VI .
An Analysis of the earthy Substance from New South Wales , called Sydneia or Terra Australis .
By Charles Hatchett , Esq. F. R. S. Read February 8 , 1798 , ?
.1 THE late ingenious JOSIAH WEDGWOOD , Esq. F. R. S. published , in the Philosophical Transactions for the year i 790 , an account of some analytical experiments on a mineral substance from Sydney Cove , in New South Wales.* This substance , Mr. WEDGWOOD describes to be composed of a fine white sand , a soft white earth , some colourless micaceous particles , and also some which were black , resembling black mica , or black lead .
Nitric acid did not appear to act on any part of this earthy substance ; and even a portion on which sulphuric acid had been boiled to dryness , afforded afterwards , when edulcorated with water , only a few flocculi , which Mr. WEDGWOOD conceived to be aluminous earth .
The muriatic acid , during digestion , seemed to act as little as the two preceding acids ; but , upon water being poured in , to wash out the remaining portion , the liquor instantly became white as milk , with a fine white curdy substance intermixed ; the concentrated acid having , in the opinion of the author , extracted something which the simple dilution with water precipitated .
The remaining part was repeatedly digested with muriatic acid , and treated with water , as before , till the milky appearance was no longer produced .
The properties of this white precipitate , Mr. WEDGWOOD states to be as follows .
Lst .
It is only soluble in boiling concentrated muriatic acid .
2dly .
It is precipitated by water , in the form of a white earth ; which may again be dissolved by boiling muriatic acid .
3dly .
When nitric acid is mixed with the muriatic solution of this earth , there is no appearance of a precipitate ; not even when water is added , provided that the nitric acid exceeds , or nearly approaches , the quantity of muriatic acid .
4thly .
The earth is precipitated by the alkalies .
5thly .
The muriatic solution does not crystallize by evaporation ; but becomes a butyraceous mass , which soon liquefies on exposure to the air .
6thly .
The butyraceous mass is not corrosive to the taste ; and is even less pungent than the combination of calcareous earth with the same acid .
7thly .
Heat approaching to ignition disengages the acid from the butyraceous mass , in white fumes , and a white substance remains .
8thly .
The white precipitated earth is fusibleper se , in from 142 ' to I,56 of Mr. NWEDGWOOD 's thermometer , and it is thus distinguished from all the other primitive earths .
And , 9thly .
This precipitate cannot be reduced to a-metallic state , when exposed to heat with inflammable substances .
From these properties , Mr. WEDGWOOD says , that although he cannot absolutely determine whether this substance belongs to the class of earths , or that of metallic substances , yet he is inclined to refer it to the former .
Professor BLUMENBACH , of Gbttingen , in his Manual of Natural History , published il 1791 , also mentions that he had examined a portion of this earthy substance , by means of muriatic acid , after the manner of Mr. WEDGWOOD , and that he had obtained a slight precipitate by the addition of weater .
* In consequence of these experiments , the mineralogists throughout Europe admitted the white precipitated substance to be a primitive earth ; and we accordingly find , in all the systematical works on mineralogy published since the abovementioned period , that it is arranged as a distinct genus , under the names of Sydnii7 , Aut"rala , Terra Australis , and Austral Sand .
The extreme scarcity of this substance prevented the chemists in general from examining more minutely into the nature of this new primitive earth , till Mr. KLAPROTH , in the second volume of his Additions Lo the Chemical Knowledgeof Mineral Bodies , gave to the public a memoir entitled A Chemical Examination of the Austral Sand . ?
In this memoir , Mr. KLAPROTHsays , that he had received from Mr. HAIDINGER , of Vienna , two samples of this substance ; one of which had a considerable qu , ,antity of black shinling particles intermixed with it , which , although regarded by many as graphite or plumbago , he was inclined to believe to be Elseng-limmer or micaceous iron ore .
The other contained much less of these black or dark grey ' Handbucb der Nattrgescbicbte , p. 567 and 568 .
t Beitrage sir Cbeinischen Kenntniss der Mineralkbrper.-Zweiter Band , p. 66 .
particles , and , as he considered it to be more pure than the former , he subjected it to the following experiments , J. It was digested , at three different times withconcentrated muriatic acid , in a boiling heat , and the acid was afterwards filtrated through paper .
The solution was then mixed by degrees with pure water , which did not however produce any precipiew tate , even when warmed .
Carbonate of potash caused some flocculi to fall , which , edulcorated and dried , weighed 3.25 grains .
This precipitate was dissolved in diluted sulphuric acid , and left a small portion of siliceous earth ; after which the solution , by evaporation , afforded crystals of alum .
2 .
The residuum .
of the muriatic solution was mixed with three times the weight of potash , and exposed to a red heat .
Muriatic acid was then poured on the mass , and the insoluble gelatinous residuum was edulcorated on a filter ; and , after a red heat , weighed 19.50 grains , which proved to be siliceous earth .
3 .
The muriatic solution , with prussiate of potash , afforded a blue precipitate ; the ferruginous part of which was about one quarter of a grain .
4 .
The solution was then saturated with carbonate of pot .
ash , and some alumine was precipitated ; which , after a red heat , weighed 8.5o grains , and with sulphuric acid formed alum .
Siliceous earth , alumine , and iron , appeared.therefore to be the only ingredients of this substance ; but , as Mr. KLAPROTH had no more than thirty grains to examine , he could not extend his experiments .
From those above related , he is of opinion that the existence of this primitive earth may be much doubted , and that this doubt can only -be removed in the course of time , by other analyses , Mr. KLAPROTH concludes his memoir by saying , that the substance examined by him was undoubtedly the genuine austral sand , as Mr. IAIDINGER had received it from Sir JOSEPH BANKS , when he was in London .
Mr. NICHOLSON , however , in the 9th Number of his Journal of Natural Philosophy , &amp;c. ( p. 410a .
) published on the ist of December , 1797 , questions much , whether the substance examined by Mr. KLAPROTH was the same as that examined by Mr. WEDGWOOD ; and , after having contrasted their experiments , says , " , hence it seems fair to conclude that the two " minerals were not the same , however this may have hap"pened ; and that the existence of the new fusible earth of " WEDGWOQD stands on the same evidence as before , namely , " his experiments , which have not yet been repeated , that I " know of .
" Some of Mr. NICHOLSON'S objections to the .
experiments of Mr. KLAPROTH , being founded principally on some difference in the external characters of the substance examined by him , and the one examined by Mr. WEDGWOOD , are such as very naturally occur ; but the following pages will , I believe , prove that Mr. KLAPROTH 's experiments were made on that which might be justly regarded as the Sydneia or austral sand .
In 1796 , the Right Hon. Sir JOSEPH BANKS , P. R. S. favoured me with a specimen of the Sydneia , which had been lately brought to England ; a portion of this I soon after examined , in a cursory manner , by muriatic acid , but did not obtain any .
precipitate when water was added to the filtrated solution .
Upon mentioning this circumstance , and expressing a desire to examine this substance with more accuracy , Sir JOSEPH BANKS , with his usual readiness to promote every scientific inquiry , not only permitted me to take specimens from different -parts of the box which contained the earth already mend .
tioned , but ( that every doubt might be obviated ) gave me about 0oo grains which remained of the identical substance examined by Mr. WEDGWOOD .
Upon these the following experiments were made ; and , to distinguish them , I shall call the first , No. i , and that examined by Mr. WEDGWOOD , No. g ? .
2 .
Analysis of the Sydneia , No. i. The Sydneia , No. i , is in masses and lumps , of a pale greyish white , intermixed with a few particles of white mica , and also occasionally with some which are of a dark grey , resembling graphite or plumbago .
It easily crumbles between the fingers , to a powder nearly impalpable , which has rather an unctuous feel .
Small fragments of vegetable matter are also commonly found intermixed with it ; and the general aspect is that of an earthy substance which has been deposited by water .
EXPERIMENT 1 .
400 Grains were put into a glass mattress , and one quart of distilled water being added , the whole was boiled to one fourth .
The liquor was then filtrated , and a portion being examined by the re-agents commonly used , afforded no trace of matter Q2o in solution .
The remainder was then evaporated , without leaving any residuum .
EXPERIMENT 2 .
About 200 grains of the earth , rubbed toga fine powder , ,were put into a glass retort , into which I poured three ounces of concentrated pure muriatic acid. .
The retort was placed in sand , and the acid was distilled , till the matter in the retort remained dry .
Two ounces of muriatic .
acid were again poured on it , and distilled as before , till only one fourth-remained .
The whole was then put into a mattress , which was placed in an inclined position , so that when the earth had subsided , the liquor might be decanted , without disturbing the sediment .
When it had remained thus for 12 hours , the acid was carefully poured into a glass vessel ; but , as I observed that it was not so perfectly transparent as before it had been thus employed , I suffered it to-remain 24 hours , but did not perceive any sediment .
Half of this liquor was diluted with about twelve parts of distilled water , and , after a few hours , a very small quantity of a white earth subsided .
This however did not appear to me to be a precipitate caused by a change in the chemical affinities , but rather an earthy matter which had been suspended in the concentrated acid , and afterwards deposited , when the liquor was rendered less dense by the addition of water .
To ascertain this , I poured the remaining portion of the concentrated liquor on a filter of four folds : it passed perfectly transparent , and , although diluted with twenty-four parts of water , it remained unchanged , and as pellucid as before .
I now filtrated the former portion , and added it to that already mentioned .
It was then evaporated to dryness , and left a pale brownish mass , which was dissolved again , by digestion , in the smallest possible quantity of muriatic acid .
Water was added , in a very large proportion , to this solution , without producing any effect ; I then , by prussiate of potash , precipitated a quantity of iron , which was separated by a filter .
The .
clear solution was then saturated with lixivium of carbonate of potash , and a white precipitate wasproduced , which was , collected and edulcorated .
This , when digested with diliuted sulphuric acid , was dissolved ; and the superfluous acid being driven off by heat , boiling water was poured on the residuum , and completely dissolved it .
To this solution some drops of lixivium of potash were added , and , by repeated evaporations , the whole formed crystals of alum .
From the above experiment it appeared , that the muriatic acid had only dissolved some alumine and iron ; but , in order to satisfy myself more completely in respect to the component parts of this substance , I made the following analysis .
Analysis .
A. 400 grains were put into a glass retort , which was then made red-hot during half an hour .
Some water came over , and the earth afterwards weighed 380.80 grains , so that the loss amounted to 19.2o grains .
The greater part of this loss was , occasioned by the dissipation of the water imbibed by the earth ; to which must be added , the loss of weight caused by the combustion of a small portion of vegetable matter .
B. The 38o.8o grains were rubbed to a fine powder , and being put into a glass retort , 1470 grains of pure concentrated sulphuric acid were added .
The.retort was then placed in a small reverberatory , and the fire was gradually increased , till the acid was distilled over it was then poured back on the matter in the retort , and distilled as before , till a mass nearly dry remained .
On this , boiling distilled water was repeatedly poured , until it no longer changed the colour of litmus paper , and was den void of taste .
The undissolved portion was then dried , and made red-hot ; after which it weighed 281 grains .
C. I now mixed the 281 grains with 3oo grains of dry carbonate of potash , and exposed the mixture to a strong red heat , in a silver crucible , during four hours .
The mass was loose , and of a greyish white : it was softened with water , and , being put into a retort , sulphuric acid was added to a considerable excess .
The whole was then distilled to dryness , and , when a sufficient quantity of boiling water had been added , it was poured on a filter , and the residuum was xvell washed ; it was then made red-hot , and afterwards weighed 274.75 grains .
D. The solutions of B and C were added together , and were much reduced by evaporation .
Pure ammoniac was then employed to saturate the acid , and a copious loose precipitate , of a pale yellowish colour was produced ; which , collected , edulcorated , and made red-hot , weighed o03.70 grains .
E. The filtrated liquor of D was again evaporated , and carbonate of potash being added , a slight precipitation of earthy matter took place ; which , by the test of sulphuric acid , proved to be some alumine which had not been precipitated in the former experiment : this weighed 1.20 grain , F. The 1o3.70 grains of D were completely dissolved when digested with nitric acid , excepting a small residuum of -siliceous earth , which weighed to ?
go grain .
Go The nitric solution was evaporated to dryness , and a second portion of the same acid wasadded , and in like manner evaporated .
The residuum was then made red-hot , and digested with diluted nitric acid , which left a considerable portion of red oxide of iron .
The solution was again evaporated , and the residuum , being treated as before , again deposited some oxide of iron , much less in quantity than the former .
The whole of the oxide was then heated with wax in a porcelain crucible , was taken up by a magnet , and weighed 26.50 grains .
H , The nitric solution of G was saturated with ammoniac , and a loose white precipitate was formed ; which , edulcorated and made red-hot , weighed 76 grains .
I. These 76 grains were dissolved when digested with diluted sulphuric acid ; and , when the excess of acid had been expelled by heat , the saline mass was dissolved in boiling water .
, To this solution I added some lixivium of potash , and , by gradual and repeated evaporations , obtained the whole in regular octoedral crystals of alum .
K. The 274.75 grains of C now alone remained to be exam mined .
They appeared to consist of siliceous earth , mixed with the dark grey shining particles already mentioned ; but , as I shall describe , in the following experiments , the process by which these were separated , I shall now only say that they amounted to 7.50 grains .
L. The earth with which the abovementioned particles were mixed weighed 267.25 grains .
This earth was white , and arid to the touch : when melted with two parts of soda , it formed a colourless glass ; and , with four parts of the same it dissolved in water , and formed a liquor silicum : it was therefore pure Siliceous earth or silica , The substance here examined was composed therefore of the following ingredients .
grains .
Pure siliceous earth or silica { F gan090 L. 267.25 , Alumine _ fE 1.20 .
: .
l~~IH .
X76 Oxide of iron G. 26.5o Dark grey particles K. 7.50 Water and vegetable matter .
A. 19.20 398.55 The foregoing analysis was repeated several times , and always with similar results ; excepting , that as .
I had taken the specimens from different parts of a large quantity , I found that the proportions of the ingredients were not constantly the same : that of the siliceous earth , for example , was sometimes greater , and the alumine and iron proportionably less .
Some specimens were also nearly or totally destitute of the dark grey shining particles .
; in short , every circumstance was such as might be expected from a mixed substance , which , from the nature of its formation , cannot have the ingredients in any fixed proportion.* As this substance agreed in its general characters , for the greater part , with that described by Mr. WEDGWOOD , and as it was indisputably brought from the same place , there appeared every reason to believe that the nature of both was the same ; but , to obviate as much as possible any doubt or objection , I determined to repeat the experiments , and the analysis , on that portion which remained of the identical substance examined by Mr. WEDGWOOD , and which from that period had been reserved by Sir JOSEPH BANKS , who kindly favoured me with it for this purpose .
3 .
Analysis of the Sydneia , No. 2 .
This substance , as has already been mentioned , consists of a white transparent quartzose sand , a soft opaque white earth , some particles of white mica , and a quantity of dark lead.-grey particles , which have a metallic lustre .
The Sydneia , No. 2 , appears chiefly to differ from No. 1 , by being more arenaceous , and by a larger proportion of the dark grey particles .
Many experiments , similar to those made on No. 1 , already described , were made on this substance , with pure concentrated muriatic acid ; but , as none of these afforded any appearance of a precipitate by the means of water , I do not think it necessary to enter into a circumstantial account of them , and shall proceed therefore to the analysis .
At loo grains were exposed to a red heat , in a glass retort , and , after half an hour , were found to have lost in weight 2.20 grains .
B. The 97.80 grains which remained were mixed with 3oo grains of dry carbonate of potash , and the mixture was exposed to a strong red heat , in a crucible of silver , during three hours .
When cold , the mass was softened with water , and was put into a glass mattress .
I then added three ounces of pure con centratedmuriatic acid , and digested it for two hours in a strong sand heat .
Boiling water was then added , : and the whole being poured on a filter , the residuum was edulcorated , dried , and made red-hot ; it then weighed 85.50 grains .
C. The filtrated solution was evaporated t one fourth , and pure ammoniac being added , a precipitate was formed , which , after a red heat , weighed lo.70 grains .
D. One ounce of muriatic acid was poured on the 1o.70 grains , in a mattress , which was then heated .
The whole of the 10.70 grains was dissolved , excepting a small portion of siliceous earth , which weighed 0.3o0 grain .
E. The muriatic solution was then reduced by evaporation .
, to about one fourth ; to which I added a large quantity of distilled water , which did not however produce any change .
I then gradually added a solution of pure crystallized prussiate of potash , and heated the liquor till the whole of the iron was precipitated ; after which , ammonic precipitated a loose white earth , which , edulcorated and made red-hot , weighed 7.20 grains .
The iron precipitated by the prussiate may therefore be estimated at 3.20 grains .
F. The 7.20 grains of the white earth were digested with , sulphuric acid , and , after the excess of acid had been expelled by heat , boiling water was poured on the saline residuum. .
The solution was then gradually evaporated , with the addition of a small portion of lixivium of potash , .
and afforded crystals .
of alum , without a. trace of any other substanceG .
I now proceeded to examine the 8 grains of B. .
These appeared .
to consist of siliceous earth , or fine particles of quartz , mingled-with a. considerable quantity of thedark grey shining particles .
Mr. WEDGWOOD ; was of opinion that these were a peculiar species of plumbago or graphite .
Professor BLUMENBACH , on the contrary , regards them as molybdana : and Mr. KLAPROTH believes them to be eisenglimnner or micaceous iron ore .
When rubbed between the fingers , they leave a dark grey stain , and the feel is unctuous , like that of plumbago , or moo lybdaena : the traces which they make on paper also resemble those of the abovementioned substances , but the lustre of the particles approaches nearer to that of molybdana .
In order therefore to determine whether or not they consisted totally or partially of molybdana , I put the 85.50 grains into a small glass retort , and added two ounces of concentrated nitric acid .
The retort was then placed in a sand heat , and the distillation was continued , till the matter remained dry .
The acid was then poured back into the retort , and distilled as before ; but I did not observe that the grey particles had suffered any change , nor were nitrous fumes produced , as when molybdnaa is thus treated .
To be more certain , however , I digested pure ammoniac on the residuum ; and , having decanted it into a mattress , I evaporated it to dryness , without perceiving any vestige of oxide of molybdxana , or indeed of any other substance .
It was evident therefore that molybdana was not present ; and , as the general external characters and properties corresponded ; with those of plumbago , I was inclined to believe that these were particles of that substance , and not micaceous iron , as Mr. KLAPROTHL imagined .
To determine this , the following experiment was made .
H. 200 grains of pure nitre in powder were mixed with the.85.5o grains , and the mixture was gradually projected into a crucible , made strongly red-hot .
Al feeble detonation took place at each projection ; and , after a quarter of an hour had elapsed , the crucible was removed .
When cold , the mass was porous and white , without any appearance of the dark grey particles .
Boiling water was poured on it , and the whole being put into a mattress , one ounce of nuriatic acid was added , and digested with it in a sand heat .
By evaporation it became gelatinous : it was then emptied on a filter , and , being well washed , dried , and made red-hot , weighed 75.25 grains .
The appearance of this was that of a white earth , arid to the touch .
When melted with two parts of soda , a colourless glass was formed ; and , with four parts of the same , it was soluble in water , and produced liquor silicum ; it was therefore pure siliceous earth .
I. The filtrated liquor was saturated with ammoniac , and , upon -being heated- , a few brownish flocculi were precipitated , which , when collected and dried , weighed 040 grain .
This precipitatewas , dissolved in muriatic acid , and was again precipitated by prulssiate of potash , in the state of Prussian blue .
The liquor from which the flocculi of iron had been separated was then examined , by adding carbonate of potash , and lastly , by being evaporated to dryness ; but it no longer afforded any earthy ormetallic substance : so that , by the process of detonation with nitre4 the 85.5o grains afforded 75.25 grains of pure siliceous earth , with 0.40 grain of iron ; and , as the dark grey substance-was destroyed , excepting the 0.40 grain of iron abovemen~tioned , and as 985 grains of the original weight of 85 .
grainswere dissipated , there can be no doubt but that this substance , amounting to 10.25 grains , was carburetof iron orplumbago ; especially as some experiments whichI purposely made , op that from Keswick in Cumberland , were attended with similar results .
It is also evident , that these particles could not be eisenglimmer or micaceous iron , as nitre has little or no effect on that substance , when projected into a heated crucible .
In a subsequent experiment on the same , the crucible was removed immediately after the last projection , and 1 then observed that an effervescence , with a disengagement of carbonic acid , took place , upon the addition of the muriatic acid , as is usual when pure plumbago is decomposed by nitre , and that less of the gelatinous matter was formed by evaporation .
The cause of this difference was evidently the duration of the red heat ; for , in the first ; instance , the alkali developed by the decomposition of the nitre had time to unite with the siliceous earth , so as , whendissolved , to form liquor silicum ; but , in the second experiment , a portion of alkali remained combined with the carbonic acid , produced by the carbon of the decomposed plumbago .
The produce of 1oo grains by this : analysis was , grains .
Silica _ .
D. 0.30 H. 75.25 Alumine F. 7.20 Oxide of iron E. 3.20 Graphite or plumbago A I. 1Q.25 Water a A. ' 2.20 98.40 Mr. WEDGWOOD says , that sulphur'ic acid cannot dissolve the precipitated earth , 'andhas but little effect I on themixed Substance substance , even when distilled to dryness ; but , from ; the pre. .
ceding .
experiments , I had reason to believe that the aluminous earth and iron would be separated by reiterated distillation ; I therefore repeated the analysis in the following manner .
Second Analysis of the -Sydneia , No..A.I oo grains of the earth were put into a glass retort , upon which 4oo grains of pure concentrated sulphuric acid were poured .
The retort was placed in a small reverberatory , and the fire was continued till a dry mass remained .
400 grains of the acid were again poured in , and distilled as before .
Upon the dry mass , boiling water was poured , and the whole was then emptied on a filter , and edulcorated .
The residuum , after a red heat , weighed 87.75 grains , and consisted of siliceous earth , mixed with some mica , and with particles of plumbago B. -The filtrated solution , , by ammoniac , afforded a precipi.tate , which weighed 9.5o grains ; and , being examined , as in the former experiment , yielded 6.5o grains of alumine , and 3 grains of oxide of iron .
The plumbago was separated from the siliceous matter , in the manner already described , and amounted to about io grains .
By this analysis I obtained , grains .
Silica and mica 77.75 Alumine 6.o Oxide of iron 3 Plumbago 10 97.25 It appears therefore that the Sydneian earth , when treated with sulphuric acid , is capable of being for the greater part decomposed ; and -Mr .
WEDGWOODprobably did not succeed , because his process was in some respect differentr that the distillation was not sufficiently repeated , have not thought it necessary to bemore circumstantial in the account of this second analysis , as the operations were similar to those of the former .
These experiments fprove that the earthy substance called Sydniaor terra australis , consists of siliceous earth , alumine , oxide of Iron , and black lead or graphite- .
The presence of the latter appears to beaccidental , and it probably was mixed with the other substances at the time when they were transported , and deposited , by means of water ; for this appears evidently to have been the case , from the general characters of this mixed earthy substance. .
The quartz and mica , which are so visible , indicate a graniti .
origin ; and the softwhite earth has probably been formed by a decomposition of feldt spar , such as is to be seen inR many places , and particularly at St. Stephen 's in Cornwall The gra. .
nitic sand which covers the borders of the Mer de Glace , at Chamouni , in Savoy , also much resembles the terra australisi , excepting that the feldt spar is not in a stateof decomposition : in short , the general aspect , and the analysis , concur toprove , .
that the Sydneia has been formed by the disintegration arid de composition of granite , or gnezss .
Mr. WEDGwooD 's experiments -are so circumstantial , that had I only examined the earth last brought to England , I should have supposed , with -Mr .
NICHOLSON , that I had operated on a different substance ; but , as I hadi an opportunity to examine , , by analysis , a portion of the same earth on which Mr. WEDGOWOOD made his experiments , and -as I received it from Sir JOSEPH BANKS , the same gentleman who had furnished Mr. WEDGWOOD with it , no suspicion can be entertained about its identity .
Some of the experiments which I have related , and which prove that some of the finer earthy particles remained suspended in the concentrated muriatic acid , and were precipitated when the acid was diluted with water , appear in some measure to account for the mistake which has been made , in supposing that a primitive earth , before unknown , was present ; but this alone will not account for many of the other properties mentioned by Mr. WEDGWOOD , such as , ist .
The repeated and exclusive solubility in the muriatic acid , and subsequent precipitation by water .
2dly .
The butyraceous mass which was formed by evaporation .
And , ?
dly .
The degree of fusibility of the precipitated earth .
These indeed I can-by no means explain , but by supposing that the acids used by Mr. WEDGWOOD were impure .
This supposition appears to be corroborated by a passage in Mr. WEDGWOOD'S paper , where he says , " ohere the Prussian lixi"vium , in whatever quantity it was added , occasioned no pre " cipitation at all , ( only the usual bluishness arising from the " iron always found in the common acids.")* Now if ( as it seems from this expression ) Mr. WEDGWOOD employed the common acids of the shops , without having previously examined and purified them , all certainty of analysis must fall , as the impurity of such acids is well known to every practical chemist ; but , whether this was the cause , or not , of the effects described by Mr. WEDGWOOD , I do not hesitate to assert , that the mineral which has been examined does not contain any primitive earth , or substance possessing the properties ascribed to it , and consequently , that the Sydneian genus , in future , must be omitted in the mineral system .

