XXI .
Experiments to determine the Density of the Earth .
By Henry Cavendisb , Esq. F.iR .
S. and A. S. Read June 21 , 1798 .
IN/ ANY years ago , the late Rev. JOHN MICHELL , of this Society , contrived a method of determining the density of the earth , by rendering sensible the attraction of small quantities of matter ; !
but , as .
he was engaged in other pursuits , he did not complete the apparatus till a short time before his death , and did not live to make any experiments with it .
After his death , the apparatus came to the Rev. FRANCIS JOHN HYDE WOLLASTON , Jacksonian Professor at Cambridge , who , not having conveniences .
for making experiments with it , in the manner he could wish , was so good as to give it to , me .
The apparatus is very simple it consists of a wooden arm , 6 feet long , made so , as to unite great strength with little weight .
This arm is suspended in an horizontal position , by ' a slender wire 40 inches long , and to each extremity is hung a leaden ball , about 2 inches in diameter ; and the whole is enclosed in a narrow wooden case , to defend it from the wind .
As no more force is required to make this arm turn round on its centre , than what is necessary to twist the suspending wire , it is plain , that if the wire is sufficiently slender , the most minute force , such as the attraction of a leaden weight a few inches in diameter , will be sufficient to draw the arm sensibly aside .
The weights which Mr. MICHELL intended to use were 8 inches diameter .
One of these was to be placed on one side the case , opposite to one of the balls , and as near it as could conveniently be done , and the other on the other side , opposite to the other ball , so that the attraction of both these weights would conspire in drawing the arm aside and , when its position , as affected by these weights , was ascertained , the weights were to be removed to the other side of the case , so as to draw the arm the contrary way , and the position of the arm was to be again determined ; and , consequently , half the difference of these positions would show how much the arm was drawn aside by the attraction of the weights .
In order to determine from hence the density of the earth , it is necessary to ascertain what force is required to draw the arm aside through a given sspace .
This Mr. MICHELL intended to do , by putting the arin in m otion , and observing the time of its vibrations , from which it may easily be computed.* Mr. MICHELL had prepared two wooden stands , on which the leaden weights were to be supported , and pushed forwairds , till they came almost in contact with the case ; but he seems to have intended to move them by hand .
As the force with which the balls are attracted by these weights is excessively minute , not more than 5 of their weight , it is plain , that a very minute disturbing force will be sufficient to destroy the success of the experiment ; and , from the following experiments it will appear , that the disturbing Mr. CO ULOMB has , in a variety of cases , used a contrivance of this kind for trying small attractions ; but Mr. MICHE FL informed me of his intention of making this experiment , and of the method he intended to use , before the publication of any of Mr. CouLOMB'S experiments .
force most difficult to guard against , i 's that arising from the variations of heat and cold ; for , if one side of the case is warmer than the other , the air in contact with it will be rarefied , and , in consequence , will ascend , while that on the other side will descend , and produce a current which will draw the arm sensibly aside.* As I was convinced 'of the necessity of guarding against this source of error , I resolved to place the apparatus in a room which should remain constantly shut , , and to observe the motion of the arm from without , by means of a telescope ; and to suspend the leaden weights in such manner , that I could move them without entering into the room .
This difference in the manner of observing , rendered it necessary to make some alteration in Mr. MICOELL'S apparatus ; and , as there were some parts of it which I thought not so convenient as could be wished , I chose to make the greatest part of it afresh .
Fig. 1 .
( Tab. XXIII .
) is a longitudinal vertical section through the instrument , and the building in which it is placed .
ABCDDCBAEFFE , is the case ; x and x are the two balls , which are suspended by the wires hx from the arm gbmh , which is itself suspended by the slender wire g 1 .
This arm consists of a slender deal rod hmh , strengthened by a silver wire bgb ; vby which means it is made strong enough to support the balls , though very light.* : The case is supported , and set horizontal , by four screws , rest.ing on posts fixed firmly into the ground : two of them are represented in the figure , by S and S ; the two others ' are not represented , to avoid confusion .
' GG and GG are the end walls of the building .
W and W are the leaden weights ; which are suspended by the copper rods RrPrR , and the wooden bar rr , from the centre pin Pp .
This pin passes through a hole in the beam HIT , perpendicularly over the centre of theF instrument , and turns round in it , being prevented from falling by the plate p. MM is a pulley , fastened to this pin ; and Mm , a cord wound round the pulley , and passing through the end wall ; by which the observer may turn it round , and thereby move the weights from one situation to the other .
Fig , 2- .
( Tab. XXIV .
) is a plan of the instrument .
AAAA is the case .
SSSS , the four screws for supporting it .
bb , the arm and balls .
Wand W , the weights .
MM , the pulley for moving them .
When the weights are in this position , both conspire in drawing the arm in the direction b W ; but , when they are removed to the situation w and w , represented by the dotted lines , both conspire in drawing the arm in the contrary direction b w. These weights are prevented from striking the instrument , by pieces of Wood , which stop them as soon as they come within of an inch of the case .
The pieces of wood are fastened to the wall of the build-M ing ; and I find , that the weights may strike against them with considerable force , without sensibly shaking the instrument .
In order to determine the situation of the arm , slips of ivory are placed within the case , as near to each end of the arm as can be done without danger of touching it , and are divided to 2oths of an inch .
Another small slip of ivory is placed at each end of the arm , serving as a vernier , and subdividing these divisions into A parts ; so that the position of the arm may be observed with ease to looths of an inch , and may be estimated to less .
These divisions are viewed , by means of the short telescopes T and T , ( fig. i. ) through slits cut in the end of the case , and stopped with glass ; they are enlightened by the lamps L and L , with convex glasses , placed so as to throw the light on the divisions ; no other light being admitted into the room .
The divisions on the slips of ivory run in the direction Ww , ( fig. 2 .
) SO that , when the weights are placed in the positions w and w , represented by the dotted circles , the arm is drawn aside , in such direction as to make the index point to a higher number on the slips of ivory ; for which reason , I call this the positive position of the weights .
FK , ( fig. 1 .
) is a wooden rod , which , by means of an endless screw , turns round the support to which the wire gl is fastened , and thereby enables the observer to turn round the wire , till the arm settles in the middle of the case , without danger of touch-^ ing either side .
The wire gI is fastened to its support at top , and to the centre of the arm at bottom , by brass clips , in which it is pinched by screws .
In these two figures , the different parts are drawn nearly in the proper proportion to each other , and on a scale of one to thirteen .
Before I proceed to the account of the experiments , it will be proper to say something of the manner of observing .
Suppose the arm to be at rest , and its position to be observed , let the weights be then moved , the arm will not only be drawn aside thereby , but it will be made to vibrate , and its vibrations will continue a great while ; so that , in order to determine how much the arm is drawn aside , it is necessary to observe the extreme points of the vibrations , and from thence to determine the point which it would -rest at if its motion was destroyed , or the point of rest as I shall call it .
To do this , I observe three successive extreme points of a vibration , and take the mean between the first and third of these points , as the extreme point of vibration in one direction , and then assume the mean between this and the se , cond extreme , as the point of rest ; for , as the vibrations are continually diminishing , it is evident , that the mean between two extreme points will not give the true point of rest .
It may be thought more exact , to observe many extreme points of vibration , so as to find the point of rest by different sets of three extremes , and to take the mean result ; but it must be observed , that notwithstanding the pains taken to prevent any disturbing force , the arm will seldom remain perfectly at rest for an hour together ; for which reason , it is best to determine the point of rest , from observations made as soon after the motion of the weights as possible .
The next thing to be determined is the time of vibration , which I find in this manner : I observe the two extreme points of a vibration , and also the times at which the arm arrives at two given divisions between these extremes , taking care , as well as I can guess , that these divisions shall be on different sides of the middle point , and not very far from it .
I then compute the middle point of the vibration , and , by proportion , find the time at which the arm comes to this middle point .
I then , after a number of vibrations , repeat this operation , and divide the interval of time , between the coming of the arm to these two middle points , by the number of vibrations , which gives the time of one vibration .
The following example will explain what is here said more clearly .
Extreme Point of Time of middle Point-S .
Divisiors .
rest .
| of vibration .
27,2 h. h h. 25 10$2 74 102s23 24 57 102r3 22,1 24,6 27 -24,7 22,6 24,75 26,8 24,8 23 _W 24,85 26,6 24,9 25 115 221 24 6 48 1l 522 23,4 The first column contains the extreme points of the vibrations .
The second , the intermediate divisions .
The third , the time at which the arm came to these divisions ; and the fourth , the point of rest , which is thus found : the mean between the first and third extreme points is 27,1 , and the mean between this and the second extreme point is 24,6 , which is the point of rest as found by the three first extremes .
In like manner , the point of rest found by the second , third , and Wth extremes , i ' 24,7 , and so on .
The fifth column is the time at which the arm came to the middle point of the vibration , which is thus found : the mean between 27,2 and 22,1 is 24,65 , and is the middle point of the first vibration ; and , as the arm came to 95 at ioh 23 ' 4 " , and to 24 at 10h 23 ' 57 " , we find , by proportion , that it came to 24,65 at 10h 23 ' 23 " .
In like manner , the arm came to the middle of the seventh vibration at i ll s ' 2 2 " ; and , therefore , six vibrations were performed in 41 ' A9 " , or one vibration in 7 ' O " .
To judge of the propriety of this method , we must consider in what manner the vibration is affected by the resistance of the air , and by the motion of the point of rest .
Let the arm , during the first vibration move from D to B , ( Tab. XXIV .
fig. 3 .
) and , duringthe second , from B to d , B dbeing less than DB , on accountof theresistance .
BisectDB in M , and Bd in m , and bisect Mm in n , and let x be any point in the vibration ; then , if the resistance is proportional to the square of the velocity , the whole time of a vibration is very little altered ; but , if T is taken to the time of one vibration , as the diameter of a circle to its semicircumference , the time of moving from B to n exTx Dd ceeds -L a vibration , by SB nearly ; and the time of moving from B to m falls short of 2a vibration , by as much ; and the time of moving from B to x , in the second vibration , exceeds that of moving from x to B , in the first , by D ?
jLtLi )(n xv Bx x x~ ' supposing Dd to be bisected in Y ; so that , if a mean is taken , between the time of the first arrival of the arm at x and its returning back to the same point , this mean will be earlier than the true time of its coming to B , by Tx Dd X &gt; Bxa BnV Bx ) &lt; xa The effect of motion in the point of rest is , that when the arm is moving in the same direction as the point of rest , the time of moving from one extreme point of vibration to the other is increased , and it is diminished when they are moving in contrary directions ; but , if the point of rest moves uniformly , the time of moving from one extreme to the middle point of the vibration , will be equal to that of moving from the middle point to the other extreme , and moreover the time of two successive vibrations will be very little altered ; and , therefore , the time of moving from the middle point of one vibration to the middle point of the next , will also be very little altered , It appears , therefore , that on account of the resistance of the air , the time at which the arm comes to the middle point of the vibration , is not exactly the mean between the times of its coming to the extreme points , which causes some inaccuracy in my method of finding the time of a vibration .
It must be observed , however , that as the time of coming to the middle point is before the middle of the vibration , both in the first and last vibration , and in general is nearly equally so , the error produced from this cause must be inconsiderable ; and , on the whole , I see no method of finding the time of a vibration which is liable to less objection .
The time of a vibration may be determined , either by previous trials , or it may be done at each experiment , by ascertaining the time of the vibrations which the arm is actually put into by the motion of the weights ; but there is one advantage in the latter method , namely , that if there should be any acci- .
dental attraction , such as electricity , in the glass plates through which the motion of the arm is seen , which should increase the force necessary to draw the arm aside , it would also diminish the time of vibration ; and , consequently , the error in the result would be much less , when the force required to draw the arm aside was deduced from experiments made at the time , than when it was taken from previous experiments .
Account of the Experiments .
In my first experiments , the wire by which the arm was suspended was 394 inches long , and was of copper silvered , one foot of which weighed 2T+L grains : its stiffness was such , as to make the arm perform a vibration in about 15 minutes .
I immediately found , indeed , that it was not stiff enough , as the attraction of the weights drew the balls so much aside , as to make them touch the sides of the case ; I , however , chose to make some experiments with it , before I changed it .
In this trial , the rods by which the leaden weights were suspended were of iron ; for , as I had taken care that there should be nothing magnetical in the arm , it seemed of no signification whether the rods were magnetical or not ; but , for greater security , I took off the leaden weights , and tried what effect the rods would have by themselves .
Now I find , by computation , that the attraction of gravity of these rods on .
the balls , is to that of the weights , nearly as 17 to 500o ; so that , as the attraction of the weights appeared , by the foregoing trial , to be sufficient to draw the arm aside by about i , divisions the attraction of the rods alone should draw it aside about -t of a division ; and , therefore , the motion of the rods from one near position to the other , should move it about j of a division .
The result of , the experiment -was , that for the first 15 minutes after the rods were removed from one near position to the other , very little motion was produced in the arm , and hardly more than ought to be produced by the action of gravity ; but the motion then increased , so that , in about a quarter or half an hour more , it was found to have moved 2 or 1 division , in the same direction that it ought to have done by the action of gravity .
On returning the irons back to their former position , the arm moved backward , in the same manner that it before moved forward .
It must be observed , that the motion of the arm , in these experiments , was hardly more than would sometimes take place without any apparent cause ; but yet , as in three experiments which were made with these rods , the motion was constantly of the same kind , though differing in quantity from to 1I division , there seems great reason to think that it was produced by the rods .
As this effect seemed to me to be owing to magnetism , though it was not such as I should have expected from that cause , I changed the iron rods for copper , and tried them as before ; the result was , that there still seemed to be some effect of the same kind , but more irregular , so that I attributed it to some accidental cause , and therefore hung on the leaden weights , and proceeded with the experiments .
It must be observed , that the effect which seemed to be produced by moving the iron rods from one near position to the other , was , at a medium , not more than one division ; whereas the effect produced by moving the weight from the midway to the near position , was about 15 divisions ; so that , if I had continued to use the iron rods , the error in the result caused thereby , could hardly have exceeded - !
of the whole .
EXPERIMENT 1 .
Aug. 5 .
Weights in midway position .
points .
Divisionls .
Time .
D of e ofmid Difference .
points .
rest~~Po of vibr , :tion .
h. _149 42 0 11 , 55 0 11,5 10 50 11,5 At 'Oh 5 ' , weights moved to positive position .
23,4 27,6 25,82 24,7_ 26,07 27,3 _ 26,1 25,1 At ih 6 ' , weights returned back to midway position .
1100 48~ 1 12 1 301 0 18 , -12 14 56 12 1629 } ~i6 9 11 17 20 6,6 -11,92 14 36 11 30 24~ 12 l1 I 3 ? ?
453 i6 ) , _ 11,72 15 13 12 45 58k 45 1t1 47 41 7 ?
7 Motion on moving from midway to pos .
= 14,32 pos .
to midway _ 14,1 Time of one vibration -14 ' 5 It must be observed , that in this experiment , the attraction of the weights drew the arm from X 1,5 to 295,8 , so that , if no contrivance had been used to prevent it , the momentum acquired thereby would have carried it to near 40 , and would , therefore , have made the balls to strike against the case .
To prevent this , after the arm had moved near 15 divisions , I returned the weights to the midway position , and let them remain there , till the arm came nearly to the extent of its vibration , and then again moved them to the positive position , whereby the vibrations were so much diminished , that the balls did not touch the sides and it was this which prevented my observing the first extremity of the vibration .
A like method xvas used , when the weights were returned toa the midway position , and in the twofollowing experiments .
The vibrations , in moving the weights from the midway to the positive position , were so small , that it was thought not worth while to observe the time of the vibration .
When the weights were returned to the , midway position , I determined the time of the arm 's coming to the middle point of each vibration , in order to see how nearly the times of the different vibrations agreed together .
In great part of the following experiments , I contented myself with observing the time of its coming to the middle point of only the first and last vibration .
EXPERIMENT II .
Aug. 6 .
Weights in midway position .
Extreme Divisions .
Time .
Point of Timeof mid .
Difference points .
rest .
of vibration .
h. , .
h. , , , 11 10 40 11 ~1 1 0.1 17 0ll 5 !
5 250 11 , Weights moved to positive position .
29,3 24,1 26,87 S3 _ 27,57 26,2 _ 28,02 29,7 28,12 26,9 28 , o5 28,7 o 27,85 27,1 9 27,82 28,4 Weights returned to midway position .
6 12 1 3501 41 '3~4 34J 18,5 12,37 14 52 13 18 99 } _ 18853 12:t919 11 33 4%8 6714 12 34 51 38 15,2 11 13 46 13 45 8_ 47 25 12 ' 46 22142 Extreme Tie Point of Time of mid .
Difrne points .
Divisions .
Time .
rest .
of vibration .
Difference h. , h. iI 7,1 10 75 1525 11 2 348k , ,612 lg 548f1l 2 2-50 i3 , G Motion of arm on moving weights from midway to pos .
15,87 pos .
to midway = 1545 Time of one vibration 14 ] 42 " EXPERIMENT II .
I Aug. 7 .
The weights being in the positive position , and the arm a little in motion .
31,5 29 _ 30O,12 31 _ 30,02 29 , 1Weights moved to midway position .
9 14 10 34 18 } _ 1034 15 85 80 4 20,5 6 14,8 14 44 15 49 31~ 14 47 49 39 9,2 _ 14,07 14 38 '64 11 5 714 15 618f 14 3Q Extreme .
Tie .
Point of Time of mid .
Divisions .
Time .
~~~~~Difference .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
h. , h. 174 ~~~~13,52 14u 47 14 11 18 46 } 11 19 4 13 i1958J 119 10,1 13,3. .
14 27 13 33 46 14 35 !
6 J.33 Weights moved to positive position .
32 28 0 2'481 5 J~~~ ~ 07j ?
2+ 2 59 27 3 5f 23,7 _ 27,8 31,8 _ 28,27 2,5,8 ___ 28,62 27 44 58,281 46 50 4740 ( Motion of the arm on moving weights from pos .
to mid .
15,22 mid .
to pos .
14,5 Time of one vibration , when in mid .
position = 14 39 " pos .
position -4 54 These experiments are sufficient to show , that the attraction of the weights on the balls is very sensible , and are also sufficiently regular to determine the quantity of this attraction pretty nearly , as the extreme results do not differ from each other by more than -/ O part .
But there is a circumstance in them , the reason of which does not readily appear , namely , that the effect of the attraction seems to increase , for half an hour , or an hour , after the motion of the weights as it may be observed , that in all three experiments , the mean position kept increasing for that time , after moving the weights to the posi- ' tive position ; and kept decreasing , after moving them from the positive to the midway position .
The first cause which occurred to me was , that possibly there might be a want of elasticity , either in the suspending wire , or something it was fastened to , which might make it yield more to a given pressure , after a long continuance of that pressure , , than it did at first ' To put this to the trial , I moved the index so much , that the arm , if not prevented by the sides of the case , would have stood at about -5o divisions , so that , as it could not move farther than to ' divisions , it was kept in a position iS divisions distant from that which it would naturally have assumed from the stiffness of the wire ; or , in other words , the wire was twisted is divisions .
After having remained two or three hours in this position , the index was moved back , so as to leave the arm at liberty to assume its natural position .
It must be observed , that if a wire is twisted only a little more than its elasticity admits of , then , instead of setting , as it is called , or acquiring a permanent twist all at once , it sets gradually , and , when it is left at liberty , it gradually loses part of that set which it acquired ; so that if , in this experiment , the wire , by having been kept twisted for two or three hours , had gradually yielded to this pressure , or had begun to set , it would gradually restore itself , wshen left at liberty , and the point of rest world gradually move backwards ; but , though the experiment was twice repeated , I could not perceive any such effect .
The arm was next suspended by a stiffel wire .
EXPERIMENT IV .
Aug. 12 .
Weights in midway position .
Extreme Divisions .
Time .
Point of Time of mid .
Difference .
points , rest , of vibration .
_ -. .
_..h .
21 , -6 930 0 21,5 52 0 21,5 10 13 0 21,5 Weights moved from midway to positive position .
27,2 22,1 _ 24,6 27 _ 24,67 22,6 24,75 26,8 _ 24,8 23,0 24,85 26,6 ___ 24,9 23,4 Weights moved to negative position .
15 '2 }10 20 31 22,4 18,72 20 26 45 } 2731 15,1 _ 18,52 6 57 19 3514 20 48 !
-42 21,5 18,35 7 23 20 40 23 45 19 41 18 ?
,153 18,22 6 48 i8 48 8g6 } 48 39 19 492 4 20,8 18,6 58 118 1 54 45 j~55 37 15,55 Weights moved to positive position .
Extreme Diiin .
Tm .
Point of Time of mid .
Difference .
points .
e Divisions .
Timeo rst .
Of vibration .
~h .
, _hi 8l 31,3 25 11 10 25 } 23 11 3 j114 17,1 !
24,02 73 22 1 7 .
6 } 30,6 24,17 71 25 24 33 } 23 2517 7 2444 18,4 9 24,32 _75 23 31 21 } 3149 29,9 __ 24,4 _6 59 2-5 3 3848 2-3 39 39 } _1 38 481 19,4 _ 24,5 76 23 45 16 46 12 4554 29,3 Motion of arm on moving weights from midway to pos .
= 3,1 pos .
to neg .
-6 i8 neg .
to pos .
=5,92 Time of one vibration in neg .
position 7 ' 1 " pos .
position =7 3 EXPERIMENT V. Aug. 20 .
The weights being in the positive position , the arm was made to vibrate , by moving the index .
Extreme Divisions.f Time of mid .
Difference .
Oins~eDiviio h. Time .
rest .
of vibration'.Difrne h._ , h. 29,6 2 1 , 1_ 25,2 -29 , _ 25,17 21,6 Weights moved to negative position .
22,6 20 10 22 47 _1 19 23 30f 2 16 , 19,27 21,9 ___ 19,15 16,5 19,1 21,5 19,07 16,8 _ 19,07 21,2 ___ 19,07 17 , 19,05 so,8 _ 19,02 17,4 19,05 2o,6 i 19,02 201 132916 ) ; 335 19 33 58 17,5 _ 18,97 4 17 13 19 41 16 } 41 6 20,3 Weights moved to positive position .
E xtrem,.e DvsnsPoint of Time of mid .
Dferce poiuts .
i rest .
of vibration .
h. , .
, h. , , , 20,2 24 11 49 10 } 26 5o19J 29,4 -24,95 77 26 i56i 564i4 25 47 44 20,8 _ 24,92 28,7 24,87 21,3 9 24,85 28,1 24,75 2 1,5 24,67 27,6 24,67 22 _ 24,7 2,4 0 45 48 25 46 43 o 46 21 27,224,7 71 25 53 11 5322 24 54 95 22,4 Motion of arm on moving weights from pos .
to neg .
5,9 neg .
to pos .
5,98 Time of one vibration , when weights are in neg .
position 7 15 ti pos .
position 75 In the fourth experiment , the effect of the weights seemed to increase on standing , in all three motions of the weights , conformably to what was observed with the former wire ; but , in the last experiment , the case was different ; for though , on moving the weights from positive to negative , the effect seemed to increase on standing , yet , on moving them from negative to positive , it diminished .
My next trials were , to see whether this effect was owing to magnetism .
Now , as-it happened , the case in which the arm was enclosed , was placed nearly parallel to the magnetic east and west , and therefore , if there was any thing magnetic in the balls and weights , the balls would acquire polarity from the earth ; and the weights also , after having remained some time , either in the positive or negative position , would acquire polarity in the same direction , and would attract the balls ; but , when the weights were moved to the contrary position , that pole which before pointed to the north , would point to the south , and would repel the ball it was approached to ; but yet , as repelling one ball towards the south has the same effect on the arm as attracting the other towards the north , this would have no effect on the position of the arm .
After some time , however , the poles of the weight would be reversed , and would begin to attract the balls , and would therefore produce the same kind of effect as was actually observed .
To try whether this was the case , I detached the weights from the upper part of the copper rods by which they were suspended , but still , retained the lower joint , namely , that which passed through them ; I then fixed them in their positive position , in such manner , that they could turn round on this joint , as a vertical axis .
I also made an apparatus , by which I could turn them half way round , on these vertical axes , without opening the door of the room .
Having suffered the apparatus to remain in this manner for a day , I next morning observed the arm , and , having found it to be stationary , turned the weights half way round on their axes , but could not perceive any motion in the arm .
Having suffered the weights to remain in this position for about an hourP I turned them back into their former position , but without its having any effect on the arm .
This experiment was repeated on two other days , with the same result .
We may be sure , therefore , that the effect in question could not be produced by magnetism in the weights ; for , if it was , turning them half round on their axes , would immediately have changed their magnetic attraction into repulsion , and have produced a motion in the arm .
As a further proof of this , I took off the leaden weights , and in their room placed two 1i-inch magnets ; the apparatus for turning them round being left as it was , and the magnets be'Ing placed horizontal , and pointing to the balls , and with their north poles turned to the north ; but I could not find that any alteration was produced in the place of the arm , by turning them half round ; which not only confirms the deduction drawn from the former experiment , but also seems to show , that in the experiments with the iron rods , the effect produced could not be owing to magnetism .
The next thing which suggested itself to me was , that possibly the effect might be owing to a difference of temperature between the weights and the case ; for it is evident , that if the weights were much warmer than the case , they would warm that side which was next to them , and produce a current of air , which would make the balls approach nearer to the weights .
Though I thought it not likely that there should be sufficient difference , between the heat of the weights and case , to have ?
R2 any sensible effect , and though it seemed improbable that , in all the foregoing experiments , the weights should happen to be warmer than the case , I resolved to examine into it , and for this purpose removed the apparatus used in the last experiments , and supported the weights by the copper rods , as before ; and , having placed them in the midway position , I put a lamp under each , and placed a thermometer with its ball close to the outside of the case , near that part which one of the weights approached to in its positive position , and in such manner that I could distinguish the divisions by the telescope .
Having done this , I shut the door , and some time after moved the weights to the positive position .
At first , the arm was drawn aside only in its usual manner ; but , in half an hour , the effect was so much increased , that the arm was drawn 14 divisions aside , instead of about three , as it would otherwise have been , and the thermometer was raised near 10 2- ; namely , from 61 ?
to 692 .
On opening the door , the weights were found to be no more heated , than just to prevent their feeling cool to my fingers .
As the effect of a difference of temperature appeared to be so great , I bored a small hole in one of the weights , about threequarters of an inch , deep , and inserted the ball of a small thermometer , and then covered up the opening with cement .
Another small thermometer was placed with its ball close to the case , and as near to that part to which the weight was approached as could be done with safety ; the thermometers being so placed , that when the weights were in the negative position , both could be seen through one of the telescopes , by means of light reflected from a concave mirror .
EXPERIMENT VI .
Sept. 6 .
Weights in midway position .
Extreme Divisions .
Time .
Point of Thermometer points .
Dressed .
in Air .
inWeight .
h ' 18,9 9 43 55,5 i8,815 10 3 18,85 Weights moved to negative position .
13,1 , 10 12 55,5 55A 18,4 18 15,82 : 13S,4 225 missed .
13,6 ~~39 55,5 5,8 .
17,6 46 15,65 13,8 653 i,6 ; 17,4 _ ii 0 15,65 14,0 7 i5,65 17,2 14 55,5 Weights moved to positive position .
25,8 _ 23 17,5 _0 21,055 25,4 37 21,6 18,1 44 21,65 25,0 _ 51 missed .
24)7 05 19 , 12 21,77 24,4 19 Motion of arm on moving weights from midway to,03 to +59 EXPERIMENT VII .
Sept. 18 .
Weights in midway position .
Extreme Divisions Time .
Point of Thermometer points .
f rest .
in Air .
inWeight .
19,4 8 So 56,7 194 9 32 56,6 Weights moved to negative position .
13,6 40 57,2 i8,8 4 16,251,3,81 54I Eight extreme points missed .
16'.9 _ so 58 145,5 115 15,62e i6,6 12 Weights moved to positive position .
2644 201 565 17,2 _ 28 21,72 6,11 3S Four extreme points missed .
19,3 o0 25,1 j17 2223 19 &gt; 7 _ 24 Motion of arm on moving weights from midway to-= , to + 6 , EXPERIMENT VIII .
Sept. 23 .
Weights in midway position. .
Extreme Point of Thermometer points .
visons .
itme. .
in Air .
inWeight .
pons hi 53,1 19,3 9 46 53,19,2 10 45 19,2 53,1 Weights moved to negative position .
3,5\ _ 56 5,6 18,6 11 3 16 , X7 13,6 10 I Four extreme points missed .
17,4 44 14,1 58.51 15,7 _ 17,21 58 .
53 6 Weights moved to positive position .
'I5,71 0 11 1 26,7 18 21,42 166 -15 f53,15 Two extreme points missed .
25)9 36 X8,1I43j21,9 Motion of arm on moving weights from midway to -3 , IS .
to + =-5,72 In these three experiments , the effect of the weight appeared to increase from two to five tenths of a division , on standing an hour ; and the thermometers showed , that the weights were three or five tenths of a degree warmer than the air close to the case .
In the two last experiments , I put a lamp into the room , over night , in hopes of making the air warmer than the weights , but without effect , as the heat of the weights exceeded that of the air more inthese two experiments than in the former .
On the evening of October 17 , the weights being placed in the midway position , lamps were put under them , in order to warm them ; the door was then shut , and the lamps suffered to burn out .
The next morning it was found , on moving the weights to the negative position , that they were 702 warmer than the air near the case .
After they had continued an hour in that position , they were found to have cooled 1 so as to be only 60 warmer than the air .
They were then moved to the positive position ; and in both positions the arm was drawn aside about four divisions more , after the weights had remained an hour in that position , than it was at first .
May 22 , 1798 .
The experiment was repeated in the same manner , except that the lamps were made so as to burn only a short time , and only two hours were suffered to elapse before the weights were moved .
The weights were now found to be scarcely q ' warmer than the case ; and the arm was drawn aside about two divisions more , after the weights had remained an hour in the position they were moved to , than it was at first .
On May 23 , the experiment was tried in the same manner , except that the weights were cooled by laying sic on them ; the -ice being confined in its place by tin plates , which , on moving the weights , fell to the ground , so as not to be in the way .
On moving the weights to the negative position , they were found to be about 8 ?
colder than the air , and their effect on the arm seemed now to diminish on standing , instead of increasing , as it did before ; as the arm was drawyn aside about 2divisions less , at the end of an hour after the motion of the weights , than it was at first .
It seems sufficiently proved , therefore , that the effect in question is produced , as above explained , by the difference of temperature between the weights and case ; for , in the 6th , 8th , and 9th experiments , in which the weights were not much warmer than the case , their effect increased but little on standing ; whereas , it increased much , when they were much warmer than the case , and decreased much , when they were much cooler .
It must be observed that in this apparatus , the box in which the balls play is pretty deep , and the balls hang near the bottom of it , which makes the effect of the current of air more sensible than it would otherwise be , and is a defect which I intend to rectify in some future experiments .
EXPERIMENT ix .
April 29 .
Weights in positive position .
Extreme Divisions ime .
Point of Time of middle points ... st. f. vibration .
h#hr 34,7 Weights moved to negative position .
Extreme Divisions. .
Point of Time-of mid .
Difference .
points .
Tioe .
rest .
of vibration .
h. h , h , 2 3 , 8 28 11 18 2943 33,2 _ 28,52 29 25 27'1 28 571 ~ 24 23,9 _ 28,25 32 28,01 24,15 27,82 31 27,63 24,4 27,55 30 , 4 27,47 i 28 07 4 } o 726 27 53j -24,7 Motion of arm = 6,32 Time of vibration _ =6/ 58 " EXPERIMENT X. May 5 Weights in positive position .
34Z5 8315 33397 3474 Weights moved to negative position .
22,3 28 1043 42 6 29 44 G6 ~ 43 33,2 27,82 70 28 50 331 5036 27 5_1 Of 226I 27,72 Extreme Divisions .
Time .
Point of Time of mid .
Difference .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
h. h. , n , a 32,5 27,7 23,2 a 27,58 3 1,45 274 235 _ 27,28 27 11 25 201 28 58j~~ 11 25 24 so7 27,21 373 28 32 01 322917 27 32 40f 23,95 56 27,21 6 S6 27 39 191 f228n [ 3919 } ~| 39 23 28 40 2J 30,2,5 Motion of arm 6 , Time of vibration 6 ' 59 " EXPERIMENT XI .
May 6 .
Weights in positive position .
34,9 34,1 __ 34X47 34,8 34,49 34,25 Weights moved to negative positions 28284 89 69 59 } _oo -8 29 10 0 27j 33,3 7 29 6 52 27 7 51 Extreme Divisions .
Time .
Point of rime of mid .
points .
rest , of vibration .
h. , h. , R 23,8 __ 28,35 32,5 28,3 24,4 missed .
2,4,8 31,73 28,17 29 1048 371 28 4921f 10 49 8 25,3 _28,2 2,8 56 85 29 56 t 56 5613 30,9 Motion of arm _ 6 , o7 Time of vibration 7 ' 1 In the three foregoing experiments , the index was purposely moved so that , before the beginning of the experiment , the balls rested as near the sides of the case as they could , without danger of touching it ; for it must be observed , that when the arm is at 35 , they begin to touch .
In the two following experiments , the index was in its usual position .
EXPERIMENT XII .
May 9 .
Weights in negative position .
I74 9 45 0 174 58o 7 ?
4 10o 8o 174 lo 0 1-7 i4i Weights moved to positive position .
Extreme Divisions .
Time Point of Time of mid .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
h. , , h. 28,85 24 10 20 5102059 22 21 46J 18,4 9 23,49 28,3 23,57 19,3 23,67 27,8 23,72 20 23,8 27-4 23,83 24 11 3 13 2354 11 3 14 20,55 23,87 23 9 45 } io i8 27 Motion of arm 6,09 Time of vibration 7 =7 3 " EXPERIMENT XIII .
May 25 .
Weights in negative position .
16 18,3 __ 17)2 Weights moved to positive position .
29,6 25 10 22 02 24 0 45 174 23,32 23 29 59 } 33 28,9 _23,4 24 3,6 &amp; 8N 3 2-3 , 3724 37 7 18,4 , 23,52 Extreme Ti Point of Time of mid .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
-h .
h. , 23 10 44 3)1 41 24 104414 2894 23,62 19,4 _ 23,7 27,8 6 23,7 24 1 5261 11 31 23 6 iJ 19,9 _ 23,72 27,3 1 02 !
212 ) ! !
I1235 24 5 Weights moved to negative position .
13.5 21,8 _ 17,75 18 37 34173 17 38 io 37 39 13,9 I7,67 18 44 264 44 45 21,1 _ 17,62 14,4 17,6 20,5 17,52 14,7 17547 20 _ 17,42 0 19 57 0120 24 17 20 5 15 17,37 17 27 151 2730 i3 28 i1 .
19,5 Motion of the arm on moving weights from to + 6,12 + to 5,97 Time of vibration at + 7 ' 6 " -7 7 EXPERIMENT XIV .
May 2,6 .
Weights in negative position .
Extreme Divisions Time .
Point of Time of mid .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
h. / h. 16 , i 9 1s O , i6,1 24 0 161L t46 o 16,1 49 a i6 , Weights moved to positive position .
27,7 23 10 046 } 22i i6J 1 1723 22,37 22S 7 58 2,5 8 27 85 27,2 22,5 23 15 2 } _5 18,3 __ 22,665 26,8 ___ 22,75 19,1 _ 22,8,5 26,4 22,97 23 43 40 } 4332 22 4~2 20 _ 23 , 15 22 49 53 } 50 41 2,3 50 371 26,2 Weights moved to negative position .
12,4 i6 fit 7 53 }i 8 25 17 ' 8 2712 f~~l5 _ ~1 ~ 17,02~ 21,5 1}_2 17 115 30 16 J 16 31527 Extreme Dvisio ; ls Time .
Point of Time of mid .
points .
T rest .
of vibration .
h. h. : - .
12,7 16,9 20,7 _ 16185 1333 ___ 6,82 20 __ 16,72 13,6 ~~~ 16,67 Ai6 11 50 : 33~ .
IO 17 1X S1 Ago S8 T9,5 6 _65 17 57 523 }=5 '7 ~ ~~58 6 16 58 44F 14l- .
' .
Motion of arm by moving weights from to += 6,27 + to 6 , i3 Time of vibration at + 7 ' 6"1 - .
76 In the next experiment , the balls , before the motion of the weights , were made to rest as near as possible to , the sides of the case , but on the contrary side from what they did in the 9th , 10th , and X ith experiments .
EXPERIMENT XV .
May 27 .
Weights in negative position .
3333 ; _~ 3,61 3,85 _ 3,61 Weights moved to positive position .
Extreme Divisions Time .
Point of Tiite of mid .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
, lh .
, , h. , X 10 10 5 59 } 92 97 4,8 9,95 9 12 43 } 13 10 13 111 14,8 10,007 , 1 0 , _4 1 , ? ?
10 2 24 } 20 13 59 _ 10,23 14,35 i_ 10,35 6,8 10,46 13,9 108,52 too48 , 30 } 48 42 7,5 1o,6 10 552G6 Mo 55 48 115 Motion of the arm 6,4 Time of vibration 717 ' The two following experiments were made by Mr. GILPIN , who was so good as to assist me on the occasion .
EXPERIMENT--XVI .
May 28 .
Weights in negative position .
22,155 21 14,4)9 Weights moved to positive position .
Extreme Divisions .
Time .
Point of Trimne of rnid .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
_ 11._l h , , hJ*,1,26,6 22 10 2253 1 21 23 20 1S,3 }10 23 15 15,8 _ 21 20 30 7 ' 1 21 361i 30 3.0 925,8 21.,05 22 37 23g 1 .
7 45 21 551 168 21 , 11 20 4S 42}9 _ 45 1 21 ~45 4 2,0,5 21,11 22 51 54 I 21 52321 6220 17,57 : 21,2 21 59 31 1 22 1:1 0 13 !
j593 24,6 Q 21,28 22 624 11 649 18,3 27 Motion of the arm 6,1 Time of vibration = 7 ' 16 " EXPERIMENT XVII .
May 3o .
Weights in negative position .
17,2 10 19 0 17,1 25 0 '17,07 29 0 1715 40 0 1745 49 0 1742 51 0 17,42 .
11 10 17,42 sot Weights moved to positive position .
Extreme Divisions .
Time .
Point of Time of mid .
points .
rest .
of vibrationp h. , * h. , , 28,8 24 1111 _}3 i8 , i _ 23,2 27,8 23,12 l23 491 }540 I8,8 _ 23,2 23 ~~3234 24 3313J } _ Sg4 27,38 23,31 24 39-28 } 23 40 ' 19,7 23,44 23 4633 1 24 3473 } 27,38 23,52 24 539614 V3~~ 34 23 5417123 204 is 23,57 23 0 334 24 5i8 J0 05 26,5 23,55 2-78314 } 750o 23 21 L 20,8 _ 23,59 23 14 34 } 26,2524 152 24 01 7i3 Weights moved to negative position .
Extreme Divisions .
Time Point of Time of mid .
points .
rest .
of vibration .
h. , h. .
13,3 17 0 32 191 _ 32 44 22,4 17,95 i8 -39 46 } 17 4019 39 44 137 _ 17,85 17 46 26 } 46 48 18 47 f 21,6 l7,72 7 53 3431 17 54~20J 53 50 14 -17,6 17 1 0391 05 18 1 20f 5 20,8 _17,47 187 87 39 } 7 59 17 2 14,3 _17,37 17 14 54 11 i8 15 42f1 4 20,1 17,27 146[8 21 32 } 21321 ~22 5 14,6 Motion of the arm on moving weights from to += 5,78 + to 5,64 Time of vibration at __+ 7 ' 2 ' $M .
-7 3 On the Method of computing the Density of the Earth from these Experiments .
I shall first compute this , on the supposition that the arm and copper rods have no weight , and that the weights exert no sensible attraction , except on the nearest ball ; and shall then examine what corrections are necessary , on account of the arm and rods , and some other small causes .
The first thing is , to find the force required to draw the arm aside , which , as was before said , is to be determined by the time of a vibration .
The distance of the centres of the two balls from each other is 3 inches , and therefore the distance of each from the centre of motion is ?
6,65 , and the length of a pendulum vibrating seconds , in this climate , is 39,14 ; therefore , if the stiffness of the wire by which the arm is suspended is such , that the force which 5 must be applied to each ball , in order to draw the arm aside by the angle A , is to the weight of that ball as the arch of A to the radius , the arm will vibrate in the same time as a pendulum whose length is 36,65 inches , that is , in , / '3 ? ? ?
?iseconds ; and therefore , if the stiffness of the wire is such as to make it vibrate in N seconds , the force which must be applied to each ball , in order to draw it aside by the angle A , is to the weight of the ball as the arch of AxX to the radius .
But the ivory N 39,14 scale at the end of the arm is 38,3 inches from the centre of motion , and each division is -Iof an inch , and therefore subtends an angle at the centre , whose arch is a and therefore the force which must be applied to each ball , to draw the arm aside by one division , is to the weight of the ball as -66'N2 3 ' to 1 , or as 8iS N ?
to I. .
766 N2Z 39,14 88N The next thing is , to find the proportion which the attraction of the weight on the ball bears to that of the earth thereon , supposing the ball to be placed in the middle of the case , that is , to be not nearer to one side than the other .
When the weights are approached to the balls , their centres are 8,85 inches from the middle line of the case ; but , through inadvertence , the distance , from each other , of the rods which support these weights , was made equal to the distance of the centres of the balls from each other , whereas it ought to have been somewhat greater .
In consequence of this , the centres of the weights are not exactly opposite to those of the balls , when they are approached together ; and the effect of the weights , in drawing the arm aside , is less than it would otherwise have been , in the triplicate ratio of 8,85 to the chord of the angle whose sine is 36,65 8,85th 3665 , or in the triplicate ratio of the cosine of this angle to the radius , or in the ratio of,9779 tol .
Each of the weights weighs 924390OO grains , and therefore is equal in weight to o,64 , spherical feet of water ; and therefore its attraction on a particle placed at the centre of the ball , is to the attraction of a spherical foot of water on an equal particle placed on its surface , as 10,64 x,9779 x to 1 .
The mean diameter of the earth is 41800000 feet ; * and therefore , if the mean density of the earth is to that of water as D to one , the attraction of the leaden weight on the ball will be to that of the earth thereon , as 10,64 x,9779 x ; to 41800000 Di to 8739000 D. It is shown , therefore , that the force which must be applied to each ball , in order to draw the arm one division out of its natural position , is ' of the weight of the ball ; and , if the 8i8 Nz mean density of the earth is to that of water as D to i , the attraction of the weight on the ball is 8 of the weight of 8739000D that ball and therefore the attraction will be able to draw the 8i8 N1 N___ arm out of its natural position by I-38o or 10683 D divisions ; and therefore , if on moving the weights from the midway to a near position the arm is found to move B divisions , or if it moves 2B divisions on moving the weights from one near position to the other , it follows that the density of the earth , or D , is 1o683 B We must now consider the corrections which must be applied to this result ; first , for the effect which the resistance of the arm to motion has on the time of the vibration : 2d , for the attraction of the weights on the arm : 3d , for their attraction on the farther ball : 4th , for the attraction of the copper rods on the balls and arm : 5th , for the attraction of the case on the balls and arm : and 6th , for the alteration of the attraction of the weights on the balls , according to the position of the arm , and the effect which that has on the time of vibration .
None of these corrections , indeed , except the last , are of much signification , but they ought not entirely to be neglected .
As to the first , it must be reonsidered , that during thie vibrations of the arm and balls , part of the force is spent in accelerating the arm ; and therefore , in order to find the force required to draw them out of their natural position , we must find the proportion which the forces spent in accelerating the arm and balls bear to each other .
Let EDC e dc ( fig. 4 .
) be the arm .
B and b the balls .
Cs the suspending wire .
The arm consists of 4 parts first , a deal rod Dc d , 73,3 inches long ; 2d , the silver wire DC d , weighing 170 grains ; 3d , the end pieces DE and e dl , to which the ivory vernier is fastened , each of which weighs 45 grains ; and 4th , , some brass work C c , at the centre .
The deal rod , when dry , weighs 232o grains , but when very damp , as it commonly was during the experiments , weighs 2400 ; the transverse section is of the shape represented in fig. 5 ; the thickness BA , and the dimensions of the part DE ed , being the same in all parts ; but the breadth Bb diminishes gradually , from the middle to the ends .
The area of this section is , i of a square inch at the middle , and 146 at the end ; and therefore , if any point x ( fig. 4 .
) is taken in c d , and C-x is called x , this rod weighs 27 cd ~~~~~~~~73,3X Y2-38 per inch at the middle ; ,2400 &gt; 3 X146 at the end , and 24003 3 '3'384x 73,3 X,238 7 3,3 X3 =33207384,8 at x ; and therefore , as the weight of the wire is 7170 per inch , the deal rod and wire together may be considered as a rod whose weight at x 349= 3343 X per inch .
73,3 pe II But the force required to accelerate any quantity of matter placed at x , is proportional to x ' ; that is , it is to the force required to accelerate the same quantity of matter placed at d as x2 to 1 ; and therefore , if cd is called 1 , and x is supposed to Sow , the fluxion of the force required to accelerate the deal rod and wire is proportional to x/ " ( 3490-1848 X the fluent of which 73,3I generated while x flows from c to d , Lx 39 =48 -050* 73,3 34 so that the force required to accelerate each half of the deal rod and wire , is the same as is required to accelerate 35o grains placed at d. The resistance to motion of each of the pieces de , is equal to that of 48 grains placed at d ; as the distance of their centres of gravity from C is 38 inches .
The resistance of the brass work at the centre may be disregarded ; and therefore the whole force required to accelerate the arm , is the same as that required to accelerate 398 grains placed at each of the points D and d. Each of the balls weighs 1i 26e2 grains4 and they are placed at the same distance from the centre as 1 ) and d ; and therefore , the force required to accelerate the balls and armn together , is the same as if each ball weighed i 1iGo , and the arm had .
no weight ; and therefore , supposing the time of a vibration to be given , the force required to draw the arm aside , is greater than if the arm had no weight , in the proportion of i i66o to 1 1262 , or of 1,0353 to 1 .
To find the attraction of the weights on the arm , through d draw the vertical pjane dwb perpendicular to D d , and let w be the centre of the weight , whylich , though notacourately in this plane , may , Without sensible error , be considered as placed therein , and let b be the cenitre of the ball ; then wb is horizontal and = 8,8 , , and db is vertiecal and = , let wa -a , wb_ b , and let or 1 -x = z ; then the attraction of the weight on a particle of matter at x , in the direction d w , is to its attraction on the same particle placed at b:b : a ' + z ' I , or is pro portional to ; , and the force of that attraction to move the arm , is proportional to b ' x , 'and the weight of the deal\ rod and wire at the point X , was before said to be 34_90_-_848 X 1642 + 1848 X 3_90..-188.per inch ; and therefore , if dx flows , 73,3 73,3 the fluxion of the power to move the arm =17x 7+ 3148 Z 73,3 MX i_ .
I _8 b3X Z.X3ZX821+103 z-924zz l+_~1 -m =X 821 + 924Z X %+ IZ+1zzd 924-a2 b3 XXSZI+163z+94 924b X z2* b---~zI+Io~ ?
E 92-which , as o8 x 89 , 4103z 24 P 895 zV z a)~ZX89~+1z +1 zz The fluent of this a21+12 I/ a1+Pz1'aVaz+1+Pzz io3 P+ 103 3 9240 1z+a +12z ~~l/ a ; +--+ lt 1-b log .
a ?
LLand the force lVa +11 a P. a with which the attraction of the weight , on the nearest half , of the , deal rod and wire , tends to move the arm , is proportional to this fluent generated while z flows from o tQ i , that is , to 1 28 grains .
The force with which the attraction of the weight on the end-piece de tends to move the arm , is proportional to 47 x or 29 grains ; and therefore the whole power of the weight to move the arm , by means of its attraction on the nearest part thereof , is equal to its attraction on 15 ; 7 grains placed at b , which is 5 or , o 39 of its attraction on the ball .
It must be observed , that the effect of the attraction of the weight on the whole arm is rather less than this , as its attraction on the farther half draws it the contrary way ; but , as the attraction on this is small , in comparison of its attraction on the nearer half , it may be disregarded .
The attraction of the weight on the furthest ball , in the direction b w , is to its attraction on the nearest ball : : w d ' : w D3 .
: , ool07 : i ; and therefore the effect of the attraction of the weight on both balls , is to that of its attraction on the nearest ball::,9983 : 1 .
To find the attraction of the copper rod on the nearest ball , let b and w ( fig. 6 .
) be the centres of the ball and weight , and ea the perpendicular part of the copper rod , which consists of two parts , ad and de .
ad weighs 22000 grains , and is i6 inches long , and is nearly bisected by w. de weighs 41000 , and is 46 inches long .
wb is 8,8.5 inches , and is perpendicular to ew .
Now , the attraction of a line ew , of uniform thickness , on b , in the direction bw , is to that of the same quantity of matter placed at w : : bw : e b ; and therefore the attraction of the part da equals that of " " Wb or 163oo , placed at w ; 4 b and the attraction of de equals that of 41000 x ew " x 41 000ed be~'0 dx bx or 2500 , placed at the same point so that the ate ed bdpon traction of the perpendicular part of the copper rod on b , is to that of the weight thereon , as i88oo : 2439000 , or -as , oo771 to 1 .
As for the attraction of the inclined part of the rod and wooden bar , marked Pr and rr in fig. 1 , it may safely be neglected , and so may the attraction of the whole rod on the arm and farthest ball ; and therefore the attraction of the weight and copper rod , on the arm and both balls together , exceeds the attraction of the weight on the nearest ball , in the proportion of,9983 +,0139 +,0077 to one , or of 0o1 99 to I. The next thing to be considered , is the attraction of the mahogany case .
Now it is evident , that when the arm stands at,3 the middle division , the attractions of the opposite sides of the case balance each other , and have no power to draw the arm either way .
When the arm is removed from this division , it is attracted a little towards the nearest side , so that the force required to draw the arm aside is rather less than it would otherwise be ; but yet , if this force is proportional to the distance of the arm from the middle division , it makes no error in the'result ; for , though the attraction will draw the arm aside more than it would otherwise do , yet , as the accelerating force by which the arm is made to vibrate is diminished in the same proportion , the square of the time of a vibration will be:increased in the same proportion as the space by which the arm is drawn aside , and therefore the result will be the same as if the case exerted no attraction ; but , if the attraction of the case is not proportional to the distance of the arm from the middle point , the ratio in which the accelerating force is diminished is different in different parts of the vibration , and the square ' of the time of a vibration will not be increased in the same proportion as the quantity by which the arm is drawn aside , and therefore the result will be altered thereby .
On computation , I find that the force by which the attraction draws the arm from the centre is far from being proportional to the distance , but the whole force is so small as not to be worth regarding ; for , in no position of the arm does the attraction of the case on the balls exceed that of 5th of a spheric inch of water , placed at the distance of i inch from the centre of the balls ; and the attraction of the leaden weight equals that of lo,6 spheric feet of water placed at 8,85 inches , or of 234 spheric inches placed at 1 inch distance ; so that the attraction of the case on the balls can in no position of the arm exceed of that of the weight .
The computation is given in the Appendix .
It has been shown , therefore , that the force required to draw the arm aside one division , is greater than it would be if the arm had no weight , in the ratio of 1,0353 to 1 , and therefore 8385 N3 of the weight of the ball ; and moreover , the attraction of the weight ant copper rod on the arm and both balls together , exceeds the attraction of the weight on the nearest ball , in the ratio of 1,0199 to ' , and therefore -70I99 of the 8739000 D weight of the ball ; consequently D is really equal to SiS N 1,0353 X 1 ; 099 B or N1 instead of N1 as by the former 8739000B ' 10844 B'683B'3 computation .
It remains to be considered how much this is affected by the position of the arm .
Suppose the weights to be approached to the balls ; let W , ( fig. 7 .
) be the centre of one of the weights ; let M be the centre of the nearest ball at its mean position , as when the arm is at 20 divisions ; let B be the point which it actually rests at ; and let A be the point which it would rest at , if the weight was remnoved .
; consequently , -AB is the space by which it isdrawn aside by means of the attraction ; and let MP be the space by which it would be drawn aside , if the attraction on it was the same as when it is at M. But the attraction at B is greatqr than at M , in the proportion of WM ' : WB1 ; and therefore , AB=M:x M_x1+ 2 , MB , very nearly .
Let now the weights be moved to the contrary near position , and let w be now the centre of the nearest weight , and b the point of rest of the centre of the ball ; then Ab= M= x1+ zM JB a zMb =2zMB Bb MW ' n b=M x X2 ++W 2-M ~X1I+ 7 ; so that the whole motion Bb is greater than it would be if the attraction on the ball was the same in all places as it is at M , in the ratio of 1+ Mb to one ; and , therefore , does not depend sensibly on the place of the arm , in either position of the weights , but only on the quantity of its motion , by moving them .
This variation in the attraction of the weight , affects also the time of vibration ; for , suppose the weights to be approached to the balls , let W be the centre of the nearest weight ; let B and A represent the same things as before ; and let x be the centre of the ball , at any point of its vibration ; let AB represent the force with which the.ball , when placed at B , is drawn towards A by the stiffness of the wire ; then , as B is the point of rest , the attraction of the weight thereon will also equal AB ; and , when the ball is at x , the force with which it is drawn towards A , by the stiffness of the wire , A x , and that with which it is drawn in the contrary direction , by the attraction , = AB x so that the actual force by which it is drawn towards A= AxAB + BA xAB x+ w2s zBx xAB Bx WB very nearly .
So that the actual force with which the ball is drawn towards the middle point of the vibration , is less than it would be if the weights were removed , in the ratio of i -AB to one , and the square of the time of a vibration is increased in the ratio of i to 1-AB which differs very little from that of 1+ to 1 , which is the ratio in which the motion of the arm , by moving the weights from one near position to the other , is increased .
The motion of the ball answering to one division of the'arm _X36,35 ; and , if mB is the motion of the ball answering to d divisions on the arm , MB __ 36,3 5 ( ; d and there20 X 38,3X)8,85 185 fore , the time of vibration , and motion of the arm , must be corrected as follows- : If the time of vibration is determined by an experiment in which the weights are in the near position , and the motion of the arm , by moving the weights from the near to the midway position , is d divisions , the observed time must be diminished in the subduplicate ratio of 1 to 1 , that is , in the ratio d of I_d to 1 ; but , when it is determined by an experiment in which the weights are in the midway position , no correction , must be applied .
To correct the motion of the arm caused by moving the weights from a near to the midway position , or the reverse , observe how much the position of the arm differs from 20 di-* visions , when the weights are in the near position : let this be n divisions , then , if the arm at that time is on the same side of the division of 20 as the weight , the observed motion must be diminished by the.2J part of the whole ; but , otherwise , it must be as much increased .
If the weights are moved from one near position to the other , and the motion of the arm is 2d divisions , the observed motion must be diminished by the -8d part of the whole .
If the weights are moved from one near position to the other , and the time of vibration is determined while the weights are in one of those positions , there is no need of correcting either the motion of the arm , or the time of vibration .
CONCLUSION .
Thefollowing Table contains the Result of the Experiments .
Exper .
Mot .
weight Mot .
aim Do .
corr .
rime vib .
Do .
corr .
" Density .
{ im to4+ 14,32 13,42 , , , _ 5)5 or+ tO .
14,1 13,17 14,55 _ 5,6i 2 m. to + 15,87 14,69 4,88 + tomr .
1,45 14,14 14,42 5,07 + tO m. 15,22 13,56 14,39 5,26 3 m. to + 14,5 13,28 14,54 5'55o ( m. to + 3,1 2,95 6,54 5,36 4+ to6,18 7,1 5,29 ( tO + 5,92 7,3 8+ tO 5)9 _ 795 _ 5,65 5o to + 5,98 7,5 5,57 6 m. to3,03 2,9 5_ 5,53 to + 5,9 5,71 5,62 7 |M .
to )7 ; S|S ?
|S 41 |$29 rn t15 3.,03 by 6,57 5,2 t..o + Q6 ' 5,9 en.~448 m. to3,13 3,00 _ 5,34 8 -tO + 5,72 5,54).579 9+ to 6,32 _ 6,58 5,1 10 + to 6,15 6,59 5,27 11 + tQ 6,07 7,1 5 ',39 12 9 tO + 6,09 7,3 _ 5,42 S -.tOt + 6,12 7,6 5,47 13 + to5,97 7,7 5,63 S.-to + 6,27 7,6 .
5,34 14 + to.6 , 7,6 5,46 15 to + 6,34 7,7 5,3 16.to + 6,1 7,16 5,75 to + 5,78 7,2 5,68 + to5,64 73 585 From this table it appears , that though the experiments agree pretty well together , yet the difference between them , both ins the quantity of motion of the arm and in the time of vibration , is greater than can proceed merely from the error of observation .
As to the difference in the motion of the arm , it may very well be accounted for , from the current of air produced by the difference of temperature ; but , whether this can account for the difference in the time of vibration , is doubtful .
If the current of air was regular , and of the same swiftness in all parts of the vibration of the ball , I think it could not ; but , as there.will most likely be much irregularity in the current , it may very likely be sufficient to account for the difference .
By a mean of the experiments made with the wire first used , the density of the earth comes out 5,48 times greater than that of water ; and by a mean of those inade with the latter wire , it comes out the same ; and the extreme difference of the results of the 23 observations made with this wire , is only Ail ; so that the extreme results do not differ from the mean by more than,38 , or I of the whole , and therefore the density should seem to be determined hereby , to great exactness .
It , indeed , may be objected , that as the result appears to be influenced by the current of air , or some other cause , the laws of which we are not well acquainted with , this cause may perhaps act always , or commonly , in the same direction , and thereby make a considerable error in the result .
But yet , as the experiments were tried in various weathers , and with considerable variety in the difference of temperature of the weights and air , and with the arm resting at different distances from the sides of the case , it seems very unlikely that this cause should act so uniformly in the same way , as to make the error of the mean result nearly equal to the difference between this and the extreme ; and , therefore , it seems very unlikely that the density of the earth should differ from 5,48 by so much as I of the whole .
Another objection , perhaps , may be made to these experiments , namely , that it is uncertain whether , in these small distances , the force of gravity follows , exactly the same law as in greater distances .
There is no reason , however , to think that any irregularity of this kind takes place , until the bodies come within the action of what is called the attraction of cohesion , and which seems to extend only to very minute distances .
With a view to see whether the result could be affected by this attraction , I made the 9th , 10th , 1 ith , and Pith experiments , in which the balls were made to rest as close to the sides of the case as they could ; but there is no difference to be depended on , between the results under that circumstance , and when the balls are placed in any other part of the case .
According to the experiments made by Dr. MASKELYNE , on the attraction of the hill Schehallien , the density of the earth is 4{i times that of water ; which differs rather more from the preceding determination than I should have expected .
But I forbear entering into any consideration of which determination is most to be depended on , till I have examined more carefully how much the preceding determination is affected by irregularities whose quantity I cannot measure .
APPENDIX .
On the Attraction of the Mahogany Case on the Balls .
THE first thing is , to find the attraction of the rectangular plane c k,3 b ( fig. 8 .
) on the point a , placed in the line ac per .
pendicular to this plane .
Letac=a , ck=b , cb-x , andlet a , + w5 , and azb , vz , then the attraction of the line bA on a , in the direction a b , = bb= a ; and therefore , if cb flows , the fluxion of the at .
traction of the plane on the point a , in the direction c b , bx vx Vbqb 7v V/ a2 + SO XA2+ bz+xz Va2+x1 s b"+ VX+ az +vW2 the variable part of the fluent of which = log .
v+V1+ ve , and therefore the whole attractionlog .
c k+a X ab so that the attraction of the plane , in the direction c b , is found readily by logarithms , but I know no way of finding its attraction in the direction a c , except by an infinite series .
The two most convenient series I know , are the following : b First series .
Let-= x , and let A= arc whose tang .
is r , B==A-x , CB + , D= C- , &amp;c. then the attrac3 5 ____ B we 3C W4 + 3W tion in the direction ac -/ Iw xA+2 2.+.4.6 ' &amp;c. c ) v a &gt; For the second series , let A=arc whose tang.-= , B =A ACB+IDC &amp;c. then the attraction arc.90 3 r3 5i +/ 1v AB+3 CV 3 .
5D C. .
2.4 Z.4.O It must be observed , that the first series fai-ls when v is greater than unity , and the second , when it is less ; but , if b is taken equal to the least of the two lines ck and cb , there is no case in which one or the other of them may not be used conveniently .
By the help of these series , I computed the following table.,19621,3714 '5145 , 6D48,70711 , 808,8575 9285,98151 , ,11962,00001 '3714,00039 00148,514.5,00074 00277 00521,6208 001100040 600778o1183,7071 0014000522 o1008 015 2502002,7808 00171 o0637012451896O240 03247 085750-020700772 01522 02339031160396405057,9285 , 00244,0091Oo0810o0280703778048670o63g1 81l9,9815 00271 0101902o84 03193 4368 05639 07478 09931 192849 100284 01054 02135 03347 04560105975107978 1:0789 14632 19612 Finld : in this table , with the argument -ak at top , and the argucb meant cb in the left hand column , the corresponding logarithm ; ck then add together this logarithmthe logarithm of Tk , and the logarithm of Tb ; the sum is logarithm of the attraction .
To compute from hence the attraction of the case on the ball , let the box DCBA , ( fig. 1 .
) in which the ball plays , be divided into two parts , by a vertical section , perpendicular to the length of the case , and passing through the centre of the ball ; and , in fig. A , let the parallk lopiped ABDE abde be one of these parts , ABDE being the abovementioned vertical section ; let x be the centre of the ball , and draw the parallelogram inpm x parallel to BbdD , and xgrp parallel to ABbn , and bisect AA in c. Now , the dimensions of the box , on the inside , are Bb 1,75 ; BD=-3,6 BA 1,7S ; and AA=5 ; whence I find , that if xc and Ax are taken as in the two upper lines of the following table , the attractions of the different parts are as set down below .
x i75 15,25 Ax _ 105 1,3 1,55 Excess of attract of Ddrg above Bbrg 2374,1614 , o8i3 e mdrp above nbrp 2374,1614,0813 .
mesp above n asp,370,25i6 1271 Sum of these 8453,5744,2897 Excess of attract .
of Bbnf3 above Ddmc,35007,3271 , i6oG Aang above Eem |,4677q 43079,1525 Whole attraction of the inside surfaced , o o6 of the half box 3109,3 It appears , therefore , that the attraction of the box onx increases faster than in proportion to the distance xc .
The specific gravity of the wood used in this case is,6i , and its thickness is 4 of an inch ; and therefore , if the attraction of the ou-tside surface of the box was the same as that of the inside , the whole attraction of the box on the ball , when cZ = &gt; 75 would be equal to 2 x,1231 X X61 x4 cubic inches , or,201 spheric inches of water , placed at the distance of one inch from the centre of the ball In reality , it can never be so great as this , as the attraction of the outside surface is rather less than that of the inside ; and , moreover , the distance of x from c can never be quite so great as,75 of an inch , as the greatest motion of the arm is only i-L inchb fkioiij .
Yrrans .
MD C CXC NC : Tnab .
XXTV.pS-z6 .
P. X L'L,1 W IS~s 1E 0 ):~ of ' ; 11~~~~~~~~~~~ UM _X VB~~~~ EZRA 11~~~ as _A 13 Id a B~~~~~~~~-------26'~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4\3 ?

