Ill. On the Discovery of four additional Satellites of the Georgium Sidus .
The retrograde Motion of its old Satellites announced ; and the Cause of their Disappearance at certain Distances from the Planet explained .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F. R. S. Read December 14 , 1797 , HAVING been lately much engaged in improving my tables for calculating the places of the Georgian satellites , I found it necessary to recompute all my observations of them .
In looking over the whole series , from the -year of the first discovery of the satellites in 1787 to the present time , I found these observations so extensive , especially with regard to a miscellaneous branch of them , that I resolved to make this latter .
part the subject of a strict examination .
The observations I allude to relate to the discovery of four additional satellites : to surmises of a large and a small ring , at rectangles to each other : to the light and size-of the satellites : and to their disappearance at certain distances from the planet .
In this undertaking , I was much assisted by a set of short and easy theorems I had laid down for calculating all the particulars respecting the motions of satellites ; such as , finding the longitude of the satellite from the angle of position , or the position from the longitude : the inclination of the orbit from the angle of position and longitude : the apogee : the greatest elongation ; and other particulars .
Having moreover calculated tables for reduction : for the position of the point of greatest elongation ; and for the distance of the apogee,. .
or opening of the ellipsis ' ; and also contrived an expeditious application of the globe for checking computations of this sort , I found many former intricacies vanish .
By the help of these tables and theorems , I could examine the miscellaneous -observations relating to additional satellites , on a supposition that their orbits were in , the same plane with the two .
already known , and .
that the. .
direction of their motion was .
also the same with that of the latter .
And here I take an opportunity to announce , that the motion.of the Georgian .
satellites is retrograde .
This seems to be a remarkable instance of the great variety that takes place among the movements of the heavenly bodies .
Hitherto , all .
the planets and satellites of the solar-system have been found to direct their course according to the order of the signs : even the diurnal or rotatory motions , not only of the primary planets , but also of the sun , and six of their secondala ries or satellites , now are known to follow the same direction ; l but here we.have two .
considerable celestial bodies completing their revolutions in a retrograde order .
I return , to the examination of the miscellaneous observations , , , the result of which .
has been of considerable importance , and will be contained in this paper .
The existence of four additional satellites of our new planet will be proved .
The obser-v vations which tend to ascertain the existence .
of rings not appearing to be satisfactorily supported , it will be proper that surmises of them should either be given up , as ill founded , or at least reserved till superior instruments can be provided , to throw more light upon the subject .
A remarkable phenomenon , of the vanishing of the satellites , will be shown to take place , and its cause animadverted upon .
I shall now , in the first place , relate the observations on which these conclusions must rest for support , and afterwards join some short arguments , to show that my results are fairly deduced from them .
For the sake of perspicuity , I shall arrange the observations under three differentl heads ; and begin with those which relate to the discovery of additional satellites .
A great number of observations on supposed satellites , that were afterwards found to be stars , or of which it could not be ascertained whether they were stars or satellites , for want of clear weather , will only be related .
For , to -enter into the particular manner of recording these supposed satellites , or to give the figures which were delineated to point them out , would take up too much time , and be of no considerable service to our present argument .
It ought however to be mentioned , that nearly the same precaution was taken with all the related observations as , it will be found , was used in those that are given in the words of the journals that contain them .
The former will be distinguished under the head Reports , the latter under that of Observations .
Investigation of additional Satellites .
Reports .
Feb. 6 , 1782 .
A very faint star was pointed out as probably a satellite , but Feb. 7 and 8 was found remaining in its former situation .
March 4 , 1783 .
A satellite was suspected , but March 8 was found to be a star .
-was delineated , but the 6th it was seen remaining in its former place .
Nov. 19 , 1783 .
A supposed satellite was marked down , , but no opportunity lcould be had to account for it afterwards .
Nov. 6 , 1784 .
Supposed 1stand 2d satellites were pointed out , but not accounted for afterwards.* Many other fruitless endeavours for the discoveryof satellites weremade but , finding my instrument , in the NEWTONIAN form , not adequate to the undertaking , the pursuit was partly relinquished .
The additional light/ however which I gained by introducing the Front-view in my telescope , soon after gave me an opportunity of resuming it with more success .
Jan. 11 , 1787 .
; Three supposed satellites were observed : a first , a second , and a third .
Jan. 12 , the 1st and 2d were gone from the places in which I had marked them , but the 3d was remaining , and therefore was a fixed star .
* Jan. 14 .
A supposed 3d satellite was delineated , but on the 17th it was found to be a star .
Jan. 17 .
Supposed 3d , 4th , and lth satellites were marked , but were found remaining in their former places on the i 8th .
Jan. 24 Supposed 3d and 4th satellites were noted , but the weather proving bad on the succeeding nights , till February 4 , they were lost in uncertainty .
Feb. 4 .
A 3d satellite was marked , but not being afterwards accounted for remains lost .
Feb. 7 .
A supposed 3d satellite was proved to be a star the 9th .
Feb. lo .
Supposed 3d and 4th satellites have not been afterwards accounted for .
Feb. 13 .
Supposed-3d , 4th , and 5th satellites proved stars the 16th , Feb. P6 .
A 3d satellite proved a star the 17th .
Feb. 19 .
Supposed 3d and 4th satellites were proved to be stars the same evening , by being left in their places , while the planet was moving on .
Feb. 22 .
The supposed 3d and 4th of the i9th were seen remaining in their former places ; and new dd , 4th , and 5th satellites were marked ; but these were lost through bad weather , which lasted till March 4 .
March 5 .
A supposed 3d satellite proved to be a star the 7th .
March 7 .
The position of a 3d was taken , and a 4th also marked ; but March 8 they were both proved to be fixed stars .
October go .
A very small star was seen near the planet , but lost , for want of opportunity to account for it .
March iq , 1789 .
The positions of 3d and 4th satellites were taken but the i4th they were found to be stars .
March i6 .
Supposed Ad and 4th satellites were well laid down , but March 20 were found to be stars .
March 26 .
The places of supposed Rd and 4thsatellites were ascertained , but no opportunity could be had of deciding whether they were stars or satellites .
Dec. 15 .
A supposed 3d satellite was accurately delineated , but proved to be a star the 16th .
Observations .
" Jan. iS , 1790 .
6h 1 ' .
*A supposed Id satellite is about " 2 diameters of the planet following ; excessively faint , and only seen by glimpses .
" 7h 57 ' .
I cannot , perceive the 3d .
" Reports .
Jan. i8 , 1790 .
A supposed 4th satellite was described , but was found to be a star the i9th .
Jan. 20 .
A 3d satellite was perceived , and its angleof position ascertained but was afterwards lost , for want of opportunity to examine its place again .
Observations .
" Feb. 9 , 1790 .
6h 28 ' .
There is a supposed 3d satellite , in a " line with the planet and the 2d satellite .
" so 6h 40 ' .
Configuration of the Georgian planet and satel"lites .
" See Tab. II .
fig. i. tc Clouds prevent further observations .
" " c Feb. ii .
The supposed 3d satellite of the 9th of February " I believe is wanting ; at least I cannot see it , though the wea " there is very clear , but windy .
" " Feb. -12 .
The supposed 3d satellite of the 9th is not in the place where I saw it that night .
" Reports .
Feb. ii , 1790 .
Supposed 3d and 4th satellites were laid down , but on the 12th they were both found remaining in their former places .
Feb. 16 .
A 3d satellite was delin eated , but on the 17th it proved to be a star .
March a. Supposed 3d and 4th satellites were laid down .
, but on the 8th were seen remaining in their places .
Feb. 4 , 1791 .
A 3d satellite was marked , but has not been accounted for afterwards .
Feb. a. Supposed 3d , 4th , and 5th satellites were delineated , but no opportunity could afterwards be found to ascertain their existence .
March a. Supposed 3d , 4th , and 5th satellites were put down .
They could not be seen March 6 , but were proved to be small stars the 7th .
: Feb. 12 , 1792 .
A third satellite was delineated , but was left behind by the planet the same evening , and also seen in its former place the next night .
Feb. 13 .
A 3d satellite was put down , but proved to be a star the 14th .
Feb. 20 .
The position of a 3d satellite was taken , but 4 hours after was found to be left behind by the planet .
It was also seen in its former place Feb. 21 .
Feb. 26 .
A 3d satellite , between the planet and 2d , was ob-e served which , 3h 7 afterwards , was thought to be left behind , -but was so faint as hardly to be perceivable .
A fourth was also put down .
Neither of them have been accounted for afterwards .
March 8 , 193 .
The position of a supposed 3d satellite was taken , but the next day it was found to be a star .
March 9 .
A supposed 3d satellite was observed , at 5 or 6 times the distance of the ist , but was not accounted for afterwards .
March 14 .
Supposed 3d and 4th satellites were observed , but no opportunity could be had afterwards to see them again .
" Feb. 25 1794 .
With 320 , there is a small star a , fig. about i , degrees north preceding the planet ; and another b , " about 3o degrees-north preceding : also one c , directly pre"ceding .
There is a very small fourth star d , making a trape"zium with the other three ; and two more of , preceding this 4th star , are in a line with it .
" " Feb. 26 .
The , stars , in figure 2 , markedfe d a , are in a line .
" cThere is a star g , at rectangles tofe d a : the perpendicular " c falls upon d : it is towards the south .
There is also a star h , " north off d a ; but it is too faint to admit of a determination " of its place : I can only see it now and then by imperfect " glimpses .
" " Feb. 28 .
6h 40 ' .
The stars fe da of the 26th are in their cc places .
c is in the place where I have marked it .
The star X"g is in the place where I marked it .
I see also the very small star h. ' c 6h so ' .
There is a very small star k , but not so small as h , c " very near to , and north followingf , which I did not see on " c the .
26th .
It is not quite half way between f and e , but " nearer to f than to e. It makes an obtuse triangle with f " and e. " 9h 43t .
The motion of the planet this evening , since the " first observation , is very visible .
' CC 10h 7 ' .
I cannot perceive the star 4 .
The weather is not " so clear as it was .
" CC 10h 211 .
I cannot perceive the star k in the place where it was 6h so5 .
" " March 4 , 1794 .
Power 320 6h 46 ' .
The stars abed efg " of Feb. 28 , fig. A. are in their places , but I cannot see the small star k. The evening is not very clear .
" " o9h sl ' .
I cannot see the star k. " s0 oh s'* I suppose a , in , figure4 , to be the star towards which the planet is moving .
" " ca6 are in a crooked line .
Cc c of are nearly in a line ; f is a little preceding .
" c de form a triangle .
" c There is a small star1 , preceding d. " There is an exceeding:small star k , in the line bk but a little preceding and nearer b. " c abc are largestars .
adeg are also pretty large .
" ff and h are small .
Power , 157 .
" c With 320 , there is also a very small star 1 , near d , forming " an isosceles triangle hd 1 , on the preceding side .
" " March A. 7h 39 ' .
Power 320 .
The stars abed efg hkI " are in the places where they were marked last night .
" 9h7'l 7 There is a very small star n , south of g ; , another m , preceding g ; and a third o , south following g. " A0h 19 ' .
1 suspect a very small star , south following the " planet , at one-third of the distance of the ist satellite ; but " cannot , verify it with 480 .
With 6oo , the same suspicion " continues .
" " March 7 .
h 48 ' .
The stars abed efg bkI are in their " places .
" " ' mo are in their places .
" " The planet has passed between the stars of pretty near to ] .
" Reports .
March 2,1 , 1794 .
Power 82o .
A -small star was suspected south of the planet , or about -8 , ?
south following .
It could not be verified with 480 , nor with 60o ; and was even supposed to have been a deception but the 22d was found remaining in the place where the planet had left it .
Observations .
" c March 26 , 1794.9gh 3,5* 'With 480 , I see the ist satellite " Cmuch better than with320 .
1 suspected , with 32o , a 3d sa"tellite , directly north of the planet , a little farther off than the si ist , and this power almost verifies the suspicion .
" See figure A. ( Tab. III .
) 9h44 With 6oo , I still suspect the same , but cannot sa"tisfy myself of the reality .
" { 1 jh 32 ' .
I see the supposed 3d satellite perfectly well now .
" It is much smaller than the ist , and in a line with the planet " -rand the ist ; so that probably it is a fixed star ; sioce it pre " ceded the ist , when I saw it before , I think more than the " s quicker motion of the ist satellite would account for .
If it " be afixed star , it makes almost a rectangular triangle with q r , " the shorter leg being 3d r ; or it is almost in a line with : q " and n. " " N. B. .
The lines in the description are truer than in the " figure , as the latter is only intended to point out the stars in question .
" " March 27 .
8h 37 ' .
Power 320 .
The same small star , ob"served last night at 1 2h 32 ' , is gone from the place where I " saw it .
From its light last night , compared to r , which to-night -is very near the planet , and scarcely visible , I am " certain that it must be bright enough to be perceived imme"diately , if it wereI in the place .
pointed out by my descrip"tion .
" 0h " o-20 ' .
The planet is considerably removed from the " star r. CC11h 41 ' .
1 had many glimpses of small stars or supposed " satellites : one of them in a place agreeing with the 3d satel"lite of last night , ( supposing it to have moved with the planet ; ) " that is , :a little farther off , and after the 1st .
; Another prep " ceding the ist , but nearer .
Some others south , at a good dis"tance ; but not one of them could I see for any constancy .
" They were only lucid glimpses. .
" Reports .
March 27 , 1794 .
A supposed 4th satellite was delineated , but proved to be a star the 28th .
Observations .
" o March 4 , 1796 .
Configuration of the Georgian.planet and " ; fixed stars for ioht'* " See fig. 6 .
" March 5 .
9 " 50 ' I suspected a very small star between c 4 " and b , which was not there last night .
I had a pretty cer- .
tain glimpse of it .
Itis in a line from the planet towardsf : " power 320 .
With 6oo , I see the satellite better than before ; " but cannot perceive the suspected small star .
a10h 17 ' .
The air is remarkably clear at present , but I can"not perceive the suspected star .
" " 4 March 9 .
111h 2-3 ' .
As the probability of other satellites is , " that they revolve in the same plane with the ist and ?
d , I " ; 0chiefly.'lo~ok- , for them in the direction , of their orbits , Iwhch " is now nearly a straight line .
" " April 5 , 1 7,96 .
There is no star in the line of the transverse , " that can be taken for a satellite : the evening is veryx beauti- .
" ful , and I examined that line with soo , at a distance ; and " with 60o , within the orbits of the two satellites .
" " March 23 , 1797 .
Three very small stars 0P Q , are in the " path of the planet ; they forman obtuseltriangle .
" ` " March 25 .
1h 4 ' .
A very bright star S , at almost the dis"tance of the field of view , is a little tsouth of the path of the " planet .
It has a small north preceding sar T , which points " f-to t8vo more V W , towards the north .
" " Between the triangle of March 23d and the four last men"tionedstars , is a very small star X.2 &gt; " March 28 .
oh 52 ' .
I see the stars S TV WX of March " 25eth .
' " 1 ljh 25 ' .
From X towards the triangle 0PQ of March 93d , " is an exceeding small star Y , about four times the distance " of the 2d satellite , and nearly in the line of the greatest elonga"tion .
, I do not remember to have seen it the 2s5th .
' a11h 141 .
The distance of Y from Xis about X of the disitance of X from the triangle .
Itrequires much attention to see it , but I have a very complete vieW of it , by drawing " the planet just o0ut of the field , and the star X almost-on " the preceding side .
" Arguments upon the Reports and , Observations .
From the reports of the great number of supposed satellites , compared with the select .
observations which are given at length , it must be evident that the method of looking for difficult objects , and of marking them down by lines and angles , with every other -possible advantage for finding them again , has been completely understood and put in I practice .
So guarded against , deceptions , we cannot:but : allow , that even ea singe glimpse of a very small star is a considerable argument in fayour of its existence .
What I call verifying a suspicion , ; which is generally , done with a higher power than that which caused the suspicion , is obtaining a steadier view of the existence of the object in question , that is , to see..it in -such:a manrner as to be able .
to fix .
an eye upon it , and to ; compare iit-with other surrounding objects ; and thus to be able to ascertain its relative situation with those other objects , in a satisfactory manner .
An interior Satellite .
The'observation of Jan. 18 , 1790 , says , " a supposed 3d sateb"lite is about two diameters of the planet following .
" There is not the least doubt expressed about the existence of the , satellite , or object in question , which therefore must be looked upon as.as , certained .
Now , the angle of the greatest elongation of the-Georgian satellites , by my new tables , at the time of observation , was 81j ' 8 N.F. Therefore , the angle of the apogee wasp 8 ?
27 S.F. ; and since , by observation , the-satellite was " , following , " without any mention of degrees being made , we may admit it to have been not far from the parallel ; suppose ii or 12 degrees S.F. In this case , the satellite would be in the apogee about the time of the 2d observation , at 7h 57'-which says , .
{ sI cannot perceive the satellite .
" But it will be shown hereafter , when I come to treat of the vanishing of the satellites , that it would become invisible in this situation .
Indeed , without the supposition of 12 the satellite 's coming to the apogee , it might easily happen that the least change in the clearness of the air , during a. timeof 1h Si , which elapsed between the first and second observationmight render an objectinvisible , which , as the first observation says , " -was " excessively-faint , and could onlybe seen by " glimpses .
" From the observed distance , which is put at " 2 diameters " of the planet , " we may conclude what would be the distance of its greatest elongation .
For , 2 diameters from the disk of the planet give 2j from the centre .
Now , the distance of the apogeeat this time , by my tables , was 64 , supposing that of the greatest elongation itherefore ee have , the radius of its orbit 6,5 6(14",2 =1 This calculation is not intended to determine precisely the distance of the satellite , but only to show that its orbit is more contracted than that of the ist , and that consequently it-is an interior satellite .
If any doubt should be entertained about the validity of this observation , we have a second , and very strking one , of March t , i794 ; S where an interior satellite was suspected south following the -planet , at one-third of the distance of the 1st .
March 4 , 'when a description was made of the stars , as in figure 4 , this satellite was not in the Place where it was observed the 5thl .
And , by an examination of the same stars March 7 , it appears , that even the smallest starsn m o , of the Sth , were seen in their former places , but not the satellite .
The observation therefore must be looked upon as decisivewith regard to its existence .
If any doubt should arise , on account of the-suspicion not being verified with 480 , I must remark that being used to such imperfect glimpses , it has generally , turned out , even when -I have given up as improbable the existence of a supposed satellite seen in that manners that it has afterwards nevertheless been discovered that a small star remained in the place where the satellite had been suspected to be situated .
An instance of this may be seen in the report of the observations that were made March 21 and 22 , 1794.Besides , in the present case , it is additionally mentioned , that the same object was examined with a power of 600 , which continued the.suspicion .
From the assigned place of this satellite , at 3 of the distance of that of the first , it appears that this observation belongs to the interior satellite of Jan. 18 , 1790 , which has already-been examined .
-The 1st satellitewas this evening at its greatest elongation , one-third of which is about i i " .
The apogee distance of a satellite whose greatest distance ; is 16 " , 1 would have been 6"t , i on the day of our observation ; - : but , not -being come to the apogee , by many degrees , it could not be so near the planet. .
For the sake of greater precision , let us admit that the satellite was exactly south following ; that is , 45 degrees from theparallel , ` and 45 from the meridian then , by calculation , a satellite whose orbit .
is at 16 " , i from the planet , would , in the situation now admitted , have been 7'1,1 from its centre , which might coarsely be rated at -3 of the distanceof the first .
But the estimation of i i"is probably more accurate than that in the ist observation , where 2 diameters are given .
And , by calculating-from this quantity , we find that the greatest elongation distance of the satellite is - , now , putting sj diameters in the first observation , instead of a , the distance deduced from it will-come out : 'X-9",3 ?
; which is certainly an agreement sufficientlyC near to admit both observations to belong to the same satellite .
March,27 , 1794 .
We find a third observation , which will .
assistin supporting .
the two former ones .
A glimpse of a sa41 tellite is mentioned , which was preceding the 1st , but nearer the planet .
The position of the ist satellite the same evening was , by measuring , found to be 620,1 N.F. which is still a considerable way from its greatest elongation ; but our new satellite preceded it , and was therefore more advanced in its orbit , or nearer its greatest distance ; and yet the observation says , that it was not so far from the planet as the ist ; 1 -not- , withstanding this latter was in a more contracted part of ' its orbit .
It follows therefore that this was also an interior satellite .
Now , since we may allow these three observations to belong to the same , we ought not to mP'ke a distinction ; but admit , as sufficiently established , the existence of at least one interior satellite of our new planet .
An intermediate Satellite .
March 26 , 1794 .
A satellite was suspected , directly north of the planet .
At first it could not be verified , but was seen perfectly.well afterwards .
It was supposed that probably it might he a star , but this was left undecided .
The observation of March 27th however removes all doubt upon the subject ; as it -fully affirmsthat the small star observed the 26th , at 1 1h,32 was gone from the place in which it was the day before .
Such strong circumstances-are mentioned in confirmation , that we cannot hesitate placing this among the list of existing satellites .
It was not the interior satellite of Jan. i8 , 1790 ; for both the ist and 2d known satellites were in full view March 26th ; see figure j. and the observation places this new one in a line drawn from the planet continued through the 1st ; with the remark , that it was a little farther from the planet than the 1st .
The 2d was then near its greatest southern elongation , and we may see -from the figure , as well as from the above description , that the orbit of this new satellite is situated -between the-orbits of the other two .
&gt; We have a second observation of the same satellite March.7 , 1794 , ; where , among the glimpses of additional satellites at 41 h ' , is mentioned " one in a placeprobably agreeing with " the new satellite of March 26th , " which , by its motion , must have been carried forward , so as to be where the observation of the 27th says it was , namely , ( " a little farther off and after the ist ; " that is , at a little greater distance from the planet than the ist , and not so far advanced in its orbit as that satellite .
This amounts not only to an additional proof , but even announces the recognition of the satellite , and its motion in the course of one day .
An exterior Satellite .
Feb. 9 , 1790 .
A new satellite was seen , in a line with the planet and the 2d satellite .
See figure 1 .
To convince us that this was not a fixed star , we have the observations of two other nights , the 1i th and 12th of February , where the removal of it , from the place in which it was Feb. 9 , is clearly decmnonstrated .
As it was in a line continued from the planet through the second satellite , its orbit must evidently be of a greater dimension than that of the 2d ; I shall therefore put it down as an exterior satellite , Most likely this satellite also was seen among the supposed satellites south of the planet , March 27 , 1794 ; where we find mention made of " d some others south , at a good distance .
" In that case , this will make a second observation .
We have a third observation of the same new satellite March 5 , 1796 ; when a very small star was seen , in a placed where the evening before there had been none ; as appears by the confi guration of the 5th of March .
See figure 6 .
At the time of the observation , the planet was come to the longitude of the place where the star was perceived to be ; which agrees with the idea of its having been brought to that situation by the planet .
It may be objected , that the'star could not be verified with a power of 6oo ; but here we have more than a bare suspicion of the satellite , for the observation says , s " I had a pretty certain ; glimpse of it : ; " and this appears also from the assigned place of the star at the intersection of two given ines .
For , such a delineation could not have been made , without having perceived it with a considerable degree of steady vision .
Its distance , to judge by the description , will agree sufficiently with the two foregoing observations of this new exterior satellites The most distant Satellite .
On Feb. 28 , 1794 , a star was perceived where on the 26th there was none .
This star was larger than a very small star which was observed the 26th , not far from the place of the new supposed satellite ; and a configuration , having been made expressly , : by way of ascertaining what stars might afterwards come into a situation where they could be mistaken for satellites , our new star or satellite would not have been omitted , when a smaller one very near- : itwas scrupulously recorded .
The motion of the planet , in-0 hours and 3 minlutes , is mewtioned as very visible .
; The place of .
, thestar , which was a new visitor this evening , was very paticularly delineated , at 6h 50 ' .
From its situation , it is evident the motion of the planet must have carried this star , if it was one of its satellites , towards the large star f , figure 3 ; in the light of which a dim satellite would be lost .
This accordingly happened ; for at:1oh and 10 h21 ' it was no longer visible .
The direction of the planet 's motion is plainly pointed out , by the place of the planetMarch 2d .
With respect to the orbit of this satellite , it appears , from iits situation near the apogee , where it was seen , that its distance was to that of the second satellite , which was then near its greatest elongation , as 8 to A. .
And , since the apogee distance , on the day of observation , was only,37 , we have its greatest 8 elongation as _37 to 5 ; that is , as 2,6 to A , or above 4 to i. From which we ilay conclude , that its orbit must lie considerably without the before mentioned exterior satelliteof Feb..9 17,90. .
We have a second observation of it March 27 , 1794 ; which thoughnot very strong , yet adds confirmation to the former .
For that evening , which was uncommonly fine , other satellites , south , at a good distance , were perceived .
This mustrelate principally to our present satellite , which may certainly be said to be at a good distance from the planet , and which , by that time , was probably in the southern part of its orbit , and near its greatest elongation .
There is a third observation , March 28 , 1797 , which probably also belongs to this satellite .
For the exceedingly small star Y. which is mentioned as not having been seen the with , when thedelineation of the stars was madej will agree very well with the two 'former observations ; and , being near the greatest elongation , the distance of this satellite is well pointed out , and agrees remarkably well with the calculation of the first observation of it .
It remains now only to be mentioned , that in such delicate observations as these of the additional satellites , there may possibly arise some doubts With those who are very scrupulous ; but , as I have been much in the habit of seeing very small and dim objects , I have not been detained from publishing these observations sooner , 'on account of the least uncertainty about the existence of these satellites , but merely because I was " in hopes of being able soon to give a better account of them , with regard to their periodical revolutions .
It did not appear satisfactory to me to announce a satellite , unless I could , at the same time , have pointed out more precisely the place where it might be found by other astronomers .
But , as more time is now already elapsed than I had allowed myself for a completion of the theory of these satellites , I thought it better not to defer the communication any longer .
The arrangement of the four new and the two old satellites together will be thus .
: ; First satellite , the interior one of Jan. 8 , 1790 .
Second satellite , the nearest old one of Jan. 11 , 1787 .
Third satellite , the intermediate one of March 26 , 1 79f .
Fourth satellite , the farthest old one of Jan. 11 , 1787 .
Fifth satellite , the exterior one of Feb. 9 , 1790 .
Sixth satellite , the most distant one of Feb. 2.8 , 1 794 Observations and Reports tending to the Discovery of one or more Rings of the Georgian Planet , and theflattening of its polar Regions.* " Nov. 13 , , 1782 .
7-feet reflector , power 460 .
1 perceive no " flattening of the polar regions .
" April 8 , 1783 .
1 surmise a polar flattening .
" " " Feb. 4 , 1787 .
20-feet reflector , power 300 .
Well defined ; " no appearance of any ring ; much daylight .
" March 4 .
I beginto entertain again a suspicion that the " planet is not round .
When I see it most distinctly , it appes " ' to have double , opposite points See figure 7 .
Perhaps a " ; double ring ; that is , two rings , at rectangles to each other .
" March 5 .
The Georgian Sidus not being round , the telescope .
was turned to Jupiter .
I viewed that planet with iS , 300 , and 480 , which showed it perfectly well defined .
Returning to the Georgian planet , it was again seen affected with projecting points .
Two opposite ones , that were large and blunt , from preceding to following ; an dtwo others , that were small and less blunt , from north to south .
See figure 7 .
March 7 .
Position of the great ring R , from 70 ?
S.P. to 7e N.F. Small ring r , from 2o N.P. to 200 N.F. 6oo .
showed R and r. 8oo R and r. 1200 R and r. " March 8 .
R and r are probably deceptions .
" ' " Nov. 9 .
The suspicion of a ring returns often when I ad"just the focus by one of the satellites , but yet I think it has " no foundation .
" Feb. 22 , 1789 .
A ring was suspected .
The observations are distinguished from the reports by marks of quotation , ( 4c ' " March i6 7h 17t .
I have turned my speculum 900 round .
" =cA certain appearance , owing to a defect which it has con"tracted by exposure to the air since it was made , is gone " with it ; ( see fig. 9 and lo ; ) but the suspected ring remains in the place where I saw it last .
f7 50 ' .
Power 471 shows the same appearance rather " stronger .
Power 589 still shows the samee .
" Memorandum .
The ring is short , not like that of Saturn .
" It seems to be as in figure 8 and this may account for the " great difficulty of verifying it .
It is remarkable that the two anse seem of a colour a little inclined to red , The blur oc"casioned by the fault of the speculum is , to-night , as repre"sented in figure 9 .
The other evening it was as in figurer 1 ; " and the ring is likewise as it was the same evening .
" " March 20 .
7h 5 When the satellites arebest in focus , " the suspicion of a ring is the strongest .
" Dec. i5 .
The planet is not round , and I have not much " doubt but that it has a ring .
" " Feb. 26 1792 .
6h34 ' .
My telescope is extremely distinct ; and , when I adjust it upon a very minute double star , which " is not far from the planet , I see a very faint ray , like a ring " crossing the planet , over the centre .
This appearance is of " an equal length on both -sides , so that I strongly suspect -it ito be a ring .
There is , however , a possibility of its being an " imperfection in the speculum , owing to some slight scratch : " I shall take its position , and afterwards turn the speculum on " its axis .
" " c8 " 3 .
Position of the supposed ring 550,6 from N.P. to S.F. " i gh5 6 ' .
I have turned the speculum one quadrant round ; " but the appearance of the very faint ray continues where it , " s was before , so that the defect is not in the speculum , nor is " it in the eye-glass .
But still it is now also pretty evident " that it arises from some external cause ; for it is now in the " same situation , with regard to the tube , in which it was 3+ " hours ago : whereas , the parallel is differently situated , and " the ring , of course , ought to be so too .
" " c March 5 , 1792 .
I viewed the Georgian planet with a newly " polished speculum , of an excellent figure .
It showed the pla"net very well defied , and without any suspicion of a ring .
" I viewed it successivdy with 240 , 300 , 480 , ; 6o , 8oo , 1200 , " and 2400 ; all which powers my speculum bore with great dis"tinctness .
I am pretty well convinced that the disk is flat- .
" tened .
" The moon was pretty near the planet .
" Dec. 4 , 1793 .
7-feet reflector , power 287 .
The Georgian planet is not so well defined as , from the extraordinary dis"tinctnes &amp; of my present 7-feet telescope , it ought to be .
There is a suspicion of some apparatus about the planet .
" " Feb. 26 , 1794 .
20-feet reflector , power 480 .
The planet ' " seems to be a little lengthened out , i.n the direction of the longer axis of the satellites ' orbits " " April 2l , 179 .
lo-feet reflector , power 400 .
The telescope " adjusted to a neighbouring star , so as to make it perfectly " round .
The disk of the planet seems to be a little elliptical .
" With 6oo , also adjusted upon the neighbouring star , the disk still seems elliptical .
" Remarks upon the foregoing Observations .
With regard to the phenomena which gave rise to the suspicion of one or more rings , it must be noticed , that .
few specula or object-glasses are so very perfect as notto be affected with some rays or inequalities , when high powers are used , and the object to be viewed is very minute .
It seems , however , from the observations of March i6 , 1789 , and Feb. 26 , 1792 , that the cause of deception , in this case , must be looked for elsewhere .
It has often happened , that the situation of the eye-glass , being on one side of the tube , which brings the observer close to the mouth of it , has occasioned a visible defect in the view of a very minute object , when proper care has not been taken to keep out of the way ; * especially when the wind is in such a quarter as to come from the observer across the telescope .
The direction of a current of air alone may also affect vision .
Without , however , entering further into the discussion of a subject that must be attended with uncertainty , I will only add that the observation of the 26th seems to be very decisive against the existence of a ring .
When the surmises arose at first , I thought it proper to suppose , that a ring might be in such a situation as to render it almost invisible , and that , consequently , observations should not be given up , till a sufficient time had elapsed to obtain a better view of such a supposed ring , by a removal of the planet from its node .
This has now sufficiently been obtained in the course of ten years for , let the node of the ring have been in any situation whatsoever , provided it kept to the same , we must by this time have had a pretty good view of the ring itself .
Placing therefore great confidence on the observation of March 5 , 1792 , supported by my late views of the planet , I venture to affirm , that it has no ring in the least resembling that , or rather those , of Saturn .
The flattening of the poles of the planet seems to be sufficiently ascertained by many observations .
The 7-feet , the Io-feet , and the 20-feet instruments , equally confirm it ; and the direction pointed out Feb. 26 , i79 seems to be conform able to the analogies that may be drawnfrom the situation of the equator of Saturn , and of Jupiter .
This being admitted , we may without hesitation conclude , that the Georgian planet also has a rotation upon its axis , of a considerable degree of velocity .
Reports and Observations relating to the Light and Size of the Georgian Satellites , and to their vanishing at certain Distancesfrom the Planet .
Jan. 14 , 1787 .
A star was put down , as a supposed very faint satellite ; but , on the : 17th , the planet -being removed , it appeared nearly as bright as two considerable stars that , had also been noted .
" Jan. 17 .
The ist satellite is the smallest in appearance .
" Jan. 24 .
The 2d satellite is brighter than the first .
" " Feb. 9 , -1787 .
The 1st satellite is larger than the second .
" Feb. 1o .
The planet was supposed to go to a triangle of pretty bright stars .
The 1 ith it was between them , and the stars of the triangle were so dim , that , had they not been seen before , they might have beeii supposed to be satellites .
" Sept. 19,1IS7 .
4h 24 .
I can still see the satellites , though " daylight is already very strong : they are , fainter than the " faintest of Saturn. 's satellites .
" * - " Feb. 22 , 1791 .
I cannot perceive the ist satellite , probably owing to its nearness to the planet .
" " March 2 , 1791 .
The ist satellite is hardly to be seen ; I " have however had several perfect glimpses of it .
It seems to " be about the most contracted part of its orbit .
" March 6 .
The supposed 3d and 4th satellites of March 5th were imaginred to have been gone from their former places ; but were seen the 7th , with this memorandum .
" I mistook them last night for other stars , they being so large that I did not know them again .
" ' " March 9 .
The 2d satellite is nearer the planet than the " a first , and on that account appears smaller .
Dec..9 , 1791 .
I do not perceive the ist satellite .
" " I Feb. 13 , 1792 .
6h 16i .
The 3d supposed satellite of last " night is a considerable star ; not much less than b. " When the supposed third was pointed out the night before , it is said to be smaller than the ist and 2d satellites .
By the figure , it did not exceed the distance of the 2d ; and b is called.a pretty large star .
Feb. 20 , 1792 .
The ?
d satellite , being at a great distance , was mistaken for a pretty large star , till about four hours after , when its motion along with the planet was perceived .
" Feb. 21 , 1792 .
7h 36 ' .
I cannot see the 2d satellite .
By " calculation , it -should be about 8 ?
,6 S.F. and I suspect it tQ " be there , but cannot get the least assurance .
" March 15 , 1792 .
I cannot see the 1st satellite with zoo ; nor with 480 ; nor with 6oo .
" c " March 19 .
8h 35 ' .
I cannot see the 2d satellite with 300 .
" With 480 I see it very well I see it also with 8oo ; and very " C well with 1200 .
With .
2400 and 4800 the satellite cannot be -C seen ; but there seems to be a whitish haziness coming on .
' March 4 , 1794 .
The 1st satellite could not be seen , March 7 .
The ist was invisible .
March 1t .
Both 1st and 2d were invisible .
March 2a1 .
The i st was invisible , though looked for with all the powers of the instrument .
March 22 .
The ?
d was hardly visible .
March 9j .
The 2d was not to be seen .
March 26 .
The 1st was but just visible .
March 5 , 1796 .
The.2d was invisible .
April , 1 796 .
The 1st was ivisible .
" March 1-7 , 1797 .
Power 6oo .
Neither of the satellites are " visible to-night ; with:oo I cannot see them .
The night is very beautiful , and I have a field bar to hide the planet ; but , notwithstanding this , I cannot see either of te satellitesi .
D --March , 1 .
The ist satellite was invisible .
March 23 .
The 2d was invisible .
The ist could not-be seen immediately , but , having : been informed where -exactly to look for it , according to my calculation of its place , it was perceived ; and with 6oo seen very well .
March 2,5 .
Both satellites were invisible .
Remarks on , the foregoing Observations .
From the observations of Jan. 14 , Feb. 1o , March 6 , 178 7 and Feb. 13 792 , it appears , that all very small stars , when they come near the planet , lose much of their lustre .
Indeed , every observation that has been ; recorded before , of supposed satellites that have been proved to be stars afterwards , has fully confirmed this circumstance ; for they were always found to be considerable stars , Sand their being mistaken for satellites was owing to their loss of light when near the planet .
This would hardly deserve notice , as it is well known that a superior light will obstruct an inferior one ; but some circumstances which attend the operation of the affections of light upon the eye , when objects are very faint , are so remarkable , that they must not be passed over in silence .
After having been used to follow up the satellites of Saturn and Jupiter , to the very margin of their planets , so as even to measure the apparent diameter of one of Jupiter 's satellites by its entrance on the disk , * I was in hopes that a similar opportunity would soon have offered with the Georgian satellites : not indeed to measure the satellites , but to measure the planet itself , by means of the passage of the satellite over its disk .
I expected also to have settled the epochs of the satellites , from their conjunctions and oppositions , with more accuracy than I have yet been able to do , from their various positions in other parts of their orbits .
A disappointment of obtaining these capital advantages deserves to have its cause investigated ; but , first of all , let us cast a look upon the observations .
The satellites , xve may remark , become regularly invisible , when , after their elongation , they arrive to certain distances from the planet .
In order to find what these distances are , we will take the first observation of this kind , as an example .
Feb. 22 , 1791 , the first satellite could not be seen .
Now , by my lately constructed tables , its longitude from the apogee , at the time of observation , was 204,5 degrees ; that is , 24,5 degrees ~from the mostcontracted part of its orbit , on the side that is turned to us , which , as its opposite is called the apogee , I shall call the perigee .
By my tables also for the same day , we have the distance of the apogee from the planet , which is,6o ; supposing the greatest elongation distance to be l. This a See Phil. Trans. for 1797 , Part IL page 335 .
being given , we may find an easy method of ascertaining the distance of the satellite , when it is near the apogee or perigee : for it will be sufficiently true for our purpose to use the following analogy .
Cosine of the distance of the satellite from the apogee or perigee is to theapogee distance from the planet , as the greatest elongation is to the distance of the satellite from the planet .
When the ellipsis is very open , this theorem will only hold good in moderate distances from the apogee or perigee ; but , when it is a good deal flattened , it will not be coftsiderably out in more distant situations : and it will also be sufficiently accurate to take the natural cosine from the tables to two places of decimals only .
When this is applied to our present instance , we have,91 for the natural cosine of 24,5 degrees ; and the distance of the satellite from the planet will come out 6X 3-3 " 21 8,.,91 By this method , it appears that the satellite , when it could not beseen , was nearly ?
2 " from the planet .
We must not however conclude , that this is the given distance at which it will always vanish .
For instance , the same satellite , though hardly to be seen , was however not quite invisible March 2 , 1791 .
Its distance from the planet , computed as before , weas then only,6 X'1 9",8 .
The clearness of the atmosphere , and other favourable circumistances , niust certainly have great influence in observations of very faint objects ; therefore , a computation of all the observations where the satellites were not seen , as well as a few others where they were seen , when pretty near the apogee or perigee , will be the surest way of settling the fact .
The result of these computations is thus .
L. o First satellite invisible .
Second satellite invisible .
1791 .
Feb. 22 at 2 1,8 1792 .
Feb. 21 at:3,3 Dec. 19 at 16,9 1794 .
March 17 at 20,7 1792 .
March 15 at 18,4 March 23 at 17,9 1794 .
March 4 at 18,5 1796 .
March 5 at 9,3 March 7 at 12,5 March 17 ; at6,3 March '17 at 17,0 March-23:-at -1~6,2 March 21 at 15,5 March 25 at 8,7 April 4 at 8S5 1797 .
March 17 at -4,8 : March 21 at 4,6 March 25 at 4,8 First satellite visible .
Second satellite visible .
1791 .
March 2 at 19,8 1794 .
March 22 at 17,5 1794 .
Feb. 26 at 14,1 ___________ Thus , having the observations and calculated distances under our inspection , we find that both the satellites became always invisible when they were near the planet : that the 1st was generally lost when it came within 18 " of the planet , and the 2d at the distance of about 20 " .
In very uncommon and beautiful nights , the ist has once been seen at 13i",8 , and the 2d at 17",3 ; but at no time have they been visible when nearer the planet .
I shall now endeavour to investigate the .
cause which caui render small stars and satellites invisible at so great a distance as i8 or 20 " .
A dense atmosphere of the planet would account for the defalcation of light sufficiently , were it not proved that the satellites are equally lost , whether-'they arein the nearest half of their orbits , or in that which is farthest from us .
But , as a satellite cannot be ecliosed -by an atmosphere that is behind it , a sUrmise of this kind tannot be ; entertained .
Let us then turn our view to light itseltf and see whether certain affections between bright and~vry bright objects , contrasted with others that take place between faint~and very faint ones , will not explain the phenomenon of'vanishing satellites .
The light of Jupiter or Saturn , for instance , on account of its brilliancy , is diffused , almost equally , over a space of several minutes all around these planets .
Their satellites also , having a great share of brightness , and moving in a sphere that !
is strongly illuminated , cannot be much affected by their various distances ' from the planets .
The case then is , that they have much lightto lose , and comparatively lose but little .
The Georgian planet , on the contrary , is very faint ; and the influence of its feeble light cannot extend far , with any degree of equality .
This enables us to see the faintest objeicts , &amp; ` e-n when they are only a minute or two removed from it .
The satellites of this planet are very nearly the dimmest objects that can be seen in the heavens ; so that they cannot bear any considerable diminution of their light , by a contrast withaW more luminous object , without becoming invisible .
If then the sphere of illumination of our new planet be limited to i ' or 20"s , we may fully account for the loss of the satellites-when they come its reach ; for they have very little light to lose , and lose it pretty suddenly .
This contrast , therefore , between the condition of the Georgian satellites and those of the brighter planets , seems to be sufficient to account for the phenomenon of their becoming invisible .
We may avail ourselves of the observations that relate to the distances at which the satellites vanish , to determine their relative brightness .
The 2d satellite appears generally brighter than the ist ; but , as the former is usually lost farther from the planet than the latter , we may admit the 1st satellite to be rather brighter than the 2d .
This seems to be confirmed by the observation of March 9 , 1791 ; where the 2d appeared to be smaller than the ist , though the latter was only 25 " from the planet , while the other was 3o",8 .
The first of the new satellites will hardly ever be seen others wise than about its greatest elongations , but cannot be much inferior in brightness to the other two ; and , if rany more interior satellites should exist , we shall probably not obtain a sight of them ; for the same reason that the inhabitants of the Georgiar planet perhaps never can discover the existence of our earth Venus , and Mercury .
The 2d new or intermediate satellite is considerably Smaller than the ist and gd old satellites .
The two exterior , or 5th and 6th satellites , are the smallest of all , and must chiefly be looked for in their greatest elongations .
Periodical Revolutions of the new Satellites .
It may be some satisfaction to know what time the four additional satellites probably employ inw revolving round their planet .
Now , as this can only be ascertained with accuracy by many observations , we must of course remain in suspense , till a series of them can be properly instituted .
But , in the mean time , we may admit the distance of the interior satellite to be 25",5 , as our calculation of the estimation of March 5 , 1794 , gives it ; and from this we compute thatits periodical revolution will be 5 days , 21 hours , 25 minutes .
; If we place the intermediate satellite at an equal distance between the two old ones , or at 38",57 , its period will be lo days , 23 hours , 4 minutes .
By the figure of Feb. 9 , 1790 , it seems that the nearest exterior satellite is about double the distance of the farthest old one ; hence , its periodical time is found to be 38 days , i hour , 49 minutes .
The most distant satellite , according to the calculation of the observation of Feb. 28 , 1794 , is full four times as far from the planet as the old 2d satellite ; it will therefore take at least 107 days , 16 hours , 40 minutes , to complete one revolution. .
It will hardly be necessary to add , that the accuracy of these periods depends 'entirely upon the truth of the assumed distances ; some considerable difference , therefore , may be expected , when observations shall furnish us with proper data for more accurate determinations .
Slough , near Windsor , September I , 1797 .

