VII .
An experimental Inquiry concerning the Reproduction of Nerves .
By John Haighton , M. D. Communicated by Maxwell Garthshore , M. D. F. R. S. Read February 26 , 1795 .
AN animate machine differs from an inanimate one in nothing more conspicuously , than in its power of repairing its injuries , .
and of curing its diseases .
It is wisely contrived by nature that , in many instances , the cause producing the injury lays the foundation for the cure ; for as injuries , particularly those occasioned by cutting instruments , are necessarily attended with an effusion of blood , from the division of blood-vessels , this fluid , either immediately or remotely , fills up the breach .
Hence every part possessed of vascularity , and consequently of blood , carries with it the principle by which it repairs its injuries ; and the facility with which this process is conducted , generally bears some proportion to the freedom of the circulation in each individual part .
But it has been a subject of inquiry with ana mistsand physiologists , to determine of what nature the new formed part is , and how far it may be said to possess the characters of the original part .
There are few who will deny , that a bone , when fractured , fills up the chasm with a substance of its own kind ; or that a tendon , when divided , repairs with a substance resembling itself .
But this law of nature is not admitted as universal ; and this power of repairing in kind .
has been denied to several of the constituent parts of an .
animal machine .
With respect-to the nerves , it has been both affirmed and denied : .
some .
assert , .
that the .
new formed substance possesses the characters of the primitive nerve ; others .
maintain , that it is totally different &gt; and .
both found their opinions on experiment .
When .
opinions so opposite to .
each other prevail on a point , .
which experiment seems so fully adequate to decide , we are naturally led to take a view of the manner in which the experiments were conducted , and consider the criterion to which each party appealed.* There are only two tests which seem to offer themselves , and from which any degree of Judgment can be formed .
These are , either a minute and careful examination of the new formed : substance in an anatomical way , and an accurate comparison .
of it with the original nerve ; or , a cautious attention , to the function of that nerve , by which we see the loss of it from the division , and the return of it from the reunion of the divided parts .
Those who have subjected this matter to the test of experiment , have made their appeal to the first criterion ; , and have either affirmed or denied the reproduction , according as they thought thel new formed part either agreed with or differed from the original nerve ; This criterion certainly supposes , that anatomy is fully competent to determine , what is the precise structure of nerves , what are the nature and characters of ultimate nervous fibres , and by what mechanism or power they execute their allotted # Vide FON TA N. A , and A.R ; N , M ANN .
function .
It supposes likewise ( and which byv the way is not true ) , that anatomists are perfectly agreed upon this matter ; and that those who make their appeal to anatomy , haveadmitted a common standard of comparison , by which they allow their experiments to be judged ; baut no position is more remote from fact .
It is -sufficienit to say , that some think ultimate nervous fibres are constructed to act by tremors , whilst others believe them to be hollow tubes .
Nor is the difference of opinion less , respecting the appearances which they exhibit on being viewedby a microscope .
One eminent physiologist* observes , that the ultimate nervous fibres are c serpentine and convoluted , " C very much resembling the winding of the seminal ducts in " the testicle , or epididymis : " but having extended his microscopical observations to other parts , he finds a similar disposition of fibre ; nay , even neutral salts , in a state of crystallization , and metals , when microscopically examined , have convoluted fibrous appearances , corresponding with -those : of nerves .
Another ingenious inquirer , + having subjected the nerves to microscopic examination , thought at one time that their fibres were composed of cylinders , with bands twined around them , in a spiral direction ; but subsequent examinations convinced him , that this appearance had its origin in an optical deception , and thattheir true 'direction was that of " parallel winding fibres .
" 'I have not yet heard whether a third examination has rectified the errors of the two former .
As it appears then , , that microscopical observers neither agree--with each other on this subject , nor with themselves , I think it fair to conclude , that ocular inspection cannot be ads Knitted as a fair appeal , from which we can determine whether D Dr. MQNR.4 f F9gT4PA , , the substance which unites the extremities of divided nerves is of the same nature as the original nerve .
Dr. ARNEMANN , of Gottingen , who has written ex professo on the reproduction of nerves , denies positively , from anatomical examination that the new formed substance is of the nature of nerve ; and on being shown the result of some of my experiments , he declared at the first glance of the eye , cc that the medium of union did not possess the characters of " nerve ; : and further , " that the true nervous substance is " never reproduced .
" But he had already prejudged the matter .
On the other hand , I am , persuaded that if the same preparations had been shown to the Abbe FONTANA , he would have seen in the new formed substance a continuation of the winding parallel fibres , agreeable to the result of his own experiments .
Such a contrariety of opinions determined me to decline an , appeal so undecisive , and to submit my inquiries to a test less doubtful and fallacious : and as such a test was not to be found within the pale of anatomy , I resolved to try whether the reb sources of pbhysiology could not furnish me with what I wished .
From physiology we learn , that if the action of a nere be suspended by a division of tit , and if that action be recovered in consequence of an union of its divided extremitis , such medium of union must possess the characters and properties of nerve .
I had therefore only to determine , what nerves appeared the most favourabl.e for the experiment , and pursue the position just stated to its ultimate consequence .
I know not whether my choice was judicious , but I determined on the eighth pair .
The first step I took in this inquiry , was to ascertain what riJcts will arisefrom the division of both of these nerves , together with that branch of the great sympathetic nerve accomanying and strongly adhering to them .
EXPERIMENT .
A dog being properly secured , and a convenient incision made on the fore part of the neck , I divided both the nerves of the eighth pair : he became immediately restless and uneasy , betraying symptoms of great distress upon the stomach , which continued eight hours when he died .
Though the result of this experiment is perfectly agreeable to what otherexperimentaltphysiologists have stated , I-thought it of importance to the present inquiry , to give it confirmation by further expetinent .
I therefore repeated it on two other dogs , one of which survived it three days , the other only two .
From these experiments we learn , that the action of these nerves was suspended , and that those vital organs which received their nervous energy from this source , had their functions arrested , so ; that death followed as a necessary consequence .
It may be said here , by way of objection , that a violent shock had been suddenly given to the machine ; and that the animal perished rather from the sudden deprivation of thener- .
vous influence , than from -its absolute loss ; and that if the same quantity had been abstracted nina more gradual way , the anise mal might hae survived it .
How little validity there would be in such an objection , the following experiment will evince .
EXPERIMENT .
Another dog being procured ?
I divided only one of the nerves of the eighth pair .
I was surprised to see how slightly he was affected from it ; -for , excepting a little moroseness , there was scarcely any alteration perceptible , so that in a few hours after the operation he took food as usual .
On the third day , I divided the other nerve : ; but the same symptoms imipediately supervened here as followed the division of both nerves in the tfotmer experiments : he continued in a state of restlessness and anxiety , with palpitations and tremors , until the fourth day , when he died .
The event of this experiment differs in nothing from the former , than that the fate of the animal was suspended a little longer , but the ultimate effect was exactly the -same : therefore , in the first experiments , the death of the animal is not to be imputed to the mere sudden deprivation of nervous energy , but-to its absolute loss .
Wishing next to determine whether , by lengthening the interval between the division of the two nerves , a fewdays more , the life of the animal could not be protracted to a greater length , or even saved , I made another experiment .
EXPERIMENT .
Having divided one of the nerves of the eighth pair , and waited the'lapse of nine days , I divided the other .
The same symptoms came on now as in the last experiment , but scarcely so violent .
The only kind of food he would takeas milk , and that in small quantities , and this always produced great uneasiness at the stomach , with symptoms of indigestion .
In this state he continued thirteen days , and then died , very much emaciated .
From this dog having lingered so long , I was beginning to entertain hopes of his recovery , and had that eventually hap-W pened , I doubt much whether , even under the present uncertainty of things , I could have resisted the temptation of ascrib- .
ing such recovery to the reproduction of the nerves ; but the event put a stop to my speculation .
I think I have now proved my first position , ( viz. ) that whether the eighth pair of nerves be divided in immediate succession , so as to deprive an animal of their influence suddenly , or whether this deprivation be effected in a more gradual way , the consequences are in the end equally fatal .
I , must next endeavour to avail myself of this fact in the solution of the problem now before me .
-If the substance of nerve be re.produced , certainly-a period longer than the above must be necessary for this process ; but to mark the precise point of time when the line is to be drawn , would require the sacrifice of more animals than a question of mere curiosity could justify .
I must , therefore , content myself with giving a general answer to the question , and inquire whether , by suspending the division of the second nerve for a much greater length of time than was done in the two last experiments , the existence of theanimal could be preserved .
EXPERIMENT .
Another dog ' being procured , and one of the nerves of the eighth pair divided , I allowed six weeks to elapse before the other was cut through .
This division of the corresponding nerve evidently deranged him ; but in a much less degree than in the former experiments .
For some days he refused solid food , but took milk ; afterwards he ate solid food in small quantities ; and near a month had passed away before he fed as usual .
The .
actions-of the stomach were for a long time evi* dently deranged , :so tha the was continually harassed with symptoms of .
indigestion ; and six months had nearly elapsed before he recovered his health , though during five months of the time he took his usual quantity of food .
CNow , to what cause are we to impute his recovery ?
The most probable , one appears to be , that in the interval , of six weeks the first nerve had been reproduced ; so that the actions of those organs depending upon this nerve , though somewhat disturbed , were not suspended .
But as the union of the second nerve advanced , and the reproduction of the first became more perfect , the vital organs gradually recovered their healthy state .
I kept this animal'nineteen months during the greatest part of which time , he performed the office of a yard dog .
And here it may be proper.-to observe , that in all the experI iments , the voice was totally lost on the divisio of the second nerve .
This effect anatomists will easily understand , from recollecting that the recurrent branches of the eighth pair , which are the true vocal nerves , originate below the part where the trunks of the eighth pair were cut through ; consequently those nerves are themselves in effect divided .
Now it deserves to be remarked , that his voice returned in proportion as his general health improved ; and in about six months he could bark as strongly as before , 'but the pitch of his -voice was evidently raised .
From this experiment , I am strongly inclined to believe that there must have been a true 'reproduction of the nerve ; yet I do not contend , that if the part of union were examined by an anatomical eye , such reproduction would be very : evi .
Z dent .
On the contrary , I am persuaded that anatomy can determine only the presence and existence of an uniting medium ; but it is the province of physiology to decide whether the medium of union possess the characters , and perform the function , of the original nerve .
The evidence of reproduction , as resting on this experiment , may not be sufficient to obviate certain doubts , which reflections upon this subject may probably suggest .
There is a difficulty which naturally presents itself here , and this is , the possibility of the stomach and vocal organs having received an additional supply of nervous energy from another source .
And to give an appearance of validity to this objection , it may be said that the eighth pair of nerves communicates energy to the larynx by means of the laryngeal branch , and that this branch arises from the trunk above the part where the division was made , and consequently its function received no interruption from the experiment .
Again , with regard to the stomach , another apparent objection offers .
This organ receives nerves from the great sympathetic , as well as the eighth pair ; and nothing hitherto advanced has tended to disprove , that the defect of nervous influence from the division of the latter , has been supplied by greater exertions of the former .
Lastly , the familiar analogy of the vascular system , where collateral branches are enlarged from the obliteration of a principal trunk , tends further to give weight to these doubts .
To remove these seeming difficulties by anatomical investigation , or by directing my views to any changes that might be induced on the anastomosing nervous filaments , would be an undertaking not less tedious in its execution than unsatisfactory in its result ; for there would still remain room for opposite opinions : and while some would argue that these anastomosing filaments were become evidently enlarged , others .
would contend that they had not suffered the slightest change .
Now , I have already expressed my distrust of those decisions which are founded on an appeal to the eye , , seeing that anatomy has yet to explain bywhat mechanism orstructure these organs perform their office .
; and because I have frequently heard opposite opinions on my own .
preparations .
I therefore prefer an appeal to the functions of these parts , andinquire whether ; in the experiment in which the dog survived : the division of the second nerve of the eighth pair after an .
interval of six weeks , it was effected by the reproduction of the , first dividednerve , or in .
another way ?
Thereare only two possible answers to such , a question ; : these are , that either the functions of the stomach , larynx , &amp;c. were carried on by anastomosing nerves ; or that the united ; nerves had recovered their original importance .
If the first be contended for , this consequenceought to ensue , ( viz. ) that the eighth pair should now be entirely useless , .
and both of them may be .
divided a second time , without injuring any of the functions of the animal .
If the last be granted , it must of necessity follow , that the medium of union possessed , the same properties as the original nerve .
I have now circumscribed the field of inquiry , and havedrawn the question into so narrow a compass , that it is in the power of a single experiment to prove either the affirmative or , negative .
If now the eighth pair be divided a second time in .
immediate succession , and the animal sustain it with impunity , I conceive it right to conclude , that the actions of those organs , which originally were carried on through the means of the eighth pair , are now performed by other channels , and that the true substance of the nerve is not reproduced .
But on the contrary , if the animal die in consequence of it , then I think it equally just to infer , that the new formed substance is really and truly nerve , because we know of no other substance which can perform the office of nerve .
I shall rely then upon the following , and consider it as my experimentum crucis .
EXPERIMENT .
Having the dog in my possession upon which I divided the eighth pair of nerves nineteen months before , I cut through both of them now , in immediate succession .
The usual symptoms were immediately induced , and continued until the second day , when he died .
After death I carefully dissected out these nerves , and have preserved them as evidences of my success , I think I have now answered the question I proposed to myself , and can affirm that nerves are not only capable of being united when divided , but that the new formed substance is really and truly nerve .
, I forbear to make any animadversions on the experiments of those who have formed conclusions contrary to my own : to such I can only say , that I shall always consider myself highly honoured in having the opportunity of showing them the result of my own experiments ; and , as far as these will allow me , to convince by ocular demonstration , though I shouldfail to persuade by argument .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATE ( Tab. XVII .
) The three figures are taken from preparations now in the author 's possession , being the result of some of the experiments related in the paper .
In each figure the nerve is represented in connection with the carotid artery , to which it naturally adheres by cellular membrane .
Fig. ist .
A , the carotid artery .
B , one of the nerves of the eighth pair .
C , the part where the first division was made , as it appeared after nineteen months .
D , the part where the second division was made , and from which the dog died on the second day .
Fig. 2d .
A and B. the carotid artery and nerve of the opposite side .
C , the union which followed , the first divisions forming a swell like a ganglion .
D , the second division , made two days before death .
Fig. 3d .
The same nerve cut open .
a , b , c , represent bristles to keep the cut surfaces asunder .
MI &gt; CCXCV .
D d

