XIV .
Observations on the Grafting of Trees .
In a Letterfrom Thomas Andrew Knight , Esq. to Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read April 30 , 1795 .
SIR , I AM encouraged to address the following letter to you , by the opinion you were last year pleased to express of part of my experiments and observations , on the diseases and decay of those varieties of the apple and pear which have been long in:cultivation .
The disease from whose ravages they suffer most is the canker , the effects of which are generally first seen in the winter , or when the sap is first rising in the spring .
The bark becomes discoloured in spots , under which the wood , in the annual shoots , is dead to the centre , and in the older branches , to the depth of the last summer 's growth .
Previous to making any experimehts , I had conversed with several planters , who entertained an opinion , that it was impossible to obtain healthy trees of those varieties which flourished in the beginning , and middle of the present century , and which now form the largest orchards in ' this country .
The appearance of the young trees , which I had seen , justified the cone clusion they bad drawn ; but the silence of every writer on the subject of planting , which had come in my way , convinced me that it was a vulgar error , and the following experiments were undertaken to prove it so .
I suspected that the appearance of decay in the trees I had seen lately grafted , arose from the diseased state of the grafts , and concluded , that if I took scions or buds from trees grafted in the year preceding , I should succeed in propagating any kind I chose .
With thisview I inserted some cuttings of the best wood I could find , in the old trees , an young stocks raised from seed .
I again inserted grafts and buds taken from these on other young stocks , and wishing to get rid of all connection with the old trees , I repeated this six years ; each year taking the young shoots from the trees last grafted .
Stocks of different kinds were tried , some were double grafted , others obtained from apple-trees which grew from cuttings , and others from the seed of each kind of fruit afterwards inserted on them ; I was surprised to find that many of these stocks inherited all the diseases of the parent trees .
The wood appearing perfect and healthyin many of my last grafted trees , I flattered myself that I had succeeded ; but my old enemies , the moss and canker , in three years convinced me of my mistake .
Some of them , however , trained to a south wall , escaped all their diseases , and seemed ( like invalids ) to enjoy the benefit of a better climate .
I had_ before frequently observed , that all the old fruits suffered least in warm situations , where the soil was not unfavourable .
I tried the effects of laying one kind , but the canker destroyed it at the ground .
Indeed I had no hopes of success from this method , as I had observed that several sorts which had always been propagated from cuttings , were as much diseased as any others .
The wood of all the old fruits has long appeared to me to possess less elasticity and hardness , and to feel more soft and spongy under the knife , than -that of the new varieties .
which I have obtained from seed .
This defect may , I think , be the immediate cause of the canker and moss , though it-is probably itself the effect of old age , and therefore incurable .
Being at length convinced that all efforts , to make grafts from old and worn out trees grow , were ineffectual , I thought it probable that those taken from very young trees , raised from seed , could not be made to bear fruit .
The event here answered my expectation .
Cuttings from seedling apple-trees of two years old were inserted on stocks of twenty , and in a bearing state .
These have now been grafted nine years , and though they have been frequently transplanted to check their growth , they have not yet produced a single blossom .
I have since grafted some very old trees with cuttings from seedling apple-trees of five years old : their growth has been extremely rapid , and there appears no probability that their time of producing fruit will be accelerated , or that their health will be injured , by the great age of the stocks .
A seedling apple-tree usually bears fruit in thirteen or fourteen years ; and I therefore conclude , that I have to wait for a blossom till the trees from which the grafts were taken attain that age , though I have reason to believe , from the form of their buds , that they will be extremely prolific .
Every cutting , therefore , taken from the apple ( and probably from every other ) tree , will be affected by the state of the parent stock .
If that be too young to produce fruit , it will grow ' with vigour , but will not blossom ; and if it be too old , it will immediately produce fruit , but will never make a healthy tree , and consequently ; never answer the intention , of the planter .
The !
root , however , and the part of the stock adjoining it , are greatly more durable than the bearing branches ; and I have no doubt but that scions obtained from either would grow ' with vigour , when those taken from the bearing branches would not .
The following experiment will at least evince the probability of this in the pear-tree .
I took cuttings from the extremities of the bearing branches of some old ungrafted pear-trees , and others from scions which sprang out of the trunks near the ground , and inserted some of each on the same stocks .
The former grew without thorns , as in the cultivated varieties , and produced blossoms the second year ; whilst the latter assumed the appearance of stocks just raised from seeds , were covered -with thorns , and have not yet produced any blossoms .
The extremities of those branches , which produce seeds in every tree , probably show the first indication of decay ; and we frequently see ( particularly in the oak ) young branches prbduced from the trunk , when the ends of the old ones have long been dead .
The same tree when cropped will produce an almost eternal succession of branches .
The durability of the apple and pear , I have long suspected to be different in different .
varieties , but that none of either would vegetate with vigour much , if at all , beyond the life of the parent stock , provided that died from mere old age .
I am confirmed in this opinion by the books you did me the ho-nour to send me : of the apples mentioned and describedby PARKINSON , the names only remain , and those since applied to other kinds now also worn out ; but many of EVELYN'S are still well known , particularly the red-streak .
This apple , he informs us , was raised from seed by Lord SCUDAMORE in the beginning of the last century.* We have many trees of it , but they appear to have been in a state of decay during the last forty # Probably about the year 1 634 .
years .
Some others mentioned by him are in a much better state of vegetation ; but they have all ceased to deserve the -attention of the planter .
The durability of the pear is ' probably something more than double that of the apple .
It has-been remarked by EVELYN , and by almost every writer since , on the subject of planting , that the growth of plants raised from seeds was more rapid , and that they produced better trees than those obtained from layers-or cuttings .
This seems to point out-some kind of decay attending the latter modes of propagation , though the custom i-in the public nurseries of taking layers from stools ( trees cropped annually close to the groundd ) probably retards its effects , as each plant-rises immediately from the root of the parent stock .
Were a -tree capable of affording an eternalsuccession of healthy plants from its -roots , I think our woods must have been wholly over-run with those species of trees .
which propagate in this manner , as those scions from the roots always grow in the first three or four years ' , with much greater rapidity than seedling -plants .
An aspen is eldom seen with- .
out a thousand suckers 'rising from its roots , yet2 this tree is thiidny , though universally , scattered over the'woodla nds of this country .
Ii can sp-ak from experience , that the luxuriance and excessive disposition to extend ' itself in anoth plant , which propagates itself from ' the root ( the raspberry ) , decline in twenty -years from the seed .
The common elm being ; alwavys propagated from scions or 'layers , and growing with tIuxurian4'e , #seems to foni 'm anexception , butas : some varieties grow mu h-better than others , 'tappears nothimprobble that the -mosthetlthy are those which have last been oitained from seed .
The different degrees of ; health ; in our peach and nec^* tarine trees may , I think , arise from the same source .
The oak is much more long-lived in the north of Europe than here ; though its timber is less durable , from the numerous pores attending its slow growth .
The climate of this country being colder than its native , may in the same way add to the durability of the elm ; which may possibly be further increased by its not producing seeds in this climate , as the life of many annuals may be increased to twice its natural period , if not more , by preventing their seeding .
I have been induced to say a great deal more on this subject than , I fear , you will think it deserves , from a conviction that immense advantages would arise from the cultivation of the pear and apple in other counties , and that the ill success which has attended any efforts to propagate them , has arisen from the use of worn out and diseased kinds .
Their cultivation is ill understood in this country , and worse practised ; yet an acre of ground , fully planted , frequently affords an average produce of more than five hundred gallons of liquor , with a tolerably good crop of grass ; and I have not the least doubt but that there are large quantities of ground in almost every county in England capable of affording an equal produce I have only to add an assurance , that the results:of the foregoing experiments are correctly stated ; and that I am , Sir , &amp;c. E1ton , Herefordshire , April I3 , 179 ; .
THO .
AND .
KNIGHT .

