III On the Nature and Construction of the Sun andfixed Stars .
BY WILLIAM HERSCHEL , LL. D. F. R. S. *Read December i'S , i794 .
AMONG the celestial bodies the sun is certainly the first which should attract our notice .
It is a fountain of light that illuminates the world !
it is the cause of that heat which maintains the productive power-of nature , and makes the earth a fit habitation for man !
it is the central body of the planetary system ; and what renders a knowledge of its nature still more interesting to us is , that the numberless stars which compose the universe , appear , by the strictest analogy , to be similar bodies .
Their innate light is so intense , that it reaches the eye of the observer from the remotest regions of space , and forcibly claims his notice .
Now , , if we are:convinced that an inquiry into the nature and pro~perties of the sun is highly worthy of our notice , we -mTiay also with great satisfaction reflect on the considerable progress that has already been made in our knowledge of this eminent body .
It would require a long detail to enumerate all the various discoveries which have been made on this subject ; I shall , therefore , content myself with giving only the most.capital of them .
Sir IsAAC NEWTON has shown that the sun , by its attractive power , retains the planets of our system in their orbits .
He has also pointed out the method whereby the quantity of matter it contains may be accurately determined .
Dr. BRADLEY has assigned the velocity of the solar light with a degree of precision exceeding our utmost expectation .
GALILEO , SCHEINER , HEVELIUS , CASSINI , and others , have ascertained the rotation of the sun upon its axis , and determined the position of its equator .
By means of the transit of Venus over the disc of the sun , out mathematicians have calculated its distance from the earth ; its real diameter and magnitude ; the density of the matter of which it is composed and the faIl of heavy bodies on its surface .
From the particulars here enumerated , it is sufficiently obvious , that we have already a very clear idea of the vast importance , and powerful influence of the sun on its planetary system .
And if we add to this the beneficent effects we feel on this globe from the diffusion of the solar rays ; and consider that , by well traced analogies , the same effects have been proved to take place on other planets of this system ; I should not wonder if we were induced to think that nothing remained to be added in order to complete our knowledge : and yet it will not be difficult to-shew that we are still very ignorant , at least with regard to the internal construction of the sun .
The various conjectureswhich have been formed on this subject , are evident marks of the uncertainty under which we have hitherto laboured .
The dark spots in " the sun , for instance , have been supposed , to be solid bodies revolving very near its surface .
They have been conjectured to be the smoke of volcanoes , or the scum floating upon an ocean of fluid matter .
They have also been taken for clouds .
They were explained to be opaque masses , swimming in the fluid matter of the sun ; dipping down occasionally .
It has been supposed that a fiery liquid surrounded the sun , and that , by its ebbing and flowing , the highest parts of it were occasionally uncovered , and appeared under the shape of dark spots ; and that , by the return of this fiery liI quid , they were again covered , and in that manner successively assumed different phases .
The stun itself has been called a globe of fire , though perhaps metaphorically .
The waste it would undergo by a gradual consumption , on the supposition of its being ignited , has been ingeniously calculated .
And in the same -point of view its immense power of heating the bodies of such comets as draw very near to it has ' been assigned .
The bright spots , or faculx , have been called clouds of light , and luminous vapours .
The light of the suit itself has been supposed to be directly invisible , and not to be perceived unless by reflection ; though the proofs , which are brought in support of that opinion , seem to me to amount to no more than , what is sufficiently evident , that we cannot see when rays of light do not enter the eye .
But it is time to profit by the many valuable observations that we are now in possession of .
A list of successive eminent astronomers may be named , from GALILEO down to the present time ; who have furnished us with materials for examixation .
In supporting the ideas I shall-'propose in this paper , with regard to the physical construction of the sun , I have availed myself of the labours of all these astronomers , but have been induced thereto only by my own actual observation of the solar phaxnomena ; which , besides verifying those particulars that had been already observed , gave me such views of the solar regions as led to the foundation of a very rational system .
For , having the -advantage of former observations , my latest reviews of the body of the sun were immediately directed to the most essential points ; and the work was by this means facilitated , and contracted into a pretty narrow compass .
The following is a short extract of my observations on the sun , to which I have joined the consequences I now believe myself entitled to draw from them .
When all the reasonings -on the several phenomenon are put together , and a few additional arguments , taken from analogy , which I shall also add , are properly con-sidered it will be found that a general conclusion may be made which seems to throw a considerable light upon our present subject .
In the year 1779 , therewas a spot on the sun which was large enough to be seen with the naked eye .
-By ; a view of it with a 7-feet reflector , charged with a very high power , it appeared to be divided into two parts .
The largest of the two , on the 19th of April , measured A ' 8 " , o6 in diameter ; which is equal , in length , to more than ?
1 thousand miles .
Both together must certainly havre extended above 50 thousand .
The idea of its being occasioned by a volcanic explosion , violently driving away a fiery fluid , which on its return would gradually fill up the vacancy , and thus restore the sun , in that place , to its former splendour , ought to be rejected on many accounts .
, To mention only one , the great extent of the spot is very unfavourable to that ' supposition .
Indeed a much less violent and less pernicious cause may be assigned ' , to account for .
all the appearances of the spot .
When we see a dark belt near the equator of the planet Jupiter , we do not recur to earthquakes and volcanoes for its origin .
An atmosphere , with its n-atura.l changes , will explain such belts .
Our spot in the sun may be accounted for on the same principles .
The earth is surrounded by an atmosphere , composed of various elastic fluids- .
The sun also has its atmosphere , and if some of the fluids which enter into its composition should be of a shining brilliancy , in the manner that will be explained hereafter , while others are merely -transparent , any temporary cause which may remove the lucid fluid will permit us ^to see the body of the sunf through the transparent ones .
If-an observer.were placed on the -moon , ,-he w-ould see the solid body of our -earth .
only in those places.whre the transparent fluids of our atmosphere would permit hbim .
In others , the o6paque vapoturs would reflect the light-of the sun , without permitting his vieW to penetrate to the suvface oft ou0 r Jgbbe , lie would probably also find that our planaet had-occasionally some shing fluids in its atmosphere ; vas , notuinlikely , somte of-our northern lights might nt escape his notice , if they happened in the tnenlightenled part of the earth , and were teenr by him in his long dark night .
Nay , we have pretty good reason : to believe , that probably all the planets -emit .
light in some degree ; for the illumnination which remains on the moon in a total eclipse : cannot be entirely ascribed to the light which may reach it by the r-e1fraction of the earth 's atmosphere .
For -instance in the eclipse of the moon , which happened October &lt; 2q , 1790 , the rays of the sun refracted by the atmosphere of the earth towards the moon , admitting the mean horizontal refraction to be go ' -5o",8 , would meet in a focus above 189 thousand miles -beyond the moon , ; so that consequently there could be no illumination from rays refracted by our atmosphere .
It is , however , not improbable , that about the polar regions of the earth there may be refraction enough to bring some of the solar rays to a shorter focus .
The distance of the moon at the time of the eclipse would require a refraction of 54 6 " equal to its horizontal parallax at that time , to bring them to a focus so as to throw light on the moon .
The unenlightened part of the planet Venus has also been seen by different persons , and not having a satellite , those regions that are turned from the sun cannot possibly shine by a borrowed light ; so that this faint illumination must denote some phosphoric quality of the atmosphere of Venus .
In the instance of our large spot on the sun , I concluded from appearances that I viewed the real solid body of the sun itself , of which we rarely see more than its shining atmosphere .
In the year 1783 , I observed a fine large spot , and followed it up to the edge of the sun 's limb .
Here I took notice that the spot was plainly depressed below the surface of the sun ; and 'that it had very broad shelving sides .
I also suspected , some part , at least , of the shelving sides to be elevated above the surface of the sun ; and observed that , contrary to what usually happens , the margin of that side of the spot , which was farthest from the limb , was the broadest .
The luminous shelving sides of a spot may be explained by a gentle and gradual removal of the shining fluid , which permits us to see the globe of the sun .
As to the uncommon appearance of the broadest -margin being on that side of the spot which was farthest from the limb when the spot came near the edge of it , ' we may surmnise that the sun has inequalities on its surface , which may possibly be the cause of it .
For , when mountainous countries are exposed , if it should chance that the highest parts of the landscape are situated so as to be near that side of the margin , or penumbra of thespot , which is towards the limb , it may partly intercept our view of it , when the spot is seen very obliquely .
This would require elevations at least five or six hundred miles high but considering the great attraction exerted by the sun upon bodies at its surface , and the slow revolution it has upon its axis , we may readily admit inequalities to that amount .
From the centrifugal force at the sun 's equator , and the weight of bodies at its surface , I compute that the power of throwing down a mountain by the exertion of the former , balanced by the superior force of keeping it in its situation of the , latter , is near six and a half times less On the sun than on our equatorial regions ; and as an elevation similar to one of three miles on the earth would not be less than g34 miles on the sun , there can be no doubt but that a mountain much higher would stand very firmly .
The little density of the solar body seems also to be in favour of the height of its mountains ; for , ceteris paribus , dense bodies will sooner come to their level than rare ones .
The difference il1 the vanishing of the shelving side , instead of explaining it by mountains , may also , and perhaps more satisfactorily , be accounted -for from the real difference of the extent , the arrangement , the height , and the intensity of the shining fluid ' , added to the occasional changes that may happen in these particulars , during the time in which the spot approaches to the edge of the disc .
However , by admitting large mountains on the surface of the sun , we shall account for the different opinions of two eminent astronomers one of whom believed the spots depressed below the sun , while the other supposed them ele.vated above it .
For it is not improbable that some of the solar mountains may be high enough occasionally to project above the shining elastic fluid , when , by some agitation or other cause , it is not of the usual height ; and this opinion is much , strengthened by the return of some remarkable spots , which served CASSINI to ascertain the period of the sun 's rotation .
A very high country , or chain of mountains , may oftener become visible , by , the removal of the obstructing fluid , than the lower regions , on account of its not being so deeply covered with it .
In the year 1791 , I examined a large spot in the sun , , and found it evidently depressed below the level of the surface ; about the dark part was a broad margin , or plane of consi- .
derable extent , less bright than the sun , and also lower than its surface .
This plane seemed to rise , with shelving sides , up to the place where it joined the level of the surface .
In confirmation of these appearances , I carefully remarked that the disc of the sun was visibly convex ; and the reason of my attention to this particular , was my being already long ac quainted with a certain optical deception , that takes place now and then when we view the moon which isv that all the elevated spots on its surface will seiem .
to be cavities , and all cavities will assume the shape of mountains .
But then , at the same time the moon , instead of having the convex appearance of a globe , will seem to be a large concave portion of an hollow sphere .
As soon as , by the force of imagination , you drive away the fallacious appearance of a concave moon , you restore the mountains to their protuberance , and sink the cavities again below thelevel of the surface .
Now , when I saw the spot lower than the shining matter of the sun , and an extended plane , also depressed , with shelving sides rising up to the level , I also found that the sun was convex , and appeared 4i its natural globular state .
Hence I conclude that there could be no deception in those appearances .
How very ill would this observation agree with the ideas of solid bodies bobbing up and down in a fiery liquid ?
with the smoke of volcanoes , or scum upon an ocean ?
And how easily it is explained upon our foregoing theory .
The removal of the shining atmosphere , which permits us to see the , sun , must naturally be attended with a gradual diminution on its borders ; an instance of a similar kind we have daily before us , when through the opening of a cloud we see the sky , which generally is attended by a surrounding haziness of some short extent ; and seldom transits , from a perfect clearness , at once to the greatest obscurity .
Aug. 26 , 1792 .
I examined the sun with several powers , from 90 to too .
It appears evidently that the black spots are the opaque ground , or body of the sun ; and that the luminous part is an atmosphere , which , being interrupted or broken , gives us a transient glimpse of the sun itself .
My 7-feet re , flector , which is in high perfection , represents the spots , as it always used to do , much depressed below the surface of the luminous part .
Sept. 2 , i792 .
I saw two spots in the sun with the naked eye .
In the telescope I found they were clusters of spots , with many scattered ones besides .
Every one of them was certainly below the surface of the luminous disc .
Sept. 8 , 1792.-D Having made a small speculum , a merely brought to a perfect figure upon hones , without polish , I found , that by stifling a great part of the solar rays , my object speculum would bear a greater aperture ; and thus enabled me to see with more comfort , and less danger .
The surface of the sun was unequal ; many parts of it being elevated , and others depressed .
This Nisi here to be understood of the shining surface only , as the real body of the suncan probably be seldom seen , otherwise than in its black spots .
It may not be impossible , as light is a transparent fluid , that the sun 's real surface also may now and then be perceived ; as we see the shape of the wick of a candle through its flame , or the contents of a furnace in the midst of the brightest glare of it ; but this , I should suppose , will only happen where the lucid matterof the sun is not very accumulated Sept. 9 , 1792 .
I found one of the dark spots in the sun drawn pretty near the preceding edge .
In its neighbourhood I saw a great number of elevated bright places : , making various figuresI shall call them facula , with HEVELIUS ; but without assigning to this term any other meaning than what it willhereafter appear ought to be given to it .
I see these facuhe extended , on the preceding side , over about one-sixth part of the sun ; but so far from resembling torches , they appear to me like the shrivelled elevations upon a dried apple , extended in length , and most of them are joined together , making waves , or waving lines .
By some good views in the afternoon , I find that the rest of the surface of the sun does not contain any facula , except a few on the following , and equatorial part of the sun .
Towards the north and south I see no faculae there is all over the sun a great unevenness in the surface , which has the appearance of a mixture of small points of an unequal light ; but they are evidently an unevenness or roughness of high and low parts .
Sept. lax , 1792 .
The facule , in the preceding part of the 5sun , are much gone out of the disc , and those in the following are come on .
A dark spot also is come on with them .
Sept. 13 , 1 792 .
There are a great number of faculae on the equatorial part of the sun , towards the preceding and following parts .
I cannot see any towards the poles ; but a roughness is visible every where .
Sept. i6 , 1792 .
The sun contains many large faculae , on the following side of its equator , and also several on the preceding side .
I perceive none about the poles .
They seem generally to accompany the spots , and probably , as the faculx certainly are elevations , a great number of them may occasion neighbouring depressions : that is to say , dark spots .
The faculae being elevations , very satisfactorily explains the reason why they disappear towards the middle of the sun , and re-appear on ; the other margin ; for , about the place where we lose them , they begin to be edge-ways to our view ; and if between the faculae should lie dark spots , they will most frequently break out in the middle of the sun , because they are no longer covered by the side views of these facule .
Sept. 22 , 1792 .
There are not many facula in the sun , and but few spots ; the whole disc , however , is very much marked with roughness , like an orange .
Some of the lowest parts of the inequalities are blackish .
Sept. 23 , 1792 .
The following side of the sun contains many facule , near the limb .
They take up an arch of about So degrees .
There are , likewise , some on the preceding side .
The north and squth is rough as usual ; but differently disposed .
The faculae are ridges of elevations above the rough surface .
Feb. 23 , 1794 .
By an experiment I have just now tried , I find it confirmed that the sun cannot be so distinctly viewed with a small aperture and faint darkening glasses , as with a large aperture and stronger ones ; this latter is the method I always use .
One of the black spots on the preceding margin , which was greatly below the surface of the sun , had , next to it , a protuberant lump of shining matter , a little brighter than the rest of the sun .
About all the spots , the shining matter seems to have been disturbed ; and is uneven , lumpy , and zig-zagged in an irregular manner .
I call the spots black , not that they are entirely so , but merely to distinguish them ; for there is not one of them , ^ to-day , which is not partly , or entirely , covered over with whitish and unequally bright nebulosity , or cloudiness .
This , in many of them , comes near to an extinction of the spot ; and in others , seems to bring on a subdivision .
Sept 28 , 1794 .
There is a dark spot in the sun on the following side .
It is certainly depressed below the shining atmosphere , and has shelving sides of shining matter , which rise up higher than the general surface , and are brightest at the top .
The preceding shelving side is rendered almost invisible , by the overhanging of the preceding elevations ; while the following is very well exposed:the spot being apparently such in figure as denotes a circular form , viewed in an oblique direction .
Near the following margin are many bright elevations , close to visible depressions .
The depressed parts are less bright than the common surface .
The penumbra , as it is called , about this spot , is a consi derable plane , of less brightness than the common surface , and seems .
to be as much depressed below that surface as the spot is below the plane .
Hence , if the brightness of the sun is occasioned by the lucid atmosphere , the intensity of the brightness .
must be less where it is depressed ; for light , being transparent , must be the more intense the more it is deep .
Oct. 12 , 1794 .
The whole surface of the sun is diversified by inequality in the elevation of the shining atmosphere .
The lowest parts are every where darkest ; and every little pit has the appearance of a more ' or less dark spot .
A dark spot , which is on the preceding side , is surrounded by very great inequalities in the elevation of the lucid atmosphere ; and its depression below the same is bounded by an immediate rising of very bright light .
Oct. 13 , 1794 .
The spot in the sun , I observed yesterday is drawn so near the margin that the elevated side of the fob .
lowing part of it hides all the black ground , and still leaves the cavity visible , so that the depression of the black spots , and the elevation of the facule , are equally evident .
It will ' now be easy to bring the result of these observations into a very narrow compass .
That the sun has -a very extensive atmosphere cannot be doubted ; and that thisatmosphere consists of various elastic fluids , that are more or less lucid and transparent , and of which the lucid one is that which furnishes us with light , seems also to be -fully established by all , the phenomena of its spots , of the facuw , and of the lucid surface itself .
There is no kind of Variety in these appearances what may be-accounted for with the greatest facility , from the continual agitations which we may easily canceive must take place in the regions of such extensive elastic fluids .
It will be , lecessary , however , to be a little more particular , as to the manner in which !
I suppose the lucid fluid of the sun to be generated in its atmosphere .
An an'alogy that may be drawn from the generation of clouds in our own atmosphere .
seems to be a very proper one , and full of instruction .
Our clouds are probably decompositions of some-of the elastic fluids of the atmosphere itself , when such natural causes , as in this grand chemical laboratory are generally at work , act upon them ; we may therefore admit that in the very extensive atmosphere of the sun , from causes of the same nature , similar phaoeomena will take place ; but with this difference , that , the continual and very extensive decompositions of the elastic fluids of the sun , are of a phosphoricnature , and attended with lucid appearances , by giving out light .
If it should be objected , that such violent and unremitting decompositions would exhaust the sun , we may recur , again to our analogy , which will furnish us with the following reflections .
The extent of our own atmosphere , we see , is still preserved , notwithstanding the copious decompositions of its fluids , in clouds and falling rain ; in flashes of lightning , in meteors , and other luminous phenomenon ; because there are fresh supplies of elastic vapours , continually ascending to make good the waste occasioned by those decompositions .
But it may be urged , that the case with the decomposition of the elastic fluids in the solar atmosphere would be very different , since light is emitted , and does not return to the sun , as clouds do to the earth when they descend in showers of rain .
To which I answer , that in the decomposition of.phosphoric fluids every other ingredient but light may also return to the body of the sun .
And that the emission of light .
must waste the.sun , is not a difficulty that can be opposed to our hypothesis.::For as it is an evident fact that the sun does emit light , the same objection , if it could be one , would equally militate against every other assignable way to account for the phaenomenona .
There -are moreover considerations that may lessen the pres-t sure of this alleged difficulty .
We know , the exceeding subtilty of light to be such , that in ages of time its emanation from the sun -cannot very sensibly lessen the size of this great.body .
To this may be added , that , very possibly , there may also be ways of restoration to compensate for what is lost by the emission of light ; though the manner in which this can be brought about should not appear to us .
Many of the operations of nature are carried oif in her great laboratory , which we cannot comprehend but now and then we see some of the tools with which she is at work .
We need not wonder that their construction should be so singular as to induce us to confess our ignorance of the method of employing them- , but we may rest assured that they are not a mere lisus naturw .
I allude to thie great number of small telescopic comets that have been observed ; and to ' the , far greater number still that are probably much too small for being noticed-by bur most diligent searchers after them .
Those six , for instance , .
which my sister ha~sfdiscovered , I can froihm-examination affirm had not the least .
appearance of any solid nucleus , andseemed to be mere collections of vapours condensed about a ' centre .
Five more , thatI have also observed , were nearly of , thie.same .
nature .
This throws a mystery over their destination , which seems to place them in the allegorical view of tools , probably designed for somesalutary .
purposes to be wrought by -them ; and , whether the restoration..of what is lost to the sun bythe emission of light , .
the possibility-of which we have been mentioning above , may not be one of these purposes , I shall .
not presume to determine .
The motion of the comet discovered by Mr. MESSIER in June , 177.o , plainly indicated how much its orbit wasg liable to be changed , by the perturbations of the planets ; from which , and the little agreement that can be found between the elements of the orbits of all the comets that have been observed , it appears clearly that they may be directed to carry their salutary influence to any part of the heavens .
My hypothesis , however , as before observed , does not lay me under any obligation to explain how the sun can sustain the waste of light , nor to show that it will sustain it for ever ; and I should also remark that , as in the analogy of generating clouds I merely allude to their production as .
owing to a decomposition of some of the elastic fluids of our atmosphere , that analogy , which firmly rests upon the fact , will not be less to my purpose to whatever cause these clouds may owe their origin .
It is the same with the lucid clouds , if I mayso call them , of the sun .
They plainly exist , because we see them ; the manner of their being generated may remain an hypothesis ; and mine , till a better can be proposed , may stand good ; but whether it does or not , the consequences I am going to draw from what has been said will not be affected by it .
Before I proceed , I shall only point out , that according to the above theory , a dark spot in the sun is a place in its atmosphere which happens to be free from luminous decompositions , ; and that facula are , on the -contrary , more copiousriixtutres of such fluids as decompose each other .
The pe.numbra which attends the spots % being generally depressed more or less .
to about half way between the solid body of the sun and : the upper part of those regions in which luminous de- " compositions take place , must of course be fainter than other parts .
No spot favourable for taking measures having lately been on the sun , I can only judge , from former appearances , that the regions in which the luminous solar clouds are formed , adding thereto the elevation of the faculae , cannot be less than 1843 , nor much .
more than 2765 miles in depth .
It is true that in our atmosphere the extent of the clouds is limited to was very narrow compass ; but we ought rather to compare the solar ones to the luminous decompositions which take place in our aurora borealis , or luminous arches , which extend much farther than the cloudy regions .
The density of the luminous solar clouds ) though very great , may not be exceedingly more so than that of our aurora borealis .
For , if we consider what would be the brilliancy of a space two or three thousand miles deep , filledwith such corruscations as we see now and then in our atmosphere , their apparent intensity , when viewed at the distance of the sun , might not be much inferior to that of the lucid solar fluid .
From the lumin ous atmosphee of the sun I proceed to its opaque body , which by calculation from the pdwer it exerts upon the planets we know to be of great solidity ; and from the phbnomena of the dark spots , many of which , probably on account of their high situations , have been repeatedly seen , and otherwise denote inequalities in their level , we surmise that its surface is diversified with mountains and vallies .
What has been said enablesus to come to some very important conclusions , by remarking , that this way of considering the sun and its atmosphere , removes the great dissimilarity we have hitherto been used to find between its condition and that of the rest of the great bodies of the solar ysstem .
The sun , viewed in this light , appears to be nothing else than a very eminent , large , and lucidplanet , evidently the first , or in strictness of speaking , the only primary one of our system ; all others being trulysecondary to it .
I lts similarity to the other globes of the solar system with regard to its solidity , its atmosphere , and its diversified surface ; the rotation upon its axis , and the fall of heavy bodies , leads us on to suppose that it is most-probably also inhabited , like the rest of the planets , by beings whose organs are adapted to the peculiar circumstances of-that vast globe .
-Whatever fanciful poets might say , in making the.sun the abode of blessed spirits , or angry moralists devise , in pointing it out as a fit place for the punishment of the wickedi , it does not appear that they had any other foundation for their assers tions than mere opinion and vague surmise ; but now I think myself authorized , upon , astronomical principles , to propose the sun as an inhabitable world , and am persuaded that the foregoing observations , with the conclusions I have drawn from them , arefully sufficient to answer every objection that may be made against it .
It may , however , not be amiss to remove a certain difficulty , which arises from the effect of the sun 's rays upon our globe .
The heat which is here , at the distance of 9,5 millions of miles , produced by these rays , is so considerable , that it may be objected , that the surface of the globe of the sun itself must be scorched up beyond all conception .
Thismay be very substantially answered by many proofs drawn from natural -philosophy , which show that heat is produced by the -sun 's rays only whenthey act -upon a calorific medium ; , they are the cause of the production of heat , by tiniting with the matter of fire , which is contained in the substances that are heated : as the collision of flint and steel will inflame a magazine of gunpowder , by putting all the latent fire it contains into action .
But an instance or two of the manner in which the solar rays produce their effect , will bring this home to our most common experience .
On the tops of mountains of a sufficient height , at an altitude where clouds can very seldom reach , to shelter them from the direct rays of the sun , we always find regions of ice and .
snow .
Now if the solar rays themselves : conveyed all the heat we find on this globe , it ought to be hottest where their course is least interrupted .
Again , our aeronauts all confirm the coldness of the upper regions of the atmosphere ; and since , therefore , even on our earth the heat of any situation depends upon the aptness of the-.mediumto yield to the impression of the solar rays , we have onlyto admit , that on the sun itself , the elastic fluids composing its atmosphere , and the matter , on its surface , are of such a nature as not to be capable of any excessive affection from its own rays ; and , indeed , this seemsto be proved by the copious emission of them for if the elastic fluids of the atmosphere , or the matter contained on the surface of the sun , were of such a nature as to admit of an easy , chemical combination with its rays , their emission would be much impeded .
Another well known fact is , that the solar , focus of the largest lens , thrown into the air , will occasionno sensible heat in the place where it has been kept -for a considerable time , although its power of exciting combustion , when proper bodies are exposed , should be sufficient to fuse the most refractory substances.* It will not be necessary to mention other objections , as I can think of none that may be made , but what a proper consideration of the foregoing observations will easily remove ; such as may be urged from the dissimilarity between the luminous atmosphere of the sun and that of our globe will be touched upon hereafter , when I consider the objections that may be assigned against the moon 's being an inhabitable satellite .
I shall now endeavour , by analogical reasonings , to support the ideas I have suggested concerning the construction and purposes of the sun ; in order to which , it will be necessary to begin with such arguments as the nature of the case will admit , to show that our moon is probably inhabited .
This satellite is of all the heavenly bodies the nearest , and therefore most within the reach of our telescopes .
Accordingly we find , ' by repeated inspection , that we can with perfect confidence give the following account of it .
It is a secondary planet , of a considerable ' size ; the surface of which is diversified , like that of the earth , by mountains and vallies .
Its situation , with respect to the sun , is much like that of the earth ; and , by a rotation on its axis , it enjoys an agreeable variety of seasons , and of day and night .
To the moon , our globe will appear to be a very capital satellite .
; undergoing the same -regular changes of illuminations as the moon does to the earth .
, The sun the planets , and the starry constellations of the heavens , will rise and set there as they do here ; and heavy bodies will fall on the moon as they do on the earth .
There seems only to be wanting , in order to comrplete the analogy that it should be inhabited like theearth .
To this0 -it may be objected , that we perceive no large seas in the moon ; that its atmosphere ( the existence of which has even been doubted by many ) is extremely rare , and unfit fr the purposes of animal life ; , that its climates , its seasons , and the length-of its days , totally differ from ours ; that without dense clouds ( which the moon has not ) , there can -be no rain , perhaps no rivers , no lakes .
In short that , notwithstanding the similarity which has been pointed out , thereseems to be a decided difference in the two planets we have compared .
MY answer to this will be , that that very difference which is now objected , will rather strengthen the force of my argument than lessen its value : we find , even upon our globe ; that there is the most striking difference in the situationsof the creatures that live upon it .
While man walks up on the ground , the birds fly in the air , and fishes swim in water ; ' we can certainly not object to the conveniences afforded by the moon , if those that are to Inhabit its regions are fitted to their conditions as well as we on this globe are to ours .
An absolute , or total samneness , seems rather to denote imperfections , such as nature never exposes to our view ; and , on this account , I believe the analogies that have been mentioned fully sufficient to establish the high probability of the moon 's being inhabited like the earth .
To proceed , we will now suppose an inhabitant of the moon , whQ hasnot properly considered such analogical reasonings as might induce him to surmise that our earth is inhabited , were to give it as his opinion that the use of that great body , whichhe sees in his neighbourhood , is to carry about his little globe , that it may be properly exposed to the light of the ; sun , so as to enjoy an agreeable and useful variety of illumination , as well-as to give it light by reflection from the sun , when direct daylight cannot be had .
Suppose also that the inhabitants .
of the satellites of Jupiter , Saturn , and the Georgian planet , were to look upon the primary ones , to which they belong , as mere attractive centres , to keep together their orbits , to direct their revolution round the sun , and to supply them with reflected light in the absence of direct illumination .
Ought we not to condemn their ignorance , as proceeding from w want of attention and proper reflection ?
It is very true that the earth , and those other planets that have satellites about them , perform all the offices that have been named , for the inhabitants of these little globes ; but to us , who live upon one of these planets , their reasonings cannot but appear very defective ; when we see what a magnificent dwelling place the earth affords to numberless intelligent beings .
These considerations ought to make the inhabitants of the planets wiser than we have supposed those of their satellites to be .
We surely ought not , like them , to say " the sun ( that " immense globe , whose body would much more than fill the " whole orbit of the moon ) is merely an attractive centre to " us .
" From experience we can affirm , that the performance of the most salutary offices to inferior planets , is not inconsistent with the dignity of superior purposes ; and , in consequence of such ; analogical reasonings , assisted by telescopic views , which plainly favour the same opinion , we need not hesitate to admit that the sun is richly stored with inhabitants .
This way of considering the sun is of the utmost importance in its consequences .
That stars are suns can hardly adm it of a doubt .
Their immense distance would perfectly exclude them from our view , if the light they send us were not of the solar kind .
Besides , the analogy may be traced much farther .
The sun turns on its axis .
So does the star Algol .
So do the stars called P Lyra , S Cephei , V Antinoi , o Ceti , and many more ; most probably all .
From what other cause can we so probably account for their periodical changes . ?
Again , our sun has spots on its surface .
So has the star Algol ; and so have the stars already named and probably every star in the heavens .
On our sun these spots are Changeable .
So they are on the star o Ceti ; as evidently appears from the irregularity of its changeable lustre , which is often broken in upon by accidental changes , while the general period continues unaltered .
The same little deviations have been observed in other periodical stars , and ought to be ascribed to the same cause .
But if stars are suns , and suns are inhabitable , we see at once what an extensive field for animation opens itself to our view .
It is true that analogy may induce us to conclude , that since stars appear to be 'suns , and suns , according to the common opinion , are bodies that serve to enlighten , warm , and sustain a system of planets , we may have an idea of numberless globes that serve for the habitation of living creatures .
But if these suns themselves are primary planets , we may see some thousands of them with our own eyes ; and millions by the help of telescopes ; when at the same time , the same analogical reasonings still remainsin full force , with regard to the planets which these suns may:support .
In this place I may , however take -notice that , from other considerations the idea of suns or stars being merely the supporters of systems of planets is not absolutely to be admitted as a general one .
Among the great number of very compressed clusters of stars , I have given in my catalogues , there are some which open a different view of the heavens to us .
The stars in them are so very close together , that , notwithstanding .
the great distance at which we may suppose the cluster itself to be , it will hardly be possible to assign any sufficient mutual distance to the stars composing the cluster , to leave room for crowding in those planets , for whose support these stars have -been , or might be , supposed to exist .
It should seem , therefore , highly probable that they exist for themselves ; and are , in fact , only very capital , lucid , primary planets , connected together in one great system : of mutual support .
As in this argument I do not proceed upon conjectures , but have actual observations in view , I shall mention an instance in the clusters , No. 26 , 28 , and 35 , VI .
class , of my catalogue of nebula , and clusters of stars .
( See Phil. Trans. Vol. LXXIX .
Part II P. 251 .
) The stars in them are so crowded , that I cannot conjecture them to be at a greater apparent distance from each other than five seconds ; even after a proper allowance for such stars , as on a supposition of a globular form of the cluster , will interfere with one another , has been made .
Now , if we would leave as much room between each of these stars as there is between the sun land Sirius , we must place these clusters 42104 times as far from us as that star is from the sun .
But-in order to bring down the lustre of Sirius to that of an equal star placed , at such a -distance , I ought to reduce the aperture of my ?
o-feet telescope to less tha the twoand-twenty hundredth part of an inch ; when certainly I could no -longer expect to see any star at all .
; The same remark may be made , with regard to the number of very close double stars- ; whose apparent diameters being alike , and not very small , do not indicate any very great mutual distance .
From which , however , must be deducted all those where the different distances may be compensated by the real difference in their respective magnitudes .
To what has been said may be added , that in some parts of the milky way , where yet the stars are not very small , they are so crowded , that in the year 1792 , Aug. 22 1 found by the gages that , in 41 minutes of time , no less than 258 thousand of them had passed through the field of view of my telescope.* It seems , therefore , upon the whole not improbable that , in many cases , stars are united insuch close , systems as not to leave much room for the orbits of planets , or comets 7 and that consequently , upon this account also , .
many stars , unless we would make them -mere uiseless brilliant points , may themselves be-lucid planets , perhaps unattended-by satellites .
POSTSC RI PT .
The following observations , which were made with an improved apparatus , and under the most favourable circumstances , should be added to those which have been given .
They are decisive with regard to one of the conditions of the lucid imatter of the sun .
' Nov. 26 , 1794 Eight spots in the sun , and several subdi visions of them , are all equally depressed .
The sun is mottled every where .
The mottled appearance of the sun is owing to an inequality in the level of the surface .
The sun is equally mottled at its poles and at its equator ; ?
but the mottled appearances may be seenbetter about the middle of the disc than towards the circumference , on account of the sun 's spherical form .
The unevenness arising from the elevation and depression of the mottled appearance on the surface of the sun , seems , in -many places , to amount to as much , or to nearly as much as the depression of the penumbrae of the spots below the upper part of the shining substance ; without including faculae , which are protuberant .
The lucid substance of the sun is neither a liquid , nor an elastic fluid ; , as is evident from its not instantly fillingup the cavities of the spots , and of the unevenness of the mottled parts .
It ex ' ts , therefore , in , the manner of lucid clouds swimming in the transparent atmosphere of the sun or ra .
there , of luminous decompositions taking place within that atnjosphere .

