XXII , .
On the Fructjfication of the submersed A/ gee .
By Mrt Corrda de Serra , F.a R. S. Read June i6 , 1796 .
TH .
E light which the prevailing spirit of inquiry and observation has thrown on the means of reproduction allowed by nature to vegetable beings , is not yet equally diffused over all of them .
Those whose simpler organization seems , when exam mined , to want some of the parts which we are accustomed to consider as essential to generation , continue to the present moment more or less involved in darkness ; and their fecundation , and means of reproduction , are still objects of doubt and inquiry , Amongst them the Fuci , Ceramiums , Ulve , Confervae , all submersed algae , are perhaps in the number of the less illustrated .
It is probable that their peculiar way of living , which requires from nature a particular modification in the parts destined to reproduce them , as well as in the means of performing this operation , has been the principal cause of the perplexity of naturalists on this subject .
They have either sought for things in their ordinary form , which nature furnishes to these plants under a different one , adapted to their circumstances ; or they have thought that she deviates from her usual ways , when she only makes use of her stubborn versatility , enforcing the execution of her general plan , by the means which at first sight seem to make her deviate from it .
In the present memoir I shall endeavour to ascertain what parts of these plants perform the sexual functions : and , in order to be clear , I will first relate in a few words , what has been observed .
and believed on this point , and proceed afterwards to the exposition of the opinions which observation and the strictest analogy induce me to hold on this subject .
REAUMUR was the first naturalist who bestowed a proper attention upon the fructification of the Fuci .
Two elaborate , memoirs of this great man are to be found , in the Parisian Transactions for the years 1711 and 1712 , in which he endeavours to persuade us , that the vesiculx filled with small grains are the female part of the fructification , in , the fuci , and the filamentous hairs , which are found in different parts of the frons , the male organs .
He examined eleven species of fuci , in eight of which he found grains , and only in six the fil* lamentous hairs .
It is unlucky for his opinion , that these hairs have no antherae , and still more unlucky , that their existence has no relation at all to that of the vesicles which bear the grains , for they are persistent through all the life of the plant , without any remarkable alteration .
Their situation besides is very unfit for the fecundation of the grains , except in the Fucus elongatus .
Notwithstanding the weight of these objections,.which he did not conceal , this otherwise sensible naturalist tried to the last to support by hypotheses , what he could not fairly prove by observations .
His great name , joined to the general ascendency which the sexual system gained a little after all over Europe , gave nevertheless a common currency to his opinion ; and it was received , though in a wavering manner , by LINNEUs himself , and , what is more surprising , by the last of the JUSSIEUS .
These great men indeed gave it as the prevail .
ing opinion of the day , not confirmed by any sanction of theirs , This was not the case of less profound botanists -'for they , as the fashion then was , attempted to see stamina and antherse , like the common ones , wherever they had not been observed before .
I deem it unnecessary to stop a morment to consider the multitude of supposed stamina , which DONATI , GRISELINI , and others imagined they had found in Fuci , and U1vX , because it is at present clearly evinced that these fancied stab mina are only organs of nutrition. .
Cooler observation and reflection exploded at length all these dreams ; but OMELIN , and GxRTNER , the two greater among the naturalists who followed a different way of thinking , went perhaps too far on the opposite side .
GMELIN , convinced both by reason and observation of the1 inutility of theREAUMURIAN anthers , and writing at a time when the recent publications on the hydra , and on the aphides , had made it fashionable to find examples of multiplication of organized bodies without fecundation , determined to consider these plants as in the same predicament .
Every one may see , in his Historia Fucorum , the elaborate discussion by which he endeavours to establish his opinion .
It dazzles at first sight , but , on a candid examination , all his arguments , when deprived of the apparatus of science which accompanies them , n may be reduced to the following ; namely , that since the supposed male organs are not such in reality , and noothers are to be found , the small grains which act as seeds are prolific , without receiving external fecundation .
We shall see as we proceed , how groundless is the supposition on which this argument rests .
G.ERTNER , by far a deeper naturalist than the preceding , and keeping more closely to the ways of nature , would , no doubt , have given us the true and simple account of the fructification of the submersed algae , if the specious ADANSONIAN theory of aphrodite plants , and his own ideas of the perfect seed , had not led him ( according to my opinion ) astray .
The grains of the Ceramiums and Ulva , and the lateral internodia of the Conferve , he excludes from the number of seeds , and believes them to be gems of a particular kind , which he calls gongyli , or gemmw carpomorphb , consequently not standing in need of fecundation .
The grains of the fuci he judges to be true seeds ; but , in this case , he believes that the uterus performs the male functions , and that the plants , in respect to their fecundation , are aphrodite , having only the apparatus fwmineus , et intim am utriusque sexus sub specie singuli copulam .
Both he and GMELIN , forced by phmnomena which they could not help observing , have been in some moments very near to what I conceive to be the truth , but have sacrificed it to preconceived opinions .
In the last year two English botanists , to whom science stands indebted for many excellent descriptions and figures of fuci , Major VELLEY , and Mr. STACKHOUSE , treated this same matter , the first at large , the second occasionally .
Both have stated , with great ingenuity and candour , the many objections which attend the existing systems , and both declared themselves not fully satisfied with the present state of our knowledge on this subject .
Mr. STACKHOUSE , indeed , seems to cherish hopes of future discoveries of the male organs , in what he calls the concealed fibrous fructification , the antherea not seeming necessary to him , nor the farinaceous pollen.* Perfectly agreeing with him , in what respects the needlessness of a farinaceous pollen , I cannot accede to the other parts of .
Nereis Britannica , in the preface , and page 3o .
3s 2 his opinion .
A membranaceous loculament , containing the pollen , is the only necessary part of the male apparatus in plants ; the filaments and the fibrous texture are only the pedicles of it , and very far from being necessary , as the sessile antherae of numberless fructifications clearly prove .
If a fibrous concealed structure could be esteemed of any use , it was already found by GMEL IN , in the seed-vessels of the true fuci , and elegantly described by Major VELLEY , in the Fucus Vesiculosus , and by Mr. STACKJHOUSE himself , in the Fucus Siliquosus ; but , even when magnified , it offers nothing more than simple tu.bular vessels , with frequent anastomoses , very remote indeed from the nature of a male apparatus .
Having stated the leading systems on the fructification of submersed algae , I will next submit to this Society such opinions as the phenomenon I have observed induce me to have about it .
All these plants are furnished with grains , which are a temporary production , and , by their falling , give rise to new individuals of the same species .
In the true fuci , they are contained in an uterus , which has a temporary existence , and for their sake only , where they have a placentation , and are covere .
by a testa , or coat of their own .
Nobody doubts that they a re true seeds .
The Ceramiums and Ulvae have the same grains , as means of reproduction ; and the confervoe also have them , though of a different shape .
What then can be the reasons why these last are to be considered as gongyli and gemmae carpomorpha ?
The only arguments adduced to deprive them of the nature of seeds are the three following .
ist .
The grains of the Ulvae and Ceramiums are solitary , not * Hist. Fucorum , page .
z5 , et seq. contained in a proper uterus , consequently without a placentationi .
They are , says GzRTNER , part of the medulla of their mother , and their skin is part of the maternal one.* 2d .
They do not , in germinating , leave any coat behind.t 3d .
In the'confervz , whose grains have some likeness to fresh internodia , two or more of them very often coalesce , but give rise to only one individual .
All these reasons require to be candidly discussed ; and I hope the result of the investigation will afford us many additional motives to believe them to be true seeds .
The first of these objections cannot stand the test of close examination .
The grains of the Ceramiums(like those of the true Fuci ) fall at a proper period , which GARTNER calls seniumn , but which others will call maturity .
If gently squeezed , they come forth from the little cavity where they are formed , and which they must leave when ripe .
They come forth whole , and disengaged from the mother , and from every part of the frons ; they have therefore a skin of their own .
They are contained in a small uterus , proportionate to their size , which is of a temporary existence , and for them alone ; where they are no doubt affixed bysome placentation , from which , when they come to maturity , they are disengaged and fall .
If we add to these considerations , that of their existing there enveloped in a soft juicy substance , alltheirdifference from the seedsofthe truefuci wholly disappears ; ?
and a strong probability arises , that GzERTNER'S observations were made on dry specimens , as well as with a mind not wholly impartial to his preconceived theories .
The second reason is of a more specious nature , algd requires serious attention .
Animals are divided into oviparous and viviparous , and a generally received comparison points out the seeds as the eggs in plants , and the gems as correspondent to living born foetuses .
We cannot conceive , says GmRTNER , an egg where the animal , when coming forth , does not leave the shell behind ; and , in the same manner , we cannot conceive a seed where the coats are not left behind in the germination .
The grains of the Ulvae , Ceramiums , &amp;c. according to him , do not leave any coat when they germinate , and are consequently genzrnc carpornorpl .
Every candid naturalist will easily acknowledge , that we are not possessed of observations sufficiently decisive to enable us to speak dogmatically , on phenomenon so little obvious as the germination of these grains .
But I will not contest the fact , I will only examine the principle .
This general rule , of judging whether these grains be seeds or gems , by their leaving their coats in the germination , or not , is contradicted by nature , both in the instance of gems , and in that of eggs .
All gems , properly so called , throw off their scaly hybernacula in the act of germinating .
On the contrary , the eggs of frogs and toads leave no coat at all in their hatching , because they are possessed of none .
Their very viscous albumen answers , in such an element as water , all the purposes the testa accomplishes in other eggs .
Allowing GA &amp; RTNER the exactness of his observation concerning our plants , the analogy -between these submersed algae and the aquatic oviparous quadrupeds would be striking , since both those plants and these animals are capable , from their structure , of being nourished by absorption ; their embryos are hatched in the same element , and equally surrounded by a tenacious mucous substance , without any exterior coats .
If the spawn of frogs be eggs , the grains of these plants must be seeds .
The third objections very far from being an Urgent one , is , I am persuaded , a capital reason to believe that the seeming lateral internodia of the Confervs , since they are capable of cohering two or more together and produce only one individual , are true seeds , and not gems .
The coherence of two living embryos , whether gems or seeds , mfay form monsters , but it is equally impossible , in both cases , that perfect individuals should regularly be formed by such coalition .
Observation daily shows , that of two or more neighbouring , gems or seeds , one may thrive by rendering the other abortive ; but , in this case , gems never cohere , the abortive one falls .
In seeds , on the contrary , not only the abortive coheres to the thriving one ; but this abortion happens oftener in the several species of plants , in proportion as the seeds , by their sit uation , , are apt to cohere .
In some genera it is even a regular proceeding of nature , as in the Dalea , Lagoecia , Hasselquistia , Sapindus , Ornitrophe , &amp;c. These objections having been I hope satisfactorily answered , I do not hesitate to consider these grains of the submersed algae to be , what obviously they seem , their effective seeds .
The figure , formation , and temporary fall of these bodies , would never have left any room for the above doubts if their fecundation had been easily accounted for .
This point we must now proceed to investigate , and examine whether the mucous ; substance which surrounds these seeds can be considered as true pollen .
Pollen is by its nature immiscible with water , and sp ecifically lighter than that fluid .
In the aquatic plants , which have a farinaceous pollen , the buds of the flowers emerge from the surface of the water , and the fecundation is performed in the open air .
The phenomena attending the blossom of the Potamogetones , Myriophylla , Vallisneria , &amp;c. are too well known to require a particular mention .
In some aquatic plants , whose flowers have not the faculty of emerging from water in the period of fructification , but still are endowed with farinaceous pollen , nature has taken every precaution to defend it from that element .
The flower of the Zostera is situated , and its fecundation happens , in the interior cavity of the stem , which opens itself afterwards to let loose the fecundated seeds .
The concave bases of the leaves in the Isoetes , closely adhering to each other , and perhaps more so in the -act of fecundation , forbid the entrance of water to the minute flowers situated within them .
In the Pilularia , and Marsilea , whose flowers are exposed to inundations , the fecundation is performed in perfectly closed vessels .
Even in plants living in the air , nature employs numberless well known contrivances , to shelter the farinaceous pollen from the contact of water in rainy seasons .
The pollen , to be active in fecundation , needs not always be farinaceous .
In most Apocyneae it is rather a fluid ; in the Orchideax it is an aggregate of solid parts , of a ceraceous appearance ; in some Contortae it is found in a solid or rather viscous state .
In the Pilularia , and Marsilea , the par.- .
ticles of the pollen are kept in small bags of a mucous substance , compared by BERNARD DE JUSSIEu to dissolved gumn .
The original state in which it is found in every flower , before the act of fecundation , is that of a mucus , but it is perfectly active even in that state , since its particles , after becoming a little dry , if put into certain fluids , are seen , by the help of the microscope , acting in the same manner as when in the state of perfect farina , The plants whose fructification lies unsheltered under water are very few in number ; and such of them as have been hitherto thoroughly examined , ( the Ceratophyllumn and the Chara ) , have antherw furnished with mucous pollen , not bursting in the fecundation .
From the time of DILLENIUS it has been obo served , that the submersed antherm of the Ceratophyllum never burst , but are found whole , though the seeds be ripe , * If squeezed , they shed a soft and pulpous matter , like that which is found in unripe antherse .
DILLENIUS suspected that the fructification of the Chara being equally submersed , its anthers and pollen would be of the same nature with the preceding , and observations have fully confirmed the conjectures of this great naturalist .
The antherae of the Chara do not burst in fecundation ; its pollen is mucous ; the germen has no pistillum , and is probably fecundated through its receptaculum , as there exists in each internodium , according to modern observationst a chain of vessels which twist round the antherae and the fruit , and in which a circulation of humours is visible , at least in the period of fructification .
If pollen therefore , under the shape of farina , be unfit for fecundation in the water ; Iif nature has taken a particular care to guard this operation from the presence of that element ; , if Plantas Gissenses , page .
9i .
t CORTI , Osserv .
Microscop .
Lucca , 1774 .
pollen can exist in an active state under a mucous appearance ; and if the anthera of perfectly submersed flowers are nothing else than closed vessels filled with mucous pollen ; what ' doubt can we entertain , that the mucilaginous vesicles of the submersed AIga ?
( which contain also their seeds ) are anthers , and very appropriate to the nature and situation of these plants ?
An observation made by GLEICHEN shows more clearly the propriety of such a fructification .
The pollen of any flower , when put into water , in a very short time begins to move , and its particles agitate themselves in every direction , perfectly resembling the most lively animalcula .
Their-activity in this state lasts some time ; but , if the least quantity of salt be put into the liquor , death quickly ensues , from which they never more recover.* This enclosed mucilaginous fructification was therefore the only one which could ensure existence to vegetables living chiefly in sea-water , with which their mucus is found to be immiscible.t A still more urgent consideration will , I hope , determine those who may hesitate to consider the mucus of these plants as pollen , and the vesicles which contain it as anthers .
The parts of fructification , in all plants , are temporary , and their existence is relative to their particular functions , and to each other , The moment the fecundation happens is a moment of crisis : henceforth the fecundated parts proceed to grow and perfect themselves , the fecundating ones change and decay .
This is a general law of nature , to which we know no exception , nor can any be easily conceived to exist .
We must remark , that there is an epoch when the mucous substance in the vesicles of the fuci suffers a material alteration , but the grains proceed to their perfection .
In the Fucus vesiculosus this change of colour and consistency in the mucus is evident to common sight .
It is still more evident in the Fucus selaginoideus , where the temporary bright and vivid colour of the mucus , followed by a prompt decay after that period , has struck even those naturalists who most decidedly opposed the existenceof male parts in these plants ; * and lam confident , from the steadiness with which nature adheres to her general plans , that proper observations will demonstrate the same in every species of these submersed algae , and confirm what the forementioned analogies induce me to think , viz. That the vesicles of all these plants , whatever be their shape , if containing grains and mucus , are to be considered as hermaphrodite flowers ; the grains they contain as their seeds , and the mucous substance as their pollen .
*k GA RT N ER } , page .
xxxii .

