XVII .
On dferent Sorts of Lime used in Agriculture .
By Smithson Tenant , Esq. F. IL Se Read June 6 , 1799 .
I WAS informed last summer , that in the neighbourhood of Doncaster , two kinds of lime were employed in agriculture , which were supposed to differ materially in their effects .
One of these , which was procured near the town , it was necessary to -use sparingly , and to spread very evenly over the land ; for it was said that a large proportion of it , instead of increasing , diminished the fertility of the soil ; and , that wherever a heap of it was left in one spot , all vegetation was prevented for many years .
Fifty or sixty bushels upon an acre , were considered to be as much as could be used with advantage .
The other sort of lime , which was obtained from a village near Ferry-bridge , though considerably dearer , from the distant carriage , was more frequently tenployed , on account of its superior utility .
A large quantity was never found to be injurious ; and the spots which were entirely covered with it , instead of being rendered barren , became remarkably fertile .
The different properties ascribed to these two kinds of lime were so very distinct , that it seemed probable they could not be imaginary ; and it therefore appeared to be worth the trouble of ascertaining them more fully , and of attempting to discover the , nature of the ingredients from whence the difference arose .
For this purpose , I procured some -pieces of each sort of limestone , and first tried what would be their effect upon vegetables , in their natural state , by reducing them to coarse powder , and sowing in them .
the seeds of different plants .
In both kinds , the seeds grew equally well , and nearly in the same manner as they would in sand , or any other substance which affords no nourishment to vegetables .
Pieces of each sort of stone 'were then burnt to lime ; and , after they had been exposed for some weeks to the air , that their causticity -might be diminished , some seeds weresown in them .
In the kind of lime which was found most beneficial to land , almost all the seeds came up , and continued to grow , as long as they were supplied with water ; and the roots of the plants had many fibres , which had penetrated to the bottom of the cup in which they grew .
Upon examining the composition of this sort of lime , it proved to consist entirely of calcareous earth .
By its exposure to the air for about three months , it was found to have absorbed four-fifths of the fixed air required to saturate it .
In the other kind , a few only of the seeds grew and the plants produced from them had hardly any stalks or roots , being formed almost entirely of the two seed-leaves , which lay quite loose upon the surface .
This sort of lime , being spread upon a garden soil , to the thickness of about the tenth of an inch , prevented nearly all the seeds which had been sown from coming up , whilst no injury was occasioned by common lime used in the same manner .
Upon examining the composition of this substance , which was so destructive to the plants , it was discovered to contain three parts of pure calcareous earth , and two of magnesia .
The quantity of fixed air which it had absorbed by being exposed for about the same time as the pure lime just mentioned , was only 4P hundredths of that combined with it before it was burnt .
As it seemed probable , that the magnesia contained in this lime was the cause of its peculiar properties , the following experiments were made , to determine the effects of that substance upon the growth of vegetables .
Some seeds , chiefly of colewort , which were preferred from their growing quickly , were sown in uncalcined magnesia ; but , though they sprouted , the leaves never rose above the surface , and the plants were entirely without roots : nor did they appear to grow better in magnesia which had been washed in-water containing fixed air .
Calcined magnesia was , however , much more destructive , as the seeds would not come up in it .
To compare its effects on vegetables with those of lime , each of these earths was mixed , in different proportions , with sand , in small cups , in which , ; seeds were then sown .
The lime was -obtained from marble ; and , before it was put into the sand , was made to fall to powder , by being moistened with water .
In a mixture of four ounces of sand with three or four grains of calcined magnesia , it was a long time before the seeds came up , and the plants bhad hardly any roots or stalks ; andJ , with ten grains or more of magnesia , there was no appearance of vegetation .
Thirty or forty grains of lime did not retard the growth of the seeds more than three or lour of magnesia , and the injurious efficts were not so lasting .
The lime , by absorbing fixed air , soon lost its destructive properties ; so that , after keeping these mixtures four or five weeks , seeds were found to grow in that with forty grains of lime , nearly as well as in pure sand ; but , in that with four grains of magnesia , they produced only the seed-leaves , as was described before .
It was necessary occasionally to break Ini pieces the sand which had so much lime , as it would otherwise have been too hard to admit the seeds to penetrate through it .
Plants will bear a much larger proportion of magnesia in vegetable soil than in sand-:with twenty grains , however , of calcined magnesia , in as much soil as was equal in bulk to four ounces of sand , the seeds produced only the seed-leaves , without roots ; and , with about forty grains , they were entirely prevented from coming up .
In countries where the magnesian lime is employed , it was said , that the barrenness of any spot on which a heap of it had been laid , would continue for many years .
To learn how far it could , by time be deprived of its injurious qualities , I procured some pieces of mortar made of this Species of lime , from two houses , one of which had been built three , and the other eight years : they were taken from the outside of the building , where they had been exposed to the air .
After they were reduced to powder , seeds were sown in them .
Only a few came up , and even those produced merely the seed-leaves , without any roots .
As plants would grow in the limestone from which this species of lime was formed although not in the mortar made from it , I wished to know what proportion of the fixed air originally contained in the limestone , had been absorbed by the mortar .
For this purpose , a piece of it was finely powdered , to render it of an uniform quality : it was then tried how much of this powder and of the limestone would saturate the same ' quantity of acid : by this means , I ascertained , the proportions of limestone and mortar containing equal quantities of the magnesian lime .
, The fixed air being obtained from them in those proportions , and measured in an inverted vessel , with quicksilver , it was found , that the mortar which had been exposed three years had absorbed 43 , and that of eight years , only 47 hundredths of the quantity originally contained in the limestone .
I was not able to obtain any mortar which had been made earlier , though it might deserve to be known how much fixed air it was ultimately capable of absorbing .
Corn .
mon mortar , which had been exposed to the air for a year and three quarters , had regained 63 hundredths of its full quantity of fixed air .
As the preceding experiments were tried during the winter , in a room warmed by fire , perhaps , under circumstances more favourable to vegetation , the same quantity of magnesia would not be equally pernicious .
Magnesian limestone may be easily distinguished from that which is purely calcareous , by the slowness of its solution in acids , which is so considerable , that even the softest kind of the former is much longer in dissolving than marble .
From this property of the magnesian limestone , there appeared to be reason for suspecting that the kind of marble which had been called Dolomite , from M. DOLOMIEU , who first remarked its peculiarity in dissolving slowly , might also be similar in its composition .
An analysis of this substance was lately given in the / ournal de Physique , but this is probably erroneous ; for , upon examining three specimens , they were found to consist of magnesia and calcareous earth , like the magnesian limestone ; so that it ought , no doubt , to be considered as the same species of stone , but in a state of greater purity .
The piqces of Dolomite were from different places ; one of them being found among the ruins of Rome , where it is thought to have come from Greece , as many statues of Grecian workmanship are made of it , and no quarries of a similar kind are known in Italy ; thei second was said to have been thrown up by Mount Vesuvius ; and the third was from Iona , one of the western islands of Scotland .
In many ; kinds of common marble , small particles and veins may be observed , which are a long time in dissolving .
These , upon examination , I discovered to contain a considerable proportion of magnesia ; but , as they were probably not quitefree from the surrounding marble , I did not ascertain the quanrk tity precisely .
The crystallized structure which may generally be observed in the magnesian limestone , seems to show that it has not been formed by the accidental union of the two earths , but must have resulted from their chemical combination .
The difficulty of dissolving it , may also arise from the attraction of the different component parts to each other .
The mortar formed from this kind of lime , is as soluble in acids as common marble ; and the substances of which it consists are easily separated .
The magnesia may be taken from it by boiling it in muriated lime , and lime is precipitated by it from lime water ; but neither of these eff &amp; ts can be -produced by the stone , before it is calcined .
Magnesian limestone is probably very abundant in various parts of England .
It appears to extend for thirty or forty -miles , from a little south-west of Worksop , in Nottinghamshire , to near Ferry-bridge , in Yorkshire .
About five or six miles further north there is a quarry of it , near Sherburn ; but , whether this is a continuation from the stratum near Ferry-bridge , I have not learnt .
From some specimens which were sent me , I find that the cathedral and walls of York are made of it .
I have not been able to learn whether there were any shells in the limestone of the tract of country before mentioned .
In Mr. MARSHALL'S account of the agriculture of the midland counties , he speaks of the lime made at Breedon , near Derby , as destructive to vegetables , when used in large quantities .
I therefore procured some pieces of it , and they were discovered to contain nearly the same proportion of magnesia as that before described .
In this quarry , the stone is frequently crystallized in a rhomboidal form ; and petrified shells , not calcareous , but similar in composition to the stone itself , are sometimes , but very rarely , found in it .
This substance seems to be common in Northumberland .
In the third volume of the Annals of Agriculture , Dr. FENWICK , of Newcastle , observes , that the farmers of that country divide limes into hot and mild .
The former of these is no doubt magnesian , as it has similar effects on the soil ; and he remarks , that it is not so easily dissolved in acids as the latter .
At Matlock , in Derbyshire , the two kinds are contiguous to each other ; the rocks on the side of the river where the houses are built being magnesian , and on the other , calcareous .
The magnesian rock appears also to be incumbent upon a calcareous stratum ; for , in descending a cave formed in this rock , a distinct vein of common limestone -may be observed , which contains no magnesia .
The latter stratum is very full of shells ; but , though there are some also in the magnesian rock , yet they are very rare .
In the following tables , containing the analysis of various specimens , some other places are mentioned where this substance is found , but of which I received no further information .
After it was known that the magnesian marble and limestone consisted of the two earths , their proportion was attempted to be discovered , by trying how much gypsum and Epsom salt could be obtained , by means of vitriolic acid , from a certain Ss S weight of each specimen .
When the superfluous vitriolic acld had been evaporated by heat , the Epsom salt was separated from the gypsum by water .
The result of these trials is expressed in the following table .
Dry gypsum .
Dry Epsom salt .
S grains of limestone from Breedon gave 3.9 3.1 Matlock 3.95 2.9 Worksop 3.8 3.o York..8 3 grains of calcareous spar and 1 grain l of calcined magnesia gave J As the preceding method of estimating the quantities of magnesia and calcareous earth is liable to considerable error , I afterwards examined them in the following manner , which seems capable of great exactness .
Twenty-five grains of each substance were dissolved by marine acid , in a cup of platina , and , after the solution was evaporated to dryness- , it was made red hot for a few minutes .
The mass remaining in the cup , which consisted of muriated lime , and of the magnesia freed from the acid , was washed out with water , and poured into a phial .
There was then added to it a know In quantity of diluted marine acid , somewhat more than was sufficient to redissolve the magnesia , and , after the solution , a certain weight of calcareous spar , part of which would be dissolved by the superfluous acid .
By the quantity of spar remaining undissolved- , it was learnt how much acid was -required to dissolve the magnesia .
The iron 'and argillaceous earthvcontained in some specimens , were precipitated by the spar , and therefore could not occasion any error .
The calcareous spar , however , dissolved more slowly where there was argillaceousearth , as it became coated with it ; but this incrustation was occasionally removed , and , in all the experi. .
ments , the spar was left in the solution till it suffered ' no further diminution .
For this purpose , it was necessary to keep them slightly warm for some days , during which time , the phials were generally closed , to prevent any escape of the acid .
The first experiment in the following table was made upon , known quantities of magnesia .
and calcareous earth , to try the accuracy of the process .
For this purpose , also , the seconc1 was repeated upon a piece of limestone , prevfously powdered , to render every part of it of the same quality .
The first column shows the quantity of calcareous spar which might have been dissolved by the acid required to take up the magnesia .
The second shows the corresponding quantities of magnesia in Ed grains of each substance .
The third expresses the , quantity oflime .
This was inferred by subtracting the weight of the magnesia , and of the iron and clay , from 13.2 grains , the weight of the whole quantity of earth in 25 grains of limestone .
This is probably not very incorrect , as , in two specim'ens which differed most in the proportion of magnesia and lime , the weight of there two earths was nearly the same .
A piece of Dolomite , from Rome , was wrapped in athin leaf of platina , that no part of it might be lost , and , being then exposed to a strong heat , left of earth 5s2.9 per cent. Dolomite from Mount Vesuvius-.- , .
52.8Breedon limestone 52.4 Calcareous spar left of lime 55.8 In three of the experiments , also , the calcareous earth was .
precipitated by mineral alkaliand the quantity of it being ' tried by that of the marine acid required to dissolve it , it cor-n .
responded very nearly with that put down .
A quantity of marine acid which would dissolve igrainsof calcareous spar , would also d-issolve-.5 of calined magnesia , and~ of Lime , &amp;c. 2S grains of spar ; so that , 2 .
grains of spar required the same quantity of acid as L. grains of magnesia .
The magnesia used was very pure , and made red hot immediately before it was weighed .
Quantity of spar which the acid , reSubstances examinwed .
quired to I ron take up the Quantity of Quantity of and magnesia , magnesia .
lime .
clay .
would have dissolved .
Mixture of 5 , grains of magnesia and 14 grains of calcareous spar 12.5 5 7.8 0 2S grains of Breedon limestone , previously powdered 11 .
5 07 i 7.929 2 25 grains from part of the same powder 5.o6 5.082 7913 . !
25grains of Dolomite from Rome _12.2 5.37 7.73 .
Dolomite from Inso lona _ 10 .
1 4.4 7.8 1.0 ?
ble sub stance .
' Vesuvian Dolomnite __ 10-38 4.565 8.575.oG A second experiment , from part of the same Vesuvian Dolomite 10.03 4.411 8.849.06 2s grains of magnesian limestone from Wansworth , near Doncaster 12.75.61 7.34.25 Thorpe arch io.4 4.84 7.8.6 Matlock 12.5 5.5 7.388.31 York minster 11 .
4.84 8.26.1.I Worksop I.6 5*104 7.496 6 Sherburn 11.5 !
* ?
8 7.f 6W Westminster-hall io.i 4.44 8.37.4

