II .
The Bakerian Lecture .
Observations upon an unusual bori- .
zontal Refraction of the Air ; with Remarks on the Variations to which the lower Parts of the Atmosphere are sometimes subject .
By the Rev. S. Vince , A. M. F. R. S. andPlumian Professor of Astronomy and 'exerimental Philosophy , in the University of Cambridge .
Read November 15 , 1798 .
THHE uncertainty of the refraction of the air near the horizon has long been known to astronomers , the mean refraction varying by quantities which cannot be accounted for from the variations of the barometer and thermometer ; on which account , altitudes of the heavenly bodies which are not more than , ' or 6 ?
, ought never to be made use of when any consequences are to be deduced from them .
The cause of this uncertainty is probably the great quantities of gross vapours , and exhalations of various kinds , which are suspended in the air near to the earth 's surface , and the variations to which they are subject ; causes , of which we have no , instruments to measure the effects which they produce , in refracting the rays of light .
In general , the .
course of a. ray passing through the atmosphere , is that of a curve which is concave towards the earth , the effect of which is to give an apparent elevation to the object ; and thus the heavenly bodies appear above the horizon , when they are actually below it ; but it will not alter the position of their parts , in respect to the horizon , .
that is , the image of the highest part of the object will be uppermost , and the image of the lowest part will be undermost .
The figures , however , of the sun and moon , when ner the horizon , will suffer a change , in consequence of the refraction of the under limb being greater than that of the upper ; from which they assume an elliptical form , the -minor axis of which is perpendicular to the horizon , and the majoraxis parallel to it .
But a perpendicular object , situated upon the surface of the earth , will not have its length altered by refraction , the refraction of the bottom being the same as that of the top.* These are the effects which are produced upon bodies at or near the horizon , in the common state of the atmosphere , by what I shall call the usual refraction .
But , besides the usual refraction which affects the rays of light , the atmosphere over the sea is sometimes found to be in a state which refracts the rays in such a manner as to produce other images of the object , which we will call an effect from an unusual refraction .
In the Phil. Trans. for 1797 , Mr. HUDDART has described some effects of this kind , which he has accounted for by supposing that , from the evaporation of the watter , the refractive power of the air is not greatest at the surface of the sea , but at some distance above it ; and this will -solve , in a very satisfactory manner , all the phenomena which he has observed .
But effects very different from those which have been described by Mr. HUDDARTare sometimes found to -take place .
These I had an opportunity of observing at Ramsgate , last summer , on August the first , from about half an hour after four o'clock in the afternoon till between seven and eight .
The day had been extremely hot , and the evening was very sultry the sky was clear , with a few flying clouds I shall describe the phenomena as I observed them with a terrestrial telescope , which magnified between 30 and 40 times they were visible , however , to the naked eye .
The height of the eye , above the surface of the water , at which most of the observations were made , was about 25 feet ; , some of them , however , were made at about 8o feet from the surface ; and it did not appear that any of the phenomena were altered from varying the height of the eye , the general effect remaining the same .
The first unusual appearance which I observed , was that which is represented in Tab. I. fig. i. Directing my telescope at random , to examine any objects which might happen to be in view , I saw the top of the masts of a ship A , above the horizon , xy , of the sea , as shown in the figure ; at the same time also , I discovered in the field of view , two complete images , B , C , of the ship in the air , vertical to the ship itself , B being inverted , and C erect , having their hulks joined .
The phenomenon was so strange , that I requested a person present to look into the telescope , and examine what was to be seen in it , who : immediately described the two images , as observed by myself ; indeed they were so perfect , that it was impossible we could differ in our description .
Upon this , I immediately took a drawing of the relative magnitudes and distances of the ship and its images , which , at that time , were as represented in the figure , as near as it was possible for the eye to judge ; and it was , very easy to estimate them to a very considerable degree of accuracy .
As the ship was receding from the shore , less and less : of its masts became visible ; and , , continuing my observations , in order to discover whether any , or what variations might take place , I found that , as the ship descended , the images B , C ascended ; but , as the ship did not sink below the horizon , I had not an opportunity of observing at what time , and in what order , the images would have vanished , if the ship had so disappeared .
Being desirous of seeing whether the same effect was produced upon the other ships which were visible , I directed my telescope to another ship A , ( fig. 2 .
) whose hulk was just in the horizon xy ; when I observed a complete inverted image B , the main-mast of which just touched that of the ship itself .
In this case , there was no second image as before .
The ship A moving upon the horizon , B continued to move with it , without any variation in its appearance .
The next ship which I directed my telescope to , v. was so far on the other side of the horizon ry , as just to prevent its hulk from being seen , as is represented by A , ( fig. 3 .
) .
'And here I observed only an inverted image of part of the ship ; the image y of the topsail , with the mast joining that of the ship , the image x of the top a of the other mast , and the image z of the end c of the bowsprit , only appearing at that time .
These images would suddenly appear and disappear very quickly after each other ; first appearing below , and running up very rapidly , showing more and less of the masts at different times , as they broke out ; resembling , in the swiftness of their breaking out , the shooting out of a beam of the Aurora borealis .
As the ship was descending on the other side of the horizon , I continued my observations upon it , in order to discover what changes might take place ; when I found , that as it continued to descend , more of the image gradually appeared , till at last the image of the whole ship was completed , with their main-masts touching each other ; and , upon the ship descending lower , the image and the ship separated ; but I observed no second image , as in the first case ; a second image , however might probably have appeared , if the ship had continued to descend .
Upon moving my telescope along the horizon , in order to examine any other ships which might be in sight , I observed , just at the horizon xy , ( in fig. 4 .
) the top a of the mast of a ship ; and here an effect was observed , which had not been before discovered ; for there was an inverted image B , vertical to a , an erect image C , both of them very perfect and well defined , and an image vw of the sea between them , the water appearing very distinctly .
As the ship was coming up towards the horizon , I continued to observe it , in order to discover the variations which might follow , and found , that as the ship approached the horizon , the image C gradually disappeared , and at last it vanished ; after that , the image vw of the sea disappeared ; and during this time the image B descended ; but the ship did not rise so near to the horizon as to bring the main-masts together .
Had 1 , directed my telescope to the same point of the horizon a little sooner , Ishould have seen the two images , before the ship itself was visible .
In fact , the images were visible , when the whole ship was actually below the horizon ; for , from the very small part of the-mast which was at first visible , that part must then have been below the horizon , and appeared above it by the usual refraction ; the altitude of a , above the horizon , having then been much less than the inkcrease of altitude which arises from the common horizontal refraction .
The discovery of ships in this manner might , in some cases , be of great importance ; and , on such occasions , it might be -worth while to appoint proper persons to make observations for thatpurpose The cliffs at Calais being very visible I directed my telsecope towards them , in order to examine whether there was any Dthing unusual in their appearance ; when I observed an image Of the cliffis , above the cliffs themselves , together with an image of the sea separating them , as is represented in fig. .
; in which , xy represents the horizon of th-ye sea , AB the cliffs , ab their image , and vw the image of the sea between them : the depth of ab was much less than that of AB .
It is probable , however , that vw might not be the image of the sea immediately adjoin. .
ing to the cliffs , but a partial elevation of the sea at some di'stance from them ; and that the image vw might interoept some part of the image a bI , which would otherwise have been visible : We must not therefore concude , tha e ige ab , so far as it appeared , waUs less than the corresponding part of the object .
From the memorandums which I made at the time of observation , I do not find that I examined the appearance of the cliff AB , and its image a b ; which , had there at that time been any striking marks in them , would have determined whe- .
there the object and its image were of the same magnitude .
The image ab was , however , erect ; the boun daries on the top of ABuand ab agreeing together .
Having examined this or some time , and taken a drawing of the appearance , during which I could discover -no variatin , I directed my telescope to other -objects and , upon turni-ng it again to the same cliffs , after the space of about six or -seven -minutesy , the " images ab and -vw were vanished ; but , examining them again soon after , the images were again visible , and in every respect the same as they appeared before .
A short time after , they Idisappeared , and did not appear a:ny more .
Soon after the above appearances , I observed a ship C , with the hulk below the horizon xy , passing by the same cliff AB ; an inverted image D of which appeared against the cliffs , as represented in fig. 6 .
The ship was in motion , and remained at the same distance on the other side of the horizon : I continued my observations upon it till it had passed the cliffs for a considerable distance , but there was no change of appearance .
The cliffs were illuminated by the sun , and appeared very dis-tinctly ; but there was no image above , as in the last case .
Continuing toobserve the same cliffs AB , fig. 7 , 1 soon after discovered two partial elevations m , n , of the sea , by the unusual refraction ; they changed their figures a little , and dis appeared in the place where they first appeared , and were equally .
distinct in every part .
About this , time , I observed a very thick fog coming upon the horizon from the other side , rolling upon it with a prodigious velocity ; curling as it went along , like volumes of smoke sometimes out of a chimney .
This appeared several times .
I conclude , therefore , that there was a considerable fog on the other side of the horizon .
The last phenomenon which I observed was that which is represented in fig. -8 , ; where xy represents the horizon , ab two p.rtial elevations of the sea , meeting at c , and continued to d ; e , another partial elevation of the sea , of which kind I observed several , l+ some of which moved parallel to the horizon , with a very great velocity .
I conjecture , therefore , that these appearances were , in part at least , caused by the fog on the other side of the horizon .
For , though I did not at the same time see the motion of these images and that of the fog , yet , from memory , I judged the motions to be equal ; and they were also in the same direction .
A fog which , by producing an unusual refracrD tion , might form these images , would , by its motion , produce a corresponding motion of the images .
I have here described all the different phenomena which I observed from the unusual refraction , of most of which I saw a great many instances .
Every ship which I observed on the other side of the horizon of the sea , exhibited phaInomena of the kind here described , but not in the same degree .
Of two ships which , in different parts , were equally sunk below the horizon , the inverted image of one would but just begin to appear , whilst that of the other would represent nearly the whole of the ship .
But this I observed , in general , that as the ship gradu-. .
ally descended below the horizon , more of the image gradually appeared , and it ascended ; and the contrary , when the ships were ascending .
Upon the horizon , in different parts , one ship would have a complete inverted image ; another would have only a partial image ; and a third would have no image at all .
The images were in general extremely well defined ; and frequenrsly appeared as clear and sharp as the ships themselves , and of the same magnitude .
Of the ships on this side of the horizon , no phenomena of this kind appeared .
There was no Jfog upon our coast ; and the ships in the Downs , and the South Foreland , exhibited no uncommon appearances .
The usual refraction at the same time was uncommonly great ; for the tide was high , and at the very edge of the water I could see the cliffs at Calais a very considerable height above the horizon ; whereas they are frequently not to be seen in clear weather from the high lands about the place .
The French coast also appeared both ways , to a much greater distance than I ever observed it at any other time ; , particularly towards the east , on which part also the unusual refraction was the strongest , During the remainder of my stay at Ramsgate , which was about five weeks , I continued daily to examineall the ships in sight ; but I discovered no phenomenon similar to those which I have here given a description of .
The phaomnenon of the ship observed by Mr. HUDDART , differed altogether from those above described , as the inverted image which he observed was below the ship itself .
An appearance of this kind I observed on August the 17th , about half an hour after three o'clock in the afternoon , of which fig. 9 .
is a representation .
The real ship is represented by A , and the image by B ; er , myv , the hulks ' ; st the flag , and wx its image , just touching it , with the sea xy below .
Between the two hulks , some faint dark spots and lines appeared , but I could not discover what they were the representatives of .
The vessel , at the time of this appearance , was not quite come up to the horizon ; .land , as it approached it , the image gradually diminished , and totallydisappeared when the ship arrived at the horizon .
It remains now , that we inquire into the causes which might produce the very extraordinary effects which have been above related .
From the phenomenon , we are immediately led to the nature of the path of the rays of light to produce them ; and we may conceive , that the air may possibly be in such a state as will account for the unusual tract which they must have described .
For , let bz ( fig. io .
) be the surface of the sea ; ab an object ; E the place of the eye ; are E , bs E , the progress of two rays , by the usual refraction , from the extreme parts of the oboe ject to the eye ; to these curves draw the tangents E a ' , E b ' , and a ' b ' will be the image of the object , as usually formed .
Now , if we take the case represented in fig. 4,.let a " b " represent the inverted image , and a " ' b " ' the 'erect image ; join a"l E , a " ' E , and b EL , b " ' E , and these lines must respectively be the directions of the .
rays enteringnthe eye from a andb , in order to produce the images a " Li " and a " ' by'V hence , these lines must be tangents at E , to the curves which are described by the rays of light ; let therefore a nX E , a:m E , ; by E , bw E , be the curves described .
We have therefore to assign a cause which may bring rays passing above the rays .
arE , bsEE , .
to the eye at E. Now , if there were no variation of the refractive power of the air , a ray of light passing through it would describe a straight line ; therefore , the .
curvature of a ray of light passing through the atmosphere , depends upon the variation .
of the refractive power of the air .
If , therefore , we suppose theair lying above are E , to vary quicker in its refractive power than the air through which a rE passes , the curvature of a ray proceeding above that of a rE , will be greater than the curvature of are E ; and upon this principle we may co , once .
iv that a ray may describe the curve an E : and , in like manner , if a quicker variation of refractive power should take place above the curve an E. than in that curve , a third ray may describe the curve am E. The same may be said for the rays by E , bw E , diverging from b. The alterations of the refractive power may arise , partly from the variations of its density , and partly from the variations of its moisture ; and the passage of the rays through the boundary of the fog may there suffer a very considerable refraction ; for , from the motion of the fog , and that of the images abovementioned , I have no doubt that the fog was a very considerable agent in producing the phanomena .
When all the causes co-operate , I can easily conceive that they may produce the effects which I have described .
If the cause should not operate in the , tract of air through which the curves an E , bvE pass , but should operate in the tract through which am E , bwE pass , an erect image would be visible , but there would be no inverted image ; nld , should it operate in the latter care , but not in : the former , there would e -only an inverted image .
As the phamomtena are very iurious , and extraordinary in their nature , and have not , that I know of , been before observed , I have thought proper to lay -a description of them , with all the attending circumstances , before the Royal Society .
They appear to be of considerable importance ; as they leaid us to a knowledge of those changes to which the lower parts of the atmosphere -are 's-aonetimes Subject .
If , when these phenomenon appear , a vessel , furnished with a barometer , thermometer , and hygrometer , below , and also at the top of the mast , were sent out to pass below the horizon and return again , and an observer at land , having like instruments , were to note , at certain intervals , the situation and figure of the imaes , it might throw further light upon this subject , and lead to useful discoveries respecting the state of the atmosphere , from a conJunction of the causes which afect these instruments .

