X1 .
Observations on the Influence , which incites the Muscles of Animals to contract inMr .
Galvani 's Experiments .
By William Charles Wells , M. D. F.R. S. Read March 19 , 1795 .
INMR ' .
VOLTA , in his letters to-Mr .
CAVALL-O , which have been read to this Society , not only has shown that the conclusions , which Mr. GALVANI drew from his experiments on the application of metals to the nerves and muscles of animals , are in various respects erroneous , but has also made known several important facts , in addition to those which had been discovered by that author .
As he appears , however , from these letters , to have fallen into some mistakes himself , and has certainly not-exhausted the subject which he has treated in them , I shall venture to communicate to this learned body a few observations I have made respecting it , which may contribute , both to correct his errors , and to increase our knowledge of the cause of those motions , which have been attributed by Mr. GALVANI and others to an animal electricity .
These observations will-be so arranged , as to-furnish answers , more or less satisfactory , tithe following questions : Does the incitement of the influence which , in Mr. GALVANI 's experiments , occasions the muscles of animals to contract , either wholly , or in part , depend upon any peculiar property of living bodiesl ?
What are the conditions necessary for the excitement of this influence ?
Is it electrical ?
When a muscle contracts upon a connection being formed , by means of one or more metals , between its external surface and the nerve which penetrates it , Mr. GALVANI contends that , previously to this effect , the inner and outer parts of the muscle contain different quantities of the electric fluid ; that the nerve is consequently in .
the same state , with respect to that fluid , as the internal substance of the muscle ; and ' that upon the application of one or more metals between its outer surfaced and thenerve , an electrical discharge takes .
place , which is thecause of the contraction of the muscle .
In short , he supposes a complete similarity to exist between a muscle , in a proper condition to exhibit this appearance , and a charged ' Leyden phial ; the nerve of the former answering , as far as .
his experiments are concerned , the same purpose as the : wire , .
which is connected with the internal surface of the latter .
-Now5 , if this were just , such a muscle ought to contract , whenever a communication is formed between .
its internal surface and the nerve , by means of any conductor of electricity ; and accordingly Mr. VOLTA , who to ascertain extent adopts Mr. GALVANI'S theory , asserts this to be the case , as often as the experiment is mace upon an animal which has been newly killed .
But I am inclined to believe that he rests this assertion upon some general principle , which he thinks estab- .
lished , and not upon particular facts ; for he gives none in proof of it , and I have often held a nerve of an , animal newlyi killed in one hand , , while with the other Itouched the muscle to which the nerve belonged , but never saw contractions by this means excited .
I have also frequently taken hold of a nerve of an animal , which was recently killed , with a non-con doctor of electricity , and have in this way applied its loose Kk 2end to the external surface of the muscle which it entered , withoutever observing motion to follow .
I think , therefore , I am entitled to conclude , not only that the theory advanced by Mr. GALVANI , respecting the cause of the muscular motions in his experiments , is erroneous ; but also , that the in , fluence , whatever its nature may be , br- , which : they are excited , does not exist in a disengaged state in the muscles and nerves , previously to the application of metals .
Should it be urged against this conclusion , that , since metals are much better conductors of electricity than 'moist substances , the charge of a muscle may be too weak to force its way through the latter , though it may be able to pass along the former ; my answer is , that , in all Mr. GALVANI 's experiments , the nerve makes a part of the connecting medium between the two surfaces of the muscle , and ; thatthe power of no compound conductor can be greater than that of the worst conducting substance , which constitutes a part , of it .
It may be said , however , that , although there is no proof that any influence naturally resides--in the nerves or muscles , capable of producing the-effects mentioned by Mr. GALVAN ' I these substances may still , by some power independent of the properties they possess in common with dead matter , contribute to the excitement of the influence , which is so well known to exist in them , after a certain application of metals .
Before I'enter upon the discussion of this supposition , I must observe , that there are two cases of such-an application of metals the first is , when we employ only one-metal ; the second , when we employ two or more .
With respect to the first case , a late author , Dr. FOWLER , who seems to have : made many experiments relative to this point , positively asserts , that henever saw a fair instance of motion being produced by the mete application of a single metal to a muscle and its nerve .
I shall , therefore , defer treating this case , till I speak of the conditions which are necessary for the excitement of the influence .
Nor will the present subject suffer from this delay ; for if it be shown , as I expect it will , that , when two or more metals are used , the muscle and its nerve do not furnish aiiy thing but what every other moist substance is equally capable of doing , it will , I think , , be readily granted , that they can give nothing more , when only one metal is applied to them .
In regard to the second case , Mr. VOLTA has affirmed , or has said at least , what I regard as equivalent to affirming , that , when two metals are employed , the influence in question is excited by their action upon the mere moisture of the parts which they touch .
The proofs , however , of this assertion were reserved for some future communication .
But as more than two years have now elapsed since they were promised , and none have been given to thisSociety , or have appeared , as far as I can learn , in any other way , I hope I shall not be thought precipitate , if , at this distance of time , I offer one of the same point , which seems to me both plain and decisive .
It is known , that , if a muscle andits nerve be covered with two pieces of the same metal , no motion will take place upon connecting those pieces , by means of one or more different metals .
After making this experiment one day , I accidentally applied the metal I had used as the connector , and which I still held in one hand , to the coating of the muscle only , while with the other hand I touched the similar coating of the nerve , and-was surprised to find that the muscle was immediately thrown into contraction .
Having produced motions in this way sufficiently often to place the fact beyond doubt , I next began to consider , its relations to other facts formerly known .
I very soon perceived , that the immediate excitingcause of these motions could not be derived from the action of the metals , upon the muscle and nerve , to which they were applied ; otherwise it must have been admitted , that my body and a metal formed together a better conductor of the exciting influence than a metal alone , the contrary of which I had known , from many experiments , , to be the case .
The only source , therefore , to which .
it could possibly be referred , was the action of the metals upon my own body .
It then occurred to me , that a proper opportunity now offered itself of determining,. .
whether ani-mals contribute to the pro-duction of this influence by means of any other property than .
their moisture .
With this view , I emrployed .
various moist substances , il which there could be no , suspicion of life , to constitute , with one or more metals , different from , that of the , coatings of the muscle and nerve , a connecting medium between those coatings , and found that they produced the same effect as my body .
A single drop of water was even sufficient for this purpose ; though , in general , the greater the quantity of the moisture which was used , .
the more readily and powerfully were contractions of the muscle excited .
But , if the mutual operation of metals and moisture befully adequate to the excitement of an influence capable of occasioning muscles to contract , it follows , as an immediate consequence , that animals act by their moisture alone in giving origin to the same influence in Mr. GALVANI 's experiments , unless we are to admit more causes of an effect than what are sufficient for its production .
Before I dismiss this part of my subject I may mention , that , being in possession of a method to determine what substances are capable , along with metals , of exciting the influence , I made several experiments for the purpose of ascertaining this point .
I found , in consequence , .
that all fluid bodies , except mercury , that are good conductors of electricity , all those at least which I tried , can with the aid of metals produce it .
The bodies I tried , beside water , were alcohol , vinegar , and the mineral acids ; the last both in their concentrated states , and when diluted with vrious portions of water .
Alcohol , however , operated feebly .
On the other hand , no fluid , which is a nonconductor of electricity , would assist in its production : those upon which the experiment was made were the fat and essential oils .
Ether , from its similarity to alcohol , Iexpected would also have concurred in the excitement of the influence , but it did not ; neither would it tconduct the influence when excited by any other means .
I may remark , however , that the ether I employed had been prepared with great care ; other ether , therefore , less accurately made , may possibly be found to contribute to the excitement of the influence , either from the undecomposed alcohol , or naked acid , it may contain .
Having thus given an answer to the first question , I proceed to the discussion of the second .
It has hitherto been maintained by every author , whose works I have read upon the subject of Mr. GALVANI'S experiments , and by every person with whom I have conversed respecting it , that metals are the only substances capable , by their application to parts of animals , of exciting the influence , which in those experiments ~occasions the muscles to .
contract .
But it appears rather extraordinary , that none of those , who contend for the identity of this influence and the electric fluid , have ever suspected , that the only very good dry conductor of the latter which we know , beside.the metals , possesses like them the property of exciting the former .
I con , fess , however , that it was not this consideration , but accident , which led me to discover that charcoal is endowed with this property , and in such a degree that along with zinc , it ex-k cites at least as strongly as gold with zinc , the most power , ful combination , I believe , which can .
in this way be formed of the metals .
But to prevent disappointments I must men.tion , that all charcoal is not equally fit for this purpose , and that long keeping seems to diminish its power .
It being shown that charcoal is also to be ranked among the exciters of this influence , I shall now speak of the circumstances , in which both it and the metals must be placed , to fit them for the exercise of their power .
With respect to metals , .
Mr. VOLTA maintains , that to this end it is only necessary , that two different species be applied to any other body which is a good conductor of electricity , and that a communication be established between the two metallic coatings .
But charcoal is a much better conductor of electricity than water , and yet metals in contact with it alone will not excite .
Again , Mr. VOLTA says , that the simple application of two metals to two parts of an animal disturbs the equilibrium of the electric fluid , ?
and .
disposes it to pass from one of the parts to the other , which passage actually takes place , as soon as a conductor is applied , between , the metals .
But what should prevent .
the passage of the fluid before the application of a -new conductor , since the-metals were already connected by means of the moisture of the animal . ?
Further , a consequence of this opinion is , that , if the under surfaces of two different metals -be placed in moisture , and their upper surfaces be afterwards connected by means of a nerve , still attached to its muscle , contractions ought then to be produced ; since the whole quantity of the electric fluid necessary to restore the equilibrium , which has been disturbed by the action of the metals , must pass through the nerve .
This experiment I have made , and as I did not find the muscle to contract , I must hold Mr. VOLTA'S opinion on .
this point to be likewise ill founded .
The fact is , that as far as the contraction of muscles is a test , whether the influence exists or not , and we have no other , it is never excited , when two metals , or one metal and charcoal are necest sary for this purpose , unless these substances touch each other , and are also in contact with some of the fluids formerly mentioned .
But there is still another requisite for the excitement of the influence , which is a communication , by means of some good conductor of electricity , between the.two quantities of fluid , to which the dry exciters are applied , beside that which takes place between the same quantities of fluid , when the dry exciters are , brought into contact with each other .
As from this last circumstance , a complete circle of connection is formed among the-different substances employed , it has been imagined by many , that the individual quantity of the influence excited goes the whole round , each time contraction is produced .
There is an experiment however , first , I believe , made by Dr. FOW LER , which appears to contradict this opinion .
He brought two different metals into contact with each other in water , at the distance of about aan inch from the divided end of a nerve , placed in the same water , and found that the m uscles , which depended upon it , were from this procedure thrown into contractions .
Now , in this experiment , there was surely room enough for the influence to pass through both metals , and themoisture immediately touching them , without going near to the nerve .
I think it , therefore , probable , that motions are in no case produced by any thing passing from the dry exciters through the muscles and nerve , but that they are occasioned by some influence , naturally contained in those bodies as moist substances , being suddenly put in motion when the two dry exciters are made to touch both them , and each other ; in like manner as persons , it is said , have been killed by the motion of their proper quantity of the electric fluid .
But to return from conjecture to facts , I shall now examine , whether it be always necessary to employ two dry exciters , that is , two metals , or one metal and charcoal , in order to occasion contractions .
Gold and zinc , the first the most perfect of the metals , the other an imperfect one , operate together very powerfully in producing contractions ; while gold , and the next most perfect me .
tal , silver , operate very feebly .
It would seem , therefore , that the more similar the metals are which are thus used , the less is the power arising from their combination .
Two pieces of the same metal , but with different portions of alloy , are still more feeble than gold and silver ; and the power of such pieces becomes less and less , in proportion as they approach each other in point of purity .
From these factsit has been inferred , that , if any two pieces of the same metal were to possess precisely the same degree of purity , they would if used together be entirely inert , in regard to the excitement of muscular contractions in confirmation of which , many persons have asserted , that they have never observed muscles to move from the employment of two such pieces of metal , or of one piece of metal having the same fineness through its whole extent .
Others , however , upon the authoritysof their observations , have maintained the contrary ; and to the testimony of these I must add my own , as I have frequently seen muscular motions produced not only by a single metal , but likewise by charcoal alone .
Nor will credit be denied me on this head , after I have pointed out certain practices , by which any one of those substances may at pleasure be made to produce contractions .
The most proper way of mentioning these practices will , perhaps , be to relate in what manner they came to my knowledge .
I one day placed a piece of silver , and another of tin-foil , at a small distance from each other upon the crural nerve of a frog , and then applied a bent silver probe between them , with the view of ascertaining , whether contractions would arise , agreeably to Mr. VOLTA'S declaration , from the influence passing through a portion of the nerve without entering the muscles .
Having finished this experiment , I immediately after applied the same probe between the silver coating of the nerve and the naked muscles , and was surprised to see these contract .
A second and third application were followed by the same effects , but further applications were of no avail .
It then occurred to me that motions might re-appear , if I again touched the two coatings with the probe , and the event proved th4e conjecture to have been fortunate ; for after every application of the probe to the two coatings , contractions were several times excited by it .
The fact being thus established , that under certain circumstances contractions could be produced by silver alones Ll I it next became a subject of inquiry , whether this was owing to any disposition of the muscles and nerve , which had been induced upon them by Mr. VOLTA 's experiment or whether , the condition of the muscles and nerve being unaltered by that experimenta the silver had gained some new property by coming into contact with the tin-foil .
The point in doubt was soon determined , by applying the probe toa piece of tin-foil .
which had no connection with any part of theanimal ; for , .
when this was done , it was again enabled to produce contractions .
As these experiments , however , frequently did not succeed when made upon other frogs , I ; afterwards varied themetals , and found in consequence , that zinc , particularly if moistened ; communicated an exciting power pretty constantly to silver , gold , and iron .
If any of these metals were slightly rubbed on the zinc , they almost always acquired such a power .
It will , perhaps , be thought from the last-mentionedcir-c cumstance , that , in every instance of motion being in this way produced , It was in truth owing to some part of one of the metals laving been abraded by the other ; so that , under the appearance of one metal , two .
were in reality applied .
But it can scarcely be supposed , that , from touching thepolished surface of tin-foil in the gentlest manner with the smooth round end of a silver probe , any part of the former metal was carried away by the latter ; and even when , friction was usedP , as the zinc was muchharder than the gold and silver , it is not probable that it -was in : the least abraded by them .
Besides , .
moisture , as I have already said , increases this effect of fric lion , though it lessens friction itself .
The most powerful argument , however , in favour of my opinion , is another fact I discovered in pursuing this subject ; *which is , that an exciting power may be given to a metal by rubbing it on many substances beside : another metal , such as , silk , woollen , leather , fish-skin , the ; palm of the human hand , , sealing-wax , marble , and wood .
Other substances will , doubtless , be hereafter added to this listd .
As the metals while they were rubbed were -held in my hand , which , from , thedrynessof its s"carf-skin , might have afforded some resistance to the , passage of small quantities of the electric fluid and as the substances , upon .
which the friC .
tion .
was made- , were either electrics , .
or imperfect conductors of electricity I oncethought it possible , that the metal subjected to the friction had acquired by means of it an .
electrical charge , which , though very slight , was still sufficient to act as .
a stimulus upon the nerves to which it was , communicated , .
But that this was not the casewas afterwards made evident , by the following experiments ; and considerations .
i. A metal , rendered capable by friction of exciting con.tractions , produced : no change upon .
Mr. BENNET'S gold-leaf electrometer .
2 .
The interposition of moisture does .
not , in any instance i know of , increase the effect of friction in exciting the electric fluid .
In some instances it certainly lessens this effect ... But moistened substances , when rukzbed by a. metal , communicate to it the capacity of producing contractions , much more readily than the same substances doa when dry .
g. If my hand , from being an imperfect conductor , had Occasioned an accumulation of electricity in the metal which was rubbed , a greater effect of the same kind ought certainly to have been produced by insulating the metal completely ; which is contrary to fact .
4 .
I placed a limb of a frog , properly prepared upon the floor of my chamber ; if a severe frost had not prevailed when I made this experiment , I should have laid it upon the moistened surface of the earth .
I then raised from the muscles , by means of an electric , the loose end of the nerve , and touched it with the rubbed part of a piece of metal ; but no contractions followed .
To be convinced that this was not owing to any want of virtue in the metal , I kept the same part of it stillin contact with the nerve , while I applied another part to the muscles ; immediately upon which contractions were excited .
5 .
Admitting now the limb of an animal to be in such an experiment completely insulated , and that the metal actually becomes electrical from the friction it undergoes , surely a very few applications can only be required to place them both i0 the same state with respect to the electric fluid ; and when this happens , all motions depending on the transflux of that fluid must necessarily cease .
I have found , however , that a piece of metal which has been rubbed will excite contractions , after Kit has been many times applied to the limb .
In one instance , vigorous contractions were occasioned by the 200th application ; and if I ha4 chosen to push the experiment further , I might certainly have produced many more .
I may mention also , as connected with this fact , that I have frequently observed a piece of metal to excite motions , an entire day after it had been rubbed .
What I have said will , probably , be thought more than suflicient to prove , that metals , after being rubbed , do not produce muscular contractions by means of any disengaged electricity they contain .
If my opinion were now asked , respecting the mode in which friction communicates , such a power to them , + I should say , that the part which has been rubbed is .
so -far altered , in , some condition or property , as to be affected differently , by the fluid exciters , from a part which has not been rubbed ; in short , that the rubbed part becomes , as it were , a different metal .
, There are two facts , beside those already mentioned , which support this conjecture .
The first is , that when I have endeavoured to give an .
equal degree of friction to the two parts of the metal which I applied to the muscle and its nerve , little or no motion was excited , by it ; so : that it is reasonable to suppose , that , if precisely the same degree of friction were given to both the parts , no contractions would sever be produced by them , when used in this way .
The second is .
, tnat , although only one part of the metal be rubbed , still , if both the muscle and nerve be coated with some other metal , the application of the rubbed inetal between these similar coatings will not be followed by motions ; which , however , will immediately be produced , by touching the naked muscle and nerve with .
the same piece of metal .
But , whether any part of my reasoning upon this head be admitted as just or not , it must yet be granted , as I think I cannot be mistaken respecting the fact &gt; ; -x which have been mentioned , that very slight accid"Ients may give the power of exciting contractions to a single metal , which had it not before ; and that we may hence easily account for the discordant testimonies of authors u.pon th s point .
Hitherto I have spoken only of the effets of friction upon metals .
But to coxltcude this part of my subject , , I 'must now remark , that charcoal , though from its friability not very fit for the experiment , may yet be rendered capable by the same means of producing -contractions , without the assistance of any of the metals .
My next and last object is to inquire , whether the influence , which inx all these experiments immediately excites the muscles to act , be electrical or not .
The points of difference between any two species of natural bodies , even those which , from the similarity of some of their most obvious qualities , have once been thought the same , are found , upon accurate examination , greatly to exceed in number those of their agreement .
When , therefore , two substances are known to have many properties in common .
, while their differences are few , and none of these absolutely contradict'such a conclusion , we infer with considerable confidence , that they are the same , though we .
may not be immediately able to explain why their resemblance is not complete .
Aftrer Mr. WALSH , for instance , had discovered , that the influence of the torpedo was transmitted by all the various bodies which are good conductors of the electric fluid , philosophers made little hesitation in admitting them to be one and the same substance , though some of their apparent differences could not then be accounted for .
In like manner , the inquirers into the nature of the influence , the effects of which are so evident in Mr. GALvANI'S experiments , have very generally , and in my opinion justly , allowed it to be electrical , on the ground that its conductors and those of electricity are altogether the same .
To this , however , an objection has been made by Dr. FOWLERU which , if wll founded , would certainly prove them to be different substances ; for he has asserted that charcoal , which is so good a conductor of electricity , refuses to transmit the influence , upon which the motions in Mr GALVAN I'S experiments depend .
In reply I shall only say , that Dr. FOWLER must have been unfortunate with respect to the charcoal he employed ; since all the pieces I ever tried , and I have tried many , were found to-conduct this influence .
O Qther argum-ents have likewise been urged against the identity of the'two influences ; -all of which , however , except- .
ing one , I shall decline discussing , as they either are of little importance , or have not been stated with sufficient precision .
The objection I mean is , that in none of the experiments with animals , prepared after the manner of Mr. GALVANI , are those appearances of attraction and repulsion to be observed which are held to be the tests of the presence of electricity .
My answer to it is , that no such appearances can occur in Mr. GALVANI'S experiments , consistently with the known requisites for their success , and the established laws of electricity .
For , as it has been proved that there is naturally no disengaged electric fluid in the nerves and muscles of animals , I except the torpedo and a few others , no signs of attraction and repulsion can be looked for in those substances , before the application of metals or charcoal ; and after these have been applied , the equilibrium of the influence , agreeably to what has been already shown , is never disturbed , unless means for its restoration be at the same time afforded .
Neither then ought signs of attraction and repulsion to be in this case presented , on the supposition that the influence is electrical ; since it is necessary for the exhibition of such appearances , that bodies after becoming electrical , should remain so during some sensible portion of time : it being well known , for example , that the passage of the charge of a Leyden phial , from one of its surfaces to the other , does not ; affect the most delicate electron meter , suspended from a wire or other substance , which forms the communication between them .
Such are the observations I mean at present to submit to the consideration of this Society , respecting the influence which incites the muscles of animals to contract , in Mr. GALVANI'S experiments ,

