XX .
An Inquiry concerning the chemical Properties that have , been attributed to Light .
By Benjamin Count of Rumford , F.R.S. M.IRI .
A Read June 14 , 1798 .
IN the Second PFart of my Seventh Essay , ( on the propagation of heat in fluids , ) I have mentioned the reasons which had induced me to doubt of the existence of those chemical properties in light that have been attributed to it , and to conclude , that all those visible changes produced in bodies by exposure to the action of the sun 's rays , are effected , not by any chemical combination of the matter of light with such bodies , but merely by the heat which is generated , or excited , by the light that is absorbed by them .
As the decision of this question is a matter of great importance to the advancement of science , and particularly to chemistry , and as the subject is in many respects curious and interesting , it has often employed my thoughts in my leisure hours ; and I have -spent much time in endeavouring to contrive experiments , from the unequivocal results of which thp truth might be made to appear .
Though I have not been so successful in these investigations as I could wish , yet I cannot help flattering myself , that an account of the results of some of my late experiments will be thought sufficiently interesting to merit the attention of the Royal Society .
Having found that gold , or silver , might be melted by , the heat ( invisible to the sight ) which exists in the air , at the disc tance of more than an inch above the point of the flame of a wax-candle , ( see my Seventh Essay , Part IL page I350 ) 1 was curious to know what effect this heat would produce on the oxides of those metals .
Experiment No. i. Having evaporated to dryness a solution of fine gold in aqua regia , I dissolved the residuum , in just as much distilled water as was necessary in order that the solution ( which was of a beautiful yellow colour ) might not be disposed to crystallize ; and , wetting the middle of a piece of white taffeta riband , 1{ inch wide , and about eight inches long , in this solution , I held the riband , with both my hands , stretched horizontally over the clear bright flame , of a wax candle ; the under side of the riband being kept at the distance of about i2 inch above the point of the flame .
The result of this expel riment was very striking .
That part of the riband which was directly over the point of the flame , began almost immediately to emit steam in dense clouds ; and , in about lo seconds , a circular spot , about a of an inch in diameter , having become nearly dry , a spot of a very fine purple colour , approaching to crimson , suddenly made its appearance in the middle of it , and , spreading rapidly on all sides , became , in one or two seconds more , nearly an inch in diameter .
By moving the riband , so as to bring , in their turns , all the parts of it which had been wetted with the solution to be exposed to the action of the current of hot vapour that arose from the burning candle , all those parts which had been so wetted , were tinged with the same beautiful purple colour .
This colour , which was uncommonly brilliant , passed quite through the'ribandi , and I found the stain to be perfectly indelible .
I endeavoured to wash it out ; but nothing I applied to it , and among other things I tried super-oxygenated marine acid , appeared in the smallest degree to diminish its lustre .
The hue was not uniform , but varied from a light crimson to , a very deep purple , approaching to a reddish brown. .
I searched , but in vain , for traces of revived gold , in its reguline form and colou-r ; but , though I could not perceive that the riband was gilded , it had all the appearance of being covered with a thin coating of the most beautiful purple enamel , which , in the sun , had a degree of brilliancy that was sometimes quite dazzling .
Experiment'No .
2 .
A piece of the riband which had been wetted with the aqueous solution of the oxide , was carefully dried in a dark closet , and was then exposed , dry , over the flame of a burning wax candle .
The part of the riband which had been wetted with the solution , ( and which on drying had acquired a faint yellow colour , ) was tinged of the same bright purple colour as was produced in the last-mentioned experiment , when the riband was exposed wet to the action of the heat .
* Experiment No. 3 .
A piece of the riband which had been wetted with the solution , and dried in the dark , was now wetted with distilled water , and exposed 'wet to the action of the ascend .
ing current of hot vapour which arose from the burning candle : the purple stain was -produced as before , which extended as far as the riband had been wetted with the solution , but no ?
farther .
I afterwards varied this experiment in several ways , sometimes using paper , sometimes fine linen , and sometimes fine cotton cloths , instead of the silk riband ; but nearly the same tinge was produced , whatever the substance was that was made to imbibe the aqueous solution of the metallic oxide .
Similar experiments , and with similar results , were likewise made with pieces of riband , fine linen , cotton , paper , &amp; c wettedin an aqueous solution of nitrate of silver ; with this difference , however , that the tinge produced by this metallic oxide , instead of being of a deep purple , inclining to crimson , was of a very dark orange colour , or -rather of a yellowish brown .
In order to discover whether the purple tinge , in the expe.riments with the oxide of gold , was occasioned by the heat communicated by the -ascending current of hot vapour , or by the light of the candle , I made the following experiment , 3the result of which , I conceive to have been decisive .
Experiment No. 4 .
A piece of riband was wetted with the aqueous solution of the oxide of gold , and held vertically by the side of the clear flame of a burning wax candle , at the distance of less than half an inch from the flame .
The riband was dried , but its colour was not in the smallest degree changed .
When it was held a few seconds within about -8 of an inch of the flame , a tinge of a most beautiful crimson colourr , in the form of a narrow vertical stripe , was produced .
The heat which existed at that distance from..the flame , on the side of it , where this coloured stripe was produced , was sufficiently intense , as I found by experiment , to melt very fine silver wire , flatted , such as is used in making silver lace .
The objects I had in view in the following experiments , are too evident to require any particular explanation .
Experiment No. a. Two like pieces of riband were wetted at the same time in the solution , and suspended , while wet , in two thin phials , A and B , of very transparent and colourless glass ; the mouths of the phials Kbeing leftopen Both these phials were placed in a window which fronted the south ; that distinguished by the letter A being exposed naked to the direct rays of a bright sun ; while B was enclosed in a cylinder of pasteboard , painted black within and without , and closed with a fit ' cover , and consequently remained in -perfect darkness .
In a very few minutes , the riband in the phial A began sen .
sibly to change its colour , and to take a purple hue ; and , at the end of five hours , it had acquired a , deep crimson tint throughout .
The phial B was exposed in the window , in its dark cylindrical cover ; three days ; but there was not the smallest appear- .
ance of anychange of colour in the silk .
Experiment No. 6 .
Two small parcels of magnesia alba , in an impalpable powder , ( about half as much in each as could be made to lie on a shilling , ) were placed in heaps , in two China plates , A and B , and thoroughly moistened with the beforementioned aqueous solution of the oxide of gold .
Both plates were placed in the same window ; the moistened earth in the -plate A being exposed naked to the sun 's rays ; while that in the plate B was exactly covered with a tea-cup , turned upside down , which excluded all light .
, The magnesia alba in the plate A , which was exposed to the strong light of the sun , began almost immediately to change colour , , taking a faint violet hue , which by degrees : became more and more intense , and in a few hours ended in a-deep purple ; while that in the plate B , which was kept in the dark , retained the yellowish cast it had acquired from the solution , without the smallest appearance of change .
Experiment No. 7 .
A small parcel of magnesia alba , placed on a china plate , having been moistened with the aqueous solution of the oxide of gold , and thoroughly dried in , a dark closet , was now exposed , ' in this dry state , to the action of the direct rays of a very bright sun .
, It had been exposed to this strong light above half an hour , before its colour began to be sensibly changed ; and , at the end of three hours , it had acquired only a very faint violet hue .
Being now thoroughly wetted with distilled water , it changed colour very rapidly , and soon came to be of a deep purple tint , approaching to crimson .
Experiment no .
8 .
A piece of white taffeta riband , which had been wetted with the solution , and thoroughly dried in the dark , was suspended in a clean dry phial of very fine transc parent glass ; and the phial , being well stopped with a dry cork , was exposed to the strong light of a bright sun .
After the riband had been exposed , in this manner , to the action of the sun 's direct rays about half an hour , there were here and there some faint appearances of a change of its colour ; but it showed no disposition to take that deep purple hue which the riband had always acquired , when exposed to the light in the preceding experiments .
On taking the riband out of the phial , and wetting it thoroughly with distillk4 water , and exposing it again , while thus wetted , to the sun 's rays , it almost instantly began to change colour , and soon became of a deep purple tint ; but , though I examined the surface of the riband with the utmost care , and with a good lens , both during the experiment and after it , I could not perceive the smallest particle of revived gold , nor did I see any vestige remaining that appeared to indicate that any had in fact been revived .
rfhis experiment was repeated several times , and always with results which led me to conclude , ( what indeed was reasonable to expect , ) that light has little effect in changing the colour of metallic oxides , -as long as they are in a -state of crystallization .
The heat which is generated by the absorption of the rays of light must necessarily , at the moment of its generation at least , exist in almost infinitely small spaces ; and consequently , it is only in bodies that are inconceivably small that it can produce durable effects , in any degree indicative of its extreme intensity .
Perhaps the particles of the oxide of gold dissolved in water , are of such dimensions and it is very remarkable , that the colours produced , in some of my experiments on white ribands , by means of an aqueous solution of the -oxide of gold , are precisely the same as are produced from the oxide of that metal , by enamellers , in the intense heat of their furnaces .
As the colouring substance is the same , and as the colours produced are the same , why should we not conclude that the effects are produced in both these cases by the same means , that is to say , by the agency of heat ?
or , in other words , and to be more explicit , by exposing the oxide in a certain temperrature , at which it becomes disposedI to vitrify , or to undergo a change in regard to the quantity of oxygen with which it is combined ?
But the results of the following experiments afford still more satisfactory information , respecting the intensity of - the heat generated in all cases where light is absorbed , and the striking effects which , under certain circumstances , it is capable of producing .
The facility with which most of the metallic oxides are reduced , in the dry way , by means of charcoal , shows that , at a certain ( high ) temperature , oxygen is disposed to -quit those metals , in order to form a chemical union with the charcoal , or at least with some one of its constituent principles , if it be a compound substance , ; and hence I concluded , that gold might be revived , in the moist way , by means of charcoal , from a solution of its oxide in water , were it possible , under such circumstances , to communicate to the charcoal , and to the oxide , at the same time , a degree of heat sufficient for that.purpose .
To see if-this might not be done by means of light , I made , or rather repeated , the following very interesting experiment .
Experiment No. 9 .
Into a thin tube of very fine colourless glass , 10 inches long , and -jL of an inch in diameter , closed hermetically at its lower end , I put as many pieces of charcoal , about the size of large peas , as filled the tube to the height of , two inches ; and , having poured on them as much of the aqueous solution of nitro-muriate of gold as nearly covered them , ex{posed the tube , with its contents , to the action of the direct rays of a very bright sun .
In less than half an hour , small specks of revived gold , in all its metallic splendour , began to make their appearance here and there on the surface of the charcoal ; and , in six hours , the solution , which at first was of a bright yellow colour , became perfectly colourless , AND AS CLEAR AND TRANSPARENT AS THE PUREST WATER .
The surface of the charcoal was , in several places , nearly covered with small particles of revived gold ; and the inside of the glass tube , in that part where it was in contact with the upper surface of the contained liquid , was most beautifully gilded .
This gilding of the tube was very splendid , when viewed by reflected light ; but , when the tube was placed between the light and the eye , it appeared like a thin cloud , of a greenish blue colour , without the smallest appearance of any metallic splendour .
From the colour , and apparent density of this cloud , I was induced to conclude , that the gilding on the glass was less than one millionth part of an inch in thickness .
This interesting experiment was repeated six times , and always with nearly the same result .
The gold was completely revived in each of them , and the solution left perfectly colourless ; in most of the experiments , however , the sides of the glass were not gilded , all the revived gold remaining attached to the surface of the charcoal .
In two of these experiments , I made use of pieces of charcoal which had been previously boiled several hours in a large quantity of distilled water , and which were introduced wet , and hot , into the tube , and immediately covered by the solution , to prevent them from imbibing any air ; and , in different experiments , the solution was used of different degrees of strength .
I plainly perceived that the experiment succeeded best , that is to say , that the gold was soonest revived , in those cases in which the solution was most diluted : one of the experiments , however , and which succeeded perfectly , was made with the solution so much condensed , that it was nearly at the point at which it became disposed to crystallize .
* On examining , with a good microscope , the particles of revived gold which remained attached to the surface of the charcoal , after it had been dried , I found the'n to consist of an infinite number of small scales , separated from each other ; not very highly polished , but possessing the true metallic splendour , and a very deep and rich gold colour .
The gold which attached itself to the inside of the glass tube , was in the form of a ring , about -T of an inch wide , ( badly defined however below , ) and adhered to the glass with so much obstinacy , as not to be removed by rinsing out the tube a great number of times with water ; it had , as has already been observed , a very high polish , when seen by reflected light .
Those who enter into the spirit of these investigations , will easily imagine how impatient I must have been , after seeing the results of these experiments , to find out whether gold could be revived from this aqueous solution of its oxide by means of charcoal , without the assistance of I'ght , and merely by such a degree of equal heat as could be given to it in the dark .
To determine that important question , the following experiment was made .
:Experiment No. lo .
A cylindrical glass tube , _- .
of an inch in diameter , and 0o inche3 long , closed hermetically at its lower end , and containing a quantity of a diluted aqueous solution of the oxide of gold , mixed with charcoal in broken pieces , about the size of large peas , was put into a fit cylindrical tin case , which was nricely closed with a fit cover ; and the glass tube , with its contents , so shutup in the dark , was exposed two hours , in the temperature of 2100 of FAIHRENHEIT'S SCaNle .
On taking the glass tube out of its tin case , I found the solution perfectly colourless , and the revived gold adhering to the surface of the charcoal .
On repeating the experiment , and using the solution nearly saturateJ will the oxide , the result was precisely the same ; the solution being found perfectly colourless , and the revived gold adhering to the surface of the charcoal .
I own fairly , that the results of these experiments were quite contrary to my expectations , and that I am not able to reconcile them with my hypothesis , respecting the causes of the reduction of the oxide , in the foregoig sexperiments ; but , whatever may be the fate of this , or of any other hypothesis of Minle , I hope and trust that I never shall be so weak as to feel pain at the discovery of truth , however contrary it may be to my expectations ; and still less , to feel a secret wish to suppress experiments , merely because their results militate against my speculative opinions .
It is proper I should observe , that the charcoal usedin this last-mentioned experiment had been boiled two hours in distilled water , by which means its pores had been so completely filled with that fluid , that the pieces of it that were used were specifically heavier than water , and sunk in it , to the bottom of the containing vessel .
Having been so successful in my attempts to reduce the oxide of gold , by means of charcoal , in the moist way , I lost no time in making similar experiments with the oxide of silver .
Experiment No. i 1 .
A solution of fine silver , in strong nitrous acid , was evaporated to dryness , and the residuum redissolved in distilled water .
A portion of this solution , ( which was perfectly colourless , ) diluted with twice as much distilled water , was poured into a phial containing a number of small pieces of charcoal ; and the phial , being well closed with a new cork stoppie , was exposed to the action of the sun 's rays .
In less than an hour , small specks of revived silver began to make their appearance on the surface of the charcoal ; and , at the end of two hours , these specks became very numerous , and had increased so much in size , that they were distinctly visible to the naked eye , at the distance of more than three feet .
They were very white , and possessed the metallic splendour of silver in so high a degree , that when enlightened by the sun 's beams , their lustre was nearly equal to that of very small diamonds .
The phial , which was in the form of a pear , and about 1inch in diameter at its bulb , was very thin , and made of very fine colourless glass ; the aqueous solution was also perfectly transparent and colourless ; and , when the contents of the phial were illuminated by the direct rays of a bright sun , the contrast of the white colour of these little metallic spangles with the black charcoal to which they were fixed , and their extreme brilliancy , afforded a very beautiful and interesting sight .
As the air had been previously expelled from the charcoal , by boiling it in distilled water , it was specifically heavier than the aqueous solution of the metallic oxide , and consequently remained at the bottom of the bottle .
Experiment No. 12 .
A phial , as nearly as possible like that used in the last experiment , and containing the same quantity of diluted aqueous solution of nitrate of silver , and also of charcoal , was enclosed in a cylindrical tin box , and exposed one hour to the heat of boiling water , in an apparatus used for boiling potatoes in steam , for the table .
The result of this experiment was uncommonly striking .
The surface of the charcoal was covered with a most beautiful metallic vegetation ; small filaments of revived silver , resembling fine flatted silver wire , pushing out from its surface , in all directions !
Some of these metallic filaments were above one-tenth of an inch in length .
On -agitating the contents of the phial , they were easily detached from the , surface of the charcoal , to which they seemed to adhere but very slightly .
These experiments were repeated several times , and always with precisely the same results .
When the oxide of gold was reduced in this way , the revived metal appeared under the form of small scales , adhering firmly to the surface of the charcoal .
May not the difference of the forms under which gold and silver are revived from their oxides , in this process , be owing to the difference of the specific gravities of those metals ?
The following experiments which were first suggested by an accident , were made with a view to investigate still farther the causes of those effects which have been attributed to the supposed chemical properties of light .
Having accidentally put away two small phials , each containing a quantity of aqueous solution of the oxide of gold and sulphuric ether , in each of which the ether had extracted the gold completely from the solution , as was evident by the yellow colour of the solution having been transferred to the ether , and the solution being left colourless ; in one of the phials , which happened to stand in a window in which there was occasionally a strong light , ( though the direct rays of the sun never fell on it , ) I found , in about three weeks , that the oxide was almost entirely reduced ; the revived gold appearing in all its metallic splendour , in the form of a thin pellicle , swimming on the surface of the aqueous liquor in the phial , and the colour of the ether which reposed on it having become quite faint ; while no -visible change had been produced in the contents of the other phial , which had stood in a dark corner of the room .
As these appearances induced me to suspect , or rather strengthened the suspicions I had before conceived , that the separation of gold from ether , under its metallic form , when a solution of its oxide is mixed with that fluid , is always effected by a reduction of the oxide by means of light , I made the following experiment , with a view to the farther investigation of that matter .
Experiment No. 13 .
Into a small pear-like phial , of very fine transparent glass , I put equal quantities of an aqueous solution of the muriatic oxide of gold and sulphuric ether ; and the phial , which was about half filled , being closed with a good cork , well secured in its place , was exposed to the action of the direct rays of a bright sun .
A pellicle of revived gold , in all its metallic splendour , began almost immediately to be formed on the surface of the aqueous liquid , and soon covered it entirely ; and , at the end of two hours , the whole of the oxide was completely reduced , as was evident from the appearance of the ether , which became perfectly colourless .
On shaking the phial , ^the metallic pellicle which covered the surface of the aqueous liquid was broken into small pieces , which had exactly the appearance of leaf gold , possessing the true colour , and all the metallic brilliancy , of that metal On suffering the phial to stand quiet , the aqueous liquor and , the ether separated , and most of the broken pieces of the thin sheet of gold descended to the bottom of the phial : the remainder of them floated on the surface of the aqueous liquid ; and the ether , as well as the aqueous liquid , appeared to be perfectly transparent and colourless .
By the length of time which was required for the ether and the aqueous liquid to separate , I thought I could perceive that the ether had lost something of its fluidity ; but , as this was an event I expected , it is the more likely , on that account , that I was deceived , when I imagined I saw proofs of its having taken place .
On removing the cork , after the contents of the bottlel had been suffered to cool , there was no appearance of any consider-able quantity of air , or other permanently elastic fluid , having been either generated or absorbed , during the experiment .
Finding that the oxide of gold might be so completely and so expeditiously reduced , by means of ether , I conceived It might be possible to perform that chemical process , in the moist way , by means of essential oils ; and this conjecture proved to be well founded .
Experiment No. 14 .
Upon a quantity of a diluted aqueous solution of nitro-muriate of gold , in a small pear-like phial , about iinch in diameter at its bulb , was poured a small quantity of ethereal oil of turpentine , just as much as was sufficient to cover the aqueous solution to the height of 2of an inch ; and the phial , being well closed with a good cork , well secured , was exposed one hour to the heat of boiling water in a steam-vessel .
The gold was revived , appearing in the form of a splendid pellicle , of a bright gold colour , which floated on the surface of the aqueous liquid .
The oil of turpentine , which , at the beginning of the experiment , was as pale and colourless as pure water , had taken a bright yellow hue ; and the aqueous fluid , on which it reposed , had entirely lost its yellow colour .
On shaking the phial , its contents were intimately mixed ; but , on suffering it to stand quiet , the oil of turpentine soon 'separated from the aqueous liquid , retaining its bright yellows hue , and leaving the aqueous liquid colourless .
On shaking the phial , before it had been exposed to the heat , and mixing its contents , and then suffering it to stand quiet , the oil of turpentine , on taking its place at the top of the aqueous solution , was not found to have acquired any colour ; nor was the bright gold colour of the solution found to be at all impaired .
When sulphuric ether was used , instead of the oil of turpentine , the effect was in this respect very diffcrent .
To find out whether the oil of turpentine used in this experiment , and which had acquired a deep yellow colour , had lost that property by which it effected the reduction of the metallic oxide , I now poured an additional quantity of the aqueous so- ' lution of the oxide into the phial , and , shaking the phial , exposed it , with its contents , to the heat of boiling water .
After it had been exposed to this heat about two hours , I examined it , and found , that though a considerable quantity of gold had been revived , yet the aqueous liquid still retained a faint yellow colour .
The oil of turpentine had acquired a deeper and richer gold colour , approaching to orange .
To the contents of the:phial , I now added about half as much distilled water , and , mixing the whole by shaking , I exposed the phial again , during two hours , to the heat of boiling water- ; when the remainder of the oxide was reduced , and the-aqueous liquid left perfectly colourless .
On repeating this experiment with oil of turpentine , and varying it , by using a solution of the oxide of silver , ( an aqueous solution of nitrate of silver , ) instead of that of gold , the result was nearly the same : the metal was revived , and the oil of turpentine acquired a faint greenish-yellow colourl .
I also revived the oxides of gold and of silver with oil of olives , by a similar process , with the heat of boiling water .
The oil of olives used in these experiments lost its transparency , and became deeply coloured ; that used in the reduction of the oxide of silver , taking a very deep dirty brown colour , approaching to black ; and that employed in reducing the oxide of gold , being changed to a yellowish-brown , with a purple hue .
In the experiment with the oxide of silver , the inside of the phial , in the region where the oil reposed on the aqueous soll tion , r was beautifully silvered , the revived metal forming a narrow metallic ring , extending quite round the phial ; and , in both experiments , small detached pellicles of revived metal were visible in the oil , and adhered in several places to the inside of the phial , forming bright spots , in which the colour of the metal , and its , peculiar splendour , were perfectly conspicuous .
Experiment No. 5. .
As carbon is one of the constituent principles of spirit of wine , as well as of essentials oils and sulphuric ether , I thought it possible that I might succeed in the reduction of the oxide of gold , by mixing alcohol , with an aqueous solution of nitro-muriate of gold , and .
exposing the mixture , in a phial well closed , to the heat of boiling water ; but the experiment did not succeed .
Bypouring upon this mixture a small quantity of oil of olives , and exposing it again to the heat of boilin-g water , the gold was revived .
Is it not probable , that the reason why the oxiee was not reduced by alcohol , is the mobility of those elements , , which ought to act on each other , in order that the effect in question may be produced ?
I have no doubt but the oxide would be reduced , could the alcohol be made to rest on the surface of the aqueous solution , without mixing with it .
I wished to have been able to have collected and examined the elastic fluids , which probably were formed in most of the preceding experiments ; but my time was so much taken up with othermatters , that I had not leisure to pursue these investigations farther .
In order to see what effects would be produced by the heat generated at the surface of an opaque body , of a nature different from those hitherto used in the reduction of the metallic oxides , and one that is little disposed to form A chemical union with oxygen , ( magnesia a/ ba , ) when , being immersed in an aqueous solution of the oxide of gold , the rays of the sun were made to impinge on it , I contrived the following experiment .
Eaperiment No. i6 .
I took four small thin phials , A , B , C , and D , pf very fine glass , and , putting into each of them about five grains of dry magnesia alba , I filled the phial A , nearly full , with a saturated aqueous solution of the oxide of gold .
I filled the phial B , in like manner , with some of the same solution , diluted with an equal quantity of distilled water ; and the phials C and D were filled with the solution still farther diluted .
These phials , open or without stoppers , were exposed one whole day to the action of the direct rays of a bright sun , their contents being often well mixed together , during that time , by shaking .
The contents of all these phials changed colour , more or less , but they acquired very different hues .
The contents of the phial A became of a very deep rich gold colour , approaching to orange , the earthy sediment being throughout of the same tint .
The contents of the phial B , which were at first of a light straw colour , first changed to a light green , and then to a greenish blue .
The phial having been suffered to stand quiet several days , in an uninhabited room , in a retired part of the house , the solution became nearly colourless , and the sediment was found to be of a dirty olive colour .
The colour of the contQnts of the phials C and D was changed nearly in the same manner ; and , having been suffered to stand quiet two or three days , to settle , the solution was found to be quite colourless , and the sediment to be deeply coloured .
There 30 2 was , however , a very remarkable difference in the hues of the two phials ; that of the phial C being of a light greenish-blue ; while that in the phial D was indigo , and of so deep a tint , that it might easily have been taken for black .
These appearances were certainly very striking , and well calculated to excite my curiosity ; but I am so much engaged in public business , that it is not at present in my power to .
pursue these inquiries farther .
I wish that what I have done may induce others , who have more time to spare , to devote some portion of their leisure to these interesting investigations. .

