XVII Essay on the Resolution of Algebraic Equations:attempting to distinguish particularly , the real Principle of every Method , and the true Causes of the Limitations to which it is subject .
By Giffin Wilson , Esq. Communicated by Edward Whitaker Gray , M. D. Sec. R. S. Read June 6 , 1799 .
INTRODUCTION .
1 .
THE practical management of algebraic equations , as far as respects the solution of problems depending upon them , is well understood ; but their general theory , being considered as an abstruse and purely speculative subject , is no where , that I have seen , so fully analysed , as with all the assistance to be derived from the application of the principles of combination , it appears to me it might be .
2 .
The difficulties under which the higher branches of algebra still labour are generally known .
No degree of equations beyond the second , is yet perfectly resolved : cubics present frequently an irreducible case : biquadratics have , by several methods , been reduced to cubics ; but no formula exhibiting to the eye the actual resolution of a biquadratic has yet appeared : and , for the fifth degree , and all upwards , not even a clue which promises a general resolution has been struck out , by the continued labour and ingenuity of mathematicians for several centuries .
3 .
This failure in the chain , beginning at the third degree , and its breaking off entirely after the fourth , have been very puzzling and mortifying circumstances to the cultivators of algebra .
Having in the first degrees proceeded upon apparently very general principles , and made a seeming progress towards a general resolution of equations , it is provoking to find it suddenly interrupted , not to be resumed by any contrivance .
Various causes have been assigned for so remarkable a difficulty ; but the generality of those causes , as commonly given , do not reach the principle .
It has been usual for operators , when they found their methods fail , to look back till they could detect some inconsistence or impossibility in their work , and to suppose the difficulty explained , by pointing out the period at which such an error is made .
The power and richness of the algebraic calculus affords numerous ways of compassing the same thing ; and , as all of them fail when applied to this objects , there is necessarily a point in every one of them , at which some inconsistence or impossibility is introduced : thence , a number of different causes may be imagined .
In Dr. WARING'S Meditationes Algebraic ' , ( p. 182 .
) may be seen several concurrent reasons assigned , why the methods there shown , and Dr. WARING'S own , ( unldoubtedly the most general of any of them , since it proceeds upon one principle to the fifth degree , ) cannot apply further : but , all reasons drawn from the data of any particular method , ( like that commonly given for the imperfection in CARDAN'S Rule , which I shall examine hereafter , ) though very just in themselves , cannot be conclusive : they indisputably show , why the precise method to which they respectively apply must fail ; but that does not exclude the expectation that some other , founded upon different principles , may succeed .
The question therefore recurs : Is there not some paramount fundamental reason for this general failure ?
If there can be shown to be any thing in the nature of abstract quantity , which governs the several orders of quantities from which equations are framed , and leads directly to the distinctions and limitations practice discovers , that will reach the difficulty at its source , and afford the satisfaction desired .
4 .
I think , that by turning the course of our inquiry rather to examine how we come to succeed at all , in resolving anty degree of equations , than why our success is so liiited , the true principle upon which their resolution must depend will appear ; and with what probability , and by what means , ( if possible , ) we may expect to render our methods more perfect .
With this ' idea , I shall take a concise view of the nature and resolution of equations in general ; pointing out the common difficulty , and by what circumstances that difficulty is , in certain cases lessened or removed ; confining myself always to the principle of each step , and a strict analysis of the result , avoiding all detail of mere operation ; and , without pretending to -much novelty upon a subject already so beaten , I persuade myself , such an investigation will lead to som3e conclusions which have not been remarked , and which are both curious and important .
CHAP .
L. Of the Resoluti~onz of Equations in general .
5 .
EQUxATIONS in that part of algebra which treats of their general resolution , are usually considered to be reduced to one genei-l jorm , for the greater convenience of comparing them , i. e. to their lowest rational dimensions , with unity always for the coefficient of the highest power of the unknown quantity ; in which state , every simple equation is already resolved .
The resolution of all other degrees , is the finding the simple equations of which they are compounded : but , to do this in a general manner , it is evident we must seek , instead of the particular equations themselves directly , a general expression representing them all ; which general expression is called the formula of resolution , such as , the common quadratic resolution , or that given for cubics by CARDAN 's Rule .
6 .
These formuli , properly speaking , are rather the reversion of an equation , than the resolution of it : for , although the unknown quantity be evolved or reduced to a simple dimension , the known parts are necessarily involved or affected with a surd at least as high as the dimension of the equation , in order to exhibit the proper numbers of correspondent values belonging to the unknown quantity in an equation of that degree .
Thus , the equation ( x'-px +q_ o ) and its common resolution ( X t-s/ 2Pare both the same quadratic ; only , under the first form , the unknown quantity , being of the dimension of the second degree , has two values ; whereas , in the second form , it has only one , and the double value is transferred , by the quadratic surd , to the known parts on the opposite side of the equation .
Thus also , the equation ( x'qx +r= o ) and the CARDANIC formula belonging to it x= r+rq7 4 .
7+_ ) are , in the same manner , the same cubic merely reverted .
But , as equations are usually denominXated from the dimension of the unknown quantity , these resolutions are commonly deemed simple equations : they may in this view be defined to be , the simple equations that the original quadratic , cubic , or other higher given equation , contained in , power , since they express the nature and form of a quantity which , by involution or reverting the operation , re-produces it ; as the root of any power , being reinvolved , returns to the power from which it xvas extracted .
This fixed and visible connection between the equation and the general formula for its roots , throws a beauty and elegance into the method of pure algebraic resolution , which none of the others , such as the method of divisors , and all the contrivances for approximation , can pretend to .
For , when by Slany of those methods we have obtained one or more separate roots , the relation to the original equation is no longer perceivable ; but here the chain is perfect .
The equation leads to the resolution : the resolution emnbraces at once all the correspondent roots ; and , when reinvolved , proves the operation , by reproducing the original equation .
Thus , for example , if ( x 5x +4= o ) , and it be perceived , or found by any conjectural method , that unity is one of the roots of that equation , there is no discernible connection between the simple equation expressing ( x= i ) and the original equation ; no transformation of one will produce the other .
This latter equation ( x = 1 ) , though truly expressing , a numeral root of the former , is no more a resolution of it than of the equations ( x"-6x += o ) , ( x2 7x +6 =o ) , or any other of the infinite number of equations of which unity is a root ; whereas , the algebraic resolution of ( x25x +4= o ) Vizt ( z--5-5/ 235-l6 ) , which equally expresses ( i ) , and ( 4 ) the other root , needs only to be cleared of its radical , to show itself .
KDCCXC IX N 1n but another form of the same equation ; and gives ( xe. .
X+4 o ) as at first .
7 .
This view of the algebraic resolution of an equation shows , that it does not so much aim at giving us the roots themselves , as the basis or common principle of their artificial combination in the equation to which it applies ; pointing out some form of a perfect power , of which they may be conceived to be the correspondent natural roots .
From which it follows , that if the transformation required to be made in the given equation be possible , or such as can really be effected , the resolution will be real ; for every real power has some real root : but that if , on the contrary , the power into which the equation is conceived to be transformed be merely imaginary , the resolution must be so too ; for all the roots of an imaginary power are themselves imaginary .
It doth not therefore depend upon the nature of the roots of the equation themselves , but on the form which the equation must assume to become a perfect power , to determine , whether the resolution be real or imaginary : so that the nature of the resolution , and that of the roots of an equation may be very different , as we know is frequently the case ; particularly in the resolution of cubic equaltions by CARDAN'S rule , where , when the roots are real , the resolution is almost always imaginary .
This has seemed to surprise and perplex some writers very much , who have treated it as at best a paradox , if not a contradiction , * but surely without cause ; for , as the formula affects only to be an ideal representation of the mechanism or structure of a perfect power # Vide PLAYFAIR on the Arith .
of Impossibles , Phil. Trans. 1778 , P. 318 ; Dr. HUTTON on Cubic Equations , ditto , 1780 , page 387 ; and Mr. BARON MASERESi Script .
Logaritb .
Vol. II .
p. 456 .
-answering to the given affected equation , ; it may be expected to be clear or complicated , real or imaginary , not as the roots themselves are simple and real , but as the principle of their union , of which only it is truly the index , is -near or remote : it merely shows the central point of their combination , which , like the centre of gravity , suspension , or any other power , may not actually exist in any of the bodies whose motions it governs , but in some imaginary point without , and remote from them all .
Had the nature of the algebraic resolution of an equation been considered in this light , and the forms to which they are proposed to be reduced , been compared with the original forms of the roots in the given equation , no surprise or appearance of paradox could have arisen in the matter ; but it must have been clearly perceivable , what cases would admit of real and what only of imaginary resolutions , as will be shown hereafter .
I have dwelt the longer upon the nature of the algebraic resolotion of an equation , because it is a very curious subject , about which many errors and inconsistencies have been fallen into , though hardly any direct examination of it is to be found in any of our books .
It is the sole method of obtaining a complete general answer to any problem .
It makes algebra consistent with itself , and sufficient to solve its own difficulties , without foreign aid , ( from series or other branches ; ) and , iil all cases where any general ulterior use is to be made of the resolution of an equation , is the only method that avails at all .
8 .
In order to obtain this general resolution , the common methods have been , ( without considering the nature of the roots , ) to attempt some universal reduction in the ]orms of equIations ; as , N nI ist .
The destroying their intermediate terms , and converting them into pure powers .
Or , 2dly .
The discovering some constant complement which will always raise them to the nearest perfect power .
In both which cases , the resolution will afterwards be nothing more than simple extraction of the proper root .
Or , Idly .
The assuming some convenient formula with indeterinmate coefficients ; and , by assigning their values properly , adapting it to every case .
It would be going to too great a length , to give distinct examples here , of the application of these methods .
Numerous instances of each of them are given in the common books of algebra , which usually treat them as separate and distinct from each other ; but the fact is , they are all in truth the same .
Whoever tries them separately , will find , , however variously they seem to set out , they lead precisely to the s'ame conclusions , and fail precisely in the same points .
A quadratic , when there resolved by completing the square , or by expunging the second term : a cubic , whether resolved by CARDAN'S rule , or by completing the cube , or by assuming a resolution , as suggested in Dr. WARING'S Meditationes Algebraica ?
, ( p. I 79 , i8o .
) present the same formula of resolution , and the same limitations and irreducible cases .
And the reason is easily found .
To complete the requisite power , ( according to the index of the equation , ) or to destroy the intermediate terms , occasions an alteration in just the same number of terms it is only the particular relation they are required to , bear to each other that is varied .
In the one case , they are all to be equal , ( or equal to nothing ; ) in the other , to correspond respectively with the known law of the binomial theorem , which gives the uncig of a regular power .
Both depend upon the practicability of a more general problem , of which they are but specific cases ; viz. the problem " s to give the coejcients of an equation any general determinate relation .
" If that were practicable , and it were possible to mould them so as to establish a general relation between them , ( or any required number of them , ) it is easy to perceive , that the particular relation must be a secondary consideration ; and that , wherever the same number of terms are to be acted upon , the same means that might make them equal , might give them any other proportion at pleasure , 9 .
However , of all these methods , and any other of the kind , it is to be observed , that the principle is demonstrably a false assumption .
For , if it be once admitted that the construction of equations , and the laws of the successive coefficients received ever since VIETA'S time , be true ; or that all equations are formed invariably in the same manner , from the continual multiplication of the simple equations of their roots , which experience confirms without any exception ; * it follows , that the nature of the roots must infallibly govern that of the equation derived from them ; that the same form of equation can only be produced by the same forms of roots ; and therefore , before all sorts of equations can be made into pure or perfect powers , or be given any other general shape , it must be shown , that all quantities are capable of taking the forms required to produce equations of that sort , which will presently be seen to be impos .
sible .
If those who have lost their time and labour in vain endeavours to improve these general methods , had , instead of involving themselves in a labyrinth of substitution and process , upon the chance of some means of simplification presenting itself , considered beforehand the probability of success , the imperfection of CARDAN 's rule would never have appeared a paradox , nor the interruption of all further progress by it have given room for surprise .
They must have seen , that no equation beyond a quadratic can admit of a real extinction of its intermediate terms .
In the general equation ( x1 -_px1 +q x , -2 -rxn-3 + sSn-e4 &amp;c. _ o ) , ( p ) being the sums of the roots , and ( q ) the sum of their combinations in pairs , by Sir I. NEWTON'S theorem for finding the sums of the powers of the roots , ( q ) will be the sum of their squares ; and therefore , if both ( p ) and ( q ) vanish , the sum of the squares of the roots must vanish also which can never happen with real quantities .
Besides this , in attempting to destroy many intermediate terms at once , we know by experience , the equations that become incidentally necessary to be solved , rise to a much higher dimension than the given equation ; so that our labour , in this respect , defeats itself .
io .
Nor will these difficulties be avoided , if we abandon the idea of a general resolution , and attempt to work out the roots separately : although the number of coefficients is always sufficient to afford a distinct equation to each root , and therefore , by the common principles of indeterminate equations , will clearly determine them all ; and would also find them , if the equations afforded by the coefficients were all of the same degree ; but they rise successively , and , from the drawing them together , in order to expunge the several unknown quantities , the index of the reducing equation increases so as to defeat the e5 operation .
To show this , let us recur to the general equation before given ( rx.pxnl-l + qxn-2 -rx-3 + sx14 -= ) suppose its ( n ) roots to be represented by ( a , b , c , d , &amp;c. n then , by the construction of equations , we have ( n ) distinct equations from the several coefficients in succession ; viz. a+b+c+d &amp;c. ... +n innumber(n)=p , ab +ac +ad &amp;c. ( nx tjZ)=q , abc+abd &amp;c. xXr ( abcde &amp;c. n ) , or the product of them all , being the coefflcient of the last term .
Now , as we have ( n ) equations , and ( n ) indeterminate quantities , it is evident , that by employing each equation successively to determine one quantity , the whole will be determined .
But the equations are not all of the same degree : the first , is a simple equation : the second , being composed on one side wholly of products by two , is in degree a quadratic ; the third , for the same reason , a cubic ; and so on .
If the first of these equations be used to determine ( a ) , we shall have ( a =p -bc -d &amp;c. n ) ; inserting that value for ( a ) in the second equation , it becomes the quadratic ( pbb+pc ( 4 .
+pd d-bc-bd &amp;c. = q ) .
If that quadratic be solved to determine ( b ) , and the values of ( a and b ) be inserted in the third equation , it becomes the cubic ( C3 &amp;c. .
r).* Moreover , the quadratic having two roots , its solution will have introduced a quadratic surd .
Before therefore we can proceed to employ the third equation to determine ( c ) , it must be ?
squared to clear it of that surd , and of course will then rise to the 6th degree .
The solution of such a dimension ( if admitted for the present to be equally possible ) must introduce higher radicals ; and , by the intrusion of these superfluous roots at every stage , our labour increases , 'instead of diminishing .
This is the diffit culty alluded to before ; and , as we have appropriated already all our subordinate equations , we have nothing ' to oppose it .
It therefore seems , hopeless , to expect to make any general impression upon indeterminate equations , without more help beyoMd the m ere knowledge of the constitution of the coefficients .
1 i. This difficulty , however , is wholly removedby the least circumstance that discloses any particular relation amongst the coefficients of an equation , independent of the general law of their cQnstructlon .
This , of course , whenever it occurs , furnishes -new conditions and means of comparing the -terms .
^Every particularity in the coefficients that gives specific varieties to the forms of equations , must , from the nature of their construction , have its source in some particular relation between two or more of the roots , and therefore , as far as that relation extends , detects them infallibly .
The observation of the forms and relations of the coefficients under different species of equations , and the correspondent inferences to be drawn , as to the connection of their roots , would form a curious and very useful part of a complete treatise upon the whole doctrine of equations , which is a work much wanted .
The most striking of these rela.tions will be obvious , or familiar , to the reader who has at all considered the nature of the subject ; such as , that equations deficient in every alternate term arise from pairs of equal roots with opposite signs ( - ?
a , - : !
b &amp;c. ) ; that those whose terms on both sides the middle term are alike ( which are generally called recurring equations ) arise from pairs of roots , of which each pair contains a quantity and its reciprocal ( a aI , b+ &amp; C. ) ; together with MACLAURIN'5 demonstration of the particularities of the coefficients when an equation has equal roots.* And the extent to which these notices might easily be carried , from observation of the effects of the'different sorts of proportion , and all other relations , is prodigious .
But my present concern is merely with the result , supposing from any means a relation to be previously discovered affecting any number of the roots .
For example , -suppose , in the above given equation , ( XnpXiz-1 + qxn-2 _ rxn-3 + SX-4 &amp; C. o ) , whose roots we called ( a , b , c , d &amp;c. ... n ) , we happened to know that two of the number ( a and b ) were equal ; then , since they might both be expressed by the same character , the ( n ) roots of the equation might now be represented by only ( n i ) distinct characters ; and therefore , of the subordinate equations derived from the construction of the coefficients , two might be employed to determine one root .
( a and b ) being equal , the equation furnished by the value of the coefficient ( p ) , and also that furnished by the coefficient ( q ) , may be both together used to determine the same quantity .
But , if any quantity ( a ) be a root of an equation , the simple equation ( x a= o ) must be a divisor of that equation ; therefore here ( x a ) must be a common divisor of the two equations furnished by ( p and q ) , and consequently may be found , without resolving either of them , by continual division or subtraction , according to theordinary rule for finding the common measure.* 12 .
Any other relation from the knowledge of which one character may be made to represent two , or more roots , evbdently answers the same end .
Indeed all relations of that kind may be converted into equality itself , by taking , instead of the given equation , some other properly derived from it .
Thus if , instead of ( a and b ) being the same , ( b ) had been supposed the negative of ( a ) or ( a ) , and then , ,instead of the former equatiOn1 , that of the squares of the roots were taken , the relation would be made equality ; for ( a ) and ( a ) have the same square .
If arithmetical proportion was known to be the relation of any number of the roots , by taking the equation of their differences , it would also be converted into equality .
13 If three or more roots , or any number of parcels of roots , are known to be related , and their common relation be used to represent them , of course the number of distinct characters to be determined will proportionably be diminished : and , as the number of subordinate equations furnished by the coefficients remains always the same , while the dimension of the proposed equation is unaltered , more of them may be used together to discover the related roots , and their investigation be proportionably facilitated .
This single observation ' , in the hands of a skilful analyst , is sufficient for the reduction , if not the solution , of any particular numeral equation whatsoever , and the more so the larger its dimension : for , from the endless variety of relations numbers bear to each other , hardly any set of them can occur , as the coefficients of an equation , or perhaps exist , that , upon being compared , do not exhibit some peculiarity ( of greater or less extent ) sufficient to afford a clue to the correspondent relation in their roots .
And , if no such clue is immediately given by the equation itself , taking the equation of the differences or sums in pairs , or of the squares , &amp;c. of the roots , will soon find one .
But , as peculiarities of that sort ( though never so frequent ) may be deemed always accidental , and evidently , no general method can be founded upon them , even where the coficients are given , it may be asked , How any use can be made of them in cases of indeterminate equations ? ?
14 .
To this I answer , that there are some properties of quantities that depend only on the index of the equation , without any regard to the value of its coefficients ; or , in other words , there are some peculiar properties which merely depend upon the number of any set of quantities , abstracted from all consideration of their nature and values .
For example , two quantities ( a ) and ( b ) have their differences the same quantity ( a b ) , onlytaken both affirmatively and negatively , ( a b ) and ( b a ) ; when squared , these differences become equal ; ( a. 2ab + b6 ) is the square of both : therefore , let the quantities themselves be chosen as they may , the equation of the squares of their if 2 , 3 , or more pairs of roots are equal , the reduction can only be carried down to a quadratic , cubic , Mc .
for , every pair of equal roots being equally to be found by the method , of course the final or resulting equation must be of a dimension as great as their number .
0o 2 differences muist have both equal roots , and consequently be reducible by the reasoning in Art .
ii , 19 , and 1g .
Again , three quantities , however distinct in themselves , give a set of differences marked with a peculiar relation , any two of them being equal to the third ; ( a , b , c , ) being three quantities , ( a b+bca c ) .
Also , if the three quantities be so chosen originally as to have their sum equal nothing , one of them must necessarily equal in magnitude the sum of the -remaining two ; and therefore , whether taken simply or summed in pairs , their relative magnitudes must remain the same .
Againfour quantities , of any sort whatever , may be pursued to a constant relation , though somewhat more remote , and grounded upon very different causes ; viz. ( a , b , c , d , ) being four quantities , from their combinations by pairs ( ab , ac , ad , be , bd , cd , ) six in number , added together two by two , thus , ( ab+ cd ) ( ac + bd ) ( ad + bc ) three quantities are formed , sufficiently distinguished from the group of similar combinations to be found separately , as will be shown hereafter .
And also , if the four quantities are originally so taken as to have their sum equal to nothing , their sums in pairs , though six in number , will be reduced to three in effect ; for , if ( a +b+c+d= o ) , by transposition , ( a +b -cd ) ( a +c= -bd ) ( a + d=b-c ) i. e. three of the six must be merely the negatives of the other three ; which relation , if they are squared , will become equality , so that the number of distinct squares will be only three .
These properties though without any order or connection , and confineci merely to particular ranks or numbers of quantities , being generaI to all ossible or imaginable quantities of those classes afford mrethods general , as to those degrees , but without producing any result really general to equations at large .
15 .
Having shown that an indeterminate general equation cannot be resolved by any of the methods whose principle is yet known , because they are all grounded upon the assumption of some particularity , either inherent in the roots , or universally communicable to them , which , so far from being general , is seldom found , and absolutely incompatible with many sorts .
of roots ; that the difficulty is in all cases the same , the intrusion of superfluous roots and higher radicals ; that a relation of any kind ( when known ) obviates that difficulty , as far as it extends ; and that some orders of quantities have generally a constants and necessary relation , more or less remote , I proceed to examine , more minutely , the application of these observations to the se-veral degrees of equations to which they materially apply .
CHAP .
IIL Of the Resolution or Reduction of Equations of particularDegrees. .
16 .
IN examining those degrees of equations which submit to be resolved , I shall observe the same order as I did before ; 2 .
e. first consider the power of obtaining a general formula , or complete resolution ; and , if that is not attainable directly , inquire by what general means the roots can be ; separately investigated , and what new forms they have taken , or what different functions of them are used in the operation .
17 .
If we resume the general indeterminate equation ( X px-:L + qx"n-2 rxn-3 &amp;c. = o ) , and assign the progressive values ( 2 , 3 , 4 &amp;c. ) to the index ( n ) , in the first case it will become the quadratic ( x2 -px +q o ) .
Now , as this equation has two roots , in order to obtain a general formula for its resolution , the first step that suggests itself is , to inquire what is necessary to construct a general representation of two quantities in a simple equation .
Two quantities are known to be generally expressed by means of their sum and difference ; that half their sum added to half their difference gives the greater , and the same quantities subtracted , the lesser .
The sum being always the coefficient of the second term of the equation , is given in all cases , and here the difference is readily found ; for , the square of the difference of any two quantities differs from the square of their sum by a constant quantity , viz. four times their product or the coefficient of the third term .
If ( a ) and ( b ) be called the roots of the equation ( xf px +q =o ) ; then ( p a+ b ) and ( p2= a'+ 2ab + b ' ) , -(q ab ) and ( -4q= -4ab ______________ the square whence ( a2ab +b a-=p 4q of the difference .
The difference itself is therefore ( v 4 4q ) .
And now , being possessed of the parts required to construct a general representation of the two quantities , we can at once complete the formula of general resolution of equations of this degree , viz. This , as I observed before in Art .
6 , is however the same quadratic , only reverted ; for , the quadratic surd it contains is frequently incapable of further reduction .
Therefore , generally speaking , the degree of the equation is not altered ; only the place of the index , which being first affixed to the unknown quantity , is now transferred to the known ones .
But nevertheless , this resolution is , in all cases , equally true and direct ; for , involving no other radical than belongs to the degree it relates to , it faithfully exhibits the nature of the roots and is always rational or real , or not , according as they are so~ 18 .
If , instead of seeking , a priori , the formula of resolution,. .
we attempt to find the roots simply , we may instantly trace a constant connection between them , or at least between their , differences ; which ( however the quantities are varied ) are .
always related in the same manner , being ( a b ) and , ( a + b ) the same quantity with different signs , : and consequently their ' squares precisely the same , From which it appears , that the ; equation of those differences will always want the second termor be a pure quadratic ; and that of theirsquares will be a perfect binomial square , having both roots equal ; which roots maytherefore , by the reasoning in Art .
i , becertainly found .
But the inference is just the same as before the equation is not lowered in degree the equal relation is brought no nearer than between the squares of the differences ; and , whenthey are found , .
the same quadratic surd , must be used to arrive at the roots themselves .
This formula of resolution x is the same given for quadratics in every algebra ; but it is notusually remarked , or perhaps understood , that the whole operation , however varied in appearance by setting about to comrplete the square ( as it is called ) or to destroy the second term , is merely employed to obtain the difference of the roots ; that ( upon analysing the formula ) the part under the vinculum is always that difference , and nothing else , and why it must be so .
19 .
Next , let ( n ) , and the equation be the complete cubic ( x3p x ' +qxr= o ) .
If we make it our first step here , as in the last case , to inquire what is necessary to construct a general representation of three numbers in simple equations , we shall find it must consist of the same parts , the sum and the differences : but , as the differences increase in nunber , to show the order in which they are taken , and the law they observe progressively , I shall subjoin a general table of the simple representation of the different orders of quantities .
As in every equation the sum of the roots is always given , I shall , for greater simplicity in my table , suppose it always to vanish .
If then there be a series of general equations , beginning with a quadratic , and proceeding upwards with progressive indexes , in all of which the coefficient of the second ternm ( p ) be taken = ( o ) , and ( A ) be supposed a difference of the roots of the first , ( A ) and ( B ) two of the differences of the roots of the second , ( A , B , C , ) three differences of those of the third , and so on ; in taking of which differences , no other caution is necessary than that they should be similarly situated , viz. all derived by comparing the same individual root with the remaining ones , as if ( a ) be taken as a root , and ( a-b ) be the first difference , ( a c , a d , a e.c. a-n ) , having all the same antecedent letter ( whose number will always be ( n ) ) must be the rest ; then , the table will be as follows : Table of the simple Representation of the Roots of Equations of progressive Indexes .
In quadratics , X_A2 In cubics , A +B 3X -A -B fA -13 , ~I , A_ _B 23 +S 7A+BL~ ~~~~~~~~ 2 In biquadratics , rA B_ B+ C [ A ?
I ?
C +3 -3 A-B-Ci ACBC 3* _ __ __ 33 A ?
+B A ?
+C 3 In the fifth degree , fA +B+ C+ D A-B B +C BC+D x=1 Fq~~~+ABC B -iC _ ~+ D ' ABI444A DC B _C DC -D [ Vs +4+44 A4-B A+C A+D LPp4 AIDCCXCIX .
P p In the ( nth ) degree , or generally , fA +B +C+ D-+ ?
E Uc .
( ni ) in number + &amp; C 7T in number + +--3"_BCS.in numb .t I __ _ _X ~~~~A C B_ C ' _ A-_B-_C _D-E Sc. hPA _D B _D +A E+BE B S &amp; 20 .
The inspection of the table shows us , that in all cases , to construct a general simple representation of any number of quantities , and consequently to construct a direct resolution of their equation , we must first find a certain number of their differences ; but we have no general ineans of separating particular differences from the rest ; and the whole number of differences increases in a proportion so much greater than the number of quantities , that the former difficulty recurs , the previous steps involve higher dimensions than the original equation .
The original index being ( n ) , that of the equation of the difference of the roots is ( n xn i ) .
However , from the nature of differences , ( being taken both affirmatively and negatively , ) all equations formed from them must ( as observed of quantities of that sort in Art .
i 1 .
) be universally deficient in every alternate term , which brings their equation to the form of equations of only half their own index , or ( n x X2y !
) but , in this case , their differences are six , and their equation , with that cosideration , is reduced no lower than a cubic form , which is the same degree with the proposed equation ; therefore , it does not appear that we can be enabled , a priori , to determine the formula of any direct resolution of this case .
21 .
Let us then try to trace some relation which may convert some or all of the roots , or some regular function of them , into equal quantities ; when , the equation of that function having equal roots , of course those roots will be separately deducible , as shown in Art .
11 , 12 .
In Art .
14 , we may remember , two particularities were mentioned to belong to three quantities izi that their differences were so related as to be every two of them equal to the third ; and that , if the quantities themselves have their sum equal to nothing , two of them also must equal the third , and their magnitude be respectively the same , whether they are taken simply , or summed in pairs .
To avail ourselves of both these properties , let us suppose the second term to be expunged from the given equation , ( which we know may always be effected , ) its form will then be ( x ' qx +r a ) , * and the sum of its roots equal to nothing .
Let ( a ) and ( b ) be two of its roots , the third will therefore be ( a -b ) ; take their sums by two ( -a , b , a+ b ) ; take their differences ( 2a + b , a+ 2b , a b ) and their negatives , which may be divided into two sets whose sum is nothing , like that of the roots , viz. a b , a+ 2b , -a b -a + b , a 2b , 2a +bJ So that , from the given equation we derive three others , which make a set of four exactly similar .
Ist .
( x ' qx +r o ) the given equation .
2d .
( x'qxr o ) that of its roots summed in pairs .
3d .
~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 4th .
X ' 3 qx v'/ 4q3 -27r~ = 0two similar equations , With .
x33 Sqx -V4q 3270 =o formed by dividing ( x'-6 qx4 +9 q2 x2 4 q3 + 27 r2 =0 ) the equation of the differences , into two wanting the second term . ?
2 .
Now , leaving these considerations for a moment , let us speculate upon the further reduction of the equation .
If , instead of the present form ( X3 qx +r= o ) , ( q ) could be supposed to vanish as well as ( p ) , a still more powerful additional relation would be given the roots ; for , the equation being then a pure cubic , ( x'3=r ) , its roots would obviously be the cube roots of ( r ) , and all cube roots are alike , If ( r ) be a cube , and ( yr ) be one of its roots , the remaining two are ( + x3 X Yr and ''x d/ yr ) , let ( r ) be any quantity whatsoever , real or imaginary .
But it is clear , from what has been before observed in Art .
9 , that this reduction is not generally possible , since it supposes two contiguous internmediate terms to vanish together , which real roots do not admit of : it must therefore be effected by means of some imaginary assumption .
Those who are conversant in the use of impossible quantities , will at once perceive , that the addition or subtraction ( which in surd quantities is always the same thing , as they are equivocal in sign , ) of the iniaginry surd sq j to each root of the equation , will infallibly cause ( q ) to vanish , f b+ v -q , but the new roots h thi 3 eqa-b to -3i qa so formed , would not have their sum equal to no3thing ; and therefore , in destroying the third term , the second would be revived , so that nothing would be gained .
23 .
To understand how this difficulty is ever removed , let us examine particularly some equation that wants both second and third terms , and observe accurately the constitution of its toots .
The simplest of the kind is the pure cubic ( x'= 1 ) , whose roots are ( 1 , 2-X+ ' 3 ) ; but , to avoid fractions in the roots , let us take ( X3 = 8 ) , whose roots are ( 2 , -1 3 ) Distinguishing the real and the imaginary parts the real are ( 2 , - , 1 ) ; the imaginary are ( =V-3I orf 3x X ) , which are the dffferences of the real parts , multiplied by the ima- ' ginary surd ( V 4 ) .
It appears , therefore , that the roots of a pure -cubic are compounded of the roots of some affected cubic , added to their differences drawn into the imaginary surd ( V/ -4 ) .
The real parts ( 2 , I , - ) are the roots of the cubic equation ( x-3 x+2 o ) .
The imaginary , of the equation ( X3 +3X+ *=o ) , or the roots of the similar equa .
tion of the differences of the former , viz. ( X ' -9 X + ( X x2 X2 O ) ; to find the similar equation of their differences ( x'3 9 X ' +* o ) ; and , to find the equation produced by the quantities formed from the addition of the roots of the one to those of the other multiplied into the imaginary surd ( v-3 ) .
The equation last found would , however , be of the dimension of the 9th power , at least : for , the addition of each root of the second equation to every separate root of the first , produces a separate quantity : thus , 21 )F2o 1-+o 0+ being the rootsof the ist .
( 0 ) + V-+ 3V ' +3V-3 &amp; +3V-I &lt; those of the 2d .
L2-SV3 , -1-3Vi 1 3V-IJ will be the nine quantities formed by their addition .
But we have a decisive clue to distinguish some from the rest ; for we know , that if we find the equation of the cubes of those quantities , it must have three equal roots ; for , every time the sum of two of the roots of the first equation meets its own difference , it will constitute a cube root of ( 8 ) , and therefore , the equation ( X38 -o ) will be three times contained in the resulting equation of cubes .
That equal root being discovered by the method of finding equal roots , so often alluded to before , reduces the equation ( 3x+2 a ) to the pure cubic ( x'= 8 ) .
24 .
The instance in the last article , of the reduction of the equation ( x3 3x +2 o ) to a pure cubic , by means of the equation ( x ' +3x o ) , evidently depends upon the coefficient of the second term vanishing ; aund also , that of the third term being the same in both , but of opposite signs .
For , the roots of the one , in their combinations by two , producing ( 3 ) , and those of the other ( + a ) , of course destroy each other ; and , as the sums of both equal nothing , when added togetler their sum will still be nothing ; so that no nezv second term can arise , as in Art .
22 .
If we now return to the considerations in Art .
21 , where we showed how to derive from every cubic equation ( X3 qx + rY o ) wanting the 2d term , a similar equation ( X3 jqx + v"4q ' 27r2 a ) , being the equation of three of the differences of the roots of the former , so arranged as to want the second term also , we may perceive that , to render the third term the same in both , we need only divide the roots of the latter by ( v/ 3 ) or , which is the same thing , multiply them into the ( V4 ) .
For , the equation ( x ' -qx + v4 q327r2 0 ) when its roots are multiplied ' by the ( 2'3)2 .
becomes -(x-qx +3 If , by the same rea- ' son , they had been multiplied by the ( V/ i- ) , it would be ( x3 + qx + 4/ v 37 -l =o where the sign of the coefiPcient of ( x ) is opposite to that of ( q ) in the given equation .
Therefore , the roots of the equation ( x _qx+ r= o ) , and .
that of its differences , multiplied into the imaginary surd v viz. ( X3 +qx+q o , will , by being added together , ( according to the method in the last Article , ) lead to a reduction of that equation to a pure cubic ; i. e. the equationformed from their addition will have three roots , whose cubes are the same .
25 .
The analysis of the pure cubic gives us the following general properties , belonging to any set of those equations whose sum , is nothing .
Viz .
ist .
If three such quantities ( a , b , -a b ) be added V* Vide SAN DERSON'S Algebra , Vol. IT .
p. 6%8 ; and HALE'S Analysis , P. 146 .
in pairs , and three of their differences be also taken so as to have their sum nothing , ( a b , a+ 2b , 2a b ) ; 'if then each sum be formed into a binomial , by joining to it its correspondent difference multiplied by the imaginary surd T the quantities so formed a+ a+ sbAV I3 -hb 2 , b / - ' ?
will have the same cube .
Example 1st , a+ b +a a+b+ aSb sa b12 aaV_ ta 14 3 za3+Sab+zb ' 3 3--+2.a+b9a b V-j = a..a+b+oa blV/ -3 a+ b+a-b V-j za3+ Iodlb + ioab+ 2Ib3 +2a+ bl a:r_ 33 &gt; * 3 2a1 _-4abb _433a+a_ 2I V_ za3 ? ?
4ab+4a bz b3 2a3 + Salb + 8ab2 la+2bl3 v33 3 ?
a'xa+2bV-v/ 3~~~~~~~~~~~ IZ azb + 2ab jz 8 a ' 2a -1aV 3+ 8a3+ -z-Iab'''-a a +2 + bvl b 2a bI V 3b1 +4ab +gb1\V-^ 4 ab 4 a1 -3 b 2abI _ ^/ .
IL 3~~~~~~~~ 2b ?
+ 4ab ' + 24ab l 21 " 2bP+Sab1 ?
4a'b 333+bx3 a2b-bV ~ z1b2azbab1 +ctu+zab-.1 ; abl_8b~l 7=..b-2a.2b3 , +ab + 4I *-ab-2 ab ls 31 The quantity 2 a1 b+ 2za b'+ 8 a3+ 12 a3 b-IZ a b1-8 b31= 6X-1b zaa+3alb+ a+ zb 3 33V 3 +a33 is therefore the common cube of those 3 binomials .
Q. E M. Now let the equation of the 3 quantities ( a , b , a _b , ) be ( X-q x+r= o ) ; then , by the construction of equations , ( q-a'+iab+b ) and ( 4eq'34a6+Iza5b+z4a4b-+z8a3b3+z4at b4++t:zabs+4b ) , also ( _r-al b+a b ) and ( 27 r-27 za4b+s4 a3b3+27 a " b4 whence ( +q3_ -7 r=4 a6+ 2a b_3 a4_ 76 3 b3 +x 12 aP+ 6 ) and its square root , or ( q r_ z tbb -zb ' .
Therefore , the quantity The equation ( X3q x+r O ) may hence he reduced to a Wpure cubic of thais form ( = bx |-r + V4 ?
z7r 3 ) which , --when cleared of its irrational quadratic surd , becomes ( x6+ 8rx3+ a 6rt= -64q3r432rt ) , or(*6 ?
8rX3+ 64q Q ) ; or,4 dividing -its roots by ( 2 ) to reduce it still l-ower , ( x6+ rxe + r-= o ) , the common reducing equation ob 27~ ~~~ ~~~32 tamned by CARDAN'S r:ule .
Example 2d .
L Jet ( , , r ) , the roots of the ; equation ( x7x +6 o ) , be taken ; the binomials formed from them will be , according to the directions of the rule , f~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ X.2I3-.TV-T F 3-'lV-T -z4-xgV-T '+3-+ ? ?
4_ 4 96 4+ !
6V-r + 6-4O &amp; N. 6 .
Jt is necessary to change -_ + 16 or +o the sign of the middle dif~e 3.K[/ ..j-2 4/ i + rence , becausedtheir sum must _oots ___ 2to reuc is always oQ ) .
2 6-I82-. .
T-.3Z4/ ' 32+'ov X } 3| _~~~2-36 64T 36 + 32 33 The quantity ( 24 jis therefore the common cube of th7ese 6 binomials t Example 3d Let ( --do + ) the roots of the equation ( x3 21 X 20 -0 ) , which are the differences used in the last example , be next taken ; F54 IV-3 4+ ZV-3 1-3V-3 -I+ '_I3 -5+37-T=5+1/ -3 5+ 'V-3 4+ zV-3 I3V-3 J5+3V-7--5+'V-3 25-IO./ -3 16+ i6V-3 I6V-3 -3 zI 27 , __I____i._-I-5 6f+4 ?
6V_ 44++-3 22-IOV-3 4+I6V-3 -266V-3 X'_ 5+ IV-3 4+ 2V-3 I3V-3 '+5=+ I 1 .
-I " Q+SOV-3 I6+64V-3 _266V-3 +4_5=_9 '--9V32-3 30+Z273 -96+ 8V-3 -54+78sV3 8o+7 V3 -8O+72V.--3 -80+72V-3 which last cube , if divided by ( 3 ) , becomes 3+ 24V---3 ) , or exactly the reverse of the first ; the -reason of which will be shown in the next section of this Article .
The cube ( 24 -83V0 3 ) , when its equation ( X3=24_TVis made rational , gives the quadratic-formed equation of the 6th degree ( X6-_ 48 X3-5+ 76= 42 ?
) ; or , transposing all the terms to one side , and dividing it by ( 2 ) , to reduce it , as before , ( X66x ' + 3243 = 0 ) ; the same equation that results from the common methods .
2dly .
The differences of the three differences ( ab , a+2 b , 2a b ) are ( 3 a , 3 b , 3xa+ b ) , or merely three times the original quantities .
Had , therefore , the differences themselves been taken as original quantities , and binomials been formed from them , according to the directions before observed , those binomials , and the ultimately resulting cubes , would differ from the former , in nothing essential but the place of the surd .
The differences which were affected with it before , would now be clear ; and the quantities themselves , or , which is the same thing , their sums in pairs , be affected with it .
However , as these latter are to be multiplied by three , that multiplication will destroy the fraction when they come againto be multiplied by the surd ( V ) , since ( j x a/ 4f= / 3 ) .
Wherefore , the same end , as to reducing the equation , will be obtained , whether , after adding the sums of the roots in pairs to their respeclive d~fferences , we multiply the sums by ( Ve-a ) , or divide the differences by it ; as has been already shown in the 3d Example to the last Section of this Article .
3dly .
If any cubic equation wanting the second term , be -transformed into the equation of that function of its roots , formed of the cubes of the binomials arising from joining the sum of each pair of roots to its correspondent difference drawn into the imaginary fractional surd ( 4 ) or each difference to its correspondent sum drawn into the surd ( v - ) , the transformed equation will have among its roots three equal cubes ; by finding which , according to the methods of finding equal roots , the equation is reduced to a pure cubic .
4thi-y .
The roots of a cubic equation may be all real ; or:only one of -them real and the remaining two imaginary If only one be real , they Will be of this form ( a , _ ab-I ) and , " by taking their sums and differences according to the rule , and multiplying the latter into the( / V ) , ) one of the resulting binomials will be real , and the other -two imaginary : the cube produced by them will therefore be real .
When all the roots are real , if two be equal , one difference necessarily vanishes ; wherefore the imaginary factor will only appear about the two that remain ; and here again , the cube produced will be real .
But if all the roots are real , and unequal , their sums and differences will all be real : whence , all the binomials will involve the imaginary surd ; which constitutes the irreducible case .
To give examples of this let , 1st .
( X2 X+4= o ) , a cubic equation , whose roots are ( 2,1 +/ _i , l -V the binomials constructed by taking their sums and differences as before , will be 2-1 +tw-1 1+ Vi2 11 -1 -1 24+V-rs I =3 +V/ -inomial -2+ 2V ) , when the latter quantity ( 2 V/ -i ) is drawn into the imaginary surd ( V ?
) ) becomes ( 2 a -real quantity 2dly .
Let ( x33 X+2 o ) be proposed , whose roots have been , in Art .
23 , shown to be ( 2 , ,-i ) .
Here 21 , = + Il 2+I+K l. I=2 VThis latter binomial must evidently remain.-14-= oJ real , since the difference into which the imaginary factor was to have been drawn vanishes .
3dly .
Let ( xa- ' 7x+ 6 ) be given , whose roots are ( i , The binomials derived from these have been before given , in the 2d Example to the first Section of this Article ; and the cube they produce shown to be ( 21 8V ) , the cube root of which cannot be extracted ; it being from the quadratic surd , it involves , in truth , not a cube , but a truncate sixth power in a cubic shape : and when , to remove its equivocal state , it is made rational , shows itself to be properly the sixth power ' equation ( xx6 6 x3 + 32473 ) as before demonstrated 26 .
This is the common reduction of a cubic equation , to one of the sixth degree but in form a quadratic , obtained , by clearing of its quadratic surd , the pure cubic formed by either of the two sets of binomials before described and this is the only reduction of it yet discovered .
Perhaps the method called CARDAN'S rule , is the shortest mode of effecting this reduction ; but I am not aware , that the realprinciple upon which it is founded has been any where fully analysed and explained , except in the foregoing investigation of it .
The ordinary expositions of it -certainly disclose nothing of the principle , and are even in many respects faulty ; for they treat it as the effect of a suppos position or lucky conjecture , when , in fact , there is no supposition or conjecture made ; a regular clue , furnished by certain demonstrable peculiarities in some functions of this order of quantities , being pursued , till such a relationship amongst the roots may be inferred , as may be converted into equality at some known period .
They also fail to account for the most striking part of the result ; the irreducibility happening uniformly in cases where it has been supposed least to be expected , i. e. when the roots are real ; which they refer to a particular limitation in one of the steps taken , when it is , in truth , of much deeper origin than any particular method , being the necessary consequence of the constitution of the cube power .
27 .
The result of these observations upon cubic equations shows , that directly they are not resolvable i. e. they cannot , like quadratics , be always brought to a mere extraction of their correspondent root : that , however , by means of the peculiarities inseparable from the number of three quantities , a relation is discoverable , which inevitably gives equal roots to the equation of the cubes of a particular function of them ; but that , that function involves sometimes a quadratic surd which was not in the roots themselves , but arose from the form necessary to be given them ; that the equal relation not taking place in any case , till the cube of that function , and , in some cases , not being rational , -till the square of that cube , the equation is not lowered in degree , by the operation , but rather increased .
28 .
Let ( n 4 ) ) , and the equation become the general biquadratic '(x4 , ,-px ' + ' qx -rx +s= a ) , the number of differences are twelve ; we cannot , therefore , hope to obtain a direct simple resolution .
But , in Art .
14 , two peculiarities belonging to sets of four quantities were pointed out , from which it is easy to obtain a reduction of the equation to a cubic form .
Thefirst peculiarity there mentioned , was shown to subsist among the sums of the combinations of the roots in pairs .
If ( a , b , c -d , ) be supposed the roots of the given equation , and their combinations by two ( ab , ac , ad , bc , bd , cd , ) be summed in pairs , though the number of quantities so formed are no fewer than 3o , yet there is an evident distinction obserrvable amongst them ; for , in some , ( the first six , ) no letter occurs twice .
If , therefore , instead of simply requiring the sums of the combinations of the roots in pairs , that function of the roots had been required , consisting of the sums of these combinations , into the forming of which no root enters twice , only six out of the whole number of combinations of the kind would answer that condition ; and those six would be the same three repeated , for ( ab + cd , and cd + ab &amp;c. ) are the same quantities .
So that the three quantities ( a b+ cd , ac+ bd , ad + bc , ) would be the functions required , and all of the kind that can be made .
Now , there is no proposition in the theory of equations more certain , than that the equation of any regular function of the roots may always be found by means of the known values of the coefficients.* As there are but three functions in this case , the resulting equation must consequently be a cubic ; and , by taking the several combinations of the quantities ( ab + cd , ac + bd , ad + bc , ) , we may obtain their equation , .
viz. ( xe-qx %Pr4sx -tp1s ?
4qs---r o ) &gt; ; Therefore , the fnding the equation of that function of the roots fa biquadratic which arises from its combinations by two summed in pairs , so however that no root shall occur twice in any scb sum , reduces the biquadratic to a cubic .
29 .
Another peculiarity of four quantities is also given in Art .
14- , i. e. that if taken originally so as to have their sum equal to nothing , the six quantities formed from their sums in pairs , will be the same three quantities taken both affirmatively and negatively .
Then we know , by the reasoning in Art .
ii the equation of those quantities ( though of the sixth degree ) will want every alternate term , or be of a cubic form ; accordingly , the equation of the function of the roots formed by sum* WARING'S Meds Algeb .
cap. i. p. 1 .
t infra .
6 p4 ming them in pairs , isx __q_+_X_ v+ 9J p4 ?
r = o , +4 X which , when ( p ) is supposed to vanish , becomes ( x2 qx4 +q -4sxro ) .
So .
These two methods , one applying to the biquadratic equations complete in their terms , and the other to those from which the second term has been expunged , are , all that have yet been discovered ; and , notwithstanding the number of different methods attributed to different writers , which from their manner of setting out appear distinct , they will all be found to resolve themselves , in principle , into one of these .
Dr. HUTTON'S Mathematical Dictionary , under the article Biquadratic Equations , gives four methods ; viz. FERRARI'S , DES CARTES'S , EULER'S , and SIMPSON'S ; to which may be added another by Dr. WARING , t and perhaps many more .
They proceed upon a variety of different contrivances ; but , when analysed , and the real object gained is viewed apart from the process that led to it , FERRARI'S , which is the oldest and does not require the extinction of the second term , will be seen to produce the cubic ( x ' q x ' + pr 45 X -.p 's 44qs r1= o ) ; and DES CARTES'S , which supposes the second term to be first destroyed , terminates in the cubic-formed equation of the sixth degree ( x6-2 qx4 + qua-4slxt-rat a ) .
The rest produce cubics , or cubicformed sixth powers , whose roots are some parts or multiples of this last ; except WARING'S method , which does not expunge the second term , and therefore produces a cubic whose roots are parts of the first .
But , whether the resulting equation be * WARING'S Medit .
Algeb .
p. 133 .
j Ibid. p. 13 8 ; and the Appendix to Dr. HUTTON'S Dictionary .
that of the function , formed by summing the combinations by two of the roots in pairs , or summing the roots -themselves in pairs , or the equation of the halves , or quarters , or doubles , trebles , &amp;c. of those functions , is immaterial ; no new function is employed , no other principle put in action , than what is derived .
from.the general properties of this degree of quantities here explained .
31 .
Biquadratics being generally thus reducible to cubics of course , by resolving those cubics , distinguishing what function their roots are of the roots of the original biquadratic , they may all be found ; and , for practical utility , there is no preference to be made of either of the two methods ; for , the first , though a real cubic , being formed from products of the roots , it requires a quadratic equation to obtain them after the cubic is resolved ; whereas the second , though an equation of the sixth power , being formed from simple addition of the roots , gives them at once .
But , as-both these cubics necessarily have all their roots real , when those of the given biquadratic are so , and the resolution of cubics is in that case imaginary , it follows , that no biquadratic having all its roots real , can admit of a real solution by either of these methods .
32 .
The formula expressing the actual resolution of a biquadratic has not been given ; the writers upon algebra going no further than to point out the cubics by means of which such a resolution may be obtained .
To be sure , such a formula would be very long , and ( till the 'imperfection in the cubic resolution , which must make a large part of it , can be removed , ) embarrassed with radicals , so as to be of little practical use ; but it would be a valuable accession to the theoretical part of algebra , to have the analysis of this degree carried as far as that of the preceding , by developing every part of the functions , that enter into the resolution , so as to be able to compose it at once , or make a complete reduction of the equation , without the intervention of any other steps .
33 .
Let ( n ) be taken ( j ) , or any higher number .
Here , the number of differences is increased to twenty ; and , the higher we go the more they increase , so that a direct simple resolution is out of the question .
Nor are we yetacquainted with any peculiarity attending five , or any higher number of quantities , upon wh1licll we can ground a relation to effect a reduction of any sort ; wherefore , no method is known for equations of this and the hig-her orders .
Whether any may ever be discovered , it is not easy to pronounce : if the reasoning from Art .
8 to Art .
15 , of this Paper , be correct , there can be no chance , until some peculiar property of quantities of this class can be hit upon .
It is perhaps a discouraging presumption against the existence of any such property , that no art nor labour has hitherto afforded the least clue to lead to one , but , on the other hand , it is impossible to tell what general properties of quantity may remain to be discovered ; and , from the great distance the peculiarities of the degrees we have treated of lie from the surface , and their total want of order or connection with each other , it may be justly expected those of the higher degrees may lie still more detached and remote , beyond any efforts that have yet been made upon the subject .
The proper method to proceed seems there fore to be , abandoning all projects for the general resolution of equations , to investigate regularly the abstract properties of each separate order or number of quantities , turning them into all shapes , sifting all their combinations , and constructing and examining the equations of different complex functions of them , in order to see if latent peculiarities be not to be traced out in some of them .
Wherever any distinguishing property is found , it will , by the principles here explained , infallibly lead to some method for the degree to which it belongs ; and , whoever may be fortunate enough to discover any such property , in five , six , or any higher order of quantities , will have the honour of removing the important-and hitherto impenetrable barrier , which has so long obstructed the farther improvement of algebra .

