XIX .
On the periodical Star I Herculis ; tvith Remarks tending to establish the rotatory Motion of the Stars on their Axes .
To which is added a Second Catalogue of the comparative Brightness of the Stars .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F.R. S. Read June 9 , 1796 .
IN my first catalogue of the comparative brightness of the stars , I announced a Herculis as a periodical star .
The precision of the characters introduced in that catalogue is such , that the smallest alteration in the lustre of the stars may be discovered , by a proper attention to their expressions : the variation in the light of a Herculis is , however , pretty considerable , and cannot easily be mistaken , when strictly compared to a proper standard .
IThe star most conveniently situated for this purpose is X Ophiuchi ; and as I have had no reason , during the time of my observations , to doubt the uniformity of its lustre , I have made use of it in the following comparisons ; which seem to be sufficiently decisive , with regard to the periodical variations of the light of a Herculis .
Other stars besides x Ophiuchi have also been consulted ; but the unsteadiness of their light would draw me into difficulties , which at present it will be proper to avoid .
For this reason I only give the following table , which will be found to contain at least four regular changes of the alternate increase and decay of the apparent lustre of our new periodical star , deduced from a comparison of its brightness with that of z Ophiuchi .
In this short table , the number 64 refers to the stars in the constellation of Hercules , and 27 to those in the constellation of Ophiuchus .
The characters that are used to denote their relative lustre , have been explained among the introductory remarks to the first catalogue of the comparative brightness of the stars .
Table of the Variation of Light observed in a ( FL .
64 ) HercuEis , compared to x ( FL .
27 ) Ophiuchi .
1795 .
May iS 6427 '795 .
Nov. 0o 64 ; 27 22 64=27 26 64 27 JulV 6 27 ; 64 -28,1 64 T 27 August 17 27 64 Dec. 151 27 ; 6 18 2764 1796 .
Jan. 9 64 ; 27 September 16 64 27 March 5 64 ; 27 17 64 -27 9 64 27 18 64,27 1o 64 27 20 64 27 28 27 , 64 21 64 T 27 April 4 27T 6 22 64 , 27 5 27T6 October 2 64 27 9 27`'6 6 6 , ; 27 May 2 64 27 7 64 .
; 27 4 64 27 9 64 .
27 S 64 27 11 64 27 to 64= ' 27 15 27 64 11 64=27 ______ _6 27 , 64 14 64=527__ 17:7 , 64 16 64= ' 27 25 264 17 64= 27 26 27 64 18 64 27 28 27 , 64 19 64= , 27 30 27 64 22 64 -27 November ~ , 27 64 64 27 6 64 27 64 6 9427 9 64 2726 64 , 27 lo 64.27 97 64,27 In order now from this table to obtain the time of the period , we shall first take all the successive observations from the i6th of September till the 28th of November .
They show very clearly that the star has completely gone through all its changes .
For , admitting a maximum of the light of a Herculis to have been the 16th of September , we find a minimum the 2Ath of October ; and a second maximum about the 28th of November .
The period , therefore , is of somewhat more than two months duration .
But as changeable stars are subject to temporary inequalities , which will render a determination of the length of a period , from a single series of changes , liable to considerable errors , we shall now take the assistance of the most distant observations .
By an 'inspection of the table , we find again the first maximum to have been about the 16th of September , 1795 ; and the fourth the 14th of May , 1796 , This being an interval of 241 days , in which four successive changes have been gone through , we obtain about 6o days and a quarter for the duration of the period .
In confirmation of this computation , the table shows that our periodical star was very faint in August , 1795 ; bright about the middle of September faint towards the end of Oc-tober ; bright the latter part of November ; faint in December ; bright in January , 1,796 ; not observed in February ; bright in March ; faint in April ; andlastly , bright again in May .
This is just what should have happened according to the above determination , which , as we have seen , gives a period of eight weeks , four days and a quarter .
Greater accuracy can only be obtained by future observations .
On the Rotatory Motion of the Stars on their Axes , I shall now add a few remarks on the subject of the rotation of the fixed stars on their axes .
This motion has been lately ' mentioned in a paper , where I could not have an opportunity to enter into the reasons why it ought to be admitted.* The discovery of the period of a Herculis furnishes me with an opportunity to say a few words upon the subject , as every -addition to the list of periodical stars increases our knowledge of the construction of the celestial bodies .
Not so much because now one star more is known to be subject to periodical changes in its lustre ; for this would indeed be of no great Conlsequence .
But we ought not to be satisfied with merelydinrolling this circumstance among the list of facts we are acquainted with .
The rotatory motion of stars upon their axes is a capital feature in their resemblance to the sun .
It appears to me now , that we cannot refuse to admit such a motion , and that indeed it may be as evidently proved as the diurnal motion of the earth .
Dark spots , or large portions of the surface , less luminous than the rest , turned alternately in certain directions , either towards or from us , will account for all the phamnomena of periodical changes in the lustre of the stars , so satisfactorily , that we certainly need not look out for any other cause .
Let us , however , take a review of any objections that Might be made .
The periods in the change of the lustre of Algol , 3 Lyrae , 3 Cephei , and X Antinoi , are short ; being only A , , , 6 and 7 days respectively : those of o Ceti , the changeable star in Hydra , and that in the neck of the Swan are long , amounting to , 394 , and 4,97 days .
Will not a doubt arise whether the same cause can be admitted to explain indiscriminately phbaoenena that are so different in their duration . ?
To this it may be answered , that the whole force of the obection is founded upon our very limited acquaintance with the state of the heavens .
Hitherto we have only had seven stars whose periodical changes have been determined .
No wonder then that proper connections between their different periods were wanting .
But let us now place a Herculis among the list , which is not less than 6o days in performing one return of its changes .
Here we find immediately , that the step from the rotation of a Herculis to that of C Ceti , is far less considerable than that from the period of Algol to the rotation of a Herculis ; and thus a link in the chain is now supplied , which removes the objection that arose from the vacancy .
There is , however , another instance of a slow , rotatory mo-e tion ; and it is doubly instructive upon this occasion .
In one of my former papers it has been shown , that the 5th satellite of Saturn , revolves on its axis in 79 days ; this not only shows that very slow rotatory motions take place among the celestial bodies ; but from the arguments that were brought to prove its rotation , which I believe no astronomer will oppose , we are led to apply the same reasoning to similar appearances among the fixed stars .
A variation of light , owing to the alternate exposition of a more or less bright hemisphere of this periodic cal satellite , plainly indicates that the similar phenomenon of a changeable star , arises from the various lustre of the different parts of its surface , successively turned to us by its rotatory motion .
The rotations of the sun and moon , and of several of the planets , become visible in a telescope by means of the spots on their surfaces ; the remote situation and smallness of the 5th satellite of Saturn , leave us without this assistance ; but what wIe can no longer perceive , with our best optical instruments , we now supply by rational arguments .
The change in the light of the satellite proves the rotation ; and the rotation once admitted , proves the existence of spots , or less luminous regions on its surface , which at setting off were only hypothetical .
In the same manner a still more extended similarity between the sun and the stars offers itself , by the spots that now must also be admitted to take place on their surfaces , as well as on that of the sun .
To return to the difficulty which has been started , it may be further urged , that there are some reasons to surmise that the 34-Cygzni is a periodical star of i8 years return ; * and that other stars seem very slowly to diminish their lustre , and may probably recover it hereafter .
In answer to this , I remark that it will not be necessary to remove objections to the rotatory motion of the stars , inferred from their very slowly changeable lustre , till they come properly supported by well ascertained facts .
Many causes in the physical construction of the stars may occasionan accidental and gradual increase or decay of brightness , not subject to any regularity in its duration .
But when settled periods can be ascertained , notwithstanding they should be of the most ex- , tended duration , it will not be difficult to find other causes to explain them , without giving up the rotatory motion .
' When the biography of the stars , if I may be allowed the expression , is arrived to such perfection as to present us with a complete relation of all the incidents that have happened to the most eminent of them , we may then possibly not only be still more assured of their rotatory motion , but also perceive that they have other movements , such as nutations or changes in the inclination of their axes ; which , added to bodies much flattened by quick rotatory motions , or surrounded by rings like Saturn , will easily account for many new phamnomena that may thene offer themselves to our extended views .
Memorandum relating to thefollowing Catalogue .
It was my intention to have continued to remark all the deviations of brightness here assigned to the stars , from the magnitudes which are given by FLAMSTEED , either in his observations , .
or in the British catalogue ; but I now find this author so little consistent , that it appears to be of no use to refer to his determinations .
In the constellation of Aries are no less than 31 stars , in which the magnitudes of his catalogue differ from those we find in his observations ; and these are generally the stars of the greatest brightness .
The difference is also very considerable : thus , 41 Arietis is observed 6 m , the catalogue gives Em 5o is observed 7 m , the catalogue gives 5m ; 35 is m. , catalogue 'm 3 is 6m , catalogue Ain ; 38 is 6m , catalogue 7 m. The notes to these and the remaining constellations , therefore , will now be confined chiefly to my own observations , and to the correction of errors that havefallen under my notice .
1.Catalogue ' othcomparative Brightnzess of the Stars .
Lustre of the stars in Aries .
1 ~7.6 [ Does not exist .
f 17 .
612,8 2 ; 8 31 j ~6 ~4 , .
41 17.618-43 51 4 41.5 5 -3 Aurig'- , 92 Cetl,5 41 -s ___ 11 ~~5 357 Caissiop 99 Pic 5Iio0 Piscium 66 1.f64 Trianguli 88 Pegasi ; 6 71 tcLj147 ___ , '~ 15.19 ' ' 9,1 9,914 io 6.71:14 , 10-2 ii 16 f20 , ii .
6:1 16.519,912 9T12 1,217 '31 2 57 Ardro ; 13 132Aurigae 111 ~43Andromedve-,1 , i 141 61 14 , 10 9,9147 i~f J7 1518.2,3 19 16.7120,919 20 6 ; 21.20,11 20 , 19 21 ) I_7 10 -21.20 22 9 , ' 1%158.22 '17 , 02.15 23j O ' 7 f18.-23 24)_ 6 131,294 ~ceti , 64_Ceti_____ 215 1 64 Ceti 25 261 16.7 9129,26 , 27 ____ _ Lustre of the stars in Aries .
27j1 1 6.-726,27 28jJ 6j Does not exist , or is lost 29 6.71 129,26.9iL .
7 I530 -3~3 i.6Triangluo 311 1-5I3.6 38-31,24 32 7 I6 l48 =32 34 'IL 5I 30 33 35,3 -33 1,6Trianguli 34 LJ6 32 T394 3951 4 1,39.'35 33 35,30 35*-57 36j 7 j53 ; 36 5o -371 6 I43 87 39 4 39 35 40 116 146.40 , 45 42 1Vl 6 142T , 46 4 S43 431 o6 j424 , 433 7_ ___ __ _ 441 p6 154 , ,44 45 ?
2L6.7l40 45 5 , 46 p67 1742 46 .
40 471 6.7,163.-47 , 65 48 | 158.48 6 , 48 , 57 48c ' 32 491 I 52T49 .
1 '507 6 ~520 54,5 531 17 1459 541 16.7 52 I4 , Al I1 7 1s6.s3 54 6 .
7.5 54 , 41 a.56 ) 6.7152,56.-55 577 4 35 H 57 58 48 , 57 , ,8 Lustre of the stars in Aries .
581 f5 77.58.48 57,58,6 59162-59 .
_60 60 7 59 , 60 .
64 61'1 7 158,61,63 _~~~~5 6 62( 61 62 59 -63 !
6 148 .
63 6 1 , 6 , 65 63 .
47 641 6 6o.64-66 651 17 j-63 , , 65 47 65 66jj .
7 16466 7 Tauri .
66 Lustre of the stars in Canis major .
o1~~ 1I t.24 2M2 21 , 2 , 2,5 A14 j3 3 .
13 3 ; 8 Columbx 41 4___ 51___I 4_,5 611s1 8-6 71 &gt; 2 17,8 7 23 8_ 7_ ioj 'f6 11310 12 Pf6 17.12 13 !
' 3 -1 -s I 10 -2A1 ?
1 s , 1 14 , 20 _~~~~5 J 14 , 15 1 19 15 1 16 01 o59 2 , 16 , 28 17 1j6 15-17.12 181 K14 120,18.11 '91 &lt; 6 119 120 14 J23 , 20 14,20 18 I V3 17 , 23,20 26 27.2 ... , _ __ 27Jt 7f 28 -27,2.6 28J $ 16 , 28 -27 28-80 29W ~5 3~.2 01 15 1,28-,30 29__ 311 13.21 2)31 i Nais , Lustre of the stars in Canis minor .
41 o6 3--4,2 4.6 61 oI 6 14.6 , IL 6,11 76 6 71 , 79 72 28 1 P1 6 19 618-2 f-3 _,..9 P6 17 ' i89 10 1.2 Oriois 58 Orion is .
10 i 11 Orionis- , l 12 , ___ 5.6 1Does not exist .
___ 13 .
I 13Navi , 13 113 av1s-13_ 141 6 13 14 , Lustre of the stars in Cassiopea .
eJ 63 1-69 '1 113 71 --2 1771 24 o4 o !
2,7 2-3 41 6 73 .
8 d5 _55 49-6 261 n1 678 81 t6 2.88- ; 91 16 16.3 .
lo 10M 16 C9.C13 o~~~~~ , 3 , -1 1 93*7 I 17 126 -5-12 13a 149 12 136 i2 13 .
16 15 4:53 161 6 13 1S 6 171 -C 14J4 17--14 94 -17 18 I3 18 27 18 .
27 1-91 6 19 25 20IX 6 922,20 211 162 21 23 2 !
2 66 9 , 2 , 20 231 16 121 23 924 vt4 24 17 P-4 -S 92417 915 v5 19,25 s6 I l17 28 1)26 27 g 8 , 8.27 1 28t vI6 J'28 26 29 116 Does not exist. .
_~~~ 3..~~~ -6 43 4 ... ... ... L Lustre of the stars in Cassiopea. .
32 6 132-35_ 193H 14 -24--33,14 339T30 15,33 34 J6 H,1-34 351 7 132-35 361 5 I.6 1 3631 36,46 371 31 53 1Arietis 37 --45 38J 6 42-38 40,38 39 2c 39 It 44 40 Ib 6 I42 , 40 , 38 41 6 Does not exist .
42 1g6 48 -42-38 42 , 40 4 ?
Ic t6 31 , 43 4+1 16I 39 44-34 45 3 137 45 46 d6 36 , 46,31 47 5 47'49 48 e5 50-48 -54 48-42 49 61 47 , 49 SO I1 4.51 50-48 _ __ __ _ K51 L6 Does not exist , or is lost .
521 17 153T7592 53 , P5255 5 31 7 j53 T52 53,52541 148--54 55\ 16 [ 5255 Lustre of the stars in Cetus .
294 S125 46I4 t. 5 1 Lustre of the stars in Cetus.:51 J7-6 9j 6 9 , &gt; o1j 6_f 12 lo10l , 12 , 10 44 Piscium 10 11 6|i o , il 12 1j6 13,12 -10 13 , 12 .
15 113-12 10 i3 6 J13,12 20,13 112 13 -12 '1j6j Does not exist .
f6 ' 12.15 16 38 Pegasi 16 44 Pegasi 17 J 9 ' 5 17 , 19 17,5 3 i8 I 61 23,18 K9 ( P 5 17 , 1922 3,919 20 I16 i20 , 20-26 21 'I6 2721 22 93 5 19-22 .
23 23j 15 122.-23,1 8 -24j l Z6 IDoes not exist .
26 6 120-26,33 27 J6 128 , 27 .
30 27.21 28j 6 137,28,27 , 291 6 35 , 29 301 16 127.30,32 1.3 1-4 3j 16 30o,32.41 32.44 316 126,23 , 35 341 6 34 , 38 351 6 33,35,29 36 6 J36 41 02 Lustre of the stars in Cetus .
371 15 125.37,28 38/ J. 16 / 34,58.39 39 / 6 38 .
39 , 40 4 ?
0l 1 39 )40 .
402 41 6 32.41 36.41 4,21I 6 40.42-43 42 4 441 J6 132 _4 45/ 1I1 31.45 45,52 46 1sI 50,46 48 .
46 53-46 471 16 1,47'49 48 16 / 48 .
46 49 / 6 147,49.50 5o I6 149.50o46 51 / 16 110 Piscium-51,98 Piscium 52 r 34.445 i 52.55 531 x5I / 5553 -46 5414 6 ~64,54 -3 52 _ , ,_.5 3 I'-_ 6/ 56t 4 / 59-56,57 571 16 / 56,57 57.74 '58/ 6 Js8,66 59/ 47 f4.5j5566o/ / 61 60-61 611 17 16o-6i 63 62/ / 6.7 63-462 62 63 6 666,63-62 61,6$ 41 6 65--64,554 65 64 1 24 Arietis , 64 25 Arietis 6 165 , _24Aries 6 65 ; 91 65 , 24 Arietl$ Lustre of the stars in Cetus .
661 16 j66,63 58,66,63 68 o 3.2 68 &lt; lo m 68= 3Arietis 68 &gt; .
13Arietis 87 Tauri &gt; 68 70$ 16 169.7o075 71$6 $71.62o 8i,71-79 72 .
I 8 .
4..72 73 ? ?
2$ 5.4 87,73.65 73-91 74 $6f 57.74 751 5.6 $70 75 , 84 76$ o$4 89-76.83 : 771 16 177.Xo 78$ 4.5 919678,97 88,78-85 79 $6f 71-79 8o$ $6 ( 77.80,67 82 1"31 _8____ _ _.~ ~~~7 6 .
, , , .
8 .
__ , 3 ?
tS3 J90,863 76.83.72 : 84 I 75i ; 84 ; 85 f6 178-85 88-8 86 3 8689 87 4 87 , 73 88j 668 88 78888 89 4.3 89 , 90 8976 0_ 8__ 89 , 90 , -83 91 4_| 73-91 65i 91 92 12 92 4Arietis 193$ $6 19693 , 97 94 || |6 196,94-95 95 16 94-95 Lustre of the stars in Cetus .
V967,96,7 96,9 96 -93 9 ~J 78.,97 93,97 Lustre of the stars in Corvus .
L of 47 t-I-E8 2-iwT p ?
|4 | 92,1 07 6 i3 5 i'T:15__8_-_____________ 61 6 137 S 37 9,7-1 2 7-1 8Iw 51 -59 1 I3 1499 , o7 4992 Lustre of the stars in E~ridanus .
I1 T4 1*2 T ' 41 -2,4 v17 3 118.3 4| 1|64 I *64l5 4 -6 |I6 I-4,6 .
71 I6 5 - , ,7 8 |P |6|o8 91 P2 " 1S 13-9 , 10 13 914 1134 i16 3 &lt; 1 1 16 1 , -1 t27 12 I19 , 12 151 16 91 174 l5t Lustre of the stars in Eridanus .
i6j 4 J ; 16 , n1 17 14.51 1722 _8 1 j3.4 23,18 -26 23,18.3 19 T4 127,19,12 2 , f0 5.6 15 -20 21/ 6 ' 122 ; 21 221 f5.6 1 17-22 ; 21 231 ~'3.4134,923 18 53 , 23 241 5 f32,24 ; 25 24-25 25 6 124 ; 25 24-25 26/ 14 / 18-26,32 271 14 / 11.27,19 27-33 28 6.5 36 , 28 29 1 16.7 H0 , 29 3 ?
1 5.6 f132 -0 , 29 , II 5j.6 J Does not exist 32 1 14.5 / 26,32 30 26,32 - , 35 32,24 / 93 4.5 2733.-36 34/ 9y / 67,34 - , S3 315 / 5 s 32-,35 36/ 4 33.36,2'-8 37 40,37 , 81 0 3.41 38,40 39 1A | , / 40.39,42 40I d j38 4o37 40 39 411 14 314'43 42f 4 43I39,42 43J 5 41 43 44/ / 5-6 49 44 45/ i 5.6 45 49 46 16 46 47 Lustre of the stars in Eridanus , 471 4 146.-47,56 48tLuJ 4 148.57 48 -,51 49 $.6 45 s.49 44 so5 v4 Q50.52 52,50 51 cf 41j57-,51 48-},51 52Li .
3 50.52 52,50 54 3.4 54 60 s5 J6 j56,55 56f 6 147,56,55 6356,2J.LLJ4 ~48 57-,51 58 15.616o,58 .
59 ________ 601 j6 fs4-6o , 8 6i1 5rS 69,61,65 62i b6 65 -,62 63 16 f6463-56 64 116 64--63 6,5j t1 s j6,65-,62 66 11 61 68.66 671 b3 67 , 34 67--68 68j 6 167 --68.66 69g x4 169,61 Lustre of the stars in Gem-in .
1H11 181-l39 Tauri 21 i8 15-2 4 A. 7 4 .
6 Lus-tre of the stars in Geminl .
4.5.37,3..3 , : .
81 7818 .
9 91 17 J8.9 , o ol 8 9 , lo .
ll iII81 io.l.12 121 18 1ii.12 13( f-~ J3 j27 ; 3,7 13,27 L3 ; 7 '17 1619,23 71 61 no exist 16 , 7i1 293 17 20 , 13 , 23 205 7.8T fo4Ara3 20519 20-9g 26 1.~ fb6 21 6.7 Does not exist .
31 9 51 27-3122 ~~ 6 K8,35Or ' 35.332 21 16 16 54Auriga-2 26 5 26 61 37 1 ? ?
36,3 | 27 31 91 27_7 29 6 .
7 ?
os n~ot exist .
_ &gt; . ?
..l_ 3 331 16 7l 1'5 3 3S 0:4 77 ; 34ff 43g..X ... Lustre of the stars in Gemini .
38 1eI60 8o8 .
83 39 6 .
7 37 39 .
40 4111 6 45-41 45,41,50 42 1 s &lt; 6 142- , 44 43 A34 31 343 441 6.7 42 - , 44 4510 6.51-45-41 6 .
45 41 461 I5 I60 -46 69,46 62-46 471 I6 48 , 47 , 52 48 m6 57-48 , 47 491 17I 2-49 58)49 s50 f6 141 50 5t1 156 s51 45 51 68,52I n 17 6 47 , 52-49 52 , 58 53 16.7 159 53 541 A1 54 ; 55 55 13 15.577 54 ; 55 s6I q 16.7 56 63 57 1A5 S.6 J 57-48 58 _ 78 7852,58,49 59 J6 164 -5,9 59 .
53 6oj 45 I4 .
16o-65 60-46 6o 062 61I r6 126.61 63,61 62 ?
sI 6o 62 46 63 p6 16 ; 63,61 64T bj 6_ 65 .
64 59 6s b " j6o-66 66 786624 66.3 Aur$6 67 1 7 .
1 68 -,67 68j k6 66-67 5,8 , , 68,81.~~~~6 - , 67. .
45 , Lustre of the stars in Gemini .
69f Ivs 169 .
8 69 446 7 ?
t5 8c ) #7O 711 5 71 7 .
80 t16 Does not exist .
73 1| 6.7 | Does not exist .
741 ff 68 1,7485 7.5 ( 17,3 76 !
c6 183 78 i77 1 IA4.5 5577 34 ' , 78 j9 J78 8-,66 78,67Vixginis 87fauri--78 791 / 7 / 82 79,84 so 1 71 I -t7 8070 8iK 16 168 8S1744 82 6 __ _ 82 , 84 82 .
79 83 p I__ 83 '-76 / 5+ , ( 3 4 , 1j 82 84 79,84 85 16 74-8 -82 Lustre of the stars in Leo .
444t i4 4T1 -2 8_1 6_ 46A 16 7 , 418 5{8 6 16 7os 6 7 , 11 12 7.8 9)9 Lustre of the stars in Leo .
13 6139 141 3 ? ?
4 ( 14 47 14 , 30 16 lQ 6 I16-7 lo , 8 17 1 I3 GS 3-17 70 17-36 17-30 11 _ I6817 36 17-,70 191 17 23.19,21 20o 162 _- , o : 22j g6 I22.15 1,22,20 2j 116 1,8,23 19 241 !
3.4 47 24 6.7 D Does not exist .
26i1 7j Does not exist .
1 18 7 1_Does not exist .
24 I29-07 31-29 30 34 70 * SO 17-30 936.3 14 30 31 1AI ( 31-29 3140 g2 1 os I X11 78 Geminorumn - , 32 , 66 Geminorum 331 6 .
7 ILost or 34--33 34 7 42 -34 35 6 39 ; 35 -36 13 I17 36.70 70.6 .
30 36j 11 '736 4,6 L4enis minoris 17-,36 37 1j6 37-42 38 I36j Does not exist .
'391 6 K ; 9 35 40I 6 31(-40 41 2 4z,94 41-94 41I,94 Lustre of the stars in Leo .
4i2/ 6 137 -42 -34 44 1.56 1 44t 45 49 , 44 43 45/ IIj 144 45 46,45 46-0 4j 6 146 47 Leonis minoris 46 45 46-50 { 01 ~46.5 471 Pi4 14 , 47'24 481 161 48,4A9 49 i6 48 , 49,44 50/ i7.6 46 50 s1 mI 6 46.50 52 K16 41 Leonis minoris-52 153 53I 16 5s3,52 54/ 4.5 60 54-,72 55 6.5 55 57 55 , 62 56 f6 .
7/ 59- , 56 57 16 / 55-57 602 , -57 sj8 d1 6.5 63 58 ; 59 591 c5 58 ; 59 t956 601 b/ 160.54 6i/ I,5 61,69 02 I , 6/ 5 5,62,57 6T ] 14 5 Jt3-58 641 / 66764 65 i6 J79 , b 5 7( 66 j6 6966 67/ 6 |72 -9 67 64 68/ 2 .
3 194-6'8 --17 68-t 7 o9 5.6 6i,69-66 70/ 0/ S / 17-70 3 .
7O SO 17- , 70.3 71 / /6t Does not exist .
Lustre of the stars in Leo .
72 15 54 -,792-,67 73 66 7381 74 141 91 .
7-,87 75 6 184,75,79 761 17 17976 65 , 76 77 45 177 , 78 781 14 177 78-91 77i| edit.61 7,9-76 79,65 8o I6 189-8o-83 81i 6 j73 ; 81 86-81,90 ' 82 7|78 }8.3 82 8~~I 8 f0 88 , 82 84|v 4 I84y 75 851 6_ 85 8p 86 16 86 -81 871 e 4.51 74-K7 90j 6 j8i5o88 891 161 9So 91_ 1 4M 7891 ^ 7s 91 14 193 95 9 41 1i } 1 41 94 41 -94 41 68 =w ; 61 9Notes to Aries .
l There is no observation of this star in FLAMSTEED'S works .
Perhaps one of the observations of 1o0 Piscium was placed 8 degrees too much north , xvhich would produce the first Arietis .
2 There are two stars , the largest of which I take to be the 2d Arietis , and have estimated its brightess .
28 There is an observation in the second volume of the HIistoria Cwlestis , page 81 8 ; and in all appearance it is a good one .
" But as we find no where the 2'6th and 28th observed together , it is probable that only one of them existed in FLAME STEED'S time .
The observation , Dec. io , 1692 , being corrected -- ' of time in RA , will agree with the four observa-* tions on page 8i , i8i , 273 , and 283 .
Catalogue and Atlas .
i and 28 should be out .
Atlas .
A small star under 41 towards 16 Trianguli should be out .
Notes to Canis major .
'Order of magnitude Nov. 17 , 1784 . ? ?
2M ' 2 .
3n 3g.2m Iq3m o4m .
" " 2 " Is 3m , January 9 , 1796 .
" 23 " Is hardly 5 m , January o , 1796 .
" Notes to Canis minor .
3 " Is 4m , January 9 , 1796.q Is io The comparative brightness at first sight is ioig Orionis ; but the light of Rigel being more brilliant than that of Procyon , a continuance of its impression , when we look a good while , occasions an increase ; and it becomes i9 Orionls , 1o .
12 FLAMSTEED never observed this star .
Catalogue and Atlas .
12 should be out .
Notes to Cassiopea .
" Order of magnitude May 12 , 1783 .
, av 2 " m8 There are two stars , nearly equal .
29 There is no observation of FLAMSTEED of this star .
41 There is no observation of this star by FLAMSTEED .
5i FLAMSTEED observed this star Dec. 16 , 1691 .
The ob-o servation , however , is marked defective in zenith-distance .
There is a star , about 9 or lo m , near the place where 51 should be .
55 That which I have estimated is the largest of several small stars about the place of 5 .
Catalogue and Atlas .
29 , 41 , and 51 should be out .
52 and 53 are not laid down in Atlas as they are in the heavens ; and on examining FLAMSTEED'S observation on page 2o8 , it appears that the catalogue is erroneous ; for by that observation 52 is the most north , and 53 the most south , contrary to the catalogue .
; ..Notes to Cetus .
-4 There is no observation of this star by FLAMSTEED .
24 There is no observation of thisstar by FLAMSTEED .
At Is to6 Piscium .
68 A periodical star of ' a great range in its lustre , as appears from the expressions I have given of its comparative bright. .
ness .
Its period is 331 days , to hours , 19 minutes .
See Phil. Trans. 1i792 , Part I. page 25 .
Different authors , however , vary a little in their determinations of the length of this period ; for which we may account by admitting the star to be subject to considerable alterations in the emission of light , from some parts of its surface , which being more copious sometimes in one place , and sometimes in another at some small distance , will give a different result to the observations of the time of its maximum ; while , notwithstanding , the general period of its changes will not be considerably affected -by it .
We have a similar instance in the rotation of Jupiter , which seems to vary on account of the little stability of its spots .
See oPhil .
Trans. 1781 , Part I. page ae3 to 126 .
90 Is 1 Eridani .
Catalogue and Atlas .
14 and 24 should be out .
S " requires+ 4 ' 8"1 of time in RA .
Sept. - , 1786 .
" Atlas .
i8 - " , Is not laid down very accurately in Atls , Sept. Ac 1795 .
Notes to Corvus .
" Order of magnitude May i2 , 1783 .
f yu3a .
" The order , by the present catalogue , does not agree with that in 1783 .
It is no longer 3 , i but f3 ' ; but the constellation is so low that precision is difficult .
Notes to Eridanus .
i Is go Ceti .
21 FLAMSTEED has no observation of this star .
Catalogue and Atlas .
5i must be out .
40 " requires + 6 ' in PD , January 31 , 1786 .
" Notes to Gemini .
21 There is an observation by FL'AMSTEED on page 294 , but -with a small correction , minus , in time it will agree with 20 , and my double star IV .
46 marked 21 : is 20 Geminorum .
29 There is no observation by FLAMSTEED upon this star .
54 Seems to be increasing .
There is an interval of 9 months between the two observations of my catalogue .
Mr. BODE supposes the star to be changeable .
See Astronomishes fabrBucb , 1788 , page 255 .
And 1793 , page 201 .
72 and 73 There are no observations of these stars by FLAMSTEED .
78 " 3 appears to be of a deeper colour than it was a good " many years ago .
I should now ( Jan. 8 , 1796 ) place it " i ; among the red , or ruddy stars ; which formerly I did not " use-to do .
J ' Catalogue and Atlas .
2r , 29 , 72 , and 73 should be out .
Atlas .
17 requires -1 ' in PD. Notes to Leo .
" Order of magnitude May 12 , 1783 .
I0 " In y 2 ' in 2'M SE ant 10 LE Va. ' 25 There is no observation of this star by FLAMSTEED ; but if -14 ' o " in RA and + 2g 25 ' 295 " in PD be applied , according to the edition of 1712 , the place will then agree with lo Sextantis .
There are two very small stars near the place where 25 is put in Atlas ; one of them is the star V. 63 , which in my catalogue of double stars is called 295 Leonis .
, 26 There is an observation of this star by FLAMSTEED on page 299 ; but it is defective .
28 There is anl observation without time on page 299 , marked " Leonis , " taken after the transit of Mars , which has probably occasioned the insertion of 28 into the British catalogue ; but the observed star must have been ii Sextantis .
38 In the observation , March lo , 1691 ; the number 821,6G is cast up 6 degrees too little , which produced this star ; when the error is corrected , we find that the star observed was 37 .
41 This is the double star in my second catalogue I. 28 , and by a series of observations , it appears now that the distance between the two stars is considerably increased , since &amp;c. the year 1782 .
I mention this circumstance here , as it will probably explain some apparent increase of brightness , that seems to have taken place in this star ; for although the same quantity of light , when it is spread over more space , must appear less intense than it will do when it remains in a more confined state , it may nevertheless , by an increase of apparent magnitude , become entitled to be ranged upon a par with a brighter star .
71 FLAMSTEED never observed this star .
94 From the expressions of this cataloge , it i evident , that the star is less now than it was 13 years ago .
420 Of MAYER'S catalogue is not visible .
Catalogue and Atlas .
25 , s26 28 , 38 , and 71 should be out .
WM .
HERSCHEL .
Slough , near Windsor , June i , 1796 .

