IX .
On a submarine Forest , on the east Coast of England .
&gt; By Joseph Correa de Serra , LL. D. F. R. S. and A. S. Read February 28 , 1799 .
IN geology , more perhaps than Fin any other branch of natural history , there exists a necessity of strictly separating the facts observed from the ideas which , in order to explain them , may occur to the mind of the observer .
In the present state of this science , every well ascertained fact increases our still narrow stock of real knowledge ; when , on the contrary , the reasonings we are enabled to make , are at best but ingenious guesses , which too often bias and mislead the judgment .
I shall therefore endeavour , in this Paper , to give , first , a mere description of the object , unmixed with any systematical ideas , and shall afterwards offer -such conjectures on its cause as seemi to me to be fairly grounded on observation .
It was a common report in Lincolnshire , that a large extent of islets of moor , situated along its coast , and visible only in the lowest ebbs of the year , was chiefly composed of decayed trees .
These islets are marked in MITcHELL'S chart of that coast , by the name of clay huts ; and the village of Huttoft , opposite to which they principally lie , seems to have derived its name from them .
In the month of September , 1796 , I went to Sutton , on the coast of Lincolnshire , in company with the Right Hon , President of this Society , in order to examine their extent and nature .
The i9th of the month , being the first day after the equinoctial full moon , Iwhen the lowest ebbs were to be expected , we went in a boat , at half past twelve at noon , and soon after set foot upon one of the largest islets then appearing .
Its exposed surface was about thirty yards long , and twenty-five wide , when the tide was at the lowest .
A great number of similar islets were visible round us , chiefly to the eastward and southward ; and the fishermen , whose authority on this point is very competent , say , that similar moors are to be found along the whole coast , from Skegness to Grimsby , particularly off Addlethorpe and Mablethorpe .
The channels dividing the islets were , at the time we saw them , wide , and of various depths ; the islets themselves ranging generally from east to west in their largest dimension .
We visited them again in the ebbs of the 20th and 2 ist ; and , though it generally did not ebb so far as we expected , we could notwithstanding ascertain , that they , consisted almost entirely of roots , trunks , branches , and leaves of trees and shrubs , intermixed with some leaves of aquatic plants .
The remains of some of these trees were still standing on their roots ; while the trunks of the greater part lay scattered on the ground , in every possible direction .
The bark of the trees and roots appeared generally as fresh as when they were growing ; in that of the birches particularly , of which a great quantity was found , even the thin silvery membranes of the outer skin were discernible .
The timber of all kinds , on the contrary , was decomposed and soft , in the greatest part of the trees ; in some , however , it was firm , especially in the knots .
The people of the country have often found among them very sound pieces of timber , fit to be employed for several ceconomical purposes .
The sorts of wood which are still distinguishable are birch , fir , and oak .
Other woods evidently exist in these islets , 'of some of which we found the leaves in the soil ; but our present knowledge of the comparative anatomy of timbers , is not so far advanced as to afford us the means of pronouncing with confidence respecting their species In general , the trunks , branches , and roots of the decayed trees , were considerably flattened ; which is a phenomenon observed in the Surtarbrand or fossil wood of Iceland , and which SCHEUCHZER remarked also in the fossil wood found in the neighbourhood of the lake of Thun , in Switzerland .
The soil to which the trees are affixed and in which they grew , is a soft greasy clay ; 5 but , for many inches above its surface , the soil is entirely composed of rotten leaves , scarcely distinguishable to the eye , many of which ; may be separated , by putting the soil in water , and dexterously and patiently using a -spatula , or a blunt knife .
By this method , I obtained some perfect leaves of flex Aquifolium , which are now in the Herbarium ' of the Right Hon. Sir JOSEPH BANKS ; and some other leaves which , though less perfect , seem to belong to some species of willow .
In this stratum of rotten leaves 'we could also distinguish several roots of Arundo .
Pbragmites .
These islets , according to the most accurate information , extend at least twelve miles in length , and about a mile in breadth , opposite to Sutton shore .
; The water without them , towards the sea , generally deepens suddenly , so as to form a steep bank .
The channels between the several islets , when the islets are dry , in the lowest ebbs of the year , are from four to twelve feet deep ; their bottoms are clay or sand , and their direction is generally from east to west .
A well dug at Stkton , by JoSHuA SEARBY , shows that a moor of the same nature is found under ground , in that part of the country , at the depth of sixteen feet ; consequently , very nearly on the sameD level with that which constitutes the islets .
The disposition of the strata was found to be as follows A Clay , 16 feet .
Moor , similar to that of the islets from 3 to 4 ditto .
Soft moor , like the scowerings of a ditch bottom , mixed with shells and silt , 20 ditto .
Marly clay , I foot .
Chalk rock , from i to 2 feet .
Clay , i yards .
Gravel and water ; the water has a chalybeate taste .
In order to ascertain the course of this subterraneous stratum of decayed vegetables , Sir JosEPH BANKS directed a boring to be made , in the fields belonging to the Royal Society , in the parish of Mablethorpe .
Moor , of a similar nature to that of SEARBY'S well , and of the islets , was found , very nearly on the same level , about four feet thick , and under it a soft clay .
The whole appearance of the rotten vegetables we observed , perfectly resembles , according to the remark of Sir JosEPH BANKS , the moor which , in Blankeney fen , and in other parts of the East fen in Lincolnshire , is thrown up in the making of banks ; barks , like those of the birch tree , being there also abundantly found .
This moor extends over all the Lincolnshire fens , and has been traced as far as Peterborough , more:than sixty miles to the south of Sutton .
On the north side , the moory islets , according to the fishermen , extend as far as Grimsby , situated on the south side of the mouth of the Humber ; and it is a remarkable circumstance , that in the , large tracts of low lands which lie on the south banks of that river , a little above its mouth , there is a subterraneous stratum of decayed trees and shrubs , exactly like those we observed at Sutton ; particularly at Axholme isle , a tract of ten miles in length , by five in breadth and atHatfield chase , which comprehends one hundred and eighty thousand acres .
DUGDALE* had long ago made this observation , in the first of these places .
; and DE LA PRYME ?
in the second .
The roots are there likewise standing in the places where they grew the trunks lie prostrate .
The woods are of the same species as at Sutton .
Roots of aquatic plants and reeds are likewise mixed with them ; and they are covered by a stratum of some yards of soil , the thickness of which , though not ascertained with exactness by the abovementioned observers , , we may easily conceive to correspond with that which covers , the stratum of decayed wood at Sutton , by the circumstance of the roots being ( according to Mr. RICHARDSON'S observations ) only visible when the water is low , where a channiel was cut , which has left them .
uncovered .
Little doubt can be entertained of the moory islets of Sutton being a part of this extensive subterraneous stratum , .
, which , by some inroad of the sea , has been there stripped of its covering of soil .
The identity of the levels ; .
that of the species of trees ; the roots of these affixed , in both , to the soil where they grew ; and , above all , the flattened shape of the trunks , branches , and roots , found in the islets , ( which can only be accounted for by the heavy pressure of a superinduced stratum , ) are sufficient reasons for this opinion .
Such a wide spread assemblage of vegetable ruins , lying " almost in the same level , and that level generally under the common mark of low water , must naturally strike the observer , and give birth to the following questions .
i. What is the epoch of this destruction ? ?
2 .
By what agency was it effected . ?
In answer to these questions , I will venture to submit the following reflections .
The fossil remains of vegetables hitherto dug up in so many parts of the globe , are , on a close inspection , found to belong to two very different states of our planet .
The parts of vegetables , and their impressions , found in mountains of a cotaceous , schistous , or even sometimes of a calcareous nature , are chiefly of plants now existing between the tropics , which could neither have grown in the latitudes in which they are dug up , nor have been carried and deposited there by any of the acting forces under the present constitution of nature .
The formation , indeed , of the very mountains in which they are buried , and the nature and disposition of the materials which compose them , are such as we cannot account for by any of the actions and re-actions which , in the actual state of things , take place on the surface of the earth .
We must necessarily recur to that period in the history of our planet , 'when the surface of the ocean was at least so much above its present level , as to cover even the summits of these secondary mountains which contain the remains of tropical plants .
The changes which these vegetables have suffered in their substance , is almost total ; they commonly retain only the external configuration of what they originally were .
Such is the state in which they have been found in England , by LLWYD ; in France , by JUSSIEU ; in the Netherlands , by BURTIN ; not to mention instances in more distant countries .
Some of the impressions or remains of plants found in soils of this nature , which were , by more ancient and less enlightened oryctologists , supposed to belong to plants actually growing in temperate and cold climates , seem , on accurate investigation , to have been parts of exotic vegetables .
In fact , whether we suppose them to have grown near the spot where they are found , or to have been carried thither from different .
parts , by the force of an impelling flood , it is equally difficult to conceive , how organized beings , which , in order to live , require such a vast difference in temperature and in seasons , could live on the same spot , or how their remains could ( from climates so widely distant ) be brought together to the same place , by one -common dislocating cause .
To this ancient order of fossil vegetables belong whatever retains a vegetable shape , found in or near coal mines , and ( to judge from the places where they have been found ) the greater part of the agatized woods .
But , from the species and present state of the trees which are the subject of this Memoir , and from the situation and nature of the soil in which they are found , it seems very clear that they do not belong to this primeval order of vegetable ruins The second order of fossil vegetables , comprehends those which are found in strata of clay or sand ; materials which are the result of slow depositions of the sea or of rivers , agents still at work under the present constitution of our planet .
These vegetable remains are found in such flat countries as may be considered to be of a new formation .
Their vegetable organization still subsists , at least in part ; and their vegetable substance has-suffered a change only in colour , smell , or consistence ; alterations which are produced by the development of their oily and bituminous parts , or by their natural progress towards rottenness .
Such are the fossil vegetables found in Cornwall , by BORLASE ; in , Essex , by DERHAM ; in Yorkshire , by DE LA PRYME , and RICHARDSON ; and in foreign countries , by other naturalists .
These vegetables are found at different depths , some of them much below the present level of the sea , but in clayey or sandy strata , ( evidently belonging to modern formation , ) and have , no doubt , been carried from their original place , and deposited there by the force of great rivers or currents , as it has been observed with .
respect to the Mississipi.* In many instances , however , , these trees and shrubs are found standing on their roots , generally in low or marshy places , above , or very little below , the actual level of the sea .
To this last description of fossil vegetables , the decayed trees here described certainly belong .
They have not been transported by currents or rivers ; but , though standing in their native soil , we cannot suppose the level in which ' they are found , to be the same as that in which they grew .
It would have been impossible for any of these trees and shrubs to vegetate so near the sea , and below the common level of its water : the waves would cover such tracts of land , and hinder any vegetation .
We cannot conceive that the surface of the ocean has ever been lower than it now is ; on the contrary , we are led by numberless phenomena to believe , that the level of the waters in our globe is much below what it was in former periods ; we must therefore conclude , that the forest here de'* Lk COU DR EN1ERE sir ls Depots du Mississipi .
yorn .
de Ehys .
Vol. XXJ , p. 309 scribed grew in a level high enough to permit its vegetation , and that the force ( whatever it was ) which destroyed it , lovered the level of the ground where it stood .
There is a force of subsidence ( particularly in soft ground ) which , being a natural consequence of gravity , slowly though perpetually operating , has its action sometimes quickened and rendered sudden by extraneous causes , for instance , by earthquakes .
The slow effects of this force of subsidence have been accurately remarked in many places ; examples also of its sudden action are recorded in almost every history of grea-t earthquakes .
The , shores of Alexandria , according to DOLOMIEU'S observations- , are a foot lower than they were in gthe time of the PTOLEMIES .
DONATI , in his natural history of the Adriatic .
, has remarked , seemingly with great accuracy , the effects of this subsidence at Venice ; at Pola , in Istria ; at Lissa , BJua , Zara , and Diclo , on the coast of Dalmatia .
In England , BORLASE has given , in the Philosophical Transactions , * a curious observation of a subsidence , of at least sixteen feet , in , the ground between Sampson and Trescaw islands , in Scilly .
The soft and low ground between the towns of Thorne and Gowle , in Yorkshire , a space of many miles , has so much subsided , in latter times , that some old men of Thorne affirmed , " that whereas they could before see little of the steeple , ( of Gowle , ) " d they now see the churchyard wall."+ The instances of similar subsidence which might be mentioned , are innumerable .
This force of subsidence , suddenly acting by means of someearthquake , seems to me the most probable cause to which the actual submarine situation of the forest we are speaking .
I of may .
be ascribed .
It affords a simple easy explanation of the matter its probability is supported by numberless instances of similar events ; and it is not liable to the strong objections which exist against the hypothesis of the alternate depression and elevation of the level of the ocean ; an opinion which , to be credible , requires the support of a great number of proofs , less equivocal than those which have hitherto been urged in its favour , even by the genius of a LAVOISIER.* The stratum ofsoil , sixteen feet thick , placed above the decayed trees , seems to remove the epoch of their sinking and destruction , far beyond the reach of any historical knowledge .
In CAISARWS time , the level of the North sea appears to have been the same as in our days .
Hementions the separation of the Wahal branch of the Rhine , and its junction to the Meuse ; noticing the then existing distance from that junction to the sea ; which agrees , according to D'ANVILLE'S inquiriest with the actual distance .
Some of the Roman roads constructed by order of AuGUSTUS , under AGRIPPA 's administration , leading to the maritime towns of Belgium , still exist , and reach the present shore .
S The descriptions which Roman authors have left us , of the coasts , ports , and mouths of rivers , on both sides of the North sea , agree in general with their present state ; except in the places ravaged by the inroads of this sea , more apt , from its form , to destroy the surrounding countries , thanto increase them .
An exact resemblance exists between maritime Flanders and BASI the opposite low coast of England , both in poitt of elevation above the sea , and , of internal structure and arrangemenLt of their soils .
On both sides , strata of clay , silt , and sand , + ( often mixed with decayed vegetables , ) are found near the surface ; and , in , both , these superior materials cover a very deep stratum of bluish or dark-coloured Qlay , unmixed with extraneous obo.e dies .
On both sides ; they .
are the lowermost part of the soil , existing between the ridges of high lands , * on their respective sides of the same narrow sea .
These two countries are certainly coeval ; and , whatever proves that maritime Flanders has been for many ages out of the sea , rust , in my opinion , prove also , that the forest we are speaking of was long before that time destroyed , and buried under a stratum of soil .
Now it seems proved , from historical records , carefully collected by several learned members of the Brussels Academy , that no material change has happened to the lowermost part of mari* time Flanders , during the period of the last two thousand yearst I am therefore inclined to suppose the original catastrophe which buried this forest , to be of a very ancient date ; but I suspect the inroad of the sea which uncovered the decayed trees of the islets of Sutton , to be comparatively recent .
The state of the leaves and of the timber , and also the tradition of &amp;c. the neighbouring people , concur to strengthen this suspiciow .
Leaves and other delicate parts of plants ; though they may be long preserved ina subterraneous situation , cannqt remain unipjured , when exposed to the action of the Wavesand of the air .
The people of the country believe , that their parish church once stood on the spot where the islets now are , and was sub- .
, merged by the inroads of the sea ; that , at very low.v water , their ancestors could even discern its ruins ; that their present church was built to supply the place of that which the waves washed away ; and that even their present clock belonged to the old church .
So many concomitant though weak testimo- .
nies , incline me to believe their report , and to suppose that some of the stormy inundations of the North sea , which in theselast centuries have washed away such large tracts of land on its shores , took away a soil resting on clay , and at last un " .
covered the trees which are the subject of this Paper ,

