Mr. HUNTER , but , from the multiplicity of his engagements , had remained neglected in the cask at the time of his death , and in the following year was dried , to show the proboscis , that it might not be altogether spoiled .
Upon examining this dried head , the bones had been so much broken , that one of the organs of hearing was altogether wanting : the other , however , was fortunately entire ; and the membrana tympani and small bones , having been little disturbed in the drying of the parts , remained nearly in their natural situation .
The membrana tympani , and every other part of the organ , were found to be much larger in proportion than in other quadrupeds , or in man ; differing in this respect from the eye of the elephant , which is unusually small , when compared with the enormous bulk of the animal .
The membrane was found of an oval form ; the short diameter of the oval rather more than an inch in length ; the long , diameter an inch and -71ths .
In the human ear , the membrana tympani is nearly circular ; , the longest diameter is 2-1ths of an inch the shortest - !
-ths .
As the membrane in the elephant exceeds that of the human ear in thickness as much as in extent , which is as the squares of their diameters , or in the proportion of 135 to 14 , it is natural to conclude that the muscular fibres which are to stretch the one , must greatly exceed in strength those capable of producing the same -degree of tension in the other .
From this statement , the muscular structure in the human membrana tympani will necessarily be so much less distinct than in the elephant , as scarcely to be visible to the naked eye , and will easily be overlooked by the most attentive observer , who is not directed by some previous information to examine it under the most favourable circumstances ; but , when these are attended to , it can be perceived without the aid of glasses .
If the membrana tympani of the human ear is completely exposed on both sides , by removing the contiguous parts , and the cuticular covering is carefully washed off from its external surface , then , by placing it in a clear light , the radiated direction of its fibres may be easily detected .
If a common magnifying glass is used , they are rendered nearly as distinct as those of the elephant appear to the naked eye ; their course is exactly the same ; and they differ in nothing but in being formed upon a smaller scale .
When view'ed in a microscope magnifying 2 , times the muscular fibres are beautifully conspicuous , and appear uniformly the same throughout the whole surface , there being no central tendons , as in the diaphragm ; the muscular fibres appear only to form the internal layer of the membrane , and are most distinctly seen when viewed on that side .
In examining this membrane in different subjects , the parts were frequently found in a more or less morbid state .
In one instance , the membrane was found loaded with blood-vessels , was less transparent than usual , and was united by close adhesion to the point of the long process of the incus .
In another instance , there was a preternatural ossification adhering to it , at a small distance from the end of the handle of the malleus .
As muscles in general are supplied with blood-vessels in proportion to the frequency of their action , it -is an object of importance to determine the vascularity of the membrana tympani .
Upon this subject , my own want of information has been amply supplied by Dr. BAILLIE , who , in a communication upon this subject , showed me a preparation of the membrane , in which the vessels had been most successfully injected with coloured wax .
In this preparation , the most beautiful of the kind I ever saw , the vessels in their distribution resembled those of the iris , and were nearly half as numerous : they anastomosed with one another in a similar manner , and their general direction was from the circumference to the handle of the malleus ; from near this handle , a small trunk sent off ' branches , ina radiated manner , which anastomosed with those which had an opposite course .
This correspondence , in the number and distribution of bloodvessels , between the membrana tympani and the iris , is a strong circumstance in confirmation of that membrane being endowed with muscular action .
In the horse , the membrana tympani is smaller than in man ; its long diameter is 2-a-ths of an inch ; the short one -1--ths ; and it is almost quite flat , while in man it is concave , which makes the difference of extent considerably exceed the difference in the diameters .
In the horse , the fibrous structure is not visible to the naked eye it is even indistinctly seen when viewed through a common magnifying glass ; but in a microscope it is very visible , and in every other respect agrees in structure with the membrane in the human ear , and in that of the elephant .
In birds , the membrana tympani is larger in proportion than in the quadrupqd , and more circular in its shape .
In the goose , it is --5ihs of an inch in its longest diameter , and ; &gt; .ths in its shortest diameter .
In the turkey , --7 , ths by -1-ths .
It is thinner in its coats in birds than in the horse , and to the naked eye hasno appearance of fibres ; but , when viewed in a microscope , there is a visible radiated structure , not very unlike tne wire marks upon common writing paper .
In a former Lecture upon the Structure of Muscles* in which a comprehensive view was taken of the subject , it was stated , that the organization necessary for muscular contraction could exist in an apparent membrane , and that a fasciculated structure was only necessary when muscular action was to be enabled to overcome resistance .
The coats of the Taonia hydatigena were mentioned as an instance of the first ; and the human heart as the most complex of the second .
In comparing the membranae tympani of different animals , they afford a beautiful illustration of the truth of this position .
In birds , where from the smallness of its size the resistance is very trifling , the membrane is very similar to the coat of an hydatid , only still thinner .
In the elephant , fibres forming fasciculi are very distinct .
The membrane of the horse , and that of the human ear , form the intermediate gradations .
The knowledge of a muscular structure in the membrana tympani , enables us to explain many phenomena in hearing , which have not hitherto been accounted for in a satisfactory manner .
It is principally by means of this muscle that accurate perceptions of sound are communicated to the internal organ , and that the membrana tympani is enabled to vary the state of its tension , so as to receive them in the quick succession in which they are conveyed to it .
In the human ear , and in that of birds , the radiated fibres of the membrana tympani have their principal attachment to the extremity of the handle of the malleus , which is nearly in the centre of the membrane .
II the membrane of the elephant , which is oval , the attachment to the handle of the malleus is at some distance from the centre .
In the horse , deer , and cat , which have the membrane still more oval than the elephant , the handle of the malleus is situated in the long axis of the membrane , with its extremity extending beyond the centre , reaching nearer to the circumference ; and the fibres of the radiated muscle are not only attached to its end , but also laterally to nearly the whole length of its handle .
This oval form of the membrana tympani , in those quadrupeds , and the very extensive attachment of the fibres of the radiated muscle to the handle of the malleus , may be the reason why their ears are not equally fitted to hear inarticulate sounds , as the ears of birds and of man .
Should this radiated muscle of the membrana tympani ( which is probably the smallest in the body that has a distinct action ) be thought too insignificant to have an office of so much consequence assigned to it , let it be remembered , that the size of muscles is no indication of their importance , but only of the resistance to be overcome by their action ; and that the more delicate actions are performed universally in the body by very small muscles , of which the iris in the eye furnishes a very conspicuous example .
Before the mode in which the radiated muscle adapts the meinbrana tympani to different sounds can be explained , it is necessary that the more important parts of the organ should be enumerated , and the use commonly assigned to each of them pointed out .
In man and the more perfect quadrupeds , this organ consists of the following parts : the mem brana tympani , situated betxveen the external passage and the cavity of the tympanum ; four smadl b.iies , which , form achain across the tympanum , connecting the membrane tympani with another membrane lining the foramen ovale , which opens into the vestibulum , a more internal part of the organ of hearing .
The bones are , the malleus , which is united to the membrane tympani by a portion of its handle , and to the second bone or incus by its head .
The incus , which is connected to the malleus by a capsular ligament , forming a regular joint , the surfaces of the bones being covered with cartilage , but they have only a tremulous motion on one another .
The incus is also attached to the side of the cavity of the tympanum , where the mastoid cells open , by a ligament on which it moves backwards and forwards : it is united by its long process to the orbicular bone , which is the smallest in the body , and connects the incus to the fourth bone or stapes , which has its base applied to the foramen ovale , or opening leading into the cavity of the vestibulum .
The cavity of the tympanum , in which these bones are situated , communicates with the external air by means of the Eustachian tube , so that there is always air behind the membrana tympani .
The malleus has three muscles , by which it , is moved ; one of them is called the tensor , from its pulling the malleus inwards , and tightening the membrana tympani : the other two act in an opposite direction , and relax the membrane ; the largest of these is called the obliquus , and is the antagonist of the tensor muscle ; the other is very small , and is called the laxator .
The stapes has one muscle , which acts upon it by bringing its basis closer to the foramen ovale .
The vestibulum , which is completely separated from the tympanum , by the membrane that lines the foramen ovale , communicates freely with the cochlea and -semicircular canals ; but these cavities are filled with a watery liquor , and have no communication ( as the tympanum has ) with the external air .
This fact was ascertained in the horse , by the following experiment , repeated several times .
The organ of hearing was separated from the skull immediately after death , and the cavity of the tympanum exposed ; the parts were then immersed in water , and the stapes removed ; by which means , the membrane of the foramen ovale was destroyed , but no globule of air was seen to escape through the water.* The following uses have generally been assigned to the parts now mentioned .
The membrana tympani was supposed to be adapted to receive impressions , by the combined action of the tensor and laxator muscles varying the degree of its tension , so as to bring it in unison with different sounds : these impressions were conducted , by the chain of bones , to the vestibulum , cochlea , and semicircular canals ; in which cavities , particularly the cochlea , they were supposed to undergo some modification , before they were impressed upon the nerves spread upon the linings of these cavities .
The function of modifying impressions of sound was assigned to the cochlea , partly from the delicacy of its internal structure , supposed to resemble a musical instrument , and partly from there being no other part of the organ apparently suited for repeating the variety of delicate sounds which pass into the ear : the changes that could be produced upon the membrana tympani by the muscles of the malleus , being considered as incapable of answering that purpose .
This slight sketch of the organ of hearing , and of the uses , as they are generally understood , of the different parts , will enable me to point out , with more clearness , what parts of the theory appear defective , and what improvements may be made on it .
It is true that the membrana tym pani is stretched and relaxed by the action of the muscles of the malleus , but not for the purpose alleged in the commonly received theory .
It is stretched , in order to bring the radiated muscle of the membrane itself into a state capable of acting , and of giving those different degrees of tension to the membrane which empower it to correspond with the variety of external tremors : when the membrane is relaxed , the radiated muscle cannot act with any effect , and external tremors make less accurate impressions .
The membrana tympani , with its tensor and radiated muscles , may be not unaptly compared to a monochord , of which the membrana tympani is the string ; the tensor muscle the screw , giving the necessary tension to make the string perform its proper scale of vibrations ; and the radiated muscle acting upon the membrane like the moveable bridge of the monochord , adjusting it to the vibrations required to be produced .
The combined effects of the action of these muscles give the perceptions of grave and acute tones ; and , in proportion as their original conformation is more or less perfect , so will their actions be , and , consequently , the perceptions of sound which they communicate .
This mode of subdividing the motions of the membrana tympani between two sets of muscles , allotting a portion to each , is not peculiar to this part .
A remarkable instance of it -appears in the rapid movements of the fingers , in performing several actions , and particularly in playing on a musical instrument .
In all such rapid motions , the fingers are bent to a certain degree by the long muscles that lie upon the fore-arm , to the tendons of which a set of smaller muscles are attached , called lumbricales .
These last are unable to produce any effect on the fingers , till elongated in consequence of the action of the long muscles in bending the other joints the lumbricales then become capable of bending the fingers a little more , and of acting with great rapidity .
It is ' a curious circumstance , that a similar application of muscles should be employed to fit the fingers to produce a quick succession of sounds , and to enable the ear to be impressed by them .
From the explanation given of the adjustment of the membrana tympani , the difference between a musical ear and one which is too imperfect to distinguish the different notes in music , will appear to arise entirely from the greater or less nicety with which the muscle of the malleus renders the membrane capable of being truly adjusted .
If the tension be perfect , all the variations produced by the action of the radiated muscle will be equally correct , and the ear truly musical ; but , if the first adjustment is imperfect , although the actions of the radiated muscle may still produce infinite variations , none of them will be correct : the effect , in this respect , will be similar to that produced by playing upon a musical instrument which is not in tune .
' The hearing of articulate sounds requires less nicety in the adjustment , than of inarticulate or musical ones : an ear may therefore be able to perceive the one , although it is not fitted to receive distinct perceptions from the other .
The nicety or correctness of a musical ear being the result of muscular action , renders it , in part , an acquirement ; for , although the original formation of these muscles in some ears renders them more capable of arriving at this perfection in their action , early cultivation is still necessary for that purpose ; and it is found that an ear , which upon the first trials seemed unfit to receive accurate perceptions of sounds , shall , by early and constant application , be rendered tolerably correct , but never can attain excellence .
There are organs of hearing in which the parts are so nicely adjusted to one another , as to render them capable of a degree of correctness in hearing sounds which appears preternatural .
Children who during their infancy are much in the society of musical performers , will be naturally induced to attend more to inarticulate sounds than articulate ones , and by these means acquire a correct ear , which , after listening for two or three years to articulate sounds only , would have been attained with more difficulty .
This mode of adapting the ear to different sounds , appears to be one of the most beautiful applications of muscles in the body ; the mechanism is so simple , and the variety of effects so great .
Several ways in which the correctness of hearing is affected by the wrong actions of the muscles of the tympanum , that appeared to be inexplicable , can be readily accounted for , now that the means by which the membrane adjusts itself are understood .
The following are instances of this kind .
CASE 1 .
A gentleman thirty-three years of age , who possessed a very correct ear , so as to be cap-able of singing in concert , though he had never learned music , was suddenly seized witha giddiness in the head , and a slight degree of numbness in the right side and arm .
These feelings went off in a few hours , but on the third day returned , and for several weeks he had returns of the same sensations .
It was soon discovered that he had lost his musical ear ; he could neither sing a note inltune , nor in the smallest degree perceive harmony in the performance of others .
For some time he himself thought he had become a little deaf , but his medical attendant was not sensible of that in conversation .
Upon going into the country , he derived great benefit from exercise and sea-bathing .
Twenty months after the first attack , he was capable of sings ing a Scotch air with tolerable exactness , though he could not sing in , concert .
He continued to improve in his health , and in the course of twoor three years completely recovered his ear for music .
In this case , there appeared to be some affection of the brain , which had diminished the actions of the tensor muscles of the membrana tympani , through the medium of the nerves which regulate their actions ; this gradually went off , and the muscles recovered their former action .
CASE 2 .
A young lady was seized with a frenzy which lasted for several years .
Previous to her derangement , she was incapable of singing in tune , from the want of an ear for music ; but in the course of her madness she frequently , to the astonishment of her relations , sung a tune with tolerable correctness .
This case is the reverse of the former ; and , as it arose from a directly contrary affection of the brain may be considered as the result of an unusual degree of action in the tensor muscles , giving the membrane a more correct adjustment than it had before .
CASE 3 .
An eminent music master , after catching cold , found a confusion of sounds in his ears .
Upon strict attention , he discovered that the pitch of one ear was half a note lower than that of the other ; and that the perception of a simple sound did not reach both ears at the same instant , but seemed as two distinct sounds , following each other in quick succession , the last being the lowest and weakest .
This complaint distressed him for a long time , but he recovered from it without any medical aid .
Inr this case , the whole defect appears to have been in the action of the radiated muscle , exerted neither with the same quickness nor force in one ear as in the other , so that the sound was half a note too low , as well as later in being impressed upon the organ .
This affection of the muscle of the membrana tympani is very similar to an affection of the straight muscles of one of the eyes , producing double vision , which I have noticed in a former lecture , when treating of the wrong actions of that organ.* In endeavouring to explain the uses of the more internal parts of the ear , considerable advantage may be derived from classing them in two divisions ; namely , those which are formed for the purpose of receiving impressions conveyed through the medium of liquid or of solid substances ; and those adapted to receive impressions made by the impulses of an elastic fluid , as the common air .
This can be done very correctly .
Fish , which are formed to hear in water , can have only the parts belonging to the first division ; while all the parts found in the ears of birds and Vide Philosophical Transactions for the year 1797 .
quadrupeds , that are not met with in fish , must belong to the second .
In fish , the organ consists of a vestibulum and three semicircular canals , and these are met with in all fish .
In some genera there is an external opening , and substances of a hard nature are found lying loose in the vestibulum : these , however , cannot be considered as essential parts of the organ , from their not being common to fish in general .
Birds have the vestibulum and semicircular canals in common with fish , but they have also a membrana tympani ; a slender bone connecting that membrane with the vestibulum ; and an Eustachian tube .
In birds , the membrana tympani is convex externally , being pushed forwards by the end of the slender bone abovementioned .
In quadrupeds and man , besides the vestibulum and canals met with in fish , the membrana tympani , the bone connecting it with the vestibulum , and the Eustachian tube , found in birds , there is a cochlea .
The membrana tympani is either flat or concave externally ; the bony connection between it and the vestibulum is made up of several bones , supplied with muscles to move them in different directions .
The parts which compose the organ of hearing in fish , must be intended for receiving impressions conveyed through water : those additional parts met with in birds , and the still greater addictions which are found in the , quadruped and man , must be intended by nature for rendering more perfect the impressions conveyed to the ear through the medium of the external air .
Fish , from the structure of the organ , can only hear sounds which agitate the water immediately in contact with the head of the fish ; so that the impulse is conveyed , without interruption , from the liquid in which they live , to the organ of P. hearing .
Man is capable of hearing in a similar manner to fishes , when a communication of solid parts is kept up between the sounding body and the bones of the skull : experiments of this kind must have been made by many members of this learned Society .
One of the most common is , applying a watch to the forehead , and stopping the ears , which does not prevent the ticking from being heard : the sound is still more distinct when the watch is applied to the mastoid process .
Here , as the sound can neither pass through the mneatus externus , nor by the Eustachian tube , while themouth is kept shut , it evidently must be conducted through the bones of the skull .
When the sound produced by boiling water is brought to the ear , by one end of an iron rod resting upon the side of the kettle and the other kept in contact with the teeth , the sound is conducted in the same way , although in this case it has by some been supposed to pass through the Eustachian tube .
In this mode of hearing , the vestibulum and semicircular canals are probably the only parts of the organ which are necessary to convey the impression to the expansion of the auditory nerve .
In hearing in air , the use of the membrana tympani in man and quadrupeds has already been explained .
Its office in birds is precisely the same ; but as in birds this membrane has no tensor muscle to vary its adjustment , but is always kept tense by the pressure of the end of the slender bone , the scale in birds cannot descend so low as in the human ear ; and theintervals in their scale will be more minute , in consequence of the slightest tremor communicated by the action of the radiated .
muscle to one end of the slender bone being immediately conducted to the internal organ ; while in the human ear it has to pass from one bone to another , before it arrives at the vestibu- .
lum .
The cochlea has been considered by all physiologists as one of the most intricate and curious parts of the ear , and on that account had a most important office assigned to it .
This , honwever , is now to be transferred to the membrana tympani ; and , upon attentive consideration of the subject , it will appear imp possible for the cochlea to be of any use in modulating sounds , since the ear is only intended to convey impressions received from external bodies ; hence , no impression can be communicated to the cochlea , which has not been transmitted by the membrana tympani .
But , if all the varieties of sound are repeated by the membrana tympani , no modulation in the cochlea is required ; and , when it is considered that the cochlea contains water , instead of air , the effect upon every part will be found to be simultaneous .
That the cochlea is neither absolutely necessary to fit the organ to be impressed by sounds communicated through air , nor to render it what is termed a musical ear , is sufficiently proved by that part being wanting in birds , whose organ is particularly adapted to inarticulate sounds .
Some birds , particularly bulfinches , can be taught to sing various airs , although it will -be always in high notes .
If it should be found that birds hear less accurately than quadrupeds , it will favour the idea that the great delicacy of structure of the cochlea , is intended to render the nerves which are spread upon it more readily impressed by weak tremors , than those in either the vestibulum or semicircular canals .
The cochlea and semicircular canals must be considered as two of the most important parts of the ear ; their peculiar forms are no doubt adapted to some essential purposes ; but , what are the precise advantages derived from their particular shape , is at present unknown .
There is , however , much ground to believe , that a more extensive knowledge in comparative anatomy , joined with future observations , may clear up this very curious and obscure part of the physiology of the organ of hearing .
In the elephant , the small bones , the cochlea , and semicircular canals , are larger than those in the human ear , nearly in the same proportion with the increased size of the membrana tympaani .
In that animal , there is a very remarkable peculiarity ; which is , a cellular structure occupying the upper and posterior part of the skull , enclosed between the two tables , communicating by a considerable aperture with the cavity of the tympanum , and lined by a similar membrane : the cells communicate freely with one another at their lower extremities , but not near the upper , forming irregular cylinders , placed in a converging direction , towards the cavity of the tympanum .
There is no middle bony septum , separating the cells of the skull belonging to one ear from those which open into the other , but a ready communication between them .
On the anterior part of the skull there is also a similar cellular structure , only much smaller , which communicates with the nose , but is entirely separate and distinct from that which forms an appendage to the organ of hearing .
That the elephant hears better than other animals , is generally asserted by those-who have had opportunities of making observations on the subject .
As this opinion has been advanced by men who had no knowledge in anatomy , and had 1 ) e no previous theory to bias their judgment , it is deserving of credit .
The organ of hearing being now found more perfect , and formed upon a larger scale than in any other animal with which we are acquainted , considerable weight is given to this opinion .
Mr. CORSE , who resided many years at Tiperah , in Bengal , and paid particular attention to the manners and habits of ele .
phants , concurs in the belief of their hearing being more acute than that of man .
The following circumstances are mentioned by him in proof of it .
A tame elephant , who was never reconciled to have a horse moving behind him , although he expressed no uneasiness if the horse was within his view , either before or on one side , could distinguish the sound of a horse 's foot at a distance , some time before any person in company heard it : this was known by his pricking up his ears , quickening his pace , and turning his head from side to side .
A tame female elephant , who had a young one , was occasionally sent out with other elephants for food , without the young one being allowed to follow .
She was not in the habit of pining after her young one , unless she heard its voice ; but frequently , on the road home , when no one could distinguish any sound whatever , she pricked up her ears , and made a noise expressive of having heard the call of her young .
This having occurred frequently , attracted Mr. CORSE 's notice , and made hlim , at the time the female elephant used these expressions , stop the party , and desire the gentlemen to listen ; but they were unable to hear any thing till they had approached nearer to the place where the young one was kept .
The foregoing observations , the object of which has been to prove that the membrana tympani of the ear has a muscular structure , have already exceeded the limits of a lecture , which prevents us from going further at present into the consideration of this very curious and important organ .
The general analogy between the uses of its different parts and those of the organ of vision , and the similar variations of their actions when under the influence of disease , furnish materials which , on some future occasion , may be laid before this learned Society .
PHILOSOPHICAL TRA-NSACTION S. I. The Croonian Lecture .
On the Structure and Uses of the Memo brana Tympani of the Ear .
By Everard Home , Esq. F. R. S. Read November 7 , l 799 .
THE subject of inquiry appointed by the Croonian Institution , has been greatly elucidated at different times by ingenious members of this learned Society .
A large field , however , still remains open ; and , respecting future investigations , I shall have occasion to offer a fresh proof of the aid to be derived from comparative anatomy , in ascertaining the structure of parts which , from their minuteness and situation in the human body , admit with much difficulty of being explored .
The principal object of the present lecture is to communicate a discovery of the structure of the membrana tympani ; which , in some respects , affords a new and very curious instance of the application of muscular action , and may conduce to account for certain phanomena in the sense of hearing , in a more satisfactory manner than has hitherto been proposed .
The membrana tympani has always been considered as a common membrane , which , by means of muscles belonging to the malleus being stretched or relaxed , became fitted , in its -various degrees of tension , to convey the vast variety of external sounds to the internal organ .
Its shape , situation , and office , have procured it the name of drum of the ear ; and the muscles of the malleus having been deemed sufficient for bracing and unbracing it , less attention was bestowed on the structure of the membrane itself : to which may be added , that In the human ear , and generally in the ear of quadrupeds , the membrane is so extremely small and thin , and in its situation so peculiarly confined , as not to be got at for inspection but with much difficulty .
The case is different in the elephant , where this membrane is so very large , that the parts of which it is composed are readily distinguished : they are even conspicuous to the naked eye ; and muscular fibres are seen passing along the membrane , in a radiated manner , from the bony rim which surrounds it , towards the handle of the malleus to which the central part of the membrane is firmly attached .
This discovery in the elephant having led to that of a similar construction in the human membrana tympani , it may not be improper to relate the circumstances by which I became engaged in the investigation of the organ of hearing in that animal .
Three different opportunities have occurred of dissecting the elephant in London , by the deaths of those which had been presented to his Majesty , and were kept at the King 's stables at Pimlico .
One of them was given to the late Dr. HUNTER ; one to his brother Mr. J. HUNTER ; and the third to Sir ASHTON LEVER .
From my being connected with Mr. JOHN HUNTER'S pursuits in comparative anatomy , I was employed throughout the whole of these dissections , and became extremely desirous of examining the initernal parts of the ear , the structure of that organ in the human body having at a very early period particularly engaged my attention ; * but neither Dr. HUNTER nor his brother could be prevailed upon to sacrifice so large a portion of the skull as was necessary for the purpose .
When Mr. CORSE arrived from Bengal , last year , and mentioned his having brought over a number of skulls of elephants , in order to show the progress of the formation of their grinding teeth , ?
the desire to examine the organ of hearing in that animal recurred to me so strongly , that I requested to have one of the skulls for that purpose , and Mr. CORSE very readily and obligingly complied with my request .
After having examined the organ in the dried skull , the want of the membrana tympani , and of the small bones , made the information thus received of a very unsatisfactory nature , and increased the desire of seeing these parts in the recent head .
In considering how this could be done , I recollected a mutilated elephant 's head , preserved in spirits , which had been sent to

