XVIII .
Experiments on carbonated hydrogenous Gas ; with a View to determine whether Carbon be a simple or a compound Substance .
By Mr. William Henry .
Communicated by Mr. Thomas Henry , F. R. S. Read June 29 , 1797 .
THE progress of chemical science depends not only on the acquisition of new facts , but on the accurate establishment , and just valuation , of those we already possess : for its general principles will otherwise be liable to frequent subversions ; and the mutabilityof its doctrines will but illaccord with the unvaried order of nature .
Impressed with this conviction , I have been in .
duced to examine a late attempt to withdrawfrom itsrank among the elementary bodies , one of the most interesting objects of chemistry .
The inferences respecting the composition of charcoal , deduced by Dr. AuSTIN from his experiments on the heavy inflammable air , * lead to changes so numerous in our explanations of natural phenomena , that they ought not to be admitted without the strictest scrutiny of the reasoning of this philosopher , and an attentive repetition of the experiments themselves .
In the former , sources of fallacy may , I think , be easily detected ; and in the latter , there is reason to suspect that Dr. AUSTIN has been misled by inattention to some collateral circumstances .
Several chemists , however , of distinguished rank have expressed themselves satisfied with the evidence thus produced in favour of the composition of charcoal ; and amongst these it may be sufficient to mention Dr. BEDDOES , who has availed himself of the theory of Dr. AUSTIN , in explaining some appearances that attend the conversion of cast into malleable iron .
The heavy inflammable air , having been proved to consist of a solution of pure charcoal in light inflammable air , is termed , in the new nomenclature , carbonated hydrogenous gas .
By -repeatedly passing the electric shock through a small quantity of this gas , confined in a bent tube over mercury , Dr. AuSTIN found that it was permanently dilated to more than twice its original volume .
An expansion so remarkable could not , as he observes , be occasioned by any other known cause than the evolution of light inflammable air .
When the electrified air was fired with oxygenous gas , it was found that more oxygen was required for its saturation than before the action of the electric fluid ; which proves that , by this process , an actual addition was made of combustible matter .
The light inflammable air disengaged by the electrization , proceeded , without doubt , from the decomposition of some substance within the influence of the electric fluid , and not merely from the expansion of that contained in the carbonated hydrogenous gas : for had the quantity of hydrogen remained unaltered , and its state of dilatation only been changed , there would not , after electrization , have been any increased consumption of oxygen .
The only substances in contact with the glass tube and mercury , in these experiments , besides the hydrogen of the dense * Phil. Trans. Vol. LXXXI .
inflammable gas , were carbon and water ; which last , though probably not a constituent of gases , is , however , copiously diffused through them .
If the evolved hydrogen proceeded from the decomposition of the former of these two substances , it is evident that a certain volume of the carbonated hydrogenous gas must yield , after electrization , on combustion with oxygen , less carbonic acid than an equal volume of non-electrified gas ; or , in other words , the inflammation of 20 measures of carbonated hydrogen , expanded by electricity from lo , should not afford so much carbonic acid as lo measures of the unelectrified .
From the fact which has been before stated , respecting the inA creased consumption of oxygen by the electrified air , it follows , that in determining the quantity of its carbon by combustion , .
such an addition of oxygen should be made , to that necessary for the saturation of the gas before exposure to the electric shock , as will completely saturate the evolved hydrogen .
For if this caution be not observed , we may reasonably suspect that the product of carbonic acid is diminished , only because a part of the heavy inflammable air has escaped combustion .
It might , indeed , be supposed , that in consequence of the superior affinity of carbon for oxygen , the whole of the former substance , contained in the dense inflammable gas , would be saturated , and changed into carbonic acid , before the attraction of hydrogen for oxygen could operate in the production of water .
But I have found that the residue , after inflaming the carbonated hydrogenous gas with a deficiency of oxygen , and removing the carbonic acid , is not simply hydrogenous but carbonated hydrogenous gas .
In the 2d , 5th , and .
6th of Dr. AUSTIN 's experiments , in which the quantity of carbon , in the electrified gas , was exa mnined by deflagrating it with oxygen , the combustion was incomplete , because a sufficiency of oxygen was not employed ; and Dr. AUSTIN himself was aware that , in each of them , " c a " small quantity of heavy inflammable air might escape unal"tered .
" It is observable , also , that the product of carbonic acid , from the electrified gas , increased in proportion as the combustion was more perfect .
We may infer , therefore , that if it had been complete , there would have been no deficiency of this acid gas , and consequently no indication of a decomposition of charcoal .
A strong objection , however , is applicable to these , as well as to most of Dr. AUSTIN'S experiments , that the residues were not examined with sufficient attention .
In one instance we are told , that the remaining gas was inflammable , and in another , that it supported combustion like vital air .
I need hardly remark , that a satisfactory analysis cannot be attained of any substance , without the most scrupulous regard not only to the qualities , but to the precise quantities of the products of our operations .
To the 8th and 9th experiments , the objection may be urged with additional weight , ' which has been brought against the preceding ones , that the quantity of oxygen , instead of being duly increased in the combustion of the electrified gas , was , on the contrary , diminished .
Thus , in the 8th experiment , 2,83 measures of carbonated .
hydrogen were-inflamed with 4,58 measures of oxygenous gas ; but in the 9th , though the 2,83 measures were dilated to 5716 , and had therefore received a considerable addition of combustible matter , the oxygen employed was only 4 , og .
To the rest of Dr. AuSTIN 's experiments either one or both of the above objections are applicable .
The first and most important step , therefore , in the repetition of these experiments , is to determine , whether the carbonated hydrogenous gas really sustains , by the process of electrization , a diminution of its quantity of carbon ; because , should this be decided in the negative , we derive from the fact a very useful direction in ascertaining the true source of the evolved hydrogen .
The following experiments were therefore made with a view to decide this question , and the error of Dr. AUSTIN , in employing too little oxygen , was carefully avoided.* Experiment i. In a bent tube , standing inverted over mercury , 94,5 measures of carbonated hydrogenous gas from acetite of pot-ash , were mixed with 107,5 of oxygen .
The total , 202 , was reduced by an explosion to 128,5 , and was farther contracted by lime water to EG .
A solution of hepar sulphuris left only 23 measures .
The diminution by lime water , viz. 74,5 measures , makes known to us the quantity of carbonic acid afforded by the combustion of 94,5 measures of carbonated hydrogenous gas : and the residue after the action of hepar sulphuris , viz. 23 measures , gives the proportion of azotic gas contained in the carbonated hydrogen ; for the oxygenous gaz employed , which was procured from oxygenated muriate of pot-ash , was so pure , that the small quantity used in this experiment could not contain a measurable portion of azotic gas .
Experiment 2 .
The same quantity of carbonated hydrogen was expanded by repeated electrical shocks to i 88 measures .
The addition of hydrogenous gas , therefore , amounted to 93 5 .
The gas , thus dilated , was fired , at different times , with 392,5 measures of oxygenous gas ; and the residue , after these several explosions was 203 measures .
Lime water reduced it to 1928,5 , and sulphur of pot-ash to 1 9 .
In this instance , as in the for .
mer one , the product of carbonic acid is 74,5 measures .
Finding , from the first experiment and other similar ones , that the carbonated hydrogenous gas , which was the subject of them , contained a very large admixture of azotic gas , I again submitted to distillation a quantity of the acetite of pot-ash , with every precaution to prevent the adulteration of the product with atmospherical air .
Such an adulteration , I have observed , impedes considerably the dilatation of the gas , and for a time even entirely prevents it .
This explains the failure , which some experienced chemists have met with , in their attempts to expand the carbonated hydrogenous gas by electricity .
Gas which is thus vitiated becomes , however , capable of expansion , after exposure to the sulphur of pot-ash .
Experiment 3 .
Carbonated hydrogen 340 measures were exploded with the proper proportion of oxygenous gas .
The carbonic acid produced amounted to 380 measures , and the residue of azotic gas was 20 measures .
Experiment 4 .
The same quantity , when expanded to 690 , gave on combustion 380 measures of carbonic acid , and 19,8 of azotic gas .
Experiment 7 .
Three hundred and fifteen measures of carbonated hydrogen yielded 359 measures of carbonic acid , and i8,5 measures of azote .
Experiment 6 .
The same quantity , after expansion to 60o , afforded the same products of carbonic acid and azotic gases .
Experiments 7 and 8 .
As much carbonic acid was obtained by the combustion of 408 measures of carbonated hydrogenous gas , expanded from 2o0 , as from 200 measures of the non-electric fired gas ; and the residues of azotic gas were the same in both cases .
It is unnecessary to state the particulars of several other experiments , similar to those above related , which were attended with the same results .
They sufficiently prove that the action of the electric spark , when passed through carbonated hydrogenous gas , is not exerted in .
the decomposition of carbon ; for the same quantity of this substance is found after as before electrization .
Even granting that charcoal is a compound , the constituents of which are held together by a very forcible affinity , it does not appear likely that the agency of the electric shock , which seems , in this instance , analogous to that of caloric , should effect its decomposition under the circumstances of these experiments .
For it is a known property of charcoalto decompose water , when aided by a high temperature ; and its union with oxygen 'is a much more probable event , when this body is present , than a separation into its constituent principles- .
As an argument , also , that water is the source of the light inflammable air in this process , it may be observed , that the dilatation in Dr. AuSTIN'S experiments could never be carried much farther than twice the original bulk of the gas.* This fact evidently implies that the expansion ceased only in consequence of the entire destruction of the matter , whose decomposition afforded the light inflammable air , and this substance couldnot be carbon , because Dr. AUSTIN admits that a large portion , and I have shown that the whole of it , still remains unaltered .
If the dilatation of the carbonated hydrogenous gas arose from the decomposition of water , the effect should cease when this fluid is previously abstracted .
To ascertain whether this consequence would really follow , I exposed a portion of the gas , for several days before electrization , to dry caustic alkali .
On attempting its expansion , I found that it could not be carried beyond onesixth the original bulk of the gas .
By 16o very strong explosions it attained this small degree of dilatation , but 8o more produced not the least effect ; though the former number would have been amply sufficient to have dilated the gas , in its ordinary state , to more than twice its original volume .
A drop or two of water being admitted to this portion of gas , the expansion went on as usual ; and I may here observe , that when a little water gained admission into the tube along with the gas , in any experiment , which often happened before I had acquired sufficient expertness in transferring the air from water to mercury , the dilatation went on with remarkable rapidity .
Carbonic acid gas , according to the discovery of M. MONGE , * undergoes , when submitted to the electric shock , a change similar to that effected on the carbonated hydrogen ; and the expansion has been shown , by Messrs. LANDRIANI and VAN MARUM , t to be owing to the same cause , viz , the extrication of light inflammable air .
The added gas , M. MONGE ably contends , cannot proceed from any other source than the water held in solution by all aeriform bodies , the oxygen of which he supposes to combine with the mercury .
That the decomponent of the water , however , in the experiments which I have described , is not a metallic body , will appear highly probable when we reflect that there is present in them a combustible substance , viz. charcoal , which attracts oxygen much more strongly than metals ; and the following experiments evince that the mercury , by which the air was confined , had no share in producing the phoenomena .
Experiment g. A portion of carbonated hydrogenous gas .
was introduced into a glass tube closed at one end , into which a piece of gold wire was inserted that projected both within and without the cavity of the tube .
The open end of the tube was then closed by a stopper perforated also with gold wire , so that electric shocks could be passed through the confined air , without the contact of any metal that has the power of decomposing water .
On opening the tube with its mouth downwards , under water , a quantity of airimmediately rushed out. .
Experiment i o. The dilatation of the gas was found to proceed very rapidly when standing over water , and exposed to the action of the electric fluid , conveyed by gold conductors .
We have only , therefore , in the two preceding experiments ; , one substance in contact with the gas which is capable of decomposing water , viz. charcoal .
Theunion of this body with the oxygen of the water would be rendered palpable by the formation of carbonic acid ; but Dr. AUSTIN did not observe that any precipitation was occasioned in lime water , by agitating it with the electrified gas .
On passing up syrup of violets to the electrified air , with the expectation of its indicating the volatile alkali , as in the experiments of Dr. AUsTIN , no change of colour took place , though the test was of unexceptionable purity .
On examining , however , whether any alteration of bulk had been produced in the air by the contact of this liquid , it appeared that of 709 measures , loo had been absorbed .
Suspecting that the absorption was owing to the presence of carbonic acid , I introduced some lime water to a volume of the expanded gas amounting to 5,6 measures , when they were immediately reduced to 512 .
The contraction would probably have been still more remarkable if the gas had been farther expanded before the admission of the liquid .
The change in the lime water was very trifling ; but my friend Mr. Rupp , who witnessed this as well as several of the other experiments , and who ismuch conversant in the observation of chemical facts , was satisfied that , after a while , he saw small flocculi of a precipitate on the surface of the mercury .
This contraction of bulk cannot be ascribed to any other cause than the absorption of carbonic acid ; for besides the fact that the colour of syrup of violets and of turmeric , which I also tried , .
were not affected by exposure to the electrified gas , I have this objection to the absorbed gas being ammoniac , that no diminution either of bulk or transparency occurred on the admixture of muriatic acid gas with the electrified air ; whereas ammoniac woull have been exhibited under the form of a neutral salt .
When water was passed up to this mixture of the two gases , there was an absorption not only of the muriatic gas , but of something more .
Conceiving that the demolition of charcoal , by the action of the electric fluid , was sufficiently proved by his experiments , Dr. AUSTIN assigns the evolved hydrogen as one of its constituents , and the other he concludes to be azote .
Thi &amp; inference , however , rests almost entirely upon estimates , in which material errors may be discovered .
Some of these it may be well to point out , for the satisfaction of such as have acquiesced in Dr. AUSTIN'S opinion .
The carbonated hydrogenous gas submitted to Dr. AUSTIN KS experiments clearly appears , from his own account , to have been largely adulterated with azotic gas .
One source of its impurity he has disclosed , by informing us that the gas " c had " 9 been very long exposed to water ; " * for Dr. HIGGINS has somewhere shown that the heavy inflammable air , after standing long over water , leaves a larger residue of azote , on comnbustion , than when recently prepared . ?
It is probable also , that the proportion of azote derived from the water , would increase with the time of its exposure ; and thus a fertile source of error is suggested , which appears wholly to have escaped Dr. AUSTIN'S attention .
In repeating his experiments , I was careful that comparative ones , on two equal quantities of the electrified and unelectrified gas , should .
be made without the intervention of any time that could vary the proportion of azote in either of the gases .
To the 9th experiment , in which the quantity of azote seems to have been increased by electrization , I must repeat the objection , that a sufficiency of oxygenous gas was not used in the combustion .
In the 8th experiment , 2,83 of the unelectrified air were fired with 4,17 oxygenous gas , and only o01 of the latter remained above what was sufficient for saturation ; but in the 9th , though the 2,83 measures were expanded to 5,16 , the quantity of oxygen employed was o , o8 less than in the former experiment ; and it may therefore be presumed that a , smuall quantity of inflammable air might escape unaltered , and might add apparently to the product of azote .
In the 8th experiment also , the portion of oxygenous gas that was more than sufficient to saturate the carbonated hydrogen , would probably comibine , in part , with the remaining azote , as in the experiments of Dr. HIGGINS * and Dr. PRIESTLEY .
f But in the 9th , the quantity of oxygenous gas was hardly sufficient to saturate both kinds of inflammable air after electrization , and could not therefore diminish the azotic gas .
When the proportion of oxygen is duly increased , and the inflammation of the electrified air is performed in small portions , there is no augmentation , but on the contrary a decrease of the quantity of the azote , as will appear on comparing the ist and 2d of the experiments which I have related , Trwo circumstances were observed , in the experiments of Dr. AuSTIN , which have not been noticed in the preceding account of the repetition of them , viz. the appearance of a deposit from the carbonated hydrogenous gas during its electrization , and the formation of ammoniac by the same process .
In some experiments , which I made on the first portion of gas , both these facts were sufficiently apparent ; but neither of them occurred on electrifying the gas which was afterwards procured .
Suspecting that the cessation of them arose from the superior purity of the latter portion from azotic gas , I passed the electric shock through a mixture of carbonated hydrogen with about one-fourth its bulk of azote , and thus again produced the precipitate , which would have been of a white colour , if it had not been obscured by minute globules of mercury , that were driven -upwards by the force of the explosion .
An infusion of violets was tinged green when admitted to the electrified gas ; but the change of colour did not occur instantly , as happens from the absorption of ammoniacal gas ; and required for its production that the liquid should be brought extensively into contact with the inner surface of the tube .
From this effect on a blue vegetable colour , we may infer that the precipitate was an alkaline substance , and probably the carbonate of ammoniac ; but the quantity was much too minute to be the subject of more decisive experiment .
I shall conclude this memoir , with a brief summary of the facts that are established by the preceding experiments .
* Those included under the first head are deducible from the experiments of Dr. AUSTIN .
1.Carbonated hydrogenous gas , in its ordinary state , is permanently dilated by the electric shock to more than twice its original volume ; and as light inflammable air is the only substance we are acquainted with , that is capable of occasioning so great an expansion , and of exhibiting the phanomena that appear on firing the electrified gas with oxygen , we may ascribe the : dilatation to the production of hydrogenous gas .
2 .
The hydrogenous gas evolved by this process does not arise from the decomposition of charcoal ; because the same quantity of that substance is contained in the gas after , as before electrization.,9 .
The h.ydrogenous gas proceeds from decomposed water ; because when this fluid is abstracted as far as possible from the carbonated hydrogenous gas , before submitting it to the action of electricity , the dilatation cannot be extended beyond one-sixth its usual amount .
4 .
The decCmponent of the water is not a metallic substance , because carbonated hydrogenous gas is expanded when in contact only with a glass tube , and gold , a metal , which has no power of separating water into its formative principles .
A. The oxygen of the water ( when the electric fluidX is passed through carbonated hydrogenous gas , that holds this substance in solution ) , combines with the carbon , and fornis carbonic acid .
This production of carbonic acid , therefore ; adds to the dilatation Qccasioned by the evolution of hydrogenous gas .
6 .
There is not , by the action of the electric matter on car- : bonated hydrogenous gas , any generation of azotic gas .
7 .
Carbon , it appears , therefore , from the united evidence of these facts , is still to be considered as an elementary body ; that is , as a body with the composition of which we are unacquainted , but which may nevertheless yield to the labours , of some future and more successful analyst :

