XII .
An Account of some Experiments on the Fecundation of Vegetables .
In a Letter from Thomas Andrew Knight Esq. to the Righton .
Sir Joseph .
Banks , K. B. P. R. S. Read May 9 , 1799 .
Elton , April z , i 7990 HEresult of -some experiments which I have amused myself in making on plants &gt; , appearing to me to be interesting to the naturalist , by proving the existence of superfoetation in the ve-getable world , and being likely to conduce to some improvements in agriculture , I have taken the liberty to communicate them to you .
The breeders of animals have very long entertained an opinion , that considerable advantages are obtained by breeding from males and females not related to epach other .
Though this opinion has lately been controverted , the number of its opposers has , gradually diminished ; and I can speak from my own observation and experience , that animals degenerate , in size at least on the same pasture , and in other respects under the same management , when this process of crossing the breed is neglected .
The close analogy between the animal and vegetable world , and the sexual system equally pervading both , induced me to suppose , that similar means might be productive of similar effects in each ; and the event has , I think , fully justified this opinion .
The principal object I had in view , was to obtain new and improved varieties of the apple , to supply the place of those which have become diseased and unproductive , by having been cultivated beyond the period which nature appearsto have , assigned to their existence .
But , as I foresaw that several years must elapse , before the success or failure of this process could possibly be ascertained , I wished , in the interval , to see what would be its effects on annual plants .
Amongst these , none appeared so well calculated to answer my purpose as the common pea ; not only because I could obtain many varieties of this plant , of different forms , sizes , and colours ; but also , because the structure of its blossom , by preventing the ingress of insects and adventitious farina , hasrendeed itsvarieties remarkably permanent .
I had a kind growing in-my garden , which , having beer long cultivated in the same soil ; had ceased to -be productive , and did not appear to recover The whole of its former " vigour , when removed to a soil of a somewhat different quality ; on this , my first experiment , in 1 787 was made .
Having opened a dozen of its immature blossoms , I destrroyed the male parts , taking great care -not to injure the female ones ; and , a few days afterwards , when the blos'soms.appeared mature , I introduced the farina of pa very large and luxuriant gray pea into one half of the blossoms , leaving the other half as they were .
The pods of each grew equally well but I soon perceived , that in those into whose blossoms the farina had not been introduced , the seeds remained nearly as they were before the blossoms expanded , and in that state they withered..Those in the other pods attained maturty , but were not in any sensible degree different from those affiorded by other plants of the same variety ; owing I imagine , to the ' ternal covering of the seed ( as I have found in other plants ) being furnished entirely by the female .
In the succeeding spring , the difference , however , became extremely obvious ; for the plants from them rose with excessive luxuriance , and the colour of their leaves and stems clearly indicated , that they had all exchanged their whiteness for the colour of the male parent : the seeds produced in autumn were dark gray .
By introducing the farina of another white variety , ( or , in some instances , by simple culture , ) I found this colour was easily discharged , and a numerous variety of new kinds produced , many of which were , in size , and in every other respect , much superior to the original white kind , and grew with excessive luxuriance , some of them attaining the height of more than twelve feet .
I had frequent occasion to observe , in this plant , a stronger tendency to produce purple blossoms ; and coloured seeds , than white ones ; for , when I introduced the farina of a purple blossom into a wxhite one , the whole of the seeds in the succeeding year became coloured ; but , when I endeavoured to discharge this colour , by reversing the process , a part only of them afforded plants with white blossoms ; this part sometimes occupying one end of the pod .
, and being at other times irregularly intermixed with those which , when sown , retained their colour .
It may perhaps be -supposed , that something might depend on the quantity of farina employed ; but I never could discover , in this , or in any other experiment , in which superfoetation did not take place , that the largest or smallest quantity of farina afforded any difference in the effect produced .
The dissimilarity I observed in the offspring afforded by dif .
ferent kinds of farina , in these experiments , pointed out to me an easy method of ascertaining whether superfeetation ( the MnCCXCIX , D d existence of which has been admitted amongst animals ) could also take place in the vegetable world .
For , as the offspring of a white pea is always white , unless the farina of a coloured kind be introduced into the blossom , and , as the colour of the gray one is always transferred to its offspring , though the female be white , it readily occurred to me , that if the farina of both were mingled , or applied at the same moment , the offspring of each could be easily distinguished .
My first experiment was not altogether successful ; for the offspring of five pods ( the whole which escaped the birds ) received their colour from the coloured male .
There was , however , a strong resemblance to the other male , in the growth and character of more than one of the plants ; and the seeds of several , in the autumn , very closely resembled it in every thing but colour .
In this experiment , I used the farina of a white pea , which possessed the remarkable property of shrivelling excessively when ripe ; and , in the second year , I obtained white seeds from the gray ones above 'mentioned , perfectly similar to it .
I am strongly disposed to believe , that the seeds were here of common parentage ; but I do not conceive myself to be in possession of facts sufficient to enable me to speak with decision on this question .
If , however , the female afford the first organised atom , and the farina act only as a stimulus , it appears to me by no means impossible , that the explosion of two vesicles of farina at the.same moment , ( taken from different plants , ) may afford seeds ( as I have supposed ) of common parentage ; and , as I am unable to discover any source of : inaccuracy in this experiment , I must believe this to have happened .
Another species of superfoetation ( if I have justly applied that term to a process in which one seed appears to have been the offspring of two males ) has occurred to me so often , as to remove all possibility of doubt as to its existence .
In 1797 , the -year after I had seen the result of the last mentioned experiment , having prepared a great many white blossoms I introduced the farina of a white and that of a gray pea , nearly at the same moment , into each ; and as , in the last year , the character of the co-loured malehad prevailed , I used its farina more sparingly than that of the white one ; and now almost every pod afforded plants of different colours .
The majority , however , were white ; but the characters of the two kinds were not sufficiently distinct to allow me to judge with precision , whether any of the seeds produced were of common parentage or not .
In the last year , I was more fortunate : having prepared blossoms of the little early frame pea , I introduced its own farina , and immediately afterwards that of a very large and late gray kind , and I sowed the seeds thus obtained in the end of the last summer .
Many of them retained the colour and character of the small early pea , not in the slightest degree altered , and blossomed before they were eighteen inches high ; whilst others , ( taken from the same pods , ) whose colour was changed , grew to the height of more than four feet , and were killed by the frost , before any blossoms appeared .
It is evident that in these instances superfoetation took place ; and it is equally evident , that the seeds were not all of common parentage .
Should subsequent experience evince , that a single plant may be the offspring of two males , the analogy between animal and vegetable nature may induce some curious conjecture , relative to the process of generation in the animal world .
In the course of the preceding experiments , I could never DdX observe that the character , either of the male or female , in this plant , at all preponderated in the offspring but , as this point appeared interesting , I made a few trials to ascertain it .
And , as the foregoing observations had occurred in experiments made principally to obtain new and improved varieties of the pea , for garden culture , I chose , for a similar purpose , the more hardy varieties usually sown in the fields .
By introducing the farina of the largest and most luxuriant kinds into the blossoms of the most diminutive , and by reversing this process , I found that the powers of the male and female , in their effects on the offspring , are exactly equal .
The vigour of the growth , the size of the seeds produced , and the season of maturity , were the same , though the one was a very early , and the other a late variety .
I had , in this experiment , a striking instance of the stimulative effects of crossing the breeds ; for the smallest variety , whose height rarely exceeded two feet , was increased to six feet ; whilst the height of the large and luxuriant kind was very little diminished .
By this process , it is evident , that any number of new varieties may be obtained ; and it is highly probable , that many of these will be found better calculated to correct the den fects of different soils and situations , than any we have at present ; for , I imagine that all we now possess , have in a great measure been the produce of accident ; and it will rarely happen , in this or any other case , that accident has done all that art will be found able to accomplish .
The success of my endeavours to produce improved varieties of the pea , induced me to try some experiments on wheat ; but these did not succeed to my expectations .
I readily obtained as many varieties as I wished , by merely sowing the different kinds together ; for the structure of the blossom of .
this plant ( unlike that of the pea ) freely admits the ingress of adventitious farina , and is thence very liable to sport in varieties .
Some of those I obtained were excellent ; -others very bad ; and none of them permanent .
By separating the best varieties , a most abundant crop was produced ; but its quality was not quite equal to the quantity , and all the discarded varieties again made their appearance .
It appeared to me an extraordinary circumstance , that , in the years 1795 and 1796 , when almost the whole crop of corn in the island was blighted , the varieties thus obtained , and these only , eschped , in this neighbourhood , though sown in several different soils and situations .
My success on the apple ( as far as long experience and at- .
tention have enabled me to judge from the cultivated appearance ' of trees which have not yet borne fruit ) ' has been fully equal to my hopes .
But , as the improvement of this fruit was the first object of my attention , no probable means of improvement , either from soil or aspect , were neglected .
The plants , however , which I obtained from my effortsto unite the good qualities of two kinds of apple , seem to possess the greatest health and luxuriance of growth , as well as the most promising appearance in other respects .
In some of these , the-character of the male appears to prevail ; in others , that of the female ; and in others , both appear blended , or neither is distinguishable .
These variations , which were often observable in the seeds taken from a single apple , evidently arise from the want of permanence in the character of this fruit , when raised from seed .
The results of similar experiments on another fruit , the grape , were nearly the same as of those on the apple , except that , by mingling the farina of a black and a white gralpe , just as the blossoms of the latter were .
expanding , I sometimes obad tained plants , from the same berry , so dissimilar , Athat I had good reason to believe them the produce of superfoetation .
By taking off the cups , and destroying the immature male parts , ( as in the pea , ) I perfectly succeeded in combining the characters of different varieties of this -fruit , as far as the changes of form , and autumnal , tints , in theleaves of the offspring , will allow me to judge .
Many experiments , of the same kind , were tried on other plants ; but it is sufficient to say , that all tended to , evince , that improved varieties of every fruit and esculent plant may be obtained by this process , and that nature intended that a sexual intercourse should take place between neighbouring plants of the same species .
The probability of this will , I think , .
be ape parent , when we take a view of the variety of methods which nature has taken to disperse the farina , even of those plants in which it has placed the male and female parts within the same empalement .
It is often scattered by an elastic exertionof the filaments which support it , on the first opening of the blossom ; and its excessive lightness renders it capable of being carried to a great distance by the wind .
Its position within the blossom , is generally well adapted to place it on the bodies of insects ; and the villous coat of the numerous family of bees , is not less well calculated to carry it .
I have frequently ohbserved , with great pleasure , the dispersion of the farina of some of the grasses , when the sun had just risen in a dewy morning .
It seemed to be impelled from the plant with considerable force ; and , being blue , was easily visible , and very strongly resembled , in appearance , the explosion of a grain of gun .
powder .
An examination of the structure of the blossoms of many plants , will immediately point out , that nature has some thing more in view , than that its own proper males should fecundate each blossom ; for the means it employs are always those best calculated to answer the intended purpose .
But the farina is often so placed , that it can never reach the summit of the pointal , unless by adventitious means ; and many trials have convinced me , that it has no action on any other part of it .
In promoting this sexual intercourse between neighbouring plants of the same species , nature appears to me to have an important purpose in view ; for , independent of its stimulative power , this intercourse certainly tends to confine within more narrow limits , those variations which accidental richness or poverty of soil usually produces .
It may be objected , by those who admit the existence of vegetable mules , that , under this extensive intercourse , , these must have been more numerous ; but my total want of success , in many endeavours , to produce a single mule plant , makes me much disposed to believe that hybrid plants have been mistaken for mules ; and to doubt ( with all the deference I feel for the opinions of LINNIEUS and his illustrious followers ) whether nature ever did , or ever will , permit the production of such a monster .
The existence of numerous mules in the animal world , between kindred species , is allowed ; but nature has here guarded against their production , by impelling every animal to seek its proper mate ; and , amongst the feathered tribe , when , from perversion of appetite , sexual intercourse takes place between those of distinct.genera , * it has Iin some instances at least , rendered the death of the female the inevitable consequence .
But , :in the vegetable world , there is not any thing to -direct the male toits proper female : its farina is carried by winds and insects , to plants of every different genus and species ; and it therefore appears to me , ( as vegetable mules certainly are 'not common .
) : that nature has not permitted thema to exist at alL I cannot dismiss this subject , without expressing my regret , that those who have made the science of botany their study , should have considered the improvement of those vegetables -which , in their cultivated state , afford the largest portion of subsistence to mankind and other animals , as little connected with the object of their pursuit .
Hence it has happened , that whilst much attention has been paid to the improvement of every species of useful animal , the most valuable esculent plants have been almost , wholly neglected .
But , when the extent of the benefit which would arise to the agriculture of the country , from the possession of varieties of plants which , with the same extent-of soil and labour , would afford-even a small increase of produce , is considered , this subject appears of no inconsiderable importance .
The improvement of animals is attended with much expense , and the improved kinds necessarily extend themselves slowly ; but a single bushel of improved wheat or peas , may in ten years be made to afford seed enough to supply the whole island ; and a single apple , or other fruit-tree , may within the same time be extended to every garden in it .
These consi7 .
derations have been the cause of my addressing the foregoing observations to you at this time ; for it was much my wish to have ascertained , before I wrote to you , whether in any instance a single plant can be the offspring of two male parents .
The decision of thdt question must of necessity have occupied two years , and must therefore be left to the test of future experts meant .

