X~VIII Experiments and -Observations on Shell and Bone .
By Charles Hatchett , Esq. F. R. S. Read June 139 , 1799- .
SOME experiments which I lately made at the request of Mr. HOME , and which he has done me the honour to mention in his ingenious Paper on the teeth of graminivorous quadrupeds , induced me to turn my attention more particularly to the chemical examination of -shell and bone , especially as the formerappeared to have been hitherto much neglected .
The time since these experiments were began- , has not been sufficient to enable me to enter into all the minutia of the chemical analysis of these substances ; but , .
as some remarkable facts were ascertained , I have now ventured to bring them forward , with the addition of some observations , although , as yet , the whole is little more than a very imperfect outline .
The first of these experiments were made on the shells of marine animals ; and , to avoid repetition and prolixity , I shall in a great measure , once for all describe the menstrua , the precipitants , and the mode of operation .
When shells were examined , they were immersed in acetous acid , or nitric acid diluted according to circumstances , with 4 , A , 6 , or more parts of distilled water ; and the solution was always made-without heat .
The carbonate of lime was precipitated by carbonate of am.moniac , or of potash ; and phosphate of lime ( if present ) was previously precipitated by pure or caustic ammoniac .
If any other phosphate , like that of soda , was suspected , it was discovered by solution of acetite of lead .
Bones and teeth were also subjected to the action of the acetous , or diluted nitric and muriatic acids .
The dissolved portion was examined by the abovementioned precipitants ; and , in experiments where the quantity of the substance would permit , the phosphoric acid was also separated by nitric or sulphuric acid .
The phosphoric acid thus obtained , was proved , after concentration , by experiments which , being usually employed for such purposes , are too well known to require description .
It is necessary moreover to observe , that as the substances examined were very numerous , and my principal object was to discover the most prominent characters in them , I did not , for thepresent , attempt in general to ascertain minutely the proportions3so much as the number and quality , of their respective ingredients .
The greater part , if not all , of marine shells , appear to be of two descriptions , in respect to the substance of which they arc composed .
Those which will be first noticed , have a porcellaneous aspect , with an enamelled surface , and , when broken , are often in a slight degree of a fibrous texture .
The shells of the other division have generally , if not always , a strong epidermis , under which is the shell , principally or entirely composed of the substance called nacre or mother of pearl .
Of the porcellaneous shells , various species of Voluta , Cyprxa , and others of a similar nature , were examined .
Of the shells composed of nacre or mother of pearl , I selected the oyster , the-river muscle , the Haliotis Iris , and the Turbo olearius. .
Experiments on Porcellaneous Shells .
Shells of this:description , when exposed to a red heat in a -crucible , during about a quarter of an hour , crackled and lost the colours of their enamelled surface ; they did not emit any apparent smoke , nor any smell like that of burned horn or cartilage .
Their figure remained unchanged , excepting a few flaws ; and theybecame of an opaque white tinged partially with pale gray , but retained part of their original gloss .
The shells which had not been exposed to fire , ( whether entire or in powder , ) dissolved with great effervescence in the various acids ; and the solution afterwardsremained colourless and transparent .
But the shells which had been burned , upon being dissolved , deposited a very small quantity of animal coal ; and thereby the presence of some gluten was denoted although the proportion was too small to be discovered in the solution of the shells which had not been burned .
The various solutions were filtrated , and were examined by pure ammoniac and acetite of lead ; but I never obtained any trace of phosphate of Jime , nor of any other combination of phosphoric acid .
The carbonate of lime was afterwards precipitated by carbonate of ammoniac ; ; and , from many experiments it appeared , that porcellaneous shells consist of carbonate of lime , cemented by a very small portion of animal gluten .
Previous to the experiments on shells composed of:nacre or mother of pearl , I examined some Patellae from Madeira .
When thesewere exposed to a red heat in a crucible , there was a perceptible smell , like that of horn , hair , or feathers .
The proportion of carbonic matter deposited by the subsequent solution , was more considerable than that of the shells abovementioned ; and the proportion of carbonate of lime , relative to their weight , was less .
When the recent shells were immersed in very dilute nitric acid , the epidermis was separated , the whole of the carbonate of lime was dissolved , and a gelatinous substance , nearly liquid , remained ; but without retaining the figure of the shell , and without any fibrous appearance .
These shells evidently , therefore , contain a larger portion of a more viscid gelatinous substance than those before mentioned ; but the solution , separated from the gelatinous substance , afforded nothing but carbonate of lime .
, Experiments on Shells composed of Nacre or Mother of Pearl .
When the shell of the common oyster was exposed to a red heat , the effects were the same as those observed in the Patellae and the solution of the unburned shell was similar , only the gelatinous part was rather of a greater consistency .
A species of the river muscle was next subjected to experiment .
This , when burned in a crucible , emitted much Smoke , with a strong smell of burned cartilage or horn ; the shell throughout became of a dark gray , and exfoliated .
By solution in the acids , a large quantity of carbonic matter was separated ; and much less of carbonate of lime was obtained , from a given weight of the shell , than from those already mentioned .
Upon immersing an unburned shell in dilute nitric acid , a rapid solution and effervescence at first took place , but gradually became less , so that the disengagement of the carbonic acid gas was to be perceived only at intervals At the end of two days , I found nearly the whole0of the carbonate of lime dissolved ; but a series of membranes , retaining the figure of the shell , remained , of which the epidermis consti tuted the first .
In the-beginnhing , the carbonate of lime was readily dissolved , because the acid menstruum had an easy access ; but , after this , it had more difficulty to insinuate itself between the different membranes , and of course the solution of the carbonate of lime was slower .
During the solution , the carbonic acid gas was entangled , and retained in many places between the membranes , so-as to give to the whole a cellular appearance .
The Haliqtis Iris , and the Turbo olearius , resembled this muscle , excepting that their membranaceous parts were more compact and dense .
These shells , when deprived by an acid menstruum of their hardeningsiubs tance , or carbonate of lime , appear to be formed of various membranes , applied stratum ; super stratum .
Each membrane has a corresponding coat or crust of carbonate of lime ; which is so situated , that it is always between every two membranes , beginning with the epidermis , and endingwith the last formed internal membrane .
The animals which inhabit these stratified shells , increase their habitation by the addition of a stratum of carbonate of lime , secured by a new membrane ; and , as every additional stratum exceeds in extent that which was previously formed , the-shell becomes stronger in proportion as it is enlarged ; T. t 2 and the growth and age of the animal become denoted , by the number of the strata which concur to form the shell .
Although the Haliotis Iris and the Turbo olearius are composed of the true mother of pearl , I was induced to repeat the foregoing experiments , on some detached pieces of mother of pearl , such as are brought from China .
These experiments I need not describe , as the results were precisely the same .
I must , however observe , that the membranaceous or cartilaginous parts of these shells , as well as of the pieces of mother of pearl , retained the exact figure of the shell , or piece , which had been immersed in the acid menstruum ; and these membranaceous parts distinctly appeared to be composed of fibres placed in a parallel direction , corresponding to the configuration of the shell .
The same experiments were made on pearls ; which proved to be similar in composition to the mother of pearl ; and , so far as their size would enable me to discern , they appeared to be formed by concentric coats of membrane and carbonate of lime ; by this structure , they much resemble the globular calcareous concretions , found -at Carlsbad and other places , called Pisolithes .
The wavy appearance and irridescency of mother of pearl , and of pearl , are evidently the edect of their lamellated structure and semitransparency ; in which , in some degree , they are resembled by the lamellated stone called Adularia .
When the experiments on the porcellaneous shells , and on those formed of mother of pearl are compared , it appears , that the porcellaneous shells are composed of carbonate of lime , cemented by a very small , portion of-g luten ; and that mother of pearl and pearl do not differ from .
these , except by a smaller proportion of carbonate of lime ; which , instead of being simply cemented by animal gluten , is intermixed with , and serves to harden , a membranaceous or cartilaginous substance ; and this substance , even when deprived of the carbonate of lime , still retains the figure of the shell .
But , between these extremes there will , probably , be found many gradations ; and these we have the greater reason to expect , from the example afforded by the Patelke , which have been lately mentioned .
Some few experiments were made on certain land shells ; and , in the common garden snail I thought that I discovered some traces of phosphate of lime ; but , as I did not find any in the Helix nemoralis , it may be doubted whether the presence of phosphate of lime should be considered as a chemical character of land shells.* Experiments on the covering Substance of crustaceous Marine Animals.4 As I was not acquainted with any experiments by which the chemical nature of the substance which covers crustaceous marine animals had been determined , I was desirous to ascertain in what respect it was different from shell , and I began these on-three species of the Echinus , with which I had been favoured by the Right Honourable President .
I was the more inclined to begin with the Echini , because naturalists do not appear to be perfectly agreed , whether to call them testaceous or crustaceous animals .
KLEIN , who has written a work upon Echini , after having.noticed the various opinions of RONDELET , RUMPHIUS , and -others , determines that they are to be regarded as testaceous.animals .
His words are , " Sic plurimas testas marinas , in " statu naturali consideratas , cum echinodermatis potius quam " cum crustis astacorum vel cancrorum confer licebit .
Itaque " echinoderma , cum ARISTOTELE , qui echinos inter testacea quiz " bus facultas ingrediendi est reponit , nec non cum BELONIO " ALDROVANDO , et excellentissimo SLOANIO ; religiose testam appellamus , quam satis duram in nxonnullis offendimus .
" But LINNJEUS was of the contrary opinion , as appears from his definition of the echinus .
" Corpus subrotundum , crusta ossea tectum , spinis mobilibus sepius aspera .
" ?
Now , as the experiments above related had proved , that the shells of marine animals were composed of carbonate of lime , without any phosphate , I thougoht it very possible , that the covering of the crustaceous animals might , in some respect , be , different , and if so , I should thus , by chemical characters , be enabled to ascertain the class to which the Echinus was to be referred .
Of the three Echini which were examined , one had small spines ; the second had large obtuse spires ; 7 and the third was of a very flat form .
* KLEINX , Naturalis disposition Echinodermatum , &amp;c. p. 10 t Systema Nature .
Edit .
GM L1N , P. 3168 .
Portions of these echini were separately immersed in acetous , muriatic , and diluted nitric acid , by each of which they were completely dissolved , with much effervescence ; depositing , at the same time , a thin outer skin or epidermis .
The transparency of the solutions was also disturbed by a portion of gluten , which remained suspended , and communicated a brownish colour to the liquors .
The solutions in acetous and diluted nitricacid were filtrated ; after which , from the acetous solution of each Echinus , I obtained a precipitate of phosphate of lead , by the addition of acetite of lead ; and , having thus proved the presence of phosphoric acid , I saturated the nitric solutions with pure , ammoniac , by which a quantity of phosphate of lime was obtained , much inferior , however , in quantity , to the carbonate of lime , which was afterwards precipitated by carbonate of ammoniac .
The composition of the crust of the Echinus is therefore dif- .
ferent from that of marine shells ; and , by the relative proportions and nature of the ingredients , it approaches most nearly to the shells of the eggs of birds ; which , in like manner , consist of carbonate , with a small proportion of phosphate of limej .
cemented by gluten .
It remained now , to examine the composition of those substances which are decidedly called crustaceous ; but , previous to this , some experiments Were made on the Asterias or star-fish , of which I took the species commonly found on our coasts , and known by the popular name of five fingers , ( Asterias rubens .
) The Asterias is thus described by LINNAUS .
" Corpus de " pressum , subtus sulcatum : crusta coriacea , tentaculis murin"cata .
" * When the Asterias was immersed in the acids , a considerable effervescence was produced , and a thin external stratum was dissolved ; after which , it remained in a perfectly coriaceous ?
tate , and complete , ' in respect to the original figure .
The dissolved portion , being examined by the usual precipi-c tants , proved to be carbonate of lime , without any mixture of phosphate ; -'but , in another species of the Asterias , which had twelve rays , ( Asterias papposa , ) I discovered a small quantity of phosphate of lime .
I am therefore induced to -sus-pect , that in the different species of the Asterias , nature makes an imperfect-attempt to -formshell on some , and a crustaceous coating on others ; and that a series of gradations is thus formed , between the testaceous , the crustaceous , and the coriaceous marine animals .
it was now requisite to ascertain if phosphate 'of lim e is a component part of the substance which covers the crustaceous marine or aquatic animals , such as the crab , lobster , prawn , and crayfish .
Pieces of this stibtante , taken from various parts of those &gt; :animals , was , at different times , immersed in acetous , and in diluted nitric acid ; 'those which had been placed in the diluted nitric acid , produced a moderate effervescence , and in a short time were found to be soft and elastic , of a yellowish-white colour , and like a cartilage which retained theforiginal figure .
The same effects were produced by acetous acid , but in a less degree ; in the latter case also , the 'colouring matter remained , and was soluble in alcohol .
All the solutions , both acetous and nitric , afforded carbonate and phosphate of lime , although the former was in the largest proportion .
There is reason to conclude , therefore , that phosphate of lime , -miingled with the carbonate , is a chemical characteristic which distinguishes the crustaceous from the testaceous substances ; and that the principal difference in the qualities of each , when complete , is caused by the proportion of the hardening substances , relative to the gluten by which they are cemented ; orby the abundance and consistency of the gelatinous , membranaceous , or cartilaginous substance , in and on which , the carbonate of lime , or the mixture of carbonate and phosphate of lime , has been secreted and deposited .
Moreover , as the presence of phosphate of lime , mingled with carbonate , appears to be a chemical character of crusta'ceous marine animals , there is every reason to conclude that LINNAEuS did right not to place the Echini among the testaceous ones .
The presence of phosphate of lime , in the substance which covers the crustaceous marine animals , appears to denote an approximation to the nature of bone , which , not only by the experiments of Mr. GAHN , but by the united testimony of all chemists , has been proved principally to consist ( as far as the ossifying substance is concerned ) of phosphate of lime .
This consideration , therefore , induced me to repeat the above experiments , on the bones of various animals .
It is scarcely necessary for me to mention the usual effects of acids on bones steeped in them , as they are known to every physiologist and anatomist .
In every operation of this nature , the ossifying substance , which is principally phosphate of lime , is dissolved and a cartilage or membrane , of the figure of the original bone , remains ; so that the first origin of bones appears to be by the formation of -a membrane or cartilage , of the requisite figure , which , when the subsequent secretion of the osifying substane takes place , is penetrated by it , and thus becomes more or less converted into the state of bone .
It is also known , that the nature of the bone is more influenced by the greater or less predominance of the membranaceous or cartilaginous part , than by any other cause .
It is not , therefore , for me to add any thing to this part ; and , in respect to the substance-which is the cause of ossification , little also requires to be mentioned , for this ( as has been already observed ) is known principally to consist of phosphate of lime .
I shall only , therefore , briefly mention the results of certain experiments .
The bones of fish , such as those of the salmon , mackerel , brill , and skate , afforded phosphate of lime ; and the only difference was , that the bones of these fish appeared in general to contain more of the cartilaginous substance , relative to the phosphate of lime , than is commonly found in the bones of quadrupeds , &amp;c. The different bones , also , of the same fish , were various in this respect ; and the bones about the head of the skate , only differed from cartilage , by containing a moderate proportion of phosphate of lime .
It is at present believed that phosphate , with some sulphate of lime , constitutes the whole of the ossifying substance ; and perhaps the formation of bone from cartilage , depends only on the phosphate of lime ; but , whether this is the case or not , it is fit that I should notice a third substance , which constantly occurred.in the course of my experiments .
When human bones , or teeth , as well as those of quadrupeds and fish , whether recent or calcined , were exposed to the action of acids , an effervescence , although at times but feeble , was produced .
This circumstance , at first , I did not particularly notice , but the following experiments excited my attention .
After the phosphate of lime had been precipitated from the solutions of various teeth and bones , by pure ammoniac , I observed , that a second precipitate , much smaller in quantity , was obtained by the addition of carbonate of ammoniac .
This second precipitate dissolved in acids , with much effervescence , during which , carbonic acid was disengaged ; and selenite was formed by adding sulphuric acid .
Moreover , the solution of this precipitate did not contain any -phosphoric acid ; nor did the liquor from which the precipitate had been separated afford any trace of it .
This precipitate was therefore carbonate of lime ; but I still was not certain that it existed , as such , in the teeth and bones .
Although regular and comparative analyses of the bones of different animals have not hitherto been made , yet , by the experiments of Messrs. GAHN , SCHEELE , MACQUER , FOURcROY , BERNIARD , and the Marquis de BULLION , it has been proved , that phosphate of lime is the principal ossifying substance of bones in general , and that this is accompanied by a small proportion of some saline substances , and by sulphate of lime .
I was therefore desirous to ascertain , whether the carbonate of lime which I had obtained by the abovementioned experiments , had been produced from the sulphate of lime decom- .
posed -by the alkaline precipitant , or whether the greater part had not existed in the bones , in the state of carbonate .
Each of the solutions in nitric acid afforded a precipitate with nitrate of barytes ; but the quantity of sulphuric acid thus separated , appeared by far too small to be capable of saturating the whole of the carbonate of liRme obtained from an equal quantity of the solution .
To prove , therefore , the presence of the carbonic acid , :and theconsequent formation of carbonate of lime , portions of the various teeth and bones were immersed , at separate times ; in muriatic acid ; and the gas produced was received in line water , by which it was speedily absorbed , and a proportionate quantity of carbonate of lime was obtained .
Although it appears , that the principal effects during ossification are produced by phosphate of lime , yet we here see , that not only some sulphate , but also some carbonate of lime , enters the composition of bones ; and it is not a little curious to observe , that as the carbonate of lime exceeds in quantity the phosphate of lime in crustaceous marine animals , and in the egg shells of birds , so in bones it is vice versa .
It is possible , when many accurate comparative analyses of bones have been made , that some may be found composed only of phosphate of lime ; and that thus , shells containing only carbonate of lime , and bones containing only phosphate of lime , will form the two extremi.ties of the chain .
I shall now make a few remarks on the enamel of teeth .
When a tooth coated with enamel is 'immersed in diluted nitric or muriatic acid , a feeble effervescence takes place , and the enamel i 's completely dissolved ; so also is the bony part , but the cartilage of that part is left , retaining the shape of the tooth .
Or , if a tooth in which the enamel is intermixed with the bony substance , is plunged in the acid , the enamel and the bony part are dissolved , in the same manner as before ; that is to say , the enamel is completely taken up by the acid , while the tooth , like other bones , remains in a pulpy or cartilaginous state , having been deprived of the ossifying substance .
Consequently , those parts which were coated or penetrated by lines of enamel , are diminished , in proportion to the thickness of the enamel which has been thus dissolved ; but little or no diminution is , observed in the tooth.* Mr. HUNTER has noticed this ; and , speaking of enamel , says , " s when soaked in a gentle acid , there appears nogristly or " c fleshy part with which the earthy part had been incor " ; porated."+ Now , when the difference ' which has ' been lately stated , ' between porcellaneous shell and mother of pearl , is considered , it is not possible to avoid the comparing of these to enamel and : tooth .
When porcellaneous shell , whole-or in-powder , is exposed to the action of acids , it is completely dissolved , without .
leaving any residcuum .
Enamel is also 'completely dissolved , in thelike manner .
' Porcellaneous shell and enamel , when burned , emit little .
or no smoke , nor-scarcely any smell of burned-horn , or cartilage .
Their figure , after having been exposed to fire , is not mate-s rially -changed , except by cracking in some parts : their external gloss partly remains , and their colour at most becomes gray , verydifferent from what happens to mother of pearl , or tooth .
Intheir fracture they have a fibrous texture ; and , in short , the only essential difference between them appears to be , that porcellaneous shell consists of carbonate of lime , and enamel of phosphate .
of lime , each being cemented by a snmall-portion of gluten .
In like manner , if the effects produced by fire and acid menstrua , on shells composed of mother of pearl , and on the substance of teeth Land bone , are compared , a great similarity will be found ; for , when exposed to a red heat , ist .
They smoke much , and emit a smell of-burned cartilage , or horn .
2dly .
They become of a dark gray or black colour .
3dly .
The animal coal thus formed is of difficult incineration .
4thly .
They retain much of their original figure ; but the membranaceous shells are subject to exfoliate.* 5thly .
These substances , ( pearl , mother of pearl , tooth , and bone , ) when immersed in certain acids , part with their hardening or ossifying substances , and then remain in the state of membrane or cartilage .
6thly .
When previously burned , and afterwards dissolved in acids , a quantity of animal coal is separated , according to the proportion of the gelatinous , membranaceous , or cartilaginous substance , and according to the duration of the red heat .
And lastly , the acid solutions of these substances , by proper precipitants , afford carbonate of lime , in the one case , and phosphate of lime principally , in the other , in a proportion relative to the membrane or cartilage with which , or on which , the one or the other had been mixed , or deposited .
As porcellaneous shell principally differs from mother of pearl , only by a relative proportion between the carbonate of lime and the gluten or membrane , in like manner , the enamel appears only to be different from tooth or bone , by being destitute of cartilage , and by being principally formed of phosphate of lime , cemented by gluten .
The difference , in the latter case , seems to expliain why the bones and teeth of animals fed on madder become red , when , at the same time , the like colour is not communicated to the enamel ; for it appears probable , that the cartilages-which form the original structure of the teeth and bones become the channels by which the tinging principle is communicated and diffused % .
These comparative experiments prove , that there is a great approximation in the nature of porcellaneousshell and the enamel of teethe and also in that of mother of pearl and bone ; and , if a shell should be found composed of mother of pearl coated by the porcellaneous substance , it will resemble a tooth coated by the enamel , with the difference-of carbonate being .
substituted for phosphate of lime .
Some experiiments on ' cartilaginous substances I ( which I intended to have inserted in this Paper , but which I am prevented from doing , as they are not as yet sufficiently advanced , ) have in a great measure convinced me , that membranes and cartilages ( whether destined to become bones by a natural process , as in young animals- , or whether they become such by morbid ossification , as often happens in those which are aged , ) do not contain the ossifying substance , or phosphate of lime , as a constituent principle .
I mean by this , that I believe the portionof phosphate of lime found in cartilaginous and horny sub ; stances to be simply mixed as an extraneous matter ; and that , when it is absent , membrane , cartilages and horn , aree most perfect and complete .
The frequent-presence-ofl phosphate-of lime in cartilaginous substances , is not a proof of its being one of their constituent principles , but -only that it has become deposited and mixed wlith .
, them , .
in .
proportion.to the .
, tendency they may.have to .
form modifications of bone ; or according to their vicinity with such membranes or cartilages as are liable to such a change .
If horns are examined , few I believe will be found to contain phosphate of lime in such a proportion as to be considered an essential ingredient .
I would not be understood to speak here of such as stag or buck horn , for that has every chemical character of bone , with some excess of cartilage ; but I allude to those in which the substance of the horn is distinctly separate from the bone , and which , like a sheath , covers a bony protuberance which issues from theos frontis of certain animals.* Horns of this nature , such as those of the ox , the ram , and the chamois , also tortoise shell , afford , after distillation and in-cineration , so very small a residuum , of which only a small part is phosphate of lime , that this latter can scarcely be regarded as a necessary ingredient .
By some experiments made on 500C grains of the horn of the ox , I obtained , after a long continued heat , only i,50 gr. of residuum ; and , of this , less than half proved to be phosphate of lime .
78 grains of the horn of the chamois afforded only 0 , ,o of residuum and Soo grains of tortoise shell yielded not more than o,5 of a grain , of which less than half was phosphate of lime .
Now it must be evident , that so very small a quantity cannot influence the nature of the substances which afforded it ; , and the same may be said of synovia , 480 grains of which did not yield more than one grain of phosphate of lime .
This substance is undoubtedly various in its proportions , in , all these and other animal substances , arising probably from o Nature seems here to have made an analysis or separation of horn from bone .
the age and habit of the animal which has produced them ; but I believe that I may , at least , venture to place some confidence in the foregoing experiments , as several others , made since the above was written , have tended to confirm them- .
In the course of making the experiments which havebeen related , I examined the fossil bones of Gibraltar , as well as some glossopetre or shark 's teeth .
The latter afforded phosphate and carbonate of lime ; but the carbonate of lime was visibly owing principally to the matter of the calcareous strata which had enclosed these teeth , and ; which had insinuated itself into the cavities left by the decomposition of the original cartilaginous substance .
The bones of the Gibraltar rock also consist principally of phosphate of lime ; and the cavities have been partly filled by the carbonate of lime which cements theme together .
Fossil bones resemble boneswhich , by combustion , have , been deprived of their ; cartilaginous part ; for , they retain the .
figure of the original bone , without being bone in reality , as , one of the most essential parts has been-i taken away .
Now , such fossil or burned bones can no ; more be regarded as bone , * These experiments were repeated on bladder , which I chose in preference to any .
other membrane , as not being liable to ossification , and therefore likely to contain very little or no phosphate of lime .
z50 grains of dry hogs ' bladder , after incineration , left a residuum the weight of , which did not exceed - .
th of a grain .
This was dissolved in diluted nitric acid ; and , .
upon adding pure ammoniac , some faint traces of phosphate of lime were .
observed .
Now , as 25o grains of bladder did not afford more than."th of a grain of residuum , of which only a part consisted of phosphate of lime , there is much reason to regard &amp; this experiment as an additional proof , that phosphate of lime is not an essential ingredient of membrane .
than charcoal can be considered as the vegetable of which it retains the figure and fibrous structure .
Bones which keep their figure after combustion resemble charcoal made from vegetablesreplete with fibre ; and cartilagnous bones which lose their shape by the same cause , may be compared to succulent plants which are reduced in bulk and shape in a similar , manner .
From these last experiments , I much question if bodies consisting of phosphate of liime , , -like bones , have concurred materially to -form -strata of limestone or chalk ; for , it appears to be improbable that phosphate is converted into carbonate of lime , after these bodies have become extraneous fossils .
The destruction or decomposition , of the cartilaginous parts of teeth and bones in a fossil state , must have been the work of a very long period of time , unless accelerated by the action of some mineral principle ; for , after having , in the usual manner , steeped in muriatic acid the os humeri of a man brought from Hythe , in Kent , and said to have been taken from a Saxon tomb , I found the remaining cartilage nearly as complete as that of a recent bone .
The difficult destructibility of substances of a somewhat similar nature , appears also from the mining implements formed of horn , which are not unfrequently -found in excavations of high antiquity .

