XI .
An Inquiry concerning the Weight ascribed to Heat .
By Benjamin , Count of Rumford , F. R. S. M. 1 .
L A. &amp;c. Read May 9 , 1799 .
tree various experiments which have hitherto been made with a view to determine the question so long agitated , relative to the weight which has been supposed to be gained , or to be lost , by bodies upon their being heated , are of a nature so , very delicate , and are liable to so many errors , not only on account of the imperfections of the instruments made use of , but also , of those , much more difficult to appreciate , arising from the vertical currents in the atmosphere , caused by the hot or the cold body which is placed in the balance , that it is not at all surprising that opinions have been so much divided , relative to a fact so very difficult to ascertain .
It is a considerable time since I first began to meditate on this subject , and I have made many experiments with a view to its investigation ; and in these experiments , I have taken all those precautions to avoid errors , which a knowledgeof the various sources of them , and an earnest desire to determine a fact which I conceived to be of importance to be known , could inspire ; but , though all my researches tended to convince me more and more , that a body acquires no additional wez'ht zupon being heated , or rather , that heat has no effect whatever upon the weights of bodies , I have been so sensible of the delicacy of the inquiry , that I was for a long time afraid to form a decided opinion upon the subject .
Being much struck with the experiments recorded in the Transactions of the Royal Society , Vol. LXXV .
made by Dr. FORDYCE , upon the weight said to be acquired by water upon being frozen ; and being possessed of an excellent balance , belonging to His most Serene Highness the ELECTOR PALATINE DUKE of BAVARIA ; early in the beginning of the winter of the year 1787 , -as soon as the cold was sufficiently intense for my purpose , -1 set about to : repeat those experiments in order to convince myself whether the very extraordinary fact related , might be depended on ; and , with a view to removing , as far as was in my power , every source of error and deception , I proceeded in the following manner .
Having provided a number of glass bottles , of the form and size of what in England is called a Florence flask , blown as thin as possible , and of the same shape and dimensions , I chose out from amongst them two ) which , after using every method I could imagine of comparing them together , appeared to be so much alike as hardly to be distinguished .
Into one of these bottles , which I shall call A , I put 4107,86 grains Troy of pure distilled water , which filled it about half full ; and ; into the other , B , I put an equal weight of weak spirit of wine ; and , sealing both the bottles hermetically , and washing them , and wiping them perfectly clean and dry on the outside , I suspended them to the arms of the balance , and placed the balance in a large room , -which for some weeks had been regularly heated every day by a German stove , and in which the air was kept up to the temperature of 61 ?
of FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer , with very little variation .
Having suffered the bottles , with their contents , to remain in this situation till I conceived they must have acquired the temperature of the circumambient air , I wiped them afresh , with a very clean dry cambric handkerchief , and brought them into the most exact equilibrium possible , by attaching a small piece of very fine silver wire to the arm of the balance to ' which the bottle which was the lightest was suspended .
Having suffered the apparatus to remain in this situation about twelve hours longer , and finding no alteration in the relative weights of the bottles , they continuing all this time to be in the most perfect equilibrium , -I now removed them into a large uninhabited room , fronting the north , in which the air , which was very quiet , was at the temperature of 290 , F ; the air without doors being at the same time at 270 ; and , going out of the room , and locking the door after me , I suffered the bottles to remain forty-eight hours , undisturbed , in this cold situation , attached to the arms of the balance as before .
At the expiration of that time , I entered the room , _.using the utmost caution not to disturb the balance , when , to my great surprise , I found that the bottle A very sensibly preponderated .
The water which this bottle contained was completely frozen into one solid body of ice ; but the spirit of wine , ii m the bottle B , showed no signs of freezing .
I now very cautiously restored the equilibrium , by adding small pieces of the very fine wire of which gold lace is made , to the arm of the balance to which the bottle B was suspended , when I found that the bottle A had augmented its weight by 3 part of its whole weight at the beginning of the experiment ; the weight of the bottle with its contents having been 481 1,23 grains Troy , ( the bottle weighing 703,377 grains , and the water 417786 grains , ) and it requiring now !
L3 parts of a grain , added to the opposite arm of the balance , to counterbalance it .
Having had occasion just at this time to write to my friend , Sir CHARLES BLAGDEN , upon another subject , I added a postscript to my letter , giving him a short account of this experiment , and telling hinm how " very contrary to my expectation " the result of it had turned out ; but I soon after found that I had been too hasty in my communication .
Sir CHARLES , in his answer to my letter , -expressed doubts respecting the fact S but , before his letter had reached me , I had learned from my own experience , how very dangerous it is , in philosophical investigations , to draw conclusions from single experiments .
Having removed the balance , with the two bottles attached to it , from the cold into the warm room , ( which still remained at the temperature of 610 ) , the ice in the bottle A gradually thawed ; and , being at length totally reduced to water , and this water having acquired the temperature of the surrounding air , the two bottles , after being wiped perfectly clean and dry , were found to : weigh as at the beginning of the experiment , before the water was frozen .
This experiment being repeated , gave nearly the same result , the water appearing , when frozen , to be heavier than in its fluid state ; but some irregularity in the manner in which the water lost the additional weight which it had appeared to acquire upon being frozen , when it was afterwards thawed , as also a sensible difference in the quantities of weight apparently acquired in the different experiments , led me to suspect , ; that the experiment could not be depended on for deciding the -fact in question ; I therefore set about to repeat it , with some variations and improvements but , before I give an account of my further investigations relative to this subject,.it may not be amiss to mention the method I pursued for discovering whether the appearances mentioned in the foregoing experiments might not arise from the 'imperfections of my balance ; and it may likewise be proper to give an account , in this place , of an intermediate experiment which I made , with a view to discover , by a shorter route , and in a manner less exceptionable than that above mentioned , whether bodies actually lose , or acquire , any weight , upon acquiring an additional quantity of latent heat .
My suspicions respecting the accuracy of the balance arose from a knowledge , -which I acquired from ' the maker of it , _ of the manner in which it was constructed .
The three principal points of the -balance having been determined , as nearly as possible , by measurement , the axes of motion were firmly fixed in their places , in a right line , and the beam being afterwards finished , and its two arms brought to be in equilibrio , the balance was proved -by suspending weights , which before were known to be exactly equal , to the ends of its arms .
If with these weights the balance remained in equilibrio , it was considered as a proof that the beam was just ; but , if one arm was found to preponderate , the other was gradually lengthened , by beating it upon an anvil , until the difference of the lengths of the arms was reduced to nothing , or until equal weights , suspended to the two arms , remained in equilibrio ; care being taken , before each trial , to bring the two ends of the beam to be in equilibria by reducing , with the file , the arm which had been lengthened .
Though , in this method of constructing balances , the most perfect equality in the lengths of the arms may be obtained , and consequently the greatest possible accuracy , when used at a time when the temperature of the air is the same as when the balance was made , yet , as it may happen , that in order to bring the arms of the balance to be of the same length , - .
one of them may be much more hammered than the other , I suspected it might be possible that the texture of the metal forming the two arms might be rendered so far different , by this operation , as to occasion a difference in their expansions with heat ; and that this difference might occasion a sensible error in the balance , when , being charged with a great weight , it should be exposed to a considerable change of temperature .
To determine whether the apparent augmentation of weight , in the experiments above related , arose in any degree from this cause , I had only to repeat the experiment , causing the two bottles A and ; B to change places upon the arms of the balance ; but , as I had already found a sensible difference in the results of different repetitions of the same experiment , made as nearly as possible under the same circumstances , and as it was above all things of importance to ascertain the accuracy of my balance , I preferred -making " a particular experiment for that purpose .
My first idea was , to suspend to the arms of the balance , by very fine wires , two equal globes of glass , filled with mercury , and , suffering them to remain in my room till theny should haveacquired the known temperature of the air in it ; to have removed them afterward into the cold , and to have seen if they still remained in equiilibrio , under such difference of tempera-ture ; but considering the obstinacy with which moisture aide heres to the surface of glass , and being afraid that , somehow or other , notwithstanding all may precautions , one of the globes might acquire or retain more of it than the other , and that hy that means its apparent weight might be increased ; and having found by a former experiment , of which I have already had the honour of communicating an account to the Royal Society , that the gilt surfaces of metals do not attract moisture ; instead of the glass globes filled with mercury , 1 made use of two equal solid globes of brass , well gilt and burnished , which I suspended to the arms of the balance , by fine gold wires .
These globes , which weighed 497 grains each , being wiped perfectly clean , and having acquired the temperature ( 61 ' ) of my room , in which they were exposed more than twenty-four hours , were brought into the most scrupulous equilibrium , and were then removed , attached to the arms of the balance , into a room in which the air was at the temperature of 260 , where they were left all night .
The result of this trial , furnished the most satisfactory proof of the accuracy of the balance ; for , upon entering the room , I found the equilibrium as perfect as at the beginning of the experiment .
Having thus removed my doubts respecting the accuracy of my balance , I now resumed my investigations relative to the augmentation of weight which fluids have been said to acquire upon being congealed .
In the experiments which I had made , I had , as I then imagined , guarded as much as possible against every source of error and deception .
The bottles being of the same size , neither any occasional alteration in the pressure of the atmosphere during the experiment , nor the necessary and unavoidable difference in the densities of the air in the hot and in the cold rooms in which they were weighed , could affect their apparent , weights ; and their shapes and their quantities of surface being the same , and as they remained for such a considerable length of time in the heat and cold to which they were exposed , I flattered myself that the quantities of moisture remaining attached to their surfaces , could not be so different as sensibly to effect the results of the experiments._-But , in regard to this last circumstance , I afterwards found reason to conclude that my opinion was erroneous .
Admitting the fact stated by Dr. FORDYCE , -(and which my experiments had hitherto rather tended to corroborate than to contradict , )lI could not conceive any other cause for the augmentation of the apparent weight of water , upon its being frozen , than the loss of so great a proportion of its latent heat as that fluid is known to evolve when it congeals ; and I concluded , that if the loss of latent heat added to the weight of one body , it must of necessity produce the same effect on another , and consequently , that the augmentation of the quantity of latent beat must : , - .
in all bodies , and in all cases,..--diminish their apparent weights .
rTo determine whether this is actually the case or not , I made the following experiment .
Having provided two bottles , as nearly alike as possible , and in all respects similar to those made use of in the experiments abovementioned into one of them I put 4012,46 grains of water , and into the other an equal weight of mercury and , sealing them hermetically and suspending them to the arms of the balance , I suffered them to acquire the temperature of my room , 610 ; then , bringing them into a perfect equilibrium with each other , I removed them into a room in which the air was at the temperature of 340 , where they remained twenty-four hours.-But there was not the least appearance of either of them acquiring , or losing , any weight .
Here it is very certain , that the quantity of heat lost by the water , must have been very considerably greater than that lost by the mercury ; the specific quantities of latent heat in water and in mercury , having been determined to be to each other as iooo to A3 ; but this difference in the quantities of heat lost , produced no sensible difference on the weights of the fluids in question .
Had any difference of weight really existed , had it been no more than one millionth part of the weight of either of the fluids , I should certainly have discovered it ; -and , had it amounted to so much as 7 part of that weight , I should have been able to have measured it ; so sensible , and so very accurate , is , the balance which I used in these experiments .
I was now much confirmed in my suspicions , that the apparent augmentation of the weight of the water upon its being frozen , in the experiments before related , arose from some accidental cause ; but I was not able to conceive what that cause could possibly be , -unless it were , eithera greater quantity of moisture attached to the external surface of the bottle which , contained the water , than to the surface of that containing the spirits of wine , -or some vertical current or currents of air , caused by the bottles or one of them not being exactly of the temperature of the surrounding atmosphere .
Though I had foreseen , and , as I thought , guarded sufficiently against , these accidents , -by making use of bottles of the same size and form , and which were blown of the same kind of glass , and at the same time , and by suffering the bottles , in the experiments , to remain for so considerable a length of time exposed to the different degrees of heat and of cold , which alternately they were made to acquire ; yet , as I did not know the relative conducting powers of ice and of spirit of wine with respect to heat ; or , in .
other words , the deges of facilty or difficulty with which they acquire the temperature of the medium in which they are exposed --or the time taken up in that operation ; and , consequently , was not absolutely certain as to the equality of the temperatures of the contents of the bottles at the time when their weights were compared , I determined now to repeat the experiments , with such variations as should put the matter in question out of all doubt .
I was the more anxious to assure myself of the real temperatures of the bottles and of their contents , as any difference in their temperatures might vitiate the experiment , not only by causing unequal currents in the air , but also , by causing , at the same time , a greater or less quantity of moisture to remain attached to the glass .
To remedy these evils , and also to render the experiment more striking and satisfactory in other respects , I proceeded in the following manner .
Having provided three bottles , A , B , and C , as nearly alike as possible , and resembling in all respects those already described ; .into the first , A , I put 4214,28 grains of water , and a small thermometer , made on purpose for the experiment , and suspended in the bottle in such a manner that its bulb remained in the middle of the mass of water ; into the second bottle , B , I put a like weight of spirit of wine , with a like thermometer ; and , into the bottle C , I put an equal weight of mercury .
These bottles , being all hermetically sealed , were placed in a large room , sin a corner far removed from the doors and windows , and where the air appeared to be perfectly quiet ; and , being suffered to remain in this situation more than twenty-four hours , the heat of the room ( 61i ) being kept up all that time with as little variation as possible , and the contents of the bottles A and B appeanng , by their enclosed thermometers , to be exactly at the same temperature , the bottles were all wiped with a very clean dry cambric handkerchief ; iad , being afterwards suffered to remain exposed to the free air of the room a couple of hours longer , in order that any inequalities in the quantities of heat , -or of the moisture attached to their surfaces , -which might have been occasioned-by the wiping , might be correted by the operation of the atmosphere by which they were surrounded , they were all weighed , and were brought into the most exact equilibrium with each other , by means of small pieces of very fine silver wire:attached to the necks of those of the bottles which were the lightest .
This being done , the bottles were all removed into a room in which the air was at ?
QO ' where they were suffered to rmain , perfectly at rest and undisturbed , forty-eight hours ; the bottles A and B ` being suspended to the arms of the balance , and the bottle C suspended , at an equal height , to the arm of a stand constructed for that purpose , : and placed as near the balance as possible , and a very sensible-thermometer:suspended by the side of it .
At the end of forty-eight hours , -during which time the apparatus was left in this situation , -l entered the room , opening the door very gently , for fear of disturbing the balance ; when I had the pleasure to find the three thermometers , -viz .
that in the bottle A , ( which was now enclosed in a solid cake of ice , -.that in the bottle B , and that suspended in the 7open air of the room , all standing at the same point , 29 ' F , and the bottles A and B remaining in the most pefect equilibrium To assure myself that the play of the balance was free , I now approached it very gently , and caused it to vibrate ; and I had the satisfaction to find .
, -not only that it moved with the utmost freedom , -but also , -when its vibrationnceased , -hat it rested precisely at the point from which it had set out .
I now removed the bottle B from the balance , and put the bottle C in its place ; and I found that that likewise remained of the same apparent weight as at the beginning of the experiment , being in the sameperfect equilibrium with the bottle A as at first .
I afterwards removed the whole apparatus into a warm room , and , causing the ice in the bottle A tothaw , and suffering the three bottles to remain till they and their contents had acquired the exact temperature of the surrounding air , I wiped them very clean , and , comparing them together , I found their weights remained unaltered .
This experiment I afterwards repeated several times , and always with precisely the same result ; the water , in no instance , appearing to gain , or to lose , the least weight , upon being frozen , or upon being thawed ; neither were the relative weights of the fluids in either of the other bottles in the least changed , by the various degrees of heat , and of cold , to which they were exposed .
If the bottles were weighed at a time when their contents were not precisely of the same temperature , they would frequently appear to have gained , or to have lost , something of their weights ; -but this doubtless arose from the vertical cur- ' rents which they caused ' in the atmosphere , upon being heated or cooled in it ; or to unequal quantities of moisture attached to the surfaces of the bottles ; -or to both these causes operating together .
As I knew that the conducting power of mercury , with respect to heat , was considerably greater than either that of water , or that of spirit of -wine , while its capacity for receiving heat is much less than that of either of them , I did not think it necessary to enclose a -thermometer in .
the bottle C , which contained the mercury ; for it was evident , that when the contents of the other two .
bottles should appear , by theirthermometers , to have arrived at the temperature of the medium in which they were -exposed , the contents of the bottle C could not fail to have acquired it also , and even to have arrived at it before them for , the time taken upin the .
heating or in the cooling of any body , is , cacteris paribu 's , as the capacity of the body to receive and retain heat , directly , and as its conducting power , inversely .
The bottles were suspended to the balance by silver wires , about two inches long , with hooks at the ends of them ; and , in removing and changing the bottles , I took care not to touch the.glass .
I likewise avoided , upon all occasions , and particularly in the cold .
room , coming near the balance with my breath , -or touching it , or any part of the apparatus with my naked hands .
Having determined that water does not acquire or lose any weight , upon being changed from a state of fluidity to that of ice , and vice versed , I shall now take my final leave of a subject which has long occupied me , and which has cost me much pains and trouble ; being fully convinced , ( from the results of the above mentioned experiments , ) that if heat be in fact a -substance , or matter , -a fluid sui generis , as haas. .
been supposed- .
which , passing from one body to another , and being accumuJated , is the immediate cause of the phoenomena we ; observe in heated bodies , ( of which , however , I cannot help entertaining doubts , ) it must be something so infinitely rare , even in its most condensed state , as to baffle , all our attempts to discover its gavity .
And , if the opinion which has been adopted by many of our ablest philosophers , that heat is nothing more than an intestine vibratory motion of the constituent parts of heated bodies , should be well founded , it is clear that the weights of bodies can in no wise be affected by such motion It is , no doubt , upon the supposition that heat is a substance distinct from the heated body , and which is accumulated in it , that all the experiments which have been undertaken , with a view to determine the weight which bodies have been supposed to gain , or to lose , upon being heated or cooled , have been made ; and , upon this supposition ( but without , however adopt- .
ing it entirely , as I do not conceive it to be sufficiently proved , ) all my researches have been directed .
The experiments with water , and with ice , were made in a manner which I take to be perfectly unexceptionable ; in which noo foreign cause whatever could affect the results of them - , and the quantity of heat which water is known to part with , upon being frozen , is so considerable , that if this loss has no effect upon its apparent weight , it may be presumed that we shall never be able to contrive an experiment by which we can render the weight of heat sensible .
Water , upon being frozen , has been found to lose a quantity of heat amounting to 14o degrees of FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer ; or , -which is the same thing , , the heat which a given quantity of water , previously cooled to the temperature of freezing , actually loses , upon being changed to ice , if it were to be imbibed and retained by an equal quantity of water , at the given temperature , ( that of freezing , ) would heat it 140 degrees , -or would raise Ait to the temperature of ( 320 + 140 ) 1620 of FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer which is only 60 short of that of boiling -water , 'consequently , any given quantity of water , at the temperature of freezing , upon being actually frozen , loses almost as much hetas , added to'it , would be sufficient tomake it bbil .
It is clear , therefore , that the difference in the quantities of heat contained by the water in its fluid state , and heated to the temperature of 610 F , and by the ice , in the experiments before mentioned , was at least nearly equal to that between water in a state of boiling , and the same at the temperature of freezing .
But this quantity of heat will appear much more considerable , when we consider the great capacity of water to contain heat , and the great apparent effect which the heat that water loses upon being frozen would produce , were it to be imbibed by , or communicated to , any body whose power of receiving and retaining heat is much less .
The capacity of water to receive and retain heat , -or what has been called its specific quantity of latent heat , has been found to be to that of gold as iooo to o,.-or as 20 to 1 ; consequently , the heat which any given quantity of -water loses upon being frozen , .
were it to be communicated to an equal weight of gold , at the temperature of freezing , the gold , instead of being heated 162 degrees , would ' be heated 140 x 20 = 2800 degrees , or , would be raised to a brzght red heat .
It appears therefore to be clearly proved , by my experiments , that a quantity of heat equal to that which 4214 grains ( or about 94 oz. ) of gold would require to heat it from the temperature of freezing water to be red hot , has no sensible effect the Weight , &amp;c. upon a balance capable of indicating sosmall a variation of weight as that of A ; -part of the body in question ; and , if the weight of gold is neither augmented nor lessened by one millionth part , upon being heated from the point of freezing water to that of abrigbt red heat , I think , we may very safely conclude , that ALL ATTEMPTS TO DISCOVER ANY EFFECT 0FV HEAT UPON THE APPARENT WEIGHTS OF EODIES , WILL BEV FRUIT-

