt but that , in the observations of the French Academicians on the velocity of sound , which appear to have been conducted with all possible attention , the dampness and coldness of the night air must have considerably increased its density : hence , the velocity was found to be only 11l9 feet in a second ; while DERHAM'S experiments , which have an equal appearance of accuracy , make it amount to 1s 42 .
Perhaps the average may , as has been already mentioned , be safely estimated at i kio .
It may here be remarked , that the well known elevation of the pitch of wind instruments , in the course of playing , sometimes amounting to half a note , is not , as is commonly supposed owing to any expansion of the instrument , for this should produce a contrary effect , but to the increased warmth of the air in the tube .
Dr. SMITHS has made a similar observation , on the pitch of an organ in summer and winter , , which he found to differ more than twice as much as the English and French experiments on the velocity of sound .
BJIANCONI found .
the velocity of sound , at Bologna , to differ atdifferent times , in the ratio of 152 to 17 X. Of the Analogy between Light and Sound .
Ever since the publication of Sir ISAAC NEWTON'S incomparable writings , his doctrines of the emanation of particles of light from lucid substances , and of the formal pre-existence of coloured rays in white light , have been almost universally admitted in this country , and but little opposed in others .
LEONARD EULER indeed , in several of his works , has advanced some powerful .
objections against them , n but not sufficiently powerful to justify the dogmatical reprobation with which he treats them ; and he has left that -system of an ethereal vibration , which after HUYGENs and some others he adopted , equally liable to be attacked on many weak sides .
Without pretending to decide positively on the controversy , it is conceived that some considerations may be brought forwards , which may tend to diminish the weight of objections to a theory similar to the HuYGENIAN .
There are also one or two difficulties in the NEWTONIAN system , which have been little observed .
The first is , the uniform velocity with which light Is supposed to be projected from all luminous bodies , in consequence of heat , or otherwise .
How happens it that , whether the projecting force is the slightest transmission of electricity , the friction of two pebbles , the lowest degree of visible ignition , the white heat of a wind furnace , or the intense heat of the sun itself , these wonderful corpuscles are always propelled with one uniform velocity ?
For , if they differed in velocity , that difference ought to produce a different refraction .
But a still more insuperable difficulty seems to occur , in the partial reflection from every refracting surface .
Why , of the same kind of rays , in every circumstance precisely similar some should always be reflected , and others transmitted , appears in this system to be wholly inexplicable .
That a medium resembling , in many properties that which has been denominated ether , does really exist , is undeniably proved by the phxnomena of electricity and the arguments against the existence of such an ether throughout the universe , have been pretty sufficiently answered by EULER .
The rapid transmission of the electrical shock , shows that the electric medium is possessed of an elasticity as great as is necessary to be supposed for the propagation of light .
, Whether the electric ether is to be considered as the same with the luminous ether , if such a fluid exists , may perhaps at some future time be discovered by experiment ; hitherto I have not been able to observe that the refractive power of a fluid undergoes any change by electricity .
The uniformity of the motion of light in the same medium , which is a difficulty in the NEWTONIAN theory , favours the admission of the HIUYGENIAN ; as all impressions are known to be transmitted through an elastic fluid with the same velocity .
It has been already shown , that sound , in all probability , has very little tendency to diverge : in a mediunm so highly elastic as the luminous ether must be supposed to be , the tendency to diverge may be considered as infinitely small , and the grand objection to the system of vibration will be removed .
It is not absolutely certain , that the white line visible in all directions on the edge of a knife , in the experiments of NEWTON and of Mr. JORDAN , was not partly occasioned by the tendency of light to diverge .
EULER'S hypothesis , of the transmission of light by an agitation of the particles of the refracting media themselves , is liable to strong objections ; according to this supposition , the refraction of the rays of light , on entering the atmosphere from the pure ether which he describes , ought to be a million times greater than it is .
For explaining the phenomenon of partial and total reflection , refraction , and inflection , nothing more is necessary than to suppose all refracting media to retain , by their attraction , a greater or less quantity of the luminous ether , so as to make its density greater than that which it possesses in a vacuum , without increasing its elasticity ; and that light is a propagation of an impulse communicated to this ether by luminous bodies : whether this impulse is produced by a partial emanation of the ether , or by vibrations of the particles of the body , and whether these vibrations are , as EULER supposed , of various and irregular magnitudes , or whether they are uniform , and comparatively large , remains to be hereafter determined .
Now , as the direction of an impulse transmitted through a fluid , depends on that of the particles in synchronous motion , to which it is always perpendicular , whatever alters the direction of the pulse , will inflect the ray of light .
If a smaller elastic body strike against a larger one , it is well known that the smaller is reflected more or less powerfully , according to the difference of their magnitudes : thus , there is always a reflection when the rays of light pass from a rarer to a denser stratum of ether ; and frequently an echo when a sound strikes against a cloud .
A greater body striking a smaller one , propels it , without losing all its motion : thus , the particles of a denser stratum of ether , do not impart the whole of their motion to a rarer , but , in their effort to proceed , they are recalled by the attraction of the refracting 'substance with equal force ; and thus a reflection is always secondarily produced , when the rays ' of light pass from a denser to a rarer stratum .
Let AB , Plate V. Fig. 29 , be a ray of light falling on the reflecting surface FGcd the direction of the vibration , pulse , impression , or condent sation .
When d comes to tH , the impression will be , either wholly or partly , reflected with the same velocity as it arrived , and EH will be equal to DH ; the angle EIH to DIHL or CIF ; and the angle of reflection to that of incidence .
Let FG , Fig. 3o , be a refracting surface .
The portion of the pulse IE , which is travelling through the refracting medium , will move with a greater or less velocity in the subduplicate ratio of the densities , and HE will be to KI in that ratio .
But LLE is , to the radius IH , the sine of the angle of refraction ; and KI that of the angle of incidence .
This explanation of refraction is nearly the same as that of EULER .
The total reflection of a ray of light by a refracting surface , is explicable in the same manner as its simple refraction ; HE , Fig. 3 i , being so much longer than KI , that the ray first becomes parallel to FG , and then , having to return through an equal diversity of media , is reflected in an equal angle .
When a ray of light passes near an inflecting body , surrounded , as all bodies are supposed to be , with an atmosphere of ether denser than the ether of the ambient air , the part of the ray nearest the body is retarded , and of course the whole ray inflected towards the body , Fig. 32 .
The repulsion of inflected rays has been very ably controverted by Mr. JORDAN , the ingenious author of a late publication on the Inflection of Light .
It has already been conjectured by EULER , that the colours of light consist in the different frequency of the vibrations of the luminous ether : it does not appear that he has sulpported this opinion by any argument ; but it is strongly confirmed , by the analogy between the colours of a thin plate and the sounds of aseries of organ pipes .
The phenomenon of the colours of thin plates require , in the NEWTONIAN system , a very complicated supposition , of an ether , anticipating by ' its motion the velocity of the corpuscles of light , and thus producing the fits of transmission and reflection ; and even this supposition does-not much assist the explanation .
It appears , from the accurate analysis of the phanomena which NEWTON has given , and which has by no means been superseded by any later observations , that the same colour recurs whenever the thickness answers to the terms , of an arithmetical progression .
Now this is precisely similar to the production of the same sound , by means of an uniform blast , from organ-pipes which are different multiples of the same length .
Supposing white light to be a continued impulse or stream of luminous ether , it may be conceived to act on the plates as a blast of air does on the organ-pipes , andtoproduce vibrations regulated in frequency by the length of the lines which are terminated by the two refracting surfaces .
It may be objected that , to complete the analogy , there should be tubes , to answer to the organpipes : but the tube of an organ-pipe is only necessary to prevent the divergence of the impression , and in light there is little or no tendency to diverge ; and indeed , in the case of a resonant passage , the air is not prevented from becoming sonorous by the liberty of lateral motion .
It would seem , that the determination of a portion of the track of a ray of light through any homogeneous stratum of ether , is sufficient to establish a length as a basis for colorific vibrations .
In inflections , the length of the track of a ray of light through the inflecting atmosphere may determine its vibrations : but , in this case , as it is probable that there is a reflection from every part of the surface of the surrounding atmosphere , contributing to the appearance of the white line in every direction , in the experiments already mentioned , so it is possible that there may be some : second reflection at the immediate surface of the body itself , and that , by mutual reflections between these two surfaces , something like the anguiform motion suspected by NEWTON may really take place ; and then the analogy to the colours of thin plates will be still stronger .
A mixture of vibrations , of all possible frequencies , may easily destroy the peculiar nature of each , and concur in a general effect of white light .
The greatest difficulty in this syStem is , to explain the different degree of refraction of differently coloured light , and the separation of white light-in refraction : yet , considering how imperfect the theory of elastic fluids still remains , it cannot be expected that every circumstance should at once be clearly elucidated .
It may hereafter be considered how far the excellent experiments of Count RUMFORD , which tend very greatly to weaken the evidence of the modern doctrife of heat , may be more or less favourable to one or the other system of light and colours .
It does not appear that any comparative experiments have been made on the inflection of light by substances possessed of different refractive powers ; undoubtedly some very interesting conclusions might be expected from the inquiry .
MXI .
Of , te Coalescence of mnusical Somnds .
It is surprising that so great a mathematician as Dr. SMITH could have entertained for a moment , an idea that the vibrations constituting different sounds should be able to cross each other in all directions , without affecting the same individual particles of air by their joint forces : undoubtedly they cross , without disturbing each other 's progress ; but this can be no otherwise effected than by each particle 's partaking of both motions .
If this assertion stood in need of any proof , it -might be amply furnished by the phwnomena of beats , and of the grave harmonics observed by ROMIEU and TARTINI ; which M. DE LA GRANGE has-already considered in the-same point of view .
In the first place , to simplify the statement , let us suppose , what probably never precisely happens , that the particles of air , in transmitting the pulses , proceed and return with uniform motions ; and , in order to represent their position to the eye , let the uniform progress of time be represented by the increase of the absciss , and the distance of the particle from its original position , by the ordinate , Fig. 33-38 .
Then , by supposing any two or more vibrations in the same direction to be com. " bined , the joint motion will be represented by the sum or difference of the ordinates .
When two sounds are of equal strength , and nearly of the same pitch , as in Fig. 36 , the joint vibration is alternately very weak and very strong , producing the effect denominated a beat , Plate VI .
Fig. ' 4 , B and C ; which is slower and more marked , as the sounds approach nearer to each other in frequency of vibrations ; and , of these beats there may happen to be several orders , according to the periodical approximations of the numbers expressing the proportions of the vibrations .
The strength of the joint sound is double that of the simple sound only at the middle of the beat , but not throughout its duration ; and it may be inferred , that the strength of sound in a concert will not be in exact proportion to the number of instruments composing it .
Could any method be devised for ascertaining this by experiment , it would assist in the comparison of sound with light .
In Plate V. Fig. a3 , let P and Q be the middle points of the progress or regress of a particle in two successive compound vibrations ; then , CP being PD , KR RN , GQ QH , and MS =SO , tw'ice their distance , 2 RS 3= cRN + 2NM + 2MS =KN + NM +NM + MO KM + NO , is equal to the sum of the distances of the corresponding parts of the simple vibrations .
For instance , if the two sounds be as 8 : 81i , the joint vibration will -be as 80.5 ; the arithmetical mean between the periods of the single vibrations .
The greater the difference in the pitch of two sounds , the more rapid the beats , till at last , like the distinct puffs of air in the experiments already related , they communicate the idea of a continued sound ; and this is the fundamental harmonic described by TARTINI .
For instance , in Plate V. Fig. S4-37 , the vibrations of sounds related as i : 2 , 4:5 , 9 : lo , Andes : 8 , are represented ; where the beats , if the sounds be not taken too grave , constitute a distinct sound , which corresponds with the time elapsing between two successive coincidences , or near approaches to coincidence : for , thatsuch a tempered interval still produces a harmonic , appears from Plate V. Fig. 38 .
But , besides this primary harmonic , a secondary note is sometimes heard , where the intermediate compound vibrations occur at a certain interval , though interruptedly ; for instance , in the coalescence of two sounds related to each other as 7 : 8 , 5 : 7 , or 4 : 5 , there is a recurrence of a similar state of the joint motion , nearly at the interval of A , -h- , or 3 of the whole period : hence , in the concord of a major third , the fourth .
below the key note is heard as distinctly as the double octave , as is seen in some degree in Plate V. Fig. 35 AB being nearly two-thirds of CD .
The same sound is Sometimes produced by taking the minor sixth below the key note ; probably because this sixth , like every other note , is almost always attended by an octave , as a harmonic .
Ifthe angles-of all thefigures resulting from the motion thus assumed be rounded off , they will approach omore nearly to a-representation of the actual circumstances ; but , as the laws by which the motion of the particles of air is regulated , differ according to the different origin and nature of the sound , it is impossible to adapt a demonstration to them all : if , however the !
particles be supposed to follow the law of the harmonic curve , derived from uniform circular motion , the compound vibration will be the harmonic instead of the arithmetical mean ; and the secondary sound of the interrupted vibrations will be more accurately formed , and more strongly marked , Plate VI .
Figs. 41 , 42 : the demonstration is deducible ' from the pro .
parties of the circle .
It is remarkable , that the law by which the motion of the particles is governed , is capable of some singular alterations by a combination of vibrations .
By adding to a given sound other similar sounds , related to it in frequency as the series of odd numbers , and in strength inversely in the same ratios , the right lines indicating an uniform motion may be ; converted , very nearly into figures of sines , and the figures of sines into right lines , as in Plate V. Figs. 3g , 40 .
XII .
Of the Frequency of Vibrations constituting a given Note .
The number of vibrations performed by a given sound in a second , has been variously ascertained ; first , by SAUVEUR , by a very~ ingenious inference from the beats of twosounds and since , by the same observer and several others , by calculation from the weight and tension of a chord .
It was thought worth while , as a confirmation , to make an experiment suggested , but coarsely conducted , by MERSENNUS , con a chord 200 incebo in length , stretched so loosely as to have its single vibrations visible ; and .
, by holding a quill nearly in contact with the chord , they were made audible , and were found , in one experiment to recur 8.3 times ina second .
By lightly pressing the chord at one-eighth of its length from the end , and at -other shorter aliquot distances , the .
fundamental note was found to be one-sixth of a tone higher than the respective octave of a tuning-fork marked C : hence , the fork was a comma and a half above the pitch assumed by SAUVEUR , of an imaginary C , consisting of one vibration in a second .
XIII .
Of the Vibrations of Chords .
By a singular oversight in the demonstration of Dr. BROOK TAYLOR , adopted as it has been by a number of later authors , it is asserted , that if a chord be once inflected into any other form than that of the harmonic curve , it will , since those parts which are without this figure are impelled towards it by an excess of force , and those within it by a deficiency , in a very short time arrive at or very near the form of this precise curve .
It would be easy to prove , if this reasoning were allowed , that the form of the curve can be no other than that of the axis , since the tending force is continually impelling the chord towards this line .
The case is very similar to that of the NEWTONIAN proposition respecting sound .
It may be proved , that every impulse is communicated along a tended chord with an uniform velocity ; and this velocity is the same which is inferred from Dr. TAYLOR'S theorem ; just as that of sound , determined by other methods , coincides with the NEWTONIAN result .
But , although several late mathematicians have given admirable solutions of all possible cases of the problem , yet it has still been supposed , that the distinctions were too minuteto be actually observed ; especially as it might have been added , since the inflexibility of a wire would dispose it , according to the doctrine of elastic rods , to assume the form of the harmonic curve .
The theorem of EULER and DE LA GRANGE , in the case where the chord is supposed to be at first at rest , is in effact this : cons tinue the figure each way , alternately on different sides of the axis , and in contrary positions ; then , from any point of the curve , take an absciss each way , in the same proportion to the length of the chord as any given portion of time bears to the time of one semivibration , and the half sum of the ordinates will be the distance of that point of the chord from the axis , at the expiration of the time given .
If the initial figure of the chord be composed of two right lines , as generally happens in musical instruments and experiments , its successive forms will be such as are represented in Plate VI .
Figs. 47 , 48 : and this result is fully confirmed by experiment .
' Take one of the lowest strings of a square piano forte , round which a fine silvered wire is wound in a spiral form ; contract the light of a window , so that , when the eye is placed in a proper position , the image of the light may appear small , bright , and well defined , on each of the convolutions of the wire .
Let the chord be now made to vibrate , and the luminous point will delineate its path , like a burning coal whirled round , and will present to the eye a line of light , which , by the assistance of a microscope , may be very accurately ob , served .
According to the different ways by which the wire is put in motion , the form of this path is no less diversified and amusing , than the multifarious forms of the quiescent lines of vibrating plates , discovered by Professor CHLADNI ; and is indeed in one respect even more interesting , as it appears to be more within the reach of mathematical calculation to determine it ; although hitherto , excepting some slight observations of bus and CHLADNI , principally on the motion of rods , nothing has been attempted on the subject .
For the present purpose , the motion of the chord may be simplified , by tying a long fine thread to any part of it , and fixing this thread in a direction perpendicular to that of the chord , without drawing it so tight as to increase the tension : by these means , the vibraations .
are confined nearly to one plane , which scarcely ever happens when the chord vibrates at liberty .
If the chord be now inflected in the middle , it will be found , by comparison with an object which marked its quiescent position , to make equal excursions on each side of the axis ; and the figure which it apparently occupies will be terminated by two lines , the more luminous as they are nearer the ends , Plate VI .
Fig. 49 .
But , if the chord be inflected near one of its extremities , Fig. 5o , it will proceed but a very small distance on the opposite side of the axis , and will there form a very bright line , indicating its longer continuance in that place ; yet it will return on the former side nearly to the point from whence it was let go , but will be there very faintly visible , on account of its short delay .
In the middle of the chord , the excursions on each side the axis are always equal ; and , beyond the middle , the same circumstances take place as in the half where it was inflected , but on the opposite side of the axis ; and this appearance continues unaltered in its proportions , as long as the chord vibrates at all : fully confirming the non-existence of the harmonic curve , and the accuracy of the construction of EULER and DE LA GRANGE .
At the same time , as M. BERNOULLI has justly observed , since every figure may be infinitely approximated , by considering its ordinates as composed of the ordinates of an infinite number of trochoids of different magnitudes , it may be demonstrated , that all these constituent curves would revert to their initial state , in the same time that a similar chord bent into a trochoidal curve would perform a single vibration ; and 'this is in some respects a convenient and compendious method of considering the problem .
But , when a chord vibrates freely , it never remains long in motion , without avery evident departure from the plane of the vibration ; and , whether from the original obliquity of the impulse , or from an interference with the reflected vibrations of the air , or from the inequability of its own weight or flexibility , or from the Immediate resistance of the particles of air in contact with it , it is thrown into a very evident rotatory motion , more or less simple and uniform according to circumstances .
Some specimens of the figures of the orbits of chords are exhibited in Plate VI .
Fig. .
At the middle of the chord , its orbit has always two equal halves , but seldom at any other point .
The curves of Fig. 46 , are described bycombining together various circular motions , supposed to be performed in aliquot parts of the primitive orbit : and some of them approach nearly to the figures actually observed .
When the chord is of unequal thickness , or when it is loosely tended and forcibly inflected , the apsides and double points of the orbits have a very evident rotatory motion .
The compound rotations seem to demonstrate to the eye the existence of secondary vibrations , and to account for the acute harmonic sounds which generally attend the fundamental sound .
There is one fact respecting these secondary notes , which seems entirely to have escaped observation .
If a chord be inflected at one-half , one-third , or any other aliquot part of its length , and then suddenly left at liberty , the harmonic note which would be produced by dividing the chord at that point is entirely lost , and is not to be disc MDccc .
T estinguished during any part of the continuance of the sound .
, This demonstrates , that the secondary notes do not depend upon any interference of the vibrations of the air with each other , nor upon any sympathetic agitation of auditory fibres , nor upon any effect of reflected aound upon the chord , but merely upon its initial figure and motion .
If it were supposed that the chord , when inflected into right lines , resolved itself necessarily into a number of secondary vibrations , according to some curves which , when properly combined , would approximate to the figure given , the supposition would indeed in some respects correspond with the phenomenon related ; as the coef-ficients of all the curves supposed to end at the angle of inflection would vanish .
But , whether we trace the constituent curves of such a figure through the various stages of their ' vibrations , or whether we follow the morecompendious method of EULER to the same purpose , the figures resulting from this series of vibrations are in fact so simple , that it seems inconceivable howthe earshould deduce the complicatedidea of a number of heterogeneous vibrations , from .
a motion of the particles of air which must be extremely regular , and almost uniform ; an iniformity which , when proper precautions are taken , is not contradicted by examining the motion of ' the chord with the assistance of a powerful magnifier .
This difficulty occurred very strongly to EULER , and DE LA GRANGE even suspects some fallacy in the experiment , and that a musical ear judges from previous association .
But , besides that these sounds are discoverable to an ear destitute of such associations , and , when the sound is produced by two strings in imperfect unison , may beverified by counting the , number of their beats , the experiment already related is an undeniable proof that no fallacy of this kind exists .
It must be confessed , that nothing fully satisfactory has yet occurred to account for the phabnomena ; but it is highly probable that the slight increase of tension produced by flexure , which is omitted in the calculations , and the unavoidable inequality of thickness or flexibility of different parts of the same chord , may , by disturbing the isocbronism of the subordinate vibrations , cause all that variety of sounds which is so inexplicable without them .
For , when the slightest difference is introduced in the periods , there is no difficulty in conceiving how the sounds may be distinguished ; and indeed , in some cases , a nice ear will discover a slight imperfection in the tune of harmonic notes : it is also often observed , in tuning an instrument , that some of the single chords produce beating sounds , which undoubtedly arise from their want of perfect uniformity .
It may be perceived that any particular harmonic is loudest , when the chord is inflected at about one-third of the corresponding aliquot part from one of the extremities of that part .
An observation of Dr. WALLIs seems to have passed unnoticed by later writers on harmonics .
If the string of a violin be struck in the middle , or at any other aliquot part , it will give either no sound at all , or a very obscure one .
This is true , not of inflections , but of the motion communicated by a bow ; and may be explained from the circumstance of the successive impulses , reflected from the fixed points at each end , destroying each other : an explanation nearly analogous to some observations of Dr. MATTHEW YOUNG on the motion of chords .
When the bow is applied not exactly at the aliquot point , but very near it , the corresponding harmonic is extremely loud ; and the fundamental note , especially in the lowest harmonics , scarcely audible : the chord assumes the appearance , at the T v aliquot points , of as many lucid lines as correspond to the number of the harmonic , more nearly approaching to each other as the bow approaches more nearly to the point , Plate VLo Fig. 5i .
According to the various modes of applying the bow , an immense variety of figures of the orbits are produced , Fig. 4S , more than enough to account for all the difference of tone in different performers .
In observations of this -kind , a series of harmonics is frequently heard in drawing the bow across the same part of the chord : these are produced by the bow ; they are however not proportionate to the whole length of the bow , but depend on the capability of the portion of the bowstring , intercepted between its end and the chord , of performing its vibrations in times which are aliquot parts of the vibration of the chord : hence it would seem , that the bow takes effect on the chord but at one instant during each fundamental vibration .
In these experiments , the bow was strung with the second string of a violin : and , in the preparatory application of resin , the longitudinal sound of CHLADNI was sometimes heard ; but it was observed to differ at least a note in different parts of the string .
XIV .
Of the Vibrations of Rods and Plates .
Some experiments were made , with the assistance of a most excellent practical musician , on the various notes produced by a glass tube , an iron rod , and a wooden ruler ; and , in a -case where the tubewas as much at liberty as possible , all the harmonics corresponding to the numbers from i to 13 , were distinctly observed ; several of them at the same time , and others by means of different blows .
This result seems to differ from the calculations of EULER and Count RICCATI , confirmed as they are by the repeated experiments of Professor CHLADNI ; it is not therefore brought forward as sufficiently controverting those calculations , but as showing the necessity of a revision of the experiments .
Scarcely any note could ever be heard when a rod was loosely held at its extremity ; nor when it was held in the middle , and struck one-seventh of the length from one end .
The very ingenious method of Professor CHLADNI , of observing the --vibrations of plates bystrewing fine sand over them , and discovering the quiescent lines by the figures into which it is thrown , has hitherto been little known in this country : his treatise on the phenomena is so complete , that no other experiments of the kind were thought necessary .
Glass vessels of various descriptions , whether made to sound by percussion or friction , were found to bealmost entirely freefrom harmonic notes ; and this observation coincides with the experiments of CHLADNI .
XV .
Of the human Voice .
The human voice , which was the object originally proposed to be illustrated by these researches , is of so complicated a nature , and so imperfectly understood , that it can be on this occasion but superficially considered .
No person , unless we except M. FERREIN , has published any thing very important on the subject of the formation of the voice , before or since DODART ; his reasoning has fully shown the analogy between the voice and the voix humaine and regal organ-pipes : but his comparison with the whistle is unfortunate ; nor is he more happy in his account of the falsetto .
A kind of experimental analysis of the voice may be thus exhibited .
By drawing in the breath , and at the same time properly contracting the larynx , a slow vibration of the ligaments .
of the glottis may be produced , making a distinct clicking sound : upon increasing the tension , and the velocity of the breath , this clicking is lost , and the sound becomes continuous , but of an extremely grave pitch : it may , by a good ear , be distinguished two octaves below the lowest A of a common bass voice , consisting in that case of about 26 vibrations in a second .
The same sound may be raised nearly to the pitch of the common voice ; but it is never smooth and clear , except perhaps in some , of those persons called ventriloquists .
When the pitch is raised still higher , the upper orifice of the larynx , formed by the summits of the arytoenoid cartilages and the epiglottis , seems to succeed to the office of the ligaments of the glottis , and to produce a retrograde falsetto , which is capable of a very great degree of acuteness .
The same difference probably takes place between the natural voice and the common falsetto : the rimula glottidis being too long to admit of a sufficient degree of tension for very acute sounds , the upper orifice of the larynx supplies its place ; hence , taking a note within the compass of either voice , it may be held , , with the same expanse of air , two or three times as long in a falsetto as in a natural voice ; hence , too , the difficulty of passing smoothly from the one voice to the other .
It has been remarked , that the larynx is always elevated when the sound is acute : but this elevation is only necessary in rapid transitions , as in a shake ; and then probably because , by the contraction of the capacity of the trachea , an increase of the pressure of the breath can be more rapidly effected this way , than by the action of the abdominal muscles alone .
The reflection of the sound thus produced from the various parts of the cavity of the mouth and nostrils , mixing at various intervals with the portions of the vibrations directly proceeding from the larynx , must , according to the temporary form of the parts , variously affect the laws of the motion of the air in each vibration , or , according to EULER'S expression , the equation of the curve conceived to correspond with this motion , and thus produce the various characters of the vowels and semi-vowels .
The principal sounding board seems to be the bony palate : the nose , except in nasal letters , affords but little resonance for the nasal passage may be closed , by applying the finger to the soft palate , without much altering the sound of vowels -not nasal .
A good ear may distinctly observe , especially in a loud bass voice , besides the fundamental note .
at least four harmonic sounds , in the order of the natural numbers ; and , the more reedy the tone of the voice , the more easily they are heard .
Faint as they are , their origin is by no means easy to be explained .
This observation is precisely confirmed , in a late dis .
sertation of M. KNECHT , published in the musical newspaper of Leipsic .
Perhaps , by a close attention to the harmonics entering into the constitution of various sounds , more may be done in , their analysis than could otherwise be expected. .
XVI .
Of the Temperament of musical Intervals .
It would have been extremely convenient for practical musi cians , and would have saved many warm controversies , among theoretical ones , if three times the ratio of + to 5 , or four times that of 5 to 6 , had been equal to the ratio of I to 2 .
As it happens to be otherwise , it has been much disputed in what intervals the imperfection should be placed .
The ARISTOXENIANS and PYTHAGOREANS were in some sense the beginners of the controversy .
SAUVEuR has given very comprehensive tables of a great number of systems of temperament ; and his own .
now ranks among the many that are rejected .
Dr. SMITH has written a large and obscure volume , which , for every purpose but for the use of an impracticable instrument , leaves the whole subject precisely where it found it .
KIRNBERGER , MARPURG , and other German writers , have disputed with great .
bitterness , almost every one for -a particular method of tuning .
It is not -with any confidence of success , that one more attempt is made , which rests its chief claim to preference , on the similarity of its theory to the actual practice of the best instrument-makers .
However we estimate the degree of imperfection of two tempered concords of the same nature , it will appear , that the manner of dividing the temperament between them does not materially alter its aggregate sum ; for instance , the imperfection of a comma in a major-third , occasions it to beat very nearly twice as fast as that of half a comnia .
If indeed the imperfection were great , it might affect an interval so materially as to destroy its character ; as , in some methods of temperament , a minor third diminished by two commas approaches more nearly to the ratio 6 : 7 , than to i : 6 ; but , with this limitation , the sum of harmony is nearly equal in all systems .
Hence , if every one of the twelve major and minor thirds occurred equally often in the compositions which are to be performed on an instrument , it would be of no great consequence , to the sum of the imperfections , among which of the thirds they were divided : and , even in this case , the opinion of the best practical authors is , that the difference of character produced by a difference of proportions in various keys , would be of considerable advantage in the general effect of modulation .
But , when it is considered , that upon an average of all the music ever composed , some particular keys occur at least twice as often as others , there seems to be a very strong additional reason for making the harmony the most perfect in those keys which are the most frequently used ; since the aggregate sum of all the imperfections which occur in playing , must by this means be diminished in the greatest possible degree , and the diversity of character at the same time preserved .
Indeed , in practice , this method , under diffhrent modifications , has been almost universal ; for , although many have pretended to an equal temperament , yet the methods which they have employed to attain it have been evidently defective .
It ap-pears to me , that every purpose may be answered , by making C : E too sharp by a quarter of a comma , which will not offend the nicest ear ; E:G , and Ab C , equal ; FT : A* too sharp by a comma ; and the major thirds of all the intermediate keys more or less perfect , as they approach more or less to C in the order of modulation .
The fifths are perfect enough in every system .
The results of this method are shown in Table xii .
In practice , nearly the same effect may be very simply produced , by tuning from C to F , Bb , Eb , G* , C , FP six perfect fourths ; and C , G , D , A , E , B , F* , six equally imperfect fifths , Plate VI .
Fig. 52 .
If the unavoidable imperfections of the fourths be such as to incline them to sharpness , the temperament will approach more nearly to equality , which is preferable to an inaccuracy on the other side .
An easy method of comparing different systems of temperament is exhibited in Plate VII .
Fig. 5j , which may easily be extended to all the sysn tems that have ever been invented .
Table xii .
ABCC 50000 1C +.0013487 1 A , E.0023603 B 53224 2 G , F.oo09oo6 2 D , B.0029122 B3 56g1 3 D , B.0024525 3 G , P.0034641 A 59676 4 A , Eb.0o04641 4 C , C*.004475 G* 63148 5 E , Ab.0044756 it F , G*.0049353 G 66822 6 B , C*.0049553 6 Bb , Eb -0053950 F* 71041 7 F.Q053950 F 7492l1 E 79752 D E3 83810 D 8g34 lEb G* , C*I Fit -.osoooooo D 89304b C* 94723 2 F , B3 , E , B.0004597 C 100000 3C , G , D , A v0o11562 A , shows the division of a monochord corresponding to each note , in the system proposed .
B , the logarithm of the temperament of each of the major thirds .
C , of the minor thirds .
D , of the fifths ; C and D being both negative .
Thus , Sir , I have endeavoured to advance a few steps only , n the investigation of some very obscure but interesting subjects .
As far as I know , most of these observations are new ; but , if they should be found to have been already made by any other person , their repetition in a connected chain of inference may still be excusable .
I am persuaded also , that at least some of the positions maintained are incontrovertibly consistent with truth and nature ; but , should further experiments tend to confute any opinions that I have suggested , I shall relinquish them with as much readiness as I have long since abandoned the hypothesis which I once took the liberty of submitting to the Royal Society , on the functions of the crystalline lens ' .
I am , &amp; C. Emanuel College , Cambridge .
THOMAS YOUNG , 8th July , 1799 .
EXPLANATION OF THE FIGURES. .
( See Plates II .
IV .
V. VI .
and VIIL ) Plate III .
Figs. l-6 .
The section of a stream of air from a tube.07 inch in diameter , as ascertained by measuring the breadth of the impression on the surface of a liquid .
The pressure imm pelling the current , was in Fig. i , i inch .
Fig. 2 , 2 .
Fig. Fj j. Fig. 4 , 4 .
Fig.,5 7 .
lFig .
6 , io .
Figs. 7-19 .
A similar section , where the tube was i in diai .
meter , compared with .
the section as inferred from the experiments with two gages , which is represented by a dotted line .
From this comparison it appears , that where the velocity of the current was small , its central parts only displaced the liquid ; and that , where it was great , it displaced , on meetings with resistance , a surface somewhat greater than its own section .
The pressure was in Fig. 7 , 1 .
Fig. 8 , 2 .
Fig. 9 , 3- .
Fig. 10 , 4 Fig. il , 7 .
Fig. 12 , o0 .
Figs. 13-20 .
A , the half section of a stream of air from a tube.i in diameter , as inferred from experiments with two : water gages .
The pressure was in Fig. 13,. .
Fig.14,.2 .
Fig. T5,.5 .
Fig. i6 , i. Fig. 17 , 3 .
Fig , i8 , A. Fig. 19 , 7 .
Fig. 20 , 1 ?
o. .
The fine lines , marked B , show the result of the observara tions with an aperture .
i in diameter opposed to the stream ; C with .
; and D with.5 .
Figs. 21-_23 .
A , the half section of a current from a tube.g in diameter , with a pressure of.5 , of 1 , and of 3 .
B shows the course of a portion next the axis of the current , equal in diameter to those represented by the last figures .
Plate IV .
Fig. 24 .
The appearance of a stream of smoke forced very gently from a fine tube .
Fig. 25 and 26 , the same appearance when the pressure is gradually increased .
Fig. ?
7 .
See Section III .
Fig. 28 .
The perpendicular lines over each division of the horizontal line show , by their length and distance from that line , the , extent of pressure capable of producing , from the respective pipes , the harmonic notes indicated by the figures placed opposite the beginning of each , according to the scale of 22 inches parallel to them .
The larger numbers , opposite the middle of each of these lines , show the number of vibrations of the corxesponding sound in a second .
Plate V. Figs. 29-33 .
See Section X. Fig. 34 .
The combination of two equal sounds constituting the interval of an octave , supposing the progress and regress of the particles of air equable .
Figs. 35 , 36 , 37 , a similar representation of a major third , major tone , and minor sixth .
Fig. : 38 .
A fourth , tempered about two commas .
Fig. 39 .
A vibration of a similar nature , combined with subordinate vibrations of the same kind in the ratios of 3 , A , and 7 Fig. 40 .
A vibration represented by a curve of which the ordinates are the sines of circular arcs increasing uniformly , corresponding with the motion of a cycloidal pendulum , combined with similar subordinate vibrations in the ratios of , a , , and 7 Plate VI .
Figs. 41 and Ado Two different positions of a major third , composed of similar vibrations , as represented by figures of sines .
Fig. 43 .
A contracted representation of a series of vibrations .
A , a simple uniform sound .
B , the beating of two equal sounds nearly in unison , as derived from rectilinear figures .
C , the beats of two equal sounds , derived from figures of sines .
D , a musical : consonance , making by Its frequent beats a fundamental harmonic .
E , the imperfect beats of two unequal sounds .
Fig. 4 .
Various forms of the orbit of a musical chord , when inflected , and when struck .
Fig. 45 .
Forms of the orbit , when the sound is produced by means of a bow .
Fig. 46 .
Epitrochoidal curves , formed by combining a simple rotation or vibration with other subordinate rotations or vibrasw tions .
Figs 47 and 48 .
The successive forms of a tended chord , when inflected and let go , according to the construction of DE LA GRANGE and EULER .
Fig. 49 .
The appearance of a vibrating chord which had been inflected in the middle , the strongest lines representing the most luminous parts .
Fig. So .
The appearance of a vibrating chord , when , inflected at any other point than the middle .
Fig. 51 .
The appearance of a chord , when put in motion by a bow applied nearly at one third of the length from its end .
Fig.5 The method of tuning recommended for common use .
, Plate VIII .
Fig. 53 .
A comparative view of different systems of tem .
, perament .
The whole circumference represents an octave .
The inner circle L is divided into 30103 parts , corresponding with the logarithmical parts of an octave .
The next circle R shows the magnitude of the simplest musical and other ratios .
Q is diNvided into twelve equal parts , representing the semitones of the equal temperament described by ZARLINO , differing but little from the system of ARISTOXENus , and warmly recommended by MARPIURG and other late writers .
Y exhibits the system proe posed in this paper as the most desirable ; and P the practical method nearly approaching to it , which corresponds with the eleventh method in MARPURG'S enumeration , except that , by beginning with C instead of B , the practical effect of the temperament is precisely inverted .
K is the system of KIRNBERGER and SULZER jr which is derived from one perfect third , ten perfect and two equally imperfect fifths .
M is the system of mean tones , the sistena participato of the old Italian , writers , still fry . .
quently used in tuning organs , approvedalso by Dr. SMITH for commonuse .
S shows the result of all the calculations in Dr. , SMITH'S harmonics , the system proposed for his changeables harpsichord , but neither in that nor any other form capable of ' : practical application .
&gt; lijo j3 Iic13 =---------Ejo4 0 -~~~~~-----.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~fg r Ad~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Fipo __ _li -ig%6 A gE __ __ *~~~~~~~~~~I -__ ___~g.__ _ ____ ___ 13 O ~~~~~~~~~~~~~At ~~~~~~~~~~~~~Fioi7 g -~~~~~~~~~~~ ---a Di Fig ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ , ____--------Fig ---------ig .
__= JLA rlig.9 - } 2vg $ g..23 S. .
~~~~~~~~B , IFig.12 -= 1h= fi.2 C -----~ ~~~~~~~~~ -------'3 ---A -i K-----------iDoi -A=== IS 7IW1020 D __ _Ah --------:23 AL-~~~~~~~ , _ B -Fig22 B -~~~~~~~~~~~._ fgo~ 3 E1- &gt; l~~~~~~}ig .
24.\~ ~~ ~~~~~~~~ 4 ' 22 ' '28 ) Iisr2( &amp; 0 !
460 Bg~~~~~26.~~~~~ ~~~i 6K ~~ ~28 r 233616428 II 2768 2076 i4i 1'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~15 II~~~~~~~~A 1/ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1248 t8 ~~~~~~~~~1040 4 u68 4 18 6 Fi--27 83-2 I ~~~~~ ~~~~~~624~ -3d40 31 6~~~~~ ~~~92 !
21 IL0 4.5 OrEN 9.40PE N -i6a opEN 20 0OPE~N 4.5 s _____ ri/ /eo .
77ais .
Mu ) ( .
( . .
] J } .
h28_ 460 2422 2680 , io15 1664 768 ~~76 1~1456 1248 1 2847 1040 876 14 1730 &lt; 7~ ~~~~~17 6 ~~83296 1340 3Hj ~~~~~~~~728.i 592 4 1 , ~~ ~~92 5 037520 312 2~ 41 10513,46 3132 i-6i oPEN20 5 OPEN 4.5 STOPPED 9.4 STOPIPED -16.1 STO-PPED 20.5 SSTOPP'EI , ~ ~~~~ ~ X , -X-z D ~~~~fig % 6 iii LB &amp; Fig~3 I 6Fig'iVg.29 C. ' A-0 &gt; J 0iC/ f~ ~~ d.FEigTu / fig. 31 F gTF l~~~~i g~~~~~40 -~~~~~~~~~~~~~ hgw fig : 3_ DL ilI-C A7 1 ) ' .
' ' ; X ANAL--\-/ " .\ _/ X -- , :.7 fly 39 I , Af Zirs40 A* / ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i Bhg42 A4g3 Bg 44 if f~ i"f iO,.:"l if ait , " :ffii I''.l .
t ' l , ,Hlfl ffUH:l'[ I !
: ; i : l"ii ill l I !
; ' : CtA ' il lj i , E , ; j 1 , : , )1Tie , 48 Fi:5 Fig:46 fig 49 Fig 5o Eig:52 IPERFECT IMPERFECT o_~ L. lFig.5i _P~u1Q"KI~4~TZ IT lio .
: huaf .
SI I ) CCI WII./ L ]J .
Fig. 53.=~ ~~~~~ sa aX _______a___XA.27~~~~~~~~~ .
12i 5.06 / / 'I 0B II 9 Ii -8 II x. / GGGG G

